The Antisymmetry Principle, Pauli Exclusion and Slater Determinants
CSIR NET chemistry: exchange symmetry, fermions and bosons, Pauli principle, Slater determinants, singlet and triplet helium, exchange integral, ortho/para H2.
- 22 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Two Heliums That Never Talk
- Identical Particles and the Exchange Operator
- The Antisymmetry Principle
- From Antisymmetry to the Pauli Exclusion Principle
- Slater Determinants
- Two Electrons: Separating Space and Spin
- Excited Helium: the Exchange Integral
- Exchange in Many-Electron Atoms
- Nuclear Spin Statistics: Antisymmetry in Molecules
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Many-electron Hamiltonians, the orbital approximation and Hartree–Fock in outline: Many-Electron Atoms: Helium, the Orbital Approximation and SCF.
- Spin angular momentum, \( \alpha \) and \( \beta \) spin functions, and adding two spins: Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum.
- Determinants: a determinant changes sign when two rows (or two columns) are swapped and is zero when two rows are equal.
The Hook: Two Heliums That Never Talk
Identical Particles and the Exchange Operator
In classical mechanics two electrons can be told apart by following their trajectories. In quantum mechanics there are no trajectories, and two electrons are truly indistinguishable: no measurement can tell which is “electron 1”.
Write \( q_i = (\mathbf{r}_i, \sigma_i) \) for the space and spin coordinates of electron \( i \). Define the exchange (permutation) operator \( \hat{P}_{12} \), which swaps the labels of particles 1 and 2:
$$\hat{P}_{12}\,\Psi(q_1, q_2, \ldots) = \Psi(q_2, q_1, \ldots)$$Two facts fix its eigenvalues:
- Swapping twice restores the original: \( \hat{P}_{12}^2 = 1 \). So the eigenvalues are \( \pm 1 \).
- The Hamiltonian treats identical particles identically, so \( [\hat{H}, \hat{P}_{12}] = 0 \). Energy eigenstates can be chosen to be eigenstates of \( \hat{P}_{12} \), and the exchange symmetry does not change with time.
Because the particles are indistinguishable, every observable, including \( \lvert\Psi\rvert^2 \), must be unchanged by \( \hat{P}_{12} \). Both eigenvalues satisfy that. Nature uses both, but not freely.
The Antisymmetry Principle
The wavefunction of a system of identical particles must be either symmetric or antisymmetric under the exchange of any two of them:
- Fermions (half-integer spin: \( \tfrac{1}{2}, \tfrac{3}{2}, \ldots \)): \( \hat{P}_{ij}\Psi = -\Psi \). Antisymmetric.
- Bosons (integer spin: \( 0, 1, 2, \ldots \)): \( \hat{P}_{ij}\Psi = +\Psi \). Symmetric.
For electrons this is the antisymmetry principle: the total wavefunction, space and spin together, must change sign when the coordinates of any two electrons are interchanged.
The link between spin and exchange symmetry (the spin–statistics connection) is proved in relativistic quantum field theory. In non-relativistic quantum chemistry it is taken as a postulate.
Fermion or boson?
A composite particle is a fermion if it contains an odd number of fermions and a boson if it contains an even number. Count protons, neutrons and electrons.
| Particle | Spin | Type | Count |
|---|---|---|---|
| electron, proton, neutron | \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) | fermion | — |
| photon | 1 | boson | — |
| ¹H nucleus (proton) | \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) | fermion | 1 |
| ²H nucleus (deuteron) | 1 | boson | 2 nucleons |
| ³He nucleus | \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) | fermion | 3 nucleons |
| ⁴He nucleus (α particle) | 0 | boson | 4 nucleons |
| ⁴He atom | 0 | boson | 4 nucleons + 2 electrons = 6 |
| ³He atom | \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) | fermion | 3 + 2 = 5 |
| ¹H atom | 0 or 1 | boson | 1 proton + 1 electron = 2 |
| ¹²C, ¹⁶O nuclei | 0 | boson | even nucleons |
| ¹³C nucleus | \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) | fermion | 13 nucleons |
The difference between ⁴He and ³He is dramatic at low temperature (the bosonic isotope becomes a superfluid at a much higher temperature than the fermionic one), a macroscopic consequence of exchange symmetry.
