Applications: Helium, Stark Effect, Anharmonicity and LCAO
CSIR NET chemistry: perturbation and variation applied to helium, 1s2s singlet-triplet, Stark effects, anharmonic oscillator, H2+ LCAO and Hückel.
- 23 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Four Answers for One Ionisation Energy
- 1. The Helium Atom: Ground State
- 2. Excited Helium: 1s2s Singlet and Triplet
- 3. The Stark Effect
- 4. The Anharmonic Oscillator
- 5. Linear Variation in Bonding: H₂⁺ and Hückel
- Choosing the Method
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- The Variational Principle: trial functions, \( dW/d\zeta = 0 \), the secular determinant.
- Perturbation Theory up to Second Order: \( E^{(1)} \), \( E^{(2)} \), parity, degenerate levels.
- Shielding and effective nuclear charge, which helium makes quantitative: Electronic Configuration, Shielding and Effective Nuclear Charge.
- The hydrogen-atom wavefunctions used throughout: The Hydrogen Atom and the Shapes of Atomic Orbitals.
- Spin and the Pauli principle for the 1s2s states: Identical Particles and the Pauli Principle.
The Hook: Four Answers for One Ionisation Energy
All atomic calculations below use atomic units: \( \hbar = m_e = e = 4\pi\varepsilon_0 = 1 \), lengths in bohr (\( a_0 \approx 0.529 \) Å), energies in hartree (\( E_h \approx 27.21 \) eV; \( \frac{1}{2}E_h \approx 13.6 \) eV).
1. The Helium Atom: Ground State
With the nucleus fixed, the Hamiltonian of a two-electron atom of nuclear charge \( Z \) is
$$\hat H = \underbrace{-\tfrac{1}{2}\nabla_1^2 - \frac{Z}{r_1}}_{\hat h_1} \;\underbrace{-\tfrac{1}{2}\nabla_2^2 - \frac{Z}{r_2}}_{\hat h_2} \;+\; \frac{1}{r_{12}}$$The \( 1/r_{12} \) term couples the electrons and makes the equation unsolvable in closed form. Treat it two ways.
Perturbation: \( \hat H^{(0)} = \hat h_1 + \hat h_2 \), \( \hat H' = 1/r_{12} \)
Zeroth order. Each electron is in a hydrogen-like 1s orbital \( \phi_{1s} = \sqrt{Z^3/\pi}\,e^{-Zr} \), and \( \psi^{(0)} = \phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{1s}(2) \).
$$E^{(0)} = 2\times\left(-\frac{Z^2}{2}\right) = -Z^2 = -4\,E_h \approx -108.8 \text{ eV}$$First order. The average repulsion of two 1s electrons is a standard integral:
$$E^{(1)} = \left\langle\frac{1}{r_{12}}\right\rangle_{1s^2} = \frac{5Z}{8}\,E_h = 1.25\,E_h \approx 34.0 \text{ eV} \quad (Z = 2)$$$$E^{(0)} + E^{(1)} = -Z^2 + \frac{5Z}{8} = -2.75\,E_h \approx -74.8 \text{ eV}$$The correction is about 30% of the zeroth-order energy: this is not a small perturbation, and it shows.
Variation: let the orbital exponent relax
Use the same product form but with an adjustable exponent \( \zeta \): \( \phi = \frac{\zeta^3}{\pi}e^{-\zeta(r_1 + r_2)} \). The pieces scale simply:
| Term | Value for exponent \( \zeta \) |
|---|---|
| Kinetic energy, two electrons | \( 2 \times \frac{\zeta^2}{2} = \zeta^2 \) |
| Nuclear attraction, two electrons | \( 2 \times (-Z\zeta) = -2Z\zeta \) |
| Electron repulsion | \( \frac{5}{8}\zeta \) |
For helium, \( \zeta = 27/16 = 1.6875 \) and \( W_{\min} = -(27/16)^2 \approx -2.848\,E_h \approx -77.5 \) eV.
