Nitrogen Fixation: Nitrogenase, FeMo-Cofactor and Dinitrogen Complexes
CSIR NET chemistry: nitrogenase Fe and MoFe proteins, P-cluster, FeMoco, Lowe–Thorneley cycle, acetylene assay, N₂ complexes, Chatt and Schrock cycles.
- 14 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Biological Electron Transfer: [4Fe–4S] clusters, their oxidation levels and spin states.
- Metalloenzymes: molybdenum enzymes (and why nitrogenase’s Mo is different).
- Electron Counting and Metal Carbonyls: σ-donation and π back-donation, which also explain how metals bind and weaken N₂.
- MO diagram of N₂ from Bonding in Homonuclear Molecules.
The Hook: Bread From Air, Two Ways
Why N₂ Is Inert
| Property | Value / reason |
|---|---|
| Bond | N≡N triple bond, about 945 kJ mol⁻¹: one of the strongest bonds in chemistry |
| Frontier orbitals | large HOMO–LUMO gap; HOMO (3σ_g) low in energy, LUMO (1π_g*) high: poor donor and poor acceptor |
| Polarity | non-polar, no dipole; very weak base (low proton affinity) |
| First step | breaking the first of the three bonds is the hardest: N₂ → N₂H₂ (diazene) is uphill, while the overall reaction to NH₃ is downhill |
| Comparison with CO | isoelectronic, but CO has a polarised HOMO on carbon and a lower LUMO, so CO binds metals far better |
So the barrier is kinetic: N₂ + 3H₂ → 2NH₃ is exothermic (ΔH° ≈ −92 kJ per 2 mol NH₃), but the first reduction steps are costly. Nitrogenase pays for them with ATP; Haber–Bosch pays with heat and pressure.
The Nitrogenase System
Found only in prokaryotes (diazotrophs): free-living (Azotobacter, Klebsiella, Clostridium), cyanobacteria (often in heterocysts), and symbionts such as Rhizobium in legume root nodules.
$$\boxed{\text{N}_2 + 8\,\text{H}^+ + 8\,e^- + 16\,\text{MgATP} \rightarrow 2\,\text{NH}_3 + \text{H}_2 + 16\,\text{MgADP} + 16\,\text{P}_i}$$At least one H₂ is evolved per N₂ even under ideal conditions; this obligatory H₂ is built into the mechanism. Per electron, two ATP are hydrolysed.
Two proteins
| Fe protein (dinitrogenase reductase) | MoFe protein (dinitrogenase) | |
|---|---|---|
| Subunits | homodimer (NifH) | α₂β₂ heterotetramer (NifD, NifK) |
| Metal clusters | one [4Fe–4S] cluster bridging the two subunits | two P-clusters [8Fe–7S] and two FeMo-cofactors |
| Nucleotide | binds two MgATP | none |
| Role | the only electron donor that works; ATP-dependent | binds and reduces substrates at FeMoco |
| O₂ sensitivity | destroyed in seconds in air | also sensitive, somewhat less |
Electron flow
graph LR
R[Fd or flavodoxin] --> FeP[Fe protein: 4Fe-4S]
FeP -->|MgATP hydrolysis, complex formation| P[P-cluster: 8Fe-7S]
P --> M[FeMoco: MoFe7S9C-homocitrate]
M --> S[N2 to 2 NH3 plus H2]- Reduced Fe protein with two MgATP bound associates with the MoFe protein.
- An electron moves from the P-cluster to FeMoco, and the P-cluster is then re-reduced by the Fe protein (the deficit-spending model).
- Two ATP are hydrolysed; Fe protein (now with ADP) dissociates. Dissociation of the complex (preceded by phosphate release) is the slow, rate-limiting part of the cycle.
- Repeat: eight such one-electron transfers are needed per N₂.
ATP hydrolysis does not supply reducing power directly. It drives conformational changes that gate electron transfer and make it one-way.
The metal clusters
P-cluster [8Fe–7S]: two [4Fe–4S] cubanes that share one corner sulfide (a μ₆-S), held by bridging and terminal cysteines. In its resting (P^N) state all eight irons are formally Fe(II). It relays electrons to FeMoco.
FeMo-cofactor (FeMoco): MoFe₇S₉C·(R)-homocitrate
- Two partial cubanes, [MoFe₃S₃] and [Fe₄S₃], joined by three μ₂-sulfides.
- At the centre, an interstitial carbide (C⁴⁻) bound to six irons, identified in 2011 (earlier described as a light atom “X”).
- Mo at one end is bound by a His of the α subunit and by homocitrate (through its hydroxyl and carboxylate O); one Fe at the other end is bound by a Cys.
- Mo is six-coordinate and coordinatively saturated, so substrates are thought to bind at the central Fe–S faces, not at Mo.
