Boranes, Carboranes and Wade's Rules
CSIR NET chemistry: deltahedra, closo/nido/arachno/hypho cages, Wade's skeletal electron pair counting, carboranes, dicarbollide and metallaboranes.
- 19 min
On this page · 15 sections
Prerequisites
- s-Block and Group 13 Compounds: diborane, the borane formula classes and Lipscomb’s styx code. This page assumes them and goes further.
- Bonding in Heteronuclear Molecules: the three-centre two-electron (3c–2e) bond.
- Allotropy of Main Group Elements: the B₁₂ icosahedron of elemental boron.
- VSEPR Theory and Shapes: you will be using an electron count to predict a shape, just as VSEPR does, but for a whole cage.
The Hook: Two Electrons Open a Cage
Deltahedra: The Closed Shapes
A deltahedron is a polyhedron whose faces are all triangles (from the Greek letter Δ). The closo boranes [BₙHₙ]²⁻ (n = 6 to 12) and the cages built from them are based on the most spherical deltahedra:
| n | Closo deltahedron | Point group (ideal) | Vertex connectivities |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | tetrahedron | \( T_d \) | 4 × 3 |
| 5 | trigonal bipyramid | \( D_{3h} \) | 2 × 3 (apical), 3 × 4 (equatorial) |
| 6 | octahedron | \( O_h \) | 6 × 4 |
| 7 | pentagonal bipyramid | \( D_{5h} \) | 2 × 5 (apical), 5 × 4 |
| 8 | dodecahedron (bisdisphenoid) | \( D_{2d} \) | 4 × 4, 4 × 5 |
| 9 | tricapped trigonal prism | \( D_{3h} \) | 3 × 4 (caps), 6 × 5 |
| 10 | bicapped square antiprism | \( D_{4d} \) | 2 × 4 (caps), 8 × 5 |
| 11 | octadecahedron | \( C_{2v} \) | 1 × 6, 2 × 4, 8 × 5 |
| 12 | icosahedron | \( I_h \) | 12 × 5 |
Every closed deltahedron with n vertices has
$$\boxed{E = 3n - 6 \text{ edges}, \qquad F = 2n - 4 \text{ triangular faces}}$$which follows from Euler’s relation \( V - E + F = 2 \) together with \( 2E = 3F \). The icosahedron: 12 vertices, 30 edges, 20 faces. Use the formula to check connectivity lists: the connectivities must add up to \( 2E \) (for n = 11: 6 + 8 + 40 = 54 = 2 × 27).
Wade’s Rules
The four (plus one) cage types
Wade’s rules, also called the polyhedral skeletal electron pair theory (PSEPT), link the number of skeletal electron pairs (SEP) to the shape. For a cage with n vertex atoms:
| SEP | Type | Shape | Parent deltahedron | Borane formula |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| \( n - 1 \) | bicapped closo | closo (n − 2) deltahedron with two capped faces | — | — |
| \( n \) | capped closo | closo (n − 1) deltahedron with one capped face | — | — |
| \( n + 1 \) | closo | closed deltahedron, n vertices | itself | [BₙHₙ]²⁻ |
| \( n + 2 \) | nido | (n + 1)-vertex deltahedron, 1 vertex missing | n + 1 | BₙHₙ₊₄ |
| \( n + 3 \) | arachno | (n + 2)-vertex deltahedron, 2 vertices missing | n + 2 | BₙHₙ₊₆ |
| \( n + 4 \) | hypho | (n + 3)-vertex deltahedron, 3 vertices missing | n + 3 | BₙHₙ₊₈ |
The capped categories matter mostly for metal clusters (they are developed on the electron counting page). For boranes the core four are enough.