Helium in one table
The accurate non-relativistic energy of helium is about \( -2.9037\,E_h \approx -79.0 \) eV. He⁺ is a one-electron ion with exact energy \( -Z^2/2 = -2\,E_h \approx -54.4 \) eV, so each approximation also predicts the first ionisation energy, \( \text{IE}_1 = E(\text{He}^+) - E(\text{He}) \).
| Level of theory | \( E(\text{He}) \) / \( E_h \) | \( E \) / eV | Error in \( E \) | Predicted IE₁ / eV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zeroth order (no repulsion) | \( -4.000 \) | \( -108.8 \) | 38% too low | 54.4 |
| First-order perturbation | \( -2.750 \) | \( -74.8 \) | 5.3% too high | 20.4 |
| Variational, \( \zeta = 27/16 \) | \( -2.848 \) | \( -77.5 \) | 1.9% too high | 23.1 |
| Accurate | \( -2.904 \) | \( -79.0 \) | about 24.6 (observed) |
Points worth stating in an exam:
- First order lies above the true energy, as it must (it is the expectation value of the full \( \hat H \) over a legal trial function).
- The variational result lies between first order and the truth: optimising \( \zeta \) can only lower \( W \) below the \( \zeta = Z \) value, which is the first-order energy.
- Even the variational error, 0.056 \( E_h \) (about 1.5 eV), is large on a chemical scale. Small energy errors in total energies become large errors in ionisation and reaction energies.
- Most of the remaining error comes from electron correlation: in a product of identical orbitals the two electrons move independently, while in reality they avoid each other.
Other two-electron systems
| System | \( Z \) | \( \zeta = Z - 5/16 \) | \( W_{\min} = -\zeta^2 \) / \( E_h \) | First order \( -Z^2 + 5Z/8 \) / \( E_h \) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H⁻ | 1 | 0.6875 | \( -0.4727 \) | \( -0.375 \) |
| He | 2 | 1.6875 | \( -2.8477 \) | \( -2.750 \) |
| Li⁺ | 3 | 2.6875 | \( -7.2227 \) | \( -7.125 \) |
H⁻ is a cautionary case. The simple variational energy \( -0.4727\,E_h \) lies above the energy of H + e⁻ (\( -0.5\,E_h \)), so this trial function predicts H⁻ to be unbound. H⁻ is in fact a bound ion; a trial function that lets the two electrons occupy different orbitals (one compact, one diffuse) captures enough correlation to bind it. The variation theorem is not violated: the simple function is just too poor to show binding.
2. Excited Helium: 1s2s Singlet and Triplet
For the configuration 1s2s, spatial functions must be combined with spin functions so that the total wavefunction is antisymmetric:
$$\psi_{\pm} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[\phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{2s}(2) \pm \phi_{2s}(1)\phi_{1s}(2)\right]$$The symmetric spatial function (+) pairs with the singlet spin function; the antisymmetric one (−) with the three triplet spin functions. First-order perturbation in \( 1/r_{12} \):
$$E_{\pm} = E^{(0)}_{1s2s} + J \pm K, \qquad E^{(0)}_{1s2s} = -\frac{Z^2}{2} - \frac{Z^2}{8}$$- \( J = \left\langle\phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{2s}(2)\left|\frac{1}{r_{12}}\right|\phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{2s}(2)\right\rangle \): the Coulomb integral, the classical repulsion of the two charge clouds.
- \( K = \left\langle\phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{2s}(2)\left|\frac{1}{r_{12}}\right|\phi_{2s}(1)\phi_{1s}(2)\right\rangle \): the exchange integral, with no classical analogue. It is positive.
So the triplet (\( J - K \)) lies below the singlet (\( J + K \)), by \( 2K \). In the triplet the spatial function vanishes when \( \mathbf r_1 = \mathbf r_2 \): same-spin electrons keep apart and repel less. This is the quantum-mechanical origin of Hund’s first rule.
With hydrogen-like orbitals, \( J = \frac{17Z}{81} \) and \( K = \frac{16Z}{729} \) (in \( E_h \)). For helium (\( Z = 2 \)):
| Quantity | Value |
|---|---|
| \( E^{(0)}_{1s2s} \) | \( -2 - 0.5 = -2.500\,E_h \) |
| \( J \) | \( 0.4198\,E_h \approx 11.42 \) eV |
| \( K \) | \( 0.0439\,E_h \approx 1.19 \) eV |
| Singlet \( 2^1S \), \( E^{(0)} + J + K \) | \( -2.036\,E_h \) |
| Triplet \( 2^3S \), \( E^{(0)} + J - K \) | \( -2.124\,E_h \) |
| Singlet–triplet gap \( 2K \) | \( 0.088\,E_h \approx 2.39 \) eV |
The ordering is right; the size of the gap is overestimated at this level (the observed 2¹S–2³S separation is under 1 eV), because the unscreened orbitals are too compact.
