Biological Electron Transfer: Cytochromes, Iron–Sulfur and Blue Copper Proteins
CSIR NET chemistry: cytochromes, rubredoxin, ferredoxins, HiPIP, Rieske, blue copper and CuA sites, redox tuning, Marcus theory in proteins, respiratory chain.
- 16 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Electrons Across Two Nanometres of Protein
- Three Families of Electron Carriers
- Cytochromes
- Iron–Sulfur Proteins
- Copper Electron-Transfer Sites
- What Sets a Reduction Potential?
- Rates: Marcus Theory in Proteins
- The Respiratory Chain as a Metal Map
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Porphyrins and Oxygen Transport: heme types a, b, c and porphyrin spectra.
- Reaction Mechanisms: Substitution and Electron Transfer: outer-sphere electron transfer, reorganisation energy and the Marcus equation.
- Magnetic Properties of Complexes: antiferromagnetic coupling, needed for iron–sulfur cluster spin states.
- The metabolic context (NADH, ubiquinone, ATP synthase) is in Bioenergetics and Metabolism.
The Hook: Electrons Across Two Nanometres of Protein
Three Families of Electron Carriers
Biological electron-transfer (ET) sites share three traits: they are one-electron carriers (the metal changes by one oxidation state), they have no open coordination site (so no substrate chemistry happens there), and their structure changes little between the two redox states (low reorganisation energy).
| Family | Metal site | Redox change | Approx. potential range (V vs SHE, pH 7) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cytochromes | heme Fe, six-coordinate, low spin | Fe(III)/Fe(II) | about −0.3 to +0.4 |
| Iron–sulfur proteins | Fe with Cys thiolate and bridging S²⁻ | cluster-level change of one electron | about −0.7 to +0.4 |
| Blue copper (type 1) | Cu with 2 His, 1 Cys, 1 Met | Cu(II)/Cu(I) | about +0.2 to +0.7 |
Organic carriers (NAD(P)H, flavins, quinones) handle two-electron steps and connect to the metal chains.
Cytochromes
Cytochromes are heme proteins whose job is ET. They are named by heme type and by the position of the reduced α band (cytochrome c has its α band at 550 nm in the reduced form).
| Cytochrome | Heme | Axial ligands | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cytochrome c | c (covalently attached) | His + Met | shuttles electrons from complex III to complex IV |
| Cytochrome b₅ | b | His + His | ER electron transfer (fatty-acid desaturation, P450 support) |
| Cytochromes b of complex III | b | His + His | Q cycle |
| Cytochrome f (b₆f complex) | c | His + N-terminal amine | photosynthetic chain |
| Hemes a, a₃ | a | a: His + His; a₃: His + open site | cytochrome c oxidase |
Why low-spin six-coordinate heme is ideal. Both Fe(II) (\( t_{2g}^6 \)) and Fe(III) (\( t_{2g}^5 \)) are low spin. The electron goes into or out of the non-bonding \( t_{2g} \) set, so Fe–N bond lengths barely change. The hydrophobic, partly buried heme also keeps solvent reorganisation small. Heme a₃ is different: it has an open site because it is not a pure ET centre but the O₂-reducing site.
Axial ligand tunes the potential. A soft thioether (Met) stabilises Fe(II) and raises E°; that is one reason cytochrome c (His/Met) has a higher potential (about +0.25 V) than bis-His cytochrome b₅ (near 0 V). An anionic thiolate (as in P450) stabilises Fe(III) and lowers E°.
Iron–Sulfur Proteins
All iron–sulfur (Fe–S) sites use cysteine thiolate ligands; most also contain inorganic (acid-labile) sulfide that is released as H₂S on acidification. In these electron-transfer sites every iron is tetrahedral and high spin.
