Hückel Theory Applications: Charges, Bond Orders, Free Valence and Heteroatoms
CSIR NET physical chemistry: Hückel π charges, Coulson bond orders, free valence, pairing theorem, NBMO coefficients, heteroatoms and limits.
- 16 min
On this page · 16 sections
Prerequisites
- Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems: energies and coefficients of ethylene, allyl, butadiene and benzene (used throughout this page).
- LCAO-MO Theory: H₂⁺, Secular Equations and Heteronuclear Bonds: the two-orbital polar bond, which is the heteroatom problem in miniature.
- Valence Bond Theory: Heitler–London, Hybridisation and MO vs VB: resonance structures, which Hückel charges and bond orders should agree with.
The Hook: Where Does the Benzyl Radical React?
π-Electron Density and Charge
If MO \( \psi_j = \sum_r c_{rj}\phi_r \) holds \( n_j \) electrons (0, 1 or 2), and overlap is neglected, the π-electron density on atom r is
\( Z_r \) is the number of π electrons atom r contributes to the neutral π system (1 for a carbon in a hydrocarbon). Summed over all atoms, \( \sum_r q_r \) equals the total number of π electrons.
Allyl, from the coefficients (\( \psi_1 = \tfrac12, \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}, \tfrac12 \); \( \psi_2 = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}, 0, -\tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} \)):
| Species | \( q_1 = q_3 \) | \( q_2 \) | Net charge on C1, C3 | Net charge on C2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cation (\( \psi_1^2 \)) | \( 2 \times \tfrac14 = 0.5 \) | \( 2 \times \tfrac12 = 1 \) | +0.5 | 0 |
| Radical (\( \psi_1^2\psi_2^1 \)) | \( 0.5 + 0.5 = 1 \) | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Anion (\( \psi_1^2\psi_2^2 \)) | \( 0.5 + 1 = 1.5 \) | 1 | −0.5 | 0 |
The charge of the cation and anion lives entirely on the terminal carbons, which is just what the two resonance structures predict.
π Bond Order (Coulson)
Total bond order \( = 1 + p_{rs} \) (one σ bond plus the π part).
| Molecule | Bond | \( p_{rs} \) | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ethylene | C1–C2 | \( 2 \times \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} \times \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} = 1 \) | full π bond |
| Allyl (all charges) | C1–C2 | \( 2 \times \tfrac12 \times \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} = 0.707 \) | \( \psi_2 \) has \( c_2 = 0 \), so adds nothing |
| Butadiene | C1–C2 | \( 2(0.372 \times 0.602 + 0.602 \times 0.372) = 0.894 \) | mostly double |
| Butadiene | C2–C3 | \( 2(0.602 \times 0.602 - 0.372 \times 0.372) = 0.447 \) | partial double |
| Benzene | any | \( 2/3 = 0.667 \) | all equal |
| Naphthalene | C1–C2 | 0.725 | shortest bond |
| Naphthalene | C2–C3 | 0.603 |
A higher π bond order means a shorter bond. Butadiene’s central bond, with \( p = 0.447 \), is shorter than a typical C–C single bond; naphthalene’s C1–C2 bond is its shortest, as X-ray structures show.
A useful identity
With overlap neglected, the total π energy can be rebuilt from charges and bond orders:
$$E_\pi = \sum_r q_r\,\alpha + 2\sum_{\text{bonds } r\text{–}s} p_{rs}\,\beta$$Butadiene: \( 4\alpha + 2\beta(0.894 + 0.447 + 0.894) = 4\alpha + 4.472\beta \). Matches the orbital sum. Use it as a check on any bond-order calculation.
