Indole, Quinoline and Isoquinoline: Benzo-fused Heterocycles
CSIR NET organic chemistry: indole C3 reactivity, Fischer indole synthesis, benzofuran, quinoline and isoquinoline syntheses (Skraup, Bischler–Napieralski).
- 17 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Pyrrole, Furan and Thiophene: five-membered π-excessive rings and why they substitute at C2.
- Pyridine, Pyridones and Pyrylium Salts: π-deficient rings, Chichibabin and SNAr selectivity.
- Anionic, Sigmatropic and Aromatic Rearrangements: the [3,3]-sigmatropic shift at the heart of the Fischer indole synthesis.
The Hook: Tryptophan, Quinine and Morphine
The Benzo-Fusion Rule
When a benzene ring is fused to a heteroaromatic ring, the reagent goes where the intermediate keeps the benzene sextet intact for as long as possible, and where the heteroatom can help.
| Ring system | Electrophiles attack | Nucleophiles attack | Reason in one line |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indole | C3 | (not typical; C2 after N-activation) | C3 attack: N stabilises the cation without disrupting the benzene sextet |
| Benzofuran | C2 (mainly) | — | O is a weaker donor; benzylic-type stabilisation of the C3 cation dominates |
| Benzothiophene | C3 (mainly; some C2) | — | between indole and benzofuran in behaviour |
| Quinoline | C5 and C8 (benzene ring, via quinolinium) | C2 and C4 | electrophiles avoid the π-deficient pyridine ring |
| Isoquinoline | C5 (and C8) | C1 | C1 is an “α to N” position flanked by the benzene ring |
Indole
Structure and acid–base behaviour
Indole is a 10π aromatic: benzene fused to pyrrole at the C2–C3 bond (the pyrrole b-face). Numbering starts at N1, then C2, C3, C3a, C4–C7, C7a. As in pyrrole, the nitrogen lone pair is in the π system.
- Basicity: very weak (pKaH about −3.6). Protonation occurs at C3, giving a 3H-indolium cation in which the benzene ring stays intact.
- N–H acidity: pKa about 16 (water scale), about 21 in DMSO. NaH or KH in DMF gives the indolyl anion, which N-alkylates; the indolylmagnesium halide reacts largely at C3.
Why C3?
Attack at C3 gives a cation in which the positive charge is stabilised directly by the nitrogen lone pair (an iminium ion) while the benzene ring remains a complete sextet. Attack at C2 can place the positive charge on nitrogen only by disrupting the benzene ring. Compare pyrrole: there C2 attack wins because there is no benzene sextet to protect.
Reactions at C3
| Reaction | Reagents | Product |
|---|---|---|
| Vilsmeier formylation | POCl₃, DMF; then aq. base | indole-3-carbaldehyde |
| Mannich reaction | CH₂O, Me₂NH, AcOH | gramine (3-(dimethylaminomethyl)indole) |
| Acylation with oxalyl chloride | (COCl)₂ | indol-3-ylglyoxylyl chloride; with an amine then LiAlH₄ → tryptamines |
| Michael addition | enones, nitroalkenes, mild acid | 3-alkylated indoles |
| Halogenation | NBS, NCS, or Br₂ in DMF, low temperature | 3-haloindoles |
| Azo coupling, nitrosation | ArN₂⁺, HNO₂ | 3-substituted products |
Gramine as a synthetic handle. Quaternisation (MeI) or simple heating makes the dimethylamino group leave; elimination gives a 3-methyleneindolenine (an azafulvene) that adds nucleophiles at the exocyclic carbon. Cyanide gives indol-3-ylacetonitrile, which reduces to tryptamine.
3-Substituted indoles. When C3 is occupied, electrophiles still often attack C3 first, and the group then migrates to C2 (via a spiro-indolenine intermediate); direct C2 attack also contributes. The intramolecular version is the Pictet–Spengler reaction of tryptamines (below).
Indole in strong acid. In concentrated acid, indoles are protonated at C3 and the 3H-indolium cation is attacked on the benzene ring (typically C5), because the pyrrole ring is no longer nucleophilic. In weaker acid, indole dimerises and trimerises through attack of neutral indole on the indolium cation.
Metalation. N-protected indoles (N-SO₂Ph, N-Boc) lithiate at C2 with n-BuLi or LDA; this is the standard route to 2-substituted indoles.
Oxidation. Indoles oxidise readily at C2–C3; oxindoles (indolin-2-ones) and isatins (indoline-2,3-diones) are the common products of controlled oxidation.
Indole syntheses
The Fischer indole synthesis
An arylhydrazone of an aldehyde or ketone with at least one α-CH₂ is heated with an acid catalyst (ZnCl₂, polyphosphoric acid, BF₃, AcOH or H₂SO₄). Ammonia is lost and an indole forms.
graph TD
A["Arylhydrazine + ketone"] --> B["Arylhydrazone"]
B -->|"H+, tautomerise"| C["Ene-hydrazine"]
C -->|"[3,3]-sigmatropic shift
N-N bond breaks, C-C bond forms"| D["Di-imine"]
D -->|"rearomatise,
NH2 attacks C=N"| E["Cyclic aminal"]
E -->|"- NH3"| F["Indole"]Key features:
- Which nitrogen is lost? The nitrogen attached to the aryl ring (Nα) becomes indole N1; the terminal NH₂ (Nβ) is lost as NH₃. Isotope-labelling experiments with ¹⁵N established this.
- New C–C bond: formed between the ortho carbon of the aryl ring and the α-carbon of the ketone in the [3,3] step.
- Unsymmetrical ketones: the direction of ene-hydrazine formation decides the product. With butan-2-one, the more substituted ene-hydrazine usually dominates under typical acid conditions, giving 2,3-dimethylindole; the less substituted one gives 2-ethylindole. The ratio depends on acid strength.
- Indole itself: acetaldehyde phenylhydrazone does not cyclise well. Instead, the phenylhydrazone of pyruvic acid gives indole-2-carboxylic acid, which decarboxylates on heating to indole.
- Cyclohexanone phenylhydrazone gives 1,2,3,4-tetrahydrocarbazole; dehydrogenation then gives carbazole (the Borsche–Drechsel route).
- meta-Substituted arylhydrazines give mixtures of 4- and 6-substituted indoles, because either ortho carbon can take part in the [3,3] shift.
Other indole syntheses
| Name | Starting materials | Key step | Typical product |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bischler (Bischler–Möhlau) | α-arylamino ketone (from α-haloketone + excess aniline), acid | intramolecular SEAr then dehydration; aryl migration can scramble substituents | 2- or 3-arylindoles |
| Reissert | o-nitrotoluene + diethyl oxalate, KOEt → o-nitrophenylpyruvate; then Zn/AcOH (or Fe/AcOH) | reduction of NO₂ to NH₂, condensation with the ketone | indole-2-carboxylic acid (→ indole by decarboxylation) |
| Madelung | N-acyl-o-toluidine + strong base (NaNH₂, KOtBu) at high temperature; milder with BuLi | intramolecular condensation of the benzylic carbanion onto the amide C=O | 2-substituted indoles |
| Leimgruber–Batcho | o-nitrotoluene + DMF dimethyl acetal (often with pyrrolidine) → β-dialkylamino-o-nitrostyrene; then reduction (H₂/Pd, Raney Ni/N₂H₄) | the reduced amine cyclises onto the enamine, expelling the amine | indoles unsubstituted at C2 and C3; widely used industrially |
| Bartoli | ortho-substituted nitroarene + 3 equiv vinyl Grignard | nitroso intermediate, [3,3] shift | 7-substituted indoles |
| Larock | o-iodoaniline + internal alkyne, Pd catalyst | carbopalladation, then C–N bond formation | 2,3-disubstituted indoles |
| Nenitzescu | 1,4-benzoquinone + β-aminocrotonate ester | Michael addition, then cyclisation and redox | 5-hydroxyindoles |
Benzofuran and Benzothiophene
Both are benzo-fused at the b-face (C2–C3) like indole.
| Feature | Benzofuran | Benzothiophene |
|---|---|---|
| Preferred SEAr site | C2 (mainly) | C3 (mainly, some C2) |
| Lithiation (n-BuLi) | C2 | C2 |
| Syntheses | salicylaldehyde or o-hydroxyaryl ketone + α-haloketone or haloacetate, base (O-alkylation then intramolecular aldol, as in the Rap–Stoermer reaction); Perkin rearrangement of 3-halocoumarins → benzofuran-2-carboxylic acids; Pd/Cu coupling of o-iodophenols with terminal alkynes followed by cyclisation | acid-catalysed cyclisation of arylthio-acetaldehyde acetals or arylthio-ketones (PPA); Pd/Cu coupling of o-haloarylthiols or thioethers with alkynes |
| Character | the furan ring is easily reduced and opened | robust, thiophene-like |
Quinoline
Structure and reactivity
Quinoline is benzene fused to pyridine at the pyridine 2,3-bond, with N at position 1. It is a weak base (pKaH about 4.9), slightly weaker than pyridine.
Electrophilic substitution occurs on the benzene ring, at C5 and C8, under strongly acidic conditions on the quinolinium ion. Nitration with HNO₃/H₂SO₄ gives a roughly equal mixture of 5- and 8-nitroquinoline. Attack at C5 or C8 gives a σ-complex that keeps the pyridinium ring intact and has more contributors than attack at C6 or C7, analogous to α-attack in naphthalene.
Nucleophilic substitution occurs on the pyridine ring, at C2 and C4:
- NaNH₂ (Chichibabin) → 2-aminoquinoline.
- Organolithiums and Grignard reagents add at C2 (C4 when C2 is blocked).
- 2- and 4-Chloroquinolines undergo SNAr readily. 4,7-Dichloroquinoline reacts with amines at C4; this is the step used to attach the side chain in chloroquine-type antimalarials.
Other reactions
- Oxidation (KMnO₄): the benzene ring is destroyed, giving pyridine-2,3-dicarboxylic acid (quinolinic acid). The electron-poor pyridine ring survives.
- Reduction: under ordinary catalytic hydrogenation or with NaBH₃CN/AcOH, the pyridine ring is reduced to give 1,2,3,4-tetrahydroquinoline. Reduction of the benzene ring needs special conditions (hydrogenation in strong acid).
- Reissert compounds: quinoline + an acyl chloride + cyanide gives a 1-acyl-2-cyano-1,2-dihydroquinoline.
- Side chains: 2-methylquinoline (quinaldine) and 4-methylquinoline (lepidine) have acidic methyl groups that condense with aldehydes; condensations of quinolinium salts give cyanine dyes.
Quinoline syntheses
All the classical routes build the pyridine ring onto an aniline.
| Name | Partner for the aniline | Conditions | Product |
|---|---|---|---|
| Skraup | glycerol | conc. H₂SO₄ (dehydrates glycerol to acrolein), mild oxidant (nitrobenzene or As₂O₅), often FeSO₄ to moderate the vigorous reaction | quinoline (unsubstituted pyridine ring) |
| Doebner–Miller | α,β-unsaturated aldehyde or ketone (or aldehydes that form one in situ) | acid (HCl, ZnCl₂) | 2- and/or 4-substituted quinolines; crotonaldehyde gives 2-methylquinoline |
| Combes | 1,3-diketone | acid (H₂SO₄): enamine then cyclisation | 2,4-disubstituted quinolines |
| Conrad–Limpach | β-ketoester, lower temperature: condensation at the ketone gives a β-arylaminoacrylate; cyclisation at about 250 °C | — | 4-quinolones (4-hydroxyquinolines) |
| Knorr quinoline | β-ketoester, higher temperature: condensation at the ester gives a β-ketoanilide; cyclisation in H₂SO₄ | — | 2-quinolones (2-hydroxyquinolines) |
| Friedländer | o-aminobenzaldehyde (or o-aminoaryl ketone) + a ketone with an α-CH₂ | acid or base | 2,3-substituted quinolines; no oxidation needed |
| Pfitzinger | isatin (opened by base to isatinate) + a ketone | KOH | quinoline-4-carboxylic acids |
Isoquinoline
Structure and reactivity
Isoquinoline has N at position 2; C1 lies between N and the ring-fusion carbon C8a. It is a slightly stronger base than quinoline (pKaH about 5.4).
- Electrophiles: benzene ring, mainly C5 (with C8). Nitration gives 5-nitroisoquinoline as the main product.
- Nucleophiles: C1. NaNH₂ gives 1-aminoisoquinoline; organolithiums add at C1; 1-chloroisoquinoline undergoes SNAr readily, while 3-chloroisoquinoline is much less reactive.
- C1-methyl (1-methylisoquinoline) is acidic and condenses with aldehydes; a 3-methyl group is much less so.
- Reissert compounds form at C1 (2-acyl-1-cyano-1,2-dihydroisoquinolines); their anions are alkylated at C1, giving a route to 1-substituted isoquinolines.
Isoquinoline syntheses
All classical routes close the pyridine ring onto a benzene ring by intramolecular electrophilic substitution, so electron-donating groups on the aromatic ring (OMe, OH) are essential for good yields. Methoxy groups meta to the point of attachment of the side chain, which places them para to the cyclisation site, are ideal; this is why 6,7-dimethoxy patterns are so common.
| Name | Substrate | Reagent | Product |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bischler–Napieralski | N-acyl-β-arylethylamine (amide) | POCl₃, P₂O₅ or Tf₂O, heat | 3,4-dihydroisoquinoline (via a nitrilium or imidoyl phosphate electrophile); dehydrogenate (Pd/C, heat) to the isoquinoline or reduce (NaBH₄) to the tetrahydroisoquinoline |
| Pictet–Spengler | β-arylethylamine + aldehyde | acid (mild for electron-rich rings) | 1,2,3,4-tetrahydroisoquinoline (via an iminium ion); tryptamine gives a tetrahydro-β-carboline |
| Pomeranz–Fritsch | benzaldehyde + aminoacetaldehyde diethyl acetal → imine (Schiff base) | strong acid (H₂SO₄) | isoquinoline (fully aromatic) |
| Pictet–Gams | β-hydroxy- or β-methoxy-β-arylethylamide | P₂O₅ or POCl₃ | isoquinoline directly (extra elimination) |
The Pictet–Spengler reaction is also how plants make the tetrahydroisoquinoline and β-carboline alkaloids (dopamine with an aldehyde; tryptamine with secologanin). An asymmetric version, with a chiral Brønsted acid, connects this page to Substrate, Reagent and Catalyst Control.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Pyrrole SEAr at C2 | Indole SEAr at C3 | |
| Indole N-alkylation (NaH, DMF) | Indolyl-MgX alkylation at C3 | |
| Quinoline SEAr at C5/C8 (benzene ring) | Quinoline Nu⁻ at C2/C4 (pyridine ring) | |
| Quinoline + KMnO₄: benzene ring oxidised (quinolinic acid) | Quinoline + H₂/catalyst: pyridine ring reduced (1,2,3,4-tetrahydroquinoline) | |
| Conrad–Limpach (ketone first, 4-quinolone) | Knorr quinoline (ester first, 2-quinolone) | |
| Bischler–Napieralski (amide + POCl₃ → 3,4-dihydro) | Pictet–Spengler (amine + aldehyde + H⁺ → tetrahydro) | |
| Bischler indole synthesis (α-arylaminoketone) | Bischler–Napieralski isoquinoline synthesis | |
| Knorr pyrrole, Knorr pyrazole | Knorr quinoline (2-quinolone) | |
| Reissert indole synthesis (o-nitrotoluene + oxalate) | Reissert compounds (acyl-cyano-dihydroquinolines) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- At which position does indole undergo Vilsmeier formylation?
- What three reagents, besides aniline, are used in the Skraup synthesis of quinoline?
- What is the product of tryptamine and acetaldehyde under mild acid?
Answers
- C3, giving indole-3-carbaldehyde.
- Glycerol, concentrated sulfuric acid and an oxidant (nitrobenzene or As₂O₅); FeSO₄ is often added as a moderator.
- 1-Methyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydro-β-carboline (Pictet–Spengler reaction).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Phenylhydrazine and cyclohexanone are heated with acetic acid. The product is:
(a) carbazole (b) 1,2,3,4-tetrahydrocarbazole (c) 2-cyclohexylindole (d) cyclohexanone azine
Answer: (b)
Fischer indole synthesis: the cyclohexanone carbons C1 and C2 become indole C2 and C3, and the remaining four CH₂ groups form the saturated ring of 1,2,3,4-tetrahydrocarbazole. Carbazole needs an extra dehydrogenation.
Practice Q2. Indole is treated with formaldehyde and dimethylamine in acetic acid. The product, and a typical use of it, are:
(a) 1-(dimethylaminomethyl)indole; N-protecting group (b) gramine; converted via the 3-methyleneindolenine into indol-3-ylacetonitrile and tryptamine (c) 2-(dimethylaminomethyl)indole; precursor of tryptophan by C2 alkylation (d) indole-3-carbaldehyde; Wittig substrate
Answer: (b)
The Mannich reaction occurs at C3 to give gramine. Loss of dimethylamine (after quaternisation) gives an electrophilic azafulvene that adds cyanide; reduction of the nitrile gives tryptamine.
Practice Q3. p-Toluidine is subjected to Skraup conditions. The product is:
(a) 5-methylquinoline (b) 6-methylquinoline (c) 7-methylquinoline (d) 8-methylquinoline
Answer: (b)
Ring closure occurs ortho to the nitrogen. With the methyl para to NH₂, it ends up at C6 of quinoline. An ortho-toluidine gives 8-methylquinoline; m-toluidine gives a 5-/7-mixture.
Practice Q4. Which statement about isoquinoline is correct?
(a) Nitration occurs mainly at C1 (b) NaNH₂ gives 1-aminoisoquinoline (c) It is a stronger base than piperidine (d) Electrophilic substitution occurs mainly at C3
Answer: (b)
Nucleophiles attack C1 (Chichibabin amination). Nitration occurs at C5 on the benzene ring, not at C1 or C3 (a and d are wrong); pKaH about 5.4 is far below piperidine’s 11.1 (c is wrong).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Phenylhydrazine is prepared with ¹⁵N on the nitrogen attached to the ring (Ph–¹⁵NH–NH₂). Its butan-2-one hydrazone is heated with polyphosphoric acid. Which statements are correct?
- The ¹⁵N label is found in the indole ring nitrogen.
- The ammonia released is unlabelled.
- A new C–C bond forms between the aryl ortho carbon and an α-carbon of the ketone in a [3,3]-sigmatropic step.
- The major indole is expected to be 2,3-dimethylindole, with 2-ethylindole as the alternative from the other ene-hydrazine.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a)
The aryl-bound nitrogen becomes N1 of the indole (1); the terminal NH₂ is expelled as NH₃, which therefore carries no label (2). The key [3,3] shift breaks the N–N bond and makes the aryl–C bond (3). Butan-2-one can form two ene-hydrazines: toward CH₂ (more substituted, giving 2,3-dimethylindole) or toward CH₃ (giving 2-ethylindole); under typical acid conditions the former dominates (4).
Practice Q6. N-[2-(3,4-Dimethoxyphenyl)ethyl]acetamide (22.33 g; C₁₂H₁₇NO₃, M = 223.27 g mol⁻¹) is heated with POCl₃ to give P (C₁₂H₁₅NO₂, M = 205.26 g mol⁻¹) in 75% yield. P is heated with Pd/C to give Q (C₁₂H₁₃NO₂, M = 203.24 g mol⁻¹) in 80% yield. Which option is correct?
(a) P = 6,7-dimethoxy-1-methyl-3,4-dihydroisoquinoline (15.4 g); Q = 6,7-dimethoxy-1-methylisoquinoline (12.2 g); overall 60% (b) P = 6,7-dimethoxy-1-methyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydroisoquinoline (15.4 g); Q = the 3,4-dihydro compound (12.2 g); overall 60% (c) P = 6,7-dimethoxy-1-methyl-3,4-dihydroisoquinoline (20.5 g); Q = 6,7-dimethoxy-1-methylisoquinoline (16.3 g); overall 80% (d) P = 5,6-dimethoxy-1-methyl-3,4-dihydroisoquinoline (15.4 g); Q = 5,6-dimethoxy-1-methylisoquinoline (12.2 g); overall 60%
Answer: (a)
- Moles of amide = 22.33/223.27 = 0.1000 mol.
- Bischler–Napieralski cyclodehydration (−H₂O) gives the 3,4-dihydroisoquinoline: 0.0750 mol × 205.26 = 15.4 g. Cyclisation occurs para to the 3-methoxy group, so the methoxy groups end up at C6 and C7 (not 5,6).
- Pd/C removes H₂: 0.0750 × 0.80 = 0.0600 mol × 203.24 = 12.2 g of the aromatic isoquinoline.
- Overall: 0.75 × 0.80 = 60%. Option (b) gives the Pictet–Spengler oxidation level; (c) ignores the yields.
Practice Q7. Aniline is heated with ethyl acetoacetate under two sets of conditions. Route 1: about 25 °C with an acid catalyst, then the intermediate is added to a very hot (about 250 °C) high-boiling solvent. Route 2: about 140 °C, then the intermediate is warmed in concentrated H₂SO₄. Which statements are correct?
- Route 1 forms an enamine (β-anilinocrotonate) first and gives 2-methyl-4-quinolone.
- Route 2 forms an anilide (acetoacetanilide) first and gives 4-methyl-2-quinolone.
- Both routes give the same quinolone, because the ring always closes onto the ketone.
- The two routes are the Conrad–Limpach and Knorr quinoline syntheses, respectively.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 3 and 4 only (c) 1 and 2 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
At low temperature the amine condenses with the more electrophilic ketone carbonyl (enamine); thermal cyclisation onto the ester then gives 2-methylquinolin-4(1H)-one (Conrad–Limpach). At higher temperature the ester is aminolysed to the β-ketoanilide; acid cyclises it onto the ketone to give 4-methylquinolin-2(1H)-one (Knorr). The products are regioisomers, so statement 3 is wrong.
Quick Revision Table
| System | SEAr | Nucleophiles | Key syntheses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indole | C3 (C2 if C3 blocked or N-protected + BuLi) | — | Fischer, Bischler, Reissert, Madelung, Leimgruber–Batcho, Bartoli (7-subst.), Larock, Nenitzescu (5-OH) |
| Benzofuran | C2 | — | salicylaldehyde + α-haloketone; Perkin rearrangement; Pd/Cu alkyne cyclisation |
| Benzothiophene | C3 | — | arylthio-acetal + PPA; Pd/Cu alkyne cyclisation |
| Quinoline | C5, C8 | C2, C4 | Skraup, Doebner–Miller, Combes, Conrad–Limpach (4-one), Knorr (2-one), Friedländer, Pfitzinger |
| Isoquinoline | C5 (C8) | C1 | Bischler–Napieralski (3,4-dihydro), Pictet–Spengler (tetrahydro), Pomeranz–Fritsch, Pictet–Gams |
| Basicity (pKaH, approx.) | indole −3.6 (C3) | quinoline 4.9, isoquinoline 5.4 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Azoles and Diazines: rings with two heteroatoms, including benzimidazoles, quinoxalines and purines.
- Aromatic Substitution: the σ-complex arguments used throughout this page.
- Named Reactions in Synthesis: where these heterocycle-forming reactions sit among other named reactions.
- Heterocyclic Compounds: Quick Revision.