Rearrangements to Electron-Deficient Carbon, Nitrogen and Oxygen
CSIR NET organic chemistry: Wagner–Meerwein, pinacol, Tiffeneau–Demjanov, benzilic acid, Wolff, Beckmann, Hofmann, Curtius, Baeyer–Villiger, Dakin.
- 17 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Carbocations: Structure, Stability and Rearrangements: cation stability, 1,2-shifts and the anti-periplanar requirement are introduced there; this page applies them to the named rearrangements.
- Stereochemistry: Stereogenicity, Chirality and Configuration: “retention at the migrating carbon” is the test that a shift is intramolecular and concerted.
- Carbonyl Condensations and Enolate Named Reactions: the substrates (ketones, diketones, β-keto esters) often come from there.
- MSc-level E/Z nomenclature of oximes.
The Hook: From Cyclohexanone to Nylon-6
The Common Pattern
All rearrangements on this page are 1,2-shifts to an electron-deficient atom. A group R moves, with its bonding pair, from atom A to the adjacent atom B, which has just lost (or is losing) a leaving group or has only six electrons.
$$\text{R–A–B–LG} \longrightarrow \text{A}^{+}\text{–B–R} \ (\text{+ LG}^-)$$Five rules cover almost every question:
- Find the electron-deficient atom. It is the carbon that ionises (best cation), the nitrogen carrying a leaving group (oxime O, N–Br, N₂ in an azide) or the oxygen of a peroxide O–O bond.
- The migrating group goes with its electron pair (it migrates as an anion-like group).
- Configuration of a migrating carbon is retained. The group never becomes free.
- In rigid systems the group anti-periplanar to the leaving group migrates (stereoelectronic control), even against migratory aptitude. This decides the Beckmann outright.
- Migratory aptitude decides when there is a choice: groups that can best stabilise positive charge in the transition state move fastest. For alkyl groups: tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl. Electron-rich aryl groups migrate well. The position of H in the series depends on the reaction.
graph TD
A["1,2-shift to electron-deficient atom"] --> B["to C"]
A --> C["to N"]
A --> D["to O"]
B --> B1["Wagner-Meerwein, pinacol,
semipinacol, Tiffeneau-Demjanov,
dienone-phenol, benzilic acid,
Wolff (carbene)"]
C --> C1["Beckmann (oxime),
Hofmann, Curtius, Lossen,
Schmidt (isocyanate family)"]
D --> D1["Baeyer-Villiger, Dakin,
Hock (cumene hydroperoxide)"]Shifts to Carbon
Wagner–Meerwein rearrangement
The general name for a 1,2-shift of an alkyl, aryl or hydride group to a carbocation, giving a more stable cation. The classic case comes from terpene chemistry: camphene hydrochloride rearranges to isobornyl chloride through a bicyclic cation (the 2-norbornyl-type ion, discussed as a non-classical ion on the carbocation page). Neopentyl systems (the hook of that page) are the simplest acyclic example.
Pinacol rearrangement
A vicinal diol with acid gives a ketone or aldehyde:
$$(\text{CH}_3)_2\text{C(OH)–C(OH)(CH}_3)_2 \xrightarrow{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} (\text{CH}_3)_3\text{C–CO–CH}_3 \ (\text{pinacolone})$$Steps: protonate one OH; lose water to form a carbocation; a group on the neighbouring carbinol carbon migrates to the cation; the oxygen lone pair stabilises the new cation (an oxocarbenium, a protonated ketone); loss of H⁺ gives the carbonyl.
Two decisions for unsymmetrical diols:
| Decision | Rule | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Which OH leaves? | the one giving the more stable carbocation | Ph₂C(OH)–C(OH)Me₂: the OH on the diphenyl carbon leaves (benzhydryl-type cation) |
| Which group migrates? | from the other carbon, higher migratory aptitude (aryl usually before alkyl), subject to anti-periplanar alignment in rings | in the same example only methyls are available: Ph₂C(CH₃)–CO–CH₃ (3,3-diphenylbutan-2-one) |
Cyclic diols give ring contraction or spiro ketones depending on which bond migrates: 1,1′-bi(cyclopentyl)-1,1′-diol rearranges with ring expansion of one ring to spiro[4.5]decan-6-one.