The formula classes are related by protonation. Write each neutral borane as a hypothetical anion plus protons:
- closo: [BₙHₙ]²⁻
- nido: BₙHₙ₊₄ = [BₙHₙ]⁴⁻ + 4H⁺
- arachno: BₙHₙ₊₆ = [BₙHₙ]⁶⁻ + 6H⁺
Each extra pair of electrons on the [BₙHₙ] skeleton opens one more vertex; the protons (as bridging H or extra terminal H) sit on the open face and do not change the electron count.
Counting skeletal electrons
Every vertex atom uses one orbital and two electrons for its exo bond (to a terminal H, an R group, or a lone pair pointing away from the cage). Whatever valence electrons remain go into the skeleton.
Main-group vertex E with exo ligand(s):
$$\boxed{\text{contribution} = v + x - 2}$$where v is the number of valence electrons of E and x the number of electrons supplied by the exo ligand (1 for H, R or a halogen σ bond; 0 for a bare atom carrying an exo lone pair).
Then add: 1 for each extra (bridging or second terminal) H, 1 for each negative charge, and subtract 1 for each positive charge. Divide by 2 for SEP.
| Vertex unit | Contribution (electrons) | Note |
|---|---|---|
| B–H, B–R, B–Cl | 2 | the reference unit |
| bare B (exo lone pair) | 1 | rare |
| C–H, C–R | 3 | isoelectronic with BH⁻ |
| bare C | 2 | |
| N–H | 4 | |
| bare N, P, As, Sb, Bi | 3 | |
| P–R | 4 | |
| bare S, Se, Te | 4 | |
| bare Si, Ge, Sn, Pb | 2 | isoelectronic with BH |
| Al–R, Ga–R | 2 |
Transition-metal vertex M(L)ₓ: the metal uses nine valence orbitals; three go to the skeleton and six are filled with exo electrons (12 electrons), so
$$\boxed{\text{contribution} = v + x - 12}$$with v the group number of the metal and x the electrons from its ligands (CO 2, PR₃ 2, η⁵-C₅H₅ 5, H 1). Fe(CO)₃: 8 + 6 − 12 = 2, the same as BH. CoCp: 9 + 5 − 12 = 2. Co(CO)₃: 9 + 6 − 12 = 3, the same as CH. Mn(CO)₃: 7 + 6 − 12 = 1. NiCp: 10 + 5 − 12 = 3.
A shortcut for neutral boranes
For BₙHₙ₊ₘ (no charge), SEP = (2n + m)/2 = n + m/2. So m = 4 gives nido, m = 6 arachno, m = 8 hypho. For anions add half the charge: \( [\text{B}_n\text{H}_{n+m}]^{z-} \) has SEP = n + (m + z)/2. [B₁₀H₁₀]²⁻: m = 0, z = 2 → n + 1, closo.
Which vertex goes missing?
| Cage | Rule | Example |
|---|---|---|
| nido | remove the most highly connected vertex of the parent | B₆H₁₀: apical vertex of the pentagonal bipyramid; B₁₀H₁₄: the unique 6-connected vertex of the 11-vertex octadecahedron |
| arachno | remove a second, adjacent vertex of high connectivity | B₄H₁₀: two adjacent (cis) vertices of the octahedron → butterfly |
Removing a highly connected vertex leaves the largest open face, where the extra hydrogens sit. B₁₀H₁₄ ends up as an open “boat” or basket, usually drawn as an icosahedron missing two adjacent vertices.
| Borane | Count | SEP | Type | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [B₆H₆]²⁻ | 12 + 2 | 7 | closo | octahedron |
| [B₁₀H₁₀]²⁻ | 20 + 2 | 11 | closo | bicapped square antiprism |
| [B₁₂H₁₂]²⁻ | 24 + 2 | 13 | closo | icosahedron |
| B₅H₉ | 10 + 4 | 7 | nido | square pyramid |
| B₆H₁₀ | 12 + 4 | 8 | nido | pentagonal pyramid |
| B₁₀H₁₄ | 20 + 4 | 12 | nido | 11-vertex parent minus one vertex |
| B₄H₁₀ | 8 + 6 | 7 | arachno | butterfly |
| B₅H₁₁ | 10 + 6 | 8 | arachno | pentagonal bipyramid minus two vertices |
Why n + 1 Pairs? The Orbital Picture
Each B–H vertex has four valence orbitals. One sp hybrid points outward and forms the exo B–H bond. That leaves three for the cage:
- one radial orbital (an sp hybrid pointing to the cage centre), and
- two tangential p orbitals (lying along the surface of the sphere).