graph LR
A[Rubredoxin: 1 Fe, 4 Cys, no S2-] --> B[2Fe-2S: rhombus, plant ferredoxin, Rieske]
B --> C[3Fe-4S: cube missing one corner]
C --> D[4Fe-4S: cubane, bacterial ferredoxin and HiPIP]The sites
| Site | Composition | Redox couple used | Spin of paramagnetic state | Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rubredoxin | Fe(SCys)₄, no sulfide | Fe(III)/Fe(II) | Fe(III) S = 5/2; Fe(II) S = 2 | bacteria; potential near 0 V |
| [2Fe–2S] ferredoxin | Fe₂S₂(SCys)₄ | [2Fe–2S]²⁺/⁺ | reduced form S = 1/2 | plant (chloroplast) ferredoxin, about −0.4 V |
| Rieske | Fe₂S₂(SCys)₂(His)₂: one Fe has two His | [2Fe–2S]²⁺/⁺ | reduced S = 1/2 | cytochrome bc₁ and b₆f; positive E° (about +0.3 V) |
| [3Fe–4S] | Fe₃S₄(SCys)₃ | [3Fe–4S]⁺/⁰ | oxidised S = 1/2 | many bacterial ferredoxins, aconitase (inactive form) |
| [4Fe–4S] ferredoxin | Fe₄S₄(SCys)₄ cubane | [4Fe–4S]²⁺/⁺ | reduced S = 1/2 | bacterial ferredoxins, about −0.3 to −0.5 V |
| HiPIP | Fe₄S₄(SCys)₄ cubane | [4Fe–4S]³⁺/²⁺ | oxidised S = 1/2 | photosynthetic bacteria, about +0.1 to +0.4 V |
Counting iron oxidation states
Use the core charge with S²⁻ = −2 and share out the rest. Cys thiolates are counted outside the core.
| Core | Formal iron content | Average Fe | Ground spin |
|---|---|---|---|
| [2Fe–2S]²⁺ | 2 Fe(III) | +3 | S = 0 (coupled) |
| [2Fe–2S]⁺ | Fe(III) + Fe(II) | +2.5 (valence-trapped) | S = 1/2 |
| [4Fe–4S]³⁺ | 3 Fe(III) + 1 Fe(II) | +2.75 | S = 1/2 |
| [4Fe–4S]²⁺ | 2 Fe(III) + 2 Fe(II) | +2.5 | S = 0 |
| [4Fe–4S]⁺ | 1 Fe(III) + 3 Fe(II) | +2.25 | S = 1/2 (usually) |
The individual Fe spins (S = 5/2 for Fe(III), S = 2 for Fe(II)) couple antiferromagnetically through the sulfides, so the cluster has a small total spin. The S = 1/2 states give characteristic EPR signals with g values below 2 (the classic “g = 1.94” type signal of reduced ferredoxins). In [4Fe–4S]²⁺ the cube is best described as two delocalised mixed-valence pairs (Fe^2.5+–Fe^2.5+), and Mössbauer spectra show all four irons as nearly equivalent.
The three-state cubane: ferredoxin vs HiPIP
The same [4Fe–4S] cubane can use three oxidation levels: 3+, 2+ and 1+. A protein uses only one couple:
- Ferredoxin: 2+/1+, low potential.
- HiPIP (high-potential iron–sulfur protein): 3+/2+, high potential.
Both rest in the diamagnetic 2+ state. Which couple is used depends on the protein: HiPIP buries its cluster in a hydrophobic pocket with fewer N–H···S hydrogen bonds to the sulfurs, which destabilises the more negative (1+) state and makes the 3+ state reachable. Ferredoxin’s cluster is more exposed and more H-bonded, stabilising the negative charge of the 1+ state.
Fe–S clusters beyond electron transfer
Aconitase uses a [4Fe–4S] cluster with one iron not bound to cysteine as a Lewis acid to dehydrate citrate. Radical SAM enzymes use a [4Fe–4S]⁺ cluster to cleave S-adenosylmethionine. Nitrogenase builds its catalytic site on Fe–S chemistry (see Nitrogen Fixation).
