Selection Rules: IR, Raman and Electronic Transitions
CSIR NET chemistry: the vanishing-integral rule, Γ3N and Γvib, IR and Raman activity, mutual exclusion, overtones, Laporte and spin rules, vibronic coupling.
- 24 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The CO₂ Band You Cannot See in the IR
- The One Rule Behind All Selection Rules
- Counting Vibrations: \( \Gamma_{3N} \) and \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} \)
- IR and Raman Activity
- Internal Coordinates: Stretches and Bends Separately
- Overtones, Combination Bands and Fermi Resonance
- Rotational Spectra
- Electronic Transitions
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Character Tables and Representations: the reduction formula and direct products are used on every line of this page.
- The table of characters \( \pm 1 + 2\cos\theta \) from Symmetry Elements and Symmetry Operations.
- Orbital angular momentum and parity of atomic orbitals from Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum.
- The harmonic oscillator picture of a vibration from Particle in a Box, Harmonic Oscillator and Tunnelling.
The Hook: The CO₂ Band You Cannot See in the IR
The One Rule Behind All Selection Rules
The intensity of a transition from state \( \psi_i \) to state \( \psi_f \) driven by an operator \( \hat{O} \) is proportional to \( |M|^2 \), where
$$M = \int \psi_f^{*}\,\hat{O}\,\psi_i\,d\tau$$An integral over all space vanishes unless the integrand is unchanged by every symmetry operation, at least in part. In group-theory language:
Equivalently: \( \Gamma(\psi_f) \times \Gamma(\psi_i) \) must contain the representation of the operator.
Everything on this page is this rule with different operators:
| Spectroscopy | Operator | Transforms as |
|---|---|---|
| IR absorption, electronic absorption | electric dipole moment \( \hat{\mu} \) | x, y, z |
| Raman scattering | polarisability \( \hat{\alpha} \) | the quadratic functions \( x^2, xy, \ldots \) |
| Magnetic-dipole transitions | angular momentum | \( R_x, R_y, R_z \) |
The rule says when a transition is forbidden by symmetry. A symmetry-allowed transition can still be weak for other reasons (small overlap, small change in dipole).
Counting Vibrations: \( \Gamma_{3N} \) and \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} \)
A molecule of N atoms has 3N degrees of freedom: 3 translations, 3 rotations (2 for a linear molecule) and \( 3N - 6 \) (or \( 3N - 5 \)) vibrations. Group theory sorts them by symmetry.
- Assign the point group.
- For each class, count the atoms left unshifted by one operation of that class.
- Multiply by the contribution per unshifted atom: E 3, \( C_2 \) −1, \( C_3 \) 0, \( C_4 \) 1, \( C_6 \) 2, σ 1, i −3, \( S_3 \) −2, \( S_4 \) −1, \( S_6 \) 0. This gives \( \Gamma_{3N} \).
- Reduce \( \Gamma_{3N} \) with the reduction formula.
- Subtract \( \Gamma_{\text{trans}} \) (the representations of x, y, z) and \( \Gamma_{\text{rot}} \) (those of \( R_x, R_y, R_z \)). What remains is \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} \).
- Check: the sum of dimensions in \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} \) equals \( 3N - 6 \) (or \( 3N - 5 \)).
The contributions are just the characters of the (x, y, z) matrices, since each unshifted atom carries its own three displacement arrows.
