IR and Raman Activity: Selection Rules
CSIR NET chemistry: IR and Raman gross and specific rules, rotational Raman (ΔJ = ±2), nuclear-spin statistics, Stokes/anti-Stokes ratios, mutual exclusion.
- 18 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Molecule That IR Cannot See
- Gross and Specific Selection Rules
- IR Activity
- Raman Scattering: Where It Comes From
- Rotational Raman Spectra
- Vibrational Raman Spectra
- Polyatomic Molecules: Counting and Assigning Modes
- IR and Raman Side by Side
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Rotational Spectra of Diatomic Molecules and Vibrational Spectra of Diatomic Molecules: rotational constant B, \( \Delta J = \pm 1 \), \( \Delta v = \pm 1 \), and the Boltzmann populations of levels.
- Point groups and character tables from Chemical Applications of Group Theory, especially its Selection Rules page: a mode’s symmetry label decides its activity.
- Spin and exchange symmetry from Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum, needed for nuclear-spin statistics.
The Hook: The Molecule That IR Cannot See
Gross and Specific Selection Rules
Every spectroscopic transition obeys two kinds of rule:
- A gross selection rule says which molecules (or which modes) can show a spectrum at all. It is a statement about a molecular property: a dipole, a polarisability, a magnetic moment.
- A specific selection rule says which changes of quantum number are allowed (\( \Delta J \), \( \Delta v \), \( \Delta S \)).
Both come from the transition moment integral. For electric-dipole absorption from state i to state f,
$$\boldsymbol{\mu}_{fi} = \int \psi_f^*\,\hat{\boldsymbol{\mu}}\,\psi_i\,d\tau$$The transition is allowed if this integral is non-zero, and its intensity is proportional to \( |\boldsymbol{\mu}_{fi}|^2 \). Group theory turns this into a fast test: the integral can be non-zero only if the direct product \( \Gamma(\psi_f) \times \Gamma(\hat\mu) \times \Gamma(\psi_i) \) contains the totally symmetric representation.
IR Activity
Gross rule. A vibration is IR active if the dipole moment changes along the vibrational coordinate: \( (\partial\mu/\partial Q)_0 \neq 0 \). The molecule need not have a permanent dipole. CO₂ has none, but its antisymmetric stretch and bend each create an oscillating dipole and both absorb strongly.
Specific rules. \( \Delta v = \pm 1 \) in the harmonic limit (overtones and combinations weakly allowed by anharmonicity). For a diatomic in a ¹Σ state, \( \Delta J = \pm 1 \) accompanies the vibrational change.
Symmetry rule. Starting from the totally symmetric v = 0 level, a fundamental is IR active if the mode belongs to the same irreducible representation as x, y or z.
Raman Scattering: Where It Comes From
When light of frequency \( \nu_0 \) falls on a molecule, its electric field \( E = E_0\cos 2\pi\nu_0 t \) induces a dipole
$$\mu_{\text{ind}} = \alpha E$$where α is the polarisability (how easily the electron cloud is distorted). If α itself oscillates with a vibration of frequency \( \nu_{\text{vib}} \), \( \alpha = \alpha_0 + (\partial\alpha/\partial Q)_0 Q_0\cos 2\pi\nu_{\text{vib}}t \), then
$$\mu_{\text{ind}} = \alpha_0E_0\cos 2\pi\nu_0t + \tfrac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\partial\alpha}{\partial Q}\right)_0 Q_0E_0\left[\cos 2\pi(\nu_0 - \nu_{\text{vib}})t + \cos 2\pi(\nu_0 + \nu_{\text{vib}})t\right]$$Three frequencies are radiated:
| Line | Frequency | Origin |
|---|---|---|
| Rayleigh | \( \nu_0 \) | elastic scattering; by far the strongest |
| Stokes | \( \nu_0 - \nu_{\text{vib}} \) | molecule left in a higher level |
| Anti-Stokes | \( \nu_0 + \nu_{\text{vib}} \) | molecule started in an excited level and gave energy to the photon |
The term exists only if \( (\partial\alpha/\partial Q)_0 \neq 0 \). That is the gross selection rule. The same argument with rotation in place of vibration gives rotational Raman lines, provided α is different along different directions in the molecule (an anisotropic polarisability), so that rotation modulates the induced dipole.
- Vibrational Raman: the polarisability must change during the vibration.
