Lightning and the Global Electric Circuit
CSIR NET Earth Sciences: lightning types, stepped and dart leaders, return strokes, thunder, sferics, Schumann resonances and the global electric circuit.
- 28 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: One Curve, Measured at Sea
- Types of Lightning
- Anatomy of a Negative Cloud-to-Ground Flash
- Thunder
- Global Lightning
- Electromagnetic Signatures: Sferics, Whistlers, Schumann Resonances
- Transient Luminous Events and High-Energy Radiation
- Chemical and Practical Effects of Lightning
- The Global Electric Circuit
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- The fair-weather field, air-Earth current, columnar resistance and relaxation time, from Fair-Weather Electric Field and Atmospheric Ionization.
- The thunderstorm tripole, graupel–ice charging and the image-charge formula, from Thunderstorm Electrification.
- Deep convection, CAPE and why land and ocean convection differ, from Vertical Stability and Tropical Convection.
- The ionosphere and the geomagnetic field that guides whistlers, from Geomagnetic Field and Its Variations.
The Hook: One Curve, Measured at Sea
How CSIR NET asks it. Part C (meteorology): types of lightning and which charge each lowers; the sequence of a cloud-to-ground flash (preliminary breakdown, stepped leader, attachment, return stroke, dart leader) with typical speeds, currents and temperatures; thunder distance; global flash rate and its land–ocean contrast; sferics, whistlers and Schumann resonances; transient luminous events; the global circuit budget (current, resistance, capacitance, time constant); the Carnegie curve; and parameterizations such as flash rate against cloud-top height.
Types of Lightning
A lightning flash is a transient, high-current discharge whose path is kilometres long. Classify flashes by where they start and end, and by the sign of charge effectively lowered to ground (for cloud-to-ground flashes).
| Type | Path | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Intracloud (IC) | Between charge regions in one cloud (most often main negative to upper positive) | The most common type globally; illuminates the cloud (“sheet lightning”) |
| Cloud-to-cloud (CC) | Between charge regions in different clouds | Less common |
| Cloud-to-air (CA) | From a charge region into clear air | Ends without reaching ground |
| Downward negative cloud-to-ground (−CG) | Main negative charge → ground | About 90% of cloud-to-ground flashes; usually several strokes |
| Downward positive cloud-to-ground (+CG) | Upper positive (often anvil or stratiform region) → ground | About 10%; usually a single stroke, often with long continuing current and large charge transfer |
| Upward (ground-to-cloud) | Leader starts from a tall structure and grows up | Common from towers and mountain-top structures; can be triggered by nearby flashes |
| Bipolar | Lowers both signs during one flash | Rare |
“Heat lightning” is not a separate type: it is lightning too far away for its thunder to be heard. Tall structures (above about 100 m) experience a large share of upward flashes; for most ground objects the flash is downward.
Anatomy of a Negative Cloud-to-Ground Flash
The negative CG flash is the most studied, because it can be recorded with cameras with moving film (streak cameras), field-change antennas and instrumented towers. Classic current measurements come from instrumented towers on Monte San Salvatore in Switzerland (K. Berger and co-workers) and from rocket-triggered lightning, in which a small rocket trailing an earthed wire is launched under a charged cloud.
graph TD
A["Preliminary breakdown
in cloud, near main negative charge
(milliseconds)"] --> B["Stepped leader
steps of tens of m, pauses of tens of microseconds
average speed about 2x10^5 m/s"]
B --> C["Attachment
upward connecting leader(s) from ground
meet the stepped leader tens of m up"]
C --> D["First return stroke
about 10^8 m/s upward
peak current about 30 kA
channel about 30,000 K"]
D --> E["Interstroke interval
tens of ms; J and K processes in cloud"]
E --> F["Dart leader
continuous, about 10^7 m/s
follows the old channel"]
F --> G["Subsequent return stroke
peak current about 10-15 kA"]
G -->|"repeats; 3-5 strokes typical"| E
G --> H["Continuing current (some flashes)
about 100 A for tens to hundreds of ms"]1. Preliminary breakdown
Inside the cloud, near the main negative charge, a series of discharges lasting milliseconds starts the flash. Its exact physics is still debated (see How Lightning Starts for hydrometeor-initiated corona and runaway electrons).
