Skip to content

Stereogenicity, Chirality and Configurational Isomerism

CSIR NET organic chemistry: stereogenic units, CIP rules, R/S and E/Z, Fischer projections, meso and pseudoasymmetry, axial and planar chirality, topicity.

  • 22 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 18 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Two Carvones, One Label Rule
  3. Isomers: the Classification
  4. Chirality Is a Symmetry Property
  5. Stereogenicity
  6. The CIP Sequence Rules
  7. Fischer Projections, D/L, Erythro/Threo
  8. Molecules with More Than One Stereocentre
  9. Chirality Without a Stereocentre
  10. Optical Activity and Enantiomeric Composition
  11. Topicity: Prostereogenic Groups and Faces
  12. Memory Tricks
  13. Don’t Confuse
  14. Common Mistakes
  15. Practice
  16. Quick Revision Table
  17. Key Takeaways
  18. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Two Carvones, One Label Rule

Isomers: the Classification

graph TD
    I["Isomers
same molecular formula"] --> C["Constitutional isomers
different connectivity"] I --> S["Stereoisomers
same connectivity,
different 3D arrangement"] S --> CF["Configurational
interconvert only by
breaking bonds"] S --> CN["Conformational
interconvert by rotation
about single bonds"] CF --> EN["Enantiomers
non-superimposable
mirror images"] CF --> DI["Diastereomers
stereoisomers that are
not mirror images"] DI --> CT["cis/trans (E/Z) isomers"] DI --> MS["Isomers with two or more
stereogenic centres, incl. meso"] CN --> AT["Atropisomers: conformers
separable because rotation
is slow"]
  • Configuration is the arrangement that can be changed only by breaking and re-forming bonds (or, for an atom such as nitrogen, by inversion through a planar state).
  • Conformation is any arrangement reached by rotation about single bonds. Conformers normally interconvert far too fast to be isolated (see Conformational Isomerism in Acyclic Systems).
  • The boundary is set by the barrier, not by the type of motion. Hindered biaryls interconvert by rotation about a single bond, yet they can be separated: these are atropisomers, which the exam treats under axial chirality.
  • Enantiomers have identical scalar properties in an achiral environment and opposite signs of optical rotation. Diastereomers differ in every physical property (melting point, solubility, NMR, \( R_f \)).

Chirality Is a Symmetry Property

Chirality criterion
A molecule is chiral if and only if it has no improper rotation axis \( S_n \). Since \( S_1 = \sigma \) and \( S_2 = i \), a molecule with a mirror plane or a centre of inversion is achiral. A chiral molecule may still have proper axes \( C_n \).
  • Chiral point groups: \( C_1 \) (asymmetric), \( C_n \) and \( D_n \) (dissymmetric), and the rotation groups T, O, I.
  • Asymmetric means no symmetry at all (\( C_1 \)). Dissymmetric means chiral but with a \( C_n \): (R,R)-tartaric acid (\( C_2 \)), trans-1,2-dimethylcyclopropane (\( C_2 \)), [Co(en)₃]³⁺ (\( D_3 \)).
  • The \( S_4 \) case matters: a molecule with only an \( S_4 \) axis (no σ, no i) is achiral even though it has no plane to point at. Point-group details are on Point Groups.
  • A molecule should be judged on its accessible conformations. If any conformation reachable at the temperature of interest has an improper axis, or the molecule interconverts rapidly with its mirror image, it is not optically active. This is why cis-1,2-dimethylcyclohexane is not resolvable (see Cyclic Systems).

Stereogenicity

Stereogenic unit
An atom, bond, axis or plane is stereogenic if interchanging two of the groups attached to it gives a stereoisomer. If the interchange gives the enantiomer, a stereogenic atom is a chirality centre; if it gives a diastereomer, the unit is stereogenic without being a chirality centre (alkene carbons, pseudoasymmetric centres).

