Skip to content

Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems

CSIR NET physical chemistry: Hückel assumptions, allyl and butadiene determinants, polyene formulas, Frost circle, 4n+2 rule and delocalisation energy.

  • 18 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 16 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Why Benzene Refuses to Add Bromine
  3. The Hückel Approximations
  4. Ethylene: Two Atoms
  5. Allyl: Three Atoms
  6. Butadiene: Four Atoms
  7. Linear Polyenes in General
  8. Cyclic Polyenes and the Frost Circle
  9. Delocalisation Energy
  10. Memory Tricks
  11. Don’t Confuse
  12. Common Mistakes
  13. Practice
  14. Quick Revision Table
  15. Key Takeaways
  16. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Why Benzene Refuses to Add Bromine

The Hückel Approximations

For a planar conjugated molecule, each π molecular orbital is written as an LCAO of the carbon \( 2p_z \) orbitals:

$$\psi_j = \sum_{r=1}^{N} c_{rj}\,\phi_r$$

Then four bold approximations are made.

Simple Hückel MO (HMO) assumptions
  1. σ–π separation. The π electrons move in a fixed field of the σ framework and are treated alone.
  2. Coulomb integrals: \( H_{rr} = \alpha \) for every carbon.
  3. Resonance integrals: \( H_{rs} = \beta \) if atoms r and s are directly bonded; \( H_{rs} = 0 \) otherwise.
  4. Overlap: \( S_{rr} = 1 \); \( S_{rs} = 0 \) for \( r \ne s \).

Both \( \alpha \) and \( \beta \) are negative. They are treated as empirical parameters, never computed.

With these, the secular determinant has \( \alpha - E \) on the diagonal, \( \beta \) where atoms are bonded, and 0 elsewhere. Divide every element by \( \beta \) and set

$$x = \frac{\alpha - E}{\beta} \qquad\Longleftrightarrow\qquad E = \alpha - x\beta$$

The determinant now has \( x \) on the diagonal and 1 for each bonded pair: it depends only on the molecule’s connectivity (its graph). Because \( \beta < 0 \), a root \( x = -1.618 \) means \( E = \alpha + 1.618\beta \), a bonding level below \( \alpha \).

Ethylene: Two Atoms

$$\begin{vmatrix} x & 1 \\ 1 & x \end{vmatrix} = x^2 - 1 = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad x = \pm1$$
MOEnergyWavefunctionOccupancy
\( \pi \)\( \alpha + \beta \)\( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}(\phi_1 + \phi_2) \)2
\( \pi^* \)\( \alpha - \beta \)\( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}(\phi_1 - \phi_2) \)0

Total π energy \( E_\pi = 2(\alpha + \beta) = 2\alpha + 2\beta \). The π-bond energy is \( 2\beta \), and the \( \pi \to \pi^* \) gap is \( 2\lvert\beta\rvert \). Ethylene’s localised π bond is the reference against which delocalisation is measured.

Allyl: Three Atoms

$$\begin{vmatrix} x & 1 & 0 \\ 1 & x & 1 \\ 0 & 1 & x \end{vmatrix} = x^3 - 2x = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad x = 0,\ \pm\sqrt2$$
MOEnergy\( c_1 \)\( c_2 \)\( c_3 \)Nodes
\( \psi_1 \)\( \alpha + \sqrt2\,\beta \)\( \tfrac12 \)\( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} \)\( \tfrac12 \)0
\( \psi_2 \) (NBMO)\( \alpha \)\( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} \)0\( -\tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} \)1 (through C2)
\( \psi_3 \)\( \alpha - \sqrt2\,\beta \)\( \tfrac12 \)\( -\tfrac{1}{\sqrt2} \)\( \tfrac12 \)2
Speciesπ electrons\( E_\pi \)Localised referenceDelocalisation energy
Allyl cation2\( 2\alpha + 2\sqrt2\,\beta \)ethylene + empty p: \( 2\alpha + 2\beta \)\( 0.828\beta \)
Allyl radical3\( 3\alpha + 2\sqrt2\,\beta \)ethylene + one electron at \( \alpha \)\( 0.828\beta \)
Allyl anion4\( 4\alpha + 2\sqrt2\,\beta \)ethylene + lone pair at \( \alpha \)\( 0.828\beta \)

The extra electrons go into the non-bonding \( \psi_2 \), which adds exactly \( \alpha \) per electron and so leaves the delocalisation energy unchanged. Because \( \psi_2 \) has a node at C2, the positive charge (cation), the unpaired spin (radical) and the negative charge (anion) all sit on C1 and C3, exactly what the two resonance structures say.