A closo cage of n vertices therefore has 3n skeletal atomic orbitals. Symmetry-adapted combinations give exactly n + 1 bonding molecular orbitals:
- one strongly bonding combination of all n radial orbitals pointing in phase into the centre (totally symmetric), and
- n bonding combinations of the 2n tangential orbitals.
For [B₆H₆]²⁻ (\( O_h \)) the seven bonding skeletal MOs are \( a_{1g} \) (radial) + \( t_{1u} \) + \( t_{2g} \) (tangential). Twelve BH electrons fill only six of them; the two extra electrons of the 2− charge fill the seventh. That is why the closo boranes are dianions, and why the neutral BₙHₙ molecules are not the stable species.
When the cage opens (nido), the orbitals that pointed at the missing vertex become non-bonding orbitals on the open face; one more electron pair fills them, and protons attach there as B–H–B bridges or BH₂ groups. Each step closo → nido → arachno adds one pair.
Wade’s Rules Beyond Boron
The same count works for any cage whose vertices behave like BH units. Two families matter most for the exam.
Electron-precise cages fit too
P₄: each bare P gives 5 − 2 = 3. Total 12 electrons = 6 pairs = n + 2 → nido, parent a trigonal bipyramid. Removing an apical (3-connected) vertex of the trigonal bipyramid leaves a tetrahedron, which is the observed shape; removing an equatorial (4-connected) vertex would give a butterfly. So P₄ is a case where the “remove the most-connected vertex” rule picks the wrong vertex. Small cages are where that rule is least reliable, and P₄ is better described simply as electron-precise: 6 edges, 6 pairs, one 2c–2e bond per edge. The same is true of tetrahedrane C₄R₄ (each CR gives 3).
When the skeletal electron pairs equal the number of edges, ordinary localised bonds describe the cage. When there are fewer pairs than edges, the bonding is delocalised and Wade’s rules are the right tool. More on electron-precise cages (P₄S₃, cubane, the Zintl ion Si₄⁴⁻) is on the main-group cages page.
Zintl ions
Bare group 14 atoms contribute 2 (like BH), group 15 atoms 3 (like CH):
| Ion | Count | SEP | Type | Observed shape |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Sn₅]²⁻, [Pb₅]²⁻ | 10 + 2 | 6 = n + 1 | closo | trigonal bipyramid |
| [Ge₉]⁴⁻, [Sn₉]⁴⁻ | 18 + 4 | 11 = n + 2 | nido | monocapped square antiprism |
| [Bi₅]³⁺ | 15 − 3 | 6 = n + 1 | closo | trigonal bipyramid |
These are worked out fully, with polycations, on the next page.
Carboranes
Isoelectronic replacement
A C–H unit gives 3 skeletal electrons, one more than B–H, so replacing BH by CH is the same as replacing BH⁻ by a neutral unit. Each carbon removes one negative charge:
$$[\text{B}_{12}\text{H}_{12}]^{2-} \rightarrow [\text{CB}_{11}\text{H}_{12}]^{-} \rightarrow \text{C}_2\text{B}_{10}\text{H}_{12}$$All three are closo icosahedra with 13 skeletal pairs.
