Sigmatropic Rearrangements: [1,j], [3,3] and [2,3] Shifts
CSIR NET organic chemistry: [i,j] notation, suprafacial and antarafacial H and C shifts, Cope, Claisen and variants, chair TS stereochemistry, [2,3] shifts.
- 16 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: A Molecule With a Million Structures
- Naming a Sigmatropic Shift
- The Orbital Picture
- [1,5]- and [1,7]-Hydrogen Shifts
- [3,3] Shifts: the Cope Family
- [3,3] Shifts: the Claisen Family
- [2,3] Shifts
- [5,5] Shifts and Other Orders
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Orbital Symmetry and Electrocyclic Reactions: terminal phases of allyl, pentadienyl and heptatrienyl orbitals; the Hückel–Möbius count.
- Cycloaddition Reactions: the general “odd count is allowed” rule, used again here.
- Anionic, Sigmatropic and Aromatic Rearrangements: the named-reaction view of Claisen, Cope, Wittig and Sommelet–Hauser, which this page explains orbitally.
- Magnetic Resonance Principles: coalescence and exchange, used for degenerate rearrangements.
The Hook: A Molecule With a Million Structures
Naming a Sigmatropic Shift
| Shift | Breaking bond | New bond | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| [1,3] | C1–H | C3–H | (thermal H shift, not observed) |
| [1,5] | C1–H | C5–H | 5-substituted cyclopentadienes |
| [1,7] | C1–H | C7–H | previtamin D₃ → vitamin D₃ |
| [3,3] | C1–C1′ | C3–C3′ | Cope, Claisen |
| [2,3] | X1–C1′ | X2–C3′ (with X2 the anionic or ylidic atom) | [2,3]-Wittig, Mislow–Evans |
| [5,5] | N1–N1′ | C5–C5′ (para carbons) | benzidine rearrangement |
The migrating group in a [1,j] shift keeps atom 1 (H, or the migrating carbon); the other fragment is numbered 1 to j along the π system.
The Orbital Picture
Model the TS as the migrating group plus the radical of the π fragment it moves across: H (1s) + allyl radical for a [1,3] shift, H + pentadienyl radical for [1,5], H + heptatrienyl radical for [1,7]. The SOMO of the odd-carbon radical sets the phases at the two ends.
| Shift | Electrons in the TS | π fragment SOMO | Terminal phases | Thermal H shift |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [1,3] | 4 | allyl ψ₂: 0.707, 0, −0.707 | opposite | antarafacial needed → geometrically impossible for a 3-atom chain |
| [1,5] | 6 | pentadienyl ψ₃: 0.577, 0, −0.577, 0, 0.577 | same | suprafacial: easy |
| [1,7] | 8 | heptatrienyl ψ₄: 0.5, 0, −0.5, 0, 0.5, 0, −0.5 | opposite | antarafacial: possible in a flexible 7-atom chain |
A 1s orbital has one lobe, so the H must bond to lobes of the same sign: if the two ends of the SOMO have the same sign on the same face, the H slides across that face (suprafacial); if opposite, it must hop from top to bottom (antarafacial).
Selection rules for [1,j] shifts
| Electrons (j + 1) | Thermal | Photochemical |
|---|---|---|
| \( 4n + 2 \) ([1,5], 6 e) | suprafacial (retention at C) or antarafacial (inversion at C) | supra-inversion or antara-retention |
| \( 4n \) ([1,3], [1,7]; 4, 8 e) | antarafacial (retention) or suprafacial with inversion at a migrating carbon | supra-retention or antara-inversion |
For hydrogen there is no inversion option (a 1s orbital has no back lobe), so only the supra/antara choice matters.
Carbon migrations: retention or inversion
A migrating carbon uses a p-type orbital with two lobes of opposite sign. It can bond to the new terminus with the same lobe (retention of configuration) or with the back lobe (inversion), which flips one phase relationship.
- [1,3]-C shift, thermal: suprafacial with inversion at the migrating carbon is allowed. Berson’s experiment on a deuterium-labelled bicyclo[3.2.0]hept-2-ene, which rearranges to a norbornene, showed inversion at the migrating carbon, as predicted.
- [1,5]-C shift, thermal: suprafacial with retention.
These are the cases Part C uses to test whether you understand that “suprafacial” alone is not the full descriptor for a migrating carbon.
Aromatic TS check
A thermal [1,5]-H shift: 6 electrons, Hückel TS (no phase inversion), aromatic, allowed. A thermal suprafacial [1,3]-H: 4 electrons, Hückel, antiaromatic, forbidden. A [3,3] shift: 6 electrons in a chair or boat Hückel array, aromatic, allowed. Woodward–Hoffmann notation for the Cope: \( [_{\sigma}2_s + {}_{\pi}2_s + {}_{\pi}2_s] \), three \( (4q+2)_s \) components, odd, allowed.
[1,5]- and [1,7]-Hydrogen Shifts
Cyclopentadienes
5-Substituted cyclopentadienes isomerise by successive suprafacial [1,5]-H shifts around the ring, readily near room temperature for hydrogen, giving mixtures rich in the 1- and 2-substituted isomers.
graph LR
A["5-Methylcyclopenta-1,3-diene"] -->|"[1,5]-H"| B["1-Methylcyclopenta-1,3-diene"]
B -->|"[1,5]-H"| C["2-Methylcyclopenta-1,3-diene"]Practical consequence: to use a 5-substituted cyclopentadiene as a Diels–Alder diene (the classic route to prostaglandin intermediates), it must be generated and trapped at low temperature, before it scrambles.
In acyclic (Z)-1,3-pentadienes the same [1,5]-H shift is detected by deuterium labelling: the H moves on one face, so a chiral, labelled substrate gives products with a defined configuration at both ends, a direct proof of suprafaciality.
Cycloheptatrienes
Substituted cycloheptatrienes also equilibrate by suprafacial [1,5]-H shifts (a 7-substituent moves to positions 3, 2 and 1 in turn). Do not confuse this with the 6π electrocyclic cycloheptatriene ⇌ norcaradiene equilibrium.
Vitamin D: the [1,7] case
Previtamin D₃ (from photochemical ring opening of 7-dehydrocholesterol) contains a (Z)-triene with a CH₃ group at one end and a CH₂ at the other. A thermal antarafacial [1,7]-H shift moves a hydrogen from the C19 methyl to C9, giving vitamin D₃. The flexible triene can twist into a helix so the H can pass from one face to the other. This is the textbook example that antarafacial shifts happen when the chain is long enough.
[3,3] Shifts: the Cope Family
The Cope rearrangement
A 1,5-diene heated rearranges to an isomeric 1,5-diene through a six-membered TS, usually a chair.
| Driving force | Example |
|---|---|
| more substituted or conjugated alkene formed | 3-phenylhexa-1,5-diene → 1-phenylhexa-1,5-diene |
| relief of ring strain | cis-1,2-divinylcyclopropane → cis,cis-cyclohepta-1,4-diene (rapid under mild conditions; must use a boat TS) |
| tautomerisation (irreversible) | oxy-Cope |
Chair-TS stereochemistry (Doering–Roth)
| Substrate | Chair arrangement | Major product |
|---|---|---|
| meso-3,4-dimethylhexa-1,5-diene | one Me pseudo-equatorial, one pseudo-axial | (2E,6Z)-octa-2,6-diene, almost exclusively |
| (±)-3,4-dimethylhexa-1,5-diene | both Me pseudo-equatorial (favoured) or both axial | (2E,6E) major, (2Z,6Z) minor |
The rule for any chair [3,3]: an equatorial substituent at an sp³ terminus becomes an E double bond; an axial one becomes Z. If the reaction had gone through a boat, meso would have given E,E or Z,Z: the observed results rule the boat out for open-chain systems.
Oxy-Cope and anionic oxy-Cope
- Oxy-Cope: a 3-hydroxyhexa-1,5-diene gives an enol, which tautomerises to a δ,ε-unsaturated carbonyl compound; tautomerisation makes it irreversible.
- Anionic oxy-Cope: forming the potassium alkoxide (KH, 18-crown-6, THF) speeds the rearrangement by many orders of magnitude, so it runs at or near room temperature. The alkoxide weakens the adjacent C3–C4 bond. Ring expansion by four carbons (1,2-divinylcyclohexanol → cyclodecenone) is the classic use.
Degenerate and fluxional Cope systems
| Molecule | What happens |
|---|---|
| Hexa-1,5-diene itself | degenerate (product = reactant); seen only by isotopic labelling |
| Homotropilidene (bicyclo[5.1.0]octa-2,5-diene) | degenerate Cope through a boat TS |
| Bullvalene | every carbon can visit every position; \( 10!/3 \) equivalent structures; single ¹H line at high temperature |
| Semibullvalene | degenerate Cope so fast that it remains rapid even at very low temperature |
Aza- and other hetero-Cope reactions
- 2-Aza-Cope of iminium ions, coupled with an intramolecular Mannich reaction (aza-Cope–Mannich, Overman), builds pyrrolidine rings in alkaloid synthesis.
- Fischer indole synthesis: the arylhydrazone tautomerises to an ene-hydrazine, which undergoes a [3,3] shift (N–N bond breaks, C–C bond forms); cyclisation and loss of NH₃ give the indole.
[3,3] Shifts: the Claisen Family
Aliphatic Claisen
An allyl vinyl ether heated gives a γ,δ-unsaturated carbonyl compound; the strong C=O formed makes it essentially irreversible.
| Variant | Starting material | How the allyl vinyl ether is made | Product |
|---|---|---|---|
| Johnson–Claisen | allylic alcohol | heat with triethyl orthoacetate, catalytic propanoic acid (ketene acetal in situ) | γ,δ-unsaturated ester |
| Eschenmoser–Claisen | allylic alcohol | N,N-dimethylacetamide dimethyl acetal | γ,δ-unsaturated amide |
| Ireland–Claisen | allyl ester | LDA, then Me₃SiCl → silyl ketene acetal; rearranges near room temperature | γ,δ-unsaturated acid |
| Carroll | allyl β-keto ester | heat; Claisen then decarboxylation | γ,δ-unsaturated ketone |
| Bellus–Claisen and others | (recognise the pattern, not every name) |
Stereochemical control. Through a chair TS, the geometry of both alkenes sets the relative configuration at the two new sp³ centres, and a stereocentre at the allylic C–O carbon is transferred to the new C–C bond (1,3-chirality transfer), with the new double bond mainly E. In the Ireland–Claisen the enolate geometry is chosen by solvent: LDA in THF and LDA in THF–HMPA give opposite ketene-acetal geometries and hence opposite diastereomers of the acid from the same (E)-allylic ester.
Aromatic Claisen
Allyl phenyl ether heated (about 200 °C) gives 2-allylphenol:
- [3,3] shift to the ortho carbon: the allyl group is attached through its former terminal carbon (allylic inversion).
- The cyclohexadienone tautomerises to the aromatic phenol.
If both ortho positions carry substituents, the dienone cannot tautomerise; a Cope shift moves the allyl group to the para carbon (second inversion), then tautomerisation gives the 4-allylphenol, with the allyl group attached through its original carbon.
| Label in allyl phenyl ether | Ortho product (one inversion) | Para product (two inversions) |
|---|---|---|
| ¹⁴C at O–CH₂ | label at the terminal =CH₂ | label at the ring–CH₂ |
A biological Claisen
Chorismate → prephenate, catalysed by chorismate mutase in the shikimate pathway (phenylalanine and tyrosine biosynthesis), is a Claisen rearrangement. The enzyme binds the substrate in the chair-like conformation; it is the standard example of an enzyme-catalysed pericyclic reaction.
[2,3] Shifts
Six electrons over five atoms: an anionic (or ylidic) atom and an allyl unit. Thermally allowed suprafacially; usually fast at low temperature through a five-membered envelope TS.
| Reaction | Substrate | Product |
|---|---|---|
| [2,3]-Wittig | allyl ether deprotonated α to O (BuLi, low temperature) | homoallylic alcohol |
| Mislow–Evans | allylic sulfoxide ⇌ allylic sulfenate ester | trapped by a thiophile (P(OMe)₃) → allylic alcohol with allylic transposition; chirality at S transferred to C |
| Sulfonium / ammonium ylides | allyl sulfide + metal carbenoid (Doyle–Kirmse), allyl ammonium salt + base | homoallylic sulfide or amine |
| Sommelet–Hauser | benzyltrimethylammonium + NaNH₂ (ylide) | N,N-dimethyl-2-methylbenzylamine: the ylide formed at an N-methyl carbon bonds to the ortho ring carbon, that carbon becomes the new CH₂NMe₂, and the old benzylic CH₂ ends up as the ortho CH₃ after rearomatisation |
The [1,2]-Wittig and Stevens [1,2] rearrangements are formally sigmatropic but go by radical-pair cleavage and recombination; they are not concerted, need higher temperature, and compete with [2,3] when the [2,3] path is unavailable. See Carbanions for the ylide chemistry.
[5,5] Shifts and Other Orders
- Benzidine rearrangement: hydrazobenzene in strong acid gives mainly benzidine (4,4′-diaminobiphenyl). The major path is interpreted as a [5,5] shift of the diprotonated hydrazobenzene (the N–N bond breaks, the two para carbons bond); diphenyline and ortho-semidines come from other paths. Crossover experiments show it is intramolecular.
- Higher orders ([3,5], [5,5] in hydrocarbons) are rare in exam questions; apply the same electron count.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| [1,5]-H shift in cyclopentadienes (sigmatropic) | cycloheptatriene ⇌ norcaradiene (6π electrocyclic) | |
| Cope: all-carbon 1,5-diene → 1,5-diene | Claisen: allyl vinyl ether → γ,δ-unsaturated carbonyl | |
| Oxy-Cope: 3-hydroxy-1,5-diene → δ,ε-unsaturated carbonyl | Claisen: γ,δ-unsaturated carbonyl | |
| Aromatic Claisen to ortho: allyl inverted | to para (ortho blocked): allyl not inverted overall | |
| [2,3]-Wittig: concerted, low temperature, homoallylic alcohol | [1,2]-Wittig: radical pair, higher temperature | |
| Cope rearrangement ([3,3]) | Cope elimination (Ei of amine oxides) | |
| Degenerate rearrangement: product identical to reactant | Equilibrium between different isomers |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Classify the Claisen rearrangement as [i,j].
- Why is a suprafacial thermal [1,5]-H shift allowed?
- What product does the Johnson–Claisen give from an allylic alcohol?
Answers
- [3,3].
- Six electrons; the pentadienyl SOMO has same-sign terminal lobes on one face, so the H can bond to both ends on the same face (Hückel, aromatic TS).
- A γ,δ-unsaturated ethyl ester.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The conversion of previtamin D₃ to vitamin D₃ is a:
(a) thermal suprafacial [1,5]-H shift (b) thermal antarafacial [1,7]-H shift (c) photochemical suprafacial [1,7]-H shift (d) thermal [3,3] shift
Answer: (b)
Eight electrons (\( 4n \)) in a [1,7]-H shift: thermally antarafacial. The flexible triene allows it. (c) is the photochemical alternative but the step is thermal.
Practice Q2. Allyl phenyl ether labelled with ¹⁴C at the O–CH₂ carbon is heated. In the 2-allylphenol formed, the label is at:
(a) the CH₂ attached to the ring (b) the internal CH (c) the terminal =CH₂ (d) scrambled equally over both ends
Answer: (c)
In the [3,3] shift the new C–C bond forms from the ortho carbon to the former terminal allyl carbon; the original O–CH₂ becomes the terminal =CH₂.
Practice Q3. (±)-3,4-Diphenylhexa-1,5-diene undergoes Cope rearrangement through a chair TS. The major product is:
(a) (E,E)-1,6-diphenylhexa-1,5-diene (b) (E,Z)-1,6-diphenylhexa-1,5-diene (c) (Z,Z)-1,6-diphenylhexa-1,5-diene (d) 3,4-diphenylcyclohexene
Answer: (a)
The racemic diastereomer can put both phenyls pseudo-equatorial; equatorial substituents give E double bonds. Phenyl conjugation also drives the equilibrium to the product.
Practice Q4. Which reaction is not a concerted [2,3]-sigmatropic shift?
(a) Mislow–Evans rearrangement (b) [2,3]-Wittig rearrangement of an allyl benzyl ether anion at −78 °C (c) Stevens rearrangement of a benzylic ammonium ylide (d) Sommelet–Hauser rearrangement
Answer: (c)
The Stevens rearrangement is a [1,2] shift by radical-pair cleavage and recombination. The other three are [2,3] shifts.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A degenerate Cope system shows two ¹H signals separated by \( \Delta\nu = 120 \) Hz at low temperature; they coalesce at \( T_c = 253 \) K. (Illustrative data.) Using \( k_c = \pi\Delta\nu/\sqrt{2} \) and the Eyring equation, which statements are correct?
- The rate constant at coalescence is about 267 s⁻¹.
- \( \Delta G^{\ddagger} \) at 253 K is about 50 kJ mol⁻¹.
- At room temperature the two sites exchange faster than at 253 K, so the spectrum shows one averaged signal.
- Coalescence shows that the molecule has two different, non-interconverting structures.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
1: \( k_c = \pi \times 120/1.414 = 267 \) s⁻¹. Correct. 2: \( \Delta G^{\ddagger} = RT\left[\ln\left(\frac{k_B T}{h}\right) - \ln k_c\right] = 8.314 \times 253 \times (29.29 - 5.59) \) J mol⁻¹ \( \approx 49.9 \) kJ mol⁻¹. Correct. 3: faster exchange above \( T_c \) gives a single averaged line. Correct. 4: coalescence means the structures are interconverting. Incorrect.
Practice Q6. 2,6-Dimethylphenyl allyl ether, with the allyl group labelled by ¹⁴C at the O–CH₂ carbon, is heated. Which statements are correct?
- The first [3,3] shift gives a 6-allyl-2,6-dimethylcyclohexa-2,4-dienone that cannot tautomerise.
- The final product is 4-allyl-2,6-dimethylphenol.
- In the final product the label is on the CH₂ attached to the ring.
- The second step is a Cope rearrangement.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 4 only
Answer: (a)
Both ortho positions carry methyls, so the ortho-allyl dienone has a quaternary C6 with no H to lose (1). A [3,3] Cope moves the allyl to the para carbon (4), then tautomerisation gives 4-allyl-2,6-dimethylphenol (2). Two allylic inversions return the label to the ring-attached CH₂ (3).
Practice Q7. A deuterated, optically active (Z)-1,3-pentadiene with defined configuration at C5 undergoes a thermal [1,5]-H (or D) shift. Which statements are correct?
- The migrating atom stays on one face of the diene throughout.
- The configuration of the new stereocentre at C1 is related to that of the old C5 in a way fixed by suprafacial migration.
- An antarafacial path would give the same stereochemical outcome.
- A photochemical [1,5]-H shift would be expected to be antarafacial.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
Thermal [1,5]-H is suprafacial (1), which links the configurations at the departure and arrival carbons in one definite way (2). An antarafacial path would deliver the H to the other face and give the opposite relationship (3 wrong). For 6 electrons under hν, the allowed mode is antarafacial (4).
Quick Revision Table
| Topic | Key facts |
|---|---|
| Naming | number from the breaking σ bond; new bond i–j |
| [1,j]-H, thermal | [1,3] antara (not seen); [1,5] supra (easy); [1,7] antara (vitamin D) |
| Photochemical | reverse: [1,3] supra, [1,5] antara |
| Carbon migration | thermal [1,3]-C supra-inversion (Berson); [1,5]-C supra-retention |
| Cope | 1,5-diene, chair TS, Doering–Roth: meso → E,Z; (±) → E,E |
| Chair rule | equatorial → E; axial → Z |
| Driving forces | conjugation, strain (divinylcyclopropane, boat), tautomerisation (oxy-Cope) |
| Anionic oxy-Cope | KH, 18-crown-6; huge acceleration; ring expansion by 4 |
| Fluxional | bullvalene \( 10!/3 = 1\,209\,600 \) tautomers; semibullvalene very fast |
| Claisen | allyl vinyl ether → γ,δ-unsaturated C=O; Johnson ester, Eschenmoser amide, Ireland acid, Carroll ketone |
| Aromatic Claisen | ortho (one inversion); para when ortho blocked (Claisen + Cope, no net inversion) |
| [2,3] | [2,3]-Wittig → homoallylic alcohol; Mislow–Evans → allylic alcohol; Sommelet–Hauser |
| Not concerted | [1,2]-Wittig, Stevens (radical pairs) |
| [5,5] | benzidine; Fischer indole is [3,3]; chorismate → prephenate is Claisen |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Next topic: Ene, Cheletropic and Other Concerted Reactions.
- Previous: Cycloaddition Reactions.
- Named-reaction details and more examples: Anionic, Sigmatropic and Aromatic Rearrangements.
- Back to the chapter overview.