Non-benzenoid Aromatic Ions and Small Rings: Generation and Reactions
CSIR NET organic chemistry: cyclopropenium, cyclobutadiene, cyclopentadienide, ferrocene, tropylium, tropolone and C8 ions, how they form and react.
- 18 min
On this page · 15 sections
Prerequisites
- Aromaticity Criteria: Hückel’s Rule, Antiaromaticity and Beyond: π counting, antiaromaticity and homoaromaticity.
- Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems: Frost-circle energies for C₃ to C₈ rings.
- Alkyl, Carbene and π Complexes: ferrocene and cyclobutadiene–iron complexes from the inorganic side.
The Hook: A Hydrocarbon That Dissolves in Water
The Map: Ring Size, Charge and π Count
| Ring | Cation | Neutral species | Anion |
|---|---|---|---|
| C₃ | C₃H₃⁺, 2π aromatic | cyclopropenone (aromatic contribution) | C₃H₃⁻, 4π antiaromatic |
| C₄ | C₄H₄²⁺, 2π aromatic (dication) | cyclobutadiene, 4π antiaromatic | C₄H₄²⁻ 6π (Hückel count only; electrons in non-bonding MOs) |
| C₅ | C₅H₅⁺, 4π antiaromatic | cyclopentadiene, non-aromatic | C₅H₅⁻, 6π aromatic |
| C₇ | C₇H₇⁺, 6π aromatic | cycloheptatriene, non-aromatic; tropone, tropolone | C₇H₇⁻, 8π antiaromatic |
| C₈ | C₈H₈²⁺, 6π (Hückel count; only substituted dications reported, in superacid) | COT, non-aromatic tub | C₈H₈²⁻, 10π aromatic |
Hückel numbers for the ions
All values are from Frost circles (\( E = \alpha + m\beta \)); delocalisation energy (DE) is measured against isolated ethylenes plus non-bonding electrons at \( \alpha \).
| Species | π electrons | Occupied levels (\( m \)) | \( E_\pi \) | DE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C₃H₃⁺ | 2 | 2 | \( 2\alpha + 4\beta \) | \( 2\beta \) |
| C₃H₃⁻ | 4 | 2; −1, −1 | \( 4\alpha + 2\beta \) | 0 (and a triplet in the regular geometry) |
| C₄H₄²⁺ | 2 | 2 | \( 2\alpha + 4\beta \) | \( 2\beta \) |
| C₄H₄ | 4 | 2; 0, 0 | \( 4\alpha + 4\beta \) | 0 |
| C₅H₅⁻ | 6 | 2; 0.618 ×2 | \( 6\alpha + 6.472\beta \) | \( 2.472\beta \) |
| C₇H₇⁺ | 6 | 2; 1.247 ×2 | \( 6\alpha + 8.988\beta \) | \( 2.988\beta \) |
| C₈H₈²⁻ (planar) | 10 | 2; 1.414 ×2; 0 ×2 | \( 10\alpha + 9.657\beta \) | \( 1.657\beta \) |
Three-Membered Rings
Cyclopropenium cation (2π)
The smallest aromatic system (\( n = 0 \)): two π electrons in one bonding MO spread over three carbons.
Generation
- Breslow (1957): the first cyclopropenium salt, triphenylcyclopropenium, was made by adding phenyldiazoacetonitrile (as a carbene source) to diphenylacetylene to give a 3-cyano-1,2,3-triphenylcyclopropene, then removing cyanide with a Lewis acid (BF₃ with water) to give the cation as its BF₄⁻ salt.
- Ionisation of 3-substituted cyclopropenes: 3-halo-, 3-methoxy- or 3-hydroxycyclopropenes ionise with Lewis acids (SbCl₅, AlCl₃, BF₃) or strong acids. Tetrachlorocyclopropene with AlCl₃ gives the trichlorocyclopropenium ion, which acts as an electrophile toward electron-rich arenes and leads to triarylcyclopropenium salts.
Properties and reactions
- Trialkyl- and triaryl-substituted cyclopropenium ions are stable salts, some persisting in water; their \( pK_{R^+} \) values (the pH at which cation and carbinol are present in equal amounts) are high for carbocations.
- Nucleophiles add at a ring carbon to give neutral 3-substituted cyclopropenes (hydroxide, alkoxide, cyanide, hydride). This is the reverse of generation.
- The cation is the strongest test of Hückel’s rule at its lower limit: a three-membered ring, severely strained, still stabilised by aromaticity.
Cyclopropenone
Cyclopropenones are polarised C⁺–O⁻; the dipolar form puts a 2π cyclopropenium ring next to an oxide. Consequences: very large dipole moments, high basicity for a ketone (they protonate on oxygen to hydroxycyclopropenium ions) and unexpectedly high stability for such a strained ring.
Generation (diphenylcyclopropenone, Breslow): α,α′-dibromination of dibenzyl ketone, then triethylamine. A Favorskii-type 1,3-elimination closes the three-membered ring and eliminates the second HBr to give the cyclopropenone.
Reactions
- Decarbonylation: photolysis expels CO to give the alkyne (diphenylcyclopropenone → diphenylacetylene + CO).
- Protonation or O-alkylation on oxygen to hydroxy- or alkoxycyclopropenium ions.
Cyclopropenyl anion (4π, antiaromatic)
Cyclopropenes are extremely weak carbon acids at C3: kinetic acidity studies (Breslow) showed that forming the cyclopropenyl anion is much harder than forming comparable open-chain or saturated carbanions. The anion would place two electrons in a degenerate antibonding pair: antiaromatic.
Four-Membered Rings
Cyclobutadiene (4π, antiaromatic)
| Feature | Fact |
|---|---|
| Ground state | singlet, rectangular (D₂h), strongly alternating bonds |
| Hückel prediction for a square | triplet diradical (two electrons in the degenerate pair at \( \alpha \)) |
| Stability | dimerises rapidly unless isolated in a frozen matrix at very low temperature |
| Bulky substituents | tetra-tert-butylcyclobutadiene (Maier) is persistent at room temperature |
Generation
- Matrix isolation: photolysis of the bicyclic lactone “photo-α-pyrone” (2-oxabicyclo[2.2.0]hex-5-en-3-one) in an argon matrix at about 8 K expels CO₂ and gives free cyclobutadiene, characterised by IR.
- Pettit (1965), metal release: cis-3,4-dichlorocyclobutene + Fe₂(CO)₉ gives the stable complex (C₄H₄)Fe(CO)₃. In that complex the ring is square and behaves like an aromatic compound: it undergoes Friedel–Crafts acylation and other electrophilic substitutions. Oxidation with Ce(IV) (ceric ammonium nitrate) releases free cyclobutadiene in solution, where it is trapped.
Reactions of free cyclobutadiene
- Diels–Alder with dienophiles: with an alkyne ester it gives a Dewar benzene; with quinones or maleate esters, bicyclo[2.2.0]hexene adducts.
- Self-dimerisation (one molecule as diene, one as dienophile) to the syn tricyclooctadiene.
The iron complex illustrates a general point: a metal can stabilise an antiaromatic ligand by taking electron density into its own orbitals. The 18-electron count of (C₄H₄)Fe(CO)₃ is worked out on the organometallic π-complexes page.
Cyclobutadiene dication and squarate
- C₄R₄²⁺ (2π): tetramethyl- and tetraphenylcyclobutadiene dications have been generated from 3,4-dihalocyclobutenes in superacid media (SbF₅ in SO₂ at low temperature) and observed by NMR. They are the four-ring analogues of cyclopropenium.
- Squarate, C₄O₄²⁻: squaric acid (3,4-dihydroxycyclobut-3-ene-1,2-dione) is an unusually strong diprotic acid for an enol. Its dianion is a symmetric (D₄h) delocalised ion that is often described as a 2π aromatic oxocarbon; how aromatic it is remains debated, so treat it as “aromatic contribution” rather than a textbook aromatic ring.
Five-Membered Rings
Cyclopentadienyl anion (6π, aromatic)
Generation
- Monomer first: cyclopentadiene dimerises by Diels–Alder at room temperature. Heating dicyclopentadiene (around 170 °C) “cracks” it by retro-Diels–Alder; the monomer is distilled and used cold.
- Deprotonation: Na metal or NaH in THF, n-BuLi, or KOH/alkoxide in polar solvents gives NaCp, LiCp or KCp. Cyclopentadiene is an unusually strong carbon acid (pKa about 16 on the aqueous scale, about 18 in DMSO), comparable to water or an alcohol, because the conjugate base is aromatic. Cyclopentane, by contrast, is a typical alkane with pKa near 50.
| Carbon acid | Conjugate base | Approximate pKa | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cyclopentadiene | C₅H₅⁻, 6π aromatic | about 16 (H₂O scale) | aromatic anion |
| Indene | indenide | weaker acid than cyclopentadiene | benzo fusion dilutes the anion’s extra stabilisation |
| Fluorene | fluorenide | weaker still | two benzo rings |
| Cycloheptatriene | C₇H₇⁻, 8π antiaromatic | about 36–39 | antiaromatic anion |
| Cyclopentane | cyclopentyl anion | about 50 | no delocalisation |
On Bordwell’s DMSO scale the values are about 18.0 (cyclopentadiene), 20.1 (indene) and 22.6 (fluorene); the order Cp-H > indene > fluorene is the safe exam fact.