- FeMoco can be extracted from the protein intact (into N-methylformamide) and restores activity to cofactor-less MoFe protein.
Alternative nitrogenases
When molybdenum is scarce, some organisms (Azotobacter vinelandii among them) use vanadium nitrogenase (FeV-cofactor) or an iron-only nitrogenase (FeFe-cofactor). Both are less efficient at N₂ reduction and divert more electrons to H₂.
The Mechanism: Lowe–Thorneley States
The Lowe–Thorneley kinetic scheme labels the MoFe protein half by how many electrons (and protons) it has received: E₀ to E₈.
- E₁–E₃: electrons and protons accumulate on FeMoco, partly as metal hydrides bridging Fe atoms. These states can lose H₂ (the non-productive path).
- E₄ (“Janus” state, with two bridging hydrides): N₂ binds, coupled to reductive elimination of H₂. This explains the obligatory 1 H₂ per N₂: N₂ binding requires the release of two hydrides as H₂, which leaves the cluster two electrons more reduced in a form that reduces N₂.
- E₅–E₈: stepwise reduction of bound N₂H_x species to two NH₃, released in turn.
Evidence for the H₂ link: H₂ is a competitive inhibitor of N₂ reduction, and under D₂ with N₂ present, nitrogenase makes HD; neither happens without N₂.
Distal vs alternating pathways
| Pathway | Protonation order | Intermediates | First NH₃ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Distal | the far N is protonated first, three times | M–N=NH, M=N–NH₂, then M≡N + NH₃ | released early, leaving a nitride |
| Alternating | the two N atoms alternately | M–NH=NH, M–NH₂–NH₂ (hydrazine-like) | released late |
Model Mo/W complexes (Chatt and Schrock chemistry) follow the distal path. For nitrogenase, release of hydrazine when the enzyme is quenched with acid during turnover, and the fact that hydrazine is a substrate, are used to argue for an alternating path or a hybrid. Treat this as open.
Substrates, inhibitors and the acetylene assay
| Molecule | Behaviour |
|---|---|
| H⁺ | always reduced to H₂ (also the only reaction left when N₂ is absent) |
| C₂H₂ | reduced by 2e⁻ to ethylene (not ethane, for Mo nitrogenase) |
| N₂O, N₃⁻, HCN, other triple-bonded molecules | reduced |
| CO | inhibits all substrate reductions except H⁺ reduction |
| H₂ | competitive inhibitor of N₂ reduction only |
Acetylene reduction assay: incubate cells or nodules with acetylene and measure ethylene by gas chromatography. It is cheap and sensitive. Conversion to N₂ fixed: N₂ → 2NH₃ needs 6e⁻ (8e⁻ including the obligatory H₂), C₂H₂ → C₂H₄ needs 2e⁻. So the theoretical ratio is 3 C₂H₄ : 1 N₂ (or 4 : 1 when the obligatory H₂ is counted). Calibrate with ¹⁵N₂ where accuracy matters.
Protecting nitrogenase from oxygen
- Leghemoglobin in legume nodules: a plant haemoglobin with a very high O₂ affinity that keeps free O₂ very low while still supplying the bacteroids’ respiration. It gives nodules their pink colour.
- Heterocysts in filamentous cyanobacteria: specialised cells with no PSII (so no O₂ evolution) and thick walls that slow O₂ entry.
- Respiratory protection in Azotobacter: very high respiration rates consume O₂ at the membrane.
- Conformational protection: a protein (FeSII) binds the nitrogenase proteins into an inactive, O₂-tolerant complex under oxygen stress.
- Temporal separation: some cyanobacteria fix N₂ only at night.
Dinitrogen Complexes and Model Chemistry
Binding modes
| Mode | Picture | Effect on N≡N |
|---|---|---|
| Terminal end-on (η¹) | M–N≡N | modest weakening; ν(N–N) lowered from 2331 cm⁻¹ (free N₂, Raman) into roughly the 1900–2200 cm⁻¹ range |
| Bridging end-on (μ-η¹:η¹) | M–N≡N–M or M=N–N=M | from slight to strong weakening, depending on electron count |
| Side-on (η²) and side-on bridging (μ-η²:η²) | N₂ parallel to M–M | strong weakening possible, especially with early metals |
Bonding is like CO: σ donation from N₂ (weak) plus π back-donation into π* (the important part). Electron-rich, low-valent metals with good σ-donor co-ligands (phosphines) bind and activate N₂ best; the more back-donation, the lower ν(N–N).
First dinitrogen complex: [Ru(NH₃)₅(N₂)]²⁺, reported by Allen and Senoff in 1965, made from RuCl₃ and hydrazine. Its strong IR band in the N≡N stretching region (IR-active once N₂ is bound unsymmetrically) identified the ligand.