\( D_{3h} \) and a worked planar molecule
| \( D_{3h} \) | E | \( 2C_3 \) | \( 3C_2 \) | \( \sigma_h \) | \( 2S_3 \) | \( 3\sigma_v \) | Linear, rotations | Quadratic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| \( A_1' \) | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | \( x^2 + y^2, z^2 \) | |
| \( A_2' \) | 1 | 1 | −1 | 1 | 1 | −1 | \( R_z \) | |
| E′ | 2 | −1 | 0 | 2 | −1 | 0 | (x, y) | \( (x^2 - y^2, xy) \) |
| \( A_1'' \) | 1 | 1 | 1 | −1 | −1 | −1 | ||
| \( A_2'' \) | 1 | 1 | −1 | −1 | −1 | 1 | z | |
| E″ | 2 | −1 | 0 | −2 | 1 | 0 | (\( R_x, R_y \)) | (xz, yz) |
Results to know
| Molecule | Group | \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} \) | IR bands | Raman bands | Coincident |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H₂O, SO₂ (yz plane) | \( C_{2v} \) | \( 2A_1 + B_2 \) | 3 | 3 | 3 |
| ClF₃ (yz plane) | \( C_{2v} \) | \( 3A_1 + B_1 + 2B_2 \) | 6 | 6 | 6 |
| SF₄, CH₂Cl₂ | \( C_{2v} \) | \( 4A_1 + A_2 + 2B_1 + 2B_2 \) | 8 | 9 | 8 |
| cis-N₂F₂ (yz plane) | \( C_{2v} \) | \( 3A_1 + A_2 + 2B_2 \) | 5 | 6 | 5 |
| trans-N₂F₂ | \( C_{2h} \) | \( 3A_g + A_u + 2B_u \) | 3 | 3 | 0 |
| CO₂ | \( D_{\infty h} \) | \( \Sigma_g^+ + \Sigma_u^+ + \Pi_u \) | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| NH₃ | \( C_{3v} \) | \( 2A_1 + 2E \) | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| CHCl₃ | \( C_{3v} \) | \( 3A_1 + 3E \) | 6 | 6 | 6 |
| BF₃ | \( D_{3h} \) | \( A_1' + 2E' + A_2'' \) | 3 | 3 | 2 |
| PCl₅ | \( D_{3h} \) | \( 2A_1' + 3E' + 2A_2'' + E'' \) | 5 | 6 | 3 |
| CH₄ | \( T_d \) | \( A_1 + E + 2T_2 \) | 2 | 4 | 2 |
| XeF₄ | \( D_{4h} \) | \( A_{1g} + B_{1g} + B_{2g} + A_{2u} + B_{2u} + 2E_u \) | 3 | 3 | 0 |
| SF₆ | \( O_h \) | \( A_{1g} + E_g + T_{2g} + 2T_{1u} + T_{2u} \) | 2 | 3 | 0 |
“Bands” here means distinct fundamental frequencies: a degenerate E or T mode gives one band. Silent modes (active in neither) in this table are \( B_{2u} \) of XeF₄ and \( T_{2u} \) of SF₆. The \( A_2 \) modes of \( C_{2v} \) molecules are IR inactive but Raman active, because xy belongs to \( A_2 \). For metal-carbonyl ν(CO) band counts, see IR and Raman Spectroscopy of Inorganic Compounds.
IR and Raman Activity
IR
The ground vibrational state is totally symmetric. A fundamental transition (v = 0 → 1) of a mode Q goes to a state with the symmetry of Q. By the vanishing-integral rule, the transition is allowed only if \( \Gamma(Q) \times \Gamma(\mu) \) contains the totally symmetric representation, which means:
$$\boxed{\text{IR active} \iff \Gamma(Q) \text{ is the representation of } x, y \text{ or } z}$$Physically: the vibration must change the dipole moment.
Raman
The Raman operator is the polarisability tensor, whose components transform like \( x^2, y^2, z^2, xy, xz, yz \). So:
$$\boxed{\text{Raman active} \iff \Gamma(Q) \text{ is the representation of a quadratic function}}$$Physically: the vibration must change the polarisability.
graph TD
A["Mode of symmetry Γ"] --> B{"Γ in the x, y, z column?"}
B -- yes --> IR["IR active"]
B -- no --> IRN["IR inactive"]
A --> C{"Γ in the quadratic column?"}
C -- yes --> R["Raman active"]
C -- no --> RN["Raman inactive"]
IRN --> S{"Also Raman inactive?"}
RN --> S
S -- yes --> SIL["Silent mode"]Mutual exclusion
In a group with a centre of inversion, x, y, z are all u and every quadratic function is g. A mode cannot be both g and u, so:
Turned around (the contrapositive), the rule gives the useful diagnostic: if any band appears at the same frequency in both the IR and the Raman spectrum, the molecule has no centre of inversion. The absence of coincidences is weaker evidence (accidental weakness can hide a band).
