Skip to content

Mass Spectrometry and Combined Structure Problems

CSIR NET organic spectroscopy: ionisation, nitrogen rule, isotope patterns, HRMS, α-cleavage, McLafferty, RDA, and solving structures from IR, UV, NMR and MS.

  • 18 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Weighing a Molecule, Then Breaking It
  3. How a Mass Spectrum Is Made
  4. Molecular Formula from the Mass Spectrum
  5. Fragmentation of Organic Ions
  6. Combined Structure Determination
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Weighing a Molecule, Then Breaking It

How a Mass Spectrum Is Made

graph LR
    A["Sample
(gas, solution, solid)"] --> B["Ion source
EI, CI, ESI, MALDI, FAB"] B --> C["Mass analyser
sector, quadrupole, TOF,
ion trap, FT-ICR, Orbitrap"] C --> D["Detector
(electron multiplier)"] D --> E["Spectrum:
relative abundance vs m/z"]

Ionisation methods

MethodHowMain ionFragmentationTypical sample
Electron ionisation (EI)70 eV electron beam knocks out an electronM⁺• (radical cation)extensive; molecular ion may be weak or absentvolatile, thermally stable organics
Chemical ionisation (CI)reagent gas (CH₄, isobutane, NH₃) ionised first; reagent ions protonate the analyte[M+H]⁺ (also adducts such as [M+NH₄]⁺)little (“soft”)to see the molecular mass when EI M⁺• is missing
Electrospray (ESI)charged droplets from solution; solvent evaporates[M+H]⁺, [M+Na]⁺, [M−H]⁻; multiply charged [M+nH]ⁿ⁺very softpolar molecules, peptides, proteins, salts
MALDIlaser on analyte in a UV-absorbing matrixmostly singly charged [M+H]⁺softproteins, polymers, large biomolecules
FABfast atoms (Xe, Ar) on a liquid matrix[M+H]⁺softolder method for polar, non-volatile compounds

70 eV is far above typical organic ionisation energies (about 8–11 eV); the excess energy drives fragmentation.

Mass analysers in one table

AnalyserPrincipleNote
Magnetic sectorions of the same kinetic energy follow radius \( r \) in field \( B \): \( m/z = B^2 r^2 e/2V \)double focusing (electric + magnetic) for high resolution
Quadrupoleonly ions of one m/z have stable paths through oscillating RF/DC fieldscompact, common in GC-MS
Time-of-flight (TOF)all ions get the same kinetic energy; flight time \( t \propto \sqrt{m/z} \)wide mass range; pairs with MALDI
Ion trap, FT-ICR, Orbitrapions trapped and their oscillation frequencies measuredvery high resolution (FT-ICR, Orbitrap)

Resolution \( R = m/\Delta m \), where \( \Delta m \) is the smallest separable mass difference at mass \( m \).

Vocabulary

TermMeaning
Molecular ion M⁺•the intact molecule minus one electron; an odd-electron radical cation
Base peakmost intense peak, set to 100 % relative abundance; not necessarily M⁺•
M+1, M+2isotope peaks one and two mass units above M
Fragment ionproduct of bond cleavage; even-electron cation (with a radical lost) or odd-electron (with a neutral molecule lost)
Metastable ionan ion that fragments in flight between source and analyser; appears as a broad peak at \( m^* = m_2^2/m_1 \) in a sector instrument

The metastable peak links a parent and daughter: for 134 → 119, \( m^* = 119^2/134 = 105.7 \). Its presence proves that 119 is formed directly from 134.

Molecular Formula from the Mass Spectrum

The nitrogen rule

Nitrogen rule
A molecule containing only C, H, N, O, S, P, Si and halogens has an odd nominal molecular mass if and only if it contains an odd number of nitrogen atoms. An even M means zero or an even number of N.

The reason: nitrogen is the only common element with an even mass (14) and an odd valence (3). As a corollary, in EI an even-electron fragment of a nitrogen-free compound has an odd m/z (CH₃CO⁺ 43, C₇H₇⁺ 91), while a fragment formed by loss of a neutral molecule (an odd-electron ion) has an even m/z (McLafferty ion 58 from 2-hexanone).