2. The stepped leader
A faintly luminous, negatively charged channel works its way toward the ground in discrete steps:
| Property | Typical value |
|---|---|
| Step length | tens of metres |
| Pause between steps | tens of microseconds |
| Average downward speed | about \(2\times10^5\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}\) (of order \(10^5\)–\(10^6\) m/s) |
| Time to reach ground | tens of milliseconds |
| Charge deposited along the channel | several coulombs |
| Shape | Branched, downward-pointing branches |
Each step is bright, the channel between steps is faint. The branching visible in photographs of lightning is the branching of the stepped leader.
3. Attachment
As the negative leader tip approaches, the field at the ground below rises sharply. When it is high enough at a tall or pointed object, an upward connecting leader (positive) starts from that object. The two meet some tens of metres above ground. The height at which the upward leader starts is the striking distance; it increases with the charge on the leader. This is the physical basis of the rolling-sphere method of lightning protection: imagine a sphere of radius equal to the striking distance rolled over a structure; every point it touches can be struck.
4. The return stroke
Once connected, the channel is effectively earthed at its bottom. A wave of very high current and intense luminosity runs up the channel, neutralising the leader charge and draining charge from the cloud. This is the bright flash seen by the eye.
| Property | Typical value |
|---|---|
| Propagation speed | about one-third to one-half the speed of light, about \(10^8\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}\) |
| Peak current, first stroke | median about 30 kA; a few percent exceed 100 kA |
| Peak current, subsequent stroke | median about 10–15 kA |
| Current rise time | microseconds |
| Peak channel temperature | about 30,000 K |
| Channel diameter | of order centimetres |
| Charge lowered per stroke | a few coulombs |
The current waveform rises in microseconds and decays over tens to hundreds of microseconds. The sudden heating to about 30,000 K raises the channel pressure far above ambient; the channel expands supersonically and the resulting shock wave decays within metres into an acoustic wave, which is thunder.
5. Dart leader and subsequent strokes
If more negative charge is available in the cloud, after an interval of tens of milliseconds a dart leader travels down the existing, still-warm channel. It moves continuously (no steps), about \(10^7\) m/s, and is not branched. A subsequent return stroke follows. During the interstroke interval, in-cloud processes (J processes and K changes) extend the channel into new charge regions and supply charge for the next stroke.
Most negative CG flashes have 3–5 strokes (sometimes more than ten), lasting a few tenths of a second in total, which is why lightning appears to flicker. Some strokes are followed by a continuing current of about 100 A lasting tens to hundreds of milliseconds; these “hot” flashes are the ones that start fires.
Totals for a negative CG flash
| Quantity | Order of magnitude |
|---|---|
| Total charge lowered | about 20–30 C (negative) |
| Duration | about 0.2–0.5 s |
| Energy dissipated | of order \(10^9\) J (estimates span roughly \(10^8\)–\(10^{10}\) J) |
| Cloud-to-ground potential difference | of order \(10^8\) V |
Positive CG flashes
A +CG flash lowers positive charge, usually from the upper positive region displaced horizontally from the main negative (anvil, or a sheared storm), or from the extensive positive layers of stratiform regions. Compared with −CG flashes, +CG flashes typically:
- have one return stroke,
- are more often followed by a long continuing current,
- can transfer much larger charge (tens to hundreds of coulombs),
- produce more of the largest peak currents,
- are the usual parents of sprites (below).
Thunder
The shock wave turns into sound within a few metres. Sound travels at about 340 m/s near the ground, light essentially instantly, so
$$\boxed{d \approx 340\,\Delta t\ \mathrm{m}\qquad\text{about 3 s per km}}$$where \(\Delta t\) is the flash-to-thunder delay in seconds. Thunder rumbles because different parts of a tortuous, kilometres-long channel are at different distances from the listener; the sound arrives over several seconds. Thunder is rarely heard beyond about 15–25 km, because sound is refracted upward when temperature decreases with height and is absorbed and masked by wind noise.
