Skip to content

Anionic, Sigmatropic and Aromatic Rearrangements

CSIR NET organic chemistry: Favorskii, Ramberg–Bäcklund, Stevens, Sommelet–Hauser, Wittig, Brook, Claisen, Cope, Fries, benzidine and Pummerer rearrangements.

  • 18 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 14 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Where Did the Labelled Carbon Go?
  3. Base-Promoted Rearrangements via Carbanions
  4. Sigmatropic Rearrangements: Claisen and Cope Families
  5. Aromatic Rearrangements
  6. The Pummerer Rearrangement
  7. Classification at a Glance
  8. Memory Tricks
  9. Don’t Confuse
  10. Common Mistakes
  11. Practice
  12. Quick Revision Table
  13. Key Takeaways
  14. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Where Did the Labelled Carbon Go?

Base-Promoted Rearrangements via Carbanions

Favorskii rearrangement

An α-halo ketone with an α′-hydrogen + base (alkoxide, hydroxide or amine) gives a carboxylic acid derivative (ester, acid, amide) with a rearranged carbon skeleton.

$$\text{2-chlorocyclohexanone} \xrightarrow{\text{NaOMe, MeOH}} \text{methyl cyclopentanecarboxylate}$$

Mechanism:

  1. Base removes the α′-proton (on the other side of the carbonyl from the halogen) to form an enolate.
  2. The enolate displaces halide internally to give a cyclopropanone.
  3. Alkoxide adds to the cyclopropanone carbonyl.
  4. The three-membered ring opens to give the more stable carbanion (the less substituted one, or one stabilised by phenyl), which is protonated.

Consequences:

  • Cyclic α-halo ketones contract by one carbon (the classic route to cyclopentane carboxylic acids from cyclohexanones, and a key step in the cubane synthesis).
  • Isotopic evidence: with ¹⁴C split equally between C-1 (C=O) and C-2 (C–Cl) of 2-chlorocyclohexanone, the ester carbonyl carbon carries half of the label and the other half is shared equally between the ring carbon bearing the ester and its ring neighbour (25% each). That is what a symmetrical cyclopropanone, in which C-2 and C-6 are equivalent, requires; a direct 1,2-shift without the cyclopropanone would not scramble the C-2 label.
  • Two isomeric α-halo ketones that give the same cyclopropanone give the same product: 1-chloro-3-phenylpropan-2-one and 1-chloro-1-phenylpropan-2-one both give the 3-phenylpropanoate (ring opening to the benzylic carbanion).
  • Quasi-Favorskii (semibenzilic) rearrangement: with no α′-H, no cyclopropanone can form. Base adds to the carbonyl and a group migrates with expulsion of halide, as in the benzilic acid mechanism.

Ramberg–Bäcklund reaction

An α-halo sulfone + strong base gives an alkene with loss of SO₂:

  1. Base deprotonates the α′-carbon of the sulfone.
  2. The carbanion displaces halide internally to form a three-membered episulfone (thiirane 1,1-dioxide).
  3. The episulfone extrudes SO₂ cheletropically to give the alkene.

The new C=C forms between the two carbons that were attached to sulfur. With KOH/CCl₄ (Meyers modification) the α-halogenation is done in situ. Cyclic sulfones give ring-contracted cycloalkenes, and strained alkenes can be made this way.

Stevens rearrangement ([1,2])

A quaternary ammonium (or sulfonium) salt with an acidifying group (C=O, aryl) on one α-carbon + strong base forms an ylide; a group on the heteroatom then migrates to the carbanion carbon, giving a tertiary amine (or sulfide):

$$\text{PhCOCH}_2\text{N}^+(\text{CH}_3)_2\text{CH}_2\text{Ph} \xrightarrow{\text{NaOH}} \text{PhCOCH(CH}_2\text{Ph)N(CH}_3)_2$$
  • Mechanism: homolysis to a radical pair held in the solvent cage, then recombination (a concerted [1,2] shift is symmetry-forbidden).
  • The migrating group is retained in configuration (fast in-cage recombination), but CIDNP signals and small amounts of crossover products betray the radical pair.
  • Migratory aptitude follows radical stability: allyl ≈ benzyl > tertiary alkyl > secondary > primary > methyl.