Degree of unsaturation (DBE)

$$\text{DBE} = C - \frac{H}{2} - \frac{X}{2} + \frac{N}{2} + 1$$

with \( X \) the number of halogens; O and S are ignored. Each ring or π bond counts 1; a triple bond counts 2; a benzene ring counts 4. A DBE of 4 or more in a small molecule strongly suggests an aromatic ring.

The rule of 13

For a hydrocarbon of nominal mass \( M \): divide by 13, \( M = 13n + r \). The base formula is \( \text{C}_n\text{H}_{n+r} \) with DBE \( = (n - r + 2)/2 \). Then trade atoms: adding O means removing CH₄ (16); adding N means removing CH₂ (14). Example: \( M = 128 = 13 \times 9 + 11 \) gives C₉H₂₀ (DBE 0, a nonane). Because one C (12 u) has the same nominal mass as H₁₂, the same mass also fits C₁₀H₈ (DBE 7, naphthalene); chemical sense or HRMS decides between such alternatives.

Isotope patterns

ElementIsotopes (approximate natural abundance)Effect
C¹²C 98.9 %, ¹³C 1.1 %M+1 about 1.1 % per carbon
H²H about 0.012 %negligible
N¹⁵N 0.37 %small M+1 contribution
O¹⁸O 0.20 %small M+2
S³⁴S about 4.2 %M+2 about 4.4 % of M per S
Cl³⁵Cl 75.8 %, ³⁷Cl 24.2 %M : M+2 about 3 : 1
Br⁷⁹Br 50.7 %, ⁸¹Br 49.3 %M : M+2 about 1 : 1
Counting carbons and halogens
  • Carbons: \( n_C \approx \dfrac{I(M+1)}{I(M)} \times \dfrac{100}{1.1} \) (when N is absent or few).
  • \( n \) halogen atoms: the M, M+2, M+4 … intensities follow the binomial expansion \( (a + b)^n \).
HalogensPattern M : M+2 : M+4 (: M+6)
Cl3 : 1
Cl₂9 : 6 : 1 (exactly 100 : 64 : 10)
Cl₃27 : 27 : 9 : 1
Br1 : 1
Br₂1 : 2 : 1
ClBr3 : 4 : 1

High-resolution MS: exact mass

Atomic masses are not whole numbers (¹²C = 12.0000 by definition; ¹H 1.00783; ¹⁴N 14.00307; ¹⁶O 15.99491). Ions of the same nominal mass therefore have different exact masses:

Formula (nominal 28)Exact mass
CO27.9949
N₂28.0061
C₂H₄28.0313

Separating CO from C₂H₄ needs \( R \approx 28/0.0364 \approx 770 \); separating CO from N₂ needs \( R \approx 28/0.0112 \approx 2500 \). Modern HRMS measures masses to a few ppm, enough to assign a unique formula to most small organic ions.

Fragmentation of Organic Ions

Fragmentation follows the stability of the products: the cation formed and the radical or neutral lost. Three guiding ideas:

  • Stevenson’s rule: when a radical cation breaks into a cation and a radical, the positive charge stays preferentially on the fragment with the lower ionisation energy.
  • Even-electron rule: even-electron ions tend to fragment to other even-electron ions plus neutral molecules, not to radicals.
  • Weakest bond, most stable product: branch points, benzylic and allylic bonds, and bonds α to heteroatoms break first.

Main fragmentation types

ProcessWhat breaksCharacteristic ions
σ-Cleavage at branching (alkanes)C–C bond at the branch point, giving the more substituted carbocationstraight-chain alkanes: clusters 14 apart, m/z 29, 43, 57, 71, 85 …; branched alkanes: weak M⁺•, strong ion from cleavage at the branch
α-Cleavage (amines, ethers, alcohols, carbonyls)bond next to the carbon bearing the heteroatom; the lone pair stabilises the cation (iminium, oxonium, acylium)primary amines R–CH₂NH₂: m/z 30 (CH₂=NH₂⁺); primary alcohols: m/z 31 (CH₂=OH⁺); methyl ketones: m/z 43 (CH₃C≡O⁺)
Benzylic cleavagebond β to the ringm/z 91 (C₇H₇⁺, usually drawn as tropylium); then 91 → 65 (loss of C₂H₂)
Acylium formation from aryl ketonesC(=O)–R bondArC≡O⁺: benzoyl m/z 105 → phenyl 77 (−CO) → 51 (−C₂H₂)
McLafferty rearrangementγ-H transferred to C=O oxygen through a six-membered transition state; Cα–Cβ bond breaks; an alkene is lostodd-electron enol radical cation, even m/z (see below)
Retro-Diels–Alder (RDA)cyclohexene ring splits into a diene and an alkenecyclohexene (M 82) → butadiene radical cation m/z 54 + ethylene
Loss of small neutral moleculeseliminationalcohols M−18 (H₂O); acetates M−60 (AcOH); alkyl halides M−HX; aldehydes M−1 (H•) and M−29 (CHO•)
Loss of halogenC–Xiodides and bromides lose X• readily