Semipinacol rearrangements
Any system that generates a carbocation next to a carbon bearing OH (or O⁻) rearranges the same way, without needing the diol:
- 2,3-Epoxy alcohols and epoxides with Lewis acids (BF₃·OEt₂): the epoxide opens to the better cation and a group migrates (the Meinwald rearrangement of epoxides to carbonyl compounds).
- β-Amino alcohols with HNO₂: diazotisation, loss of N₂, migration. The ring-expanding version is the Tiffeneau–Demjanov rearrangement:
The primary diazonium ion loses N₂, a ring C–C bond migrates to the exocyclic CH₂, and the ring grows by one carbon. The cation formed is stabilised by the OH, so the product is a clean ketone. Without the OH (aminomethylcycloalkane, the plain Demjanov reaction) you get mixtures of ring-expanded alcohols and alkenes.
Dienone–phenol rearrangement
A 4,4-disubstituted cyclohexa-2,5-dienone in acid: protonation on oxygen gives a cation delocalised to C-4’s neighbours; one C-4 substituent migrates to C-3, and loss of H⁺ from C-4 makes an aromatic phenol, which is the driving force.
$$\text{4,4-dimethylcyclohexa-2,5-dien-1-one} \xrightarrow{\text{H}^+} \text{3,4-dimethylphenol}$$It is the reverse of the logic of dearomatisation and appears in steroid chemistry (ring-A dienones to phenols).
Benzilic acid rearrangement
A 1,2-diketone + hydroxide gives an α-hydroxy carboxylate:
$$\text{PhCO–COPh} \xrightarrow{\ 1.\ \text{KOH};\ \ 2.\ \text{H}_3\text{O}^+\ } \text{Ph}_2\text{C(OH)CO}_2\text{H}\ (\text{benzilic acid})$$OH⁻ adds to one carbonyl; the tetrahedral alkoxide pushes, and a phenyl migrates to the adjacent carbonyl carbon (electron-deficient because it is a C=O carbon). Proton transfer gives the carboxylate. With alkoxide instead of hydroxide, the ester forms (benzilic ester rearrangement). Cyclic 1,2-diones undergo ring contraction: cyclohexane-1,2-dione gives 1-hydroxycyclopentane-1-carboxylic acid.
Wolff rearrangement and the Arndt–Eistert homologation
An α-diazoketone loses N₂ (with Ag₂O or other Ag(I), heat, or light) and a group migrates from the carbonyl carbon to the adjacent carbon to give a ketene. The migration may be concerted with N₂ loss or go through a ketocarbene.
The ketene is trapped by nucleophiles: water → carboxylic acid, alcohol → ester, amine → amide.
The Arndt–Eistert synthesis uses this to add one CH₂ to a carboxylic acid:
$$\text{RCOCl} \xrightarrow{\text{CH}_2\text{N}_2} \text{RCOCHN}_2 \xrightarrow{\text{Ag}_2\text{O},\ \text{H}_2\text{O}} \text{RCH}_2\text{CO}_2\text{H}$$- Use two equivalents of diazomethane (or one plus Et₃N): the HCl formed would otherwise convert the diazoketone into a chloromethyl ketone.
- The migrating R keeps its configuration, so α-amino acids are homologated to β-amino acids without racemisation.
- Cyclic α-diazoketones give ring-contracted ketenes, and so ring-contracted acids.
Meyer–Schuster and Rupe rearrangements (briefly)
Propargylic alcohols in acid give α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compounds. In the Meyer–Schuster reaction the OH formally moves 1,3 (through an allenol) to give an enone or enal. Tertiary propargylic alcohols with an available hydrogen can instead dehydrate to an enyne and hydrate to an α,β-unsaturated methyl ketone (the Rupe pathway).
Shifts to Nitrogen
Beckmann rearrangement
A ketoxime with acid or an activating agent (conc. H₂SO₄, PCl₅, SOCl₂, TsCl then heat, polyphosphoric acid) gives an N-substituted amide.