The Chatt cycle (distal mechanism)
Chatt’s group worked with low-valent Mo(0) and W(0) bis(dinitrogen) phosphine complexes, trans-[M(N₂)₂(PR₃)₄]. Protonation with acid released NH₃ and showed the stepwise distal sequence:
$$\text{M}{-}\text{N}{\equiv}\text{N} \rightarrow \text{M}{-}\text{N}{=}\text{NH}\ (\text{diazenido}) \rightarrow \text{M}{=}\text{N}{-}\text{NH}_2\ (\text{hydrazido(2-)}) \rightarrow \text{M}{\equiv}\text{N}\ (\text{nitrido}) + \text{NH}_3 \rightarrow \cdots \rightarrow \text{M} + \text{NH}_3$$The metal moves through a range of oxidation states (from 0 to high values at the nitride stage), storing the electrons needed.
Catalytic N₂ reduction at a single metal
In 2003 Yandulov and Schrock reported the first catalytic reduction of N₂ to NH₃ at a single molybdenum centre, using a bulky triamidoamine ligand on Mo, a lutidinium acid and decamethylchromocene as the electron source, at room temperature and one atmosphere. Only a few turnovers were obtained, but the intermediates along a distal (Chatt-type) path were isolated and characterised. Later systems based on Mo, Fe and other metals have improved turnover numbers.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Fe protein: one [4Fe–4S], binds MgATP | MoFe protein: P-clusters + FeMoco, binds substrate | |
| P-cluster [8Fe–7S]: electron relay | FeMoco [MoFe₇S₉C]: substrate site | |
| FeMoco Mo: no pterin, bound by His + homocitrate | Mo in xanthine oxidase etc.: pyranopterin cofactor | |
| Leghemoglobin: high O₂ affinity, keeps O₂ low | haemoglobin: cooperative O₂ delivery | |
| Distal: one N reduced fully first, nitride intermediate | alternating: N atoms protonated in turn, hydrazine-like | |
| N₂ (non-polar, weak σ donor) | CO (isoelectronic, strong σ donor, better π acceptor) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many MgATP are hydrolysed per N₂ reduced by nitrogenase?
- What light atom sits at the centre of FeMoco?
- What does acetylene become in the acetylene reduction assay?
Answers
- 16.
- Carbon (a carbide, C⁴⁻).
- Ethylene (C₂H₄).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The total number of iron atoms in one MoFe protein α₂β₂ tetramer (counting both P-clusters and both FeMo-cofactors) is:
(a) 15 (b) 16 (c) 30 (d) 34
Answer: (c)
Two FeMoco × 7 Fe = 14; two P-clusters × 8 Fe = 16; total 30. (Add the Fe protein’s 4 Fe and the full complex with one Fe protein on each half has 38.)
Practice Q2. Which molecule inhibits the reduction of N₂ and C₂H₂ by nitrogenase but not the reduction of protons?
(a) H₂ (b) CO (c) N₂O (d) O₂
Answer: (b)
CO blocks all substrate reductions except H⁺; electron flux continues to H₂. H₂ inhibits only N₂ reduction; O₂ destroys the proteins.
Practice Q3. For a series of terminal N₂ complexes, the lowest ν(N–N) is expected for:
(a) an electron-poor M(II) centre with π-acceptor co-ligands (b) an electron-rich M(0) centre with σ-donor phosphines (c) a cationic M(III) centre with halides (d) free N₂
Answer: (b)
More back-donation into N₂ π* weakens the N–N bond and lowers the stretching frequency. Electron-rich low-valent metals with σ-donor co-ligands give the most back-donation.
Practice Q4. The function of leghemoglobin in root nodules is to:
(a) reduce N₂ directly (b) store nitrogen (c) keep the free O₂ concentration low while delivering O₂ for respiration (d) provide electrons to the Fe protein
Answer: (c)
Its very high O₂ affinity buffers free O₂ at low levels, protecting nitrogenase, while still feeding the bacteroids’ terminal oxidases.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Root nodules produce 12 µmol C₂H₄ h⁻¹ in an acetylene reduction assay (practice data). Estimate the rate of N₂ fixation, (i) using the theoretical 3 : 1 ratio and (ii) allowing for the obligatory H₂. Why do the two differ?
Answer
C₂H₂ reduction takes 2e⁻ per molecule, so 12 µmol h⁻¹ of C₂H₄ means 24 µmol e⁻ h⁻¹.
(i) N₂ → 2NH₃ only: 6e⁻ per N₂, N₂ = 24/6 = 4.0 µmol h⁻¹.
(ii) With 1 H₂ per N₂: 8e⁻ per N₂, N₂ = 24/8 = 3.0 µmol h⁻¹.