- Rotational Raman: the polarisability must be anisotropic. All linear molecules (including H₂, N₂, CO₂) and symmetric tops qualify; spherical tops (CH₄, SF₆, CCl₄) do not.
Symmetry rule. A fundamental is Raman active if the mode belongs to the same irreducible representation as a quadratic function (x², y², z², xy, xz, yz or combinations), because α is a second-rank tensor.
Practical points
- The Raman shift \( \tilde\nu_0 - \tilde\nu_{\text{scattered}} \) does not depend on the laser wavelength; the absolute scattered wavenumber does.
- Scattered intensity grows roughly as the fourth power of the scattered frequency, so shorter-wavelength lasers give stronger signals (at the cost of more fluorescence).
- Water is a weak Raman scatterer but a strong IR absorber, so aqueous solutions are easily studied by Raman.
- Raman measures the same vibrational energies as IR; only the activity rules differ.
Rotational Raman Spectra
Specific rule for a linear molecule:
$$\boxed{\Delta J = 0, \pm 2}$$The process involves two photons (one absorbed, one scattered), each carrying one unit of angular momentum; equivalently, α changes twice per rotation, because a polarisability ellipsoid looks the same after a half-turn. \( \Delta J = 0 \) is just Rayleigh scattering. For symmetric tops \( \Delta J = \pm 1 \) is also allowed (with \( \Delta K = 0 \)); for linear molecules it is not.
For \( \Delta J = +2 \) (Stokes, S branch):
$$\tilde\nu = \tilde\nu_0 - [F(J+2) - F(J)] = \tilde\nu_0 - B(4J + 6), \qquad J = 0, 1, 2, \ldots$$Anti-Stokes lines (\( \Delta J = -2 \)) sit symmetrically at \( \tilde\nu_0 + B(4J + 6) \).
$$\boxed{\text{Raman shifts: } 6B,\ 10B,\ 14B,\ \ldots \qquad \text{spacing } 4B, \qquad \text{first line at } 6B}$$Compare microwave: lines at 2B, 4B, 6B with spacing 2B. Getting this factor right is half the marks in rotational Raman questions.
Nuclear-spin statistics: alternating intensities
In a homonuclear diatomic (or a centrosymmetric linear molecule such as CO₂), exchanging the two identical nuclei must leave the total wavefunction symmetric (bosons, integer I) or antisymmetric (fermions, half-integer I). Rotational levels of even and odd J have opposite exchange symmetry, so each can pair only with nuclear-spin functions of one symmetry. Of the \( (2I + 1)^2 \) nuclear spin functions, \( (I + 1)(2I + 1) \) are symmetric and \( I(2I + 1) \) antisymmetric, so the two sets of J levels carry statistical weights in the ratio \( (I + 1) : I \).
| Molecule (ground state) | Nuclear spin I | Which J levels favoured | Intensity ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| H₂ (¹Σg⁺) | 1/2 (fermions) | odd J (ortho) | odd : even = 3 : 1 |
| ¹⁹F₂ (¹Σg⁺) | 1/2 | odd J | odd : even = 3 : 1 |
| D₂ (¹Σg⁺) | 1 (bosons) | even J (ortho) | even : odd = 2 : 1 |
| ¹⁴N₂ (¹Σg⁺) | 1 | even J | even : odd = 2 : 1 |
| ¹⁶O₂ (³Σg⁻) | 0 | only odd J exist | alternate lines missing |
| ¹²C¹⁶O₂ (¹Σg⁺) | 0 for ¹⁶O | only even J exist | alternate lines missing |
| ¹⁶O¹⁸O, ¹⁴N¹⁵N | nuclei not identical | all J | no alternation |
In a Raman S branch each line is labelled by its lower J, so line intensity alternates exactly as the populations of J alternate. When one set of levels is missing entirely (¹⁶O₂, CO₂), every other line vanishes and the remaining lines are 8B apart.
Vibrational Raman Spectra
Specific rule: \( \Delta v = \pm 1 \) (harmonic), as for IR. For a diatomic the rotational structure obeys \( \Delta J = 0, \pm 2 \), giving three branches:
| Branch | \( \Delta J \) | Appearance |
|---|---|---|
| O | −2 | weak, low-shift side |
| Q | 0 | strong, sharp, at the vibrational Raman shift |
| S | +2 | weak, high-shift side |
In liquids and solutions the rotational structure is washed out, and only the Q-like band at the vibrational shift is seen.