The McLafferty rearrangement

graph LR
    A["Carbonyl with γ-H
R-C(=O)-CH₂(α)-CH₂(β)-CH₂(γ)-H"] --> B["Six-membered TS:
γ-H moves to O"] B --> C["Cα-Cβ bond breaks"] C --> D["Enol radical cation
(odd-electron, even m/z)"] C --> E["Neutral alkene lost"]

Requirements: a C=O (or C=N, C=C, aryl) group and a hydrogen on the γ carbon. The characteristic ions:

Compound classMcLafferty ion m/z (unsubstituted α carbon)
Aldehydes RCH₂CH₂CH₂CHO44
Methyl ketones58
Carboxylic acids60
Methyl esters74
Ethyl esters88
Primary amides59

Example: hexan-2-one, CH₃COCH₂CH₂CH₂CH₃ (M = 100). The γ-H on C5 transfers to O; C3–C4 breaks; propene (42) is lost; the ion CH₂=C(OH)CH₃⁺• appears at m/z 58. α-Cleavage of the same ketone gives m/z 43 (CH₃CO⁺) and m/z 85 (C₄H₉CO⁺).

Fragmentation fingerprints by class

ClassLook for
AlkanesM⁺• weak; 14-unit clusters; base 43 or 57
Alkenesallylic cleavage (m/z 41, C₃H₅⁺); RDA for cyclohexenes
Alkylbenzenesm/z 91 base peak (toluene, ethylbenzene), 65; m/z 92 by McLafferty for propylbenzene and longer chains
AlcoholsM⁺• weak or absent; M−18; α-cleavage (31 for RCH₂OH, 45 for RCH(OH)CH₃, 59 for R C(OH)(CH₃)₂)
Phenolsstrong M⁺•; M−28 (CO), M−29 (CHO)
Ethersα-cleavage to oxonium ions; C–O cleavage
AldehydesM−1, M−29; McLafferty 44
Ketonesα-cleavage to acylium ions; McLafferty 58 (methyl ketones)
Estersacylium RCO⁺, alkoxy loss (M−OR); McLafferty 74 (methyl esters)
AcidsM−17 (OH), M−45 (CO₂H); McLafferty 60
Aminesodd M (one N); α-cleavage, base 30 for RCH₂NH₂
HalidesM+2 pattern; loss of X•, loss of HX
Aromatic carbonyls105 (PhCO⁺) → 77 → 51

Combined Structure Determination

Real problems, and nearly all Part C spectroscopy questions, give more than one spectrum. Each technique answers a different question; use them in a fixed order.

graph TD
    A["MS: M⁺•, isotope pattern,
nitrogen rule, HRMS → formula"] --> B["DBE"] B --> C["IR: functional groups
(C=O type, OH, NH, C≡N, NO₂)"] C --> D["UV: conjugated chromophore?
(Woodward-Fieser)"] D --> E["¹³C + DEPT: number and type of carbons,
symmetry, carbonyl class"] E --> F["¹H: fragments from δ, integration, J"] F --> G["Assemble; check against
MS fragments and every datum"]
TechniqueMain question it answers
MSHow heavy? Which formula? Which halogens? Which fragments?
IRWhich functional groups are present or absent?
UV-VisIs there conjugation, and how extended?
¹³C/DEPTHow many distinct carbons, of which type?
¹HHow are the protons arranged and connected?
2D NMRWhich fragments connect to which?