3. The Stark Effect
An electric field \( F \) along \( z \) adds \( \hat H' = -\boldsymbol{\mu}\cdot\mathbf F \). For an electron, \( \hat H' = eFz \) (sign conventions vary; only \( |H'| \) and parity matter below).
Hydrogen 1s: no first-order effect, only polarisation
\( E^{(1)} = eF\langle 1s|z|1s\rangle = 0 \): \( z \) is odd and \( |\psi_{1s}|^2 \) is even. A non-degenerate state of definite parity has no permanent dipole moment, so the first non-zero shift is second order:
$$E^{(2)} = e^2F^2\sum_{n\neq 1s}\frac{|\langle n|z|1s\rangle|^2}{E_{1s} - E_n} \equiv -\frac{1}{2}\alpha F^2$$The shift is quadratic in the field and defines the polarisability \( \alpha \). The exact value for hydrogen is \( \alpha = \frac{9}{2}a_0^3 \) (in units with \( 4\pi\varepsilon_0 = 1 \)), a polarisability volume of about 0.667 ų. Both approximate methods bracket it.
Upper bound from closure (Unsöld). Every excited level lies at or above \( E_{n=2} \), so \( |E^{(2)}| \leq \frac{e^2F^2\sum_n|\langle n|z|1s\rangle|^2}{E_2 - E_1} = \frac{e^2F^2\langle z^2\rangle}{\frac{3}{8}E_h} \). With \( \langle z^2\rangle_{1s} = a_0^2 \), this gives \( \alpha \leq \frac{16}{3}a_0^3 \approx 5.33\,a_0^3 \).
Lower bound from variation. Take \( \phi = \psi_{1s}(1 + \lambda z) \). In atomic units, using \( \langle z^2\rangle = 1 \) and the identity \( \langle\psi_{1s}|z\hat H^{(0)}z|\psi_{1s}\rangle = E_{1s}\langle z^2\rangle + \frac{1}{2} = 0 \):
$$W(\lambda) = \frac{-\frac{1}{2} + 2\lambda F}{1 + \lambda^2} \approx -\frac{1}{2} + 2\lambda F + \frac{1}{2}\lambda^2$$Minimising, \( \lambda = -2F \) and \( W = -\frac{1}{2} - 2F^2 \), so \( \alpha_{\text{var}} = 4\,a_0^3 \). Because \( W \geq E_{\text{exact}} \), \( -\frac{1}{2}\alpha_{\text{var}}F^2 \geq -\frac{1}{2}\alpha F^2 \), so \( \alpha_{\text{var}} \leq \alpha \): a variational energy gives a lower bound to the polarisability.
$$4\,a_0^3 \;\leq\; \alpha = 4.5\,a_0^3 \;\leq\; 5.33\,a_0^3$$Hydrogen n = 2: the linear Stark effect
The level \( n = 2 \) is four-fold degenerate (2s, 2p₀, 2p₊₁, 2p₋₁), so degenerate perturbation theory applies. The matrix of \( z \) in this block has only one non-zero pair: \( z \) changes \( l \) by ±1 and does not change \( m \). So 2s couples only to 2p₀, with \( |\langle 2s|z|2p_0\rangle| = 3a_0 \).
$$\begin{vmatrix} -E^{(1)} & 3ea_0F \\ 3ea_0F & -E^{(1)} \end{vmatrix} = 0 \;\Rightarrow\; E^{(1)} = \pm 3ea_0F$$| States | First-order shift |
|---|---|
| \( \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(2s \pm 2p_0) \) | \( \pm 3ea_0F \) |
| 2p₊₁, 2p₋₁ | 0 (degenerate pair remains) |
The shift is linear in \( F \): the correct zeroth-order mixtures are lopsided along \( z \) and carry a permanent dipole of magnitude \( 3ea_0 \). Linear Stark effects require degeneracy between states of opposite parity, which in practice means the hydrogen atom (or other accidental degeneracies) and symmetric-top molecules.
