Symmetry Elements and Symmetry Operations
CSIR NET chemistry: E, Cn, σ, i and Sn; element vs operation, σv vs σd, powers of Sn, operation matrices, products, and tests for polarity and chirality.
- 22 min
On this page · 19 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: CH₄ and CH₃Cl Share a Skeleton but Not a Dipole
- Element Versus Operation
- Proper Rotation Axes, \( C_n \)
- Mirror Planes, \( \sigma \)
- The Centre of Inversion, \( i \)
- Improper Rotation Axes, \( S_n \)
- Operations as Matrices
- Combining Operations
- Listing the Elements of Common Molecules
- Symmetry Tests for Polarity and Chirality
- Symmetry-Equivalent Atoms
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Molecular shapes from VSEPR Theory and the Shapes of Molecules. You cannot find the symmetry of a molecule until you know its geometry, lone pairs included.
- Signs and nodal planes of orbitals from The Hydrogen Atom and the Shapes of Atomic Orbitals. Later in this chapter you will ask what each symmetry operation does to an orbital, not just to an atom.
- This is the first topic of Chemical Applications of Group Theory.
The Hook: CH₄ and CH₃Cl Share a Skeleton but Not a Dipole
Element Versus Operation
A symmetry operation is a movement of the molecule after which every atom sits on a position occupied by an equivalent atom. The molecule looks unchanged, though individual atoms may have moved. A symmetry element is the geometric object (a point, a line or a plane) about which the operation is carried out.
One element can generate several operations. A C₃ axis generates two distinct rotations (by 120° and by 240°). A mirror plane generates only one reflection, because reflecting twice brings everything back.
| Symbol | Element | Operation |
|---|---|---|
| \( E \) | the whole object (identity) | do nothing |
| \( C_n \) | proper axis of order \( n \) | rotate by \( 360°/n \) about the axis |
| \( \sigma \) | mirror plane | reflect through the plane |
| \( i \) | centre of inversion (a point) | send every point \( (x, y, z) \) to \( (-x, -y, -z) \) |
| \( S_n \) | improper axis of order \( n \) | rotate by \( 360°/n \), then reflect through the plane perpendicular to that axis |
The identity is not a trick. Every molecule has it, and group theory needs it in every group (it is the identity element of the group). A molecule whose only symmetry element is E, such as CHFClBr, belongs to point group \( C_1 \).
Proper Rotation Axes, \( C_n \)
Rotation by \( 360°/n \) about an axis is written \( C_n \). Applying it \( k \) times is written \( C_n^k \). Since \( C_n^n = E \), an n-fold axis generates \( n - 1 \) operations other than the identity.
| Axis | Operations it generates (besides E) | Note |
|---|---|---|
| \( C_2 \) | \( C_2 \) | 180° |
| \( C_3 \) | \( C_3, C_3^2 \) | 120°, 240° |
| \( C_4 \) | \( C_4, C_2 (= C_4^2), C_4^3 \) | the C₂ is coincident with the C₄ |
| \( C_6 \) | \( C_6, C_3 (= C_6^2), C_2 (= C_6^3), C_3^2 (= C_6^4), C_6^5 \) | a C₆ axis “contains” a C₃ and a C₂ |
The principal axis is the axis of highest order. By convention it defines the z direction. When a molecule has several C₂ axes and nothing higher (ethene, naphthalene), the choice of z is a convention, and the labels of some irreducible representations depend on it. Part C occasionally exploits this: always check which axis a question calls z.
Rotations carry a direction (clockwise or anticlockwise). Textbooks differ; what matters is that you use one direction consistently. \( C_n \) and \( C_n^{n-1} \) are rotations by the same angle in opposite senses, so they are inverses of each other.
Counting axes without double counting
Benzene has one C₆ axis. Along that same line it also has a C₃ and a C₂, but these are not extra axes: they are powers of the C₆. Perpendicular to the C₆ it has six C₂ axes: three through opposite carbon atoms (\( C_2' \)) and three through the midpoints of opposite C–C bonds (\( C_2'' \)). Asked “how many C₂ axes does benzene have?”, the answer is 7 (6 perpendicular + 1 collinear with C₆), and asked “how many C₂ axes perpendicular to the principal axis?”, the answer is 6.
Mirror Planes, \( \sigma \)
Reflection through a plane changes the sign of the coordinate perpendicular to it. Reflecting twice gives E, so each plane gives exactly one operation. Mirror planes are classified by how they sit relative to the principal axis:
| Plane | Definition | Example |
|---|---|---|
| \( \sigma_h \) (horizontal) | perpendicular to the principal axis | the molecular plane of BF₃, benzene, XeF₄ |
| \( \sigma_v \) (vertical) | contains the principal axis | the two planes of H₂O; the three planes of NH₃ |
| \( \sigma_d \) (dihedral) | contains the principal axis and bisects the angle between two C₂ axes perpendicular to it | the planes of allene; the planes between the F atoms of XeF₄ |
In square-planar XeF₄ there are four vertical planes. The two containing F–Xe–F lines contain the \( C_2' \) axes and are called \( \sigma_v \). The two lying between F atoms bisect the angle between those axes and are called \( \sigma_d \). Together with \( \sigma_h \) (the molecular plane) that makes 5 planes.
The Centre of Inversion, \( i \)
Inversion sends \( (x, y, z) \to (-x, -y, -z) \). If an atom sits at \( (x, y, z) \), an identical atom must sit at \( (-x, -y, -z) \). Consequences:
- At most one atom can lie at the centre; every other atom comes in a pair. A molecule with an odd number of some kind of atom can have i only if one of those atoms is at the centre (SF₆ yes: S at the centre; CO₂ yes: C at the centre).
- An atom at the centre is not required. Benzene, ethene and staggered ethane have i with nothing at the centre.
- No tetrahedral AB₄ molecule has i: inverting a tetrahedron gives the other tetrahedron of a cube.
\( i^2 = E \), so i gives one operation.
For orbitals, inversion defines parity: an orbital unchanged by i is g (gerade), one that changes sign is u (ungerade). s and d orbitals are g; p and f orbitals are u. This one fact underlies the Laporte rule in Selection Rules.
Improper Rotation Axes, \( S_n \)
\( S_n \) means: rotate by \( 360°/n \), then reflect through the plane perpendicular to the axis. The two steps can be done in either order. The important point is that an \( S_n \) axis can exist when neither the \( C_n \) nor the perpendicular plane exists on its own.
The standard example is methane. Take the line bisecting two opposite H–C–H angles (it coincides with a C₂ axis). Rotate by 90°: the H atoms move to positions that are not H positions, so there is no C₄. Reflect through the plane perpendicular to the axis: again not a symmetry operation alone. Do both, and every H lands on an H position. Methane has three S₄ axes.
Special cases
$$S_1 = \sigma \qquad\qquad S_2 = i$$S₁ is a rotation by 360° (which does nothing) followed by a reflection: a plain mirror plane. S₂ is a rotation by 180° followed by reflection through the perpendicular plane, which sends \( (x, y, z) \to (-x, -y, z) \to (-x, -y, -z) \): inversion. So “every molecule with a mirror plane or a centre of inversion has an improper axis” is true by definition.
Powers of \( S_n \): even and odd n behave differently
Write \( S_n^k \) for k successive applications. Since \( S_n^k = C_n^k \sigma_h^k \), and \( \sigma_h^k \) is E for even k and \( \sigma_h \) for odd k:
| Axis | Successive powers | Distinct operations |
|---|---|---|
| \( S_4 \) | \( S_4,\ S_4^2 = C_2,\ S_4^3,\ S_4^4 = E \) | 4 (two of them, \( C_2 \) and E, are proper) |
| \( S_6 \) | \( S_6,\ S_6^2 = C_3,\ S_6^3 = i,\ S_6^4 = C_3^2,\ S_6^5,\ S_6^6 = E \) | 6 |
| \( S_3 \) | \( S_3,\ S_3^2 = C_3^2,\ S_3^3 = \sigma_h,\ S_3^4 = C_3,\ S_3^5,\ S_3^6 = E \) | 6 |
For odd n, \( S_n^n = \sigma_h \), so the plane and the \( C_n \) both exist separately. That is why a molecule with an \( S_3 \) axis (BF₃, PCl₅) always has \( \sigma_h \) and \( C_3 \) as well. For even n, the plane need not exist: CH₄ has \( S_4 \) and \( C_2 \) but no \( C_4 \) and no \( \sigma_h \).
Operations as Matrices
Each operation moves the point \( (x, y, z) \) to a new point. That linear map can be written as a 3 × 3 matrix. With z along the axis:
$$E = \begin{pmatrix} 1&0&0\\0&1&0\\0&0&1 \end{pmatrix} \quad C_n = \begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta&-\sin\theta&0\\ \sin\theta&\cos\theta&0\\0&0&1 \end{pmatrix} \quad \sigma_h = \begin{pmatrix} 1&0&0\\0&1&0\\0&0&-1 \end{pmatrix} \quad i = \begin{pmatrix} -1&0&0\\0&-1&0\\0&0&-1 \end{pmatrix}$$with \( \theta = 360°/n \). An improper rotation is \( \sigma_h \cdot C_n \), so its matrix is the \( C_n \) matrix with the bottom-right 1 replaced by −1.
The sum of the diagonal elements (the trace, later called the character) is
$$\boxed{\chi(C_n) = 1 + 2\cos\theta \qquad \chi(S_n) = -1 + 2\cos\theta}$$| Operation | θ | χ |
|---|---|---|
| \( E \) | 0° | 3 |
| \( C_2 \) | 180° | −1 |
| \( C_3 \) | 120° | 0 |
| \( C_4 \) | 90° | 1 |
| \( C_6 \) | 60° | 2 |
| \( \sigma \) (= \( S_1 \)) | 360° | 1 |
| \( i \) (= \( S_2 \)) | 180° | −3 |
| \( S_3 \) | 120° | −2 |
| \( S_4 \) | 90° | −1 |
| \( S_6 \) | 60° | 0 |
Memorise this table. It is exactly the “contribution per unshifted atom” used to count vibrational modes in Selection Rules, and it is the most-used table in the chapter.
Combining Operations
Doing one operation and then another is again a symmetry operation of the molecule. The product \( AB \) means “do B first, then A”. A few combination rules let you deduce elements you have not yet spotted:
| If the molecule has | Then it also has |
|---|---|
| a \( C_n \) and one \( C_2 \) perpendicular to it | n such \( C_2 \) axes |
| a \( C_n \) and one \( \sigma_v \) | n vertical planes |
| a \( C_2 \) and a \( \sigma_h \) perpendicular to it | a centre of inversion (\( i = C_2 \sigma_h \)) |
| two mirror planes meeting at angle φ | a rotation by 2φ about their line of intersection |
| two \( C_2 \) axes meeting at angle φ | a rotation by 2φ about the axis perpendicular to both |
Check the second rule on H₂O (C₂ and two planes). With z along C₂ and the molecule in the yz plane: \( \sigma_v(xz) \) takes \( (x, y, z) \to (x, -y, z) \); then \( C_2 \) takes that to \( (-x, y, z) \). The net result is \( \sigma_v'(yz) \). So \( C_2 \cdot \sigma_v(xz) = \sigma_v'(yz) \): two planes at 90° generate the 180° rotation, and any two of the three non-identity operations generate the third.
Products need not commute. In NH₃, \( C_3 \sigma_v \) and \( \sigma_v C_3 \) are two different reflections. Groups in which every pair commutes (\( C_{2v} \), \( C_{2h} \), \( D_{2h} \)) are called Abelian, and all their irreducible representations are one-dimensional.
Listing the Elements of Common Molecules
| Molecule | Symmetry elements | Number of operations |
|---|---|---|
| H₂O | E, \( C_2 \), 2 \( \sigma_v \) | 4 |
| NH₃ | E, \( C_3 \), 3 \( \sigma_v \) | 6 |
| BF₃ | E, \( C_3 \), 3 \( C_2 \), \( \sigma_h \), \( S_3 \), 3 \( \sigma_v \) | 12 |
| Staggered ethane | E, \( C_3 \), 3 \( C_2 \), i, \( S_6 \), 3 \( \sigma_d \) | 12 |
| Allene | E, \( S_4 \) (collinear \( C_2 \)), 2 \( C_2' \), 2 \( \sigma_d \) | 8 |
| CH₄ | E, 4 \( C_3 \), 3 \( C_2 \), 3 \( S_4 \) (collinear with the \( C_2 \)), 6 \( \sigma_d \) | 24 |
| XeF₄ | E, \( C_4 \), 4 \( C_2 \) perpendicular, i, \( S_4 \), \( \sigma_h \), 2 \( \sigma_v \), 2 \( \sigma_d \) | 16 |
| Benzene | E, \( C_6 \), 6 \( C_2 \) perpendicular, i, \( S_6 \), \( S_3 \), \( \sigma_h \), 3 \( \sigma_v \), 3 \( \sigma_d \) | 24 |
| SF₆ | E, 3 \( C_4 \), 4 \( C_3 \), 6 \( C_2 \) (plus the 3 \( C_2 \) along the \( C_4 \)), i, 3 \( S_4 \), 4 \( S_6 \), 3 \( \sigma_h \), 6 \( \sigma_d \) | 48 |
| C₆₀ | E, 6 \( C_5 \), 10 \( C_3 \), 15 \( C_2 \), i, 6 \( S_{10} \), 10 \( S_6 \), 15 \( \sigma \) | 120 |
Plane counts worth knowing by heart: H₂O 2, NH₃ 3, BF₃ 4, PCl₅ 4, XeF₄ 5, CH₄ 6, benzene 7, SF₆ 9, C₆₀ 15, staggered ethane 3, allene 2.
Symmetry Tests for Polarity and Chirality
Both tests follow from the elements alone, so they belong here; Point Groups lists which groups pass.
Polarity. A molecule can have a permanent dipole moment only if the dipole vector is unchanged by every operation. So a polar molecule has no i, no \( \sigma_h \), no \( C_2 \) perpendicular to its principal axis, no more than one \( C_n \) axis (n ≥ 2), and no improper axis \( S_n \) with n ≥ 3 (an \( S_4 \) reverses the direction along its axis, so a molecule whose group is \( S_4 \) is non-polar). The dipole then lies along the unique axis, or within the mirror plane if the only element is a single plane.
Chirality. A molecule is chiral (not superimposable on its mirror image) if and only if it has no improper axis \( S_n \) of any order. Since \( S_1 = \sigma \) and \( S_2 = i \), this means no mirror plane, no centre of inversion and no higher \( S_n \).
The chirality rule is often taught as “no plane and no centre”. That is almost always enough, but not quite: a molecule with an \( S_4 \) axis and no plane or centre is still achiral. 1,3,5,7-Tetramethylcyclooctatetraene is the textbook example. Part C likes this exception.
Symmetry-Equivalent Atoms
Atoms that are interchanged by some operation of the group are symmetry-equivalent. They have identical environments, so in a rigid molecule they are chemically equivalent in NMR and give one signal. In NH₃ all three H are equivalent; in SF₄ (see-saw) the two axial F are equivalent to each other but not to the two equatorial F. Whether separate signals are actually seen also depends on exchange rates, which is why fluxional PF₅ shows one ¹⁹F environment at room temperature (see NMR Spectroscopy of Inorganic Compounds).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | Is not this |
|---|---|
| Symmetry element (axis, plane, point) | symmetry operation (the movement); one \( C_3 \) element gives two operations |
| \( \sigma_v \): contains the principal axis | \( \sigma_d \): contains the principal axis and bisects two \( C_2' \) axes |
| \( S_4 \) in CH₄ | a \( C_4 \) axis: CH₄ has none |
| \( C_2 \) collinear with \( C_4 \) or \( C_6 \) | an extra, separate axis; it is a power of the higher axis |
| Inversion centre | an atom at the centre: benzene and ethene have i with no central atom |
| Achiral | “has a mirror plane”: an \( S_4 \) alone also makes a molecule achiral |
| \( C_n^{n-1} \) | \( C_n^{-1} \) written differently; they are the same operation |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which single symmetry operation is equivalent to \( S_2 \)?
- How many distinct operations (including E) does an \( S_6 \) axis generate?
- How many mirror planes does BF₃ have?
Answers
- Inversion, i. A 180° rotation followed by reflection through the perpendicular plane sends \( (x, y, z) \) to \( (-x, -y, -z) \).
- 6. \( S_6, C_3, i, C_3^2, S_6^5, E \). Even n gives n operations.
- 4. The molecular plane (\( \sigma_h \)) and three vertical planes, each containing one B–F bond.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The total number of C₂ axes in benzene is
(a) 3 (b) 6 (c) 7 (d) 13
Answer: (c) 7
Six C₂ axes lie in the molecular plane (three through opposite C atoms, three through midpoints of opposite C–C bonds), and one C₂ lies along the C₆ axis as \( C_6^3 \). Total 7. Option (b) forgets the collinear C₂; option (d) counts the six perpendicular axes twice (6 + 6 + 1).
Practice Q2. Which molecule has an \( S_4 \) axis but no \( C_4 \) axis?
(a) XeF₄ (b) CH₄ (c) SF₆ (d) BrF₅
Answer: (b) CH₄
CH₄ has three \( S_4 \) axes but rotation by 90° alone does not superimpose it. XeF₄ and SF₆ have both \( C_4 \) and collinear \( S_4 \). BrF₅ (square pyramidal) has a \( C_4 \) but no \( S_4 \), since it has no \( \sigma_h \) and the \( S_4 \) would require the apical F to map onto the empty position below the base.
Practice Q3. The character (trace of the 3 × 3 matrix acting on x, y, z) of an \( S_3 \) operation is
(a) 0 (b) −1 (c) −2 (d) 2
Answer: (c) −2
\( \chi(S_n) = -1 + 2\cos(360°/n) \). For n = 3: \( -1 + 2\cos 120° = -1 - 1 = -2 \). Option (a) is the value for \( C_3 \); option (b) is \( S_4 \).
Practice Q4. A molecule has a \( C_2 \) axis and a mirror plane perpendicular to it. It must also have
(a) a \( C_4 \) axis (b) a centre of inversion (c) a second mirror plane containing the \( C_2 \) (d) an \( S_4 \) axis
Answer: (b)
\( C_2 \) sends \( (x, y, z) \to (-x, -y, z) \); \( \sigma_h \) then sends this to \( (-x, -y, -z) \). The product is i. trans-1,2-Dichloroethene (\( C_{2h} \)) is an example: it has \( C_2 \), \( \sigma_h \) and i, but no vertical plane, no \( C_4 \) and no \( S_4 \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Consider the following statements:
- Every molecule with an \( S_3 \) axis also has a \( \sigma_h \).
- Every molecule with an \( S_4 \) axis also has a \( \sigma_h \).
- Every molecule with an \( S_6 \) axis also has a centre of inversion.
- A molecule with an \( S_4 \) axis and no mirror plane is chiral.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1 and 3 only
- Correct. \( S_3^3 = C_3^3\sigma_h^3 = E\cdot\sigma_h = \sigma_h \).
- Wrong. \( S_4^4 = E \), and no power of \( S_4 \) is \( \sigma_h \). CH₄ and allene have \( S_4 \) and no \( \sigma_h \).
- Correct. \( S_6^3 = C_6^3 \sigma_h^3 = C_2 \sigma_h = i \).
- Wrong. Any improper axis makes a molecule achiral. The \( S_4 \) alone is enough.
Practice Q6. A rigid molecule has exactly the following symmetry elements: E, one \( C_3 \) axis, three \( C_2 \) axes perpendicular to it, and nothing else. Which statements are true?
- The molecule has 6 symmetry operations.
- The molecule is chiral.
- The molecule can have a permanent dipole moment along the \( C_3 \) axis.
- [Co(en)₃]³⁺ has this set of elements.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. E (1) + \( C_3, C_3^2 \) (2) + three \( C_2 \) (3) = 6. This is the group \( D_3 \).
- Correct. There is no improper axis of any order.
- Wrong. Any dipole along \( C_3 \) would be reversed by each perpendicular \( C_2 \), so it must be zero.
- Correct. The tris-chelate is a three-bladed propeller with \( C_3 \) and three \( C_2 \); it exists as Δ and Λ enantiomers.
Practice Q7. Using \( \chi = \pm 1 + 2\cos\theta \), find the characters of E, \( C_2 \), \( \sigma_v(xz) \) and \( \sigma_v'(yz) \) for the basis (x, y, z) in H₂O, and identify which coordinates are left unchanged by each operation.
Answer and working
- E: χ = 3; x, y, z all unchanged.
- \( C_2 \) (about z): χ = 1 + 2 cos 180° = −1; matrix diag(−1, −1, 1). Only z unchanged.
- \( \sigma_v(xz) \): χ = 1; diag(1, −1, 1). x and z unchanged, y reversed.
- \( \sigma_v'(yz) \): χ = 1; diag(−1, 1, 1). y and z unchanged, x reversed.
So the representation is (3, −1, 1, 1). In Character Tables and Representations this splits into three one-dimensional pieces: z (1, 1, 1, 1), x (1, −1, 1, −1) and y (1, −1, −1, 1), which are the A₁, B₁ and B₂ rows of the \( C_{2v} \) character table.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Five elements | E, \( C_n \), σ, i, \( S_n \) |
| \( C_n \) | generates n − 1 operations besides E; principal axis = highest n = z |
| Planes | \( \sigma_h \) ⊥ principal axis; \( \sigma_v \) contains it; \( \sigma_d \) contains it and bisects two \( C_2' \) |
| Identities | \( S_1 = \sigma \); \( S_2 = i \); \( i = C_2\sigma_h \) |
| \( S_n \) powers | even n: n operations; odd n: 2n operations and \( S_n^n = \sigma_h \) |
| \( S_6 \) | contains \( C_3 \) and i |
| Characters (x, y, z) | \( C_n \): \( 1 + 2\cos\theta \); \( S_n \): \( -1 + 2\cos\theta \); E 3, \( C_2 \) −1, \( C_3 \) 0, \( C_4 \) 1, σ 1, i −3, \( S_3 \) −2, \( S_4 \) −1, \( S_6 \) 0 |
| Order counts | H₂O 4, NH₃ 6, BF₃ 12, CH₄ 24, XeF₄ 16, benzene 24, SF₆ 48, C₆₀ 120 |
| Plane counts | BF₃ 4, XeF₄ 5, CH₄ 6, benzene 7, SF₆ 9, C₆₀ 15 |
| Polar | no i, no \( \sigma_h \), no ⊥ \( C_2 \), at most one \( C_n \), no \( S_n \) (n ≥ 3); only \( C_1, C_s, C_n, C_{nv} \) |
| Chiral | no \( S_n \) of any order |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Point Groups: collect the elements of a molecule into a point group with a flowchart, and learn which groups are polar or chiral.
- Character Tables and Representations: turn the matrices on this page into irreducible representations.
- Group Theory: Quick Revision.
- For shapes that feed this analysis, revisit Bond Angles, Bent’s Rule and the Limits of VSEPR.