Global Lightning
How much and where
Satellite optical sensors (the Optical Transient Detector, the Lightning Imaging Sensor and, on geostationary satellites, the Geostationary Lightning Mapper) give a global flash rate of about 40–50 flashes per second, often quoted as about 45 s⁻¹: of order \(1.4\times10^9\) flashes per year, IC and CG together.
| Pattern | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Land ≫ ocean: roughly 90% of flashes over land | Land heats strongly by day, building deep boundary layers and strong updrafts; strong updrafts lift supercooled water into the mixed phase where graupel–ice charging works (see Thunderstorm Electrification) |
| Tropics ≫ high latitudes | Deep convection, high freezing levels, high CAPE |
| Hotspots: the Congo basin of central Africa and the Lake Maracaibo region of Venezuela | Persistent deep convection, terrain-forced and lake-breeze circulations |
| Afternoon maximum over land (local time) | Peak surface heating and convection |
| Northern-summer maximum globally | More land in the Northern Hemisphere |
In India, the violent pre-monsoon nor’westers (Kalbaishakhi) of east and north-east India are a well-known lightning-producing storm type.
Flash rate and cloud-top height
A widely used parameterization (Price and Rind, 1992) links the flash rate F of a storm to its cloud-top height H:
$$F_{\text{land}} \propto H^{4.9},\qquad F_{\text{ocean}} \propto H^{1.73}$$The steep land exponent reflects the stronger updrafts of continental storms. It explains why modest changes in convective depth can change flash rates a lot, and why lightning is used as an indicator of storm intensity: a sudden rise in total flash rate (a lightning jump) often precedes severe weather at the ground.
Detecting lightning
| Method | What it uses | Gives |
|---|---|---|
| Magnetic direction finding | Crossed-loop antennas measure the direction of the radiated magnetic field of a return stroke | Bearing from each station; triangulation |
| Time of arrival (TOA) | Precise (GPS) timing of the same pulse at several stations | Location from arrival-time differences (hyperbolae) |
| VLF/LF networks | Sferics travelling in the Earth–ionosphere waveguide | CG (and some IC) locations over continents and oceans; peak current estimates |
| VHF mapping arrays and interferometers | VHF radiation from leader breakdown | Three-dimensional maps of the whole flash, including IC channels |
| Satellite optical sensors | Transient brightening of cloud tops | Total lightning (IC + CG), global or hemispheric |
| Field mills and field-change antennas | Electrostatic field changes | Charge removed, charge moment |
Electromagnetic Signatures: Sferics, Whistlers, Schumann Resonances
A return stroke is a vertical antenna carrying tens of kiloamperes for tens of microseconds. It radiates over a broad spectrum, strongest at VLF (3–30 kHz).
- Sferics (atmospherics). The broadband pulse propagates thousands of kilometres in the Earth–ionosphere waveguide, bounded below by the conducting ground and sea and above by the lower ionosphere (D region by day, E region by night). VLF networks use them to locate lightning globally.
- Whistlers. Part of the VLF energy leaks through the ionosphere and travels along a geomagnetic field line to the opposite hemisphere, through magnetospheric plasma that is dispersive: higher frequencies travel faster. Heard on a receiver, the signal is a tone falling in pitch over a second or so. For the simplest (low-frequency) case the delay follows Eckersley’s law, \(t = D/\sqrt{f}\), with D the dispersion. Whistlers were historically used to probe electron densities along magnetic field lines in the magnetosphere.
- Schumann resonances. The Earth’s surface and the lower ionosphere form a spherical cavity about 60–90 km thick. Lightning, about 45 flashes every second somewhere, continuously excites its global resonant modes at extremely low frequencies (ELF).
For an ideal, lossless thin cavity of radius R,
$$\boxed{f_n = \frac{c}{2\pi R}\sqrt{n(n+1)}}$$With \(c = 3.0\times10^8\) m/s and \(R = 6371\) km, \(c/2\pi R = 7.49\) Hz, giving 10.6, 18.4, 26.0 and 33.5 Hz for n = 1–4. The observed modes are near 7.8, 14, 20, 26 and 33 Hz: lower than ideal because the ionospheric boundary is lossy and the cavity is not a perfect conductor. The fundamental’s wavelength is about the Earth’s circumference. Because the resonance intensity integrates lightning over the whole planet, it is used as a monitor of global lightning activity, and its daily variation follows the UT cycle of the continental storm centres.