Sommelet–Hauser rearrangement ([2,3])

A benzyl quaternary ammonium salt + NaNH₂ in liquid NH₃ gives an ortho-substituted benzyl amine:

$$\text{PhCH}_2\text{N}^+(\text{CH}_3)_3 \xrightarrow{\text{NaNH}_2,\ \text{NH}_3} 2\text{-CH}_3\text{C}_6\text{H}_4\text{CH}_2\text{N(CH}_3)_2$$
  1. The benzylic ylide forms first (most acidic) and is in equilibrium with the methyl ylide CH₂⁻–N⁺.
  2. The methyl ylide undergoes a [2,3]-sigmatropic shift onto the ortho ring carbon, dearomatising the ring.
  3. Tautomerisation (H shift) restores aromaticity.

The product can be re-methylated (MeI) and the reaction repeated to place a further methyl group on the other ortho position. Stevens and Sommelet–Hauser compete: high temperature and aprotic conditions favour Stevens; NaNH₂/NH₃ at low temperature favours Sommelet–Hauser.

Wittig rearrangements of ethers

RearrangementSubstrateBaseMechanismProduct
[1,2]-Wittigbenzyl or allyl ether R–O–CH₂ArRLi (n-BuLi, PhLi)carbanion α to O, radical pair (like Stevens)secondary/tertiary alcohol ArCH(R)OH
[2,3]-Wittigallyl ether with a carbanion-stabilising group on the other α-carbonn-BuLi, low temperature (−78 to −60 °C)concerted five-membered envelope TShomoallylic alcohol

The [2,3]-Wittig gives mainly the E-alkene and transfers chirality from the allylic carbon; at higher temperature the [1,2] path competes. Migratory aptitude in the [1,2]-Wittig follows radical stability (allyl, benzyl > tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl).

Mislow–Evans rearrangement

An allylic sulfoxide is in equilibrium, through a [2,3]-sigmatropic shift, with an allylic sulfenate ester. A thiophile (P(OMe)₃, a secondary amine) cleaves the S–O bond to give an allylic alcohol with allylic transposition and usually E geometry. Allylic selenoxides do the same faster.

Brook rearrangement

Silyl migration from carbon to oxygen: an α-silyl alkoxide R₂C(SiR₃)–O⁻ rearranges to the silyl ether carbanion R₂C⁻–O–SiR₃. The driving force is the strong Si–O bond (much stronger than Si–C). The reaction is favoured when the carbanion formed is stabilised (aryl, ester) and by polar solvents and counter-ions that leave the alkoxide “free” (K⁺ more than Li⁺). The retro-Brook (O → C) occurs when the carbanion is unstable and Li⁺ binds the alkoxide tightly. Related [1,4]- and [1,5]-Brook shifts relay anions through a molecule (anion relay chemistry).

Sigmatropic Rearrangements: Claisen and Cope Families

A [i,j]-sigmatropic shift moves a σ-bond across a π-system; the bond that breaks is between atoms 1 and 1′, and the new bond forms between atom i of one fragment and atom j of the other. The [3,3] shifts run thermally through a six-membered, chair-like transition state (suprafacial on both components); full orbital-symmetry treatment belongs to the pericyclic unit.

Aliphatic Claisen rearrangement

An allyl vinyl ether heated rearranges to a γ,δ-unsaturated carbonyl compound:

$$\text{CH}_2{=}\text{CH–O–CH}_2\text{–CH}{=}\text{CH}_2 \xrightarrow{\Delta,\ [3,3]} \text{O}{=}\text{CH–CH}_2\text{–CH}_2\text{–CH}{=}\text{CH}_2$$
  • Driving force: C=O (strong) formed at the expense of C=C.
  • Chair transition state: substituents prefer pseudo-equatorial positions, so the new C=C is mainly E, and the relative configuration at new stereocentres follows the alkene geometries (E,E and Z,Z give one diastereomer; E,Z the other).
  • Chirality at the allylic ether carbon is transferred to the new C–C bond (1,3-chirality transfer).