| Carborane | Count | SEP | Type | Shape and isomers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C₂B₃H₅ | 3 × 2 + 2 × 3 = 12 | 6 = n + 1 | closo | trigonal bipyramid; the 1,5-isomer has both C apical |
| C₂B₄H₆ | 4 × 2 + 2 × 3 = 14 | 7 = n + 1 | closo | octahedron; 1,2- (cis) and 1,6- (trans) isomers |
| C₂B₁₀H₁₂ | 10 × 2 + 2 × 3 = 26 | 13 = n + 1 | closo | icosahedron; 1,2- (ortho), 1,7- (meta), 1,12- (para) |
| [CB₁₁H₁₂]⁻ | 11 × 2 + 3 + 1 = 26 | 13 | closo | icosahedron |
| [C₂B₉H₁₁]²⁻ | 9 × 2 + 2 × 3 + 2 = 26 | 13 = n + 2 | nido | icosahedron minus one vertex (dicarbollide) |
Where the carbons go
- Carbon prefers vertices of low connectivity (in C₂B₃H₅, the 3-connected apical sites).
- In the thermodynamically stable isomers the carbons are as far apart as possible. On heating, 1,2-C₂B₁₀H₁₂ rearranges to the 1,7-isomer and, at still higher temperature, to the 1,12-isomer. Each step is an isomerisation within the closed icosahedron; no atoms are lost.
- The C–H hydrogens of the icosahedral carboranes are weakly acidic and can be removed by organolithium bases, which is how carboranes are functionalised at carbon.
Making and opening the icosahedron
Synthesis of 1,2-C₂B₁₀H₁₂ (ortho-carborane): decaborane is first converted to a Lewis-base adduct, which then adds an alkyne:
$$\text{B}_{10}\text{H}_{14} + 2\text{L} \rightarrow \text{B}_{10}\text{H}_{12}\text{L}_2 + \text{H}_2 \qquad (\text{L} = \text{SEt}_2, \text{MeCN})$$$$\text{B}_{10}\text{H}_{12}\text{L}_2 + \text{RC}{\equiv}\text{CR} \rightarrow \text{R}_2\text{C}_2\text{B}_{10}\text{H}_{10} + 2\text{L} + \text{H}_2$$The two alkyne carbons become adjacent vertices, which is why the alkyne route gives the 1,2-isomer.
Degradation to the nido cage: strong base in alcohol (alkoxide) removes one boron vertex, the one adjacent to both carbons, from 1,2-C₂B₁₀H₁₂:
$$1{,}2\text{-C}_2\text{B}_{10}\text{H}_{12} \xrightarrow{\text{RO}^-/\text{ROH}} [7{,}8\text{-C}_2\text{B}_9\text{H}_{12}]^- \xrightarrow{\text{NaH}} [\text{C}_2\text{B}_9\text{H}_{11}]^{2-}$$The dianion is dicarbollide. Its open C₂B₃ pentagonal face carries six electrons in orbitals pointing to the empty vertex, just like the π system of the cyclopentadienide ion C₅H₅⁻.
Metallaboranes and Metallacarboranes
Because a metal fragment with the right count behaves like a BH or CH vertex, metals can occupy cage positions.
Sandwich compounds with two dicarbollide ligands are known: [Fe(C₂B₉H₁₁)₂]²⁻ is the dicarbollide counterpart of ferrocene, and the cobalt analogue [Co(C₂B₉H₁₁)₂]⁻ (“cobalt bis(dicarbollide)”) is a robust anion. Here the metal is shared by two icosahedra.