Transient Luminous Events and High-Energy Radiation
Large lightning flashes disturb the atmosphere far above the cloud. These events last milliseconds and are recorded with sensitive low-light cameras, from aircraft, the ground and the International Space Station.
| Event | Where | Parent and cause | Appearance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sprites | About 40–90 km | Mostly large +CG flashes with large charge moment change; the quasi-static field above the cloud exceeds breakdown in the thin mesospheric air | Red, with blue tendrils below; “carrot” or “column” shapes; delayed a few ms after the stroke |
| Halos | About 80 km | Same quasi-static field, diffuse | Faint red disc, often preceding a sprite |
| Elves | About 90 km, ring up to hundreds of km wide | The electromagnetic pulse of a strong return stroke heating the lower ionosphere | Expanding ring lasting under a millisecond |
| Blue jets | From cloud top up to about 40–50 km | Discharge from the upper positive charge upward | Blue cone |
| Gigantic jets | From cloud top to the lower ionosphere (about 90 km) | Upward discharges connecting the cloud to the ionosphere | Tree-like, blue lower and red upper part |
The quantity that decides whether a flash can produce a sprite is its charge moment change,
$$M_q = Q\,h$$the charge removed times the height from which it was removed (units C km). For a distant observer at ground distance \(D \gg h\), the electrostatic field change from removing charge Q from height h over conducting ground is that of a vertical dipole of moment \(2Qh\):
$$\Delta E_z \approx \frac{2kQh}{D^3}$$(use the exact form \(2kQh/(h^2 + D^2)^{3/2}\), from the image method, when D is not much larger than h). So field-change networks measure charge moments, and large-charge-moment +CG flashes in stratiform regions are the ones that light sprites.
Terrestrial gamma-ray flashes (TGFs) are sub-millisecond bursts of gamma rays from thunderstorm regions, first seen by an orbiting gamma-ray observatory in the 1990s. They are produced by runaway relativistic electron avalanches in strong thunderstorm fields, linked to the initiation and leader stages of (mostly intracloud) flashes. Ground and aircraft detectors also record longer gamma-ray glows from thunderclouds.
Chemical and Practical Effects of Lightning
- Nitrogen oxides. The hot channel fixes atmospheric N₂ and O₂ into NO (Zel’dovich chemistry), which converts to NO₂. Lightning is a major NOₓ source in the upper troposphere, where NOₓ has a long lifetime and controls ozone production. Global estimates are a few teragrams of nitrogen per year.
- Ozone is produced downstream from lightning NOₓ.
- Fulgurites are glassy tubes formed when lightning fuses sand or rock.
- Fires: long-continuing-current flashes ignite forest and grassland fires.
- Protection: a Franklin rod and its earthing provide a preferred, low-impedance path; the protected zone is estimated with the rolling-sphere (or older cone-of-protection) method. Cars and all-metal aircraft protect occupants as Faraday cages: the current flows over the conducting skin.
- Hazards on the ground: direct strike, side flash, step voltage (current spreading through the ground produces a potential difference between the feet) and touch voltage. Step voltage is why livestock with widely spaced legs are killed in large numbers and why crouching with feet together is advised outdoors.