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Base peak: most intenseMolecular ion: intact molecule minus e⁻ (may be weak)
EI: M⁺•, hard, many fragmentsCI/ESI/MALDI: [M+H]⁺, soft, few fragments
Simple cleavage: radical lost, odd m/z ion (no N)Rearrangement (McLafferty, RDA): molecule lost, even m/z ion
Nominal mass (integers)Exact mass (HRMS, 4 decimals)
M+2 of Cl (one-third of M)M+2 of Br (equal to M)
Benzylic cleavage → m/z 91Benzoyl α-cleavage → m/z 105
Metastable \( m^* = m_2^2/m_1 \)Doubly charged ion at m/z = M/2

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Spectral data are illustrative, rounded values.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. A compound containing C, H, N and O has M⁺• at m/z 135. What can you say about the number of N atoms?
  2. A molecular ion cluster shows two peaks of almost equal height, two mass units apart. Which element is indicated?
  3. Which ionisation method most often gives multiply charged ions of proteins?
Answers
  1. Odd mass → an odd number of nitrogen atoms (1, 3, …).
  2. One bromine atom (⁷⁹Br : ⁸¹Br ≈ 1 : 1).
  3. Electrospray ionisation (ESI).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. In the EI mass spectrum of hexan-2-one (M = 100), the McLafferty rearrangement gives an ion at m/z:

(a) 43 (b) 57 (c) 58 (d) 85

Answer: (c)

γ-H transfer from C5 to O and cleavage of C3–C4 expel propene (42): \( 100 - 42 = 58 \), the enol radical cation CH₂=C(OH)CH₃⁺•. m/z 43 (CH₃CO⁺) and 85 (C₄H₉CO⁺) are α-cleavage ions; 57 is C₄H₉⁺.

Practice Q2. A compound shows M⁺• peaks at m/z 156 and 158 of almost equal intensity and a strong peak at m/z 77. It is most likely:

(a) chlorobenzene (b) bromobenzene (c) 4-chlorotoluene (d) benzyl bromide

Answer: (b)

1 : 1 at M and M+2 means one Br. C₆H₅⁷⁹Br = 72 + 5 + 79 = 156. m/z 77 is C₆H₅⁺ from loss of Br•. Benzyl bromide would have M = 170/172 and a base peak at 91.

Practice Q3. For a hydrocarbon with M = 128, the rule of 13 gives a base formula and, after exchanging H₁₂ for one C, a second formula of the same nominal mass. These are:

(a) C₉H₂₀ and C₁₀H₈ (b) C₁₀H₈ and C₁₁H₁₀ (c) C₈H₁₆O and C₉H₂₀ (d) C₉H₁₈ and C₁₀H₈

Answer: (a)

\( 128 = 13 \times 9 + 11 \): C₉H₉₊₁₁ = C₉H₂₀ (DBE \( = (9 - 11 + 2)/2 = 0 \), nonane). Replacing H₁₂ by one C (both 12 u) gives C₁₀H₈ (DBE 7, naphthalene).

Practice Q4. The minimum resolution \( R = m/\Delta m \) needed to separate CO⁺• (27.9949) from C₂H₄⁺• (28.0313) is about:

(a) 77 (b) 770 (c) 2500 (d) 28 000

Answer: (b)

\( \Delta m = 28.0313 - 27.9949 = 0.0364 \); \( R = 28/0.0364 \approx 770 \). (c) is the value for CO versus N₂ (\( \Delta m = 0.0112 \)).

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. An unknown gives: MS m/z 134 (M⁺•, 35 %), 119 (100 %), 91 (40 %), 65; a metastable peak near m/z 105.7. IR 1683 cm⁻¹. ¹H NMR: δ 7.86 (2H, d, J = 8 Hz), 7.25 (2H, d, J = 8 Hz), 2.57 (3H, s), 2.41 (3H, s). Which structure and interpretation are correct?

(a) 4-methylacetophenone; 119 = M − CH₃ (acylium), 91 = 119 − CO; the metastable peak confirms 134 → 119. (b) 4-methylacetophenone; 119 = M − OH; the metastable peak confirms 119 → 91. (c) 2-phenylpropanal; 119 = M − CH₃; 91 = tropylium from the side chain. (d) 4-ethylbenzaldehyde; 119 = M − CH₃ by benzylic cleavage.