- The oxime OH is converted into a leaving group (protonation, sulfonate, phosphate).
- The group anti to the leaving group migrates from C to N as the leaving group departs: a nitrilium ion forms.
- Water attacks the nitrilium carbon; tautomerisation of the imidic acid gives the amide.
| Oxime | Group anti to OH | Product |
|---|---|---|
| Acetophenone oxime, E (OH anti to Ph; the usual isomer) | phenyl | acetanilide, PhNHCOCH₃ |
| Acetophenone oxime, Z (OH anti to CH₃) | methyl | N-methylbenzamide, PhCONHCH₃ |
| Cyclohexanone oxime | ring CH₂ | ε-caprolactam |
Points that turn into questions:
- The reaction is stereospecific: the product reveals oxime geometry. If acid isomerises the oxime before it rearranges, mixtures result; sulfonate esters at low temperature preserve specificity.
- The migrating carbon keeps its configuration.
- Aldoximes usually dehydrate to nitriles rather than rearranging.
- Beckmann fragmentation (abnormal Beckmann) competes when the group anti to the leaving group can leave as a stabilised cation (tertiary, α-alkoxy, α-amino): the products are a nitrile and the cation-derived product.
- The amide oxygen comes from water, not from the oxime: an ¹⁸O-labelled oxime gives unlabelled amide in H₂¹⁶O, and unlabelled oxime in H₂¹⁸O gives ¹⁸O-amide.
The isocyanate family: Hofmann, Curtius, Lossen, Schmidt
Four reactions, one intermediate. An acyl group bonded to a nitrogen that carries a leaving group rearranges: R migrates from the carbonyl carbon to nitrogen as the leaving group departs, giving an isocyanate R–N=C=O. Hydrolysis gives a carbamic acid, which loses CO₂ to the amine with one carbon fewer than the starting acid derivative.
| Reaction | Starting material | Reagent | Leaving group on N | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hofmann | primary amide RCONH₂ | Br₂ (or NaOBr), NaOH, H₂O | Br⁻ from the N-bromoamide anion | in MeOH gives the methyl carbamate |
| Curtius | acyl azide RCON₃ (from RCOCl + NaN₃, or RCO₂H + DPPA) | heat | N₂ | concerted; isocyanate can be isolated; mild |
| Lossen | O-acyl hydroxamic acid RCONHOCOR′ | base, heat | carboxylate | |
| Schmidt | RCO₂H | HN₃, conc. H₂SO₄ | N₂ (from a protonated acyl azide) | ketones give amides (ring expansion of cyclic ketones), aldehydes give nitriles/formamides |
Common features:
- Retention of configuration at the migrating carbon (an optically active α-substituted amide gives an optically active amine of the same configuration).
- No crossover: a mixture of two differently labelled amides gives no mixed products, so the migration is intramolecular.
- The amine has one carbon fewer (the carbonyl carbon leaves as CO₂): a degradation used to locate carboxyl groups and to make amines.
Applications: phthalimide with NaOBr/NaOH gives anthranilic acid (2-aminobenzoic acid) by Hofmann rearrangement of the ring-opened amide; Curtius on an acid via DPPA in t-BuOH gives the Boc-protected amine directly.
Neber rearrangement
A ketoxime O-sulfonate with base (alkoxide) gives an α-amino ketone, through deprotonation α to the C=N and closure to a 2H-azirine, which is hydrolysed. Unlike the Beckmann, the product keeps the ketone and adds an amino group on the α-carbon.
Shifts to Oxygen
Baeyer–Villiger oxidation
A ketone + a peroxy acid (mCPBA, peracetic acid, trifluoroperacetic acid; also H₂O₂ with Lewis acids) gives an ester; a cyclic ketone gives a lactone:
$$\text{cyclohexanone} \xrightarrow{\text{mCPBA}} \varepsilon\text{-caprolactone}$$Mechanism:
- The peracid adds to the protonated or activated carbonyl to give a tetrahedral adduct, the Criegee intermediate.