Stokes and anti-Stokes intensities
Anti-Stokes lines start from v = 1, so they are weaker by the Boltzmann factor, with a correction for the \( \nu^4 \) scattering law:
$$\boxed{\frac{I_{\text{anti-Stokes}}}{I_{\text{Stokes}}} = \left(\frac{\tilde\nu_0 + \tilde\nu_{\text{vib}}}{\tilde\nu_0 - \tilde\nu_{\text{vib}}}\right)^4 \exp\left(-\frac{hc\tilde\nu_{\text{vib}}}{kT}\right)}$$The ratio grows with temperature and falls steeply for high-wavenumber modes. Measuring it is a non-contact thermometer (used for hot gases, flames and laser-heated samples).
Polyatomic Molecules: Counting and Assigning Modes
A molecule of N atoms has \( 3N - 6 \) normal modes (\( 3N - 5 \) if linear). Each mode is classified by symmetry; its IR and Raman activity follows from the character table. Two classic triatomics:
| Molecule | Mode | Approx. wavenumber (cm⁻¹) | IR | Raman |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CO₂ (\( D_{\infty h} \)) | \( \nu_1 \) symmetric stretch (\( \Sigma_g^+ \)) | 1388 and 1285 (Fermi doublet) | no | yes (polarised) |
| \( \nu_2 \) bend (\( \Pi_u \), doubly degenerate) | 667 | yes | no | |
| \( \nu_3 \) antisymmetric stretch (\( \Sigma_u^+ \)) | 2349 | yes | no | |
| H₂O (\( C_{2v} \)) | \( \nu_1 \) symmetric stretch (\( A_1 \)) | 3657 | yes | yes (polarised) |
| \( \nu_2 \) bend (\( A_1 \)) | 1595 | yes | yes | |
| \( \nu_3 \) antisymmetric stretch (\( B_2 \)) | 3756 | yes | yes |
The CO₂ symmetric stretch appears in Raman as two bands because it lies close to the overtone of the bend (\( 2 \times 667 \)); the two states of the same symmetry mix and push apart. This is Fermi resonance, and it lends the overtone intensity it would not otherwise have.
Mutual exclusion
The useful converse: a band that appears at the same wavenumber in IR and Raman proves the molecule has no inversion centre. Linear CO₂ (centrosymmetric) shows no coincidences; linear N₂O (N–N–O, no centre) shows bands active in both, which is how its unsymmetrical structure is confirmed.
For counting tables of common shapes (AB₂, AB₃, AB₄, AB₆) and metal carbonyl ν(CO) bands, see IR and Raman Spectroscopy of Inorganic Compounds.
Depolarisation ratio
With plane-polarised laser light, measure the scattered intensity polarised perpendicular and parallel to the incident polarisation: \( \rho = I_\perp/I_\parallel \).
- Totally symmetric modes: \( 0 \le \rho < 3/4 \) (polarised).
- All other modes: \( \rho = 3/4 \) (depolarised).
(With unpolarised excitation the limiting value is 6/7.) A polarised band is therefore an immediate assignment to the totally symmetric representation.
graph TD
A["Mode or molecule"] --> B{"Does the dipole change?"}
B -->|yes| C["IR active"]
B -->|no| D["IR inactive"]
A --> E{"Does the polarisability change?"}
E -->|yes| F["Raman active"]
E -->|no| G["Raman inactive"]
C --> H{"Centre of inversion?"}
F --> H
H -->|yes| I["No mode in both:
mutual exclusion"]
H -->|no| J["Coincidences possible"]IR and Raman Side by Side
| Feature | IR absorption | Raman scattering |
|---|---|---|
| Event | photon absorbed | photon inelastically scattered |
| Gross rule (vibration) | dipole changes | polarisability changes |
| Gross rule (rotation) | permanent dipole | anisotropic polarisability |
| Symmetry rule | mode transforms as x, y, z | mode transforms as quadratic function |
| Rotational specific rule (linear) | \( \Delta J = \pm 1 \) | \( \Delta J = 0, \pm 2 \) |
| Pure rotational spacing | 2B, first line 2B | 4B, first line 6B |
| Vibrational structure of diatomic | P, R (no Q for ¹Σ) | O, Q, S (strong Q) |
| Homonuclear diatomics | inactive | active |
| Water as solvent | poor | good |
| Source | broadband IR | monochromatic laser (visible or near-IR) |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Permanent dipole: needed for microwave | changing dipole: needed for IR vibration | |
| Microwave lines: 2B, 4B, 6B | rotational Raman shifts: 6B, 10B, 14B | |
| Raman shift: independent of laser | scattered wavenumber: depends on laser | |
| Stokes: lower frequency, stronger | anti-Stokes: higher frequency, weaker, grows with T | |
| Mutual exclusion: centrosymmetric only | tetrahedral, C₃ᵥ, C₂ᵥ molecules: coincidences allowed | |
| Polarised: ρ < 3/4, totally symmetric | depolarised: ρ = 3/4 | |
| ¹⁶O₂: only odd J exist | CO₂: only even J exist |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- State the specific selection rule for the rotational Raman spectrum of a linear molecule.
- Which of H₂, HCl and CH₄ give a rotational Raman spectrum?
- Why is the anti-Stokes line weaker than the Stokes line?
Answers
- \( \Delta J = 0, \pm 2 \) (\( \Delta J = 0 \) is the Rayleigh line).
- H₂ and HCl (both linear, anisotropic polarisability). CH₄ is a spherical top: no rotational Raman spectrum.
- It starts from an excited level, whose population is smaller by the Boltzmann factor \( e^{-hc\tilde\nu/kT} \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The pure rotational Raman spectrum of a homonuclear diatomic shows Stokes lines equally spaced by 7.96 cm⁻¹ (no missing lines). The first Stokes line lies from the exciting line at:
(a) 3.98 cm⁻¹ (b) 7.96 cm⁻¹ (c) 11.94 cm⁻¹ (d) 15.92 cm⁻¹
Answer: (c) 11.94 cm⁻¹
Spacing 4B = 7.96, so B = 1.99 cm⁻¹; the first line is at 6B = 11.94 cm⁻¹. (These numbers are close to N₂.)
Practice Q2. For CO₂, the IR-active fundamentals are:
(a) symmetric stretch only (b) bend and antisymmetric stretch (c) symmetric and antisymmetric stretches (d) all three
Answer: (b)
The bend (\( \Pi_u \)) and antisymmetric stretch (\( \Sigma_u^+ \)) change the dipole. The symmetric stretch (\( \Sigma_g^+ \)) keeps it zero; it is Raman active only, as mutual exclusion requires.
Practice Q3. In the rotational Raman spectrum of H₂, the intensity ratio of lines originating from odd J to those from even J (at high temperature) is about:
(a) 1 : 1 (b) 1 : 3 (c) 2 : 1 (d) 3 : 1
Answer: (d) 3 : 1
Protons are fermions with I = 1/2. Odd-J (antisymmetric rotational function) levels pair with the three symmetric nuclear spin functions (ortho); even-J levels with the single antisymmetric one (para). Ratio 3 : 1, modulated by the Boltzmann populations.
Practice Q4. A Raman band of a molecule has depolarisation ratio 0.05 under plane-polarised excitation. The band belongs to:
(a) a doubly degenerate mode (b) a non-totally symmetric mode (c) a totally symmetric mode (d) an IR-active mode of a centrosymmetric molecule
Answer: (c)
ρ < 3/4 means polarised, which only a totally symmetric mode can be. (d) is impossible: in a centrosymmetric molecule IR-active modes are u and cannot be Raman active at all.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. CCl₄ is excited at 532 nm (18 797 cm⁻¹). Consider its 459 cm⁻¹ band (\( hc/k = 1.4388 \) cm K). Which statements are correct?
- At 300 K, \( I_{\text{anti-Stokes}}/I_{\text{Stokes}} \approx 0.13 \).
- Ignoring the frequency-to-the-fourth factor would underestimate this ratio.
- At 600 K the ratio would be about 0.40.
- The band is polarised, so it belongs to the \( A_1 \) symmetric stretch.
(a) 1 and 4 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- Boltzmann factor \( \exp(-459 \times 1.4388/300) = 0.111 \); frequency factor \( (19\,256/18\,338)^4 = 1.216 \). Ratio = 0.135. Correct.
- Without the \( \nu^4 \) factor the ratio is 0.111, smaller: correct (the anti-Stokes photon has the higher frequency and scatters more efficiently).