Two ideas, often confused, have to be separated:

TermMeaningExample
Stereogenic centreswapping two ligands gives a stereoisomerC2 of 2-butanol; each carbon of a C=C in 2-butene; C3 of 2,3,4-trihydroxyglutaric acid
Chirality centre (stereocentre in the narrow sense)a stereogenic atom whose swap gives the enantiomerC2 of 2-butanol
Pseudoasymmetric centrestereogenic, but its swap converts one achiral diastereomer into another; descriptor r/sC3 in the meso forms of 2,3,4-trihydroxyglutaric acid
Chirotopic atomany atom in a chiral environment (whether stereogenic or not)every atom of (R)-2-butanol, including the CH₃ carbons

So the alkene carbons of 2-butene are stereogenic but not chirality centres, and the pseudoasymmetric carbon is stereogenic but achirotopic.

Kinds of stereogenic unit

UnitRequirementTypical examplesDescriptor
Centre (point)tetrahedral atom with four different ligands, configurationally stableCHFClBr, 2-butanol, sulfoxides R–S(O)–R′, quaternary ammonium salts, P-stereogenic phosphinesR/S
Double bondeach sp² atom bears two different groups2-butene, oximes, iminesE/Z
Axistwo pairs of different groups held in perpendicular planes about an axis1,3-disubstituted allenes, ortho-substituted biaryls (BINOL), spiranes, 4-substituted alkylidenecyclohexanesRa/Sa or M/P
Planea plane of atoms that cannot flip, with a substituent making the two faces different(E)-cyclooctene, monosubstituted [2.2]paracyclophanes, 1,2-unsymmetrically disubstituted ferrocenesRp/Sp
Helixa screw-shaped moleculehexaheliceneP (right-handed) / M (left-handed)

Heteroatom stereocentres and inversion

  • Amines NR¹R²R³ with three different groups are chiral in principle, but invert through a planar transition state very rapidly. For NH₃ the inversion barrier is about 24 kJ mol⁻¹, so simple amines cannot be resolved.
  • Inversion is blocked when nitrogen is held in a rigid bicyclic framework (Tröger’s base is the classic resolvable example) or when the lone pair is replaced by a fourth group (quaternary ammonium salts, amine oxides).
  • Phosphines and sulfoxides invert slowly at room temperature, so P-stereogenic phosphines (DIPAMP, used in asymmetric hydrogenation) and chiral sulfoxides are configurationally stable. For assigning priorities, the lone pair is the lowest-priority “ligand”.

The CIP Sequence Rules

Cahn–Ingold–Prelog priority rules (working form)
  1. Atomic number: higher atomic number at the first point of difference gets priority. Compare atoms sphere by sphere outward, always exploring the highest-ranked branch first.
  2. Duplicate atoms: a double or triple bond is expanded into duplicated single bonds. C=O counts as C(O,O) for the carbon and O(C,C) for the oxygen; –C≡N counts as C(N,N,N).
  3. Mass number: if atomic numbers tie, the heavier isotope wins: D > H, ¹³C > ¹²C.
  4. Z before E: a seqcis (Z) branch outranks a seqtrans (E) branch.
  5. Like before unlike (R,R or S,S over R,S) and then R before S: these resolve pseudoasymmetric centres.

Assigning R/S: rank the four groups 1 to 4. View with group 4 pointing away. Trace 1 → 2 → 3: clockwise is R, anticlockwise is S. If group 4 points toward you, read the sense and reverse it.

Useful shortcuts:

  • Swapping any two groups inverts the descriptor; two swaps restore it.
  • Common rankings to know cold: –I > –Br > –Cl > –SH > –F > –OH > –NH₂ > –COOH > –CHO > –CH₂OH > –CN > –C₆H₅ > –C(CH₃)₃ > –CH=CH₂ > –CH(CH₃)₂ > –CH₂CH₃ > –CH₃ > –D > –H.
  • The first point of difference decides, not the total mass: –CH₂Br outranks –CCl₃ because Br > Cl at the first atom where the sets differ ({Br,H,H} versus {Cl,Cl,Cl}: compare the highest atom of each set first).

