Annulenes, Azulene and Fulvenes: Larger Non-benzenoid Systems
CSIR NET organic chemistry: [10]- to [18]annulenes, bridged annulenes, ring currents, azulene, fulvenes and pentalene, with syntheses and reactions.
- 16 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Aromaticity Criteria: Hückel’s Rule, Antiaromaticity and Beyond: diatropic and paratropic ring currents, planarity.
- Non-benzenoid Aromatic Ions: cyclopentadienide and tropylium, the building blocks of azulene and the fulvenes.
- Magnetic Resonance Principles: shielding and why inner protons are a ring-current probe.
The Hook: Protons Below TMS
Annulenes
The annulene table
| Annulene | π electrons | Planar? | Verdict | Key evidence or reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [4] | 4 | yes (rectangular) | antiaromatic | very reactive; bond alternation |
| [6] | 6 | yes | aromatic | benzene |
| [8] | 8 | no (tub) | non-aromatic | polyene reactivity |
| [10] | 10 | no | non-aromatic | all-cis: angle strain; trans isomers: inner H clash |
| [12] | 12 | no (twisted) | weakly antiaromatic | paratropic shifts; unstable |
| [14] | 14 | nearly | aromatic, weakly | inner H crowding; conformational mobility |
| [16] | 16 | nearly | antiaromatic (paratropic) | inner H downfield, outer upfield at low T |
| [18] | 18 | nearly | aromatic | outer δ about 9.3, inner δ about −3.0 |
| [22], [24] … | ring-current effects weaken with size | increasing bond alternation in very large rings |
Why [10]annulene fails
- All-cis [10]annulene, as a regular planar decagon, needs 144° bond angles: large angle strain at sp² carbon. It puckers and loses conjugation.
- Isomers containing trans double bonds can relieve angle strain, but then two hydrogens point into the ring centre and collide (the 1,6-hydrogens). The ring twists out of plane.
- Either way it is non-aromatic, despite having 10 π electrons.
The fix is to replace the two clashing inner hydrogens by a bridge.
Bridged annulenes
1,6-Methano[10]annulene (Vogel, 1964). A CH₂ bridge between C1 and C6 removes the clashing hydrogens and holds the 10-carbon perimeter nearly planar.
| Evidence | Observation |
|---|---|
| ¹H NMR, ring protons | about δ 7.0–7.3 (aromatic region) |
| ¹H NMR, CH₂ bridge | about δ −0.5 (shielded: the bridge sits over the π ring) |
| Bond lengths | near-equal round the perimeter |
| Chemistry | electrophilic substitution (bromination, nitration, acylation) with retention of the annulene |
Vogel’s synthesis starts from naphthalene and uses the Birch reduction:
graph TD
A["Naphthalene"] -->|"Birch: Li or Na, NH3, ROH"| B["1,4,5,8-Tetrahydronaphthalene
(isotetralin)"]
B -->|"CHCl3, base: dichlorocarbene adds
to the central, most substituted C=C"| C["Dichlorocyclopropane-fused diene"]
C -->|"Na, NH3: remove both Cl"| D["Tricyclic diene"]
D -->|"Br2 on both C=C, then base
(removes four HBr)"| E["Norcaradiene-type tetraene"]
E -->|"spontaneous valence isomerisation"| F["1,6-Methano[10]annulene"]Dimethyldihydropyrene (Boekelheide). trans-15,16-Dimethyldihydropyrene has a 14π perimeter held planar around two internal methyl groups. The methyl protons, sitting at the centre of a strong diatropic current, appear near δ −4.2, one of the most upfield signals in organic chemistry, and became a standard ring-current probe: when benzo rings are fused on, the methyl signal moves downfield in proportion to how much aromaticity the perimeter loses.
[18]Annulene: Sondheimer’s synthesis
graph TD
A["1,5-Hexadiyne"] -->|"Cu(OAc)2, pyridine
(Eglinton oxidative coupling)"| B["Cyclic trimer: cyclooctadecahexayne"]
B -->|"KOtBu, tBuOH
(prototropic rearrangement)"| C["Fully conjugated tridehydro[18]annulene"]
C -->|"H2, Lindlar-type Pd catalyst
(partial hydrogenation)"| D["[18]Annulene"]The same strategy (oxidative coupling of terminal diynes, base-catalysed rearrangement, partial hydrogenation) gave a series of annulenes and dehydroannulenes, which is how the alternation of diatropic (\( 4n + 2 \)) and paratropic (\( 4n \)) behaviour was established experimentally.
Temperature dependence. The shifts of [18]annulene are temperature dependent because several conformations interconvert; the quoted limiting values (outer about δ 9.3, inner about δ −3.0) are those of the low-temperature spectrum, and at higher temperature the two signals move toward each other. In annulenes that do exchange inner and outer protons (for example [16]annulene), the signals broaden and coalesce on warming. A Part C question can give both spectra and ask what this means: a dynamic process averaging inner and outer protons, not loss of aromaticity.
Switching ring currents by adding electrons
Adding two electrons converts a \( 4n \) annulene into a \( 4n + 2 \) dianion, and the ring current reverses:
| Neutral | Ring current | Dianion (alkali-metal reduction) | Ring current |
|---|---|---|---|
| [16]annulene (16π) | paratropic: inner H downfield | [16]annulene²⁻ (18π) | diatropic: inner H strongly upfield |
| COT (8π, tub) | none (non-planar) | COT²⁻ (10π, planar) | diatropic |
The reverse is also seen: reducing a \( 4n + 2 \) bridged annulene to its dianion makes it paratropic, so the bridge protons move downfield.
Azulene
Structure and properties
| Property | Azulene | Naphthalene (isomer) |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | C₁₀H₈ | C₁₀H₈ |
| Rings | fused 5 + 7 | fused 6 + 6 |
| Colour | deep blue | colourless |
| Dipole moment | about 1 D, five-membered ring negative | 0 |
| Hückel delocalisation energy | \( 3.364\beta \) | \( 3.683\beta \) |
| Thermodynamic stability | lower; rearranges to naphthalene on strong heating | higher |
| π electrons (perimeter) | 10 | 10 |
Why azulene is polar and blue
A dipolar resonance structure puts a 6π cyclopentadienide ring next to a 6π tropylium ring:
$$\text{azulene} \;\longleftrightarrow\; [\text{C}_5\text{-ring}]^{-}\,[\text{C}_7\text{-ring}]^{+}$$Both rings are then aromatic, which is why this contribution is significant and why the five-membered ring carries the negative end of the dipole.
Its colour comes from a small HOMO–LUMO gap: in azulene the HOMO has large coefficients at different carbons from the LUMO (unlike alternant naphthalene, where they share the same atoms), so electron–electron repulsion terms lower the S₁ state unusually far, giving weak absorption in the visible region. Azulene is also the textbook exception to Kasha’s rule: it fluoresces mainly from S₂, not S₁, because the S₂–S₁ gap is large and the S₁–S₀ gap small.
Azulene is a non-alternant hydrocarbon (it contains an odd-membered ring, so its atoms cannot be divided into starred and unstarred sets). Non-alternant hydrocarbons have unequal π charges even when neutral, unlike naphthalene, where every π charge is exactly 1.