The Global Electric Circuit
Wilson’s idea
C. T. R. Wilson (in the 1920s) proposed that thunderstorms and electrified shower clouds are the generators, the highly conducting upper atmosphere and the Earth are the two plates, and the fair-weather atmosphere is the distributed load. The circuit closes as follows:
graph TD
I["Ionosphere / equalisation layer
about +250 kV, nearly equipotential
horizontal currents spread the charge"]
S["Thunderstorms and electrified shower clouds
(generators, about 1 A each)"]
F["Fair-weather regions everywhere
air-Earth current about 2 pA per m2
total about 1 kA (load)"]
E["Earth surface (conductor)
about -5x10^5 C
currents spread through ground and sea"]
S -->|"upward Wilson current:
positive charge from cloud top to ionosphere
(conduction above the cloud)"| I
I -->|"fair-weather conduction current down"| F
F --> E
E -->|"under storms: negative charge to ground
by -CG lightning; point-discharge current up;
precipitation current (often opposite)"| S| Element | Role | Typical value |
|---|---|---|
| Thunderstorms, electrified shower clouds | Generators (batteries) | About 0.1 to a few A each; of order 1 A for an active thunderstorm |
| Number active at any moment | Of order a thousand to two thousand thunderstorms | |
| Ionosphere / equalisation layer | Upper conductor; equipotential | Ionospheric potential about 250 kV |
| Fair-weather atmosphere | Load (resistor) | Global resistance about 250 Ω; columnar resistance about \(10^{17}\ \Omega\,\mathrm{m^2}\) |
| Fair-weather current | Return path | About 2 pA/m², about 1 kA in total |
| Earth | Lower conductor | Surface charge about \(-5\times10^{5}\) C |
Above a storm the upper positive charge drives a conduction current upward through the increasingly conductive air to the ionosphere: positive charge flows up. Aircraft flying over thunderstorms measure these Wilson currents, typically of order an ampere.
Below a storm negative charge reaches the ground through −CG lightning and, by point discharge, positive ions flow upward from the ground (equivalent to negative charge reaching the Earth). Precipitation currents are often of the opposite sign but over land the net is a transfer of negative charge to the Earth. Averaged over the planet, this negative charge arriving under storms balances the positive charge arriving with the fair-weather current.
Electrified shower clouds that produce little or no lightning (including many oceanic clouds) still drive a conduction current to the ionosphere. They contribute a substantial share of the total, which is why global lightning counts and the global circuit current do not track each other exactly.
The circuit as a leaky capacitor
Treat the Earth and the equalisation layer as a capacitor C charged to \(V_I\), discharged through the fair-weather resistance R and recharged by the storms.
$$C \approx \frac{Q_\oplus}{V_I} = \frac{4.5\times10^{5}\ \mathrm{C}}{2.5\times10^{5}\ \mathrm{V}} \approx 1.8\ \mathrm{F}$$$$\tau = RC \approx 250\ \Omega\times1.8\ \mathrm{F} \approx 450\ \mathrm{s}$$The same time constant comes from \(Q_\oplus/I = 4.5\times10^5/10^3 = 450\) s and is of the order of the local relaxation time \(\varepsilon_0/\sigma\) near the ground (see Relaxation Time). Without storms the field would decay in minutes (e-folding time about 7 minutes); it has persisted for as long as it has been measured.
The Carnegie curve: evidence for the circuit
Over the oceans and at clean polar sites, the fair-weather PG (and the air-Earth current and ionospheric potential) follows the same universal-time daily cycle everywhere:
| Feature | Value |
|---|---|
| Minimum | Near 03–04 UT |
| Maximum | Near 19 UT |
| Amplitude | Roughly ±15% about the mean |
Thunderstorm activity on the planet is concentrated over three tropical land regions: the Americas, Africa and Southeast Asia–Maritime Continent–Australia. Each peaks in its local afternoon, so the global thunderstorm area has a universal-time cycle. Comparisons of the Carnegie curve with the global diurnal cycle of thunderstorm area (from meteorological records of thunder days, published by Whipple in 1929) matched it well, with the large American contribution in the evening UT hours and a minimum in the early UT hours when the main tropical land regions are in their night or early morning. This was the decisive support for Wilson’s hypothesis.
Other influences on the circuit
| Influence | Effect |
|---|---|
| Seasonal variation | The PG and ionospheric potential vary through the year with the global distribution of convection |
| ENSO and tropical temperature | Shift the global distribution of convection and so the source currents |
| Cosmic-ray changes (solar cycle, Forbush decreases) | Change ionization, so the columnar resistance of the load and the current reaching the ground |
| Volcanic eruptions, nuclear tests (historical) | Radioactive debris changed conductivity regionally |
| Upper-atmosphere generators | The ionospheric wind dynamo and the solar wind–magnetosphere dynamo add potential differences of tens of kV horizontally at high latitudes, superposed on the thunderstorm-driven circuit |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Stepped leader: first stroke only, stepped, branched, about \(2\times10^5\) m/s | vs | Dart leader: subsequent strokes, continuous, unbranched, about \(10^7\) m/s, uses the old channel |
| Leader: dim, moves down, deposits charge | vs | Return stroke: bright, moves up, high current, neutralises charge |
| Flash (the whole event, about 0.2–0.5 s) | vs | Stroke (one leader–return stroke pair) |
| −CG: about 90% of CG, multiple strokes | vs | +CG: about 10%, usually one stroke, long continuing current, sprites |
| Sprites: 40–90 km, red, quasi-static field of +CG | vs | Elves: ring near 90 km, electromagnetic pulse, under 1 ms |
| Blue jets: up from cloud top to about 40–50 km | vs | Gigantic jets: reach the lower ionosphere |
| Sferics: Earth–ionosphere waveguide, VLF, used to locate flashes | vs | Whistlers: along geomagnetic field lines, falling tone, \(t = D/\sqrt{f}\) |
| Schumann resonances: ELF, global cavity modes, about 7.8 Hz fundamental | vs | Sferics: individual VLF pulses from single strokes |
| Carnegie curve: universal time, oceans and clean sites | vs | Local diurnal curve: local time, polluted land, aerosol and mixing |
| Global lightning flash rate (counts flashes) | vs | Global circuit current (counts all electrified clouds, including non-flashing ones) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which part of a cloud-to-ground flash produces the bright luminous channel, and in which direction does it propagate?
- What fraction of cloud-to-ground flashes lower negative charge, roughly?
- Name the electromagnetic phenomenon in which a lightning signal travels along a geomagnetic field line and is heard as a falling tone.
Answers
- The return stroke, propagating upward from the ground at about \(10^8\) m/s.
- About 90%.
- A whistler: the magnetospheric plasma is dispersive, so higher frequencies arrive first.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). An observer sees a lightning flash and hears the first thunder 9.0 s later. Taking the speed of sound as 340 m/s, the distance to the nearest part of the channel is about:
- (a) 1.0 km
- (b) 2.0 km
- (c) 3.1 km
- (d) 9.0 km
Answer and explanation
(c). \(d = 340\times9.0 = 3060\) m ≈ 3.1 km. Light travel time is negligible (about 10 µs). The rule of thumb is 3 s per km. The first thunder comes from the nearest part of the channel; the rumble that follows comes from parts further away.
Q2 (practice). Arrange in correct time order for a negative cloud-to-ground flash: (P) dart leader, (Q) stepped leader, (R) first return stroke, (S) preliminary breakdown, (T) subsequent return stroke.
- (a) S, Q, R, P, T
- (b) Q, S, R, P, T
- (c) S, P, R, Q, T
- (d) S, Q, P, R, T
Answer and explanation
(a). In-cloud preliminary breakdown starts the flash; the stepped leader comes down; after attachment the first return stroke goes up; after tens of ms a dart leader comes down the old channel; a subsequent return stroke follows. The dart leader never precedes the first return stroke because it needs an existing channel.
Q3 (practice). For an ideal, lossless Earth–ionosphere cavity of radius 6371 km, the frequency of the fundamental Schumann mode is \(f_1 = (c/2\pi R)\sqrt{2}\). Which statement is correct?
- (a) \(f_1 \approx 7.8\) Hz, exactly as observed
- (b) \(f_1 \approx 10.6\) Hz; the observed value is lower because the cavity is lossy
- (c) \(f_1 \approx 10.6\) Hz; the observed value is higher because the ionosphere is a perfect conductor
- (d) \(f_1 \approx 47\) Hz, the wavelength being the Earth’s radius
Answer and explanation
(b). \(c/2\pi R = 3.0\times10^8/(2\pi\times6.371\times10^6) = 7.49\) Hz; times \(\sqrt2\) gives 10.6 Hz. The observed fundamental is about 7.8 Hz, about 0.74 of the ideal value, because the ionospheric boundary is a lossy, imperfect conductor. The fundamental wavelength is of the order of the Earth’s circumference, not its radius.
Q4 (practice). Using the land parameterization \(F \propto H^{4.9}\) for flash rate against cloud-top height, by what factor does the flash rate change when a continental storm’s top rises from 10 km to 12 km?
- (a) 1.2
- (b) 1.44
- (c) 2.4
- (d) 4.9
Answer and explanation
(c). \((12/10)^{4.9} = 1.2^{4.9} = e^{4.9\ln1.2} = e^{0.893} = 2.44\). A 20% deeper storm flashes about 2.4 times as often. Option (b) uses a square law.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Use these values for the global circuit: ionospheric potential 240 kV; columnar resistance of a fair-weather column \(1.2\times10^{17}\ \Omega\,\mathrm{m^2}\); Earth’s surface area \(5.1\times10^{14}\ \mathrm{m^2}\) (treat the whole surface as fair weather); Earth’s surface charge magnitude \(4.5\times10^{5}\) C.
(i) Find the fair-weather current density and the total current. (ii) Find the global load resistance. (iii) If an average active storm supplies 0.6 A to the ionosphere, how many must be active at once? (iv) Find the capacitance and the RC time constant. (v) What would happen to the PG at a clean ocean site if half the storms stopped for an hour?
Answer and worked solution
(i) \(J = V_I/R_c = 2.4\times10^5/1.2\times10^{17} = 2.0\times10^{-12}\ \mathrm{A\,m^{-2}}\) (2.0 pA/m²). \(I = JA = 2.0\times10^{-12}\times5.1\times10^{14} = 1020\) A.
(ii) \(R = V_I/I = 2.4\times10^5/1020 = 235\ \Omega\). (Equivalently \(R_c/A\).)
(iii) \(N = 1020/0.6 = 1700\) storms.
(iv) \(C = Q/V_I = 4.5\times10^5/2.4\times10^5 = 1.875\) F. \(\tau = RC = 235\times1.875 \approx 441\) s, about 7 minutes.
(v) The source current halves. Since an hour is many time constants (3600/441 ≈ 8), the circuit reaches its new steady state: \(V_I\) falls to about half (120 kV) and, with the load unchanged, \(J\) and the PG at the ocean site fall to about half their previous values. This is the logic of the Carnegie curve: the roughly ±15% universal-time swing in PG reflects a similar swing in the total generator current.
Q2 (practice). A ship in the open Pacific records the fair-weather PG; mean diurnal values, as a percentage of the daily mean, are tabulated below against universal time (illustrative data).
| UT (h) | 00 | 04 | 08 | 12 | 16 | 19 | 22 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PG (% of mean) | 98 | 84 | 90 | 100 | 110 | 117 | 106 |
Which of the following statements are correct?
- (A) If a second ship in the Indian Ocean recorded the same curve against UT, the variation could not be explained by local sunrise at either ship.
- (B) The maximum near 19 UT coincides with afternoon convection over the Americas.
- (C) If the ionospheric potential averages 250 kV, it ranges from about 210 kV to 290 kV.
- (D) The curve proves that global lightning flash rate peaks at 19 UT.
Options: (1) A and B only (2) A, B and C only (3) B and D only (4) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(2).
- (A) Correct. A local-time effect would shift with longitude (several hours between the Pacific and the Indian Ocean); the same UT curve at both ships implies a global cause.
- (B) Correct. At 19 UT it is mid-afternoon in the Americas (about 14–15 h local time at 75° W).
- (C) Correct. The PG at a clean site scales with \(V_I\) if the column resistance is fixed: 0.84 × 250 = 210 kV and 1.17 × 250 = 292.5 kV, so about 210–290 kV.
- (D) Incorrect. The circuit is driven by all electrified clouds, including weakly flashing ones; the curve is not a flash count. The curve tracks the generator current, not the flash count.
Q3 (practice). A negative CG flash removes −20 C from a height of 6 km above flat, conducting ground. Take \(k = 8.99\times10^9\ \mathrm{N\,m^2C^{-2}}\).
(i) Find the charge moment change. (ii) Find the change in the vertical field at the ground directly below, at 10 km, and at 60 km from the point below the charge. (iii) Does the far-field approximation \(2kQh/D^3\) work at 10 km and 60 km? (iv) A +CG flash in a stratiform region removes +80 C from 8 km. If a study gives an illustrative sprite-producing threshold of 500 C km, could this flash produce a sprite?
Answer and worked solution
(i) \(M_q = Qh = 20\ \mathrm{C}\times6\ \mathrm{km} = 120\) C km.
(ii) Field from a charge −Q at height h at ground distance D, with its image: \(|E_z| = 2kQh/(h^2+D^2)^{3/2}\), pointing up (toward the negative charge). Removing the charge changes the field by the same magnitude, toward downward (a positive field change in the PG convention).
- D = 0: \(2(8.99\times10^9)(20)/(6000)^2 = 9.99\times10^3\) V/m ≈ 10 kV/m.
- D = 10 km: \(2(8.99\times10^9)(20)(6000)/(3.6\times10^7+10^8)^{3/2} = 1.36\times10^3\) V/m.
- D = 60 km: \(\approx 9.84\) V/m.
(iii) Far-field values: at 10 km, \(2kQh/D^3 = 2.16\times10^3\) V/m, 59% too large (D is not ≫ h). At 60 km, \(9.99\) V/m, within 2% of the exact 9.84 V/m. Use the dipole form only when D is several times h.
(iv) \(M_q = 80\times8 = 640\) C km, above the 500 C km threshold given, so yes, this flash could produce a sprite. The −CG flash in (i), at 120 C km, is far below. This is why sprites are mostly associated with large +CG flashes from extensive stratiform charge layers.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Value or rule |
|---|---|
| Lightning types | IC (most common), CC, CA, −CG (about 90% of CG), +CG (about 10%), upward, bipolar |
| Stepped leader | Steps of tens of m, pauses of tens of µs, about \(2\times10^5\) m/s, branched, several C |
| Return stroke | Upward, about \(10^8\) m/s; first-stroke peak median about 30 kA; subsequent about 10–15 kA; about 30,000 K |
| Dart leader | Continuous, about \(10^7\) m/s, old channel, unbranched |
| Strokes per flash | 3–5 typical for −CG; interstroke tens of ms; flash 0.2–0.5 s |
| Continuing current | About 100 A, tens to hundreds of ms; fires |
| Flash totals | About 20–30 C; of order \(10^9\) J |
| +CG | One stroke, long continuing current, large charge, sprites, stratiform and winter storms |
| Thunder | \(d \approx 340\Delta t\); about 3 s per km; heard to about 15–25 km |
| Global flash rate | About 40–50 per second; about 90% over land; hotspots Congo basin, Lake Maracaibo |
| Flash rate vs cloud top | \(F \propto H^{4.9}\) land, \(H^{1.73}\) ocean (Price and Rind) |
| Detection | Magnetic direction finding, time of arrival, VLF/LF networks, VHF mapping, satellite optical sensors |
| Sferics / whistlers | Waveguide VLF pulses / field-aligned falling tones, \(t = D/\sqrt f\) |
| Schumann resonances | Observed about 7.8, 14, 20, 26, 33 Hz; ideal \(f_n = (c/2\pi R)\sqrt{n(n+1)}\) |
| TLEs | Sprites 40–90 km (+CG, red); elves about 90 km (EMP); blue jets to 40–50 km; gigantic jets to about 90 km |
| Charge moment | \(M_q = Qh\); far field change \(2kQh/D^3\) |
| Lightning NOₓ | A major upper-tropospheric NOₓ source; a few Tg N per year |
| Global circuit | Storms (about 1 A each, about 1000–2000) → ionosphere (about 250 kV) → fair-weather current (about 1 kA) → Earth (about \(-5\times10^5\) C) → storms |
| Circuit constants | R ≈ 250 Ω, C ≈ \(Q/V_I\) ≈ 1.8 F, τ ≈ 450 s |
| Carnegie curve | UT cycle; minimum near 03–04 UT, maximum near 19 UT; about ±15% |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
Consolidate the whole unit on the Atmospheric Electricity Quick Revision sheet, or return to the chapter overview. The fair-weather side of the circuit is on Fair-Weather Electric Field and Atmospheric Ionization. For the convection that powers the generators, revise Vertical Stability and Tropical Convection, and for the ionosphere and magnetosphere that bound the circuit from above, see Geomagnetic Field and Its Variations.