Worked examples

MoleculePriorities at the stereocentreDescriptor
D-GlyceraldehydeOH > CHO > CH₂OH > H(R)
L-AlanineNH₂ > COOH > CH₃ > H(S)
L-CysteineNH₂ > CH₂SH > COOH > H (S beats O at the second sphere)(R)
L-(+)-Lactic acidOH > COOH > CH₃ > H(S)

The cysteine row is the hook: same shape as L-alanine, opposite descriptor, because –CH₂SH ({S,H,H}) outranks –COOH ({O,O,O}) at the first point of difference.

E/Z versus cis/trans

E/Z uses CIP ranks on each alkene carbon: higher-ranked groups on the same side is Z (zusammen), on opposite sides E (entgegen). cis/trans refers to the main chain or to identical groups. The two need not agree: in 2-chlorobut-2-ene with the two methyl groups trans, the higher-ranked group on C2 is Cl and on C3 is CH₃; these are on the same side, so this “trans” isomer is (Z).

Fischer Projections, D/L, Erythro/Threo

A Fischer projection draws each stereocentre as a cross: horizontal bonds come toward the viewer, vertical bonds go away. It is an eclipsed conformation of the carbon chain.

Rules for Fischer projections
  • Allowed: rotation by 180° in the plane (configuration retained); any even number of interchanges of groups.
  • Not allowed: rotation by 90° in the plane or one interchange (each gives the enantiomer); lifting the drawing out of the plane.
  • Reading R/S: if the lowest-priority group is on a vertical bond, the observed sense of 1 → 2 → 3 is correct; if it is on a horizontal bond, reverse it.
  • D/L refers to the configuration of the highest-numbered stereocentre (the one farthest from C1) relative to glyceraldehyde: OH on the right is D. D/L has no fixed relation to R/S or to the sign of rotation; D-glyceraldehyde happens to be (R)-(+).
  • Erythro/threo describe two adjacent stereocentres in a Fischer projection: like groups on the same side is erythro (from erythrose), on opposite sides threo (from threose).
  • Syn/anti (Masamune) describe a chain drawn in zigzag: both substituents on the same face is syn. For two adjacent stereocentres, Fischer “same side” (erythro) corresponds to zigzag “opposite faces” (anti), because the Fischer projection is eclipsed and the zigzag is staggered anti. The older aldol literature used erythro/threo inconsistently, which is why syn/anti is now preferred.

Molecules with More Than One Stereocentre

Meso compounds

A meso compound has two or more stereocentres but is achiral because some accessible conformation has an improper axis (usually a mirror plane or a centre of inversion). meso-Tartaric acid is (2R,3S): its eclipsed conformation has a mirror plane, and its anti conformation has a centre of inversion.

Tests that work every time:

  1. Descriptors: a compound whose stereocentres are constitutionally equivalent and carry opposite descriptors (R,S) is meso.
  2. Fischer test: draw the Fischer projection; a horizontal mirror line through the middle means meso.

Counting stereoisomers

For n stereogenic units in an unsymmetrical molecule, the number of stereoisomers is \( 2^n \) (all chiral, \( 2^{n-1} \) pairs of enantiomers).

For a constitutionally symmetrical chain (the two halves have the same constitution, as in tartaric acid or the aldaric acids):

$$\text{n even:}\quad N = 2^{n-1} + 2^{\frac{n}{2}-1}, \qquad N_{\text{meso}} = 2^{\frac{n}{2}-1}$$$$\text{n odd:}\quad N = 2^{n-1}, \qquad N_{\text{meso}} = 2^{\frac{n-1}{2}}$$
CompoundnTotalMesoEnantiomeric pairs
2,3-Dibromobutane, tartaric acid2311
2,3,4-Trihydroxyglutaric acid; 2,3,4-tribromopentane3421
Hexaric (aldaric) acids HOOC(CHOH)₄COOH41024
Aldopentoses (unsymmetrical, for comparison)3804

The odd case contains the subtlety of the next section: the middle carbon is stereogenic only in the meso forms.

