Allotropy of Main Group Elements
CSIR NET chemistry: allotropes of carbon, boron, phosphorus, sulfur, oxygen, selenium and tin, why they differ, and the stability and transition rules.
- 18 min
On this page · 18 sections
Prerequisites
- Electronegativity and Periodic Anomalies: the first-row anomaly (strong π bonds for C, N, O) is the root of every allotropy pattern on this page.
- Bonding in Homonuclear Molecules: the MO picture of O₂ and S₂ (two unpaired electrons) is used below.
- VSEPR Theory and Shapes of Molecules: bond angles in O₃, P₄ and S₈.
The Hook: A Match Head and a Pencil
What Allotropy Is
Allotropes may differ in:
- Molecular formula (O₂ and O₃; S₈ and S₆): sometimes called molecular allotropy.
- Crystal packing of the same molecule (rhombic and monoclinic sulfur, both S₈).
- Extended bonding (diamond, a 3D network; graphite, 2D sheets; fullerenes, discrete molecules).
Kinds of allotropic change
| Type | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Enantiotropy | Each form is stable in its own temperature range; a definite transition temperature lies below the melting point, and the change is reversible | rhombic ⇌ monoclinic sulfur (about 96 °C); grey ⇌ white tin (13.2 °C) |
| Monotropy | One form is stable under all ordinary conditions; the other is metastable and changes only one way | white → red phosphorus; diamond → graphite (infinitely slow at room temperature) |
| Dynamic allotropy | The forms coexist in equilibrium in the liquid, in proportions that shift with temperature | liquid sulfur: S₈ rings and long chains |
Why Some Elements Show Allotropy and Others Do Not
The first-row elements C, N and O form strong \( p\pi\text{–}p\pi \) bonds because their 2p orbitals are compact and overlap well side by side. Heavier elements form weak π bonds, so they prefer several single (σ) bonds instead. One bond-energy comparison makes the point (approximate mean values in kJ mol⁻¹):
| Element | Triple bond | Single bond | Two \( \text{E}_2 \) molecules (2 triple bonds) | One \( \text{E}_4 \) tetrahedron (6 single bonds) | Preferred form |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N | N≡N ≈ 945 | N–N ≈ 160 | ≈ 1890 | ≈ 960 | N₂ |
| P | P≡P ≈ 490 | P–P ≈ 200 | ≈ 980 | ≈ 1200 | P₄ |
Nitrogen gains far more by keeping triple bonds; phosphorus gains by trading π bonds for extra σ bonds. The same logic separates O₂ (double bond) from S₈ (rings of single bonds), and CO₂ (molecular) from SiO₂ (network). It also explains why catenation (chains and rings of like atoms) is strongest for carbon and then sulfur: C–C and S–S single bonds are strong, whereas N–N and O–O single bonds are weakened by lone-pair repulsion on small atoms.
Carbon
| Allotrope | Hybridisation | Structure | Key properties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diamond | sp³ | 3D network of tetrahedra; cubic (diamond lattice), 8 atoms per unit cell, C–C 154 pm | hardest natural material, electrical insulator, excellent thermal conductor, density about 3.51 g cm⁻³ |
| Graphite | sp² | planar hexagonal sheets (C–C about 142 pm), ABAB stacking, interlayer spacing about 335 pm | soft, lubricant, conducts electricity in the plane, density about 2.26 g cm⁻³ |
| Fullerenes (C₆₀, C₇₀, …) | sp² (pyramidalised) | closed cages of 12 pentagons plus hexagons | molecular solids, soluble in aromatic solvents, electron acceptors |
| Graphene | sp² | a single graphite sheet | very high in-plane conductivity and strength |
| Carbon nanotubes | sp² | graphene sheet rolled into a cylinder | metallic or semiconducting depending on how the sheet is rolled |
Other forms you may meet: lonsdaleite (hexagonal diamond, found at meteorite impact sites), the rhombohedral (ABC-stacked) form of graphite present in small amounts in natural graphite, and amorphous carbons (charcoal, carbon black) that are poorly ordered graphite.
Graphite versus diamond
- Graphite is the thermodynamic standard state of carbon. \( \Delta_f H^\circ(\text{diamond}) = +1.9 \) kJ mol⁻¹ and \( \Delta_f G^\circ(\text{diamond}) = +2.9 \) kJ mol⁻¹ at 298 K.