Evidence of aromaticity: a single ¹H NMR line (all five CH equivalent, D₅h), planar structure, and the ease of formation above.
Reactions
| Reagent | Product | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| R–X | 5-alkylcyclopentadiene (isomerises by 1,5-H shifts) | C-alkylation; dialkylation possible |
| Aldehyde or ketone (with base) | fulvene (Thiele condensation) | the anion adds to C=O, then dehydration |
| FeCl₂ | ferrocene, (η⁵-C₅H₅)₂Fe | 18-electron sandwich |
| Other MXₙ | metallocenes, Cp metal carbonyls | Cp⁻ is the commonest organometallic ligand |
| CO₂ | cyclopentadienecarboxylic acid |
Ferrocene as an aromatic compound
Ferrocene’s Cp rings undergo electrophilic substitution much faster than benzene:
- Friedel–Crafts acylation (Ac₂O with H₃PO₄, or AcCl/AlCl₃) → acetylferrocene; a second acyl group goes to the other ring (1,1′-diacetylferrocene), because the first acyl group deactivates its own ring.
- Vilsmeier formylation → ferrocenecarbaldehyde; Mannich reaction (CH₂O, Me₂NH) → (dimethylaminomethyl)ferrocene.
- Direct nitration or halogenation fail: the oxidising electrophile converts Fe(II) to the ferrocenium ion [Cp₂Fe]⁺, which is not nucleophilic. Nitro- and haloferrocenes are made indirectly (for example via lithioferrocene).
- Metallation with n-BuLi gives lithioferrocene, an entry to many derivatives.
Cyclopentadienyl cation (4π, antiaromatic)
Attempts to ionise 5-substituted cyclopentadienes (halides, tosylates) proceed far more slowly than for cyclopentyl analogues. When generated (for example from 5-halocyclopentadienes with SbF₅ at very low temperature, or as the pentaphenyl derivative from pentaphenylcyclopentadienol with a Lewis acid), the cation shows triplet ESR signals: the two electrons occupy the degenerate pair with parallel spins, as Hückel theory predicts.
Seven-Membered Rings
Tropylium (cycloheptatrienylium) cation (6π, aromatic)
Generation
- Cycloheptatriene first: from benzene and diazomethane under photolysis or copper/rhodium catalysis (Buchner ring expansion, via norcaradiene ⇌ cycloheptatriene valence tautomerism). (Willstätter’s much older route degraded the tropane alkaloid skeleton.)
- Bromination–dehydrobromination (Doering–Knox): Br₂ adds to cycloheptatriene; heating the dibromide expels HBr to give tropylium bromide.
- Hydride abstraction (Dauben): trityl tetrafluoroborate, Ph₃C⁺ BF₄⁻, removes H⁻ from cycloheptatriene in acetonitrile or CH₂Cl₂: C₇H₈ + Ph₃C⁺ → C₇H₇⁺ + Ph₃CH. The reaction runs downhill because tropylium is the more stabilised cation.
Properties
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| Structure | planar regular heptagon, D₇h |
| ¹H NMR | one singlet near δ 9.2 (7H): positive charge plus diatropic ring current |
| Salts | tropylium bromide, perchlorate and tetrafluoroborate are ionic solids, soluble in water, insoluble in ether |
| \( pK_{R^+} \) | about 4.7: in water at pH 4.7 the cation and the alcohol (cycloheptatrienol) are present in equal amounts |
The equilibrium is \( \text{R}^+ + \text{H}_2\text{O} \rightleftharpoons \text{ROH} + \text{H}^+ \), so
$$\log\frac{[\text{R}^+]}{[\text{ROH}]} = pK_{R^+} - \text{pH}$$At pH 2.7 the cation is about 99% of the total; at pH 7 it is only about 0.5%. For comparison, the trityl cation needs strongly acidic solution to persist.