Answer: (a)
  • M = 134, even, no N: C₉H₁₀O (DBE 5: ring + C=O).
  • IR 1683: aryl ketone (no 2720/2820 aldehyde C–H).
  • ¹H: para-disubstituted ring (two 2H doublets, J 8 Hz), CH₃CO (δ 2.57) and Ar–CH₃ (δ 2.41).
  • MS: α-cleavage loses CH₃• to give CH₃C₆H₄C≡O⁺ (m/z 119, base peak); loss of CO gives C₇H₇⁺ (91), then 65.
  • Metastable: \( 119^2/134 = 105.7 \), proving 134 → 119 in one step. For 119 → 91 it would be \( 91^2/119 = 69.6 \). 2-Phenylpropanal and 4-ethylbenzaldehyde are aldehydes (CHO near δ 9.7–10, IR 2720) and do not give two methyl singlets.

Practice Q6. A protein’s ESI spectrum shows adjacent peaks at m/z 1001.0 and 858.1 (proton mass 1.007). The charge on the m/z 1001.0 ion and the molecular mass are:

(a) 6+ and about 6000 Da (b) 7+ and about 7000 Da (c) 6+ and about 5000 Da (d) 5+ and about 5000 Da

Answer: (a)

For adjacent peaks \( m_1 > m_2 \) carrying \( n \) and \( n + 1 \) protons: \( n = \dfrac{m_2 - 1.007}{m_1 - m_2} = \dfrac{857.09}{142.9} \approx 6.0 \). \( M = n(m_1 - 1.007) = 6 \times 999.99 \approx 6000 \) Da. Check with the other peak: \( 7 \times (858.1 - 1.007) = 6000 \) Da.

Practice Q7. A colourless compound gives M⁺• at m/z 146 with M : M+2 : M+4 ≈ 100 : 64 : 10 and M+1 about 6.6 % of M. Its proton-decoupled ¹³C spectrum shows four lines, and its ¹H spectrum shows only aromatic protons. Which conclusions are correct?

  1. The compound contains two chlorine atoms.
  2. It contains about six carbon atoms.
  3. Its DBE is 4.
  4. It is 1,3-dichlorobenzene.

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 1, 3 and 4 only

Answer: (c)
  1. Correct. 100 : 64 : 10 is \( (0.758 + 0.242)^2 \) scaled: two Cl (9 : 6 : 1).
  2. Correct. \( n_C \approx 6.6/1.1 = 6 \).
  3. Correct. \( 146 - 2(35) = 76 \) = C₆H₄, so C₆H₄Cl₂: DBE \( = 6 - 4/2 - 2/2 + 1 = 4 \) (a benzene ring).
  4. Correct. Of the three dichlorobenzenes, ortho gives 3 lines, meta 4, para 2.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
EI70 eV, M⁺•, many fragments
Soft methodsCI, ESI, MALDI, FAB: [M+H]⁺; ESI multiply charged
Analyserssector \( m/z = B^2r^2e/2V \); quadrupole; TOF \( t \propto \sqrt{m/z} \); FT-ICR/Orbitrap high resolution
Nitrogen ruleodd M ⇔ odd number of N
DBE\( C - H/2 - X/2 + N/2 + 1 \)
Rule of 13\( M = 13n + r \): \( \text{C}_n\text{H}_{n+r} \)
IsotopesM+1 ≈ 1.1 % per C; Cl 3 : 1; Br 1 : 1; Cl₂ 9 : 6 : 1; Br₂ 1 : 2 : 1; S M+2 about 4.4 %
HRMSCO 27.9949, N₂ 28.0061, C₂H₄ 28.0313
Metastable\( m^* = m_2^2/m_1 \)
α-Cleavageamine 30, alcohol 31, acetyl 43, benzoyl 105
Benzylic91 (tropylium) → 65
McLaffertyneeds γ-H; 44 (aldehyde), 58 (methyl ketone), 60 (acid), 74 (methyl ester)
RDAcyclohexene 82 → 54 + C₂H₄
Solving orderformula → DBE → IR → UV → ¹³C/DEPT → ¹H → check fragments

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement