Valence Bond Theory: Heitler–London, Hybridisation and MO vs VB
CSIR NET physical chemistry: Heitler–London treatment of H2, Coulomb and exchange integrals, singlet and triplet, ionic terms, hybrid orbitals and MO vs VB.
- 17 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Pull H₂ Apart
- The Heitler–London Wavefunction
- The Energy: Coulomb and Exchange Integrals
- Comparing the MO and VB Wavefunctions of H₂
- Hybridisation: VB for Polyatomic Molecules
- Resonance
- MO and VB: The Full Comparison
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- LCAO-MO Theory: H₂⁺, Secular Equations and Heteronuclear Bonds: overlap integral, normalisation and the MO wavefunction of H₂.
- The Variational Principle: why a better trial function always gives a lower energy.
- Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum: singlet and triplet spin functions.
- Bond Angles, Bent’s Rule and the Limits of VSEPR: the s-character formula used for hybrids below.
The Hook: Pull H₂ Apart
The Heitler–London Wavefunction
Label the two electrons 1 and 2 and the two 1s orbitals \( \phi_A \) and \( \phi_B \). At large \( R \) the ground state is “electron 1 on A, electron 2 on B”: \( \phi_A(1)\phi_B(2) \). Electrons are indistinguishable, so the swapped product \( \phi_B(1)\phi_A(2) \) is equally good. Heitler and London took the two combinations:
$$\psi_\pm(1,2) = N_\pm\left[\phi_A(1)\phi_B(2) \pm \phi_B(1)\phi_A(2)\right], \qquad N_\pm = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2(1 \pm S^2)}}$$The normalisation contains \( S^2 \), not \( S \), because the cross term is \( \int\phi_A(1)\phi_B(1)d\tau_1 \int\phi_B(2)\phi_A(2)d\tau_2 = S \cdot S \).
Adding spin: the Pauli principle picks the pairing
The total wavefunction must be antisymmetric to exchange of the two electrons.
| Spatial part | Symmetry | Spin part needed | Spin state | Molecular term |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| \( \psi_+ \) | symmetric | antisymmetric: \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt 2}[\alpha(1)\beta(2) - \beta(1)\alpha(2)] \) | singlet, \( S = 0 \) | \( ^1\Sigma_g^+ \), bonding |
| \( \psi_- \) | antisymmetric | symmetric: \( \alpha\alpha \), \( \tfrac{1}{\sqrt 2}(\alpha\beta + \beta\alpha) \), \( \beta\beta \) | triplet, \( S = 1 \) | \( ^3\Sigma_u^+ \), repulsive |
This is the quantum-mechanical meaning of “a bond is a shared pair of electrons with opposite spins”. The pairing is not a magnetic attraction between spins; it is the Pauli principle forcing the symmetric (bonding) spatial function to go with the singlet spin function.
The Energy: Coulomb and Exchange Integrals
The Hamiltonian of H₂ (atomic units) is
$$\hat H = -\tfrac12\nabla_1^2 - \tfrac12\nabla_2^2 - \frac{1}{r_{A1}} - \frac{1}{r_{B1}} - \frac{1}{r_{A2}} - \frac{1}{r_{B2}} + \frac{1}{r_{12}} + \frac{1}{R}$$Split it as two isolated atoms plus a perturbation. For the product \( \phi_A(1)\phi_B(2) \) the “extra” terms are
$$\hat H' = -\frac{1}{r_{B1}} - \frac{1}{r_{A2}} + \frac{1}{r_{12}} + \frac{1}{R}$$Then
- Coulomb integral \( J = \iint \phi_A(1)^2\,\hat H'\,\phi_B(2)^2\, d\tau_1 d\tau_2 \): the classical electrostatic energy of two hydrogen atoms’ charge clouds and nuclei. Small, and only slightly negative near \( R_e \).
- Exchange integral \( K = \iint \phi_A(1)\phi_B(1)\,\hat H'\,\phi_A(2)\phi_B(2)\, d\tau_1 d\tau_2 \): no classical analogue; arises because the electrons can swap atoms. Negative and much larger in magnitude near \( R_e \).
\( E_H = -\tfrac12 E_h \) is the energy of one isolated hydrogen atom.
Because \( K < 0 \) and \( \lvert K\rvert > \lvert J\rvert \) at bonding distances:
- Singlet \( \psi_+ \): \( E_+ - 2E_H = (J + K)/(1 + S^2) < 0 \). Bound, with a potential minimum.
- Triplet \( \psi_- \): \( E_- - 2E_H = (J - K)/(1 - S^2) > 0 \). Repulsive at all distances.
How good is it?
| Treatment of H₂ | \( R_e \) | \( D_e \) |
|---|---|---|
| Heitler–London, 1s exponent 1 | about 1.64 \( a_0 \) (87 pm) | about 3.14 eV |
| Experiment / exact | 1.40 \( a_0 \) (74 pm) | about 4.75 eV |
Like simple LCAO, the original VB function underbinds. Letting the orbital exponent vary, adding ionic terms and adding polarisation functions all improve it, as the variation theorem says they must.
Comparing the MO and VB Wavefunctions of H₂
Expand the MO function. Using unnormalised orbitals, \( \sigma_g \propto \phi_A + \phi_B \):
$$\sigma_g(1)\sigma_g(2) \propto \underbrace{\phi_A(1)\phi_B(2) + \phi_B(1)\phi_A(2)}_{\psi_{\text{cov}}:\ \text{H–H}} + \underbrace{\phi_A(1)\phi_A(2) + \phi_B(1)\phi_B(2)}_{\psi_{\text{ion}}:\ \text{H}^-\text{H}^+ \text{ and } \text{H}^+\text{H}^-}$$| Simple MO | Simple VB (Heitler–London) | |
|---|---|---|
| Spatial function | \( \psi_{\text{cov}} + \psi_{\text{ion}} \) | \( \psi_{\text{cov}} \) only |
| Ionic weight | equal to covalent, at every \( R \) | zero at every \( R \) |
| Near \( R_e \) | too much ionic character | too little (ionic structures do contribute) |
| As \( R \to \infty \) | 50 % H⁺ + H⁻: wrong, energy far too high | H + H: correct |
| Electron correlation | none: electrons move independently | over-correlated: never both on one atom |
Fixing both: they converge
VB with ionic terms (ionic–covalent resonance):
$$\Psi_{\text{VB}} = \psi_{\text{cov}} + \lambda\,\psi_{\text{ion}}, \qquad 0 < \lambda < 1$$with \( \lambda \) found variationally; it is small near \( R_e \) and goes to zero as \( R \to \infty \).
MO with configuration interaction (CI). Mix in the doubly excited configuration \( \sigma_u^2 \), which has the same symmetry (\( ^1\Sigma_g^+ \)). With \( \sigma_u \propto \phi_A - \phi_B \),
$$\sigma_u(1)\sigma_u(2) \propto \psi_{\text{ion}} - \psi_{\text{cov}}$$so (writing both configurations with unnormalised \( \phi_A \pm \phi_B \) factors)
$$\Psi_{\text{CI}} = \sigma_g^2 - c\,\sigma_u^2 = (1 + c)\,\psi_{\text{cov}} + (1 - c)\,\psi_{\text{ion}}$$Hybridisation: VB for Polyatomic Molecules
VB theory describes a bond as the overlap of one orbital on each atom. For CH₄, four equivalent C–H bonds at 109.5° cannot come from one 2s and three 2p orbitals directly, so Pauling mixed them into hybrid orbitals that point along the bonds and overlap better.
sp (180°): \( h_{1,2} = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt 2}(s \pm p_z) \)
sp² (120°): \( h_1 = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt 3}s + \sqrt{\tfrac23}\,p_x \); \( h_{2,3} = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt 3}s - \tfrac{1}{\sqrt 6}p_x \pm \tfrac{1}{\sqrt 2}p_y \)
sp³ (109.47°): \( h = \tfrac12(s + p_x + p_y + p_z) \), \( \tfrac12(s + p_x - p_y - p_z) \), \( \tfrac12(s - p_x + p_y - p_z) \), \( \tfrac12(s - p_x - p_y + p_z) \)
Two rules every hybrid set obeys:
- Normalisation: in each hybrid the squares of the coefficients add to 1. The square of the s coefficient is the hybrid’s fractional s character \( \alpha_s \).