From Antisymmetry to the Pauli Exclusion Principle
Take two electrons in the orbital approximation. Let \( \chi_a \) and \( \chi_b \) be spin-orbitals: a spatial orbital times a spin function, for example \( \chi_a = 1s\,\alpha \).
The Hartree product \( \chi_a(1)\chi_b(2) \) is not antisymmetric. The antisymmetric combination is
$$\Psi(1,2) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[\chi_a(1)\chi_b(2) - \chi_b(1)\chi_a(2)\right]$$Check: swapping 1 and 2 gives \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[\chi_a(2)\chi_b(1) - \chi_b(2)\chi_a(1)] = -\Psi(1,2) \).
Now put both electrons in the same spin-orbital, \( \chi_a = \chi_b \). The two terms are identical and cancel: \( \Psi = 0 \). Such a state does not exist.
The exclusion principle is therefore a consequence of antisymmetry within the orbital approximation, not an independent law. Antisymmetry is the deeper statement: it applies even when orbitals are not a good description.
Consequences you already use:
- An orbital holds at most two electrons, with \( m_s = +\tfrac{1}{2} \) and \( -\tfrac{1}{2} \).
- A subshell \( l \) holds \( 2(2l + 1) \) electrons: s 2, p 6, d 10, f 14. A shell \( n \) holds \( 2n^2 \).
- Lithium is \( 1s^2 2s^1 \), not \( 1s^3 \). The periodic table exists.
- The number of ways to place \( N \) electrons in a subshell of \( 2(2l + 1) \) spin-orbitals (the microstates used to build term symbols) is \( \binom{4l+2}{N} \), not \( (4l + 2)^N \).
Slater Determinants
For \( N \) electrons, the antisymmetrised product of \( N \) spin-orbitals is written compactly as a determinant:
$$\Psi(1, 2, \ldots, N) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{N!}}\begin{vmatrix} \chi_1(1) & \chi_2(1) & \cdots & \chi_N(1) \\ \chi_1(2) & \chi_2(2) & \cdots & \chi_N(2) \\ \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & \vdots \\ \chi_1(N) & \chi_2(N) & \cdots & \chi_N(N) \end{vmatrix}$$Rows are electrons, columns are spin-orbitals (some books use the transpose; the determinant is the same). The shorthand lists the diagonal: \( \Psi = \lvert \chi_1 \chi_2 \cdots \chi_N \rvert \).
| Property of determinants | Physical meaning |
|---|---|
| Swapping two rows changes the sign | swapping two electrons changes the sign: antisymmetry is built in |
| Two equal columns make it zero | two electrons in the same spin-orbital: Pauli exclusion |
| Swapping two columns changes the sign | reordering spin-orbitals only changes the overall phase, same state |
| \( N! \) terms in the expansion | the factor \( 1/\sqrt{N!} \) normalises it (for orthonormal spin-orbitals) |
Example: helium ground state
Both electrons in 1s, one with \( \alpha \) and one with \( \beta \):
$$\Psi = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{vmatrix} 1s(1)\alpha(1) & 1s(1)\beta(1) \\ 1s(2)\alpha(2) & 1s(2)\beta(2) \end{vmatrix} = 1s(1)\,1s(2)\cdot\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[\alpha(1)\beta(2) - \beta(1)\alpha(2)\right]$$The determinant factorises into a symmetric spatial part times the antisymmetric singlet spin function. The product is antisymmetric, as required. The ground state of helium is a singlet, \( ^1S_0 \).
Example: lithium ground state
$$\Psi_{\text{Li}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}\begin{vmatrix} 1s\alpha(1) & 1s\beta(1) & 2s\alpha(1) \\ 1s\alpha(2) & 1s\beta(2) & 2s\alpha(2) \\ 1s\alpha(3) & 1s\beta(3) & 2s\alpha(3) \end{vmatrix} = \lvert 1s\alpha\ 1s\beta\ 2s\alpha \rvert$$Try \( \lvert 1s\alpha\ 1s\beta\ 1s\alpha \rvert \) and two columns are equal, so it vanishes. The third electron is forced into 2s.
Two Electrons: Separating Space and Spin
For two electrons (and only for two) the total wavefunction can always be written as a spatial part times a spin part. Since the total must be antisymmetric:
$$\underbrace{\text{symmetric space}}_{+} \times \underbrace{\text{antisymmetric spin}}_{-} \qquad \text{or} \qquad \underbrace{\text{antisymmetric space}}_{-} \times \underbrace{\text{symmetric spin}}_{+}$$The four two-electron spin functions
| Spin function | \( S \) | \( M_S \) | Exchange symmetry |
|---|---|---|---|
| \( \alpha(1)\alpha(2) \) | 1 | +1 | symmetric |
| \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[\alpha(1)\beta(2) + \beta(1)\alpha(2)\right] \) | 1 | 0 | symmetric |
| \( \beta(1)\beta(2) \) | 1 | −1 | symmetric |
| \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[\alpha(1)\beta(2) - \beta(1)\alpha(2)\right] \) | 0 | 0 | antisymmetric |
The three symmetric functions form the triplet (\( 2S + 1 = 3 \)); the antisymmetric one is the singlet. The simple products \( \alpha(1)\beta(2) \) and \( \beta(1)\alpha(2) \) on their own have no definite exchange symmetry and are not eigenfunctions of \( \hat{S}^2 \).
So, for two electrons:
$$\textbf{singlet} \Leftrightarrow \text{symmetric spatial function}, \qquad \textbf{triplet} \Leftrightarrow \text{antisymmetric spatial function}$$Excited Helium: the Exchange Integral
Promote one electron: configuration \( 1s^1 2s^1 \). Write \( a = 1s \), \( b = 2s \). The allowed spatial functions are
$$\psi_\pm = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[a(1)b(2) \pm b(1)a(2)\right]$$- \( \psi_+ \) (symmetric) pairs with the singlet spin function: the \( ^1S \) state.
- \( \psi_- \) (antisymmetric) pairs with the three triplet spin functions: the \( ^3S \) state.
Take the expectation value of the Hamiltonian \( \hat{h}(1) + \hat{h}(2) + 1/r_{12} \):
$$\boxed{E_\pm = E_a + E_b + J \pm K}$$where
$$J = \iint \lvert a(1)\rvert^2 \frac{1}{r_{12}} \lvert b(2)\rvert^2\, d\tau_1 d\tau_2, \qquad K = \iint a(1)b(1)\frac{1}{r_{12}}a(2)b(2)\, d\tau_1 d\tau_2$$| Integral | Name | Meaning | Sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| \( J \) | Coulomb integral | classical repulsion between charge clouds \( \lvert a\rvert^2 \) and \( \lvert b\rvert^2 \) | positive |
| \( K \) | exchange integral | no classical analogue; appears because the spatial function is a ± combination | positive (for these atomic orbitals) |
So:
- Singlet (\( ^1S \), symmetric space): \( E = E_a + E_b + J + K \)
- Triplet (\( ^3S \), antisymmetric space): \( E = E_a + E_b + J - K \)
- Singlet–triplet gap: \( E(^1S) - E(^3S) = 2K \). The triplet lies lower.
The same reasoning applies to \( 1s^1 2p^1 \): \( ^3P \) lies below \( ^1P \), again by \( 2K \) (with a different \( K \)).
Parahelium and orthohelium
| Parahelium | Orthohelium | |
|---|---|---|
| Spin | \( S = 0 \), singlets | \( S = 1 \), triplets |
| Spatial function | symmetric | antisymmetric |
| Ground configuration \( 1s^2 \) | yes (\( 1^1S_0 \)) | impossible: \( 1s^2 \) has no antisymmetric spatial function |
| Lowest level | \( 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) | \( 1s2s\ ^3S_1 \), metastable |
| Same configuration | higher by \( 2K \) | lower by \( 2K \) |
Electric-dipole transitions do not change spin (\( \Delta S = 0 \), see Term Symbols, Coupling Schemes and Atomic Spectra), so the two systems produce two independent sets of lines. The lowest triplet, \( 1s2s\ ^3S_1 \), cannot decay to the \( 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) ground state by an allowed transition and is long-lived (metastable).
Measured energies (above the ground state, rounded): \( 1s2s\ ^3S \) about 19.82 eV, \( 1s2s\ ^1S \) about 20.62 eV. The gap, about 0.80 eV, equals \( 2K_{1s,2s} \), so \( K \approx 0.40 \) eV.
Exchange in Many-Electron Atoms
The same pattern runs through Hartree–Fock theory. For a single determinant, the energy contains for every pair of occupied spin-orbitals a Coulomb integral \( J_{ij} \), and, only if the two spin-orbitals have the same spin, an exchange integral \( -K_{ij} \). Hence:
- Same-spin electrons have repulsion \( J - K \); opposite-spin electrons have \( J \). Parallel spins are favoured.
- Exchange energy in a subshell is proportional to the number of same-spin pairs, \( \tfrac{n_\uparrow(n_\uparrow - 1)}{2} + \tfrac{n_\downarrow(n_\downarrow - 1)}{2} \). This is the source of the extra stability of half-filled and filled subshells (\( d^5 \), \( d^{10} \)) that explains Cr \( 3d^5 4s^1 \) and Cu \( 3d^{10} 4s^1 \) in Electronic Configuration, Shielding and Effective Nuclear Charge.
| Configuration | Spin arrangement | Same-spin pairs |
|---|---|---|
| \( d^4 \) high spin | ↑↑↑↑ | 6 |
| \( d^5 \) high spin | ↑↑↑↑↑ | 10 |
| \( d^6 \) high spin | ↑↑↑↑↑ ↓ | 10 |
| \( d^{10} \) | 5↑ 5↓ | 20 |
| \( p^3 \) | ↑↑↑ | 3 |
| \( p^4 \) | ↑↑↑ ↓ | 3 |
Going from \( d^4 \) to \( d^5 \) gains four exchange pairs; going from \( d^5 \) to \( d^6 \) gains none. The same count explains why the ionisation energy of O (\( p^4 \)) is lower than that of N (\( p^3 \)): removing the paired electron from \( p^4 \) loses no exchange stabilisation and relieves a pairing repulsion.
Nuclear Spin Statistics: Antisymmetry in Molecules
The symmetrisation postulate applies to nuclei too. In a homonuclear diatomic molecule, swapping the two nuclei changes the sign of the total wavefunction (fermion nuclei) or leaves it unchanged (boson nuclei). For the rotational wavefunction, exchanging the nuclei multiplies it by \( (-1)^J \), so the allowed rotational levels depend on the nuclear spin state. (The statements below are for molecules whose electronic ground state is symmetric under this exchange, as in H₂, D₂ and CO₂.)
| Molecule | Nuclear spin \( I \) | Nuclei are | Nuclear spin states | Rotational levels | Intensity ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H₂ | \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) | fermions | 3 symmetric (ortho), 1 antisymmetric (para) | ortho: odd \( J \); para: even \( J \) | odd : even = 3 : 1 |
| D₂ | 1 | bosons | 6 symmetric (ortho), 3 antisymmetric (para) | ortho: even \( J \); para: odd \( J \) | even : odd = 2 : 1 |
| ¹⁶O¹²C¹⁶O | 0 (¹⁶O) | bosons | 1 symmetric only | even \( J \) only | odd \( J \) missing |
For two nuclei of spin \( I \), there are \( (2I + 1)^2 \) spin states: \( (I + 1)(2I + 1) \) symmetric and \( I(2I + 1) \) antisymmetric. The ratio of symmetric to antisymmetric is \( (I + 1)/I \).
Consequences: alternating intensities in rotational Raman spectra of H₂ and D₂; missing alternate lines in the rotational structure of CO₂; and two forms of hydrogen (ortho and para) that interconvert only slowly without a catalyst. At high temperature normal H₂ is 3 : 1 ortho : para; at low temperature it relaxes, with a catalyst, towards pure para-H₂ (the \( J = 0 \) level is para).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Antisymmetry principle: total \( \Psi \) changes sign on exchange of any two electrons | Pauli exclusion: no two electrons in the same spin-orbital (a consequence of antisymmetry in the orbital picture) | |
| Coulomb integral \( J \): classical, present for every pair | Exchange integral \( K \): quantum, only for same-spin pairs in a determinant | |
| Singlet: antisymmetric spin, symmetric space | Triplet: symmetric spin, antisymmetric space | |
| \( \alpha(1)\beta(2) \): no definite exchange symmetry | \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[\alpha(1)\beta(2) \pm \beta(1)\alpha(2)] \): definite symmetry, definite \( S \) | |
| Swapping two rows (electrons) of a Slater determinant: sign change, same state | Two equal columns (spin-orbitals): determinant is zero, no state | |
| Parahelium: singlets, includes ground state | Para-hydrogen: nuclear-spin singlet, even \( J \) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What are the eigenvalues of the exchange operator \( \hat{P}_{12} \), and why?
- Is the spin function \( \alpha(1)\beta(2) \) symmetric, antisymmetric or neither under exchange?
- What is the normalisation factor of a Slater determinant for four electrons?
Answers
- +1 and −1. Exchanging twice gives the identity, so \( \hat{P}_{12}^2 = 1 \) and \( \lambda^2 = 1 \).
- Neither. Exchange gives \( \alpha(2)\beta(1) = \beta(1)\alpha(2) \), a different function. Only the sum (triplet, \( M_S = 0 \)) and difference (singlet) have definite symmetry.
- \( 1/\sqrt{4!} = 1/\sqrt{24} \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which of the following two-electron wavefunctions satisfies the antisymmetry principle? (\( a \) and \( b \) are different orthonormal spatial orbitals.)
(a) \( a(1)b(2)\,\alpha(1)\alpha(2) \) (b) \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[a(1)b(2) + b(1)a(2)]\,\alpha(1)\alpha(2) \) (c) \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[a(1)b(2) - b(1)a(2)]\,\alpha(1)\alpha(2) \) (d) \( \tfrac{1}{2}[a(1)b(2) - b(1)a(2)][\alpha(1)\beta(2) - \beta(1)\alpha(2)] \)
Answer: (c)
\( \alpha\alpha \) is symmetric, so the spatial part must be antisymmetric: only (c) works.
(a) has no definite symmetry. (b) is symmetric × symmetric = symmetric. (d) is antisymmetric × antisymmetric = symmetric overall: a common trap, since both factors “look antisymmetric”.
Practice Q2. For the \( 1s^1 2s^1 \) configuration of helium, with Coulomb integral \( J \) and exchange integral \( K \) (both positive), the energies of the singlet and triplet states relative to \( E_{1s} + E_{2s} \) are, respectively:
(a) \( J - K \) and \( J + K \) (b) \( J + K \) and \( J - K \) (c) \( J + 2K \) and \( J \) (d) \( J \) and \( J - 2K \)
Answer: (b)
Singlet: symmetric space, \( E = E_{1s} + E_{2s} + J + K \). Triplet: antisymmetric space, \( J - K \). The triplet is lower by \( 2K \).
Practice Q3. Which of the following is a boson?
(a) ³He atom (b) ¹³C nucleus (c) ²H nucleus (d) a neutron
Answer: (c) ²H nucleus
The deuteron has one proton and one neutron: two fermions, so a boson (spin 1). ³He atom: 2 p + 1 n + 2 e = 5, fermion. ¹³C nucleus: 13 nucleons, fermion. A neutron is a spin-½ fermion.
Practice Q4. In the high-temperature rotational Raman spectrum of H₂, lines originating from odd-\( J \) and even-\( J \) levels show an intensity alternation (apart from the Boltzmann envelope) of:
(a) 1 : 1 (b) 2 : 1 (c) 3 : 1 (d) 1 : 3
Answer: (c) 3 : 1 (odd : even)
Protons are fermions with \( I = \tfrac{1}{2} \). Four nuclear spin states: three symmetric (ortho), one antisymmetric (para). The total wavefunction must be antisymmetric under exchange of nuclei, so ortho (symmetric spin) pairs with odd \( J \) and para with even \( J \). Weights 3 : 1. The 2 : 1 ratio (b) belongs to D₂, with even \( J \) favoured.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. In helium, the \( 1s2s\ ^3S \) and \( 1s2s\ ^1S \) states lie about 19.82 eV and 20.62 eV above the ground state. The ground state is at \( -79.0 \) eV and He⁺ at \( -54.4 \) eV on the absolute scale. Which conclusions are correct?
- The exchange integral \( K_{1s,2s} \) is about 0.40 eV.
- The energy needed to ionise He from the \( 1s2s\ ^3S \) state is about 4.8 eV.
- The \( ^3S \) state can decay to the ground state by an electric-dipole transition, emitting about 19.8 eV.
- In the \( ^3S \) state the probability of finding both electrons at the same point is zero.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. Singlet − triplet \( = 2K = 20.62 - 19.82 = 0.80 \) eV, so \( K \approx 0.40 \) eV.
- Correct. Absolute energy of \( ^3S \): \( -79.0 + 19.82 = -59.18 \) eV. Ionisation to He⁺ (−54.4 eV) costs \( 59.18 - 54.4 = 4.78 \approx 4.8 \) eV. (For the singlet: about 4.0 eV.)
- Wrong. \( ^3S_1 \to {}^1S_0 \) changes \( S \) (forbidden, \( \Delta S = 0 \) is required) and is also \( S \to S \) with no parity change. The state is metastable.
- Correct. The triplet spatial function \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[a(1)b(2) - b(1)a(2)] \) vanishes at \( \mathbf{r}_1 = \mathbf{r}_2 \): the Fermi hole.
Practice Q6. Consider a three-electron Slater determinant \( \Psi = \lvert \chi_1 \chi_2 \chi_3 \rvert \) built from orthonormal spin-orbitals. Which statements are correct?
- \( \lvert \chi_2 \chi_1 \chi_3 \rvert = -\Psi \), and it describes the same physical state.
- \( \lvert \chi_1 \chi_1 \chi_3 \rvert = 0 \).
- The expansion contains 6 terms, and the normalisation factor is \( 1/6 \).
- \( \lvert 1s\alpha\ 1s\beta\ 2s\beta \rvert \) and \( \lvert 1s\alpha\ 1s\beta\ 2s\alpha \rvert \) are both acceptable ground-state functions for Li, differing only in \( M_S \).
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. Swapping two columns flips the sign; an overall phase of −1 does not change the state.
- Correct. Two equal columns: Pauli exclusion.
