Skip to content

Ideal and Non-ideal Solutions

CSIR NET chemistry: Raoult's and Henry's laws, ideal mixing, deviations, azeotropes, activity coefficients, regular solutions and colligative properties.

  • 18 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 15 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: The Azeotrope That Stops Distillation
  3. Partial Molar Quantities
  4. Raoult’s Law and the Ideal Solution
  5. Henry’s Law and the Ideal-Dilute Solution
  6. Real Solutions: Deviations from Raoult’s Law
  7. Activity and Activity Coefficients
  8. Colligative Properties
  9. Memory Tricks
  10. Don’t Confuse
  11. Common Mistakes
  12. Practice
  13. Quick Revision Table
  14. Key Takeaways
  15. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: The Azeotrope That Stops Distillation

Partial Molar Quantities

For any extensive property \( X \) of a mixture, the partial molar quantity of component \( i \) is

$$\bar{X}_i = \left(\frac{\partial X}{\partial n_i}\right)_{T,P,n_{j\neq i}}, \qquad X = \sum_i n_i\bar{X}_i$$

The partial molar Gibbs energy is the chemical potential. Partial molar volumes can be negative (MgSO₄ in water at infinite dilution: the ions collapse the open water structure around them), and they depend on composition: mixing 50 cm³ of ethanol with 50 cm³ of water gives less than 100 cm³. The Gibbs–Duhem equation applies to every partial molar quantity: \( \sum_i n_i\,d\bar{X}_i = 0 \) at constant \( T \) and \( P \).

Raoult’s Law and the Ideal Solution

Raoult's law
The partial vapour pressure of a component is proportional to its mole fraction in the liquid: \( p_A = x_A p_A^* \), where \( p_A^* \) is the vapour pressure of pure A.

An ideal solution obeys Raoult’s law for every component at every composition. Its components have identical A–A, B–B and A–B interactions in effect (benzene–toluene, chlorobenzene–bromobenzene, n-hexane–n-heptane are close). Then

$$\mu_A(\text{l}) = \mu_A^*(\text{l}) + RT\ln x_A$$

and the mixing functions are those of ideal gases:

FunctionIdeal solution
\( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G \)\( nRT(x_A\ln x_A + x_B\ln x_B) < 0 \)
\( \Delta_{\text{mix}}S \)\( -nR(x_A\ln x_A + x_B\ln x_B) > 0 \)
\( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \)0
\( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V \)0

For an equimolar mixture of 2 mol in total at 300 K: \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G = 2RT\ln 0.5 = -3.46 \) kJ and \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}S = +11.5 \) J K⁻¹. Ideal mixing is driven entirely by entropy.

Vapour composition

$$p = p_B^* + (p_A^* - p_B^*)\,x_A, \qquad y_A = \frac{x_A p_A^*}{p}$$

The total pressure is linear in liquid composition (the bubble-point line). The vapour is always richer in the more volatile component than the liquid: if \( p_A^* > p_B^* \), then \( y_A > x_A \). Plotted against vapour composition, the total pressure gives the curved dew-point line; between the two lines liquid and vapour coexist and the lever rule gives their amounts.

On a temperature–composition (boiling-point) diagram at fixed pressure, the liquid line is now the lower curve. Repeated vaporisation and condensation (each step a “theoretical plate”) walks the composition towards the more volatile pure component: that is fractional distillation.

Henry’s Law and the Ideal-Dilute Solution

Henry's law
For a solute at low mole fraction, \( p_B = x_B K_B \), where \( K_B \) is an empirical constant with pressure units (not equal to \( p_B^* \)).

In a dilute solution the solvent obeys Raoult’s law and the solute obeys Henry’s law; such a solution is ideal-dilute. The Gibbs–Duhem equation guarantees this pairing: if \( \mu_B \) varies as \( RT\ln x_B \) (Henry), then \( \mu_A \) must vary as \( RT\ln x_A \) (Raoult) over the same range. Henry’s law governs gas solubility (carbonated drinks, oxygen in blood, decompression sickness); the solubility of a gas falls as temperature rises when dissolution is exothermic, as it usually is.