Polar molecules: the rotational Stark effect
For a linear rigid rotor with dipole \( \mu \), \( \hat H' = -\mu F\cos\theta \). In a state \( |J, M\rangle \), \( \langle\cos\theta\rangle = 0 \) by parity, so a linear molecule has no first-order Stark effect. For \( J = 0 \), only \( J = 1, M = 0 \) couples, with \( |\langle 1,0|\cos\theta|0,0\rangle|^2 = \frac{1}{3} \) and gap \( E_1 - E_0 = 2B \) (with \( B \) in energy units, \( E_J = BJ(J+1) \)):
$$\boxed{E^{(2)}_{J=0} = \frac{\mu^2F^2/3}{0 - 2B} = -\frac{\mu^2F^2}{6B}}$$The ground rotational level always falls (second-order ground-state rule). Symmetric-top molecules in states with \( K \neq 0 \) and \( M \neq 0 \) do show a first-order (linear) effect, because their \( \pm K \) degeneracy plays the role of hydrogen’s 2s/2p degeneracy.
4. The Anharmonic Oscillator
A real bond potential near its minimum can be expanded as
$$V(x) = \frac{1}{2}kx^2 + cx^3 + dx^4, \qquad k = m\omega^2$$(\( m \) is the reduced mass). Treat \( cx^3 + dx^4 \) as the perturbation. With \( x_0^2 = \hbar/2m\omega \):
- The quartic term contributes at first order: \( d\,x_0^4(6v^2 + 6v + 3) \).
- The cubic term contributes nothing at first order (odd), but at second order: \( -\frac{c^2x_0^6}{\hbar\omega}(30v^2 + 30v + 11) \).
For a real bond the second-order cubic correction and the first-order quartic correction are usually of comparable size, so a consistent treatment keeps \( x^4 \) at first order and \( x^3 \) at second order. Rewrite both polynomials in \( (v + \frac{1}{2}) \):
$$6v^2 + 6v + 3 = 6\left(v + \tfrac{1}{2}\right)^2 + \tfrac{3}{2}, \qquad 30v^2 + 30v + 11 = 30\left(v + \tfrac{1}{2}\right)^2 + \tfrac{7}{2}$$So the energy has the spectroscopic form
$$E_v = \hbar\omega\left(v + \tfrac{1}{2}\right) - \hbar\omega x_e\left(v + \tfrac{1}{2}\right)^2 + \text{constant}, \qquad \hbar\omega x_e = \frac{30c^2x_0^6}{\hbar\omega} - 6d\,x_0^4$$For a typical bond the cubic term dominates (the potential is softer on the stretching side, \( c < 0 \)), \( \omega x_e > 0 \), and levels crowd together as \( v \) rises: the familiar convergence towards dissociation. The fundamental transition shifts by
$$\Delta E_{0\to 1} = \hbar\omega + 12d\,x_0^4 - \frac{60c^2x_0^6}{\hbar\omega}$$Two further consequences of the cubic term: the first-order wavefunction mixes \( v \pm 1 \) and \( v \pm 3 \) into each level, which is one reason overtones (\( \Delta v = 2, 3 \)) gain weak intensity; and \( \langle x\rangle \neq 0 \), so the mean bond length grows with \( v \).
5. Linear Variation in Bonding: H₂⁺ and Hückel
H₂⁺ as a two-function linear variation
Take \( \phi = c_A 1s_A + c_B 1s_B \). By symmetry \( H_{AA} = H_{BB} \), and the linear variation result gives
$$W_\pm = \frac{H_{AA} \pm H_{AB}}{1 \pm S}$$In atomic units, with the internuclear repulsion \( 1/R \) included, the integrals can be done in closed form:
| Integral | Expression |
|---|---|
| Overlap \( S \) | \( e^{-R}\left(1 + R + \frac{R^2}{3}\right) \) |
| \( J' = \langle 1s_A\vert \frac{1}{r_B}\vert 1s_A\rangle \) | \( \frac{1}{R}\left[1 - (1 + R)e^{-2R}\right] \) |
| \( K' = \langle 1s_A\vert \frac{1}{r_A}\vert 1s_B\rangle \) | \( (1 + R)e^{-R} \) |
| Energies | \( W_\pm = -\frac{1}{2} + \frac{1}{R} - \frac{J' \pm K'}{1 \pm S} \) |
Minimising \( W_+ \) over \( R \):
| Quantity | LCAO (\( \zeta = 1 \)) | Accurate |
|---|---|---|
| \( R_e \) | 2.49 \( a_0 \) (1.32 Å) | 2.00 \( a_0 \) (1.06 Å) |
| \( D_e \) | 0.065 \( E_h \) (1.76 eV) | 0.103 \( E_h \) (2.79 eV) |
| \( S \) at \( R_e \) | about 0.46 |
The LCAO energy is variational, so \( D_e \) is underestimated (the minimum is too shallow), never overestimated. The antibonding \( W_- \) lies above \( -\frac{1}{2}E_h \) at every \( R \): it is repulsive. Letting the exponent \( \zeta \) vary with \( R \) improves both numbers, as a second variational parameter must. The full LCAO-MO treatment is in LCAO-MO Theory: H₂⁺, Secular Equations and Heteronuclear Bonds, and the qualitative bonding picture in Bonding in Homonuclear Molecules.
Hückel theory: the same determinant, simplified
For conjugated π systems, Hückel theory is a linear variation in a basis of one p orbital per carbon, with drastic approximations: \( H_{ii} = \alpha \), \( H_{ij} = \beta \) for bonded neighbours and 0 otherwise, and \( S_{ij} = \delta_{ij} \). Writing \( x = (\alpha - E)/\beta \):
| Molecule | Secular roots \( x \) | Energies (\( \beta < 0 \)) |
|---|---|---|
| Ethylene | \( \pm 1 \) | \( \alpha + \beta,\ \alpha - \beta \) |
| Allyl | \( 0, \pm\sqrt 2 \) | \( \alpha + 1.414\beta,\ \alpha,\ \alpha - 1.414\beta \) |
| Butadiene | \( \pm 1.618, \pm 0.618 \) | \( \alpha + 1.618\beta,\ \alpha + 0.618\beta,\ \ldots \) |
Butadiene’s four π electrons fill the two lowest orbitals: \( E_\pi = 4\alpha + 4.472\beta \), against \( 4\alpha + 4\beta \) for two isolated ethylene bonds, a delocalisation energy of \( 0.472\beta \). Because \( S = 0 \), Hückel levels are symmetric about \( \alpha \), unlike the \( (\alpha \pm \beta)/(1 \pm S) \) pair. Hückel theory is developed fully in Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems.
Choosing the Method
graph TD
A["Problem to solve"] --> B{"Is H a small change
from a solvable H0?"}
B -->|Yes| C{"Is the level
degenerate?"}
C -->|No| D["Non-degenerate PT:
Stark 1s, anharmonic terms,
rotor Stark"]
C -->|Yes| E["Degenerate PT:
Stark n = 2, He 1s2s"]
B -->|No, or a bound is wanted| F{"Parameters linear
or nonlinear?"}
F -->|Nonlinear| G["Optimise exponent:
He with zeta = Z - 5/16"]
F -->|Linear| H["Secular determinant:
H2+ LCAO, Huckel"]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| He first order \( -2.75\,E_h \): uses \( \zeta = Z = 2 \) | He variational \( -2.848\,E_h \): uses \( \zeta = 27/16 \) | |
| Coulomb integral \( J \): classical repulsion | Exchange integral \( K \): purely quantum, splits singlet and triplet | |
| Quadratic Stark (H 1s, linear molecules): \( -\frac{1}{2}\alpha F^2 \) | Linear Stark (H \( n = 2 \), symmetric tops with \( K \neq 0 \)): \( \propto F \) | |
| Variational \( \alpha \): lower bound | Variational energy: upper bound | |
| LCAO H₂⁺ \( D_e \) 1.76 eV: too small | Accurate 2.79 eV | |
| Hückel \( \alpha \pm \beta \) (\( S = 0 \)): symmetric | \( (\alpha \pm \beta)/(1 \pm S) \): antibonding raised more |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the optimised orbital exponent for helium in the simple product trial function?
- Why does the hydrogen 1s level show no first-order Stark shift?
- In the 1s2s configuration of helium, which term lies lower, and by how much (in terms of integrals)?
Answers
- \( \zeta = 27/16 = 1.6875 \), from \( \zeta = Z - 5/16 \).
- Parity. \( z \) is odd and \( |\psi_{1s}|^2 \) is even, so \( \langle z\rangle = 0 \): no permanent dipole.
