Activation Analysis
CSIR NET chemistry: neutron activation analysis, activation equation, saturation, comparator method, INAA vs RNAA, interferences and NAA variants.
- 16 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Making the Sample Announce Itself
- The Principle in Four Steps
- The Activation Equation
- Standardisation: the Comparator Method
- Choosing Irradiation, Decay and Counting Times
- Instrumental and Radiochemical NAA
- Interferences
- Neutron Sources and Variants of Activation Analysis
- Advantages and Limitations
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Nuclear Reactions: cross-sections, R = Nσφ, thermal and fast neutrons, and (n,γ) versus (n,p) reactions.
- Nuclear Stability and Radioactive Decay: decay law, half-life and γ emission after β decay.
- Radio-analytical Techniques: HPGe γ spectrometry, counting statistics and carriers, all used in activation analysis.
- Analytical Applications of the Inner Transition Elements: rare-earth patterns, one of the classic outputs of activation analysis in geochemistry.
The Hook: Making the Sample Announce Itself
The Principle in Four Steps
graph LR
A["1. Irradiate
sample + standard
(reactor, n flux φ)"] --> B["2. Decay
(delay t_d: short-lived
matrix activity dies)"]
B --> C["3. Count
HPGe γ spectrum
(time t_c)"]
C --> D["4. Evaluate
γ energy → element
peak area → mass"]- Irradiation. Sample (and usually a standard) in a neutron flux, mostly thermal neutrons from a research reactor, for a chosen time tᵢ.
- Decay. A waiting time t_d lets short-lived interfering activities die away (or, for short-lived products, is kept as short as possible).
- Counting. γ spectrometry, usually with a high-resolution HPGe detector.
- Evaluation. Each γ photopeak identifies a nuclide and therefore an element; the peak area gives the amount.
Most activation analysis uses (n,γ) capture: the product is a heavier isotope of the same element, typically a β⁻ emitter followed by γ emission from the daughter. Example:
$$^{23}\text{Na}(n,\gamma)\,^{24}\text{Na} \xrightarrow{\beta^-,\ t_{1/2} \approx 15\ \text{h}} {}^{24}\text{Mg} + \gamma$$The Activation Equation
During irradiation the product is formed at a constant rate R = Nσφ and decays at a rate λN*. So
$$\frac{dN^{*}}{dt} = N\sigma\varphi - \lambda N^{*}$$and at the end of an irradiation of length tᵢ the activity is
$$\boxed{A_0 = N\sigma\varphi\left(1 - e^{-\lambda t_i}\right) = N\sigma\varphi\,S}$$where S is the saturation factor. After a decay time t_d,
$$A = N\sigma\varphi\,S\,e^{-\lambda t_d}$$with N the number of target nuclei:
$$N = \frac{m\,\theta\,N_A}{M}$$(m = mass of the element, θ = isotopic abundance of the target isotope, M = molar mass of the element).
Saturation
| Irradiation time (in half-lives of the product) | S = 1 − 2^(−n) |
|---|---|
| 0.5 | 0.29 |
| 1 | 0.50 |
| 2 | 0.75 |
| 3 | 0.875 |
| 4 | 0.94 |
| 5 | 0.97 |
| ∞ | 1.00 (saturation activity Nσφ) |
Irradiating for more than three or four half-lives of the product gains little: the activity is already 88–94% of saturation, while long-lived interferences keep growing. For short irradiations (tᵢ ≪ t½), \( S \approx \lambda t_i \), so activity grows linearly with time.
Counts recorded
If the sample is counted for a time t_c with detector efficiency ε and γ emission probability I_γ, the photopeak area is
$$C = \frac{N\sigma\varphi}{\lambda}\,\left(1 - e^{-\lambda t_i}\right)\,e^{-\lambda t_d}\,\left(1 - e^{-\lambda t_c}\right)\,\varepsilon\,I_\gamma$$The three brackets are the saturation, decay and counting factors. You do not need to memorise the full expression for standard problems, because the comparator method cancels almost everything.
Standardisation: the Comparator Method
Absolute calculation needs φ, σ, ε and I_γ, all with uncertainties. Instead, a standard of known mass of the element is irradiated together with the sample (same flux, same tᵢ) and counted in the same geometry. Everything cancels except the masses and any difference in decay time:
$$\boxed{\frac{m_x}{m_s} = \frac{C_x}{C_s}\cdot\frac{e^{-\lambda t_{d,s}}}{e^{-\lambda t_{d,x}}}}$$If both are counted after the same delay and for the same time, simply \( m_x = m_s\,C_x/C_s \).
Many laboratories now use a single comparator (often gold) and tabulated nuclear constants for each element, the k₀ method, which allows multi-element analysis without a separate standard for every element.