Metallaboranes also form by replacing a BH vertex in a borane by an isolobal metal fragment. Replacing one BH of B₅H₉ by Fe(CO)₃ (both contribute 2 electrons) gives a formula Fe(CO)₃B₄H₈ with the same count (2 + 8 + 4 = 14 electrons, 7 pairs, n = 5): a nido square pyramid. The link between BH and Fe(CO)₃ is the isolobal analogy, developed on the metal clusters page.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| n = number of occupied vertices | parent deltahedron size: n + 1 (nido), n + 2 (arachno) | |
| closo [BₙHₙ]²⁻: dianion | nido BₙHₙ₊₄: neutral, extra H on open face | |
| CH (3 electrons) | BH (2 electrons); CH = BH⁻ | |
| TM fragment: v + x − 12 | main-group vertex: v + x − 2 | |
| 1,2-C₂B₁₀H₁₂ (ortho, from alkyne) | 1,12-C₂B₁₀H₁₂ (para, most stable, from heating) | |
| [C₂B₉H₁₁]²⁻ dicarbollide (nido, 13 pairs, n = 11) | CpCo(C₂B₉H₁₁) (closo, 13 pairs, n = 12) | |
| styx code: localised 2c and 3c bond bookkeeping | Wade’s rules: delocalised count that predicts the shape |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many skeletal electron pairs does a closo cage with 9 vertices have?
- How many electrons does a Co(CO)₃ fragment contribute to a cage skeleton?
- Classify B₈H₁₂ as closo, nido or arachno.
Answers
- n + 1 = 10 pairs.
- 9 + 6 − 12 = 3 electrons (it is isolobal with CH).
- B₈H₁₂ = BₙHₙ₊₄ with n = 8: SEP = 8 + 4/2 = 10 = n + 2, nido.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The parent deltahedron of the borane B₆H₁₀ is a:
(a) octahedron (b) pentagonal bipyramid (c) dodecahedron (d) trigonal prism
Answer: (b)
6 × 2 + 4 = 16 electrons, 8 pairs = n + 2: nido. The parent has n + 1 = 7 vertices, a pentagonal bipyramid. B₆H₁₀ itself is a pentagonal pyramid. Option (a) is the trap of using n instead of n + 1; a trigonal prism is not a deltahedron.
Practice Q2. Which species is not a closo cage?
(a) [B₁₂H₁₂]²⁻ (b) C₂B₄H₆ (c) [CB₁₁H₁₂]⁻ (d) C₂B₈H₁₂
Answer: (d)
(a) 26/2 = 13 = n + 1. (b) 8 + 6 = 14 → 7 = n + 1. (c) 22 + 3 + 1 = 26 → 13 = n + 1. (d) C₂B₈H₁₂: 8 BH = 16, 2 CH = 6, extra H = 12 − 10 = 2. Total 24 → 12 pairs, n = 10: 12 = n + 2, nido.
Practice Q3. In a cage compound, a BH vertex can be replaced without changing the skeletal electron count by:
(a) Co(CO)₃ (b) Mn(CO)₃ (c) Fe(CO)₃ (d) Ni(η⁵-C₅H₅)
Answer: (c)
v + x − 12: Fe(CO)₃ = 8 + 6 − 12 = 2, same as BH. Co(CO)₃ = 3 and NiCp = 3 (like CH); Mn(CO)₃ = 1.
Practice Q4. Heating 1,2-C₂B₁₀H₁₂ eventually gives:
(a) the nido anion [C₂B₉H₁₂]⁻ (b) 1,7- and then 1,12-C₂B₁₀H₁₂ (c) B₁₀H₁₄ and acetylene (d) [B₁₂H₁₂]²⁻
Answer: (b)
Thermal rearrangement within the icosahedron moves the carbons apart: ortho → meta → para. The nido anion (a) needs a base (alkoxide), not heat.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. For the anion [B₉H₁₄]⁻, consider the statements:
- It has 12 skeletal electron pairs.
- It is an arachno cage.
- Its parent deltahedron has 11 vertices.
- It is isoelectronic (in skeletal electrons) with B₉H₁₅.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1 and 4 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2, 3 and 4
9 BH × 2 = 18; extra H = 14 − 9 = 5; charge 1. Total 18 + 5 + 1 = 24 → 12 pairs (statement 1). n = 9, 12 = n + 3: arachno (2). Parent n + 2 = 11 vertices (3). B₉H₁₅: 18 + 6 = 24, also 12 pairs (4). [B₉H₁₄]⁻ is the conjugate base of B₉H₁₅: losing H⁺ removes one H atom but adds one negative charge, so the count is unchanged. All four are correct.