- The triplet, lower by \( 2K \) (exchange integral).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Using a product of two 1s orbitals with an optimised exponent, the variational ground-state energy of Li⁺ is (in \( E_h \)):
(a) \( -7.125 \) (b) \( -7.223 \) (c) \( -9.000 \) (d) \( -4.500 \)
Answer: (b)
\( \zeta = 3 - 5/16 = 43/16 = 2.6875 \); \( W = -(2.6875)^2 \approx -7.223\,E_h \).
(a) is the first-order perturbation value \( -9 + 15/8 \). (c) ignores repulsion (\( -Z^2 \)). (d) is \( -Z^2/2 \), the one-electron Li²⁺ energy.
Practice Q2. In an electric field \( F \), the \( n = 2 \) level of the hydrogen atom splits, to first order, into:
(a) four levels, \( \pm 3ea_0F \) and \( \pm\frac{3}{2}ea_0F \) (b) three levels: \( +3ea_0F \), 0 (doubly degenerate), \( -3ea_0F \) (c) two levels, \( \pm 3ea_0F \), each doubly degenerate (d) no first-order splitting
Answer: (b)
Only 2s and 2p₀ couple (\( \Delta l = \pm 1 \), \( \Delta m = 0 \)), giving \( \pm 3ea_0F \). 2p₊₁ and 2p₋₁ stay at zero shift, still degenerate with each other.
Practice Q3. For a linear polar molecule (dipole \( \mu \), rotational constant \( B \) in energy units), the Stark shift of the \( J = 0 \) level in a weak field \( F \) is:
(a) \( -\mu F \) (b) \( -\frac{\mu^2F^2}{6B} \) (c) \( +\frac{\mu^2F^2}{6B} \) (d) \( -\frac{\mu^2F^2}{2B} \)
Answer: (b)
No first-order term (\( \langle\cos\theta\rangle_{J=0} = 0 \)). Second order: only \( |1, 0\rangle \) couples, \( |\langle 1,0|\cos\theta|0,0\rangle|^2 = 1/3 \), gap \( 2B \). \( E^{(2)} = -\frac{\mu^2F^2}{3}\cdot\frac{1}{2B} \). (c) has the wrong sign for a ground state; (d) omits the 1/3.
Practice Q4. For the helium 1s2s configuration, first-order perturbation theory with \( J = 0.420\,E_h \) and \( K = 0.044\,E_h \) predicts a singlet–triplet separation of about:
(a) 0.044 \( E_h \), singlet lower (b) 0.088 \( E_h \), triplet lower (c) 0.088 \( E_h \), singlet lower (d) 0.840 \( E_h \), triplet lower
Answer: (b)
\( E(^1S) - E(^3S) = (J + K) - (J - K) = 2K = 0.088\,E_h \approx 2.4 \) eV, with the triplet lower. (d) uses \( 2J \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. For helium, use \( E(\text{He}^+) = -2.000\,E_h \), the first-order energy \( -2.750\,E_h \), the variational energy \( -2.848\,E_h \) and the observed first ionisation energy 24.6 eV (\( 1\,E_h = 27.21 \) eV). Which statements are correct?
- First-order perturbation predicts \( \text{IE}_1 \approx 20.4 \) eV.
- The variational calculation predicts \( \text{IE}_1 \approx 23.1 \) eV.
- Both predictions are too low because both approximate energies of He lie above the true energy while He⁺ is treated exactly.
- The optimised exponent is larger than 2 because the electrons attract the nucleus more strongly together.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. \( (-2.000 + 2.750) \times 27.21 = 0.750 \times 27.21 \approx 20.4 \) eV.
- Correct. \( 0.848 \times 27.21 \approx 23.1 \) eV.
- Correct. \( \text{IE}_1 = E(\text{He}^+) - E(\text{He}) \). An He energy that is too high (not negative enough), with an exact He⁺ energy, gives too small an IE.
- Wrong. \( \zeta = 27/16 < 2 \): each electron screens the nucleus from the other.
Practice Q6. For the hydrogen atom, the trial function \( \psi_{1s}(1 + \lambda z) \) in a field \( F \) gives a minimum energy \( -\frac{1}{2} - 2F^2 \) (atomic units). The closure approximation with the \( n = 2 \) energy as the average excitation gives \( \alpha \leq \frac{16}{3}a_0^3 \). Which statements are correct?
- The trial function gives \( \alpha_{\text{var}} = 4\,a_0^3 \).