Generation
| Route | Outline |
|---|---|
| Ziegler–Hafner | a pyridinium salt is ring-opened to a glutaconaldehyde derivative (a 5-aminopenta-2,4-dienal or its iminium); condensation with cyclopentadienide gives a 6-(aminobutadienyl)fulvene, which closes the seven-membered ring on heating with loss of the amine, giving azulene |
| Pfau–Plattner | indane + ethyl diazoacetate: carbene adds to the benzene ring and the norcaradiene opens to a cycloheptatriene (Buchner ring expansion); dehydrogenation (S, Se or Pd) gives an azulene (after removing the ester) |
| From natural sesquiterpenes | hydroazulene sesquiterpenoids (guaiane type) are dehydrogenated with S or Se to blue azulenes such as guaiazulene; chamazulene forms when chamomile flowers are steam-distilled |
Reactions
| Reagent type | Site | Example | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electrophiles | C1 and C3 (five-membered ring) | acylation, Vilsmeier formylation, azo coupling, halogenation with NBS, mild nitration | attack at C1 gives a cation with a tropylium ring (azulenium) |
| Protons (strong acid) | C1 | azulenium ion; azulenes dissolve in concentrated acids and are recovered on dilution | 6π tropylium unit in the conjugate acid |
| Nucleophiles (RLi, hydride) | C4, C8 and C6 (seven-membered ring) | RLi adds; oxidation (for example chloranil) restores the azulene with R at C4 | the seven-membered ring is the electron-poor, tropylium-like part |
| Heat | whole skeleton | isomerisation to naphthalene | thermodynamics |
Fulvenes
Polarisation follows the aromatic ion
| Fulvene | Ring | Dipolar form that matters | Exocyclic carbon | Stabilised by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Triafulvene (methylenecyclopropene) | C₃ | ring⁺ (cyclopropenium, 2π) | negative | donors on the ring, acceptors on the exocyclic C |
| Pentafulvene | C₅ | ring⁻ (cyclopentadienide, 6π) | positive | donors on the exocyclic C (6-dimethylaminofulvene) |
| Heptafulvene | C₇ | ring⁺ (tropylium, 6π) | negative | acceptors on the exocyclic C (8,8-dicyanoheptafulvene is stable) |
For the parent pentafulvene the dipole is small: the dipolar aromatic contribution is minor. Putting donors on C6 increases it greatly; 6,6-bis(dimethylamino)fulvene is strongly polar.
Generation: the Thiele condensation
Cyclopentadiene + aldehyde or ketone + base (alkoxide, or a secondary amine such as pyrrolidine) → fulvene + H₂O. The cyclopentadienide anion adds to the carbonyl and the alcohol dehydrates. Acetone gives 6,6-dimethylfulvene, a yellow-orange liquid; benzophenone gives 6,6-diphenylfulvene.
Reactions of pentafulvenes
| Reagent | Site | Product | Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| RLi, LiAlH₄ (nucleophile) | C6 (the δ⁺ exocyclic carbon) | substituted cyclopentadienide anion | route to substituted Cp and ansa ligands for metallocenes |
| Dienophiles (maleic anhydride) | ring diene | Diels–Alder adduct | fulvene as a 4π diene |
| Electron-rich dienes, tropone | as 2π or 6π component | [4 + 2], [6 + 4] cycloadducts | periselectivity studies |
| O₂, light | peroxides, polymers | fulvenes are air-sensitive |
Fulvalenes and other dipolar hydrocarbons
Joining two rings by an exocyclic C=C gives a fulvalene.
| Fulvalene | Rings | Dipolar form | Polarity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pentafulvalene | 5 + 5 | none that makes both rings aromatic | non-polar, very unstable |
| Calicene (triapentafulvalene) | 3 + 5 | cyclopropenium⁺–cyclopentadienide⁻ | strongly polar; both rings aromatic in the dipolar form |
| Sesquifulvalene (pentaheptafulvalene) | 5 + 7 | tropylium⁺–cyclopentadienide⁻ | polar, five-membered ring negative |
Calicene derivatives are among the most polar hydrocarbons known, because the charge separation creates two aromatic ions.
Pentalene and heptalene
| Compound | π electrons | Behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| Pentalene (5 + 5 fused) | 8 | antiaromatic; dimerises even at low temperature; stabilised by bulky substituents |
| Pentalene dianion | 10 | aromatic; prepared as the dilithium salt and used as a ligand |
| Heptalene (7 + 7 fused) | 12 | non-planar polyene with alternating bonds; not aromatic |
Pentalene versus azulene is a good Part B contrast: azulene (10π, 5 + 7) is aromatic; pentalene (8π, 5 + 5) is antiaromatic.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Azulene: 5 + 7, blue, polar, aromatic, non-alternant | Naphthalene: 6 + 6, colourless, non-polar, alternant, more stable | |
| Azulene electrophiles at C1/C3 | Azulene nucleophiles at C4/C6/C8 | |
| Pentafulvene: ring negative, C6 positive | Heptafulvene: ring positive, C8 negative | |
| [10]annulene: non-aromatic (non-planar) | 1,6-Methano[10]annulene: aromatic (bridge keeps it planar) | |
| Averaging or coalescence of annulene NMR signals on warming: conformational dynamics | Loss of aromaticity (not what it indicates) | |
| Pentalene: 8π, antiaromatic | Pentalene dianion: 10π, aromatic |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Why is the all-cis [10]annulene not aromatic?
- On which ring of azulene does an electrophile attack, and at which positions?
- What is the Thiele condensation product of cyclopentadiene and acetone?
Answers
- A planar all-cis 10-membered ring needs 144° angles, so it puckers and loses continuous p-orbital overlap (non-planar → non-aromatic).
- The five-membered ring, at C1 (equivalently C3).
- 6,6-Dimethylfulvene.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A C₁₁H₁₀ hydrocarbon shows ¹H NMR signals at δ 7.0–7.3 (8H) and δ −0.5 (2H). It is best identified as:
(a) 1-methylnaphthalene (b) 1,6-methano[10]annulene (c) 2-methylnaphthalene (d) a [12]annulene
Answer: (b)
Eight perimeter protons in the aromatic region and a CH₂ shielded to negative δ: the bridge lies over a diatropic 10π ring. Methylnaphthalenes have 7 ArH and a CH₃ near δ 2.5; a [12]annulene would be paratropic and has a different formula.
Practice Q2. 6,6-Dimethylfulvene reacts with methyllithium. The product (before work-up) is:
(a) 1,2-adduct at a ring C=C (b) lithium tert-butylcyclopentadienide (c) 6,6-dimethylfulvene radical anion (d) lithium methylcyclopentadienide and propene
Answer: (b)
MeLi adds to C6 (the δ⁺ exocyclic carbon), giving a CMe₃ group on a cyclopentadienide ring: lithium (tert-butyl)cyclopentadienide. The driving force is formation of the aromatic anion.
Practice Q3. Which statement about azulene is incorrect?
(a) It is an isomer of naphthalene. (b) Its dipole has the negative end on the seven-membered ring. (c) It fluoresces mainly from its second excited singlet state. (d) It isomerises to naphthalene on strong heating.
Answer: (b)
The negative end is on the five-membered ring. (a), (c) (the classic exception to Kasha’s rule) and (d) are correct.
Practice Q4. Which fulvene derivative is expected to be the most stable, with the exocyclic carbon bearing the partial negative charge?
(a) heptafulvene (b) 8,8-dicyanoheptafulvene (c) pentafulvene (d) 6,6-dimethylpentafulvene
Answer: (b)
In heptafulvene the exocyclic carbon is the negative end (the ring becomes tropylium-like). Two cyano groups stabilise that negative charge, so the dicyano derivative is a stable compound, while parent heptafulvene polymerises. In pentafulvenes the exocyclic carbon is the positive end.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. The ¹H NMR spectra of [16]annulene (illustrative, approximate data) are recorded:
- at −130 °C: δ 10.5 (4H), δ 5.3 (12H);
- at +20 °C: one broad signal near δ 6.7 (16H).
Which statements are correct?
- At −130 °C the compound shows a paratropic ring current.
- The room-temperature spectrum shows that the compound has gained aromaticity.
- The room-temperature signal is close to the population-weighted average of the low-temperature signals.
- Inner and outer protons interchange by a process that is fast on the NMR time scale at +20 °C.
(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
Weighted average: \( (4 \times 10.5 + 12 \times 5.3)/16 = (42 + 63.6)/16 = 6.6 \), close to the observed 6.7. So the single line is exchange averaging (3, 4); it says nothing about a change in aromaticity (2 wrong). In the low-temperature spectrum the inner protons are far downfield and the outer upfield, a paratropic current (1).
Practice Q6. Consider the sequence: naphthalene → (Li, NH₃, EtOH) → A (C₁₀H₁₂) → (CHCl₃, KOtBu) → B → (Na, NH₃) → C (C₁₁H₁₄) → (Br₂, then base) → D (C₁₁H₁₀). Which statements are correct?