Practice Q6. A cobalt cage compound has the formula (η⁵-C₅H₅)Co(C₂B₉H₁₁). A student treats CpCo as a cage vertex. Which combination is correct?
| SEP | n | Type | |
|---|---|---|---|
| (a) | 13 | 12 | closo |
| (b) | 12 | 12 | capped |
| (c) | 13 | 11 | nido |
| (d) | 14 | 12 | nido |
Answer: (a)
CoCp: 9 + 5 − 12 = 2. Two CH: 6. Nine BH: 18. Total 26 electrons = 13 pairs. Vertices: 1 Co + 2 C + 9 B = 12. 13 = n + 1: closo icosahedron. Option (c) is the count for the free dicarbollide ligand before the metal fills the empty vertex.
Practice Q7. The closo-dicarbahexaborane C₂B₄H₆ is an octahedron with two carbon vertices. How many positional isomers are possible, and which is expected to be thermodynamically favoured?
(a) 3; 1,2 (b) 2; 1,6 (c) 2; 1,2 (d) 3; 1,6
Answer: (b) 2; 1,6
All six vertices of an octahedron are equivalent, so two carbons can be either adjacent (cis, 1,2) or opposite (trans, 1,6). Only two positional isomers exist. Carbons prefer to be as far apart as possible, so the 1,6- (trans) isomer is favoured. “Three” would be right for a trigonal bipyramid (1,5; 1,2; 2,3), where the vertices are not all equivalent.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Deltahedron | all faces triangles; E = 3n − 6, F = 2n − 4 |
| Closo shapes | 5 TBP, 6 octahedron, 7 pentagonal bipyramid, 8 dodecahedron, 9 tricapped trigonal prism, 10 bicapped square antiprism, 11 octadecahedron, 12 icosahedron |
| SEP → type | n + 1 closo, n + 2 nido, n + 3 arachno, n + 4 hypho; n capped, n − 1 bicapped |
| Main-group vertex | v + x − 2: BH 2, CH 3, bare Sn 2, bare P/Bi 3, bare S 4 |
| Metal vertex | v + x − 12: Fe(CO)₃ 2, CoCp 2, Co(CO)₃ 3, NiCp 3, Mn(CO)₃ 1 |
| Extra terms | +1 per extra H, +1 per negative charge, −1 per positive charge |
| Neutral BₙHₙ₊ₘ | SEP = n + m/2 |
| Missing vertex | nido: most connected; arachno: second, adjacent |
| Orbital reason | 1 radial + n tangential bonding MOs = n + 1; [B₆H₆]²⁻: a₁g + t₁u + t₂g |
| Key boranes | B₅H₉ square pyramid, B₆H₁₀ pentagonal pyramid, B₄H₁₀ butterfly, B₁₀H₁₄ nido basket |
| Carboranes | C₂B₃H₅ (1,5), C₂B₄H₆ (1,2 and 1,6), C₂B₁₀H₁₂ (1,2 → 1,7 → 1,12 on heating) |
| Synthesis | B₁₀H₁₂L₂ + alkyne → 1,2-C₂B₁₀H₁₂ |
| Dicarbollide | alkoxide removes B → [C₂B₉H₁₂]⁻; NaH → [C₂B₉H₁₁]²⁻, Cp⁻ analogue |
| Metallacarboranes | CpCo(C₂B₉H₁₁) closo; [Fe(C₂B₉H₁₁)₂]²⁻ ferrocene analogue |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Main-Group Cages: Zintl Ions, Electron-Precise and Oxide Cages: the same counting for bare-atom cages, and cages held by ordinary bonds.
- Metal Carbonyl Clusters and Electron Counting: Wade–Mingos rules, the 18-electron count and the isolobal analogy.
- Revise styx codes and diborane in s-Block and Group 13 Compounds.
- Chapter overview: Cages and Metal Clusters.