Skip to content

Bond Angles, Bent's Rule and the Limits of VSEPR

CSIR NET chemistry: bond-angle trends, Drago's rule, Bent's rule, hybrid s character from angles, axial preference in TBP, pseudorotation and VSEPR failures.

  • 15 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 14 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Ammonia Is Not Phosphine
  3. Four Rules for Ordering Bond Angles
  4. Drago’s Rule: When Hybridisation Stops
  5. Bent’s Rule
  6. Axial and Equatorial in the Trigonal Bipyramid
  7. Where VSEPR Fails
  8. Memory Tricks
  9. Don’t Confuse
  10. Common Mistakes
  11. Practice
  12. Quick Revision Table
  13. Key Takeaways
  14. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Ammonia Is Not Phosphine

Four Rules for Ordering Bond Angles

Rule 1: More lone pairs, smaller angle (same steric number)

MoleculeLone pairs on central atomAngle
CH₄0109.5°
NH₃1about 107°
H₂O2about 104.5°

Lone pair–bond pair repulsion squeezes the bond pairs together; two lone pairs squeeze more than one.

Rule 2: More electronegative central atom, larger angle (same ligands)

HydrideAngleHydrideAngle
NH₃about 107°H₂Oabout 104.5°
PH₃about 93.5°H₂Sabout 92°
AsH₃about 92°H₂Seabout 91°
SbH₃about 91.5°H₂Teabout 90°

A more electronegative central atom pulls the bonding pairs towards itself. The bond pairs then sit closer together near the central atom and repel each other more, opening the angle.

Rule 3: More electronegative ligand, smaller angle (same central atom)

MoleculeAngleMoleculeAngle
NH₃about 107°PCl₃about 100°
NF₃about 102°PF₃about 98°

An electronegative ligand pulls the bonding pair away from the central atom. The bond-pair domains near the centre shrink, so they repel less and the lone pair compresses the angle further.

Rule 4: Size of the ligands can override electronegativity

MoleculeAngle
OF₂about 103°
H₂Oabout 104.5°
Cl₂Oabout 111°

By Rule 3 alone Cl₂O should have a smaller angle than H₂O, since Cl is more electronegative than H. The large chlorine atoms crowd each other and open the angle instead. OF₂ follows Rule 3 (F is more electronegative than H and small).

Drago’s Rule: When Hybridisation Stops

The angles near 90° in PH₃, AsH₃, H₂S and H₂Se suggest that the central atom bonds with almost pure p orbitals and keeps its s pair as a non-directional lone pair. Drago’s empirical rule says this happens when all three conditions hold:

  1. The central atom is in period 3 or below.
  2. It carries at least one lone pair.
  3. The electronegativity of the surrounding atoms is 2.5 or less (typically H).

Under these conditions the energy gap between ns and np is large and the orbitals are too diffuse for hybridisation to pay; bond angles are close to 90°. When the ligand is electronegative (PF₃, PCl₃) the angles rise towards 100°.

Bent’s Rule

Bent's rule
Atomic s character concentrates in hybrid orbitals directed towards electropositive substituents; p character concentrates in orbitals directed towards electronegative substituents.

The reasoning: s electrons are lower in energy and held closer to the nucleus. An electronegative substituent pulls bonding density away anyway, so the central atom gains little by spending s character on that bond. It does better to put its s character into bonds to electropositive groups, and into lone pairs.

Bent’s rule explains Rule 3: in NF₃ the N–F bonds take more p character, and p-rich hybrids make smaller angles with each other. It also makes testable predictions:

  • In CH₃F, the C–F bond has more p character than an sp³ hybrid and the C–H bonds more s character. So the H–C–H angles open above 109.5° and the F–C–H angles close below it.
  • In CH₂F₂ the F–C–F angle is smaller than tetrahedral and the H–C–H angle larger.
  • The lone pair of NH₃ or H₂O is s-rich, and the bonds are p-rich: the angles are below tetrahedral.

s character from a bond angle

For two equivalent hybrids each with fractional s character \( \alpha \), orthogonality requires

$$\boxed{\cos\theta = -\frac{\alpha}{1 - \alpha}} \qquad \text{or} \qquad \boxed{\alpha = \frac{\cos\theta}{\cos\theta - 1}}$$
Angle θ\( \alpha \) (s character)Hybrid
180°0.50sp
120°0.333sp²
109.47°0.25sp³
104.5°about 0.20(H₂O O–H bonds)
90°0pure p

NMR evidence: \( ^1J(^{13}\text{C}–^1\text{H}) \)

The one-bond C–H coupling constant rises with the s character of the carbon hybrid used in the bond, approximately

$$^1J(^{13}\text{C–H}) \approx 500\,\alpha\ \text{Hz}$$

Methane (sp³, \( \alpha = 0.25 \)) has about 125 Hz and ethyne (sp, \( \alpha = 0.5 \)) about 249 Hz, as the relation predicts. Ethene (about 156 Hz) and benzene come out a little below the sp² estimate of about 167 Hz; the relation is a correlation, not an exact law.