- A is 1,4,5,8-tetrahydronaphthalene.
- Dichlorocarbene adds selectively to the tetrasubstituted central C=C of A.
- D is 1,6-methano[10]annulene, which has a 10π diatropic perimeter.
- D shows its CH₂ protons downfield of δ 7 because they are deshielded by the ring current.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
Double Birch reduction gives isotetralin (A), whose central tetrasubstituted alkene is the most electron-rich and takes the electrophilic dichlorocarbene (B). Removing both Cl gives C (C₁₁H₁₄); brominating its two C=C and eliminating four HBr introduces two more C=C (C₁₁H₁₄ → C₁₁H₁₀) and gives a norcaradiene-type intermediate that opens to 1,6-methano[10]annulene (D, C₁₁H₁₀). Its CH₂ protons sit above the ring and are shielded (about δ −0.5), so 4 is wrong.
Practice Q7. Simple Hückel delocalisation energies are \( 3.364\beta \) for azulene and \( 3.683\beta \) for naphthalene. Azulene’s measured dipole moment is about 1 D. Taking \( \beta \approx -75 \) kJ mol⁻¹, which set of conclusions is consistent?
(a) Naphthalene is more stable by about 24 kJ mol⁻¹ (Hückel estimate); azulene’s polarity shows a charge-separated contribution with the five-membered ring negative. (b) Azulene is more stable by about 24 kJ mol⁻¹; its dipole comes from the seven-membered ring being negative. (c) The two isomers have equal Hückel energies because both are 10π systems. (d) Naphthalene is more stable by about 75 kJ mol⁻¹; the dipole is zero by symmetry.
Answer: (a)
\( (3.683 - 3.364) \times 75 = 0.319 \times 75 \approx 24 \) kJ mol⁻¹ in favour of naphthalene, consistent with the thermal azulene → naphthalene rearrangement. Hückel energies depend on connectivity, not just the electron count, so (c) is wrong. Azulene has C₂v symmetry, which allows a dipole along its long axis; the negative end is on the five-membered ring. The \( \beta \) value is a rough empirical number, so only the direction and order of magnitude matter.
Quick Revision Table
| Topic | Key facts |
|---|---|
| Annulene verdicts | [4] anti; [6] arom; [8] non; [10] non (non-planar); [12] weak anti; [14] weak arom; [16] anti (paratropic); [18] arom |
| [18]annulene NMR | outer about δ 9.3, inner about δ −3.0 (low T); shifts move together on warming (conformational averaging) |
| Bridged annulenes | 1,6-methano[10]annulene: CH₂ about δ −0.5; dimethyldihydropyrene: CH₃ about δ −4.2 |
| Syntheses | Sondheimer: Eglinton coupling → KOtBu → partial H₂; Vogel: Birch → :CCl₂ → Na/NH₃ → Br₂, then base (−4 HBr) |
| Dianions | [16]annulene²⁻ diatropic; COT²⁻ aromatic; bridged \( 4n + 2 \) annulene dianions paratropic |
| Azulene | blue, about 1 D (five-ring negative), DE \( 3.364\beta \) vs naphthalene \( 3.683\beta \), S₂ fluorescence |
| Azulene reactivity | E⁺ at C1/C3; Nu⁻ at C4/C6/C8; H⁺ at C1 → azulenium; heat → naphthalene |
| Azulene syntheses | Ziegler–Hafner (pyridinium + Cp⁻); Pfau–Plattner (indane + diazoacetate); dehydrogenation of sesquiterpenes |
| Fulvenes | Thiele: CpH + R₂C=O + base; nucleophiles at C6 → Cp⁻ |
| Polarisation | pentafulvene ring⁻; triafulvene and heptafulvene ring⁺; calicene and sesquifulvalene strongly polar |
| Pentalene | 8π antiaromatic; dianion 10π aromatic |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Aromaticity: Quick Revision: the whole unit on one page.
- Back to the Aromaticity chapter overview.
- How ring currents appear in spectra: Magnetic Resonance Principles.
- Electronic spectra and excited states behind azulene’s colour: Electronic Spectra.