Free Valence
How much π bonding capacity does an atom have left over? Coulson defined
\( \sqrt3 \) is the π bond-order sum of the central carbon of trimethylenemethane, C(CH₂)₃, taken as the largest a carbon atom can have. Larger \( F_r \) means more reactive toward radicals.
| Molecule | Atom | \( N_r \) | \( F_r \) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ethylene | C1 | 1 | 0.732 |
| Allyl | C1 (terminal) | 0.707 | 1.025 |
| Allyl | C2 (central) | 1.414 | 0.318 |
| Butadiene | C1 | 0.894 | 0.838 |
| Butadiene | C2 | 1.341 | 0.391 |
| Benzene | any | 1.333 | 0.399 |
| Naphthalene | C1 (α) | 1.279 | 0.453 |
| Naphthalene | C2 (β) | 1.328 | 0.404 |
Radicals add to the ends of butadiene (1,4-addition chemistry starts at C1), and naphthalene’s α position has the larger free valence, in line with its preferred site of attack. (Some books use \( N_{\max} = 4.732 \), adding the three σ bonds; the differences between atoms are unchanged.)
Alternant Hydrocarbons
Star alternate carbon atoms. If no two starred atoms are bonded and no two unstarred atoms are bonded, the hydrocarbon is alternant. All linear polyenes, all even-membered monocyclic rings and all benzenoid hydrocarbons (benzene, naphthalene, anthracene) are alternant; any odd-membered ring breaks the pattern (fulvene, azulene, cyclopentadienyl are non-alternant).
- Energies pair up: for every level \( \alpha + m\beta \) there is one at \( \alpha - m\beta \). Levels are symmetric about \( \alpha \).
- Coefficients pair up: the paired orbital has the same coefficient magnitudes, with the sign reversed on one set (starred or unstarred) of atoms.
- Uniform charge: in a neutral alternant hydrocarbon, every carbon has \( q_r = 1 \). There is no π charge separation, and so no π contribution to a dipole moment.
- Odd alternants (odd number of carbons, e.g. allyl, benzyl, pentadienyl) have at least one non-bonding MO (NBMO) at exactly \( \alpha \).
Non-alternants have no such guarantee. Azulene, a non-alternant isomer of naphthalene, has unequal π charges between its five- and seven-membered rings and a noticeable dipole moment, while naphthalene has none.
NBMO coefficients without a determinant
For an odd alternant, choose the larger set as starred. Then (Longuet-Higgins):
- The NBMO coefficient is zero on every unstarred atom.
- Around each unstarred atom, the NBMO coefficients of its starred neighbours sum to zero.
- Normalise.
Heteroatoms
Nitrogen and oxygen are more electronegative than carbon, so their Coulomb integrals are lower, and C–X bonds differ from C–C. The standard modification:
\( h_X > 0 \) for atoms more electronegative than carbon (remember \( \beta < 0 \), so \( \alpha_X \) lies below \( \alpha \)). The values of \( h \) and \( k \) are empirical; different books use different sets, so a CSIR NET question will state the values it wants.
Two kinds of heteroatom differ by how many π electrons they give:
- Pyridine-type N (one π electron; its lone pair is in the σ plane): smaller \( h \).
- Pyrrole-type N (two π electrons; its lone pair is part of the π system): larger \( h \), because the atom is formally positive in the delocalised structure.
Hückel MOs and Reactivity
- Ionisation energy and electron affinity. Within the model, the HOMO energy tracks ionisation energy and the LUMO energy tracks electron affinity across a series of related hydrocarbons; reduction potentials of aromatic hydrocarbons correlate with LUMO energies.
- Frontier orbitals. Electrophiles attack where the HOMO coefficient is largest; nucleophiles where the LUMO coefficient is largest.
- Pericyclic reactions. The phases of Hückel MOs are the input to the Woodward–Hoffmann rules. In butadiene’s HOMO (\( \psi_2 \): 0.602, 0.372, −0.372, −0.602) the terminal coefficients have opposite signs, so thermal ring closure to cyclobutene must be conrotatory; photochemically, the HOMO is \( \psi_3 \) (terminal coefficients of the same sign) and closure is disrotatory.