Real Solutions: Deviations from Raoult’s Law

Positive deviationNegative deviation
A–B interactionsweaker than A–A and B–Bstronger than A–A and B–B
Vapour pressureabove the Raoult linebelow the Raoult line
\( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \) (typical)> 0 (endothermic)< 0 (exothermic)
\( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V \) (typical)> 0 (expansion)< 0 (contraction)
Activity coefficient \( \gamma \)> 1< 1
Azeotrope, if deviation largeminimum-boiling (maximum in \( p \))maximum-boiling (minimum in \( p \))
Examplesethanol–cyclohexane, acetone–CS₂, ethanol–wateracetone–chloroform (C–H···O hydrogen bond), HNO₃–water, HCl–water

Azeotropes

At an azeotrope, liquid and vapour have the same composition, and the mixture boils at constant temperature like a pure substance. Distillation separates a mixture only into one pure component and the azeotrope:

  • Minimum-boiling azeotrope (positive deviation): the azeotrope comes over as the distillate; the residue tends to the pure component in excess.
  • Maximum-boiling azeotrope (negative deviation): a pure component distils first; the azeotrope remains in the flask. Constant-boiling hydrochloric acid (about 20 % HCl by mass, boiling near 109 °C at 1 atm) is the standard example.

The azeotropic composition shifts with pressure, which is the basis of pressure-swing distillation. An azeotrope is therefore a mixture, not a compound.

Immiscible liquids and steam distillation

If A and B are completely immiscible, each exerts its full vapour pressure: \( p = p_A^* + p_B^* \). The mixture boils when this sum reaches the external pressure, below the boiling point of either liquid. The mass ratio in the distillate is

$$\frac{m_A}{m_B} = \frac{p_A^* M_A}{p_B^* M_B}$$

so a high-boiling, high-molar-mass organic compound (essential oils, aniline) distils with water well below 100 °C.

Activity and Activity Coefficients

Keep the ideal form of \( \mu \) and absorb the non-ideality into the activity \( a \):

$$\mu_A = \mu_A^\circ + RT\ln a_A, \qquad a_A = \gamma_A x_A$$
ConventionReferenceActivity from vapour pressureLimit
Raoult (solvent, or both components of a liquid mixture)pure liquid A\( a_A = p_A/p_A^* \)\( \gamma_A \to 1 \) as \( x_A \to 1 \)
Henry (solute)hypothetical pure B behaving as at infinite dilution\( a_B = p_B/K_B \)\( \gamma_B \to 1 \) as \( x_B \to 0 \)

For electrolyte solutions, the molality-based mean activity coefficient \( \gamma_\pm \) and the Debye–Hückel limiting law belong to the electrochemistry unit.

Excess functions and the regular solution

Excess functions measure departure from ideality: \( X^E = \Delta_{\text{mix}}X(\text{real}) - \Delta_{\text{mix}}X(\text{ideal}) \). In particular

$$G^E = RT\sum_i n_i\ln\gamma_i$$

A regular solution has ideal entropy of mixing (\( S^E = 0 \)) but non-zero enthalpy: \( H^E = G^E = n\xi RT x_A x_B \), where \( \xi \) is a dimensionless interaction parameter (\( \xi RT \) is proportional to \( 2\varepsilon_{AB} - \varepsilon_{AA} - \varepsilon_{BB} \)). It follows that

$$\boxed{\ln\gamma_A = \xi x_B^2, \qquad \ln\gamma_B = \xi x_A^2}$$

(the two-suffix Margules equations). \( \xi > 0 \) gives positive deviation; \( \xi < 0 \) negative deviation. If \( \xi > 2 \), \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G \) develops two minima and the liquids separate into two phases; the upper critical solution temperature is where \( \xi \) falls to 2 on heating. This is the thermodynamic basis of the partially miscible liquid pairs on the phase-rule page.

Colligative Properties

Colligative properties depend on the number of solute particles, not their identity, for a non-volatile solute in a dilute solution. All four come from one fact: the solute lowers the chemical potential of the solvent, \( \mu_A = \mu_A^* + RT\ln x_A \), while a pure solid solvent or the pure solvent vapour is unaffected.