Choosing Irradiation, Decay and Counting Times
The half-life of the product decides the schedule.
| Product nuclide (target) | Half-life (approx.) | Typical scheme |
|---|---|---|
| ²⁸Al (²⁷Al) | 2.24 min | short irradiation (seconds to a minute), count at once |
| ²⁷Mg (²⁶Mg) | 9.5 min | short |
| ³⁸Cl (³⁷Cl) | 37 min | short |
| ⁵⁶Mn (⁵⁵Mn) | 2.58 h | short to medium |
| ⁴²K (⁴¹K) | 12.4 h | medium |
| ²⁴Na (²³Na) | 15.0 h | medium; the main matrix nuisance |
| ⁶⁴Cu (⁶³Cu) | 12.7 h | medium |
| ⁷⁶As (⁷⁵As) | 26 h | medium |
| ¹⁹⁸Au (¹⁹⁷Au) | 2.7 d | medium; flux monitor |
| ⁵¹Cr (⁵⁰Cr) | 27.7 d | long irradiation, delay of weeks |
| ⁵⁹Fe (⁵⁸Fe) | 44.5 d | long |
| ⁴⁶Sc (⁴⁵Sc) | 84 d | long |
| ⁶⁰Co (⁵⁹Co) | 5.27 y | long |
A common INAA programme: a short irradiation of one aliquot, counted within minutes for Al, Mg, Cl, Mn, V and similar; a long irradiation of another aliquot, counted after a few days (for As, Na, La, Sm, Au) and again after several weeks, when ²⁴Na has gone (for Co, Cr, Fe, Sc, Zn, Se, the rare earths).
Short-lived products need a short delay because they disappear quickly; a 20-minute wait leaves only about 0.2% of ²⁸Al. Long-lived products need long irradiation because, for tᵢ ≪ t½, S ≈ λtᵢ is small.
Instrumental and Radiochemical NAA
| Instrumental NAA (INAA) | Radiochemical NAA (RNAA) | |
|---|---|---|
| Chemistry | none: irradiate, wait, count | chemical separation after irradiation |
| Sample | solid, intact; non-destructive | dissolved; destroyed |
| Strength | fast, multi-element, no reagent blank | removes interfering matrix activity (²⁴Na, ³²P, ⁸²Br); better detection limits for the separated elements |
| Typical use | rocks, pottery, hair, reference materials | ultra-trace elements in biological tissue and high-purity materials |
Interferences
| Type | Example | Remedy |
|---|---|---|
| Primary interference: another element gives the same product by a different reaction | ²⁷Al(n,γ)²⁸Al and ²⁸Si(n,p)²⁸Al; ²⁶Mg(n,γ)²⁷Mg and ²⁷Al(n,p)²⁷Mg; ²³Na(n,γ)²⁴Na and ²⁷Al(n,α)²⁴Na | well-thermalised irradiation position (the (n,p) and (n,α) routes need fast neutrons); correct with a pure interferent standard |
| Second-order reactions: the product itself captures a neutron | high-flux, long irradiations | correct or shorten irradiation |
| Fission interference: uranium in the sample makes fission products | ⁹⁹Mo, ¹⁴⁰La, rare earths from ²³⁵U fission | correct using the uranium content |
| Spectral interference: overlapping γ peaks | close-lying lines from different nuclides | choose another γ line, HPGe resolution, decay discrimination |
| Matrix activity: intense lines raise the Compton background | ²⁴Na, ³⁸Cl, ⁴²K, ³²P in biological samples | delay, RNAA, anticoincidence counting |
| Flux perturbation: strong absorbers in the sample | B, Cd, Gd, Li | small samples, internal standards |
Neutron Sources and Variants of Activation Analysis
Sources. Research reactors give thermal fluxes typically in the range 10¹²–10¹⁴ n cm⁻² s⁻¹, the basis of the best sensitivity. Isotopic sources (Am–Be, ²⁵²Cf) and D–T neutron generators (14 MeV) are weaker but portable; they are used for major elements and in field or process applications.
| Variant | Neutrons / particle | What it adds | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thermal NAA | thermal | standard method, highest sensitivity for most elements | Na, Mn, Co, Au, As, rare earths |
| Epithermal NAA (ENAA) | sample shielded by cadmium (or boron), which absorbs thermal neutrons | favours nuclides with large resonance capture, suppresses Na, Cl, Mn matrix activity | U, Th, As, Br and others in geological samples |
| Fast-neutron activation (FNAA) | 14 MeV (D–T generator) | threshold reactions for light elements that thermal (n,γ) misses | O by ¹⁶O(n,p)¹⁶N (t½ ≈ 7 s, high-energy γ); N by ¹⁴N(n,2n)¹³N (a β⁺ emitter) |
| Prompt-gamma NAA (PGNAA) | thermal or cold neutron beam; γ rays measured during irradiation | elements whose capture product is stable or very short-lived | H, B, Cd, Gd, also C, N, S, Si |
| Charged-particle activation (CPAA) | p, d, ³He, α from accelerators | light elements (C, N, O) at surfaces and in high-purity metals | ¹²C(d,n)¹³N |
| Photon activation (PAA) | bremsstrahlung from an electron linac | (γ,n) reactions | ¹²C(γ,n)¹¹C, light elements |
Boron is the standard PGNAA case: ¹⁰B(n,α)⁷Li leaves ⁷Li in an excited state that emits a prompt γ ray near 478 keV, Doppler-broadened because the lithium is recoiling.