Copper Electron-Transfer Sites
The three classical types
| Type | Site | Visible spectrum | EPR | Function, examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type 1 (blue) | 2 His + Cys + Met, distorted tetrahedral / trigonal | intense band near 600 nm, ε of a few thousand M⁻¹ cm⁻¹ (S(Cys) → Cu(II) LMCT) | small \( A_\parallel \) hyperfine | ET: plastocyanin, azurin, stellacyanin; also in laccase, ascorbate oxidase |
| Type 2 (normal) | N/O donors, tetragonal | weak d–d bands (ε ≈ 10²) | normal Cu(II): large \( A_\parallel \) | catalytic: Cu/Zn SOD, amine oxidase, part of multicopper oxidases |
| Type 3 (coupled pair) | two Cu, each 3 His | oxy form: intense bands from O₂²⁻ → Cu | EPR-silent (antiferromagnetic) | O₂ binding/activation: hemocyanin, tyrosinase, catechol oxidase |
Multicopper oxidases (laccase, ascorbate oxidase, ceruloplasmin) combine a type 1 site that receives electrons with a trinuclear cluster (one type 2 + one type 3 pair) that reduces O₂ to water.
Why blue copper is special: the entatic state
Cu(II) (\( d^9 \)) prefers tetragonal geometry; Cu(I) (\( d^{10} \)) prefers tetrahedral. A blue copper protein holds the metal in a compromise geometry, close to what Cu(I) wants, imposed by the folded protein. This “entatic” (strained) or rack-induced state has three consequences:
- Small reorganisation energy: the site changes little on reduction, so ET is fast.
- High reduction potential: a geometry that favours Cu(I), plus the soft Met donor, raises E° (plastocyanin about +0.37 V; aqueous Cu²⁺/Cu⁺ only +0.15 V).
- Unusual spectroscopy: the short Cu–S(Cys) bond gives intense S → Cu charge transfer (blue colour) and a highly covalent ground state with small Cu hyperfine coupling.
Cu_A: a mixed-valence dicopper ET site
In cytochrome c oxidase and nitrous oxide reductase, Cu_A is a pair of copper ions bridged by two cysteine thiolates. In its oxidised form it is Cu(1.5)–Cu(1.5): one unpaired electron delocalised over both coppers. Its EPR spectrum shows a seven-line hyperfine pattern (two equivalent Cu nuclei, I = 3/2 each, \( 2nI + 1 = 7 \)), the fingerprint of the delocalised site.
What Sets a Reduction Potential?
| Factor | Effect on E° |
|---|---|
| Soft, neutral donor (Met thioether) | stabilises the lower oxidation state → raises E° |
| Anionic donor (thiolate, phenolate) | stabilises the higher oxidation state → lowers E° |
| Low dielectric, buried site | disfavours charge build-up: pushes E° towards the less charged form |
| H-bonds to ligands (N–H···S) | stabilise extra negative charge → raise E° of reductions that add negative charge |
| Imposed geometry (entatic) | favouring the reduced geometry raises E° |
| Nearby charged residues, protons | electrostatics; proton-coupled sites shift with pH |
Rates: Marcus Theory in Proteins
For ET between two fixed centres separated by distance r (edge to edge),
$$\boxed{k_{ET} = k_0\, e^{-\beta (r - r_0)}\, \exp\!\left[-\frac{(\Delta G^\circ + \lambda)^2}{4\lambda k_B T}\right]}$$- Distance term: electronic coupling falls exponentially with distance. For protein media β is commonly quoted around 1.1–1.4 Å⁻¹, so the rate drops roughly tenfold for every 1.6–2 Å of extra distance. Gray’s experiments, which attached a ruthenium complex at surface histidines of proteins such as cytochrome c and azurin and measured ET at known distances, established this dependence.
- Driving force term: the Marcus parabola. The rate peaks when \( -\Delta G^\circ = \lambda \) and falls in the inverted region beyond.
- Reorganisation energy λ: small for cytochromes, Fe–S clusters and blue copper; the protein keeps water away and the metal site rigid.
Electrons tunnel through bonds and hydrogen bonds of the protein (pathway model), so what lies between the two centres matters as well as the distance.
The Respiratory Chain as a Metal Map
graph LR
N[NADH] --> I[Complex I: FMN, Fe-S chain]
S[Succinate] --> II[Complex II: FAD, Fe-S, heme b]
I --> Q[Ubiquinone pool]
II --> Q
Q --> III[Complex III: hemes b, Rieske 2Fe-2S, cyt c1]
III --> C[Cytochrome c]
C --> IV[Complex IV: CuA, heme a, heme a3-CuB]
IV --> O[O2 to 2 H2O]- Complex III runs the Q cycle: of the two electrons from ubiquinol, one goes through the Rieske centre and cytochrome c₁ to cytochrome c; the other recycles through the two b hemes.