PropertyFormula (dilute)Constant
Relative lowering of vapour pressure\( \dfrac{p_A^* - p_A}{p_A^*} = x_B \)none
Boiling-point elevation\( \Delta T_b = K_b\,m_B \)\( K_b = \dfrac{RT_b^{*2}M_A}{\Delta_{\text{vap}}H} \)
Freezing-point depression\( \Delta T_f = K_f\,m_B \)\( K_f = \dfrac{RT_f^{*2}M_A}{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H} \)
Osmotic pressure (van ’t Hoff)\( \Pi = c_B RT \)none

Here \( m_B \) is molality (mol kg⁻¹), \( M_A \) is the molar mass of the solvent in kg mol⁻¹, and \( c_B \) is molar concentration in mol m⁻³ if \( \Pi \) is in Pa.

Derivation sketch for \( K_f \). At the freezing point, \( \mu_A^*(\text{s}) = \mu_A^*(\text{l}) + RT\ln x_A \). Then \( \ln x_A = -\dfrac{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H}{R}\left(\dfrac{1}{T} - \dfrac{1}{T_f^*}\right) \). For a dilute solution \( \ln x_A \approx -x_B \approx -M_A m_B \) and \( 1/T - 1/T_f^* \approx \Delta T/T_f^{*2} \), which gives the formula above. For water, \( K_f = \dfrac{8.314 \times 273.15^2 \times 0.018015}{6010} = 1.86 \) K kg mol⁻¹ and similarly \( K_b \approx 0.51 \) K kg mol⁻¹.

The same equation, read the other way, is the ideal solubility of a solid in a liquid: \( \ln x_B = -\dfrac{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H_B}{R}\left(\dfrac{1}{T} - \dfrac{1}{T_{f,B}^*}\right) \). It predicts that solubility depends only on the solute’s melting properties, not on the solvent; a solid with \( \Delta_{\text{fus}}H = 19.0 \) kJ mol⁻¹ melting at 353 K has an ideal mole-fraction solubility at 298 K of \( \exp[-(19\,000/8.314)(1/298 - 1/353)] = 0.30 \).

Osmotic pressure

Solvent flows through a semipermeable membrane from pure solvent into solution until the extra pressure \( \Pi \) on the solution raises \( \mu_A \) back to \( \mu_A^* \): \( \Pi V_A = -RT\ln a_A \). For a dilute solution this becomes \( \Pi = c_B RT \), formally the ideal-gas law. Applying a pressure greater than \( \Pi \) drives solvent the other way: reverse osmosis.

Abnormal molar masses: the van ’t Hoff factor

$$i = \frac{\text{observed colligative effect}}{\text{effect expected for no dissociation or association}}, \qquad \Delta T_f = iK_f m$$
Process\( i \)Degree \( \alpha \)
Dissociation into \( \nu \) ions\( 1 + (\nu - 1)\alpha \)\( \alpha = \dfrac{i - 1}{\nu - 1} \)
Association into \( n \)-mers\( 1 - \alpha\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n}\right) \)dimer: \( \alpha = 2(1 - i) \)

NaCl in water has \( i \) somewhat below 2 at moderate concentration because of ion pairing and non-ideality; carboxylic acids in benzene have \( i \) near 0.5 because they dimerise through hydrogen bonds.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Raoult: \( p_A = x_A p_A^* \), pure-liquid constantHenry: \( p_B = x_B K_B \), empirical constant \( K_B \neq p_B^* \)
Ideal solution: \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H = 0 \), \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V = 0 \)Ideal-dilute: solvent Raoult, solute Henry; \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \) need not be 0
Minimum-boiling azeotrope: positive deviationMaximum-boiling azeotrope: negative deviation
\( \gamma \) (activity coefficient, solutions)\( \phi \) (fugacity coefficient, gases)
Molality (mol per kg solvent): \( \Delta T_f \), \( \Delta T_b \)Molarity (mol per volume): \( \Pi = cRT \)
Osmotic pressure: number-average \( M \)Light scattering: weight-average \( M \) (polymer chapter)
Steam distillation: immiscible, \( p = p_A^* + p_B^* \)Fractional distillation: miscible, Raoult