- Conservation of s: summed over the whole set, the s characters add to 1 (each atomic orbital is shared out completely). Likewise for each p orbital.
For two equivalent hybrids with s character \( \alpha_s \), orthogonality requires
$$\cos\theta = -\frac{\alpha_s}{1 - \alpha_s} \qquad\Longleftrightarrow\qquad \alpha_s = \frac{\cos\theta}{\cos\theta - 1}$$For \( sp^n \) hybrids, \( \alpha_s = 1/(n+1) \) and \( \cos\theta = -1/n \): sp 180°, sp² 120°, sp³ 109.47°.
Derivation in two lines. Write \( h_i = \sqrt{\alpha_s}\,s + \sqrt{1-\alpha_s}\,p_i \), where \( p_i \) is a p orbital pointing along hybrid \( i \). Two such p orbitals at angle \( \theta \) have \( \int p_1p_2\,d\tau = \cos\theta \). Orthogonality of the hybrids, \( \alpha_s + (1 - \alpha_s)\cos\theta = 0 \), gives the formula. The chemistry of unequal hybrids (Bent’s rule, lone pairs with extra s character) is in Bond Angles, Bent’s Rule and the Limits of VSEPR.
Resonance
When one VB structure is not enough, the wavefunction is written as a combination of several:
$$\Psi = c_1\Psi_{\text{I}} + c_2\Psi_{\text{II}} + \cdots$$Examples: the two Kekulé structures of benzene; the covalent and ionic structures of HCl (H–Cl and H⁺Cl⁻); the two structures of O₃ or NO₂⁻.
Rules for contributing structures.
- Same positions of all nuclei; only electrons are redistributed. (Tautomers are not resonance structures.)
- Same number of unpaired electrons.
- Structures of similar energy contribute most; structures with charge separation, or negative charge on the less electronegative atom, contribute less.
- The hybrid is lower in energy than any single structure. The difference is the resonance energy.
Resonance between covalent and ionic structures is also the basis of Pauling’s electronegativity scale: the extra bond energy of a polar bond A–B, beyond the mean of the A–A and B–B bond energies, is attributed to the ionic structures (see Electronegativity and Periodic Anomalies).
MO and VB: The Full Comparison
| Feature | Valence bond theory | Molecular orbital theory |
|---|---|---|
| Basic unit | electron pair localised between two atoms | one-electron orbitals delocalised over the molecule |
| Wavefunction built from | products of atomic orbitals (one electron per atom), antisymmetrised | Slater determinants of MOs |
| Ionic structures | added explicitly (resonance) | included automatically, overweighted |
| Dissociation of H₂ | correct (H + H) | wrong without CI (half H⁺ + H⁻) |
| O₂ magnetism | predicts diamagnetic (simple form): fails | two unpaired \( \pi^* \) electrons: correct |
| Odd-electron species (H₂⁺, NO) | awkward | natural |
| Ionisation energies, spectra | no natural orbital energies | Koopmans’ theorem; PES and UV bands map to MOs |
| Delocalised systems (benzene) | resonance among structures | delocalised π MOs (Hückel) |
| Chemist’s language | close to Lewis structures, hybrids, arrows | close to spectroscopy and computation |
| Improved form | VB + ionic terms | MO + CI; both converge |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Heitler–London normalisation \( [2(1 \pm S^2)]^{-1/2} \) | LCAO-MO normalisation \( [2(1 \pm S)]^{-1/2} \) | |
| Coulomb integral \( J \): classical, small | Exchange integral \( K \): quantum, the main bonding term | |
| Exchange integral \( K \) (an energy, two-electron) | Overlap \( S \) (dimensionless, one-electron) | |
| Resonance: one real molecule described by several structures | Tautomerism: different molecules in equilibrium (nuclei move) | |
| Resonance integral \( \beta \) (MO, one-electron) | Resonance energy (VB, stabilisation of the hybrid) | |
| Singlet \( ^1\Sigma_g^+ \): bonding ground state of H₂ | Triplet \( ^3\Sigma_u^+ \): repulsive |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Write the spatial part of the Heitler–London ground-state wavefunction of H₂, normalised.