Where Simple Hückel Fails
| Assumption | Consequence | Better method |
|---|---|---|
| Overlap \( S = 0 \) | levels symmetric about \( \alpha \); antibonding levels too low | include \( S \) (levels \( (\alpha + m\beta)/(1 + mS) \)) |
| All \( \beta \) equal | no bond alternation; polyene gap goes to zero for long chains | variable-β methods |
| No electron–electron repulsion | singlet and triplet of the same configuration have the same energy; ion energies poor | Pariser–Parr–Pople (PPP) |
| σ–π separation, π only | cannot treat σ bonds or non-planar molecules | extended Hückel (all valence orbitals, overlap included) |
| Parameters \( \alpha \), \( \beta \) empirical | numbers depend on the property fitted | ab initio and density functional methods |
The model’s lasting value is qualitative and topological: node counts, degeneracies, aromaticity, signs of coefficients, and trends within a series.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| π-electron density \( q_r \) (number of π electrons on r) | net charge \( \zeta_r = 1 - q_r \) for a carbon | |
| π bond order \( p_{rs} \) (0 to 1) | total bond order \( 1 + p_{rs} \) | |
| Free valence (unused π bonding capacity, radical attack) | charge density (electrophilic or nucleophilic attack) | |
| Alternant (naphthalene): uniform charge, no π dipole | non-alternant (azulene): unequal charges, dipole | |
| Pyridine N: 1 π electron | pyrrole N: 2 π electrons |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the π bond order of the C2–C3 bond in butadiene?
- What is the net π charge on C1 of the allyl anion?
- What is the π-electron density on every carbon of neutral naphthalene in simple Hückel theory?
Answers
- 0.447 (total bond order 1.447).
- −0.5: \( q_1 = 2(\tfrac12)^2 + 2(\tfrac{1}{\sqrt2})^2 = 1.5 \).
- 1 on every carbon: naphthalene is an even alternant hydrocarbon.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The π bond order of a C–C bond in benzene, in simple Hückel theory, is:
(a) 0.500 (b) 0.667 (c) 1.000 (d) 1.667
Answer: (b)
Occupied MOs: \( \psi_1 = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt6}(1,1,1,1,1,1) \) and the degenerate pair at \( \alpha + \beta \). \( \psi_1 \) contributes \( 2 \times \tfrac16 = \tfrac13 \) to every bond and the degenerate pair together another \( \tfrac13 \): \( p = 2/3 \). (d) is the total bond order.
Practice Q2. The free valence of the terminal carbon of butadiene (with \( N_{\max} = \sqrt3 \)) is:
(a) 0.391 (b) 0.732 (c) 0.838 (d) 1.025
Answer: (c)
C1 has one neighbour: \( N_1 = p_{12} = 0.894 \); \( F_1 = 1.732 - 0.894 = 0.838 \). (a) is C2, (b) ethylene, (d) the allyl terminal carbon.
Practice Q3. Which hydrocarbon is non-alternant?
(a) naphthalene (b) 1,3,5-hexatriene (c) azulene (d) benzyl radical
Answer: (c)
Azulene contains a five- and a seven-membered ring: starring alternate atoms inevitably puts two starred atoms next to each other. The other three can be starred alternately.
Practice Q4. In the benzyl cation, simple Hückel theory places the positive charge:
(a) only on CH₂ (b) 4/7 on CH₂ and 1/7 on each ortho and para carbon (c) 4/7 on CH₂ and 1/7 on each meta carbon and the para carbon (d) equally on all seven carbons
Answer: (b)
The cation has an empty NBMO; the net charge on each atom is the square of its NBMO coefficient: \( (2/\sqrt7)^2 = 4/7 \) on CH₂ and \( 1/7 \) on each of the two ortho and the para carbon. Meta and ipso have zero NBMO coefficient. The total is \( 4/7 + 3/7 = 1 \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. For a two-centre π system C=X, take \( \alpha_X = \alpha + \beta \) and \( \beta_{CX} = \beta \) (two π electrons). Which statements are correct?
- The bonding π MO lies at \( \alpha + 1.618\beta \).
- The net π charge on X is about \( -0.45 \).
- The LUMO has its larger coefficient on carbon.
- The π bond order is 1, as in ethylene.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
\( m^2 - m - 1 = 0 \): \( m = 1.618 \) and \( -0.618 \).