Butadiene: Four Atoms

$$\begin{vmatrix} x & 1 & 0 & 0 \\ 1 & x & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & x & 1 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 & x \end{vmatrix} = x^4 - 3x^2 + 1 = 0$$

So \( x^2 = (3 \pm \sqrt5)/2 \), giving \( x = \pm1.618, \pm0.618 \) (the golden ratio and its inverse).

MOEnergy\( c_1 \)\( c_2 \)\( c_3 \)\( c_4 \)Nodes
\( \psi_1 \)\( \alpha + 1.618\beta \)0.3720.6020.6020.3720
\( \psi_2 \) (HOMO)\( \alpha + 0.618\beta \)0.6020.372−0.372−0.6021
\( \psi_3 \) (LUMO)\( \alpha - 0.618\beta \)0.602−0.372−0.3720.6022
\( \psi_4 \)\( \alpha - 1.618\beta \)0.372−0.6020.602−0.3723
  • \( E_\pi = 2(\alpha + 1.618\beta) + 2(\alpha + 0.618\beta) = 4\alpha + 4.472\beta \).
  • Two isolated ethylenes: \( 4\alpha + 4\beta \).
  • Delocalisation energy \( = 0.472\beta \) (small: butadiene is only modestly stabilised).
  • HOMO–LUMO gap \( = 1.236\lvert\beta\rvert \), smaller than ethylene’s \( 2\lvert\beta\rvert \): butadiene absorbs at longer wavelength.
  • The number of nodes rises by one per level, as for a particle in a box.

Symmetry factoring: a 4 × 4 becomes two 2 × 2s

Butadiene (s-trans or s-cis) has a symmetry operation that swaps C1 ↔ C4 and C2 ↔ C3. Build symmetric and antisymmetric combinations:

  • Symmetric: \( \chi_1 = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}(\phi_1 + \phi_4) \), \( \chi_2 = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}(\phi_2 + \phi_3) \). The block is \( \begin{vmatrix} x & 1 \\ 1 & x + 1 \end{vmatrix} = x^2 + x - 1 = 0 \), giving \( x = -1.618, 0.618 \), i.e. \( E = \alpha + 1.618\beta \) and \( \alpha - 0.618\beta \) (\( \psi_1, \psi_3 \)).
  • Antisymmetric: \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}(\phi_1 - \phi_4) \), \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}(\phi_2 - \phi_3) \). Block \( x^2 - x - 1 = 0 \), giving \( x = 1.618, -0.618 \): \( \psi_4, \psi_2 \).

The \( x + 1 \) entry arises because \( \phi_2 + \phi_3 \) interacts with itself through the C2–C3 bond. Symmetry factoring is the standard trick for Part C determinants larger than 3 × 3.

Linear Polyenes in General

For a chain of \( N \) carbons:

Hückel results for linear chains
$$E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos\frac{k\pi}{N + 1}, \qquad c_{rk} = \sqrt{\frac{2}{N + 1}}\,\sin\frac{rk\pi}{N + 1}, \qquad k = 1, 2, \ldots, N$$

For even \( N \) (closed-shell polyene), the HOMO–LUMO gap is

$$\Delta E = 4\lvert\beta\rvert\,\sin\frac{\pi}{2(N + 1)}$$
Polyene\( N \)Bonding levels (\( m \) in \( \alpha + m\beta \))\( E_\pi \)Delocalisation energyGap / \( \lvert\beta\rvert \)
Ethylene21\( 2\alpha + 2\beta \)02.000
Butadiene41.618, 0.618\( 4\alpha + 4.472\beta \)\( 0.472\beta \)1.236
Hexatriene61.802, 1.247, 0.445\( 6\alpha + 6.988\beta \)\( 0.988\beta \)0.890
Octatetraene81.879, 1.532, 1.000, 0.347\( 8\alpha + 9.518\beta \)\( 1.518\beta \)0.695

The gap shrinks steadily with chain length: longer conjugation means longer absorption wavelength, the qualitative trend behind the colour of long polyenes such as carotenoids. Simple Hückel overstates the shift because it assumes equal C–C bonds; real polyenes alternate between short and long bonds, which keeps a finite gap even for very long chains.