Advantages and Limitations
| Advantages | Limitations |
|---|---|
| Very sensitive for many elements (ppm to ppb, better with RNAA) | Needs a nuclear reactor (or accelerator) for best results |
| Multi-element: tens of elements from one sample | Poor for H, C, N, O and for some heavy elements such as Pb and Bi by thermal (n,γ) |
| Non-destructive (INAA): sample can be reused or archived | Long turnaround for long-lived products (weeks) |
| No reagent blank in RNAA; contamination after irradiation is harmless | Matrix activity (Na, Cl, Br, P) can swamp traces |
| Little matrix effect on the nuclear reaction; neutrons and γ rays penetrate the whole sample | Gives total element only, not chemical form (speciation) |
| Independent of chemical state; ideal for certifying reference materials | Radioactive samples need licensed handling |
Where it is used
- Geochemistry and cosmochemistry: rare-earth patterns of rocks and meteorites; iridium and other platinum-group anomalies.
- Archaeology: provenance of pottery, obsidian and coins from their trace-element fingerprints, non-destructively.
- Forensic science: trace elements in hair, glass, paint and gunshot residue (Sb, Ba).
- Environment and biology: Se, As, Hg, Co and other trace elements in food, tissue and air filters.
- Materials: impurities at ppb levels in high-purity silicon and other electronic materials.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Saturation activity Nσφ (tᵢ → ∞) | End-of-irradiation activity Nσφ S | |
| INAA: no chemistry, non-destructive | RNAA: post-irradiation separation, destructive | |
| Thermal NAA: (n,γ), most elements | FNAA: 14 MeV threshold reactions, O, N | |
| PGNAA: γ during irradiation (B, H, Cd, Gd) | Delayed-γ NAA: γ from the radioactive product after irradiation | |
| Epithermal NAA (Cd-covered) | Thermal NAA (bare) | |
| Activation analysis: sample made radioactive | Isotope dilution: label added to the sample | |
| Primary interference (same product nuclide) | Spectral interference (different nuclides, overlapping γ lines) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Nuclear data given in a question are for that question.
Level 1: Foundation
- What fraction of saturation activity is reached after irradiating for two half-lives of the product?
- Write the product of ⁵⁹Co(n,γ).
- Which variant of NAA measures γ rays during irradiation?
Answers
- 1 − (1/2)² = 0.75.
- ⁶⁰Co.
- Prompt-gamma NAA (PGNAA).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A sample is irradiated for a time equal to three half-lives of the product. The activity at the end of irradiation, as a fraction of the saturation activity, is:
(a) 0.333 (b) 0.750 (c) 0.875 (d) 0.950
Answer: (c)
S = 1 − 2⁻³ = 0.875.
Practice Q2. In neutron activation analysis of a silicon-rich sample for aluminium (via ²⁸Al), the main primary interference comes from:
(a) ²⁸Si(n,γ)²⁹Si (b) ²⁸Si(n,p)²⁸Al (c) ²⁷Al(n,α)²⁴Na (d) ³⁰Si(n,γ)³¹Si
Answer: (b)
²⁸Si(n,p)²⁸Al gives the same product as ²⁷Al(n,γ)²⁸Al. It needs fast neutrons, so a well-thermalised irradiation position reduces it. (a) and (d) give silicon isotopes, not ²⁸Al.
Practice Q3. The main reason radiochemical NAA is free from reagent-blank errors is that:
(a) reagents are radioactive (b) separations are done after irradiation, so inactive contaminants are not counted (c) neutrons destroy impurities (d) no carriers are used
Answer: (b)
Contamination introduced after irradiation is inactive. Carriers are in fact added freely (so (d) is wrong).
Practice Q4. A standard containing 10.0 µg of an element and an unknown are irradiated together and counted under identical conditions after the same delay. The standard gives 5.0 × 10⁴ counts and the unknown 2.0 × 10⁴ counts in the same photopeak. The mass of the element in the unknown is:
(a) 4.0 µg (b) 25 µg (c) 2.5 µg (d) 0.4 µg
Answer: (a)
mₓ = 10.0 × (2.0 × 10⁴/5.0 × 10⁴) = 4.0 µg.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. 1.00 µg of sodium (single isotope ²³Na, M = 22.99 g mol⁻¹) is irradiated for 15 h at φ = 1.0 × 10¹² n cm⁻² s⁻¹. Take σ = 0.53 b and t½(²⁴Na) = 15 h. Which statements are correct?