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Take \( R = 8.314 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. What is \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \) for an ideal solution?
  2. Which colligative property is best suited to finding the molar mass of a protein?
  3. A mixture showing large negative deviation from Raoult’s law forms which type of azeotrope?
Answers
  1. Zero (also \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V = 0 \)).
  2. Osmotic pressure; the other effects are too small at the low molar concentrations involved.
  3. A maximum-boiling azeotrope (minimum in the vapour-pressure curve).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. Liquids A (\( p_A^* = 80 \) kPa) and B (\( p_B^* = 30 \) kPa) form an ideal solution. For a liquid with \( x_A = 0.40 \), the total vapour pressure and the mole fraction of A in the vapour are:

(a) 50 kPa and 0.40 (b) 50 kPa and 0.64 (c) 55 kPa and 0.64 (d) 44 kPa and 0.73

Answer: (b)

\( p = 0.40 \times 80 + 0.60 \times 30 = 32 + 18 = 50 \) kPa. \( y_A = 32/50 = 0.64 \). The vapour is enriched in the more volatile A. (a) uses the liquid composition for the vapour; (c) averages the pure vapour pressures.

Practice Q2. Water has \( \Delta_{\text{fus}}H = 6.01 \) kJ mol⁻¹ at 273.15 K and \( M = 18.015 \) g mol⁻¹. Its cryoscopic constant is closest to:

(a) 0.51 K kg mol⁻¹ (b) 1.86 K kg mol⁻¹ (c) 1860 K kg mol⁻¹ (d) 5.12 K kg mol⁻¹

Answer: (b)

\( K_f = \dfrac{RT_f^{*2}M_A}{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H} = \dfrac{8.314 \times 273.15^2 \times 0.018015}{6010} = 1.86 \) K kg mol⁻¹. (c) uses \( M \) in g mol⁻¹; (a) is the ebullioscopic constant of water; (d) is the cryoscopic constant of benzene.

Practice Q3. 2.0 g of a non-electrolyte dissolved in 100 g of water lowers the freezing point by 0.372 K (\( K_f = 1.86 \) K kg mol⁻¹). The molar mass of the solute is:

(a) 50 g mol⁻¹ (b) 100 g mol⁻¹ (c) 200 g mol⁻¹ (d) 1000 g mol⁻¹

Answer: (b)

\( m = \Delta T_f/K_f = 0.372/1.86 = 0.200 \) mol kg⁻¹. In 0.100 kg water: 0.0200 mol. \( M = 2.0/0.0200 = 100 \) g mol⁻¹. (c) and (a) come from wrongly applying a van ’t Hoff factor of 2 or 1/2 to a non-electrolyte; (d) is a factor-of-ten slip in the mass of solvent.

Practice Q4. Acetone–chloroform mixtures show:

(a) positive deviation, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H > 0 \), minimum-boiling azeotrope (b) negative deviation, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H < 0 \), maximum-boiling azeotrope (c) ideal behaviour, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H = 0 \) (d) negative deviation, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H > 0 \), minimum-boiling azeotrope

Answer: (b)

The C–H of chloroform (activated by three chlorines) hydrogen-bonds to the carbonyl oxygen of acetone, an interaction absent in either pure liquid. A–B attraction exceeds A–A and B–B: mixing is exothermic, the vapour pressure falls below Raoult’s line, and the mixture shows a vapour-pressure minimum, i.e. a maximum-boiling azeotrope.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. In a binary liquid mixture at 300 K with \( x_A = 0.50 \), the partial vapour pressure of A is 30.0 kPa; pure A has \( p_A^* = 50.0 \) kPa. Treat the mixture as a regular solution. Which statements are correct?

  1. \( a_A = 0.60 \) and \( \gamma_A = 1.20 \) (Raoult convention).
  2. The system shows positive deviation from Raoult’s law.
  3. The interaction parameter \( \xi \approx 0.73 \), so the liquids are miscible in all proportions.
  4. \( \gamma_B \) at \( x_A = 0.50 \) is less than 1.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. \( a_A = p_A/p_A^* = 30.0/50.0 = 0.60 \); \( \gamma_A = a_A/x_A = 1.20 \). Correct.
  2. \( \gamma_A > 1 \): the vapour pressure exceeds the Raoult value of 25 kPa. Correct.
  3. \( \ln\gamma_A = \xi x_B^2 \Rightarrow \xi = \ln 1.20/0.25 = 0.729 \). Phase separation needs \( \xi > 2 \). Correct.
  4. For a regular solution \( \ln\gamma_B = \xi x_A^2 = 0.729 \times 0.25 \), so \( \gamma_B = 1.20 \) at the equimolar point, greater than 1. Wrong.

Practice Q6. 1.0 g of a synthetic polymer is dissolved in water to give 100 cm³ of solution. At 300 K the osmotic pressure is 249 Pa. Which statements are correct?

  1. The molar concentration of polymer is about 0.10 mol m⁻³.
  2. The number-average molar mass is about \( 1.0 \times 10^5 \) g mol⁻¹.
  3. The freezing-point depression of this solution would be about \( 2 \times 10^{-4} \) K.
  4. The molar mass obtained is the weight-average molar mass.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. \( c = \Pi/RT = 249/(8.314 \times 300) = 0.0998 \) mol m⁻³ \( \approx 0.10 \). Correct.
  2. Amount in \( 1.0 \times 10^{-4} \) m³: \( 1.0 \times 10^{-5} \) mol. \( M = 1.0/1.0 \times 10^{-5} = 1.0 \times 10^5 \) g mol⁻¹. Correct.
  3. Molality ≈ \( 1.0 \times 10^{-5}/0.1 = 1.0 \times 10^{-4} \) mol kg⁻¹ (dilute, density ≈ 1); \( \Delta T_f = 1.86 \times 10^{-4} \) K, unmeasurably small. Correct.
  4. Colligative properties count molecules: they give the number-average. Wrong.

Practice Q7. 1.20 g of acetic acid (\( M = 60.0 \) g mol⁻¹) in 100 g of benzene (\( K_f = 5.12 \) K kg mol⁻¹) lowers the freezing point by 0.614 K. The van ’t Hoff factor and the degree of dimerisation are:

(a) 0.60 and 0.80 (b) 0.60 and 0.40 (c) 1.67 and 0.67 (d) 0.50 and 1.00

Answer: (a)

Expected (no association): \( m = (1.20/60.0)/0.100 = 0.200 \) mol kg⁻¹, \( \Delta T_f = 5.12 \times 0.200 = 1.024 \) K. \( i = 0.614/1.024 = 0.600 \). For dimerisation, \( i = 1 - \alpha/2 \Rightarrow \alpha = 2(1 - 0.600) = 0.80 \). (b) uses \( i = 1 - \alpha \); (c) inverts the ratio; (d) is complete dimerisation.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
Partial molar\( \bar{X}_i = (\partial X/\partial n_i)_{T,P,n_j} \); \( X = \sum n_i\bar{X}_i \)
Raoult\( p_A = x_A p_A^* \)
Henry\( p_B = x_B K_B \) (dilute solute)
Ideal mixing\( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G = nRT\sum x\ln x \); \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H = \Delta_{\text{mix}}V = 0 \)
Vapour\( y_A = x_A p_A^*/p \); richer in the volatile component
Positive deviationweak A–B, \( \gamma > 1 \), minimum-boiling azeotrope
Negative deviationstrong A–B, \( \gamma < 1 \), maximum-boiling azeotrope
Activity\( a_A = \gamma_A x_A = p_A/p_A^* \) (Raoult convention)
Regular solution\( \ln\gamma_A = \xi x_B^2 \); two phases if \( \xi > 2 \)
Steam distillation\( m_A/m_B = p_A^* M_A/(p_B^* M_B) \)
Colligative\( \Delta p/p^* = x_B \); \( \Delta T = Km \); \( \Pi = cRT \)
Constants (water)\( K_f = 1.86 \), \( K_b = 0.51 \) K kg mol⁻¹
\( K_f \) formula\( RT_f^{*2}M_A/\Delta_{\text{fus}}H \)
van ’t Hoff factordissociation \( 1 + (\nu - 1)\alpha \); dimerisation \( 1 - \alpha/2 \)
Ideal solubility\( \ln x_B = -(\Delta_{\text{fus}}H/R)(1/T - 1/T_f^*) \)

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement