Bonding in Homonuclear Molecules: VB and MO Theory
CSIR NET chemistry: valence bond and LCAO-MO pictures, H2+ to Ne2, s-p mixing, bond order, magnetism, O2 and N2 ions, and homonuclear polyatomics.
- 15 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Liquid Oxygen Sticks to a Magnet
- Valence Bond Theory in Brief
- Molecular Orbital Theory: The Rules
- One- and Two-Electron Molecules
- Second-Period Homonuclear Diatomics
- Ions of O₂ and N₂
- Bond Order, Length, Energy and Magnetism: Using the Diagram
- Homonuclear Polyatomic Molecules and Ions
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Electronic Configuration, Shielding and Effective Nuclear Charge: atomic orbital energies and penetration set the MO diagram.
- Ionisation Energy and Electron Affinity: the 2s–2p energy gap grows across period 2, which is why the MO ordering changes at O₂.
- VSEPR Theory and the Shapes of Molecules for the Lewis-structure starting point.
- The quantum mechanics of the variation method and LCAO is in the physical chemistry units of the syllabus and overlaps with Physical Sciences.
The Hook: Liquid Oxygen Sticks to a Magnet
Valence Bond Theory in Brief
In valence bond (VB) theory a bond forms when two half-filled atomic orbitals on neighbouring atoms overlap and their electrons pair with opposite spins. Heitler and London (1927) treated H₂ this way and obtained most of the bond energy from the exchange of the two electrons between the atoms.
- σ bonds are cylindrically symmetric about the internuclear axis (s–s, s–p, end-on p–p, hybrid overlap).
- π bonds have one nodal plane containing the axis (side-on p–p overlap).
- Hybridisation and resonance extend the picture to polyatomic molecules: O₃ is a resonance hybrid of two structures, each with one O=O and one O–O bond.
VB theory is close to the chemist’s Lewis picture and gives good geometries, but it has well-known weaknesses: it predicts O₂ to be diamagnetic, it handles odd-electron species (H₂⁺, NO, O₂⁻) awkwardly, and it gives no natural account of electronic spectra or ionisation energies of molecules.
Molecular Orbital Theory: The Rules
In the LCAO approximation each molecular orbital is a linear combination of atomic orbitals. For two identical atoms A and B:
$$\psi_{\pm} = N_{\pm}\left(\phi_A \pm \phi_B\right), \qquad N_{\pm} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2(1 \pm S)}}$$where \( S = \int \phi_A \phi_B\, d\tau \) is the overlap integral. The in-phase combination \( \psi_+ \) builds up density between the nuclei (bonding); \( \psi_- \) has a node between them (antibonding). Because of the \( 1 \pm S \) normalisation, the antibonding orbital is raised more than the bonding orbital is lowered. That is why He₂ (two bonding and two antibonding electrons) has no chemical bond.
Atomic orbitals combine significantly only if they have
- the same symmetry with respect to the internuclear axis,
- comparable energies, and
- appreciable overlap.
\( N_b \) and \( N_a \) are the numbers of electrons in bonding and antibonding orbitals. Higher bond order means a shorter, stronger bond with a higher stretching frequency. Bond order zero means no stable molecule.
Symmetry labels. For homonuclear diatomics, orbitals symmetric to inversion through the bond centre are g (gerade), antisymmetric ones u (ungerade). A σ bonding orbital is \( \sigma_g \), a σ antibonding \( \sigma_u^* \); a π bonding orbital is \( \pi_u \), a π antibonding \( \pi_g^* \). Note the reversal for π.
One- and Two-Electron Molecules
| Species | Configuration | Bond order | Bond length | Dissociation energy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H₂⁺ | \( \sigma_g^1 \) | 0.5 | about 106 pm | about 256 kJ mol⁻¹ |
| H₂ | \( \sigma_g^2 \) | 1 | 74 pm | 436 kJ mol⁻¹ |
| He₂⁺ | \( \sigma_g^2 \sigma_u^{*1} \) | 0.5 | exists (spectroscopically observed) | |
| He₂ | \( \sigma_g^2 \sigma_u^{*2} \) | 0 | no stable molecule |
H₂ has twice the bond order of H₂⁺ but less than twice its bond energy (436 against \( 2 \times 256 = 512 \) kJ mol⁻¹), because the two electrons in the same orbital repel each other.
Second-Period Homonuclear Diatomics
Combining the 2s and 2p orbitals of two identical atoms gives eight valence MOs: \( \sigma_{2s}, \sigma_{2s}^*, \sigma_{2p}, \pi_{2p} \) (two), \( \pi_{2p}^* \) (two) and \( \sigma_{2p}^* \).
s–p mixing changes the order
The \( \sigma_{2s} \) and \( \sigma_{2p} \) orbitals have the same symmetry (\( \sigma_g \)), so if the 2s and 2p atomic orbitals are close in energy they mix. Mixing pushes the lower \( \sigma_g \) down and the upper \( \sigma_g \) (\( \sigma_{2p} \)) up, above the \( \pi_{2p} \) pair.
- Li₂ to N₂ (small 2s–2p gap, strong mixing): $$\sigma_{2s} < \sigma_{2s}^* < \pi_{2p} < \sigma_{2p} < \pi_{2p}^* < \sigma_{2p}^*$$
- O₂, F₂, Ne₂ (large 2s–2p gap, weak mixing): $$\sigma_{2s} < \sigma_{2s}^* < \sigma_{2p} < \pi_{2p} < \pi_{2p}^* < \sigma_{2p}^*$$
The 2s–2p gap grows across the period because the 2s orbital, which penetrates more, feels the rising nuclear charge more strongly and drops faster in energy.
graph LR
A[2s-2p gap small: Li to N] --> B[strong s-p mixing]
B --> C[sigma 2p above pi 2p]
C --> D[B2 paramagnetic, C2 diamagnetic, N2 HOMO is sigma]
E[2s-2p gap large: O and F] --> F[weak mixing]
F --> G[sigma 2p below pi 2p]The table to know
| Molecule | Valence e⁻ | Valence configuration | Bond order | Unpaired e⁻ | Bond length (pm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Li₂ | 2 | \( \sigma_{2s}^2 \) | 1 | 0 | 267 |
| Be₂ | 4 | \( \sigma_{2s}^2\sigma_{2s}^{*2} \) | 0 | 0 | not stable |
| B₂ | 6 | \( \ldots\pi_{2p}^2 \) | 1 | 2 | 159 |
| C₂ | 8 | \( \ldots\pi_{2p}^4 \) | 2 | 0 | 124 |
| N₂ | 10 | \( \ldots\pi_{2p}^4\sigma_{2p}^2 \) | 3 | 0 | 110 |
| O₂ | 12 | \( \ldots\sigma_{2p}^2\pi_{2p}^4\pi_{2p}^{*2} \) | 2 | 2 | 121 |
| F₂ | 14 | \( \ldots\pi_{2p}^{*4} \) | 1 | 0 | 142 |
| Ne₂ | 16 | all bonding and antibonding filled | 0 | 0 | not stable |
(\( \ldots \) stands for \( \sigma_{2s}^2\sigma_{2s}^{*2} \).) Bond enthalpies: N₂ about 945, O₂ about 498 and F₂ about 158 kJ mol⁻¹. The fall from N₂ to F₂ tracks the bond order 3, 2, 1.
Ions of O₂ and N₂
Adding or removing electrons changes the bond order in a predictable direction, depending on whether the orbital involved is bonding or antibonding.
| Species | Valence e⁻ | Change from parent | Bond order | Unpaired e⁻ | O–O length (pm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| O₂⁺ (dioxygenyl) | 11 | remove one \( \pi^* \) | 2.5 | 1 | about 112 |
| O₂ | 12 | 2 | 2 | about 121 | |
| O₂⁻ (superoxide) | 13 | add one \( \pi^* \) | 1.5 | 1 | about 128 |
| O₂²⁻ (peroxide) | 14 | add two \( \pi^* \) | 1 | 0 | about 149 |
Order of bond length: \( \text{O}_2^+ < \text{O}_2 < \text{O}_2^- < \text{O}_2^{2-} \). Order of bond energy and stretching frequency: the reverse.
For nitrogen the HOMO is bonding, so the trend runs the other way on ionisation:
| Species | Valence e⁻ | Bond order | Unpaired e⁻ | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| N₂ | 10 | 3 | 0 | 110 pm |
| N₂⁺ | 9 | 2.5 | 1 | bonding \( \sigma_{2p} \) electron removed: bond longer (about 112 pm) |
| N₂⁻ | 11 | 2.5 | 1 | antibonding \( \pi^* \) electron added |
Other isoelectronic species follow the same diagram: C₂²⁻ (acetylide, as in CaC₂) has 10 valence electrons and bond order 3, like N₂; C₂⁻ has 9 and bond order 2.5.