Under acetylene, essentially all electrons go to C₂H₄ (acetylene suppresses H₂ evolution), whereas under N₂ a quarter of the electrons at minimum go to H₂. The 4 : 1 ratio is therefore the more realistic theoretical factor; real systems are calibrated with ¹⁵N₂.
Practice Q6. A nitrogenase preparation under N₂ produces 20 nmol NH₃ min⁻¹ and 15 nmol H₂ min⁻¹ (practice data). Calculate (i) the total electron flux, (ii) the fraction of electrons used to make NH₃, (iii) the H₂ evolved in excess of the obligatory amount, and (iv) the ATP consumption rate.
Answer
N₂ reduced = 20/2 = 10 nmol min⁻¹.
(i) Electrons to NH₃: 3 × 20 = 60; electrons to H₂: 2 × 15 = 30. Total = 90 nmol e⁻ min⁻¹.
(ii) 60/90 = 0.67 (two-thirds).
(iii) Obligatory H₂ = 1 per N₂ = 10 nmol min⁻¹; excess = 15 − 10 = 5 nmol H₂ min⁻¹.
(iv) 2 ATP per electron: 180 nmol ATP min⁻¹.
Note the ideal case (only obligatory H₂) would give 6/8 = 0.75 of electrons to NH₃.
Practice Q7. Consider the statements:
- In the resting state, the Fe protein’s [4Fe–4S] cluster bridges its two identical subunits.
- Mo in FeMoco is coordinated by homocitrate and a histidine residue.
- In the Lowe–Thorneley scheme, N₂ binds to the E₁ state.
- The first dinitrogen complex was a ruthenium(II) ammine complex.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) all four
Answer: (a)
- Correct. 2. Correct. 3. Wrong: N₂ binds at E₄, after four electrons and protons have accumulated, with H₂ released. 4. Correct: [Ru(NH₃)₅(N₂)]²⁺ (Allen and Senoff, 1965).
Practice Q8. Under 0.5 atm N₂ plus 0.5 atm D₂, a nitrogenase preparation produces NH₃, H₂ and HD. With D₂ but no N₂, no HD forms. With N₂ but no D₂, the ratio of H₂ to N₂ reduced is close to 1. Explain these observations with the E₄ model.
Answer
In E₄, two bridging hydrides on FeMoco are lost as H₂ when N₂ binds (reductive elimination), giving the E₄(N₂) state; this gives the minimum 1 H₂ per N₂. The step is reversible: D₂ can react with the N₂-bound state (N₂ held at the diazene level), displacing N₂ and putting two bridging deuterides back on the cofactor (an E₄ dideuteride). Each deuteride then combines with a proton and leaves as HD, as the cofactor relaxes back through E₂ to E₀. Without N₂ the E₄ hydride state never forms the N₂-bound intermediate that D₂ can react with, so no HD forms. The same reversibility explains why H₂ is a competitive inhibitor of N₂ reduction.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Why N₂ inert | ~945 kJ mol⁻¹ triple bond; big HOMO–LUMO gap; first steps uphill |
| Stoichiometry | N₂ + 8H⁺ + 8e⁻ + 16 MgATP → 2NH₃ + H₂ + 16 MgADP + 16 Pᵢ |
| Fe protein | homodimer, one [4Fe–4S], 2 MgATP |
| MoFe protein | α₂β₂, 2 P-clusters [8Fe–7S], 2 FeMoco [MoFe₇S₉C-homocitrate] |
| Electron path | Fd/flavodoxin → Fe protein → P-cluster → FeMoco; complex dissociation rate-limiting |
| Lowe–Thorneley | E₀–E₈; N₂ binds at E₄ with H₂ elimination |
| Inhibitors | CO (all but H⁺); H₂ (N₂ only, competitive); O₂ (destroys) |
| Assay | C₂H₂ → C₂H₄; 3 : 1 (4 : 1 with H₂) |
| O₂ protection | leghemoglobin, heterocysts, respiratory protection |
| Alternative | V-nitrogenase, Fe-only nitrogenase (more H₂) |
| N₂ complexes | [Ru(NH₃)₅N₂]²⁺ first (1965); end-on, bridging, side-on; ν(N–N) falls with back-donation |
| Models | Chatt cycle (distal, Mo/W phosphines); Schrock catalytic Mo (2003) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Metal Complexes in Medicine: how inorganic chemistry is used to treat and diagnose disease.
- Nodule biology and ammonia assimilation are covered in Respiration, Photorespiration and Nitrogen Metabolism.
- For π back-donation in carbonyls and other small-molecule ligands, see Electron Counting and Metal Carbonyls.
- Back to the chapter overview or the Chemical Sciences syllabus.