Axial and Equatorial in the Trigonal Bipyramid

The axial and equatorial positions of a trigonal bipyramid are not equivalent:

  • Axial bonds are longer than equatorial ones in PF₅ and PCl₅ (gas). An axial ligand has three neighbours at 90°; an equatorial one has two. In hybridisation language, the equatorial set is sp²-like (s-rich) and the axial pair p-rich.
  • More electronegative ligands go axial (sometimes called apicophilicity). By Bent’s rule, the p-rich axial orbitals suit electronegative groups. Examples: in PCl₂F₃ two F are axial and one equatorial; in PCl₃F₂ both F are axial; in CH₃PF₄ the methyl group is equatorial.
  • Lone pairs and multiple bonds go equatorial (previous topic). In SOF₄ the S=O bond is equatorial.

Berry pseudorotation

PF₅ shows only one ¹⁹F NMR environment at room temperature, although it has two axial and three equatorial fluorines. The molecule exchanges them faster than the NMR timescale by Berry pseudorotation: two equatorial F atoms open towards 180° while the two axial ones close towards 120°, passing through a square pyramidal transition state. One equatorial F (the pivot) stays equatorial. After one step the former axial atoms are equatorial and vice versa. The barrier is low, so the process is fast.

Where VSEPR Fails

VSEPR is a model for main-group molecules. Know its standard failures, because Part C uses them.

1. Stereochemically inactive lone pairs

[TeCl₆]²⁻, [SeCl₆]²⁻ and [SbCl₆]³⁻ each have a lone pair on the central atom (SN 7, AX₆E), yet they are regular octahedra. The lone pair sits in a spherical, s-type orbital and does not occupy a direction. Large central atoms surrounded by six large ligands leave no room for a directional lone pair. Contrast XeF₆, where the lone pair is stereochemically active and the octahedron is distorted.

2. Heavy alkaline-earth dihalides

Gas-phase CaF₂, SrF₂ and BaF₂ are bent, not linear as AX₂ demands. The usual explanations involve polarisation of the large cation’s core and participation of its (n−1)d orbitals. VSEPR, which only counts valence pairs, cannot predict this.

3. Transition-metal complexes

VSEPR counts electron pairs in the valence shell of a main-group atom. For d-block complexes the d electrons do not act as simple lone pairs: [Ni(CN)₄]²⁻ (\( d^8 \)) is square planar and [NiCl₄]²⁻ is tetrahedral, although both are four-coordinate Ni(II). Ligand-field and MO theory are needed.

4. Silyl compounds: planar N(SiH₃)₃

Trimethylamine N(CH₃)₃ is pyramidal, as VSEPR predicts. Trisilylamine N(SiH₃)₃ is planar at nitrogen, and the Si–O–Si angle in disiloxane (SiH₃)₂O is about 144°, far wider than the C–O–C angle in dimethyl ether (about 112°). The older explanation was N or O lone-pair donation into empty silicon 3d orbitals; the current view prefers donation into Si–H σ* orbitals (negative hyperconjugation) together with the electrostatic and steric effects of the electropositive silicon. Either way, VSEPR alone predicts the wrong geometry.

5. Limits of the model in general

  • VSEPR predicts shapes and the direction of deviations, not angles or bond lengths quantitatively.
  • It cannot rank cases where two effects compete without extra input (Cl₂O).
  • It says nothing about bond energies or magnetism; for those use molecular orbital theory.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Rule 2: more EN central atom opens the angle (NH₃ > PH₃)Rule 3: more EN ligand closes the angle (NF₃ < NH₃)
Drago: heavy central atom, H ligands, angles near 90°Bent: redistribution of s character, angles can open or close
Axial bonds in TBP longer, p-rich, prefer EN ligandsequatorial bonds shorter, s-rich, take lone pairs and double bonds
XeF₆: distorted octahedron (active lone pair)[TeCl₆]²⁻: regular octahedron (inactive lone pair)
N(CH₃)₃ pyramidalN(SiH₃)₃ planar

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which has the larger bond angle, NH₃ or NF₃?
  2. State Bent’s rule in one sentence.
  3. How many ¹⁹F NMR signals does PF₅ show at room temperature?
Answers
  1. NH₃ (about 107° against about 102°). F pulls the bonding pairs away from N, shrinking their domains.
  2. s character concentrates in orbitals directed towards electropositive substituents, and p character in orbitals directed towards electronegative substituents.
  3. One. Berry pseudorotation exchanges axial and equatorial fluorines rapidly.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. The correct order of bond angle is:

(a) H₂O > H₂S > H₂Se > H₂Te (b) H₂Te > H₂Se > H₂S > H₂O (c) H₂S > H₂O > H₂Se > H₂Te (d) H₂O > H₂Te > H₂Se > H₂S

Answer: (a)

About 104.5°, 92°, 91°, 90°. The central atom becomes less electronegative and less inclined to hybridise down the group (Drago’s rule), so the angles fall towards 90°.

Practice Q2. The correct order of the X–O–X bond angle is:

(a) OF₂ > H₂O > Cl₂O (b) Cl₂O > H₂O > OF₂ (c) H₂O > Cl₂O > OF₂ (d) H₂O > OF₂ > Cl₂O

Answer: (b)

Cl₂O (about 111°) > H₂O (about 104.5°) > OF₂ (about 103°). Fluorine’s electronegativity closes the angle; chlorine’s size opens it.

Practice Q3. In the trigonal bipyramidal molecule PCl₂F₃, the fluorine atoms occupy:

(a) all three equatorial positions (b) two axial and one equatorial position (c) one axial and two equatorial positions (d) the two axial positions only, with one F missing

Answer: (b)

More electronegative ligands prefer the p-rich axial sites (Bent’s rule). Both axial positions are filled by F; the third F and the two Cl are equatorial.

Practice Q4. Which of the following anions is a regular octahedron although its central atom carries a lone pair?

(a) [XeF₅]⁻ (b) [IF₆]⁺ (c) [TeCl₆]²⁻ (d) [SF₅]⁻

Answer: (c) [TeCl₆]²⁻

Te: 6 valence electrons, 6 Cl and a 2− charge give \( \frac{1}{2}(6 + 6 + 2) = 7 \): six bonds and one lone pair. The lone pair is stereochemically inactive, and the ion is a regular octahedron.

[IF₆]⁺ has no lone pair (\( \frac{1}{2}(7 + 6 - 1) = 6 \)) and is octahedral for the ordinary reason; it does not fit the question. [XeF₅]⁻ is pentagonal planar; [SF₅]⁻ (\( \frac{1}{2}(6 + 5 + 1) = 6 \)) is square pyramidal with an active lone pair.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. The H–N–H angle in NH₃ is about 107°. Treating the three N–H bonding hybrids as equivalent, their s character, and the s character left for the lone pair, are closest to:

(a) 22.6% and 32% (b) 25% and 25% (c) 33% and 0% (d) 18% and 46%

Answer: (a)

\( \cos 107° = -0.2924 \). \( \alpha = \frac{0.2924}{1.2924} = 0.226 \), so about 22.6% s character in each N–H hybrid.

Three bonds use \( 3 \times 22.6 = 67.9\% \) of nitrogen’s single s orbital; the lone pair has the remaining about 32%. The lone pair is s-rich compared with sp³ (25%), as Bent’s rule predicts.

Practice Q6. Consider the statements:

  1. In CH₃F the H–C–H angle is larger than 109.5°.
  2. The axial P–F bonds in PF₅ are shorter than the equatorial ones.
  3. N(SiH₃)₃ is planar at nitrogen while N(CH₃)₃ is pyramidal.
  4. Gas-phase BaF₂ is bent, contrary to the VSEPR prediction.

Which are correct?

(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
  1. Correct. Bent’s rule: the C–F bond is p-rich, the C–H bonds s-rich, so H–C–H opens.
  2. Wrong. Axial bonds are longer.
  3. Correct. A standard failure of VSEPR.
  4. Correct. Heavy alkaline-earth dihalides are bent in the gas phase.

Practice Q7. The ¹J(¹³C–¹H) coupling constant of a C–H bond is 200 Hz. Using \( J \approx 500\,\alpha \) Hz, the s character of the carbon hybrid, and the inter-orbital angle that two equivalent hybrids of that character would make, are:

(a) 40%, about 131.8° (b) 40%, about 120° (c) 33%, about 120° (d) 50%, 180°

Answer: (a)

\( \alpha = 200/500 = 0.40 \). For two equivalent hybrids, \( \cos\theta = -\frac{0.40}{0.60} = -0.667 \), so \( \theta = 131.8° \).

The angle here is a model value for two equivalent hybrids, not a measured angle. Use the relation only for hydrocarbons: electronegative substituents raise ¹J by themselves (chloroform, CHCl₃, has about 209 Hz), so a large J does not by itself prove a high s character.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
Lone pairsCH₄ 109.5° > NH₃ ≈ 107° > H₂O ≈ 104.5°
Central atom ENNH₃ > PH₃ > AsH₃ > SbH₃; H₂O > H₂S > H₂Se > H₂Te
Ligand ENNF₃ (≈ 102°) < NH₃; PF₃ (≈ 98°) < PCl₃ (≈ 100°)
Size winsOF₂ < H₂O < Cl₂O (≈ 111°)
Drago’s ruleperiod ≥ 3, lone pair, ligand EN ≤ 2.5: angles near 90°
Bent’s rules character to electropositive groups, p character to electronegative ones
s character\( \alpha = \cos\theta/(\cos\theta - 1) \); H₂O ≈ 20%, NH₃ ≈ 22.6%
\( ^1J(\text{C–H}) \)≈ 500 α Hz: CH₄ 125, C₂H₂ ≈ 249 Hz
TBPaxial longer; EN ligands axial; lp and π bonds equatorial
PseudorotationPF₅: one ¹⁹F signal at room temperature
VSEPR failures[TeCl₆]²⁻ regular; gas BaF₂ bent; d-block complexes; N(SiH₃)₃ planar

Key Takeaways

What’s Next