Polarised Raman lines
With plane-polarised exciting light, the scattered light from a totally symmetric vibration keeps much of its polarisation: depolarisation ratio below 3/4 (polarised line). All other Raman-active modes give a ratio of 3/4 (depolarised). Measuring polarisation therefore picks out the \( A_1 \), \( A_{1g} \) or \( A_1' \) modes, which is how the symmetric stretch of a molecule is assigned.
Internal Coordinates: Stretches and Bends Separately
Instead of all 3N displacements, use a chemically meaningful basis: the bonds (for stretches) or the angles (for bends). The character for each operation is the number of bonds (or angles) left unshifted. No translations or rotations need to be subtracted, but redundant combinations of angles must be.
| Molecule | \( \Gamma_{\text{stretch}} \) | \( \Gamma_{\text{bend}} \) | Sum |
|---|---|---|---|
| H₂O | \( A_1 + B_2 \) | \( A_1 \) | \( 2A_1 + B_2 \) |
| BF₃ | \( A_1' + E' \) | \( E' + A_2'' \) (in-plane and out-of-plane) | \( A_1' + 2E' + A_2'' \) |
| CH₄ | \( A_1 + T_2 \) | \( E + T_2 \) (after removing redundant \( A_1 \)) | \( A_1 + E + 2T_2 \) |
| XeF₄ | \( A_{1g} + B_{1g} + E_u \) | \( B_{2g} + A_{2u} + B_{2u} + E_u \) | \( A_{1g} + B_{1g} + B_{2g} + A_{2u} + B_{2u} + 2E_u \) |
The stretch representation is the same as the σ-bond representation used for hybrid orbitals in Character Tables and Representations. That is why the counting of ν(CO) bands in carbonyls uses exactly the same arithmetic as hybridisation.
Overtones, Combination Bands and Fermi Resonance
- The symmetry of a combination level \( v_a = 1, v_b = 1 \) is \( \Gamma_a \times \Gamma_b \).
- The first overtone (v = 2) of a non-degenerate mode is always totally symmetric, since \( \Gamma \times \Gamma \) = totally symmetric for a one-dimensional representation. So overtones of non-degenerate modes are always Raman allowed by symmetry, and IR allowed only in groups where z (or x or y) is totally symmetric (\( C_{nv} \), \( C_s \), \( C_n \), \( C_1 \)).
- For degenerate modes, the overtone symmetry is the symmetric part of \( \Gamma \times \Gamma \).
- Fermi resonance: two vibrational levels of the same symmetry and nearly the same energy mix and repel. In CO₂, the overtone of the bend (\( 2\nu_2 \), with a \( \Sigma_g^+ \) component) lies close to the symmetric stretch \( \nu_1 \) (\( \Sigma_g^+ \)). They mix, and the Raman spectrum shows two strong bands (near 1285 and 1388 cm⁻¹) instead of one.
These are anharmonic effects: in a purely harmonic oscillator only \( \Delta v = \pm 1 \) is allowed. Symmetry decides whether an overtone or combination is forbidden even when anharmonicity is present.
Rotational Spectra
The same logic gives the gross selection rules for rotation:
| Spectrum | Requirement | Which point groups qualify |
|---|---|---|
| Pure rotational (microwave) | permanent dipole moment | polar groups only: \( C_1 \), \( C_s \), \( C_n \), \( C_{nv} \), \( C_{\infty v} \) |
| Pure rotational Raman | anisotropic polarisability | all except spherical tops (\( T_d \), \( O_h \), \( I_h \)) |
So CO₂ has no microwave spectrum but a rotational Raman spectrum; CH₄ and SF₆ have neither (to a first approximation); HCl and NH₃ have both.
Electronic Transitions
For electronic absorption the operator is again \( \hat{\mu} \), but now \( \psi_i \) and \( \psi_f \) are electronic states. The direct product \( \Gamma(\psi_f) \times \Gamma(\psi_i) \) must contain the representation of x, y or z. Which one it contains tells you the polarisation of the transition.
Spin selection rule
The dipole operator does not act on spin, so \( \Delta S = 0 \). Spin-forbidden bands appear only through spin–orbit coupling, more strongly for heavier atoms, and are very weak.
The Laporte (parity) rule
In a centrosymmetric molecule, x, y, z are all u. For \( g \times u \times (\ ) \) to be totally symmetric (g), the two states must have opposite parity:
$$\boxed{g \leftrightarrow u \ \text{allowed}; \quad g \leftrightarrow g,\ u \leftrightarrow u \ \text{forbidden}}$$For a free atom the corresponding rule is \( \Delta l = \pm 1 \): s → p allowed, s → d and d → d forbidden.
Worked electronic examples
Summary of electronic selection rules
| Rule | Statement | How it is relaxed |
|---|---|---|
| Spin | \( \Delta S = 0 \) | spin–orbit coupling |
| Laporte (parity) | g ↔ u only, in centrosymmetric species | vibronic coupling; loss of i (tetrahedral, distorted complexes) |
| Orbital symmetry | \( \Gamma_f \times \Gamma_\mu \times \Gamma_i \ni A_1 \) | vibronic coupling, lower site symmetry |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | Is not this |
|---|---|
| Number of vibrational modes (3N − 6, degenerate modes counted fully) | number of bands (one per distinct frequency; E counts once, T once) |
| IR active: changes the dipole moment | Raman active: changes the polarisability |
| Mutual exclusion (needs i) | “every Raman band is IR inactive” in molecules without i: false; \( T_d \), \( C_{3v} \), \( C_{2v} \) have coincidences |
| Symmetry-forbidden (integral exactly zero) | weak (allowed but small overlap or small dipole change) |
| Laporte rule (parity, g ↔ u) | spin rule (\( \Delta S = 0 \)) |
| Polarised Raman line (totally symmetric) | IR-active band (u or x, y, z symmetry) |
| Microwave needs a permanent dipole | rotational Raman needs anisotropic polarisability (CO₂ is active) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Every count was rechecked by reducing \( \Gamma_{3N} \).
Level 1: Foundation
- How many normal modes of vibration does benzene (C₆H₆) have?
- In which column of a character table do you look to decide Raman activity?
- State the Laporte rule for a centrosymmetric complex.
Answers
- 30. N = 12, non-linear: 3(12) − 6 = 30.
- The quadratic-function column (\( x^2, xy, \ldots \)), which reflects the polarisability.
- Only g ↔ u transitions are electric-dipole allowed; g ↔ g (such as d–d) and u ↔ u are forbidden.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The number of IR-active fundamental bands of BF₃ is
(a) 2 (b) 3 (c) 4 (d) 6
Answer: (b) 3
\( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} = A_1' + 2E' + A_2'' \). IR active: \( A_2'' \) (z) and the two E′ (x, y). That is three distinct frequencies (five modes counting degeneracy). \( A_1' \) is Raman only. Option (d) is the total number of vibrational modes, 3(4) − 6, not the number of IR bands.
Practice Q2. Which molecule obeys the rule of mutual exclusion?
(a) cis-N₂F₂ (b) trans-N₂F₂ (c) NH₃ (d) CH₂Cl₂
Answer: (b)
trans-N₂F₂ (\( C_{2h} \)) has a centre of inversion: \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} = 3A_g + A_u + 2B_u \); the three \( A_g \) modes are Raman only, \( A_u \) and \( 2B_u \) IR only. The other three are \( C_{2v} \) or \( C_{3v} \), with no i.
Practice Q3. The weak intensity of d–d bands in [Ni(H₂O)₆]²⁺ compared with [NiCl₄]²⁻ is best explained by
(a) the spin selection rule (b) the Laporte rule (c) the Franck–Condon principle (d) Fermi resonance
Answer: (b)
The octahedral aqua complex has a centre of inversion, so its d–d (g → g) bands are parity-forbidden and gain intensity only by vibronic coupling. Tetrahedral [NiCl₄]²⁻ has no i. The spin-allowed bands in both complexes satisfy ΔS = 0, so (a) does not distinguish them.
Practice Q4. For H₂CO in \( C_{2v} \) (molecule in yz plane, z along C=O), the \( n \to \pi^* \) transition gives an excited state of symmetry
(a) \( ^1A_1 \), z-allowed (b) \( ^1B_1 \), x-allowed (c) \( ^1A_2 \), forbidden (d) \( ^1B_2 \), y-allowed
Answer: (c)
n is \( b_2 \), π* is \( b_1 \); \( b_2 \times b_1 = A_2 \). No component of the dipole operator transforms as \( A_2 \) in \( C_{2v} \), so the transition is electric-dipole forbidden.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A planar molecule X₂Y₂ with an X=X double bond exists as two isomers, P and Q (both planar, each Y bonded to one X). Spectra of the fundamentals:
| Isomer | IR bands | Raman bands | Bands at the same frequency in IR and Raman |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | 3 | 3 | 0 |
| Q | 5 | 6 | 5 |
Which assignment and reasoning are correct?
- P is the trans isomer (\( C_{2h} \)), Q the cis isomer (\( C_{2v} \)).
- The absence of coincidences in P is consistent with a centre of inversion.
- The one Raman band of Q with no IR partner is the \( A_2 \) mode.
- Both isomers have six fundamentals.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 1, 2 and 4 only (d) 2, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
For 4 atoms, 3(4) − 6 = 6 fundamentals (4 correct).
trans (\( C_{2h} \)): unshifted atoms E 4, \( C_2 \) 0, i 0, \( \sigma_h \) 4, so \( \Gamma_{3N} = (12, 0, 0, 4) = 4A_g + 2B_g + 2A_u + 4B_u \). Remove \( A_u + 2B_u \) (translations) and \( A_g + 2B_g \) (rotations): \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} = 3A_g + A_u + 2B_u \). IR 3, Raman 3, no coincidences. Matches P (1 and 2 correct).
cis (\( C_{2v} \), yz plane): \( \Gamma_{3N} = (12, 0, 0, 4) = 4A_1 + 2A_2 + 2B_1 + 4B_2 \). Remove \( A_1 + B_1 + B_2 \) and \( A_2 + B_1 + B_2 \): \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} = 3A_1 + A_2 + 2B_2 \). IR: \( 3A_1 + 2B_2 \) = 5. Raman: all 6 (\( A_2 \) has xy). The extra Raman band is \( A_2 \) (3 correct). Matches Q.
Practice Q6. For tetrahedral [CoCl₄]²⁻ with a \( ^4A_2 \) ground state, consider the spin-allowed transitions to \( ^4T_2 \), \( ^4T_1(F) \) and \( ^4T_1(P) \). In \( T_d \), (x, y, z) transform as \( T_2 \). Which statements are correct?
- \( ^4A_2 \to {}^4T_1(F) \) and \( ^4A_2 \to {}^4T_1(P) \) are electric-dipole allowed by symmetry.
- \( ^4A_2 \to {}^4T_2 \) is electric-dipole forbidden by symmetry.
- All three are Laporte forbidden.
- \( A_2 \times T_2 = T_1 \).
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. Characters of \( A_2 \times T_2 \): (3, 0, −1, 1, −1), which is \( T_1 \).
- Correct. \( T_1 \times T_1 \) contains \( A_1 \) (a representation times itself always does).
- Correct. \( T_1 \times T_2 = A_2 + E + T_1 + T_2 \): no \( A_1 \).