- Which integral supplies most of the bond energy in the Heitler–London treatment?
- What is the angle between two equivalent hybrids each with 25 % s character?
Answers
- \( \psi_+ = [2(1 + S^2)]^{-1/2}\left[\phi_A(1)\phi_B(2) + \phi_B(1)\phi_A(2)\right] \).
- The exchange integral \( K \).
- \( \cos\theta = -0.25/0.75 = -1/3 \), so \( \theta = 109.47° \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The normalisation constant of the Heitler–London triplet spatial function \( \phi_A(1)\phi_B(2) - \phi_B(1)\phi_A(2) \) is:
(a) \( [2(1 - S)]^{-1/2} \) (b) \( [2(1 - S^2)]^{-1/2} \) (c) \( [2(1 + S^2)]^{-1/2} \) (d) \( 1/\sqrt 2 \)
Answer: (b)
\( \int\psi^2 = 1 + 1 - 2S^2 \). The cross term is a product of two one-electron overlap integrals, \( S \times S \), and has a minus sign for the antisymmetric combination.
Practice Q2. Expanded in atomic-orbital products, the simple MO ground-state wavefunction of H₂, \( \sigma_g(1)\sigma_g(2) \), contains:
(a) only covalent terms (b) only ionic terms (c) covalent and ionic terms with equal weight (d) covalent and ionic terms with the ionic weight going to zero as \( R \to \infty \)
Answer: (c)
\( (\phi_A + \phi_B)(1)(\phi_A + \phi_B)(2) = [\phi_A\phi_B + \phi_B\phi_A] + [\phi_A\phi_A + \phi_B\phi_B] \): equal coefficients, independent of \( R \). Option (d) describes the improved (CI or VB-plus-ionic) function, not the simple MO one.
Practice Q3. In the Heitler–London treatment, the triplet state of H₂ is:
(a) bound, with a shallower minimum than the singlet (b) repulsive at all internuclear distances (c) degenerate with the singlet (d) bound only if \( J > 0 \)
Answer: (b)
\( E_- - 2E_H = (J - K)/(1 - S^2) \). With \( K \) negative and larger in magnitude than \( J \), the numerator is positive and the curve is repulsive. This is the \( ^3\Sigma_u^+ \) state.
Practice Q4. Which statement about hybrid orbitals is correct?
(a) Each sp² hybrid has 50 % s character. (b) The s characters of all hybrids in a complete set on one atom add to 1. (c) The angle between two equivalent sp hybrids is 90°. (d) Hybridisation is the cause of molecular geometry.
Answer: (b)
One s orbital is shared among the set. (a) sp² has 1/3 s. (c) sp hybrids are at 180°. (d) Hybridisation describes a geometry; it does not cause it.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. An improved H₂ wavefunction is written as \( \Psi = \sigma_g^2 - c\,\sigma_u^2 \), where both configurations use the unnormalised factors \( \phi_A \pm \phi_B \), and \( c = 0.2 \) at a given \( R \). Which statements are correct?
- \( \Psi \) is equivalent to \( \psi_{\text{cov}} + \lambda\psi_{\text{ion}} \) with \( \lambda = 2/3 \).
- \( \sigma_u^2 \) contributes covalent terms with a negative sign.
- As \( R \to \infty \), \( c \) should tend to 1.
- Mixing \( \sigma_u^2 \) into \( \sigma_g^2 \) raises the variational energy.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
\( \sigma_g^2 \propto \psi_{\text{cov}} + \psi_{\text{ion}} \) and \( \sigma_u^2 \propto \psi_{\text{ion}} - \psi_{\text{cov}} \).
\( \Psi = (1 + c)\psi_{\text{cov}} + (1 - c)\psi_{\text{ion}} = 1.2\,\psi_{\text{cov}} + 0.8\,\psi_{\text{ion}} \), so \( \lambda = 0.8/1.2 = 2/3 \).