Pseudoasymmetric centres

In 2,3,4-trihydroxyglutaric acid, C3 carries H, OH and two –CH(OH)COOH groups that have the same constitution.

  • If C2 and C4 are both R (or both S), the two ligands on C3 are identical, C3 is not stereogenic, and the molecule is chiral: this gives one pair of enantiomers, (2R,4R) and (2S,4S).
  • If C2 is R and C4 is S, the two ligands on C3 are enantiomorphic (mirror-image groups). C3 is then stereogenic, and its two arrangements give two different meso compounds. C3 is a pseudoasymmetric centre, labelled r or s, with the rule R > S used to rank the two ligands.

Total: 2 + 2 = 4 stereoisomers, matching the n-odd formula.

The same idea applies when the “enantiomorphic” difference is replaced by an E/Z difference: in CH₃CH=CH–CH(OH)–CH=CHCH₃, C4 is stereogenic only when one double bond is E and the other Z (Rule 4, Z > E).

Chirality Without a Stereocentre

Axial chirality

Four groups are held in two perpendicular planes about an axis. The molecule is chiral if the two groups at each end of the axis differ (a ≠ b at one end and c ≠ d at the other; the two ends may carry the same pair).

ClassWhy the axis is stereogenicCondition for chirality
Allenes abC=C=Ccdterminal π systems are perpendicular, so the end groups lie in perpendicular planesa ≠ b and c ≠ d; 1,3-dichloroallene is chiral, 1,1-dichloroallene is not
Cumulenes in generalan even number of cumulated C=C (allene, pentatetraene) gives perpendicular endsan odd number (butatriene) puts the ends in one plane: cis/trans (E/Z) isomerism instead
Biaryls (atropisomers)bulky ortho substituents prevent rotation about the aryl–aryl bondeach ring unsymmetrically substituted about the axis; BINOL, 6,6′-dinitrobiphenyl-2,2′-dicarboxylic acid
Spiranesthe two rings are perpendicular at the spiro atomeach ring unsymmetrically substituted, e.g. spiro[3.3]heptane-2,6-dicarboxylic acid
Alkylidenecycloalkanesthe ring plane and the exocyclic C=C plane are perpendicular4-methylcyclohexylideneacetic acid

Naming an axis (Ra/Sa). View along the axis from either end. Rank the two near groups by CIP, then the two far groups; both near groups outrank both far groups. Trace near 1 → near 2 → far 1: clockwise is Ra, anticlockwise Sa. The same result is obtained from either end.

Helicity (P/M). Take the highest-ranked near group and the highest-ranked far group; if the turn from the near one to the far one is clockwise, the helix is P (plus), otherwise M (minus). For an axis, Ra ≡ M and Sa ≡ P.

Planar chirality and helicity

  • (E)-Cyclooctene is chiral: the trans C=C forces the chain to loop over one face of the double bond, and the loop cannot pass to the other face. The (Z) isomer is achiral.
  • Monosubstituted [2.2]paracyclophanes and ferrocenes with two different substituents on one ring (1,2-pattern) are planar-chiral: the substituted ring cannot rotate to present its other face.
  • Hexahelicene is a helix of six ortho-fused benzene rings; the ends overlap, so the left- (M) and right-handed (P) forms do not interconvert at room temperature.

Optical Activity and Enantiomeric Composition

Specific rotation and enantiomeric excess
$$[\alpha]_\lambda^T = \frac{\alpha}{l\,c} \qquad (\alpha \text{ in degrees},\ l \text{ in dm},\ c \text{ in g mL}^{-1})$$$$\text{ee} = \frac{|[R]-[S]|}{[R]+[S]}\times 100\% \;\approx\; \text{optical purity} = \frac{[\alpha]_{\text{obs}}}{[\alpha]_{\text{pure}}}\times 100\%$$

Major fraction \( = \tfrac{1}{2}(1 + \text{ee}) \); enantiomer ratio \( \text{er} = (1+\text{ee})/(1-\text{ee}) \).