- The saturation activity is about 1.4 × 10⁴ Bq.
- The activity at the end of irradiation is about 6.9 × 10³ Bq.
- Irradiating for 60 h instead would raise the end-of-irradiation activity by a factor of about 1.9.
- Irradiating for 150 h instead would raise it by a factor of 10.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Nσφ = 2.62 × 10¹⁶ × 0.53 × 10⁻²⁴ × 10¹² = 1.39 × 10⁴ Bq. Correct.
- S = 0.5: 6.9 × 10³ Bq. Correct.
- 60 h = 4 half-lives, S = 0.9375; ratio 0.9375/0.5 = 1.875. Correct.
- 10 half-lives gives S ≈ 0.999, only about twice the one-half-life value, not ten times. Wrong.
Practice Q6. A 5.0 µg Mn standard and a sample are irradiated together. Take t½(⁵⁶Mn) = 2.58 h. The standard, counted 1.0 h after irradiation, gives 40 000 counts; the sample, counted 2.0 h after irradiation for the same counting time, gives 12 000 counts. The Mn content of the sample is closest to:
(a) 1.5 µg (b) 1.7 µg (c) 2.0 µg (d) 2.6 µg
Answer: (c)
λ = 0.2687 h⁻¹. Correct the sample count back by 1.0 h: 12 000 × e^0.2687 = 15 700. mₓ = 5.0 × 15 700/40 000 = 1.96 µg. (a) omits the decay correction.
Practice Q7. A geological sample contains Al, Na, Co and Mn. Which statements are correct?
- To determine Al via ²⁸Al (t½ ≈ 2.2 min), the sample should be counted within minutes of a short irradiation.
- To determine Co via ⁶⁰Co, a long irradiation and a delay of several weeks, letting ²⁴Na decay, improve the measurement.
- An irradiation of 1 h brings ²⁸Al essentially to saturation but ²⁴Na (t½ ≈ 15 h) to only about 4.5% of saturation.
- Covering the sample with cadmium increases the ²⁸Al activity from ²⁷Al(n,γ).
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct: after 20 min only (1/2)^(20/2.24) ≈ 0.2% of ²⁸Al remains.
- Correct: ²⁴Na dominates the early spectrum; after several weeks it is gone while ⁶⁰Co (5.27 y) is almost unchanged.
- Correct: 60/2.24 ≈ 27 half-lives for ²⁸Al (S ≈ 1); for ²⁴Na S = 1 − 2^(−1/15) = 0.045.
- Wrong: cadmium removes thermal neutrons, which drive (n,γ) on ²⁷Al; it lowers ²⁸Al production (it is used to suppress thermal activation of matrix elements).
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Principle | stable isotope → (n,γ) → radioactive product → γ spectrum identifies, peak area quantifies |
| Activation | A₀ = Nσφ(1 − e^(−λtᵢ)); A = A₀e^(−λt_d); N = mθN_A/M |
| Saturation | 1, 2, 3, 4 half-lives → 50, 75, 87.5, 94%; short tᵢ: S ≈ λtᵢ |
| Comparator | mₓ = m_s(Cₓ/C_s), with decay correction e^(λΔt); k₀ method uses one comparator |
| Schedules | short: ²⁸Al 2.24 min, ³⁸Cl, ⁵⁶Mn 2.58 h; medium: ²⁴Na 15 h, ⁴²K, ⁷⁶As, ¹⁹⁸Au; long: ⁵¹Cr, ⁵⁹Fe, ⁴⁶Sc, ⁶⁰Co |
| INAA vs RNAA | non-destructive, multi-element vs post-irradiation separation, no reagent blank, carriers |
| Interferences | (n,p) on Z + 1 and (n,α) on Z + 2 mimic (n,γ) on Z; fission of U; spectral overlap; ²⁴Na matrix |
| Variants | ENAA (Cd cover), FNAA 14 MeV (O, N), PGNAA (H, B, Cd, Gd), CPAA, PAA |
| Limits | poor for H, C, N, O (thermal), Pb, Bi; no speciation; needs reactor |
| Uses | rocks, meteorites, pottery provenance, forensics, high-purity Si, trace elements in tissue |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Nuclear Chemistry: Quick Revision: the whole chapter on one page.
- Cross-sections and neutron sources again: Nuclear Reactions.
- Detectors and counting statistics: Radio-analytical Techniques.
- Chapter overview: Nuclear Chemistry.