Bond Order, Length, Energy and Magnetism: Using the Diagram
A fast routine for any homonuclear diatomic or ion from period 2:
- Count valence electrons (add for negative charge, subtract for positive).
- Choose the ordering: up to 10 electrons with \( \pi_{2p} \) below \( \sigma_{2p} \) for B₂, C₂, N₂ and their ions; O₂ and F₂ ordering beyond that. (For species with 11–14 electrons, both orderings give the same answers.)
- Fill with Aufbau and Hund’s rule; read bond order and unpaired electrons.
- Higher bond order: shorter, stronger, higher frequency.
Homonuclear Polyatomic Molecules and Ions
The MO idea extends beyond diatomics. Four classic cases:
- O₃: bent (about 117°), with two equal O–O bonds (about 128 pm), between the O=O in O₂ (121 pm) and the O–O single bond in H₂O₂ (about 148 pm). In MO terms, a three-centre π system holds four π electrons (one bonding and one non-bonding π orbital filled), giving a π bond order of 0.5 per link and a total O–O bond order of 1.5. VB says the same thing with two resonance structures.
- N₃⁻ (azide): linear, two equal N–N bonds, isoelectronic with CO₂ (16 valence electrons). In covalent azides such as HN₃ the two N–N bonds become unequal.
- I₃⁻ (triiodide): linear, described by a three-centre four-electron (3c–4e) σ bond with bond order 0.5 per I–I link. The same model covers XeF₂ and is developed in Bonding in Heteronuclear Molecules.
- P₄ and S₈: element structures built from single bonds, because the larger period 3 atoms form weak pπ–pπ bonds (the first-row anomaly in reverse; see Electronegativity and Periodic Anomalies). P₄ is a tetrahedron with P–P–P angles of 60°, strongly strained, which is one reason white phosphorus is so reactive. S₈ is a puckered crown ring.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| B₂: paramagnetic (2 unpaired, \( \pi^2 \)) | C₂: diamagnetic (\( \pi^4 \)) | |
| N₂⁺: bond longer than N₂ (bonding e⁻ lost) | O₂⁺: bond shorter than O₂ (antibonding e⁻ lost) | |
| O₂⁻ superoxide: bond order 1.5, paramagnetic | O₂²⁻ peroxide: bond order 1, diamagnetic | |
| \( \sigma_g \) bonding, \( \sigma_u^* \) antibonding | \( \pi_u \) bonding, \( \pi_g^* \) antibonding | |
| VB: O₂ diamagnetic (wrong) | MO: O₂ paramagnetic (right) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the bond order of O₂⁻?
- How many unpaired electrons does B₂ have?
- Which has the shorter bond, N₂ or N₂⁺?
Answers
- 1.5. 13 valence electrons: \( (16 - 13)/2 = 1.5 \).
- 2, in the degenerate \( \pi_{2p} \) pair (s–p mixed ordering).
- N₂. N₂⁺ loses a bonding \( \sigma_{2p} \) electron; bond order falls from 3 to 2.5.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which of the following is paramagnetic?
(a) C₂ (b) N₂ (c) B₂ (d) F₂
Answer: (c) B₂
B₂ (6 valence electrons): \( \sigma_{2s}^2\sigma_{2s}^{*2}\pi_{2p}^1\pi_{2p}^1 \), two unpaired. C₂ (\( \pi^4 \)), N₂ (\( \pi^4\sigma^2 \)) and F₂ (\( \pi^{*4} \)) are all diamagnetic.
Practice Q2. The correct order of O–O bond length is:
(a) O₂ < O₂⁺ < O₂⁻ < O₂²⁻ (b) O₂⁺ < O₂ < O₂⁻ < O₂²⁻ (c) O₂²⁻ < O₂⁻ < O₂ < O₂⁺ (d) O₂⁺ < O₂⁻ < O₂ < O₂²⁻
Answer: (b)
Bond orders 2.5, 2, 1.5, 1. Higher bond order, shorter bond: about 112, 121, 128, 149 pm.
Practice Q3. The bond order and magnetic behaviour of C₂²⁻ are:
(a) 2, paramagnetic (b) 3, diamagnetic (c) 2.5, paramagnetic (d) 3, paramagnetic
Answer: (b)
C₂²⁻ has \( 8 + 2 = 10 \) valence electrons, isoelectronic with N₂: \( \sigma_{2s}^2\sigma_{2s}^{*2}\pi_{2p}^4\sigma_{2p}^2 \). Bond order \( (8 - 2)/2 = 3 \), all paired.
Practice Q4. Which species has bond order 2.5 and has its unpaired electron in a bonding orbital?
(a) O₂⁺ (b) N₂⁺ (c) N₂⁻ (d) O₂⁻
Answer: (b) N₂⁺
N₂⁺ (9 electrons): \( \ldots\pi_{2p}^4\sigma_{2p}^1 \), bond order 2.5, unpaired electron in the bonding \( \sigma_{2p} \).
O₂⁺ and N₂⁻ also have bond order 2.5, but their unpaired electron is in \( \pi^* \) (antibonding). O₂⁻ has bond order 1.5.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Consider the statements:
- Without s–p mixing, B₂ would be predicted to be diamagnetic.
- The N–N bond in N₂⁺ is longer than that in N₂.
- The peroxide ion O₂²⁻ is paramagnetic.
- He₂⁺ has a bond order of 0.5.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. With \( \sigma_{2p} \) below \( \pi_{2p} \), B₂’s last two electrons would pair in \( \sigma_{2p} \).
- Correct. A bonding electron is removed.
- Wrong. O₂²⁻ has \( \pi^{*4} \): all paired.
- Correct. \( \sigma_g^2\sigma_u^{*1} \): \( (2 - 1)/2 = 0.5 \).
Practice Q6. The sum of the unpaired electrons in O₂, O₂⁺, O₂⁻ and O₂²⁻, and the sum of their bond orders, are respectively:
(a) 4 and 7 (b) 5 and 7 (c) 4 and 6 (d) 3 and 7
Answer: (a) 4 and 7
Unpaired: \( 2 + 1 + 1 + 0 = 4 \). Bond orders: \( 2 + 2.5 + 1.5 + 1 = 7 \).
Practice Q7. The dissociation energy of H₂⁺ is about 256 kJ mol⁻¹ and that of H₂ is 436 kJ mol⁻¹. Which statements are correct?
- Doubling the bond order from H₂⁺ to H₂ does not double the bond energy.
- The shortfall, about 76 kJ mol⁻¹ from \( 2 \times 256 \), reflects repulsion between the two electrons in the \( \sigma_g \) orbital (and the changed bond length).
- H₂⁺ has a shorter bond than H₂.
- Both species are diamagnetic.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1 and 2 only
- Correct. \( 436 < 2 \times 256 = 512 \).
- Correct. \( 512 - 436 = 76 \) kJ mol⁻¹; the second electron adds less because it repels the first.
- Wrong. H₂⁺ (bond order 0.5) is longer, about 106 pm against 74 pm.
- Wrong. H₂⁺ has one unpaired electron and is paramagnetic.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| LCAO conditions | same symmetry, similar energy, good overlap |
| Antibonding | raised more than bonding is lowered (\( 1 \pm S \)) |
| Bond order | \( \frac{1}{2}(N_b - N_a) \); 10–16 valence e⁻: \( (16 - n)/2 \) |
| Order, Li₂–N₂ | \( \sigma_{2s} < \sigma_{2s}^* < \pi_{2p} < \sigma_{2p} < \pi^* < \sigma^* \) |
| Order, O₂–Ne₂ | \( \sigma_{2s} < \sigma_{2s}^* < \sigma_{2p} < \pi_{2p} < \pi^* < \sigma^* \) |
| Paramagnetic diatomics | B₂, O₂ (2 unpaired each) |
| Bond orders | Li₂ 1, Be₂ 0, B₂ 1, C₂ 2, N₂ 3, O₂ 2, F₂ 1, Ne₂ 0 |
| O₂ series | O₂⁺ 2.5 (112) < O₂ 2 (121) < O₂⁻ 1.5 (128) < O₂²⁻ 1 (149 pm) |
| N₂⁺ | bond order 2.5, longer than N₂ (HOMO \( \sigma_{2p} \) bonding) |
| Isoelectronic with N₂ | C₂²⁻, CO, CN⁻, NO⁺ (bond order 3) |
| Polyatomic | O₃ bond order 1.5; I₃⁻ 3c–4e; P₄ 60° angles |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Bonding in Heteronuclear Molecules: CO, NO, HF, polarity, dipole moments and multicentre bonds.
- Structure and Bonding: Quick Revision.
- Revisit shapes in VSEPR Theory and the Shapes of Molecules.
- Orbital energies come from Ionisation Energy and Electron Affinity.