Ene, Cheletropic and Other Concerted Reactions
CSIR NET organic chemistry: ene and retro-ene reactions, cheletropic SO2 and CO, carbenes, diimide transfer, syn (Ei) eliminations and Bergman cyclisation.
- 16 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Cycloaddition Reactions: the general Woodward–Hoffmann rule and the Diels–Alder, which the ene reaction imitates.
- Sigmatropic Rearrangements: six-electron envelope and chair transition states.
- Carbenes: singlet and triplet carbenes and their addition to alkenes.
- Elimination Reactions: E2 versus syn (Ei) eliminations, which this page places in the pericyclic family.
The Hook: Butadiene in a Bottle
The Ene Reaction
- Six electrons (the C–H σ bond, the ene π bond, the enophile π bond) in a cyclic, envelope-shaped TS: \( [_{\sigma}2_s + {}_{\pi}2_s + {}_{\pi}2_s] \), three \( (4q+2)_s \) components, thermally allowed.
- It is the Diels–Alder with the diene’s second π bond replaced by an allylic C–H bond, which is why unactivated thermal ene reactions need much higher temperatures than Diels–Alder reactions.
- It shows a significant primary kinetic isotope effect (C–H breaking in the TS) and is suprafacial on the ene.
Enophiles and variants
| Variant | Enophile | Conditions | Product |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alder-ene | maleic anhydride, acrylates, DMAD, azodicarboxylates | heat | allylsuccinic anhydride etc. (propene + maleic anhydride → allylsuccinic anhydride) |
| Carbonyl-ene | aldehydes (formaldehyde, glyoxylates, chloral) | Lewis acid (Me₂AlCl, SnCl₄) or heat | homoallylic alcohol |
| Imino-ene, nitroso-ene | imines, ArN=O | allylic amines, N-allyl hydroxylamines | |
| Schenck ene | singlet oxygen ¹O₂ | photosensitised | allylic hydroperoxide (reduce → allylic alcohol) |
| Conia-ene | enol of a ketone acts as the ene; a tethered alkene or alkyne is the enophile | heat (or metal catalysis in modern variants) | cyclic ketone with a new ring (methylene- or methylcyclopentane unit) |
| Metallo-ene | allylmetal (Mg, Pd) as the ene component; the metal plays the role of H | cyclisations, often intramolecular |
The thermal ene reaction of β-pinene with formaldehyde, giving the homoallylic alcohol nopol, is a classic industrial example of the carbonyl-ene.
Selectivity
- Regiochemistry: the new C–C bond forms at the ene terminus remote from the transferred H; the double bond moves toward the carbon that lost H.
- Hydrogen choice: only H atoms that can align with the π system in the envelope TS react.
- Stereochemistry: an endo-type TS (enophile substituent under the ene) is often preferred, as in the Diels–Alder. Lewis-acid-catalysed carbonyl-ene reactions can be made highly enantioselective.
Intramolecular ene reactions
When ene and enophile are tethered, five- and six-membered rings form under much milder conditions than the intermolecular reaction, because the entropy cost is lower. The Conia-ene is the most frequently examined example: a 1,6-enone or 1,6-ynone (or alkynyl β-keto ester), via its enol, closes to a methylenecyclopentane bearing the ketone.
Retro-ene fragmentations
The reverse reaction breaks a C–C bond and transfers an H in a six-membered cyclic TS:
| Retro-ene | Substrate | Products |
|---|---|---|
| Homoallylic alcohol fragmentation | CH₂=CH–CH₂–C(OH)R₂ (heat) | propene + R₂C=O |
| Decarboxylation of β-keto acids and malonic acids | R–CO–CH₂–COOH | CO₂ + enol → ketone |
| Ester pyrolysis (Ei, below) | R₂CH–CR₂–O–C(O)CH₃ | alkene + CH₃COOH |
| Allyl or propargyl ether fragmentations | alkene + carbonyl |
The decarboxylation of malonic and β-keto acids (as in the malonic-ester and acetoacetic-ester syntheses) is a retro-ene: the carbonyl oxygen receives the carboxyl H through a six-membered ring, and the enol tautomerises.
Cheletropic Reactions
SO₂ and dienes
| Process | Electrons | Allowed thermal mode (linear) | Stereochemistry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Butadiene + SO₂ ⇌ 3-sulfolene | 4 (diene) + 2 (SO₂ lone pair) = 6 | diene suprafacial (disrotatory) | cis-2,5-dimethyl-3-sulfolene → (E,E)-hexa-2,4-diene; trans → (E,Z) |
| Hexatriene + SO₂ ⇌ 2,7-dihydrothiepine 1,1-dioxide | 6 + 2 = 8 | triene antarafacial (conrotatory) | opposite pattern to the diene case |
The rule: in a linear cheletropic reaction (SO₂ approaches along the symmetry axis and uses its lone pair as a \( \omega 2_s \) component), the polyene must react suprafacially if it has 4 π electrons (total 6, one \( (4q+2)_s \) component, odd) and antarafacially if it has 6 (\( [_{\pi}6_a + {}_{\omega}2_s] \), count 1, odd).
Read the stereochemistry like an electrocyclic reaction: disrotatory motion of the termini of a cis-2,5-disubstituted sulfolene turns both substituents outward, giving E,E.
Synthetic use: sulfolenes as diene stores (the hook); alkylation of the sulfolene anion at C2 followed by SO₂ extrusion gives substituted dienes of defined geometry.
CO and N₂ extrusion
- 7-Norbornenones and 7-norbornadienones lose CO very easily. Tetraphenylcyclopentadienone + an alkyne gives a Diels–Alder adduct that loses CO at once to give a hexasubstituted benzene (with diphenylacetylene, hexaphenylbenzene); with benzyne it gives 1,2,3,4-tetraphenylnaphthalene. The aromatic product drives the extrusion.
- Cyclopent-3-enones lose CO only at much higher temperatures; the bridged ketones are special because loss of CO relieves strain and forms an aromatic ring.
Carbene addition as a cheletropic reaction
A singlet carbene adding to an alkene forms two σ bonds to the carbene carbon: a [2+1] cheletropic addition.
| Approach | Orbital count | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Linear (carbene lone pair pointing at the C=C midpoint, in the plane of symmetry) | 4 electrons, Hückel array | forbidden |
| Non-linear (carbene approaches sideways, empty p orbital first meeting the alkene π, then swings round) | allowed | how singlet carbenes actually add |
Singlet additions are stereospecific (cis-alkene → cis-cyclopropane); triplet carbenes add stepwise through a 1,3-diradical and scramble. Simmons–Smith reagents behave like singlet carbenoids. See Carbenes for generation and spin states.
Group Transfer Reactions
Diimide reduction
cis-Diimide (HN=NH) transfers two hydrogens to the same face of a C=C (or C≡C) and releases N₂:
$$\text{HN{=}NH} + \text{R–CH{=}CH–R} \longrightarrow \text{N}_2 + \text{R–CH}_2\text{–CH}_2\text{–R}$$| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Orbital description | \( [_{\sigma}2_s + {}_{\sigma}2_s + {}_{\pi}2_s] \): six electrons, allowed thermally |
| Stereochemistry | syn addition of two H (or D) |
| Generation | hydrazine + H₂O₂ with Cu²⁺; potassium azodicarboxylate + acetic acid; heating p-toluenesulfonylhydrazide |
| Selectivity | reduces symmetrical, non-polar π bonds (C=C, C≡C, N=N); does not reduce C=O, C≡N, NO₂ or cleave O–O, N–O or C–halogen bonds |
| Rate | faster for less substituted and strained alkenes |
| Driving force | formation of N₂ |
Diimide is therefore the reagent of choice for reducing an alkene in a molecule that contains a peroxide, a nitro group or a benzyl ether, which catalytic hydrogenation would attack.
Stereochemical test (Part C favourite): DN=ND adds two D atoms syn. (Z)-But-2-ene gives meso-2,3-dideuteriobutane; (E)-but-2-ene gives the racemic (2R,3R)/(2S,3S) pair.
Other six-centre hydrogen transfers
Hydrogen transfer from 1,4-cyclohexadiene-type donors, and the Meerwein–Ponndorf–Verley/Oppenauer hydride transfers, also run through six-membered cyclic TSs, but MPV is metal-templated (aluminium alkoxide) and is not normally classified as pericyclic.
Pyrolytic Syn (Ei) Eliminations
Intramolecular eliminations in which a basic atom of the leaving group removes a β-hydrogen through a cyclic TS. All are syn eliminations and unimolecular; they are the retro-ene (six-centre) and five-centre group-transfer members of the pericyclic family.
| Reaction | Substrate | TS ring | Relative temperature needed | By-products |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Selenoxide elimination | R–Se(=O)Ph (from selenide + H₂O₂ or mCPBA) | 5 | lowest (often at or below room temperature) | PhSeOH |
| Sulfoxide elimination | R–S(=O)Ph | 5 | higher than selenoxide (heating needed) | PhSOH |
| Cope elimination | tertiary amine N-oxide | 5 | gentle heating | R₂NOH |
| Chugaev | xanthate R–O–C(=S)SMe | 6 | moderate | COS + MeSH |
| Ester pyrolysis | acetate or benzoate | 6 | highest | carboxylic acid |
Stereochemistry and regiochemistry
- The leaving group and the β-H must be syn (eclipsed or nearly so in the five-centre cases; within about 60° in the six-centre cases).
- In cyclohexanes, only β-H atoms cis to the leaving group can be removed.
- Regiochemistry is close to statistical: count the syn β-hydrogens on each side. This often gives substantial amounts of the less substituted (Hofmann-type) alkene, unlike E1 or E2 with small bases.
- Selenoxide elimination next to a carbonyl is the standard way to make an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl from a saturated one (α-selenation, oxidation, syn elimination).
Bergman Cyclisation and Other Concerted Reactions
- Bergman cyclisation: a (Z)-hex-3-ene-1,5-diyne (an enediyne) closes on heating to a 1,4-didehydrobenzene (para-benzyne diradical), which abstracts two H atoms to give benzene. It is a six-electron cyclisation using in-plane π orbitals of the alkynes. Ten-membered cyclic enediynes cyclise at body temperature; this is how the enediyne antitumour antibiotics (calicheamicin and relatives) cut DNA: the diradical abstracts H from the deoxyribose backbone.
- Dyotropic rearrangements: two σ bonds migrate simultaneously and intramolecularly. In type I the two groups exchange positions; in type II they move to new positions. Rare in exams; recognise the name.
- Cycloreversions: retro-Diels–Alder, retro-[3+2] (ozonolysis step), and the thermal decomposition of 1,2-dioxetanes into two carbonyl compounds, one formed in an excited state (chemiluminescence; see Organic Photochemistry).
graph TD
A["Concerted reaction:
which bonds change?"] --> B{"One new sigma bond
at the ends of ONE pi system?"}
B -->|"yes"| C["Electrocyclic"]
B -->|"no"| D{"Two new sigma bonds,
ring formed?"}
D -->|"to two different atoms"| E["Cycloaddition"]
D -->|"both to the SAME atom"| F["Cheletropic"]
D -->|"no ring formed"| G{"sigma bond moves
within one molecule?"}
G -->|"yes"| H["Sigmatropic"]
G -->|"H moves to enophile,
C-C bond forms"| I["Ene"]
G -->|"two H move to
another molecule"| J["Group transfer
(diimide)"]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Ene: one C–C bond forms, H transferred, ring not formed (intermolecular) | Diels–Alder: two C–C bonds form, six-membered ring | |
| Conia-ene: enol is the ene, intramolecular | Prins reaction: carbonyl + alkene via carbocation, acid-catalysed, stepwise | |
| Cheletropic: both bonds to one atom (SO₂, CO, CR₂) | Cycloaddition: bonds to two different atoms | |
| Singlet carbene: non-linear cheletropic, stereospecific | Triplet carbene: stepwise diradical, non-stereospecific | |
| Diimide: syn H₂ transfer, spares C=O, NO₂, O–O | Catalytic hydrogenation: syn too, but reduces many other groups and can isomerise alkenes | |
| Cope elimination (amine oxide, Ei) | Cope rearrangement ([3,3]) | |
| Ei: syn, unimolecular, statistical regiochemistry | E2: anti-periplanar, needs external base |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Give the Woodward–Hoffmann descriptor of the ene reaction.
- What is the stereochemistry of diimide addition to an alkene?
- Which diene forms when trans-2,5-dimethyl-3-sulfolene is heated?
Answers
- \( [_{\sigma}2_s + {}_{\pi}2_s + {}_{\pi}2_s] \).
- Syn (both H atoms delivered to the same face).
- (2E,4Z)-Hexa-2,4-diene: disrotatory motion turns one methyl out and one in.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Propene is heated with maleic anhydride. The product is:
(a) 4-methylcyclohex-4-ene-1,2-dicarboxylic anhydride (b) allylsuccinic anhydride (c) a cyclobutane [2+2] adduct (d) 3-methylcyclobutane-1,2-dicarboxylic anhydride
Answer: (b)
Propene has an allylic H but cannot act as a diene. In the ene reaction the terminal =CH₂ of propene bonds to one alkene carbon of the anhydride, a methyl H moves to the other, and the propene double bond shifts toward the old methyl carbon. The product is an allyl group (CH₂=CH–CH₂–) on the succinic anhydride ring: allylsuccinic anhydride.
Practice Q2. A molecule contains an isolated C=C, a ketone, a nitro group and an O–O bond. To reduce only the C=C, the best reagent is:
(a) H₂, Pd/C (b) NaBH₄ (c) potassium azodicarboxylate, AcOH (d) LiAlH₄
Answer: (c)
Potassium azodicarboxylate with acid generates diimide, which reduces the C=C by syn H transfer and leaves C=O, NO₂ and O–O intact. H₂/Pd would reduce the nitro group and cleave the peroxide; the hydrides reduce the ketone.
Practice Q3. The N,N-dimethylamine oxide of cis-2-methylcyclohexylamine is heated. The alkene formed is:
(a) 1-methylcyclohexene only (b) 3-methylcyclohexene only (c) a 1 : 1 mixture of 1- and 3-methylcyclohexene (d) methylenecyclohexane
Answer: (b)
Cope elimination is syn. In the cis isomer, the C2 hydrogen is trans to the N-oxide (the methyl is cis), so it cannot be removed. Only a C6 hydrogen cis to the leaving group is available, giving 3-methylcyclohexene.
Practice Q4. Which is a cheletropic reaction?
(a) Ozone + ethylene → primary ozonide (b) Dichlorocarbene (singlet) + cyclohexene → 7,7-dichloronorcarane (c) Ketene + cyclopentadiene → cyclobutanone (d) Cope rearrangement of hexa-1,5-diene
Answer: (b)
Both new σ bonds form to the same atom (the carbene carbon). (a) and (c) form bonds to two different atoms of the adding component; (d) is sigmatropic.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. 2-Butyl acetate is pyrolysed. Assume purely statistical selection among the β-hydrogens. Which statements are correct?
- The predicted 1-butene : 2-butenes ratio is 3 : 2.
- The reaction is a syn elimination through a six-membered cyclic TS.
- The fraction of 2-butenes predicted statistically is 40 %.
- An E1 reaction of 2-butanol in acid would be expected to give a higher fraction of 2-butenes than the pyrolysis.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a)
C1 has 3 β-H (→ 1-butene); C3 has 2 β-H (→ 2-butenes). Ratio 3 : 2 (1); fraction of 2-butenes \( 2/5 = 40\% \) (3). Ester pyrolysis is a six-centre syn Ei (2). E1 goes through the 2-butyl cation and favours the more substituted alkenes (Zaitsev), so 2-butenes would dominate (4).
Practice Q6. Consider the sequence: 3-sulfolene → (LDA, then MeI) → A → (heat, with methyl acrylate present) → B. Which statements are correct?
- A is 2-methyl-3-sulfolene.
- On heating, A extrudes SO₂ by a disrotatory (linear cheletropic) process to give penta-1,3-diene.
- B is formed by a Diels–Alder reaction and is mainly the “ortho” adduct, methyl 2-methylcyclohex-3-ene-1-carboxylate.
- The SO₂ extrusion is a [4+4] cycloreversion.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
Deprotonation of the sulfolene α to the sulfonyl group and methylation gives 2-methyl-3-sulfolene (1). Linear cheletropic loss of SO₂ from a 6-electron system is suprafacial on the diene (disrotatory); the product is penta-1,3-diene (2). A 1-substituted diene with an acrylate gives the “ortho” adduct (3). The extrusion is cheletropic (both bonds to S), not a [4+4] (4 wrong).
Practice Q7. (Z)-But-2-ene and (E)-but-2-ene are each treated with dideuteriodiimide (DN=ND). Which statements are correct?
- (Z)-But-2-ene gives meso-2,3-dideuteriobutane.
- (E)-But-2-ene gives racemic (2R,3R)/(2S,3S)-2,3-dideuteriobutane.
- The two products are enantiomers of each other.
- Both reactions release N₂ as the by-product.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
Syn addition to a cis alkene of a symmetric substrate gives the meso compound (1); to the trans alkene, the racemate (2). Meso and the chiral pair are diastereomers, not enantiomers (3 wrong). The other product of every diimide transfer is N₂ (4).
Quick Revision Table
| Topic | Key facts |
|---|---|
| Ene | ene (allylic H) + enophile; \( [\sigma 2_s + \pi 2_s + \pi 2_s] \); C–C bond + H transfer + C=C shift |
| Variants | carbonyl-ene (Lewis acid) → homoallylic alcohol; Schenck (¹O₂) → allylic OOH; Conia-ene (enol, intramolecular); metallo-ene |
| Retro-ene | β-keto/malonic acid decarboxylation; homoallylic alcohol fragmentation; ester pyrolysis |
| Cheletropic | two bonds to one atom: SO₂, CO, singlet carbene |
| SO₂ rule | diene + SO₂ (6 e): disrotatory; triene + SO₂ (8 e): conrotatory |
| Sulfolene stereo | cis-2,5-dimethyl → (E,E); trans → (E,Z) |
| CO extrusion | norbornadienones; tetraphenylcyclopentadienone + alkyne → arene + CO |
| Carbenes | singlet: non-linear, stereospecific; triplet: stepwise |
| Diimide | syn H₂; spares C=O, NO₂, O–O; less substituted and strained alkenes faster |
| Ei | syn; Se-oxide, S-oxide, N-oxide (5-ring); xanthate, ester (6-ring); statistical regiochemistry |
| Bergman | enediyne → p-benzyne diradical; DNA cleavage by enediyne antibiotics |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Next topic: Organic Photochemistry, including the Schenck ene and singlet-oxygen reactions.
- Previous: Sigmatropic Rearrangements.
- The full list of elimination mechanisms: Elimination Reactions.
- Back to the chapter overview.