- Wrong. There are \( 3! = 6 \) terms, but the normalisation is \( 1/\sqrt{6} \): the six terms are mutually orthogonal and each has norm 1, so the sum has norm 6, and \( \Psi \) needs \( 1/\sqrt{6} \).
- Correct. They are the \( M_S = -\tfrac{1}{2} \) and \( +\tfrac{1}{2} \) components of the \( ^2S_{1/2} \) ground state.
Practice Q7. Which statements about nuclear spin statistics are correct? (Consider the ground electronic and vibrational states.)
- In ¹²C¹⁶O₂, rotational levels with odd \( J \) are absent.
- For D₂, the ratio of nuclear-spin weights of even-\( J \) to odd-\( J \) levels is 2 : 1.
- For ³⁵Cl₂ (\( I = \tfrac{3}{2} \)), the ratio of the two weights is 5 : 3.
- For ¹H₂, the lowest rotational level \( J = 0 \) belongs to ortho-hydrogen.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. ¹⁶O has \( I = 0 \) (boson); only the symmetric nuclear spin function exists, which allows only even \( J \).
- Correct. \( I = 1 \): \( (I+1)(2I+1) = 6 \) symmetric, \( I(2I+1) = 3 \) antisymmetric. Bosons pair symmetric spin with even \( J \): even : odd = 6 : 3 = 2 : 1.
- Correct. \( I = \tfrac{3}{2} \): symmetric \( (\tfrac{5}{2})(4) = 10 \), antisymmetric \( (\tfrac{3}{2})(4) = 6 \); ratio \( 10 : 6 = 5 : 3 \), which is \( (I+1)/I \).
- Wrong. \( J = 0 \) is even, which for H₂ is para (nuclear-spin singlet). That is why cooled hydrogen converts to para-H₂.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Exchange operator | \( \hat{P}_{12}^2 = 1 \); eigenvalues \( \pm 1 \); commutes with \( \hat{H} \) |
| Fermions | half-integer spin, antisymmetric \( \Psi \); odd number of fermion constituents |
| Bosons | integer spin, symmetric \( \Psi \); even number of fermion constituents |
| Pauli exclusion | no two electrons in the same spin-orbital; follows from antisymmetry |
| Slater determinant | \( (N!)^{-1/2}\det[\chi_j(i)] \); row swap −1, equal columns 0 |
| Two-electron spin | triplet \( \alpha\alpha \), \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\alpha\beta + \beta\alpha) \), \( \beta\beta \): symmetric; singlet \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\alpha\beta - \beta\alpha) \): antisymmetric |
| Pairing rule | singlet ↔ symmetric space; triplet ↔ antisymmetric space |
| He \( 1s2s \) energies | \( E_{1s} + E_{2s} + J \pm K \); singlet +, triplet −; gap \( 2K \) |
| He \( 1s2s \) data | \( ^3S \) 19.82 eV, \( ^1S \) 20.62 eV above ground; \( K \approx 0.40 \) eV |
| Fermi hole | antisymmetric space vanishes at \( \mathbf{r}_1 = \mathbf{r}_2 \) |
| Exchange pairs | \( n_\uparrow(n_\uparrow - 1)/2 + n_\downarrow(n_\downarrow - 1)/2 \) |
| Nuclear spin weights | sym : antisym \( = (I + 1) : I \) |
| H₂ / D₂ / CO₂ | odd : even 3 : 1 / even : odd 2 : 1 / even \( J \) only |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Term Symbols, Coupling Schemes and Atomic Spectra: counting microstates with the Pauli principle and turning them into \( ^{2S+1}L_J \) terms, Hund’s rules and spectra.
- Back to the energies: Many-Electron Atoms: Helium, the Orbital Approximation and SCF.
- The physics treatment, with the same postulate: Identical Particles and the Pauli Principle.
- Exchange energy in coordination chemistry, where it competes with ligand-field splitting: Magnetic Properties of Complexes.
- Atomic Structure and Spectroscopy: Quick Revision.