Reactions: nucleophiles add at carbon
Every nucleophile attacks a ring carbon and gives a 7-substituted cycloheptatriene (aromaticity lost; the product is a neutral, non-aromatic triene).
| Nucleophile | Product |
|---|---|
| H₂O / OH⁻ | cycloheptatrienol (which can condense to ditropyl ether) |
| CN⁻ | 7-cyanocycloheptatriene |
| NaBH₄ or LiAlH₄ (H⁻) | cycloheptatriene |
| RMgX, RLi | 7-alkyl- or 7-arylcycloheptatriene |
| NH₃, amines | 7-aminocycloheptatrienes (tropylamines) |
| ROH / RO⁻ | 7-alkoxycycloheptatrienes |
| Enolates, electron-rich arenes | C-tropylation products |
Tropylium salts are also used as hydride acceptors (oxidants) in synthesis, being reduced back to cycloheptatriene.
Cycloheptatrienyl anion (8π, antiaromatic)
Cycloheptatriene is about 20 pKa units weaker as an acid than cyclopentadiene: the anion would have 8 π electrons, two of them in a degenerate antibonding pair. Strong bases such as alkyllithium–amine mixtures or potassium amide are needed, and the anion is non-planar and reactive.
Tropone and tropolone
Tropone (cyclohepta-2,4,6-trien-1-one) has a polarised carbonyl whose dipolar form contains a tropylium ring and an oxide anion. Hence:
- larger dipole moment than a saturated cyclic ketone;
- unusually basic for a ketone: it dissolves in aqueous acid as the hydroxytropylium ion;
- reluctant to give normal carbonyl addition products;
- the triene acts as a 6π component in cycloadditions (for example [6 + 4] with cyclopentadiene).
Tropolone (2-hydroxytropone) is the better-studied case:
| Property | Fact |
|---|---|
| Acidity | pKa about 7: more acidic than phenol (about 10), weaker than carboxylic acids |
| Tautomerism | fast, degenerate proton exchange between the two oxygens; strong intramolecular H-bond |
| Metal binding | bidentate O,O-chelator; gives coloured complexes with Fe(III) and Cu(II) |
| Reactivity | phenol-like electrophilic substitution (halogenation, nitration, azo coupling); does not behave as a simple ketone |
| Natural examples | β-thujaplicin (hinokitiol) from cedar wood; the tropolone methyl ether ring of colchicine |
Generation of tropolone: a standard laboratory route is [2 + 2] cycloaddition of dichloroketene (from dichloroacetyl chloride and Et₃N) to cyclopentadiene, giving 7,7-dichlorobicyclo[3.2.0]hept-2-en-6-one, followed by solvolysis (acetate or hydroxide), which opens the four-membered ring and expands it to the seven-membered tropolone.
Eight-Membered Rings
Cyclooctatetraene and its dianion
| Species | π electrons | Shape | Bonds | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| COT, C₈H₈ | 8 | tub (D₂d) | alternating, about 1.33 and 1.47 Å | non-aromatic |
| COT radical anion | 9 | planar | delocalised | |
| COT²⁻ | 10 | planar octagon (D₈h) | all equal, about 1.41 Å | aromatic |
| COT²⁺ | 6 | planar (Hückel count; not a textbook-isolable ion) | aromatic by count |
Generation of COT: Reppe tetramerisation of acetylene over nickel cyanide catalysts (industrial). Willstätter’s earlier multistep synthesis from pseudopelletierine was the first.
Generation of COT²⁻: reduction of COT with alkali metals (K, Li) in THF or liquid NH₃ takes up two electrons; the tub flattens to a planar 10π aromatic dianion with a single ¹H NMR line.
Reactions
- K₂COT + UCl₄ → uranocene, U(η⁸-C₈H₈)₂, a sandwich of two aromatic 10π rings (Streitwieser, 1968).
- Neutral COT reacts like a polyene, often through its valence tautomer bicyclo[4.2.0]octa-2,4,7-triene: bromine gives a bicyclic dibromide; maleic anhydride gives a Diels–Alder adduct of the bicyclic form.
- COT is hydrogenated stepwise and adds electrophiles like an alkene; it shows no aromatic substitution.
- Protonation in concentrated H₂SO₄ gives the homotropylium ion, the textbook homoaromatic species (next section).
Homotropylium ion
COT + conc. H₂SO₄ (or FSO₃H) → C₈H₉⁺. Protonation creates one CH₂ group; the remaining seven sp² carbons carry 6 π electrons. The ring stays nearly closed: the p orbitals on C1 and C7 overlap through space across the CH₂, giving a homoaromatic 6π ion.
| ¹H NMR evidence (approximate) | Shift |
|---|---|
| CH₂, proton pointing over the ring (inner) | about δ −0.7 |
| CH₂, proton pointing outward | about δ 5.1 |
| Difference | about 5.8 ppm |
| Ring CH | δ 6.4–8.5 region |
A difference of almost 6 ppm between two protons on the same carbon is impossible to explain without a diatropic ring current, which is the experimental definition of homoaromaticity.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Tropylium: aromatic cation, δ 9.2, \( pK_{R^+} \) about 4.7 | Trityl cation: stabilised by phenyl resonance, not by ring aromaticity | |
| Cycloheptatriene: non-aromatic, weak acid | Cyclopentadiene: non-aromatic, but acidic because its anion is aromatic | |
| Tropone: basic carbonyl, hydroxytropylium on protonation | Tropolone: acidic (pKa about 7), chelating enol | |
| Homotropylium: COT + H⁺ | Tropylium: cycloheptatriene − H⁻ | |
| COT: tub, non-aromatic | COT²⁻: planar, aromatic (10π) | |
| Free cyclobutadiene: rectangular, antiaromatic | (C₄H₄)Fe(CO)₃: square, undergoes aromatic substitution |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which reagent converts cycloheptatriene into a tropylium salt in one step at room temperature?
- What is formed when free cyclobutadiene is generated in the presence of an alkyne dienophile?
- Why does cyclopentadiene dissolve in aqueous-alcoholic KOH while cycloheptatriene does not react?
Answers
- Trityl tetrafluoroborate (Ph₃C⁺ BF₄⁻), which abstracts hydride.
- A Dewar benzene (bicyclo[2.2.0]hexadiene) by Diels–Alder addition.
- Cyclopentadiene (pKa about 16) is deprotonated to the aromatic 6π cyclopentadienide; cycloheptatriene’s anion would be 8π antiaromatic, so it is about 20 pKa units less acidic.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Tropylium bromide reacts with sodium cyanide in water. The product is:
(a) cyanotropylium bromide (b) 7-cyanocyclohepta-1,3,5-triene (c) benzonitrile (d) no reaction, because tropylium is aromatic
Answer: (b)
Cyanide adds at a ring carbon of the cation; the product is a neutral, non-aromatic 7-substituted cycloheptatriene. Aromaticity makes the cation stable as a salt, not unreactive toward good nucleophiles.
Practice Q2. Which sequence gives free cyclobutadiene in solution?
(a) cis-3,4-dichlorocyclobutene + Fe₂(CO)₉, then Ce(IV) (b) cyclobutene + Br₂, then KOH (c) cyclooctatetraene + K, then H₂O (d) cyclopentadiene + dichloroketene, then NaOAc
Answer: (a)
Pettit’s route: form (C₄H₄)Fe(CO)₃, then oxidatively release the ligand with ceric ammonium nitrate. (d) is the tropolone route; (c) gives dihydro-COT after protonation of the dianion.
Practice Q3. Ferrocene is treated with acetic anhydride and phosphoric acid, and then the product with excess reagent under forcing conditions. The final major product is:
(a) 1,2-diacetylferrocene (b) 1,1′-diacetylferrocene (c) nitroferrocene (d) ferrocenium acetate
Answer: (b)
The first acetyl group deactivates its own Cp ring, so the second acylation occurs on the other ring: 1,1′-diacetylferrocene.
Practice Q4. Which species gives a single ¹H NMR signal and is aromatic?
(a) cyclooctatetraene (b) cycloheptatriene (c) C₈H₈²⁻ (from COT and potassium) (d) homotropylium ion
Answer: (c)
COT²⁻ is a planar D₈h, 10π aromatic ion with eight equivalent protons. COT also gives one line (all eight H are symmetry-equivalent in the D₂d tub) but is non-aromatic. Cycloheptatriene and the homotropylium ion have several inequivalent protons.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Take pKa(cyclopentadiene) = 16 and pKa(cycloheptatriene) = 36 (aqueous scale, approximate) and \( T = 298 \) K. Which statements are correct?
- The difference in standard free energy of ionisation is about 114 kJ mol⁻¹.
- The difference arises mainly because C₅H₅⁻ is aromatic and C₇H₇⁻ is antiaromatic.
- The equilibrium C₅H₅⁻ + C₇H₈ ⇌ C₅H₆ + C₇H₇⁻ has \( K \approx 10^{20} \).
- Cycloheptatriene can be fully deprotonated by sodium cyclopentadienide.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
- Correct. \( \Delta\Delta G^\circ = 2.303RT\,\Delta pK_a = 2.303 \times 8.314 \times 298 \times 20 \approx 1.14 \times 10^5 \) J mol⁻¹ \( \approx 114 \) kJ mol⁻¹.
- Correct.
- Wrong. \( K = K_a(\text{C}_7\text{H}_8)/K_a(\text{C}_5\text{H}_6) = 10^{-36}/10^{-16} = 10^{-20} \), not \( 10^{20} \).
- Wrong, for the same reason: the equilibrium lies \( 10^{20} \) to the left.
Practice Q6. A tropylium salt has \( pK_{R^+} = 4.7 \). A buffered aqueous solution of it is prepared at pH 2.7, and a second at pH 7.0. Which pair of cation fractions \( [\text{R}^+]/([\text{R}^+] + [\text{ROH}]) \) is correct?
(a) 0.99 and 0.005 (b) 0.50 and 0.50 (c) 0.01 and 0.995 (d) 0.67 and 0.33
Answer: (a)
\( [\text{R}^+]/[\text{ROH}] = 10^{pK_{R^+} - \text{pH}} \).
- pH 2.7: ratio \( 10^{2} = 100 \); fraction \( 100/101 = 0.990 \).
- pH 7.0: ratio \( 10^{-2.3} = 0.0050 \); fraction \( 0.0050/1.0050 \approx 0.005 \). Lower pH pushes the equilibrium \( \text{R}^+ + \text{H}_2\text{O} \rightleftharpoons \text{ROH} + \text{H}^+ \) to the left.
Practice Q7. Cyclooctatetraene is dissolved in FSO₃H at low temperature. The ¹H NMR spectrum shows, among others, two one-proton signals at δ 5.1 and δ −0.7 that do not exchange quickly. Which statements are correct?
- The species is C₈H₉⁺, formed by protonation.
- The δ −0.7 proton lies above the π system, inside the ring current.
- The ion has 8 π electrons and is antiaromatic.
- The results are evidence for homoaromaticity.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
Protonation gives the homotropylium ion (1). The two CH₂ protons differ by 5.8 ppm; the shielded one points over the ring (2), which needs a diatropic current from 6 π electrons over seven sp² carbons: homoaromatic (4). The ion has 6, not 8, π electrons in the cyclic array, and a paratropic ion would shield the outer, not the inner, proton (3 is wrong).
Quick Revision Table
| Species | π e⁻ | Status | Generation | Typical reaction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C₃R₃⁺ | 2 | aromatic | Breslow: carbene + alkyne, then −CN⁻; 3-X-cyclopropene + Lewis acid | Nu⁻ adds → 3-substituted cyclopropene |
| Cyclopropenone | 2 (dipolar) | aromatic contribution | dibromo-dibenzyl ketone + Et₃N | −CO → alkyne; O-protonation |
| C₄H₄ | 4 | antiaromatic | Fe(CO)₃ complex + Ce(IV); photo-α-pyrone at 8 K | Diels–Alder, dimerisation |
| C₅H₅⁻ | 6 | aromatic | crack dicyclopentadiene, then NaH/BuLi | alkylation, fulvenes, metallocenes |
| C₅H₅⁺ | 4 | antiaromatic | very hard; triplet | — |
| C₇H₇⁺ | 6 | aromatic | Br₂ then heat; Ph₃C⁺ BF₄⁻ | Nu⁻ adds → 7-substituted cycloheptatriene |
| Tropolone | 6 (dipolar) | aromatic | dichloroketene + Cp, then solvolysis | acidic (pKa about 7), chelates, SEAr |
| COT²⁻ | 10 | aromatic | COT + 2 K | uranocene with UCl₄ |
| C₈H₉⁺ | 6 | homoaromatic | COT + H₂SO₄ or FSO₃H | NMR Δδ about 5.8 ppm |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Annulenes, Azulene and Fulvenes: larger rings, fused non-benzenoid systems, and the cross-conjugated fulvenes made from cyclopentadienide.
- Back to the criteria: Aromaticity Criteria: Hückel’s Rule, Antiaromaticity and Beyond.
- Metal–ring bonding in ferrocene and uranocene: Electron Counting and Metal Carbonyls.
- Aromaticity: Quick Revision.