- Wrong. \( T_d \) has no centre of inversion, so the parity rule does not apply.
The forbidden \( ^4A_2 \to {}^4T_2 \) lies at the lowest energy (it equals \( \Delta_t \) in the weak-field d⁷ picture) and is weak; the visible blue colour comes mainly from the allowed \( ^4T_1(P) \) band.
Practice Q7. An AB₄ species is either tetrahedral or square planar. Its vibrational spectra show 3 IR fundamentals, 3 Raman fundamentals, no coincidences, and one Raman band is polarised. Which statements are correct?
- The data fit \( D_{4h} \) and not \( T_d \).
- A tetrahedral AB₄ would show 2 IR and 4 Raman bands, with 2 coincidences.
- The polarised Raman band is the \( A_{1g} \) symmetric stretch.
- One vibration of the square-planar form is inactive in both spectra.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1 and 3 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
\( D_{4h} \): \( \Gamma_{3N} = (15, 1, -1, -3, -1, -3, -1, 5, 3, 1) \) for (E, \( 2C_4 \), \( C_2 \), \( 2C_2' \), \( 2C_2'' \), i, \( 2S_4 \), \( \sigma_h \), \( 2\sigma_v \), \( 2\sigma_d \)), which reduces to \( A_{1g} + A_{2g} + B_{1g} + B_{2g} + E_g + 2A_{2u} + B_{2u} + 3E_u \). Removing \( A_{2u} + E_u \) and \( A_{2g} + E_g \): \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} = A_{1g} + B_{1g} + B_{2g} + A_{2u} + B_{2u} + 2E_u \).
- IR (\( A_{2u} \), \( E_u \)): 3 bands. Raman (\( A_{1g}, B_{1g}, B_{2g} \)): 3 bands. No coincidences (i present). \( B_{2u} \) silent. (1, 4 correct.)
- Only the totally symmetric \( A_{1g} \) mode gives a polarised Raman line (3 correct).
- \( T_d \): \( A_1 + E + 2T_2 \); IR \( 2T_2 \); Raman all four; the two \( T_2 \) coincide (2 correct).
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Master rule | \( \Gamma_f \times \Gamma_{\hat{O}} \times \Gamma_i \) must contain the totally symmetric representation |
| Modes | 3N − 6 (non-linear), 3N − 5 (linear) |
| Contribution per unshifted atom | E 3, \( C_2 \) −1, \( C_3 \) 0, \( C_4 \) 1, \( C_6 \) 2, σ 1, i −3, \( S_3 \) −2, \( S_4 \) −1, \( S_6 \) 0 |
| \( \Gamma_{\text{vib}} \) | \( \Gamma_{3N} - \Gamma_{\text{trans}} - \Gamma_{\text{rot}} \) |
| IR active | mode transforms as x, y or z |
| Raman active | mode transforms as a quadratic function |
| Mutual exclusion | centrosymmetric: no mode both; coincidence ⇒ no i |
| Polarised Raman | totally symmetric modes only (ρ < 3/4) |
| Key counts (IR/Raman) | H₂O 3/3; CO₂ 2/1; NH₃ 4/4; BF₃ 3/3; CH₄ 2/4; XeF₄ 3/3; PCl₅ 5/6; SF₆ 2/3 |
| Overtone of a non-degenerate mode | totally symmetric |
| Fermi resonance | same symmetry, near-equal energy (CO₂ ν₁ and 2ν₂) |
| Electronic | ΔS = 0; Laporte g ↔ u; orbital symmetry via direct product |
| Formaldehyde | n → π* \( ^1A_2 \) forbidden; π → π* \( ^1A_1 \) z-allowed |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Group Theory: Quick Revision: all tables and counts of the chapter on one page.
- IR and Raman Spectroscopy of Inorganic Compounds: ν(CO) band counts, linkage isomers and group frequencies.
- UV-Visible Spectroscopy of Inorganic Compounds: charge-transfer and d–d bands in practice.
- Back to the chapter overview.