Cyclic Polyenes and the Frost Circle

For a ring of \( N \) carbons every atom has two neighbours, and

$$E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos\frac{2\pi k}{N}, \qquad k = 0, \pm1, \pm2, \ldots$$

Levels with \( +k \) and \( -k \) are degenerate. Only \( k = 0 \) (and \( k = N/2 \) for even \( N \)) is non-degenerate.

The Frost circle (Frost–Musulin diagram)
Draw a circle of radius \( 2\lvert\beta\rvert \) centred at energy \( \alpha \). Inscribe the regular N-gon with one vertex pointing straight down. Each vertex gives one MO energy, and its height relative to the centre is \( 2\beta\cos(2\pi k/N) \).
RingMO energies (\( m \) in \( \alpha + m\beta \))
C₃2; −1, −1
C₄2; 0, 0; −2
C₅2; 0.618, 0.618; −1.618, −1.618
C₆2; 1, 1; −1, −1; −2
C₇2; 1.247, 1.247; −0.445, −0.445; −1.802, −1.802
C₈2; 1.414, 1.414; 0, 0; −1.414, −1.414; −2
graph TD
    A[Planar monocyclic ring, N p orbitals] --> B[Frost circle: one low level, then degenerate pairs]
    B --> C{Number of pi electrons}
    C -->|4n+2| D[all bonding levels filled: closed shell, aromatic]
    C -->|4n| E[last degenerate pair half filled: diradical, antiaromatic]
    D --> F[benzene 6, Cp anion 6, tropylium 6, C3H3 cation 2]
    E --> G[cyclobutadiene 4, Cp cation 4, C3H3 anion 4]

Hückel’s 4n + 2 rule

One low level (holds 2) plus degenerate pairs (each holds 4) means a closed shell is reached at \( 2, 6, 10, \ldots = 4n + 2 \) electrons. With \( 4n \) electrons the last degenerate pair holds only 2 electrons, one in each orbital with parallel spins (Hund’s rule): an open-shell diradical.

SpeciesRing sizeπ electronsHückel verdict\( E_\pi \)
Cyclopropenyl cation C₃H₃⁺32aromatic\( 2\alpha + 4\beta \)
Cyclobutadiene C₄H₄44antiaromatic (diradical)\( 4\alpha + 4\beta \)
Cyclopentadienyl anion C₅H₅⁻56aromatic\( 6\alpha + 6.472\beta \)
Cyclopentadienyl cation C₅H₅⁺54antiaromatic\( 4\alpha + 5.236\beta \)
Benzene C₆H₆66aromatic\( 6\alpha + 8\beta \)
Tropylium C₇H₇⁺76aromatic\( 6\alpha + 8.988\beta \)
Cyclooctatetraene dianion C₈H₈²⁻810aromatic\( 10\alpha + 9.657\beta \)

Planar cyclooctatetraene (8 π electrons) would be a Hückel diradical; the real molecule avoids this by adopting a non-planar tub shape with localised double bonds. Real cyclobutadiene is likewise not a square triplet but a rectangular, highly reactive singlet; the simple Hückel model, which assumes equal bonds, cannot capture that distortion. The aromatic C₅H₅⁻ is the ligand in ferrocene (see Alkyl, Carbene and π Complexes).

Delocalisation Energy

Delocalisation (resonance) energy
$$\text{DE} = E_\pi(\text{delocalised}) - E_\pi(\text{localised reference})$$

The reference is a set of isolated ethylene π bonds (\( 2\alpha + 2\beta \) each), plus non-bonding electrons at \( \alpha \) for any electrons that cannot be paired into ethylenic bonds. Because \( \beta < 0 \), a DE written as a positive multiple of \( \beta \) is a stabilisation.

Species\( E_\pi \)ReferenceDE
Allyl (any charge)\( \ldots + 2.828\beta \)one ethylene\( 0.828\beta \)
Butadiene\( 4\alpha + 4.472\beta \)two ethylenes\( 0.472\beta \)
Cyclobutadiene\( 4\alpha + 4\beta \)two ethylenes0
Benzene\( 6\alpha + 8\beta \)three ethylenes\( 2\beta \)
Cyclopropenyl cation\( 2\alpha + 4\beta \)one ethylene\( 2\beta \)
Cyclopentadienyl anion\( 6\alpha + 6.472\beta \)two ethylenes + lone pair\( 2.472\beta \)
Tropylium cation\( 6\alpha + 8.988\beta \)three ethylenes\( 2.988\beta \)

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
\( x = (\alpha - E)/\beta \): root \( x = -1 \) is bonding\( E = \alpha + m\beta \): \( m = +1 \) is bonding
Linear chain: \( E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos[k\pi/(N+1)] \), no degeneracyRing: \( E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos(2\pi k/N) \), degenerate pairs
Delocalisation energy (relative to ethylenes)Total π energy \( E_\pi \)
\( 4n+2 \): closed shell, aromatic\( 4n \): half-filled degenerate pair, antiaromatic
Hückel overlap \( S = 0 \): levels symmetric about \( \alpha \)With overlap: antibonding levels spread further than bonding

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. What are the Hückel π energies of the allyl system?
  2. What is the total π energy of benzene?
  3. How many π electrons does the cyclopentadienyl cation have, and is it aromatic by Hückel’s rule?
Answers
  1. \( \alpha + \sqrt2\beta \), \( \alpha \), \( \alpha - \sqrt2\beta \).
  2. \( 6\alpha + 8\beta \): two electrons at \( \alpha + 2\beta \) and four at \( \alpha + \beta \).
  3. 4; antiaromatic (a \( 4n \) system with a half-filled degenerate pair at \( \alpha + 0.618\beta \)).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. The Hückel delocalisation energy of 1,3-butadiene is:

(a) \( 0.472\beta \) (b) \( 0.828\beta \) (c) \( 2\beta \) (d) \( 4.472\beta \)

Answer: (a)

\( E_\pi = 4\alpha + 4.472\beta \); two ethylenes give \( 4\alpha + 4\beta \); difference \( 0.472\beta \). (b) is allyl; (c) is benzene; (d) is the β part of \( E_\pi \), not the DE.

Practice Q2. The HOMO energy of the allyl anion in simple Hückel theory is:

(a) \( \alpha + \sqrt2\beta \) (b) \( \alpha \) (c) \( \alpha - \sqrt2\beta \) (d) \( \alpha + \beta \)

Answer: (b)

Four π electrons: two in \( \psi_1 \) and two in the non-bonding \( \psi_2 \) at \( \alpha \). The HOMO is \( \psi_2 \).

Practice Q3. According to simple Hückel theory, which species has a closed-shell π configuration?

(a) cyclobutadiene (b) cyclopropenyl anion (c) cyclopropenyl cation (d) cyclopentadienyl cation

Answer: (c)

C₃H₃⁺ has 2 π electrons in the single level at \( \alpha + 2\beta \): closed shell, aromatic (\( n = 0 \)). The cyclopropenyl anion (4 electrons) puts two electrons in the degenerate pair at \( \alpha - \beta \); cyclobutadiene and C₅H₅⁺ have half-filled degenerate pairs.

Practice Q4. For a planar ring of five carbon \( 2p_z \) orbitals, the Hückel energies are:

(a) \( \alpha + 2\beta \); \( \alpha + 0.618\beta \) (×2); \( \alpha - 1.618\beta \) (×2) (b) \( \alpha + 1.618\beta \) (×2); \( \alpha \); \( \alpha - 1.618\beta \) (×2) (c) \( \alpha + 2\beta \); \( \alpha + \beta \) (×2); \( \alpha - \beta \) (×2) (d) \( \alpha \pm 1.732\beta \); \( \alpha \) (×3)

Answer: (a)

\( E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos(2\pi k/5) \): \( k = 0 \): \( 2 \); \( k = \pm1 \): \( 2\cos72° = 0.618 \); \( k = \pm2 \): \( 2\cos144° = -1.618 \). Sum: \( 2 + 1.236 - 3.236 = 0 \), as the trace requires.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. A conjugated diene shows its \( \pi \to \pi^* \) band at 220 nm. Assume simple Hückel theory, take the absorption energy equal to the HOMO–LUMO gap, and use \( hc = 1239.8 \) eV nm. Which set is correct?

(a) \( \lvert\beta\rvert \approx 4.56 \) eV; predicted band of the analogous triene ≈ 305 nm (b) \( \lvert\beta\rvert \approx 2.82 \) eV; predicted triene band ≈ 250 nm (c) \( \lvert\beta\rvert \approx 4.56 \) eV; predicted triene band ≈ 250 nm (d) \( \lvert\beta\rvert \approx 5.64 \) eV; predicted triene band ≈ 305 nm

Answer: (a)

Diene gap: \( E = 1239.8/220 = 5.64 \) eV \( = 1.236\lvert\beta\rvert \), so \( \lvert\beta\rvert = 4.56 \) eV.

Triene gap: \( 0.890\lvert\beta\rvert = 4.06 \) eV, so \( \lambda = 1239.8/4.06 \approx 305 \) nm.

Option (b) uses \( 2\lvert\beta\rvert \) (the ethylene gap) for the diene. In practice the real red shift per added double bond is smaller than this estimate, because real polyenes have alternating bond lengths, which simple Hückel ignores.

Practice Q6. Consider square cyclobutadiene in simple Hückel theory. Which statements are correct?

  1. Its π energy equals that of two isolated ethylene molecules.
  2. Two electrons occupy a degenerate pair of non-bonding MOs at \( \alpha \).
  3. Hund’s rule predicts a triplet ground state for the square geometry.
  4. Adding two electrons (C₄H₄²⁻) gives a configuration with 6 π electrons and a delocalisation energy of \( 2\beta \).

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only

Levels: \( \alpha + 2\beta \), \( \alpha \) (×2), \( \alpha - 2\beta \).

  1. Correct. \( E_\pi = 2(\alpha + 2\beta) + 2\alpha = 4\alpha + 4\beta \); DE = 0.
  2. Correct.
  3. Correct (within the model); the real molecule distorts to a rectangle and is a singlet.
  4. Wrong. C₄H₄²⁻ has \( E_\pi = 2(\alpha + 2\beta) + 4\alpha = 6\alpha + 4\beta \). The reference (two ethylenes plus a lone pair at \( \alpha \)) is also \( 6\alpha + 4\beta \), so the DE is 0, not \( 2\beta \). The added electrons sit in non-bonding orbitals.

Practice Q7. For the tropylium cation C₇H₇⁺, which pair (\( E_\pi \), delocalisation energy) is correct in simple Hückel theory?

(a) \( 6\alpha + 8.988\beta \), \( 2.988\beta \) (b) \( 6\alpha + 8\beta \), \( 2\beta \) (c) \( 7\alpha + 8.988\beta \), \( 2.988\beta \) (d) \( 6\alpha + 6.988\beta \), \( 0.988\beta \)

Answer: (a)

\( E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos(2\pi k/7) \): \( k = 0 \): \( 2\beta \); \( k = \pm1 \): \( 2\cos(51.43°) = 1.247 \).

Six electrons: \( 2(\alpha + 2\beta) + 4(\alpha + 1.247\beta) = 6\alpha + 8.988\beta \).

Reference: three ethylenes, \( 6\alpha + 6\beta \). DE \( = 2.988\beta \). The cation has 6 π electrons, so \( 7\alpha \) in (c) is wrong. (d) is hexatriene.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
HMO assumptionsπ only; \( H_{rr} = \alpha \); \( H_{rs} = \beta \) for neighbours, else 0; \( S_{rs} = \delta_{rs} \)
Variable\( x = (\alpha - E)/\beta \); determinant: x on diagonal, 1 per bond
Ethylene\( \alpha \pm \beta \); \( E_\pi = 2\alpha + 2\beta \)
Allyl\( \alpha + \sqrt2\beta,\ \alpha,\ \alpha - \sqrt2\beta \); DE \( 0.828\beta \)
Butadiene\( \alpha \pm 1.618\beta,\ \alpha \pm 0.618\beta \); \( E_\pi = 4\alpha + 4.472\beta \); DE \( 0.472\beta \)
Linear chain\( E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos[k\pi/(N+1)] \); gap \( 4\lvert\beta\rvert\sin[\pi/(2N+2)] \)
Ring\( E_k = \alpha + 2\beta\cos(2\pi k/N) \); Frost circle radius \( 2\lvert\beta\rvert \), vertex down
Benzene\( 2, 1, 1, -1, -1, -2 \); \( E_\pi = 6\alpha + 8\beta \); DE \( 2\beta \)
Aromatic (Hückel)planar monocycle with \( 4n + 2 \) π electrons
DE valuesC₃H₃⁺ \( 2\beta \); C₅H₅⁻ \( 2.472\beta \); C₇H₇⁺ \( 2.988\beta \); cyclobutadiene 0

Key Takeaways

What’s Next