Aromatic Claisen rearrangement

Allyl aryl ether → 2-allylphenol (the hook):

  1. [3,3] shift to the ortho carbon, with allyl inversion (C-3 of allyl bonds to the ring).
  2. The dienone tautomerises to the phenol.

If both ortho positions are substituted, the dienone cannot tautomerise. A second [3,3] shift (a Cope) moves the allyl group to the para carbon, inverting it a second time. Net result: para-allylphenol with the allyl group not inverted (label back at the terminal position relative to the start).

Variants worth knowing

VariantStarting materialReagentProduct
Johnson–Claisenallylic alcoholtriethyl orthoacetate, catalytic propanoic acid, heatγ,δ-unsaturated ester
Ireland–Claisenallyl esterLDA, then TMSCl (silyl ketene acetal), warm to room temperatureγ,δ-unsaturated carboxylic acid (after hydrolysis of the silyl ester); enolate geometry (set by THF vs THF/HMPA) controls the diastereomer
Eschenmoser–Claisenallylic alcoholN,N-dimethylacetamide dimethyl acetal, heatγ,δ-unsaturated amide
Carrollallyl β-keto esterheat (or base)γ,δ-unsaturated ketone after decarboxylation

The Ireland–Claisen runs under the mildest conditions because the silyl ketene acetal is an electron-rich “vinyl ether” that rearranges near room temperature.

Cope rearrangement

A 1,5-diene heated rearranges by a [3,3] shift to an isomeric 1,5-diene. The equilibrium lies on the side of the more substituted or conjugated diene, or the less strained one.

Stereochemistry through the chair TS (a classic Part C test):

3,4-Dimethylhexa-1,5-dieneMajor octa-2,6-diene
meso(2E,6Z) almost exclusively
racemic (dl)mainly (2E,6E), with a little (2Z,6Z) from the alternative chair

The meso isomer cannot place both methyls equatorial in a chair: one is axial and one equatorial, giving one E and one Z double bond. The dl isomer places both equatorial (E,E) or both axial (Z,Z, disfavoured).

Variants:

  • Oxy-Cope: a 3-hydroxy-1,5-diene gives an enol, which tautomerises to a δ,ε-unsaturated carbonyl; tautomerisation makes the reaction irreversible.
  • Anionic oxy-Cope: the potassium alkoxide (KH, 18-crown-6) rearranges many orders of magnitude faster than the neutral alcohol, often at or below room temperature. Very useful for ring expansion (1,2-divinylcycloalkanols give rings four carbons larger).
  • cis-1,2-Divinylcyclopropane rearranges very easily to cyclohepta-1,4-diene (relief of ring strain; the cis isomer is required for the boat TS).
  • Degenerate Cope: a molecule that rearranges into itself, e.g. bullvalene (C₁₀H₁₀), whose ¹H NMR spectrum becomes a single averaged signal at higher temperature.
  • Aza-Cope/Mannich: a 2-aza-Cope of an iminium ion followed by an intramolecular Mannich reaction, used in alkaloid synthesis.

Aromatic Rearrangements

Fries rearrangement

An aryl ester + a Lewis acid (AlCl₃, BF₃, TiCl₄) gives ortho- and para-hydroxyaryl ketones:

$$\text{PhOCOCH}_3 \xrightarrow{\text{AlCl}_3} 2\text{-HOC}_6\text{H}_4\text{COCH}_3 + 4\text{-HOC}_6\text{H}_4\text{COCH}_3$$
  • Low temperature favours para (kinetic); high temperature favours ortho (the ortho product forms a stable bidentate aluminium chelate; thermodynamic).
  • Mechanism: the Lewis acid coordinates the ester, an acylium ion is released and acylates the ring (Friedel–Crafts type); crossover experiments show both intra- and intermolecular contributions.
  • Photo-Fries: UV light cleaves the O–C(O) bond homolytically to a radical pair in a solvent cage, which recombines at ortho and para positions; no Lewis acid needed, and deactivated rings can work.
  • The related anionic Fries (an aryl carbamate ortho-lithiated with s-BuLi, then 1,3-O→C carbamoyl migration) gives salicylamides.