- Correct.
- Correct. \( \sigma_u^2 \) contains \( -\psi_{\text{cov}} \); subtracting it adds covalent character.
- Correct. At \( c = 1 \), \( \Psi = 2\psi_{\text{cov}} \): pure covalent, correct dissociation.
- Wrong. Adding a variational parameter can only lower (or leave unchanged) the energy.
Practice Q6. At some distance in a model H₂ calculation, \( J = -0.02\,E_h \), \( K = -0.10\,E_h \) and \( S = 0.75 \) (\( 1\,E_h = 27.211 \) eV). The singlet and triplet energies relative to two separated H atoms are closest to:
(a) −2.09 eV and +4.98 eV (b) −3.27 eV and +2.18 eV (c) −2.09 eV and +2.18 eV (d) −3.27 eV and +4.98 eV
Answer: (a)
\( S^2 = 0.5625 \).
Singlet: \( (J + K)/(1 + S^2) = -0.12/1.5625 = -0.0768\,E_h = -2.09 \) eV.
Triplet: \( (J - K)/(1 - S^2) = +0.08/0.4375 = +0.1829\,E_h = +4.98 \) eV.
Options with −3.27 eV and +2.18 eV come from dropping the overlap denominators (\( J + K = -0.12\,E_h \), \( J - K = +0.08\,E_h \)). The singlet–triplet gap here is about 7.07 eV, which shows how strongly the exchange integral separates the two spin states.
Practice Q7. An oxygen atom uses a set of four hybrids built from its 2s and 2p orbitals: two equivalent bonding hybrids, each with 20 % s character, and two lone-pair hybrids. Which statements are correct?
- The angle between them is about 104.5°.
- The remaining 60 % of the 2s orbital is shared by the two lone-pair hybrids.
- The lone pairs, taken together, have more s character than the two bonding hybrids together.
- The bonding hybrids are best described as sp³.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. \( \cos\theta = -0.2/0.8 = -0.25 \), \( \theta = 104.48° \).
- Correct. Total s is 1; the bonding pair uses \( 2 \times 0.20 = 0.40 \); the lone pairs share 0.60.
- Correct. 0.60 against 0.40.
- Wrong. 20 % s is \( sp^4 \) (\( 1/(n+1) = 0.2 \), \( n = 4 \)), not sp³ (25 %).
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Heitler–London singlet | \( [2(1+S^2)]^{-1/2}[\phi_A(1)\phi_B(2) + \phi_B(1)\phi_A(2)] \) × singlet spin |
| Heitler–London triplet | minus combination, \( [2(1-S^2)]^{-1/2} \), repulsive \( ^3\Sigma_u^+ \) |
| Energies | \( E_\pm = 2E_H + (J \pm K)/(1 \pm S^2) \) |
| Bonding integral | exchange \( K \) (negative, dominant) |
| H₂ numbers | HL about 3.14 eV at 1.64 \( a_0 \); exact about 4.75 eV at 1.40 \( a_0 \) |
| Simple MO | \( \psi_{\text{cov}} + \psi_{\text{ion}} \), equal weight; wrong dissociation |
| Simple VB | \( \psi_{\text{cov}} \) only; correct dissociation |
| Convergence | \( \sigma_g^2 - c\sigma_u^2 = (1+c)\psi_{\text{cov}} + (1-c)\psi_{\text{ion}} \) |
| Hybrid angle | \( \cos\theta = -\alpha_s/(1-\alpha_s) \); \( sp^n \): \( \cos\theta = -1/n \) |
| Resonance rules | same nuclei, same unpaired electrons; hybrid lower than any structure |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Bonding in Diatomics: MO Diagrams, Term Symbols and Spectra: from the H₂ term \( ^1\Sigma_g^+ \) to O₂’s \( ^3\Sigma_g^- \) and singlet oxygen.
- Resonance in benzene, done the MO way: Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems.
- Back to LCAO-MO Theory: H₂⁺ or the chapter overview.