Skip to content

Approximate Methods Formula Sheet and Short Notes

One-page CSIR NET revision: variation theorem, secular determinant, second-order perturbation formulas, helium, Stark effects, anharmonicity, H2+ LCAO.

  • 6 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 5 sections
  1. Variation method
  2. Perturbation theory
  3. Helium and two-electron systems
  4. Stark effect, anharmonicity, LCAO
  5. Perturbation vs variation

Every formula and number from The Variational Principle, Perturbation Theory up to Second Order and Applications: Helium, Stark Effect, Anharmonicity and LCAO, on one page.

Atomic units: \( 1\,E_h \approx 27.21 \) eV; \( a_0 \approx 0.529 \) Å.

Variation method

$$\boxed{W[\phi] = \frac{\langle\phi|\hat H|\phi\rangle}{\langle\phi|\phi\rangle} \geq E_0}$$
  • Proof: \( \phi = \sum c_k\psi_k \Rightarrow W = \sum|c_k|^2E_k/\sum|c_k|^2 \geq E_0 \). Equality only for \( \phi = \psi_0 \).
  • Trial function must be well behaved and obey the boundary conditions.
  • Energy error is second order in the wavefunction error; other properties are not protected.
  • Orthogonal to \( \psi_0 \) (e.g. odd function in a symmetric potential): \( W \geq E_1 \).
  • Optimised scale parameter: virial theorem holds (\( 2\langle T\rangle = -\langle V\rangle \) for Coulomb).
SystemTrialResultExact
Box\( x(L-x) \)\( 5\hbar^2/mL^2 \)\( 4.935\hbar^2/mL^2 \); trial 1.3% high
Box, \( n = 2 \)\( x(L-x)(L-2x) \)\( 21\hbar^2/mL^2 \)\( 19.74\hbar^2/mL^2 \)
H atom\( e^{-\zeta r} \)\( \zeta = 1 \), \( -0.5\,E_h \)exact
H atom\( e^{-\alpha r^2} \)\( \alpha = 8/9\pi \), \( -4/3\pi = -0.424\,E_h \) (\( -11.5 \) eV)\( -13.6 \) eV
Oscillator\( e^{-\alpha x^2} \) / \( xe^{-\alpha x^2} \)\( \frac{1}{2}\hbar\omega \) / \( \frac{3}{2}\hbar\omega \)exact
Quartic \( bx^4 \)\( e^{-\alpha x^2} \)\( 0.681(\hbar^4b/m^2)^{1/3} \)about 0.668 (numerical)

Linear variation

$$\boxed{\det|H_{ij} - WS_{ij}| = 0}$$
  • \( n \) basis functions: \( n \) roots, each an upper bound to the matching exact level; more functions never raise a root.
  • Orthogonal 2 × 2: \( W = \bar H \mp\sqrt{(\Delta/2)^2 + H_{12}^2} \); levels repel.
  • Identical diagonal: \( W_\pm = (\alpha \pm \beta)/(1 \pm S) \); antibonding raised more when \( S > 0 \).
  • Hückel (\( S = 0 \)): ethylene \( \alpha \pm \beta \); allyl \( 0, \pm\sqrt2 \); butadiene \( \pm 1.618, \pm 0.618 \); DE \( 0.472\beta \).

Perturbation theory

$$\boxed{E_n^{(1)} = H'_{nn}} \qquad \boxed{E_n^{(2)} = \sum_{m\neq n}\frac{|H'_{mn}|^2}{E_n^{(0)} - E_m^{(0)}}} \qquad \psi_n^{(1)} = \sum_{m\neq n}\frac{H'_{mn}}{E_n^{(0)} - E_m^{(0)}}\psi_m^{(0)}$$
  • Ground state: \( E^{(2)} \leq 0 \); \( E^{(0)} + E^{(1)} \) is a variational upper bound.
  • Levels repel; nearest coupled states dominate.
  • Valid if \( |H'_{mn}| \ll |E_n^{(0)} - E_m^{(0)}| \).
  • Odd \( H' \), state of definite parity: \( E^{(1)} = 0 \).
  • Degenerate level: \( \det|H'_{ij} - E^{(1)}\delta_{ij}| = 0 \) within the block.
  • Two-level: exact \( \bar E \pm\sqrt{(\Delta/2)^2 + V^2} \); PT \( \mp V^2/\Delta \). \( V/\Delta = 0.1 \): 1% error; \( 0.5 \): about 20%.
Box (\( 0 \) to \( L \))\( E_n^{(1)} \)
\( V_0 \) everywhere\( V_0 \) (exact)
\( V_0 \) in one half\( V_0/2 \), all \( n \)
\( \varepsilon x \)\( \varepsilon L/2 \), all \( n \)
\( \gamma\delta(x - L/2) \)\( 2\gamma/L \) odd \( n \); 0 even \( n \)
\( V_0\sin(\pi x/L) \)\( 8V_0/3\pi \) (\( n = 1 \)); \( 32V_0/15\pi \) (\( n = 2 \))
Oscillator (\( x_0^2 = \hbar/2m\omega \))\( E_v^{(1)} \)\( E_v^{(2)} \)
\( bx \)0\( -b^2/2m\omega^2 \) (exact, all \( v \))
\( \frac{1}{2}\delta k\,x^2 \)\( \frac{\delta k}{2k}(v + \frac{1}{2})\hbar\omega \)\( -\frac{1}{8}(\frac{\delta k}{k})^2(v + \frac{1}{2})\hbar\omega \)
\( cx^3 \)0\( -\frac{c^2x_0^6}{\hbar\omega}(30v^2 + 30v + 11) \); \( v = 0 \): \( -\frac{11c^2\hbar^2}{8m^3\omega^4} \)
\( dx^4 \)\( dx_0^4(6v^2 + 6v + 3) \); \( v = 0 \): \( \frac{3d\hbar^2}{4m^2\omega^2} \)negative

