Free Radicals: Stability, Chain Reactions and Radical Synthesis
CSIR NET organic chemistry: radical stability, bond energies, halogenation selectivity, chain reactions, cyclisations, radical clocks and EPR detection.
- 15 min
On this page · 18 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Radical That Would Not Dimerise
- Structure
- Stability
- Generation
- Reactions of Radicals
- Chain Halogenation and Selectivity
- Radical Cyclisation and Radical Clocks
- Polarity of Radicals
- Named Radical Reactions to Recognise
- Detecting Radicals
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Carbocations and Carbanions: radicals sit between them, and the contrasts are what questions test.
- Reaction Mechanisms and Chain Reactions: initiation, propagation, termination and the steady-state treatment of H₂ + Br₂.
- EPR Spectroscopy: hyperfine splitting and line counting, used here on organic radicals.
- Chain-Growth Polymerization Kinetics: the same radical steps applied to polymer synthesis.
The Hook: The Radical That Would Not Dimerise
Structure
A free radical has an atom with an unpaired electron: for a carbon radical, seven valence electrons.
| Radical | Geometry | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| CH₃• | planar or very nearly planar | the unpaired electron is in a p orbital |
| Alkyl radicals (t-Bu•) | shallow pyramid, inverting rapidly | a chiral radical racemises |
| CF₃•, radicals with electronegative substituents | clearly pyramidal | more s character in the singly occupied orbital |
| Allyl, benzyl | planar, delocalised | spin shared over several carbons |
| Vinyl, aryl (σ radicals) | electron in an sp² orbital | very reactive |
Because a radical tolerates pyramidalisation far better than a carbocation does, bridgehead radicals form much more readily than bridgehead cations.
Stability
Bond dissociation energies
Radical stability is read from the bond dissociation enthalpy (BDE) of R–H: the weaker the bond, the more stable the radical. Approximate gas-phase values:
| Bond | BDE (kJ mol⁻¹, approx.) | Radical formed |
|---|---|---|
| C₆H₅–H | about 470 | phenyl (σ) |
| CH₂=CH–H | about 460 | vinyl (σ) |
| CH₃–H | about 439 | methyl |
| CH₃CH₂–H | about 423 | primary |
| (CH₃)₂CH–H | about 412 | secondary |
| (CH₃)₃C–H | about 404 | tertiary |
| PhCH₂–H | about 375 | benzyl |
| CH₂=CHCH₂–H | about 372 | allyl |
The spread from methyl to tertiary (about 35 kJ mol⁻¹) is much smaller than the corresponding spread for carbocations. Radicals are less sensitive to substitution because the stabilising interactions (hyperconjugation, delocalisation) involve one electron, not an empty orbital.
What stabilises a radical
| Factor | Example |
|---|---|
| Hyperconjugation with adjacent C–H/C–C | 3° > 2° > 1° |
| Delocalisation over π systems | allyl, benzyl, trityl |
| Both a donor and an acceptor on the radical carbon (captodative) | R₂N–C•(R)–CN, α-amino-α-carbonyl radicals |
| Lone-pair heteroatoms (α-O, α-N) and carbonyl groups | both stabilise, unlike for ions where only one type helps |
| Steric shielding (kinetic, “persistent”) | trityl, tri-tert-butylmethyl radical |
Generation
| Method | Example | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Thermal homolysis of weak bonds | (PhCO₂)₂ → 2 PhCO₂• → Ph• + CO₂ | peroxide O–O bonds are weak |
| Azo initiators | AIBN, Me₂C(CN)–N=N–C(CN)Me₂ → 2 Me₂C•(CN) + N₂ | loss of N₂ drives homolysis on gentle heating |
| Photolysis | Cl₂ or Br₂ + hν → 2 X•; ketones (Norrish type I) | light breaks the weakest bond |
| Atom abstraction | Bu₃Sn• + R–Br → Bu₃SnBr + R• | tin hydride chain chemistry |
| One-electron oxidation | Kolbe electrolysis: RCO₂⁻ → RCO₂• + e⁻ → R• + CO₂ | R• dimerises to R–R |
| One-electron reduction | Fenton: Fe²⁺ + H₂O₂ → Fe³⁺ + HO• + OH⁻; ArN₂⁺ + Cu(I) → Ar• (Sandmeyer) | redox initiation |
| Dissolving metals | Na or Li in NH₃; SmI₂; Mg | radical anions and ketyls (Birch, pinacol, acyloin) |
Reactions of Radicals
graph TD
R["Radical R-dot"] --> A["Atom abstraction
R + H-Y gives R-H + Y"]
R --> B["Addition to C=C or C=O
(cyclisation if intramolecular)"]
R --> C["Fragmentation
beta-scission, loss of CO2"]
R --> D["Rearrangement
ring opening, 1,2-aryl shift"]
R --> E["Termination
combination, disproportionation"]
R --> F["Electron transfer
to R+ or R-"]The first four are the propagation steps of chain reactions; the fifth ends chains.
Rearrangements: what radicals do not do
Simple 1,2-shifts of H or alkyl, so common in carbocations, are not observed in radicals. Radicals do show:
- 1,2-aryl shift (the neophyl rearrangement, PhC(CH₃)₂CH₂• → •C(CH₃)₂CH₂Ph), through a spiro-cyclohexadienyl radical.
- Ring opening of strained rings: cyclopropylmethyl radical → but-3-enyl radical (very fast).
- 1,5-hydrogen atom transfer (through a six-membered transition state), the basis of the Barton nitrite and Hofmann–Löffler–Freytag reactions.
Chain Halogenation and Selectivity
$$\text{Initiation: } \text{X}_2 \xrightarrow{h\nu} 2\,\text{X}^\bullet$$$$\text{Propagation: } \text{X}^\bullet + \text{R–H} \longrightarrow \text{HX} + \text{R}^\bullet; \qquad \text{R}^\bullet + \text{X}_2 \longrightarrow \text{R–X} + \text{X}^\bullet$$$$\text{Termination: } 2\,\text{X}^\bullet,\ \text{R}^\bullet + \text{X}^\bullet,\ 2\,\text{R}^\bullet \longrightarrow \text{non-radical products}$$| Halogen | H-abstraction step | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| F₂ | strongly exothermic | violent, unselective |
| Cl₂ | exothermic, early transition state | fast, only modestly selective |
| Br₂ | endothermic, late transition state (Hammond) | slow, highly selective for the weakest C–H |
| I₂ | strongly endothermic | does not proceed |
Commonly quoted relative reactivities per hydrogen near room temperature (to be used as given data, since they depend on temperature and phase):
| 1° | 2° | 3° | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chlorination | 1 | about 3.8 | about 5 |
| Bromination | 1 | about 80 | about 1600 |
where \( n_i \) is the number of equivalent hydrogens and \( r_i \) is the per-H reactivity. Example: chlorination of propane, \( 6 \times 1 : 2 \times 3.8 = 6 : 7.6 \), so about 44% 1-chloropropane and 56% 2-chloropropane.
Allylic and benzylic bromination with NBS
N-Bromosuccinimide in CCl₄ with light or a peroxide brominates allylic and benzylic positions (Wohl–Ziegler). NBS keeps the Br₂ concentration very low (it reacts with the HBr formed to release Br₂), so the allylic radical chain wins over ionic addition of Br₂ to the C=C. Unsymmetrical allylic radicals give mixtures of allylic bromides, including the transposed isomer.
Anti-Markovnikov addition of HBr
With peroxides, HBr adds to alkenes anti-Markovnikov (the Kharasch peroxide effect): Br• adds to the terminal carbon to give the more stable (secondary) radical, which abstracts H from HBr. HCl and HI do not show this effect: for HCl the H-abstraction from H–Cl is too endothermic, and for HI the addition of I• to the alkene is endothermic.
Radical Cyclisation and Radical Clocks
The 5-hexenyl radical cyclises mainly in the 5-exo-trig mode to the cyclopentylmethyl radical, even though 6-endo would give a more stable secondary radical. The chair-like transition state for 5-exo has better orbital overlap: this is kinetic control (Beckwith’s rules, consistent with Baldwin’s rules).
A unimolecular radical reaction of known rate constant is a radical clock. In a tin hydride reduction of 6-bromohex-1-ene, the 5-hexenyl radical either abstracts H from Bu₃SnH (giving hex-1-ene, uncyclised U) or cyclises first (giving methylcyclopentane, C). If [Bu₃SnH] stays roughly constant:
$$\frac{[\text{U}]}{[\text{C}]} = \frac{k_H[\text{Bu}_3\text{SnH}]}{k_c}$$Knowing \( k_c \) (the clock) gives \( k_H \), or the reverse. High tin hydride concentration favours the uncyclised product; slow addition of Bu₃SnH (low concentration) favours cyclisation.
Polarity of Radicals
Radicals are neutral, but substituents give them nucleophilic or electrophilic character, which controls rates of addition:
| Nucleophilic radicals | Electrophilic radicals |
|---|---|
| alkyl, α-alkoxyalkyl, acyl | Cl₃C•, RO•, CF₃•, α-carbonyl radicals |
| add fastest to electron-poor alkenes (acrylates, acrylonitrile) | add fastest to electron-rich alkenes (enol ethers) |
This is why alkyl radicals add efficiently to protonated (electron-poor) heteroarenes in the Minisci reaction, and why alternating copolymers form from donor and acceptor monomers.
Named Radical Reactions to Recognise
| Reaction | Reagents | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Barton–McCombie deoxygenation | ROH → xanthate ROC(S)SMe; Bu₃SnH, AIBN | Bu₃Sn• adds to C=S; fragmentation releases R•; R–OH becomes R–H |
| Barton decarboxylation | thiohydroxamate (Barton) ester, hν or heat, H donor | RCO₂• loses CO₂; R• trapped |
| Hunsdiecker | RCO₂Ag + Br₂ | R–Br with one carbon fewer |
| Kolbe electrolysis | RCO₂⁻, anodic oxidation | R–R |
| Barton nitrite photolysis | R–O–N=O, hν | RO• abstracts δ-H by 1,5-HAT; δ-nitroso, then oxime |
| Hofmann–Löffler–Freytag | N-haloamine, H⁺, hν or heat | aminium radical does 1,5-HAT; δ-halo amine cyclises to a pyrrolidine |
| Sandmeyer | ArN₂⁺ + CuX | aryl radical, then Ar–X |
| Birch reduction | arene, Na or Li, NH₃, ROH | radical anion → radical → carbanion; 1,4-cyclohexadiene |
| Pinacol coupling / McMurry | ketone + Mg or low-valent Ti | ketyl radicals couple; McMurry deoxygenates to the alkene |
| Acyloin condensation | ester + Na, xylene | ketyl-type radical anions couple; α-hydroxy ketone |
| Autoxidation | R–H + O₂ (chain) | hydroperoxides; ethers form explosive peroxides; BHT inhibits |
| SRN1 | ArX + Nu⁻, light or e⁻ | radical-anion chain substitution on unactivated arenes |
Detecting Radicals
- EPR spectroscopy: g close to 2.00 for organic radicals; hyperfine splitting by n equivalent nuclei of spin I gives \( 2nI + 1 \) lines (for protons, n + 1 lines with binomial intensities). Groups of inequivalent nuclei multiply.
- Spin trapping: short-lived radicals add to a nitrone (PBN, DMPO) or nitroso compound to give a persistent nitroxide that EPR can see.
- CIDNP: emission or enhanced absorption lines in an NMR spectrum recorded during the reaction show products formed from radical pairs.
- Radical clocks and stereochemical probes (loss of configuration).
- Inhibition by O₂, TEMPO, hydroquinone or BHT, and acceleration by initiators or light.
| Radical | Nuclei that split | Lines |
|---|---|---|
| CH₃• | 3 equivalent H | 4 (1 : 3 : 3 : 1) |
| C₆H₆•⁻ (benzene radical anion) | 6 equivalent H | 7 (1 : 6 : 15 : 20 : 15 : 6 : 1) |
| Naphthalene radical anion | 4 H (α) and 4 H (β) | 5 × 5 = 25 |
| (CH₃)₂CH• | 1 α-H, 6 equivalent β-H | 2 × 7 = 14 |
| CH₃CH₂• | 2 α-H, 3 β-H | 3 × 4 = 12 |
The proton splitting in a π radical is proportional to the spin density on the attached carbon (McConnell relation, \( a_H = Q\rho_C \)).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Radical stability (BDE scale, small spread) | Carbocation stability (large spread) | |
| Stable radical (weak R–H) | Persistent radical (long-lived, often steric) | |
| Kharasch peroxide effect: HBr anti-Markovnikov | Ionic HBr addition: Markovnikov | |
| NBS: allylic substitution | Br₂ in CCl₄ (dark): addition across C=C | |
| Radical cyclisation 5-exo (kinetic) | Cationic cyclisations governed by cation stability | |
| Barton–McCombie: C–O → C–H | Barton decarboxylation: C–CO₂H → C–H | |
| Hunsdiecker: RCO₂Ag → RBr | Kolbe: RCO₂⁻ → R–R |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What does AIBN do in a tin hydride reaction?
- Which bond is weaker: the benzylic C–H of toluene or the methyl C–H of ethane?
- How many lines appear in the EPR spectrum of the methyl radical?
Answers
- It is the radical initiator: on heating it loses N₂ to give two 2-cyano-2-propyl radicals, which abstract H from Bu₃SnH to start the Bu₃Sn• chain.
- The benzylic C–H (about 375 vs about 423 kJ mol⁻¹), because the benzyl radical is delocalised.
- Four lines, intensity 1 : 3 : 3 : 1.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The correct order of radical stability is:
(a) PhCH₂• > (CH₃)₃C• > (CH₃)₂CH• > CH₂=CH• (b) (CH₃)₃C• > PhCH₂• > CH₂=CH• > (CH₃)₂CH• (c) CH₂=CH• > PhCH₂• > (CH₃)₃C• > (CH₃)₂CH• (d) (CH₃)₂CH• > (CH₃)₃C• > PhCH₂• > CH₂=CH•
Answer: (a)
BDEs of the parent C–H bonds increase in the order benzylic < tertiary < secondary < vinylic, so radical stability runs the opposite way. The vinyl radical is a σ radical and least stable.
Practice Q2. But-1-ene reacts with HBr in the presence of benzoyl peroxide. The major product is:
(a) 2-bromobutane (b) 1-bromobutane (c) 1,2-dibromobutane (d) 3-bromobut-1-ene
Answer: (b)
Peroxide initiates a radical chain. Br• adds to C1 to give the secondary radical at C2, which abstracts H from HBr: 1-bromobutane (anti-Markovnikov).
Practice Q3. Cyclohexene is heated with NBS and a trace of benzoyl peroxide in CCl₄. The main product is:
(a) trans-1,2-dibromocyclohexane (b) 3-bromocyclohexene (c) 1-bromocyclohexene (d) bromocyclohexane
Answer: (b)
Allylic bromination (Wohl–Ziegler). The allylic C–H is the weakest; the low Br₂ concentration supplied by NBS suppresses addition to the double bond.
Practice Q4. Which observation is not expected for a radical chain reaction?
(a) acceleration by light or AIBN (b) an induction period in the presence of a small amount of TEMPO (c) a large negative Hammett ρ (about −4 to −5) with σ⁺ (d) loss of stereochemistry at a radical centre
Answer: (c)
A large negative ρ with σ⁺ signals carbocation character in the transition state. Radical reactions typically show small ρ values. The other three are classic radical signatures.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. 2-Methylbutane is monochlorinated photochemically. Take per-H relative reactivities of 1 : 3.8 : 5.0 for primary, secondary and tertiary C–H. Which statements are correct?
- Four constitutionally different monochlorides are formed.
- 2-Chloro-3-methylbutane is the major product, at about 35%.
- 2-Chloro-2-methylbutane is formed in about 23% yield.
- Under bromination conditions (per-H 1 : 80 : 1600), 2-bromo-2-methylbutane would be over 90% of the product.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 4 only (d) 2 and 3 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
2-Methylbutane, CH₃–CH(CH₃)–CH₂–CH₃: 6 equivalent primary H on the two methyls at C2 side (C1 and the branch), 3 primary H at C4, 2 secondary H at C3, 1 tertiary H at C2. Four products.
Weights: 1-chloro-2-methylbutane \( 6 \times 1 = 6 \); 1-chloro-3-methylbutane \( 3 \times 1 = 3 \); 2-chloro-3-methylbutane \( 2 \times 3.8 = 7.6 \); 2-chloro-2-methylbutane \( 1 \times 5 = 5 \). Total 21.6.
Percentages: 27.8, 13.9, 35.2, 23.1. Statements 1, 2 and 3 correct.
Bromination: weights 6, 3, \( 2 \times 80 = 160 \), 1600; total 1769; tertiary \( 1600/1769 = 90.4\% \). Statement 4 correct.
Practice Q6. 6-Bromohex-1-ene is reduced with Bu₃SnH (kept at 0.10 M) and AIBN at 25 °C. Take the rate constant for 5-exo cyclisation of the 5-hexenyl radical as \( k_c = 2.3 \times 10^5\ \text{s}^{-1} \) and for H-abstraction from Bu₃SnH as \( k_H = 2.0 \times 10^6\ \text{M}^{-1}\,\text{s}^{-1} \). Which statements are correct?
- The ratio hex-1-ene : methylcyclopentane is about 0.87.
- Methylcyclopentane is about 53% of the hydrocarbon product.
- At [Bu₃SnH] = 0.115 M the two products would be formed in equal amounts.
- Increasing [Bu₃SnH] increases the proportion of methylcyclopentane.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. \( [\text{U}]/[\text{C}] = k_H[\text{SnH}]/k_c = (2.0 \times 10^6)(0.10)/(2.3 \times 10^5) = 0.87 \).
- Correct. C fraction \( = 1/(1 + 0.87) = 0.535 \): about 53%.
- Correct. Equal amounts when \( k_H[\text{SnH}] = k_c \): \( [\text{SnH}] = 2.3 \times 10^5 / 2.0 \times 10^6 = 0.115 \) M.
- Wrong. More tin hydride traps the open-chain radical before it cyclises, so the uncyclised hex-1-ene increases.
Practice Q7. A radical generated by photolysis in a cavity gives a solution EPR spectrum of 14 lines: a doublet (large splitting) of septets (smaller splitting). Which statements are correct?
- The radical has one α-hydrogen and six equivalent β-hydrogens.
- The radical could be the isopropyl radical.
- The ethyl radical would give the same number of lines.
- The tert-butyl radical would give 10 lines.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
1 and 2. Correct. Doublet × septet = 2 × 7 = 14 lines: one H on the radical carbon and six equivalent H on two methyls, as in (CH₃)₂CH•. 3. Wrong. CH₃CH₂• has 2 α-H (triplet) and 3 β-H (quartet): 3 × 4 = 12 lines. 4. Correct. (CH₃)₃C• has 9 equivalent β-H: 9 + 1 = 10 lines.
Quick Revision Table
| Point | Fact |
|---|---|
| Structure | CH₃• planar; alkyl radicals shallow pyramids; CF₃• pyramidal; racemise |
| Stability | vinyl, aryl < CH₃ < 1° < 2° < 3° < allyl ≈ benzyl < trityl; small spread |
| BDE (kJ mol⁻¹, approx.) | CH₃–H 439, 1° 423, 2° 412, 3° 404, allyl 372, benzyl 375, vinyl 460, phenyl 470 |
| Captodative | donor + acceptor on the radical carbon |
| Initiators | AIBN, benzoyl peroxide, light |
| Selectivity per H | Cl 1 : 3.8 : 5; Br 1 : ~80 : ~1600 (1° : 2° : 3°) |
| HBr + peroxide | anti-Markovnikov; HCl, HI do not |
| NBS | allylic and benzylic bromination |
| Cyclisation | 5-hexenyl → cyclopentylmethyl (5-exo); [U]/[C] = k_H[SnH]/k_c |
| No shifts | no 1,2-H or alkyl shifts; 1,2-aryl (neophyl) and ring opening do occur |
| Detection | EPR, spin traps, CIDNP, radical clocks, inhibitors |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Carbenes: divalent carbon with two non-bonding electrons, where the triplet state is a diradical.
- Revisit radical kinetics in Reaction Mechanisms and Chain Reactions and Photochemical Reactions.
- Back to the chapter overview.