Benzidine rearrangement

Hydrazobenzene (1,2-diphenylhydrazine) + strong acid gives mainly benzidine (4,4′-diaminobiphenyl), with diphenyline (2,4′-diaminobiphenyl) as the main by-product:

  • The diprotonated hydrazobenzene is the reactive species in many cases (rate often second order in acid).
  • Crossover experiments with two different hydrazobenzenes give no mixed products: the reaction is intramolecular.
  • Formation of benzidine is a concerted [5,5]-sigmatropic shift (heavy-atom kinetic isotope effects at both para carbons support this); diphenyline arises by a different path.

Bamberger rearrangement

N-Phenylhydroxylamine in aqueous H₂SO₄ gives 4-aminophenol. Loss of water from the O-protonated hydroxylamine gives a nitrenium ion (delocalised onto the para carbon), which water attacks at para. In the presence of other nucleophiles (alcohols, chloride) the corresponding para-substituted anilines form, showing that the reaction is intermolecular (solvent supplies the oxygen).

Smiles rearrangement

An intramolecular nucleophilic aromatic substitution: a nucleophile Y⁻ on a side chain attacks the ipso carbon of an activated aryl ring (ortho or para nitro, or a heteroaryl) through a spiro Meisenheimer intermediate, and the aryl group moves from X to Y. It is the key step of the Julia–Kocienski olefination. In the Truce–Smiles variant the nucleophile is a carbanion, and activation by nitro groups is not needed.

Other aromatic shifts to recognise

NameSubstrateConditionsProductIntra / inter
OrtonN-chloroacetanilideHCl2- and 4-chloroacetanilideinter (via Cl₂)
Hofmann–MartiusN-alkylanilinium halideheato- and p-alkylanilinesinter (alkyl cation or halide)
Fischer–HeppN-nitroso-N-alkylanilineHCl4-nitroso-N-alkylanilinemechanism debated

The Pummerer Rearrangement

A sulfoxide with an α-hydrogen + acetic anhydride (or TFAA) gives an α-acyloxy sulfide:

$$\text{R–S(O)–CH}_2\text{R}' \xrightarrow{\text{Ac}_2\text{O}} \text{R–S–CH(OAc)R}'$$

Acylation of the sulfoxide oxygen, loss of acetate as base removes the α-H, and the resulting thionium ion R–S⁺=CHR′ is captured by acetate. The sulfur is reduced (S(IV) to S(II)) while the α-carbon is oxidised to the aldehyde oxidation level; hydrolysis of the product gives an aldehyde.

Classification at a Glance

Mechanism typeRearrangements
Carbanion, then internal S_N2 / 3-membered ringFavorskii (cyclopropanone), Ramberg–Bäcklund (episulfone), Neber (azirine)
Ylide → radical pairStevens, [1,2]-Wittig
Ylide or carbanion, concerted [2,3]Sommelet–Hauser, [2,3]-Wittig, Mislow–Evans
Anion, silyl shift to OBrook
Concerted [3,3]Claisen (all variants), Cope, oxy-Cope, aza-Cope
Concerted [5,5]benzidine
Lewis-acid acylium / radical pairFries / photo-Fries
Nitrenium ion, solvent attackBamberger
Intramolecular S_NArSmiles
Thionium ionPummerer

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Favorskii: needs α′-H, cyclopropanoneQuasi-Favorskii: no α′-H, semibenzilic 1,2-shift
Stevens: [1,2], radical pair, migration to ylide carbonSommelet–Hauser: [2,3], concerted, migration to ortho ring carbon
[1,2]-Wittig: radical pair, higher temperature[2,3]-Wittig: concerted, low temperature, homoallylic alcohol
Claisen (aromatic): ortho, allyl invertedClaisen with both ortho blocked: para, allyl not inverted
Johnson–Claisen: orthoester → esterIreland–Claisen: allyl ester enolate → acid
Fries (Lewis acid): acylium, o/p by temperaturePhoto-Fries: radical pair, light
Benzidine: intramolecular, [5,5]Bamberger: intermolecular, nitrenium + water
Pummerer: sulfoxide → α-acyloxy sulfideMislow–Evans: allylic sulfoxide → allylic alcohol