- Complex IV (cytochrome c oxidase): electrons go cyt c → Cu_A → heme a → the heme a₃–Cu_B binuclear centre, where O₂ + 4e⁻ + 4H⁺ → 2H₂O without releasing superoxide or peroxide. A tyrosine cross-linked to a Cu_B histidine supplies an electron and proton during O–O cleavage. Cyanide, CO and azide inhibit by binding the a₃–Cu_B site.
Photosynthetic chains use the same parts: Rieske protein, cytochrome f, plastocyanin and ferredoxin (see Photosystems and Photosynthesis).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Rubredoxin: 1 Fe, 4 Cys, no sulfide | ferredoxin: Fe–S clusters with acid-labile sulfide | |
| [4Fe–4S] ferredoxin: 2+/1+, negative E° | HiPIP: 3+/2+, positive E° | |
| Plant-type [2Fe–2S] Fd: 4 Cys, about −0.4 V | Rieske [2Fe–2S]: 2 Cys + 2 His, about +0.3 V | |
| Type 1 Cu: intense blue, small \( A_\parallel \) | type 2 Cu: pale, normal \( A_\parallel \) | |
| Type 3 Cu: EPR-silent coupled pair, binds O₂ | Cu_A: mixed-valence pair, ET, 7-line EPR | |
| Cytochrome c: His/Met, ET only | cytochrome P450: Cys thiolate, open site, O₂ chemistry | |
| β (distance decay constant) | λ (reorganisation energy) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What are the four protein ligands of a type 1 copper site?
- Which oxidation levels of the [4Fe–4S] cluster does HiPIP use?
- Which two metal centres form the O₂-reducing site of cytochrome c oxidase?
Answers
- Two His, one Cys, one Met.
- 3+/2+.
- Heme a₃ and Cu_B.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which of the following is EPR-active (S = 1/2) in its usual paramagnetic state?
(a) oxidised HiPIP, [4Fe–4S]³⁺ (b) oxidised ferredoxin, [4Fe–4S]²⁺ (c) oxidised plant ferredoxin, [2Fe–2S]²⁺ (d) oxyhemocyanin
Answer: (a)
[4Fe–4S]³⁺ (3 Fe(III) + 1 Fe(II)) has S = 1/2. The 2+ states of both clusters are S = 0, and oxyhemocyanin is an EPR-silent coupled Cu(II) pair.
Practice Q2. The overall charge of the HiPIP active site in its oxidised form, written as [Fe₄S₄(SCys)₄]ⁿ, is:
(a) 2− (b) 1− (c) 0 (d) 3−
Answer: (b)
Core [Fe₄S₄]³⁺ plus four thiolates (4 × −1): 3 − 4 = −1. The reduced (resting) form is 2−; ferredoxin’s reduced form is 3−.
Practice Q3. Cytochrome c has E°′ = +0.25 V (practice value). At an applied potential of +0.31 V at 298 K, the ratio [Fe(III)]/[Fe(II)] is about:
(a) 0.1 (b) 1 (c) 10 (d) 100
Answer: (c)
Nernst for a one-electron couple: \( E = E^{\circ\prime} + 0.0592 \log([\text{ox}]/[\text{red}]) \). So log ratio = 0.06/0.0592 ≈ 1.01, ratio ≈ 10.
Practice Q4. Replacing the methionine ligand of a blue copper site with a ligand that binds Cu(II) more strongly (for example a harder, anionic donor) is expected to:
(a) raise E° and intensify the 600 nm band (b) lower E° (c) leave E° unchanged because Met is axial (d) convert the site to type 3
Answer: (b)
Met is a soft neutral donor that favours Cu(I); replacing it with a donor that stabilises Cu(II) lowers the reduction potential.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. In a protein, the ET rate between two centres follows \( k \propto e^{-\beta r} \) with β = 1.1 Å⁻¹ (practice value). If a mutation moves the acceptor from 10 Å to 15 Å from the donor (driving force and λ unchanged), by what factor does the rate change?
Answer
\( k_{15}/k_{10} = e^{-1.1 \times 5} = e^{-5.5} \approx 4.1 \times 10^{-3} \). The rate falls about 245-fold. Five ångströms of extra protein cost more than two orders of magnitude, which is why ET chains space their cofactors at roughly 10–14 Å.
Practice Q6. For a series of related ET reactions with λ = 0.80 eV (practice value), calculate the Marcus activation free energy for ΔG° = 0, −0.20, −0.80 and −1.20 eV. Which reaction is fastest, and what is unusual about the last one?
Answer
\( \Delta G^\ddagger = (\lambda + \Delta G^\circ)^2/4\lambda \), with 4λ = 3.2 eV:
- ΔG° = 0: 0.64/3.2 = 0.20 eV
- −0.20: 0.36/3.2 = 0.1125 eV
- −0.80: 0 → activationless, fastest
- −1.20: 0.16/3.2 = 0.050 eV
The last reaction is more exergonic than the activationless one but has a barrier again: it is in the Marcus inverted region. Its rate is lower than at −0.80 eV, though still faster than at −0.20 eV (barrier 0.050 vs 0.1125 eV).
Practice Q7. Plant ferredoxin (E°′ = −0.42 V) reduces NADP⁺ (E°′ = −0.32 V) through ferredoxin–NADP⁺ reductase. Calculate ΔG°′ for the transfer of the two electrons needed per NADP⁺, and say why a flavoprotein is needed between them.
Answer
ΔE°′ = −0.32 − (−0.42) = +0.10 V. \( \Delta G^{\circ\prime} = -nF\Delta E^{\circ\prime} = -2 \times 96{,}485 \times 0.10 \) J mol⁻¹ ≈ −19.3 kJ mol⁻¹.
Ferredoxin is a one-electron carrier; NADP⁺ accepts two electrons as a hydride. FAD in the reductase can accept electrons one at a time (via the semiquinone) and deliver them as a hydride, bridging the 1e⁻ and 2e⁻ worlds.
Practice Q8. A protein shows a strong absorption at 600 nm (ε ≈ 4500 M⁻¹ cm⁻¹), an EPR spectrum with a small copper hyperfine splitting, and E°′ = +0.36 V. After a mutation, the 600 nm band disappears, a weak band appears near 650 nm (ε ≈ 100 M⁻¹ cm⁻¹), the hyperfine splitting roughly doubles, and E°′ falls. Interpret.
Answer
The original protein is a type 1 (blue) copper site: intense S(Cys) → Cu(II) LMCT, small \( A_\parallel \) from a covalent Cu–S bond, high potential. The mutant has lost the cysteine ligand (or the strained geometry): the weak band is an ordinary Cu(II) d–d transition, the large hyperfine is typical of tetragonal type 2 copper, and the lower E° reflects a geometry that now favours Cu(II). The mutation has turned a type 1 site into a type 2 site.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| ET sites | one-electron, coordinatively saturated, low λ |
| Cytochrome c | heme c, His/Met, LS both states, about +0.25 V |
| Rubredoxin | Fe(SCys)₄, no S²⁻, Fe(III)/Fe(II) |
| [2Fe–2S] | plant Fd (4 Cys, about −0.4 V); Rieske (2 Cys + 2 His, about +0.3 V) |
| [4Fe–4S] | Fd 2+/1+ (negative); HiPIP 3+/2+ (positive); 2+ is S = 0 |
| Fe in Fe–S | tetrahedral, high spin, coupled antiferromagnetically |
| Type 1 Cu | 2 His + Cys + Met; 600 nm LMCT; small \( A_\parallel \); entatic; high E° |
| Type 2 / type 3 | normal Cu(II) / coupled EPR-silent pair |
| Cu_A | Cu(1.5)Cu(1.5), Cys-bridged, 7-line EPR |
| Marcus in proteins | \( k \propto e^{-\beta r} \exp[-(\Delta G^\circ + \lambda)^2/4\lambda k_BT] \); β ≈ 1.1–1.4 Å⁻¹ |
| Complex IV | cyt c → Cu_A → heme a → heme a₃/Cu_B → O₂ |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Metalloenzymes: metal sites with an open coordination site that do chemistry on substrates.
- Photosystems and Photosynthesis: the same ET parts driven by light.
- Back to the chapter overview or revise the Marcus equation for small molecules.