Helium and two-electron systems

$$\hat H = -\tfrac{1}{2}\nabla_1^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}\nabla_2^2 - \frac{Z}{r_1} - \frac{Z}{r_2} + \frac{1}{r_{12}}$$
LevelFormulaHe value
Zeroth order\( -Z^2 \)\( -4.000\,E_h \) (\( -108.8 \) eV)
First order\( -Z^2 + \frac{5}{8}Z \)\( -2.750\,E_h \) (\( -74.8 \) eV), IE₁ 20.4 eV
Variational\( \zeta = Z - \frac{5}{16} \), \( W = -\zeta^2 \)\( \zeta = 1.6875 \), \( -2.848\,E_h \) (\( -77.5 \) eV), IE₁ 23.1 eV
Accurate\( -2.904\,E_h \) (\( -79.0 \) eV), IE₁ about 24.6 eV
  • H⁻: \( W = -0.473\,E_h > -0.5 \): simple function fails to bind it (H⁻ is actually bound).
  • Li⁺: \( \zeta = 2.6875 \), \( W = -7.223\,E_h \).
  • 1s2s: \( E = -\frac{Z^2}{2} - \frac{Z^2}{8} + J \pm K \); \( J = 17Z/81 \), \( K = 16Z/729 \). He: \( J = 0.420 \), \( K = 0.044\,E_h \); triplet lower by \( 2K \approx 2.4 \) eV (first order overestimates the gap).

Stark effect, anharmonicity, LCAO

  • H 1s: no first order (parity); \( E^{(2)} = -\frac{1}{2}\alpha F^2 \); \( 4 \leq \alpha = 4.5 \leq \frac{16}{3}\ a_0^3 \) (variation gives the lower bound, closure the upper). \( 4.5\,a_0^3 \approx 0.667 \) ų.
  • H \( n = 2 \): 2s and 2p₀ mix, \( \pm 3ea_0F \); 2p±1 unshifted. \( F = 10^7 \) V m⁻¹: \( 3ea_0F \approx 1.6 \) meV \( \approx 12.8 \) cm⁻¹.
  • Linear rotor \( J = 0 \): \( -\mu^2F^2/6B \); no first order. Symmetric top with \( K, M \neq 0 \): first order.
  • Anharmonic \( \frac{1}{2}kx^2 + cx^3 + dx^4 \): \( \hbar\omega x_e = \frac{30c^2x_0^6}{\hbar\omega} - 6dx_0^4 \); fundamental \( \hbar\omega + 12dx_0^4 - \frac{60c^2x_0^6}{\hbar\omega} \).
  • H₂⁺ LCAO: \( S = e^{-R}(1 + R + R^2/3) \); \( R_e = 2.49\,a_0 \) (1.32 Å), \( D_e = 1.76 \) eV; accurate 2.00 \( a_0 \) (1.06 Å), 2.79 eV. Antibonding repulsive at all \( R \).

Perturbation vs variation

PerturbationVariation
Needssolvable \( \hat H^{(0)} \) near \( \hat H \)sensible trial function
Boundground state through first order onlyalways an upper bound
Failscoupling ≈ gap; degeneracywrong shape or symmetry
Quantum chemistryMP2Hartree–Fock, CI

Back to the chapter overview, or compare with the physics-side summary in Quantum Mechanics (Physical Sciences): Quick Revision.

Advertisement
Advertisement