- Diamond is denser, so pressure favours it (Le Chatelier). Synthetic diamond is made by the high-pressure, high-temperature route with a molten transition-metal solvent-catalyst, or by chemical vapour deposition from methane–hydrogen plasmas at low pressure (a kinetically controlled route).
- Conductivity: in graphite each C uses three electrons in σ bonds and the fourth in a delocalised π system across the sheet, so graphite conducts parallel to the layers but poorly perpendicular to them. Diamond has every electron in localised σ bonds: an insulator with a wide band gap.
- Lubrication: the layers are held only by weak van der Waals forces; adsorbed gases and water help them slide. In vacuum graphite is a much poorer lubricant.
Fullerenes
C₆₀ (buckminsterfullerene) was identified in 1985 by Kroto, Curl and Smalley, who shared the 1996 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. It is a truncated icosahedron (point group \( I_h \)): 60 equivalent carbon atoms, 12 pentagons and 20 hexagons, every pentagon surrounded by hexagons (the isolated pentagon rule). It has two bond lengths: shorter bonds shared by two hexagons (6:6) and longer bonds shared by a hexagon and a pentagon (6:5), so the π system is not uniformly delocalised as in benzene.
Euler’s theorem fixes the pentagon count for any closed cage made only of pentagons and hexagons with three bonds at every vertex:
$$\boxed{\text{pentagons} = 12, \qquad \text{hexagons} = \frac{n}{2} - 10, \qquad \text{edges} = \frac{3n}{2}}$$for a fullerene \( \text{C}_n \). So C₆₀ has 20 hexagons and 90 bonds; C₇₀ (point group \( D_{5h} \), rugby-ball shaped) has 25 hexagons and 105 bonds.
Chemistry worth knowing: C₆₀ is a good electron acceptor (it can take up to six electrons electrochemically); alkali metal fullerides such as K₃C₆₀ are superconductors at low temperature; C₆₀ adds to the 6:6 bonds like an electron-poor alkene (it behaves as a polyalkene, not a super-aromatic); atoms can be trapped inside the cage (endohedral fullerenes, written M@C₈₂).
Graphene and nanotubes
Graphene, a single layer of graphite, was isolated by mechanical exfoliation in 2004 by Geim and Novoselov (Nobel Prize in Physics 2010). It is a zero-band-gap semiconductor with very high carrier mobility. A carbon nanotube is a graphene sheet rolled up; the rolling direction, written as a pair of indices \( (n, m) \), decides whether the tube is metallic or semiconducting.
Boron
Every crystalline form of boron is built from B₁₂ icosahedra (12 vertices, 30 edges, 20 triangular faces), linked to one another in different ways:
- α-rhombohedral boron: B₁₂ icosahedra in a slightly deformed cubic close-packed arrangement, linked by B–B bonds and by three-centre bonds between icosahedra.
- β-rhombohedral boron: a much larger unit cell of linked icosahedra and other fragments; the thermodynamically stable form.
- α-tetragonal boron and others: further arrangements of icosahedra plus isolated boron atoms.
Boron has only three valence electrons for four valence orbitals, so it cannot form a simple network of two-centre bonds the way carbon does. It solves this “electron deficiency” with multicentre (three-centre two-electron) bonding inside and between icosahedra, the same bonding that holds the boranes together on the next page. Boron is very hard, high-melting and a semiconductor.
Phosphorus
| Allotrope | Structure | Preparation | Properties |
|---|---|---|---|
| White (yellow) | discrete P₄ tetrahedra; P–P–P angle 60°, P–P about 221 pm | condensing phosphorus vapour | waxy, soluble in CS₂, very reactive (ignites in air at about 30 °C; stored under water), glows in the dark by slow oxidation (chemiluminescence), highly toxic |
| Red | polymeric chains of linked P₄ units (amorphous or crystalline) | heating white P at about 540 K in an inert atmosphere | insoluble in CS₂, stable in air, non-toxic, does not glow |
| Black | puckered layers of three-coordinate P, graphite-like stacking | heating white P under high pressure | thermodynamically the most stable form, a semiconductor; a single layer is called phosphorene |
| Violet (Hittorf’s) | tubes of P₈ and P₉ cages linked in layers | heating red P at higher temperature | a crystalline form of red phosphorus |
Why white phosphorus is so reactive: the 60° angle in P₄ is far smaller than the angle the p orbitals prefer (about 90°), so the molecule is strained. Opening one P–P bond relieves strain, which is what happens when white phosphorus polymerises to red phosphorus or burns in air.
Nitrogen, by contrast, shows no allotropy under ordinary conditions: N₂ is the only stable form, for the bond-energy reason given above.
Sulfur
Sulfur has more allotropes than any other element, because the S–S single bond is strong and the S–S–S angle (about 105–108°) can be accommodated in rings of many sizes.
| Form | Unit | Stability range | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| α-sulfur (rhombic, orthorhombic) | cyclo-S₈ (crown, \( D_{4d} \)) | stable below about 96 °C | yellow; the form found in nature |
| β-sulfur (monoclinic) | cyclo-S₈ packed differently | about 96 °C up to its melting point (about 119 °C) | needle-shaped crystals; reverts slowly to α at room temperature |
| γ-sulfur (monoclinic) | cyclo-S₈ | metastable | “nacreous” sulfur |
| Engel’s sulfur | cyclo-S₆ (chair) | metastable | rhombohedral crystals |
| Other rings | S₇, S₁₀, S₁₂, S₁₈, S₂₀ … | metastable | prepared by specific coupling reactions |
| Plastic (catena) sulfur | long helical chains | metastable | made by pouring hot molten sulfur into cold water; rubbery, reverts to α |
| S₂ vapour | diatomic | high temperature | paramagnetic, triplet ground state like O₂ |
Rhombic and monoclinic sulfur are the textbook example of enantiotropy: they interconvert reversibly at the transition temperature, which lies below the melting point.
Liquid sulfur: dynamic allotropy
Just above its melting point liquid sulfur is a mobile yellow liquid of S₈ rings. Near 159 °C the rings open and polymerise into long chains (diradicals at their ends), and the viscosity rises steeply by several orders of magnitude; the liquid turns dark red-brown. At still higher temperatures the chains break into shorter fragments and the viscosity falls again. Quenching the chain-rich liquid traps the chains as plastic sulfur.
Oxygen
| Dioxygen, O₂ | Ozone, O₃ | |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | O=O, 121 pm | bent, O–O about 128 pm (both equal), angle about 117° |
| Magnetism | paramagnetic (triplet, two unpaired π* electrons) | diamagnetic |
| Point group | \( D_{\infty h} \) | \( C_{2v} \) |
| Formation | from O₂ by a silent electric discharge or UV light; \( 3\text{O}_2 \rightarrow 2\text{O}_3 \) is endothermic (\( \Delta_f H^\circ(\text{O}_3) \approx +143 \) kJ mol⁻¹) | |
| Character | pale blue gas, powerful oxidant, absorbs UV in the stratosphere |
Ozone’s two O–O bonds are equal and intermediate between single and double: draw two resonance structures with a central O⁺ and a terminal O⁻. Ozone is polar (small dipole moment) because the central atom is different in environment from the terminal ones. Singlet oxygen (\( ^1\Delta_g \) O₂) is an excited state of O₂, not an allotrope.
Selenium, Tellurium, Arsenic and Antimony
- Selenium: grey (trigonal) selenium, made of infinite helical chains, is the stable form; it is a photoconductor (formerly used in photocopiers and light meters). Red selenium forms consist of Se₈ rings; there is also amorphous (black and red) selenium.
- Tellurium: one crystalline form, also helical chains, with more metallic character.
- Arsenic and antimony: the stable form is a metallic grey form made of puckered layers (each atom three-coordinate, with longer contacts to the next layer). Arsenic also has a metastable yellow form made of As₄ tetrahedra, analogous to white phosphorus; a yellow form of antimony is reported but is very unstable and poorly characterised.
Going down group 15 or 16, the metallic (layered, higher coordination) forms become the stable ones, which is the allotropy face of increasing metallic character.
Tin
| α-tin (grey) | β-tin (white) | |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | diamond lattice, four-coordinate | tetragonal, distorted six-coordinate (4 + 2) |
| Character | non-metallic, semiconductor, brittle powder | metallic, malleable |
| Stability | below 13.2 °C | above 13.2 °C (up to its melting point) |
| Density | lower | higher |
White tin is the everyday metal. Kept for long periods below 13.2 °C, it slowly converts to grey tin; because grey tin is markedly less dense, the expanding regions crumble into powder (tin pest). The change is slow without seeding and is another example of enantiotropy. Lead has no such form; silicon and germanium adopt the diamond structure.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Allotropy (elements: diamond, graphite) | polymorphism (compounds: quartz, cristobalite) | |
| Enantiotropy: reversible, definite transition point (S, Sn) | monotropy: one-way change to the stable form (white → red P) | |
| Graphite C–C about 142 pm, sp² | diamond C–C 154 pm, sp³ | |
| Graphite conducts in-plane | diamond insulates; h-BN (“white graphite”) also insulates | |
| O₂ paramagnetic | O₃ diamagnetic | |
| Rhombic S₈ (below 96 °C) | monoclinic S₈ (96–119 °C): same molecule, different packing | |
| White P: P₄ molecules | red P: polymer; black P: layers | |
| Singlet O₂: an excited state | O₃: a true allotrope |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the hybridisation of carbon in graphite, and what holds the layers together?
- Which allotrope of phosphorus is stored under water, and why?
- Below what temperature is grey tin the stable form?
Answers
- sp². The layers are held by weak van der Waals forces, which is why they slide.
- White phosphorus. It ignites spontaneously in air at about 30 °C; water excludes oxygen. It does not react with water.
- 13.2 °C. Above that temperature white (β) tin is stable.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The number of hexagons in the fullerene C₈₄ is:
(a) 12 (b) 30 (c) 32 (d) 42
Answer: (c) 32
Every fullerene has 12 pentagons. Hexagons \( = n/2 - 10 = 84/2 - 10 = 32 \).
Check with Euler’s formula \( V - E + F = 2 \): \( V = 84 \), \( E = 3 \times 84/2 = 126 \), \( F = 12 + 32 = 44 \); \( 84 - 126 + 44 = 2 \). Option (a) is the pentagon count; (d) is \( n/2 \).
Practice Q2. Which pair consists of two forms that contain the same molecular unit?
(a) diamond and C₆₀ (b) rhombic and monoclinic sulfur (c) white and red phosphorus (d) O₂ and O₃
Answer: (b)
Rhombic (α) and monoclinic (β) sulfur both consist of cyclo-S₈ molecules packed differently. Diamond is a network and C₆₀ a molecule; red phosphorus is a polymer, not P₄; O₂ and O₃ are different molecules.
Practice Q3. The correct statement about the allotropes of carbon is:
(a) diamond conducts electricity because every carbon is sp³ hybridised (b) graphite is denser than diamond (c) high pressure favours the conversion of graphite into diamond (d) C₆₀ contains 12 hexagons and 20 pentagons
Answer: (c)
Diamond (about 3.51 g cm⁻³) is denser than graphite (about 2.26 g cm⁻³), so the graphite → diamond change has negative \( \Delta V \) and pressure drives it forward.
(a) Diamond is an insulator: all electrons are localised in σ bonds. (b) Reversed. (d) Reversed: 12 pentagons and 20 hexagons.
Practice Q4. Nitrogen exists as N₂ whereas phosphorus exists as P₄ because:
(a) phosphorus is more electronegative than nitrogen (b) the P≡P bond is stronger than three P–P bonds (c) nitrogen forms strong \( p\pi\text{–}p\pi \) bonds, whereas for phosphorus several σ bonds are worth more than π bonds (d) nitrogen has vacant d orbitals
Answer: (c)
Approximate bond energies: N≡N 945 against 3 × N–N ≈ 480 kJ mol⁻¹ (multiple bonds win); P≡P ≈ 490 against 3 × P–P ≈ 600 kJ mol⁻¹ (single bonds win). (a) is false; (b) is the reverse of the truth for P; (d) nitrogen has no low-lying d orbitals.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. At 298 K, \( \Delta G^\circ \) for C(graphite) → C(diamond) is +2.9 kJ mol⁻¹. Taking the densities as 2.26 (graphite) and 3.51 g cm⁻³ (diamond), independent of pressure, the minimum pressure at which diamond becomes the stable form at 298 K is closest to:
(a) 1.5 × 10⁵ bar (b) 1.5 × 10⁴ bar (c) 1.5 × 10³ bar (d) 2.9 × 10³ bar
Answer: (b) about 1.5 × 10⁴ bar
Molar volumes: \( V(\text{graphite}) = 12.011/2.26 = 5.31 \) cm³ mol⁻¹; \( V(\text{diamond}) = 12.011/3.51 = 3.42 \) cm³ mol⁻¹. So \( \Delta V = -1.89 \) cm³ mol⁻¹ \( = -1.89 \times 10^{-6} \) m³ mol⁻¹.
For an incompressible solid, \( \Delta G(p) = \Delta G^\circ + \Delta V\,(p - p^\circ) \). Setting \( \Delta G = 0 \):
$$p \approx \frac{2900\ \text{J mol}^{-1}}{1.89 \times 10^{-6}\ \text{m}^3\ \text{mol}^{-1}} = 1.53 \times 10^9\ \text{Pa} \approx 1.5 \times 10^4\ \text{bar}$$That is about 1.5 GPa at 298 K. Industrial synthesis uses higher pressures and high temperature because the rate, not the thermodynamics, is the obstacle. (a) slips a factor of 10 in the unit conversion (1 bar = 10⁵ Pa).
Practice Q6. Diamond crystallises in a cubic cell of edge 356.7 pm containing 8 carbon atoms. Which pair of values (C–C distance, density) is correct? (\( N_A = 6.022 \times 10^{23} \) mol⁻¹, C = 12.011)
(a) 154 pm, 3.52 g cm⁻³ (b) 178 pm, 3.52 g cm⁻³ (c) 154 pm, 1.76 g cm⁻³ (d) 126 pm, 2.26 g cm⁻³
Answer: (a)
In the diamond lattice each atom touches its neighbour along one quarter of the body diagonal: \( d = a\sqrt{3}/4 = 356.7 \times 1.732/4 = 154.5 \) pm.
Density \( = \dfrac{8 \times 12.011}{6.022 \times 10^{23} \times (356.7 \times 10^{-10}\ \text{cm})^3} = 3.52 \) g cm⁻³.
(b) uses \( a/2 \); (c) uses 4 atoms per cell (fcc count without the extra tetrahedral-site atoms); (d) is graphite’s density with a wrong distance.
Practice Q7. Consider the statements:
- Liquid sulfur becomes more viscous on heating above about 159 °C because S₈ rings open into long chains.
- Rhombic sulfur and monoclinic sulfur are related by monotropy.
- S₂ in the vapour is paramagnetic.
- Black phosphorus is thermodynamically more stable than white phosphorus.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
- Correct. Ring-opening polymerisation gives long chains that entangle; the viscosity rises steeply.
- Wrong. They interconvert reversibly at a definite transition temperature (about 96 °C) below the melting point: enantiotropy.
- Correct. S₂ is isovalent with O₂: two unpaired electrons in degenerate π* orbitals, a triplet ground state.
- Correct. Stability order black > red > white.
Quick Revision Table
| Element | Allotropes and key fact |
|---|---|
| Carbon | diamond (sp³, 154 pm, insulator, denser), graphite (sp², 142 pm, conductor, standard state), C₆₀ (\( I_h \), 12 pentagons + 20 hexagons), C₇₀ (\( D_{5h} \), 25 hexagons), graphene, nanotubes |
| Fullerene count | pentagons 12; hexagons \( n/2 - 10 \); edges \( 3n/2 \) |
| Graphite → diamond | \( \Delta_f G^\circ = +2.9 \) kJ mol⁻¹; \( \Delta V < 0 \), pressure favours diamond |
| Boron | all forms built from B₁₂ icosahedra; β-rhombohedral most stable |
| Phosphorus | white P₄ (60°, reactive, CS₂-soluble), red (polymer), black (layers, most stable), violet (Hittorf) |
| Sulfur | rhombic S₈ (< 96 °C) ⇌ monoclinic S₈ (96–119 °C), S₆, plastic chains, S₂ paramagnetic; viscosity jump near 159 °C |
| Oxygen | O₂ paramagnetic; O₃ bent (117°), diamagnetic, endothermic |
| Selenium | grey trigonal (helical chains, photoconductor) most stable; red Se₈ |
| Tin | grey α (diamond lattice) below 13.2 °C; white β (metal) above; tin pest |
| Types | enantiotropy (S, Sn), monotropy (P, C), dynamic (liquid S) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- s-Block and Group 13 Compounds: Hydrides, Oxides, Boranes and Borazine: the multicentre bonding that boron’s icosahedra hinted at.
- Groups 14 and 15: Silicates, Silicones, Nitrogen and Phosphorus Compounds: SiO₂ polymorphs and the structures built on them.
- Main Group Elements: Quick Revision.
- Everyday materials from the same elements, at Part A level: Chemistry of Everyday Materials.