- \( \alpha_{\text{var}} \) is a lower bound to the exact polarisability.
- The exact value must lie between \( 4\,a_0^3 \) and \( 5.33\,a_0^3 \).
- The 1s level would show a shift proportional to \( F \) if the field were strong enough.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. \( -\frac{1}{2}\alpha F^2 = -2F^2 \Rightarrow \alpha = 4 \).
- Correct. \( W \geq E_{\text{exact}} \) means \( -\frac{1}{2}\alpha_{\text{var}}F^2 \geq -\frac{1}{2}\alpha F^2 \), so \( \alpha_{\text{var}} \leq \alpha \).
- Correct. And indeed \( \alpha = 4.5\,a_0^3 \).
- Wrong. A non-degenerate state of definite parity has no linear term at any field strength; strong fields add higher even powers (and eventually ionise the atom), not a linear term.
Practice Q7. A linear molecule has dipole moment 2.0 D (\( 1\text{ D} = 3.336 \times 10^{-30} \) C m) and rotational constant \( \tilde B = 0.50 \) cm⁻¹. A field of \( 1.0 \times 10^{5} \) V m⁻¹ is applied. (\( hc = 1.986 \times 10^{-23} \) J cm.) Which statements are correct?
- \( \mu F \approx 0.034 \) cm⁻¹ in wavenumber units.
- The \( J = 0 \) level shifts by about \( -3.8 \times 10^{-4} \) cm⁻¹.
- Doubling the field quadruples the shift.
- Perturbation theory is justified because \( \mu F \ll 2B \).
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- Correct. \( \mu F = 2.0 \times 3.336 \times 10^{-30} \times 1.0 \times 10^5 = 6.67 \times 10^{-25} \) J; divided by \( hc \): \( \approx 0.0336 \) cm⁻¹.
- Correct. \( -\frac{(0.0336)^2}{6 \times 0.50} = -\frac{1.13 \times 10^{-3}}{3.0} \approx -3.8 \times 10^{-4} \) cm⁻¹.
- Correct. Second-order shift \( \propto F^2 \).
- Correct. \( 0.034 \ll 1.0 \) cm⁻¹.
Quick Revision Table
| Application | Key result |
|---|---|
| He, zeroth order | \( -Z^2 = -4\,E_h \) (\( -108.8 \) eV) |
| He, first order | \( \langle 1/r_{12}\rangle = 5Z/8 \); \( -2.75\,E_h \) (\( -74.8 \) eV) |
| He, variational | \( \zeta = Z - 5/16 = 1.6875 \); \( -(27/16)^2 = -2.848\,E_h \) (\( -77.5 \) eV) |
| He, accurate | \( -2.904\,E_h \) (\( -79.0 \) eV); IE₁ about 24.6 eV |
| Two-electron ions | \( W = -(Z - 5/16)^2 \): H⁻ \( -0.473 \) (fails to bind), Li⁺ \( -7.223\,E_h \) |
| He 1s2s | \( E = E^{(0)} + J \pm K \); triplet lower by \( 2K \); \( J = 17Z/81 \), \( K = 16Z/729 \) |
| H 1s Stark | quadratic, \( -\frac{1}{2}\alpha F^2 \); \( 4 \leq \alpha = 4.5 \leq 16/3\ a_0^3 \) |
| H \( n = 2 \) Stark | \( \pm 3ea_0F \) (2s ± 2p₀); 2p±1 unshifted |
| Rotor \( J = 0 \) | \( -\mu^2F^2/6B \) |
| Anharmonic | \( x^4 \) first order, \( x^3 \) second order; both give \( (v + \frac{1}{2})^2 \) terms |
| H₂⁺ LCAO | \( R_e = 2.49\,a_0 \), \( D_e = 1.76 \) eV (accurate 2.00 \( a_0 \), 2.79 eV) |
| Hückel | \( S = 0 \); ethylene \( \alpha \pm \beta \); butadiene \( \pm 1.618, \pm 0.618 \); DE \( 0.472\beta \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Approximate Methods: Quick Revision: every formula and number from the unit on one page.
- Revisit The Variational Principle and Perturbation Theory up to Second Order for the derivations behind these numbers.
- The molecular-orbital consequences of LCAO: Bonding in Homonuclear Molecules.
- The physics-side view of helium and the Stark effect: Perturbation Theory and the Variational Method.