VSEPR Theory and the Shapes of Molecules
CSIR NET chemistry: VSEPR postulates, steric number, AXnEm shapes from 2 to 7 electron pairs, lone-pair placement, interhalogens and xenon fluorides.
- 14 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Why ClF₃ Is Not Flat Like BF₃
- The Postulates
- The Procedure
- The Shape Table
- Where the Lone Pairs Go
- The Xenon Compounds in One Table
- Interhalogens and Polyhalide Ions
- Isoelectronic Means Isostructural
- Odd-Electron Species
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Lewis structures and formal charge (BSc level).
- Electronegativity Scales and Periodic Anomalies: electronegativity changes the size of an electron domain, and the first-row anomaly limits period 2 atoms to four pairs.
- This is the first topic of Structure and Bonding in Molecules (VSEPR). Bond-angle detail and the failures of the model follow in Bond Angles, Bent’s Rule and the Limits of VSEPR.
The Hook: Why ClF₃ Is Not Flat Like BF₃
The Postulates
- The electron pairs in the valence shell of the central atom, bonding and non-bonding, arrange themselves as far apart as possible to minimise repulsion.
- A multiple bond is treated as a single electron domain (larger than a single bond).
- Repulsions decrease in the order lone pair–lone pair > lone pair–bond pair > bond pair–bond pair.
- Bonds to more electronegative atoms occupy less space near the central atom than bonds to less electronegative atoms.
- In a filled valence shell, repulsions between domains at 90° matter far more than those at 120° or more.
The shape of the molecule is described by the positions of the atoms only. The arrangement of all electron domains (bonds and lone pairs) is the electron-pair geometry; the arrangement of the atoms is the molecular shape. CH₄, NH₃ and H₂O all have tetrahedral electron-pair geometry, but their shapes are tetrahedral, trigonal pyramidal and bent.
Why lone pairs repel more: a lone pair is held by one nucleus only, so its density spreads wider and sits closer to the central atom than a bonding pair, which is drawn out towards the ligand.
The Procedure
graph TD
A[Formula and charge] --> B[Draw Lewis structure or use the counting formula]
B --> C[Steric number = bonded atoms + lone pairs on central atom]
C --> D[Electron-pair geometry from SN]
D --> E[Place lone pairs to minimise 90 degree lone-pair repulsions]
E --> F[Name the shape from atom positions only]
F --> G[Adjust angles: lone pairs and multiple bonds squeeze, EN ligands shrink]Counting the steric number
The steric number (SN) is the number of atoms bonded to the central atom plus the number of lone pairs on it. Multiple bonds count once.
For molecules where the central atom is bonded to monovalent atoms (H, halogens) and/or doubly-bonded oxygen or sulfur, a quick count is
$$\boxed{\text{SN} = \tfrac{1}{2}\left(V + M - c + a\right)}$$where \( V \) = valence electrons of the central atom, \( M \) = number of monovalent atoms attached, \( c \) = positive charge, \( a \) = magnitude of negative charge. Divalent atoms (=O, =S) add nothing to the count but still occupy a position.
The formula fails for odd-electron species (NO₂, ClO₂: it gives a half-integer) and when the central atom is bonded to groups other than monovalent atoms or terminal O/S. For those, draw the Lewis structure.
The Shape Table
| SN | Electron-pair geometry | Type | Shape | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | linear | AX₂ | linear | BeCl₂ (gas), CO₂, HgCl₂, NO₂⁺ |
| 3 | trigonal planar | AX₃ | trigonal planar | BF₃, SO₃, NO₃⁻, CO₃²⁻ |
| 3 | AX₂E | bent (< 120°) | SO₂, O₃, NO₂⁻, SnCl₂ (gas) | |
| 4 | tetrahedral | AX₄ | tetrahedral | CH₄, NH₄⁺, SO₄²⁻, ClO₄⁻, XeO₄ |
| 4 | AX₃E | trigonal pyramidal | NH₃, PCl₃, H₃O⁺, ClO₃⁻, XeO₃ | |
| 4 | AX₂E₂ | bent (< 109.5°) | H₂O, OF₂, SCl₂, ClO₂⁻ | |
| 5 | trigonal bipyramidal | AX₅ | trigonal bipyramidal | PCl₅ (gas), PF₅, AsF₅ |
| 5 | AX₄E | see-saw | SF₄, SeF₄, TeCl₄, XeO₂F₂, IF₄⁺ | |
| 5 | AX₃E₂ | T-shaped | ClF₃, BrF₃, XeOF₂ | |
| 5 | AX₂E₃ | linear | XeF₂, I₃⁻, ICl₂⁻ | |
| 6 | octahedral | AX₆ | octahedral | SF₆, PF₆⁻, SiF₆²⁻ |
| 6 | AX₅E | square pyramidal | BrF₅, IF₅, XeOF₄, XeF₅⁺ | |
| 6 | AX₄E₂ | square planar | XeF₄, ICl₄⁻, BrF₄⁻ | |
| 7 | pentagonal bipyramidal | AX₇ | pentagonal bipyramidal | IF₇ |
| 7 | AX₆E | distorted octahedral | XeF₆ (gas) | |
| 7 | AX₅E₂ | pentagonal planar | XeF₅⁻ |
Where the Lone Pairs Go
Steric number 5: lone pairs are equatorial
A trigonal bipyramid has two kinds of position. An axial position has three neighbours at 90°; an equatorial position has only two neighbours at 90° (the axial pair) and two at 120°. Large domains go where they meet the fewest 90° interactions, so lone pairs and multiple bonds occupy equatorial positions.
The same rule places:
- the single lone pair of SF₄ equatorial: a see-saw, with F(axial)–S–F(axial) about 173° and F(eq)–S–F(eq) about 102°, both compressed from 180° and 120°;
- the three lone pairs of XeF₂ and I₃⁻ all equatorial: the two atoms are axial and the molecule is linear;
- the oxygen atoms of XeO₂F₂ equatorial (Xe=O bonds are bigger domains), with the two F atoms axial: a see-saw.
Steric number 6: lone pairs are trans
In an octahedron all six positions are equivalent, so one lone pair can go anywhere (AX₅E, square pyramidal). A second lone pair goes trans to the first, to avoid a lone pair–lone pair interaction at 90°. That gives the square planar shape of XeF₄ and ICl₄⁻.
In square pyramidal BrF₅ and IF₅ the lone pair pushes the four basal fluorines up towards the apical one, so the apical-to-basal F–X–F angles are a little less than 90°.
Steric number 7
IF₇ is a pentagonal bipyramid. XeF₆ has six bonds and one lone pair (SN 7). In the gas phase it is a distorted octahedron, not a regular one: the lone pair is stereochemically active and the molecule is fluxional, moving between distorted forms. The XeF₅⁻ anion has two lone pairs on the axis and five fluorines in a plane: pentagonal planar.
The Xenon Compounds in One Table
| Species | SN | Lone pairs | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| XeF₂ | 5 | 3 | linear |
| XeF₄ | 6 | 2 | square planar |
| XeF₆ | 7 | 1 | distorted octahedral |
| XeO₃ | 4 | 1 | trigonal pyramidal |
| XeO₄ | 4 | 0 | tetrahedral |
| XeOF₂ | 5 | 2 | T-shaped |
| XeO₂F₂ | 5 | 1 | see-saw |
| XeOF₄ | 6 | 1 | square pyramidal |
| XeO₃F₂ | 5 | 0 | trigonal bipyramidal |
| XeF₅⁺ | 6 | 1 | square pyramidal |
| XeF₅⁻ | 7 | 2 | pentagonal planar |
A short way to the lone-pair count for xenon species: xenon has 8 valence electrons; each F uses one, each O uses two (as Xe=O), a positive charge removes one. Lone pairs = (remaining electrons)/2. XeOF₄: \( 8 - 4 - 2 = 2 \), one lone pair.
Interhalogens and Polyhalide Ions
| Type | Example | SN | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| XY | ClF, ICl | – | linear diatomic |
| XY₃ | ClF₃, BrF₃ | 5 | T-shaped |
| XY₅ | BrF₅, IF₅ | 6 | square pyramidal |
| XY₇ | IF₇ | 7 | pentagonal bipyramidal |
| XY₂⁻ | ICl₂⁻, I₃⁻ | 5 | linear |
| XY₄⁻ | ICl₄⁻, BrF₄⁻ | 6 | square planar |
| XY₂⁺ | ICl₂⁺, ClF₂⁺ | 4 | bent |
| XY₄⁺ | IF₄⁺ | 5 | see-saw |
Interhalogens XYₙ always have \( n \) odd (1, 3, 5, 7), so that the total number of valence electrons is even. The larger, less electronegative halogen is the central atom.
Isoelectronic Means Isostructural
Species with the same number of atoms and the same number of valence electrons usually have the same shape. This is the quickest check in Part B.
| Valence electrons | Species | Shape |
|---|---|---|
| 16 (3 atoms) | CO₂, N₃⁻, NO₂⁺, OCN⁻, SCN⁻ | linear |
| 18 (3 atoms) | O₃, SO₂, NO₂⁻ | bent |
| 24 (4 atoms) | BF₃, CO₃²⁻, NO₃⁻, SO₃ | trigonal planar |
| 26 (4 atoms) | ClO₃⁻, SO₃²⁻, XeO₃, IO₃⁻ (all AX₃E) | trigonal pyramidal |
| 32 (5 atoms) | ClO₄⁻, SO₄²⁻, PO₄³⁻, XeO₄, SiO₄⁴⁻ | tetrahedral |
| 22 (3 atoms) | XeF₂, I₃⁻, ICl₂⁻ | linear |
| 36 (5 atoms) | XeF₄, ICl₄⁻, BrF₄⁻ | square planar |
Odd-Electron Species
A single unpaired electron is a domain smaller than a lone pair. NO₂ shows the effect neatly:
| Species | Non-bonding electrons on N | O–N–O angle |
|---|---|---|
| NO₂⁺ | 0 | 180° |
| NO₂ | 1 | about 134° |
| NO₂⁻ | 2 | about 115° |
One electron bends the molecule less than a full lone pair does.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Electron-pair geometry (bonds + lone pairs) | molecular shape (atoms only) | |
| ClF₃: T-shaped, SN 5, 2 lone pairs | BF₃: trigonal planar, SN 3, no lone pair | |
| SF₄: see-saw (AX₄E) | XeF₄: square planar (AX₄E₂) | |
| XeOF₄: square pyramidal | XeO₂F₂: see-saw | |
| XeF₆ gas: distorted octahedron | SF₆: regular octahedron | |
| I₃⁻ and XeF₂: linear | ICl₂⁺ and ClF₂⁺: bent |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the shape of XeF₄?
- How many lone pairs are there on the central atom of I₃⁻?
- Give the shape of BrF₅.
Answers
- Square planar. SN \( \frac{1}{2}(8 + 4) = 6 \), two lone pairs trans.
- 3. SN \( \frac{1}{2}(7 + 2 + 1) = 5 \), two bonded atoms, so three lone pairs (all equatorial; the ion is linear).
- Square pyramidal. SN \( \frac{1}{2}(7 + 5) = 6 \), one lone pair.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which pair of species has the same shape?
(a) XeF₂ and ICl₂⁺ (b) SF₄ and XeF₄ (c) ICl₄⁻ and XeF₄ (d) NH₃ and BF₃
Answer: (c)
ICl₄⁻: \( \frac{1}{2}(7 + 4 + 1) = 6 \), four bonds, two lone pairs: square planar. XeF₄: same count, square planar. The two are isoelectronic (36 valence electrons).
(a): XeF₂ is linear, ICl₂⁺ is bent. (b): SF₄ is see-saw, XeF₄ square planar. (d): NH₃ is pyramidal, BF₃ planar.
Practice Q2. The shape of XeOF₄ is:
(a) octahedral (b) square pyramidal (c) see-saw (d) trigonal bipyramidal
Answer: (b) square pyramidal
Xe has 8 valence electrons; four F use 4 and the double-bonded O uses 2, leaving 2 (one lone pair). Five atoms plus one lone pair: SN 6, AX₅E, square pyramidal. The O sits at the apex, trans to the lone pair.
Practice Q3. In the trigonal bipyramidal electron-pair geometry, lone pairs occupy equatorial positions because an equatorial position has:
(a) three neighbours at 90° (b) two neighbours at 90° (c) four neighbours at 90° (d) no neighbours at 90°
Answer: (b)
An equatorial site has the two axial sites at 90° and two equatorial sites at 120°. An axial site has three equatorial neighbours at 90°. Fewer 90° contacts means less repulsion for the bulky lone pair.
Practice Q4. The total number of lone pairs on the central atoms of ClF₃, XeF₂ and SF₄ taken together is:
(a) 4 (b) 5 (c) 6 (d) 7
Answer: (c) 6
ClF₃: \( \frac{1}{2}(7 + 3) = 5 \), 3 bonds, 2 lone pairs. XeF₂: \( \frac{1}{2}(8 + 2) = 5 \), 2 bonds, 3 lone pairs. SF₄: \( \frac{1}{2}(6 + 4) = 5 \), 4 bonds, 1 lone pair. Total \( 2 + 3 + 1 = 6 \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Consider the statements:
- ClF₃ is planar.
- SF₄ has a dipole moment.
- XeF₂ and I₃⁻ are isostructural.
- IF₄⁺ is square planar.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 4 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. T-shaped: Cl and three F lie in one plane.
- Correct. The see-saw shape is not centrosymmetric and the lone pair adds to the bond-dipole sum, so SF₄ is polar.
- Correct. Both AX₂E₃, linear.
- Wrong. IF₄⁺: \( \frac{1}{2}(7 + 4 - 1) = 5 \), four bonds and one lone pair: see-saw, like SF₄. Square planar needs two lone pairs (as in IF₄⁻).
Practice Q6. Which of the following sets contains only species with zero lone pairs on the central atom?
(a) XeO₄, SO₄²⁻, PCl₄⁺ (b) XeO₃, ClO₃⁻, NH₃ (c) XeF₂, CO₂, BeCl₂ (d) SF₄, XeO₂F₂, IF₄⁺
Answer: (a)
XeO₄: \( 8 - 4 \times 2 = 0 \) electrons left. SO₄²⁻: \( \frac{1}{2}(6 + 2) = 4 \) with four O. PCl₄⁺: \( \frac{1}{2}(5 + 4 - 1) = 4 \) with four Cl. All tetrahedral, no lone pairs.
(b) all have one lone pair (pyramidal). (c) XeF₂ has three. (d) all have one (see-saw).
Practice Q7. For an AX₄E₂ molecule (octahedral electron-pair geometry), which arrangement of the two lone pairs is adopted, and what is the resulting shape?
(a) cis lone pairs; see-saw (b) trans lone pairs; square planar (c) cis lone pairs; square planar (d) trans lone pairs; tetrahedral
Answer: (b)
In an octahedron there are only two ways to place two lone pairs: cis (one lp–lp contact at 90°) or trans (lp–lp at 180°, no 90° lp–lp contact). The 90° lone pair–lone pair repulsion is the largest term, so trans is adopted. The four atoms then lie in the equatorial plane: square planar, as in XeF₄.
A cis arrangement would leave the four atoms in a see-saw-like distorted shape; it is not observed.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Steric number | bonded atoms + lone pairs; \( \frac{1}{2}(V + M - c + a) \) |
| Repulsion order | lp–lp > lp–bp > bp–bp; multiple bond > single |
| SN 3 | AX₃ trigonal planar; AX₂E bent |
| SN 4 | AX₄ tetrahedral; AX₃E pyramidal; AX₂E₂ bent |
| SN 5 | AX₅ TBP; AX₄E see-saw; AX₃E₂ T-shaped; AX₂E₃ linear |
| SN 6 | AX₆ octahedral; AX₅E square pyramidal; AX₄E₂ square planar |
| SN 7 | AX₇ pentagonal bipyramid (IF₇); AX₆E distorted octahedron (XeF₆); AX₅E₂ pentagonal planar (XeF₅⁻) |
| TBP placement | lone pairs and multiple bonds equatorial |
| Octahedral placement | two lone pairs trans |
| Isoelectronic | usually isostructural (XeF₄ ≈ ICl₄⁻; CO₂ ≈ N₃⁻ ≈ NO₂⁺) |
| Odd electron | NO₂⁺ 180° > NO₂ ≈ 134° > NO₂⁻ ≈ 115° |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Bond Angles, Bent’s Rule and the Limits of VSEPR: why NH₃ is 107° but PH₃ is near 93°, where electronegative atoms go, and when VSEPR fails.
- Bonding in Homonuclear Molecules: the molecular orbital picture behind bonds.
- Structure and Bonding: Quick Revision.
- Back to Chemical Periodicity for electronegativity values.