- \( \exp(-459 \times 1.4388/600) = 0.333 \); × 1.216 = 0.40. Correct.
- Given that the band is polarised, it must be totally symmetric; in \( T_d \) CCl₄ that is the \( A_1 \) C–Cl stretch. Correct.
Practice Q6. Consider the Raman and IR spectra of ¹⁶O₂ and ¹⁶O¹⁸O gases. Which statements are correct?
- The pure rotational Raman spectrum of ¹⁶O₂ shows only half the lines expected for a heteronuclear diatomic of the same B.
- The vibrational fundamental of ¹⁶O₂ is IR inactive but Raman active.
- ¹⁶O¹⁸O shows no intensity alternation in its rotational Raman spectrum.
- ¹⁶O¹⁸O has a strong IR fundamental because the two atoms have different masses.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 4 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- ¹⁶O has I = 0, and with the ³Σg⁻ ground state only odd-J levels exist: every other Raman line is missing. Correct.
- Homonuclear: no dipole change, IR inactive; polarisability changes, Raman active. Correct.
- The nuclei are no longer identical, so no exchange restriction: all J levels, no alternation. Correct.
- Wrong. Isotopic substitution changes masses, not the electron distribution. ¹⁶O¹⁸O is symmetric in charge, so its dipole moment stays (essentially) zero during vibration. It is IR inactive to a very good approximation.
Practice Q7. A triatomic AB₂ molecule gives these fundamentals: IR bands at 2349 and 667 cm⁻¹; a Raman band at 1340 cm⁻¹ (polarised). No band appears in both spectra. Which conclusions follow?
- The molecule is linear and symmetric (B–A–B).
- The 667 cm⁻¹ band is a doubly degenerate bend.
- A bent AB₂ molecule would have shown at least one band in both spectra.
- The molecule has four normal modes.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- No coincidences: consistent with an inversion centre, which for AB₂ requires the linear symmetric shape. Correct.
- Linear AB₂ has \( 3(3) - 5 = 4 \) modes: symmetric stretch, antisymmetric stretch and a doubly degenerate bend (one band). The lowest IR band is the bend. Correct.
- Bent AB₂ (\( C_{2v} \)) has three modes, all both IR and Raman active. Correct.
- 3N − 5 = 4 (counting the degenerate pair as two). Correct.
(The data are modelled on CO₂, whose symmetric stretch actually appears as a Fermi doublet near 1285 and 1388 cm⁻¹.)
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Transition moment | allowed if \( \int\psi_f^*\hat\mu\psi_i\,d\tau \neq 0 \) |
| IR (vibration) | dipole changes; mode transforms as x, y, z |
| Raman (vibration) | polarisability changes; mode transforms as quadratic function |
| Raman (rotation) | anisotropic α: linear molecules, symmetric tops; not spherical tops |
| Rotational Raman rule | \( \Delta J = 0, \pm 2 \) (linear) |
| Rotational Raman lines | shifts \( B(4J + 6) \): 6B, 10B, 14B…; spacing 4B |
| Nuclear-spin weights | \( (I + 1) : I \); H₂ odd : even 3 : 1; N₂, D₂ even : odd 2 : 1; ¹⁶O₂ odd only; CO₂ even only |
| Vibrational Raman | \( \Delta v = \pm 1 \); O, Q, S branches; Q strongest |
| Anti-Stokes/Stokes | \( [(\tilde\nu_0 + \tilde\nu_v)/(\tilde\nu_0 - \tilde\nu_v)]^4 e^{-hc\tilde\nu_v/kT} \) |
| Modes | 3N − 6 (3N − 5 linear) |
| CO₂ | 2349 (IR), 667 (IR), 1388/1285 (Raman, Fermi doublet) |
| H₂O | 3657, 1595, 3756: all IR and Raman |
| Mutual exclusion | inversion centre ⇒ no mode both IR and Raman |
| Depolarisation | ρ < 3/4 totally symmetric; ρ = 3/4 others |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Electronic Spectra of Molecules: term symbols of diatomics, electronic selection rules, the Franck–Condon principle and what happens after absorption.
- Applications to inorganic structures (band counts for carbonyl isomers, oxyanion binding modes): IR and Raman Spectroscopy of Inorganic Compounds.
- Back to the chapter overview or the chapter quick revision.