- In the rate-determining step a group migrates from carbon to the proximal peroxide oxygen as the carboxylate leaves; the migrating group is the one antiperiplanar to the O–O bond.
- Loss of H⁺ gives the ester.
Migratory aptitude (decides regiochemistry):
$$\text{tertiary alkyl} > \text{secondary alkyl} \approx \text{cyclohexyl} \approx \text{phenyl} > \text{primary alkyl} > \text{methyl}$$with electron-rich aryl groups ahead of electron-poor ones, and H migrating readily in aldehydes (most aldehydes give carboxylic acids).
| Ketone | Migrating group | Product |
|---|---|---|
| Acetophenone | phenyl | phenyl acetate, CH₃CO₂Ph |
| Cyclohexyl methyl ketone | cyclohexyl | cyclohexyl acetate |
| 2-Methylcyclohexanone | the more substituted ring carbon (CH–CH₃) | 7-methyloxepan-2-one (O inserted next to the CHCH₃) |
| Bicyclic ketones | bridgehead (more substituted) carbon | lactone with O next to the bridgehead |
Further points:
- Retention of configuration at the migrating carbon.
- The carbonyl oxygen of the ketone becomes the carbonyl oxygen of the ester: with ¹⁸O-labelled benzophenone, the phenyl benzoate carries the label only in C=O (evidence for the Criegee intermediate and against a dioxirane pathway).
- Chemoselectivity: peracids also epoxidise alkenes. Electron-rich alkenes may epoxidise faster than a ketone undergoes Baeyer–Villiger; α,β-unsaturated ketones can give enol esters or epoxides depending on the substrate.
- Enzymatic versions (Baeyer–Villiger monooxygenases) are used for enantioselective lactone synthesis.
Dakin oxidation
An ortho- or para-hydroxy (or amino) benzaldehyde + alkaline H₂O₂ gives a phenol (catechol or hydroquinone) and formate. It is a Baeyer–Villiger in which the electron-rich aryl migrates in preference to H, giving an aryl formate that is hydrolysed. Benzaldehydes without the activating OH give mainly benzoic acids.
Hock rearrangement (cumene process)
Cumene hydroperoxide (from air oxidation of isopropylbenzene) with acid: the protonated hydroperoxide loses water as phenyl migrates from carbon to oxygen; the resulting oxocarbenium ion is hydrated and cleaves to phenol + acetone. This is the main industrial route to phenol and makes acetone as a co-product. Phenyl migrates in preference to methyl, exactly as in the Baeyer–Villiger order.
Comparison: Which Atom, Which Group, Which Product?
| Reaction | Electron-deficient atom | Trigger | Migrating group | Product |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wagner–Meerwein | C⁺ | ionisation | H, alkyl, aryl | rearranged cation → alkene / substitution |
| Pinacol | C⁺ | H⁺ on diol | from the carbinol carbon | ketone / aldehyde |
| Tiffeneau–Demjanov | C (–N₂⁺) | HNO₂ on β-amino alcohol | ring C–C | ring-expanded ketone |
| Dienone–phenol | C⁺ | H⁺ on dienone | C-4 substituent | phenol |
| Benzilic acid | carbonyl C | OH⁻ | aryl / alkyl | α-hydroxy acid |
| Wolff | carbene / C–N₂⁺ | Ag⁺, hν, Δ | R on C=O | ketene → acid, ester |
| Beckmann | N | acid / TsCl on oxime | group anti to OH | amide, lactam |
| Hofmann / Curtius / Lossen / Schmidt | N | Br₂–OH⁻ / Δ / base / HN₃ | R of RCO | isocyanate → amine (− 1 C) |
| Baeyer–Villiger | O | peracid | most substituted / aryl | ester, lactone |
| Dakin | O | H₂O₂, OH⁻ | electron-rich aryl | phenol + formate |
| Hock | O | H⁺ on ROOH | phenyl | phenol + acetone |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Pinacol rearrangement: diol + acid → ketone | Pinacol coupling: ketone + Mg(Hg) → diol | |
| Beckmann: oxime → amide (C count kept) | Hofmann: amide → amine (one C lost) | |
| Beckmann (oxime, acid) → amide | Neber (oxime sulfonate, base) → α-amino ketone | |
| Baeyer–Villiger: ketone → ester | Dakin: hydroxybenzaldehyde → phenol | |
| Tiffeneau–Demjanov: ring expansion (+1) | Favorskii and Wolff of cyclic substrates: ring contraction (−1) | |
| Curtius: acyl azide, heat, concerted | Schmidt: acid or ketone + HN₃ in strong acid | |
| Arndt–Eistert: acid + CH₂ | Hunsdiecker: acid − CO₂ → RBr |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the product of the Beckmann rearrangement of cyclohexanone oxime?
- Which product is formed when acetophenone is treated with mCPBA?
- What does the Arndt–Eistert sequence do to the carbon chain of a carboxylic acid?
Answers
- ε-Caprolactam (azepan-2-one), the nylon-6 monomer.
- Phenyl acetate: phenyl migrates in preference to methyl.
- It adds one CH₂ between R and CO₂H (homologation): RCO₂H → RCH₂CO₂H.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. 2-Methyl-1,1-diphenylpropane-1,2-diol, Ph₂C(OH)–C(OH)(CH₃)₂, is treated with conc. H₂SO₄. The major product is:
(a) PhCO–C(CH₃)₂Ph (b) Ph₂C(CH₃)–COCH₃ (c) Ph₂CH–CO–CH₂CH₃ (d) PhCO–CH(CH₃)Ph
Answer: (b)
The OH on the diphenyl carbon leaves, because the diphenylmethyl-type tertiary cation is far more stable. A group then migrates from the other carbon, which carries only methyls: a methyl moves, and the oxygen on that carbon becomes the ketone. Product: Ph₂C(CH₃)–CO–CH₃, 3,3-diphenylbutan-2-one. Option (a) would need the less stable cation to form first.
Practice Q2. (S)-2-Phenylpropanamide is treated with Br₂ and aqueous NaOH. The product is:
(a) racemic 1-phenylethanamine (b) (S)-1-phenylethanamine (c) (R)-1-phenylethanamine by inversion (d) 2-phenylpropanoic acid
Answer: (b)
Hofmann rearrangement: the 1-phenylethyl group migrates from C to N with retention. The amine is 1-phenylethanamine with one carbon fewer. The CIP descriptor stays (S) here because the priority order is unchanged: N (replacing C(=O)NH₂ as the top-priority group) > Ph > CH₃ > H, as before (CONH₂ > Ph > CH₃ > H).
Practice Q3. Which reaction converts cyclohexane-1,2-dione into 1-hydroxycyclopentane-1-carboxylic acid?
(a) Favorskii (b) benzilic acid rearrangement (c) Baeyer–Villiger (d) Tiffeneau–Demjanov
Answer: (b)
Hydroxide adds to one carbonyl of the 1,2-dione and a ring bond migrates to the other carbonyl carbon: ring contraction to an α-hydroxy acid. That is the benzilic acid rearrangement.
Practice Q4. 4-Hydroxybenzaldehyde is treated with H₂O₂ and NaOH. The organic products after acidification are:
(a) 4-hydroxybenzoic acid only (b) hydroquinone and formic acid (c) catechol and formic acid (d) phenol and CO₂
Answer: (b)
Dakin oxidation: the electron-rich 4-hydroxyphenyl group migrates from carbon to oxygen, giving the aryl formate, which is hydrolysed to hydroquinone (benzene-1,4-diol) and formate. Catechol would come from the 2-hydroxy isomer.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Benzamide (24.2 g) is converted into aniline by the Hofmann rearrangement in 85% yield. Take molar masses benzamide 121.14 g mol⁻¹, aniline 93.13 g mol⁻¹. Which statements are correct?
- The mass of aniline obtained is about 15.8 g.
- Phenyl isocyanate is an intermediate.
- One mole of CO₂ (as carbonate under the basic conditions) is formed per mole of aniline.
- If ¹⁵N-benzamide and 4-methylbenzamide (unlabelled) are rearranged together, ¹⁵N appears in 4-methylaniline.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
Moles of benzamide = 24.2/121.14 = 0.1998 mol. Theoretical aniline = 0.1998 × 93.13 = 18.6 g; at 85%, 15.8 g. Statement 1 correct.
The N-bromoamide anion loses Br⁻ as phenyl migrates: PhN=C=O. Hydrolysis gives the carbamic acid, which loses CO₂ (trapped as carbonate). Statements 2 and 3 correct.
The rearrangement is intramolecular (crossover experiments show no exchange), so the ¹⁵N label stays in aniline. Statement 4 is wrong.
Practice Q6. A ketoxime K (C₈H₉NO) is treated with PCl₅ in ether and then water to give an amide L (C₈H₉NO). Hydrolysis of L with aqueous NaOH gives aniline and acetate. Which statements are correct?
- K is acetophenone oxime with the OH anti to the phenyl group.
- L is acetanilide.
- If K had the OH anti to the methyl group, the hydrolysis products would be methylamine and benzoate.
- K and L are isomers.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 3 and 4 only
Answer: (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Aniline + acetate from hydrolysis means L = PhNHCOCH₃ (acetanilide). Phenyl must have migrated to N, so it was anti to the OH: E-acetophenone oxime. The other geometry would give N-methylbenzamide, PhCONHCH₃, hydrolysed to benzoate + methylamine. Beckmann rearrangement does not change the formula (both C₈H₉NO, M ≈ 135.2), so K and L are isomers.
Practice Q7. Benzophenone labelled with ¹⁸O at the carbonyl oxygen is oxidised with peroxybenzoic acid. Which statements are correct?
- The product is phenyl benzoate.
- The ¹⁸O label is found only in the carbonyl oxygen of the ester.
- If a symmetrical dioxirane were the key intermediate, the label would be scrambled between the carbonyl and the ether oxygen.
- The label result supports the Criegee (tetrahedral peroxy) intermediate.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Phenyl migrates to the proximal peroxide oxygen, which comes from the peracid; the original carbonyl oxygen (¹⁸O) stays as the C=O of phenyl benzoate. A dioxirane would make the two oxygens equivalent and distribute the label between C=O and C–O–Ph. The observed result, label only in C=O, supports the Criegee pathway.
Quick Revision Table
| Reaction | Substrate → product | Key rule |
|---|---|---|
| Wagner–Meerwein | cation → more stable cation | 1,2-H, alkyl, aryl shift |
| Pinacol | 1,2-diol → ketone | better cation forms; group from other carbon moves |
| Tiffeneau–Demjanov | 1-aminomethyl cycloalkanol → ring-expanded ketone | HNO₂; +1 ring size |
| Dienone–phenol | 4,4-disubstituted dienone → 3,4-disubstituted phenol | aromatisation drives |
| Benzilic acid | 1,2-dione + OH⁻ → α-hydroxy acid | cyclic: ring contraction |
| Wolff / Arndt–Eistert | diazoketone → ketene → acid | +CH₂; retention; Ag₂O or hν |
| Beckmann | oxime → amide | anti group migrates; fragmentation possible |
| Hofmann, Curtius, Lossen, Schmidt | acyl-N-LG → isocyanate → amine | −1 C; retention; intramolecular |
| Neber | oxime tosylate + base → α-amino ketone | via 2H-azirine |
| Baeyer–Villiger | ketone → ester / lactone | 3° > 2° ≈ Ph > 1° > Me; retention |
| Dakin | o/p-HO-ArCHO → phenol + formate | aryl migrates |
| Hock | cumene hydroperoxide → phenol + acetone | Ph migrates to O |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Anionic, Sigmatropic and Aromatic Rearrangements: Favorskii, Stevens, Sommelet–Hauser, Wittig, Claisen, Cope and Fries.
- Cation stability and non-classical ions: Carbocations.
- Named Reactions and Rearrangements: Quick Revision.
- Back to the chapter overview.