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. What is the intermediate in the Favorskii rearrangement of 2-chlorocyclohexanone?
  2. What does heating 3-hydroxy-1,5-hexadiene (hexa-1,5-dien-3-ol) give, after tautomerisation?
  3. Which reagent pair converts an allylic alcohol into a γ,δ-unsaturated ester in one pot?
Answers
  1. A cyclopropanone (bicyclo[4.1.0]heptan-7-one), formed by internal displacement of chloride by the α′-enolate.
  2. Hex-5-enal: the oxy-Cope gives the enol of a δ,ε-unsaturated aldehyde (C=C at C5–C6 counting the CHO as C1), which tautomerises.
  3. Triethyl orthoacetate with catalytic propanoic acid (Johnson–Claisen).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. Benzyltrimethylammonium iodide is treated with NaNH₂ in liquid ammonia. The major product is:

(a) PhCH(CH₃)N(CH₃)₂ (b) 2-methylbenzyl(dimethyl)amine (c) PhCH₂CH₂N(CH₃)₂ (d) styrene + trimethylamine

Answer: (b)

Sommelet–Hauser: the methyl ylide undergoes a [2,3] shift onto the ortho ring carbon; rearomatisation gives 2-CH₃C₆H₄CH₂N(CH₃)₂. Option (a) is the Stevens product (favoured at higher temperature in aprotic media). Hofmann elimination (d) is impossible: there is no β-H on the benzyl side.

Practice Q2. 2,6-Dimethylphenyl allyl ether, in which the terminal CH₂ of the allyl group is ¹⁴C-labelled, is heated. In the product, the label is on:

(a) the ring-bonded CH₂ of an ortho-allyl group (b) the ring-bonded CH₂ of a para-allyl group (c) the terminal =CH₂ of a para-allyl group (d) the central CH of the allyl group

Answer: (c)

Both ortho positions are blocked. The first [3,3] shift moves the allyl group to the ortho carbon with inversion (label now ring-bonded). The dienone cannot tautomerise, so a Cope moves the allyl to para with a second inversion: the label returns to the terminal =CH₂. Tautomerisation then gives 4-allyl-2,6-dimethylphenol.

Practice Q3. Phenyl acetate is heated with AlCl₃ at a high temperature without solvent. The major product is:

(a) 4-hydroxyacetophenone (b) 2-hydroxyacetophenone (c) phenol + acetyl chloride (d) 4-acetoxyacetophenone

Answer: (b)

High temperature in the Fries rearrangement favours the ortho product, stabilised as an aluminium chelate. Low temperature favours para.

Practice Q4. Which reaction produces an alkene with extrusion of SO₂?

(a) Pummerer (b) Ramberg–Bäcklund (c) Mislow–Evans (d) Julia–Lythgoe

Answer: (b)

α-Halo sulfone + base → episulfone → alkene + SO₂. (The Julia–Kocienski variant also loses SO₂, but Julia–Lythgoe ends with reductive elimination of a sulfinate; Pummerer and Mislow–Evans keep sulfur in the product or by-product without forming an alkene.)

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. meso-3,4-Dimethylhexa-1,5-diene and racemic 3,4-dimethylhexa-1,5-diene are each heated to bring about the Cope rearrangement (products analysed before any re-equilibration). Assume chair transition states only. Which statements are correct?

  1. The meso isomer gives (2E,6Z)-octa-2,6-diene as the major product.
  2. The racemic isomer gives (2E,6E)-octa-2,6-diene as the major product.
  3. In the chair TS from the meso isomer, one methyl is pseudo-axial and one pseudo-equatorial.
  4. A boat TS from the meso isomer would give (2E,6E) or (2Z,6Z) products.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (c) 1 and 2 only (d) 3 and 4 only

Answer: (b) 1, 2, 3 and 4

In a chair, the relative configuration of C-3 and C-4 determines whether the methyls are both equatorial (dl, giving E,E) or one axial and one equatorial (meso, giving E,Z). The boat reverses the relationship: the meso isomer in a boat can place both methyls in equivalent positions and gives E,E (or Z,Z). The observation that meso gives almost exclusively E,Z is the classic evidence for the chair.

Practice Q6. 2-Chlorocyclohexanone with ¹⁴C at C-1 (the carbonyl carbon) only is converted to methyl cyclopentanecarboxylate with NaOMe. Which statements are correct?

  1. The label appears only in the ester carbonyl carbon (C=O of CO₂Me).
  2. The label is distributed 50 : 50 between the ester carbonyl carbon and the ring carbon bearing it, if the cyclopropanone is symmetrical and opens either way.
  3. The label is found entirely in the ring carbon attached to the ester group.
  4. The cyclopropanone intermediate carries the label on its carbonyl carbon.

(a) 1 and 4 only (b) 2 and 4 only (c) 3 only (d) 4 only

Answer: (a) 1 and 4 only

The label is on C-1, the carbonyl carbon, and that carbon stays the cyclopropanone carbonyl (C-2 and C-6 form the three-membered ring with it). Methoxide adds to that carbonyl; it becomes the ester carbonyl whichever ring bond breaks. So statements 1 and 4 are correct, and 2 and 3 are wrong.

Scrambling concerns a label at C-2 (the carbon bearing Cl): in the symmetrical cyclopropanone C-2 and C-6 are equivalent, so a C-2 label ends up equally in the ring carbon attached to the ester and in the adjacent ring CH₂. Read carefully which carbon is labelled.

Practice Q7. An allyl ester R–CH₂–CO₂–CH₂CH=CHCH₃ (E-crotyl ester) is treated with LDA in THF at −78 °C, then TMSCl, and warmed to room temperature; aqueous work-up follows. Which statements are correct?

  1. The silyl ketene acetal undergoes a [3,3]-sigmatropic shift.
  2. The product is a γ,δ-unsaturated carboxylic acid with a terminal vinyl group and a new stereocentre bearing CH₃.
  3. Two new adjacent stereocentres are formed, and their relative configuration depends on the enolate geometry.
  4. The reaction requires temperatures above 150 °C.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only

Ireland–Claisen: the silyl ketene acetal rearranges near room temperature (statement 4 wrong). Bond formation joins the ester α-carbon (bearing R) to the crotyl CH(CH₃) terminus with allylic inversion, giving R–CH(CO₂H)–CH(CH₃)–CH=CH₂: a terminal vinyl, a new CH(CH₃) stereocentre, and a second stereocentre at the α-carbon. In the chair TS, the E- or Z-ketene acetal (set by THF versus THF–HMPA) decides syn versus anti relative configuration.

Quick Revision Table

ReactionSubstrate → productKey point
Favorskiiα-halo ketone + RO⁻ → estercyclopropanone; ring contraction; opens to more stable carbanion
Quasi-Favorskiiα-halo ketone, no α′-Hsemibenzilic 1,2-shift
Ramberg–Bäcklundα-halo sulfone + base → alkene + SO₂episulfone
Stevensammonium ylide → tertiary amine[1,2], radical pair, retention
Sommelet–Hauserbenzyl-NMe₃⁺ + NaNH₂ → o-methylbenzylamine[2,3]
[1,2]- / [2,3]-Wittigether + RLi → alcohol / homoallylic alcoholradical pair / concerted, low T
Mislow–Evansallylic sulfoxide → allylic alcohol[2,3] + thiophile
Brookα-silyl alkoxide → silyl ether carbanionSi–O bond
Claisenallyl vinyl/aryl ether → γ,δ-unsaturated carbonyl / o-allylphenol[3,3], chair, allyl inversion
Johnson / Ireland / Eschenmoserorthoester / silyl ketene acetal / amide acetalester / acid / amide
Cope / oxy-Cope / anionic oxy-Cope1,5-diene → 1,5-diene / δ,ε-unsaturated carbonylmeso → E,Z; K alkoxide very fast
Fries / photo-Friesaryl ester → hydroxyaryl ketonelow T para, high T ortho / radical pair
Benzidinehydrazobenzene + H⁺ → benzidine[5,5], intramolecular
BambergerPhNHOH + H₃O⁺ → 4-aminophenolnitrenium, intermolecular
Smilesaryl moves X → Yintramolecular S_NAr
Pummerersulfoxide + Ac₂O → α-acetoxy sulfidethionium ion

Key Takeaways

What’s Next