  • The equality of ee and optical purity assumes rotation is linear in composition, which usually holds in dilute solution but can fail through aggregation.
  • The sign of rotation (+/−, or d/l) is measured, not predicted from R/S.
  • A racemate (50:50) has zero rotation. In the solid state it can crystallise as a conglomerate (separate crystals of each enantiomer, which Pasteur picked apart for sodium ammonium tartrate) or, more often, as a racemic compound (both enantiomers in one crystal lattice).
  • Resolution separates enantiomers by converting them into diastereomers (salt formation with an enantiopure acid or base, then crystallisation), by chromatography on a chiral stationary phase, or by kinetic resolution (see Asymmetric Induction).

Worked example. A pure enantiomer has \( [\alpha]_D = +50.0 \). A sample shows \( [\alpha]_D = +20.0 \). Optical purity = 20.0/50.0 = 40%, so the (+)-enantiomer is \( \tfrac{1}{2}(1 + 0.40) = 70\% \) of the mixture and the ratio is 70:30.

Topicity: Prostereogenic Groups and Faces

Two apparently identical groups (or the two faces of a trigonal centre) are classified by the substitution test: replace each in turn by a test group and compare the two products.

Relationship of the two productsGroups or faces areDistinguished byExample
identicalhomotopicnothingthe two H of CH₂Cl₂; the two faces of acetone
enantiomersenantiotopicchiral reagents, enzymes, chiral solvents; isochronous in ordinary NMRthe CH₂ protons of ethanol; the two faces of acetaldehyde
diastereomersdiastereotopicany method in principle: different NMR shifts (anisochronous), different reaction ratesthe CH₂ protons next to a stereocentre (C3 of 2-chlorobutane); the two H on C1 of propene

Symmetry gives the same answer faster: groups interchanged by a \( C_n \) are homotopic; groups interchanged only by an improper operation (σ, i, \( S_n \)) are enantiotopic; groups not interchanged by any operation are diastereotopic.

  • Pro-R / pro-S. In a prochiral CH₂ group of Caabc type, raise one H to D in thought (D > H). If the new centre is R, that H is pro-R.
  • Re / Si faces. At a trigonal carbon with three different groups, view one face and rank the three groups. Clockwise 1 → 2 → 3 is the Re face, anticlockwise the Si face.
  • Worked example. Acetaldehyde: O > CH₃ > H. Delivery of D⁻ to the Re face gives (R)-ethanol-1-d (product ranks OH > CH₃ > D > H). The same Re-face delivery of H⁻ to CH₃CDO gives (S)-ethanol-1-d. The face label does not by itself fix the product descriptor; the incoming group’s rank does.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisIs not this
Stereogenic centre: swap gives any stereoisomerChirality centre: swap gives the enantiomer
R/S: CIP label of a configuration(+)/(−): measured direction of rotation
D/L: comparison with glyceraldehyde in a Fischer projectionR/S: CIP ranking; no fixed relation
cis/trans: identical groups or main chainE/Z: CIP ranks on each alkene carbon
Erythro: same side in a Fischer projection (eclipsed)Syn: same face in a zigzag (staggered); for adjacent centres erythro ≈ anti
Enantiotopic protons: one NMR signal in achiral solventDiastereotopic protons: in principle two signals
Meso: achiral, has stereocentresRacemate: equimolar mixture of two chiral molecules
Pseudoasymmetric (r/s): stereogenic, achirotopicChirality centre (R/S)

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not taken from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. A molecule has an \( S_4 \) axis but no mirror plane and no centre of inversion. Is it chiral?
  2. Give the CIP descriptor of L-alanine.
  3. How many stereoisomers does 2,3,4-trihydroxyglutaric acid have, and how many are meso?
Answers
  1. No. Any improper axis makes a molecule achiral; σ and i are only the special cases \( S_1 \) and \( S_2 \).
  2. (S). NH₂ > COOH > CH₃ > H, anticlockwise with H at the back.
  3. 4 stereoisomers, 2 meso. Symmetrical chain with n = 3: \( N = 2^{2} = 4 \), \( N_{\text{meso}} = 2^{1} = 2 \). The two meso forms differ at the pseudoasymmetric C3 (r and s).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. Which of the following is chiral?

(a) 1,1-dichloroallene (b) 1,3-dichloroallene (c) (E)-1,4-dichlorobuta-1,2,3-triene (d) cis-1,2-dichlorocyclopropane

Answer: (b)

1,3-Dichloroallene carries H and Cl at both ends of a two-double-bond cumulene, whose end planes are perpendicular: it has a \( C_2 \) axis only (\( C_2 \) point group), so it is chiral. (a) has two identical groups at one end, so it has a mirror plane. (c) is a triene (three cumulated double bonds), whose ends lie in one plane: E/Z isomerism, planar, achiral. (d) is meso (mirror plane through C3 bisecting C1–C2).

Practice Q2. The number of stereoisomers of 2,3,4-tribromopentane, CH₃–CHBr–CHBr–CHBr–CH₃, is

(a) 8 (b) 6 (c) 4 (d) 3

Answer: (c)

The chain is constitutionally symmetrical with n = 3 stereogenic units (C3 being pseudoasymmetric when C2 and C4 have opposite configurations). \( N = 2^{n-1} = 4 \): one enantiomeric pair (2R,4R)/(2S,4S), in which C3 is not stereogenic, and two meso forms (2R,3r,4S) and (2R,3s,4S). Option (a) is \( 2^3 \), which ignores the symmetry.

Practice Q3. Which operation on a Fischer projection gives the same compound?

(a) rotating it by 90° in the plane of the paper (b) interchanging the two horizontal groups (c) rotating it by 180° in the plane of the paper (d) reflecting it through a vertical line

Answer: (c)

A 180° in-plane rotation keeps horizontal bonds horizontal (toward the viewer) and vertical bonds vertical (away), so the configuration is unchanged. A 90° rotation turns forward bonds into backward bonds (the enantiomer); one interchange gives the enantiomer; a reflection gives the enantiomer.

Practice Q4. In which compound are the two hydrogens of the indicated CH₂ group diastereotopic?

(a) the CH₂ of ethanol (b) the CH₂ of dichloromethane (c) the C3 CH₂ of (S)-2-chlorobutane (d) a CH₂ of 1,2-dichloroethane

Answer: (c)

Replacing either H on C3 of (S)-2-chlorobutane by a test group creates a second stereocentre next to a fixed (S) centre: the two products are (2S,3R) and (2S,3S), diastereomers. In (a) and (d) the substitution products are enantiomers (enantiotopic H); in (b) they are identical (homotopic H, related by a \( C_2 \)).

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. A pure enantiomer of compound X has \( [\alpha]_D = +40.0 \). A synthetic sample (c = 0.050 g mL⁻¹ in a 1.00 dm cell) shows an observed rotation of +1.20°. The sample is then mixed with an equal mass of racemic X. Assume rotation is linear in composition.

Which statements are correct?

  1. The specific rotation of the original sample is +24.0.
  2. The original sample contains 80% of the (+)-enantiomer.
  3. After mixing with racemate, the enantiomeric excess is 30%.
  4. After mixing, the enantiomer ratio is 3:1.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. Correct. \( [\alpha] = \alpha/(lc) = 1.20/(1.00 \times 0.050) = +24.0 \).
  2. Correct. ee = 24.0/40.0 = 60%; major fraction \( = \tfrac{1}{2}(1 + 0.60) = 0.80 \).
  3. Correct. Racemate adds equal amounts of both enantiomers, halving the excess: 60% → 30%.
  4. Wrong. At 30% ee the fractions are 0.65 and 0.35, ratio 65:35 ≈ 1.86:1. A 3:1 ratio would be 50% ee.

Practice Q6. Consider hepta-2,5-dien-4-ol, CH₃–CH=CH–CH(OH)–CH=CH–CH₃.

Which statements are correct?

  1. The compound has four stereoisomers in total.
  2. None of the stereoisomers is chiral.
  3. C4 is a stereogenic centre in the (2E,5E) isomer.
  4. C4 is pseudoasymmetric (r/s) in the isomer with one E and one Z double bond.

(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only

The two alkenyl groups on C4 have the same constitution.

  • (E,E) and (Z,Z): the two groups on C4 are identical, so C4 is not stereogenic and each molecule has a mirror plane through C4 (in a suitable conformation): 2 achiral isomers. Statement 3 is therefore wrong.
  • (E,Z): the two groups differ only in E/Z (a diastereomorphic difference), so C4 is stereogenic but its swap converts one achiral diastereomer into another. C4 is pseudoasymmetric, ranked by Rule 4 (Z > E): 2 achiral isomers, r and s. Statement 4 correct.

Total 2 + 2 = 4 (statement 1 correct), none chiral (statement 2 correct).

Practice Q7. An enzyme delivers hydride (or deuteride) exclusively to the Re face of the carbonyl carbon of acetaldehyde. Two experiments are run: (i) CH₃CHO with a deuteride donor; (ii) CH₃CDO with a hydride donor.

Which statements are correct?

  1. Experiment (i) gives (R)-ethanol-1-d.
  2. Experiment (ii) gives (S)-ethanol-1-d.
  3. The two faces of acetaldehyde are enantiotopic.
  4. The two methylene protons of ordinary ethanol are diastereotopic.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 3 and 4 only

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. Correct. On the Re face O → CH₃ → H is clockwise. D arrives from the viewer’s side; in the product OH > CH₃ > D > H. The lowest group H now lies roughly in the old plane; working through the geometry (or swapping D and H, reading, then swapping back) gives R.
  2. Correct. For CH₃CDO the face ranks are O > CH₃ > D; H arrives from the viewer, so the lowest-priority group points toward the viewer and the clockwise sense reverses: S.
  3. Correct. The molecular plane is a mirror plane exchanging the two faces; no proper rotation does: enantiotopic.
  4. Wrong. They are enantiotopic (substitution gives enantiomers), which is exactly why a chiral enzyme can distinguish them while ordinary NMR cannot.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
Chirality testno \( S_n \) (including σ and i)
Chiral point groups\( C_1 \), \( C_n \), \( D_n \), T, O, I
Stereogenic vs chirality centreany stereoisomer on swap vs the enantiomer on swap
CIP rule 1atomic number at first point of difference; duplicate atoms for multiple bonds
Lower rulesheavier isotope; Z > E; like > unlike; R > S
Fischerhorizontal toward viewer; 180° rotation allowed; 90° gives the enantiomer
Counting, unsymmetrical\( 2^n \)
Counting, symmetricaleven n: \( 2^{n-1} + 2^{n/2-1} \); odd n: \( 2^{n-1} \)
Pseudoasymmetricr/s; stereogenic only when its two like ligands are enantiomorphic (or E/Z-different)
Axial chiralityallenes (even cumulenes), biaryls, spiranes, alkylidenecycloalkanes; Ra ≡ M, Sa ≡ P
Planar/helical(E)-cyclooctene, paracyclophanes, 1,2-ferrocenes; hexahelicene P/M
ee\( [\alpha]_{\text{obs}}/[\alpha]_{\text{pure}} \); major = \( (1+\text{ee})/2 \)
Topicityhomotopic (\( C_n \)), enantiotopic (σ, i, \( S_n \) only), diastereotopic (none)
Re/Siclockwise = Re

Key Takeaways

What’s Next