Bonding coefficients: \( c_C = 0.526 \), \( c_X = 0.851 \).
- Correct.
- Correct. \( q_X = 2(0.851)^2 = 1.447 \); net charge \( 1 - 1.447 = -0.447 \).
- Correct. The LUMO is the mirror image: \( c_C = 0.851 \), \( c_X = -0.526 \).
- Wrong. \( p = 2 \times 0.526 \times 0.851 = 0.894 \): polarisation reduces the π bond order below 1.
Practice Q6. For the pentadienyl radical (five-carbon open chain, 5 π electrons), which statements are correct?
- It has an NBMO at \( \alpha \) with zero coefficient on C2 and C4.
- The NBMO coefficients on C1, C3 and C5 are proportional to 1, −1, 1.
- The unpaired spin density on C3 is 1/3.
- The pentadienyl cation carries a net charge of +1/3 on each of C1, C3 and C5.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 2, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Star C1, C3, C5 (the larger set).
- Correct. NBMO coefficients vanish on unstarred C2 and C4.
- Correct. Around C2: \( c_1 + c_3 = 0 \); around C4: \( c_3 + c_5 = 0 \). So \( c_1 : c_3 : c_5 = 1 : -1 : 1 \).
- Correct. Normalised: each \( \pm1/\sqrt3 \), so each has \( c^2 = 1/3 \).
- Correct. With the NBMO empty, the net charge equals \( c^2 \): \( +1/3 \) on C1, C3, C5.
Check against the general formula: \( c_{rk} = \sqrt{2/6}\sin(rk\pi/6) \) with \( k = 3 \) gives \( \sqrt{1/3}(1, 0, -1, 0, 1) \).
Practice Q7. Hückel data for naphthalene (with \( N_{\max} = \sqrt3 \)): free valence C1 0.453, C2 0.404; π bond orders C1–C2 0.725, C2–C3 0.603, C1–C8a 0.555, C4a–C8a 0.518. Which conclusions follow within the model?
- Radical attack is predicted to favour C1 over C2.
- The C1–C2 bond is predicted to be the shortest C–C bond.
- The π charge on C1 is greater than on C2.
- The ring-fusion bond C4a–C8a has the lowest π bond order of the four listed.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. Higher free valence at C1.
- Correct. Highest π bond order, 0.725.
- Wrong. Naphthalene is an even alternant hydrocarbon; every carbon has \( q_r = 1 \). Differences in reactivity come from free valence or localisation energy, not charge.
- Correct. 0.518 is the lowest value listed.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Charge density | \( q_r = \sum_j n_j c_{rj}^2 \); net charge \( 1 - q_r \) |
| π bond order | \( p_{rs} = \sum_j n_j c_{rj}c_{sj} \); total \( 1 + p_{rs} \) |
| Energy identity | \( E_\pi = \sum q_r\alpha + 2\sum p_{rs}\beta \) |
| Bond orders | ethylene 1; allyl 0.707; butadiene 0.894, 0.447; benzene 0.667 |
| Free valence | \( F_r = \sqrt3 - \sum p_{rs} \); butadiene C1 0.838, C2 0.391; benzene 0.399 |
| Allyl charges | cation +0.5 on C1, C3; anion −0.5 on C1, C3; C2 zero |
| Alternant | energies \( \pm m \) paired; neutral: all \( q_r = 1 \); odd: NBMO at \( \alpha \) |
| NBMO rule | zero on unstarred; starred neighbours sum to zero |
| Benzyl NBMO | CH₂ 4/7; ortho, para 1/7 each |
| Heteroatom | \( \alpha_X = \alpha + h\beta \), \( \beta_{CX} = k\beta \) |
| C=X (h = k = 1) | \( \alpha + 1.618\beta \); charge on X −0.447; LUMO on C |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Chemical Bonding in Diatomics: Quick Revision: every formula and number from the chapter on one page.
- Revisit the energies in Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems.
- Aromatic ligands at work: Alkyl, Carbene and π Complexes.
- Back to the chapter overview.