Visibility and Wind Shear
CSIR NET Part C aviation meteorology: Koschmieder's law, MOR and RVR, fog types, low-level wind shear, microbursts, the F-factor and shear detection.
- 22 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Weather Hazards at Take-off, Cruise and Landing — METAR visibility groups, ceiling, and why approach has the smallest margins.
- Extinction, scattering and the optics of visibility, from Atmospheric Optics and Radiation, Scattering, Radiative Transfer and the Greenhouse Effect.
- Buoyancy, evaporative cooling and the inverted-V sounding, from Vertical Stability and Tropical Convection.
- Humidity variables and dew point, from Humidity, Precipitation and Water Balance.
The Hook: The Wind That Pushed Up Before It Pushed Down
Part 1: Visibility
Definitions you must keep apart
| Term | Definition | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Meteorological visibility (daytime) | Greatest distance at which a black object of suitable size near the ground can be seen and recognised against the horizon sky | Human observation |
| Meteorological optical range (MOR) | Length of path in the atmosphere needed to reduce the luminous flux of a collimated beam from an incandescent lamp (colour temperature 2700 K) to 5% of its original value | WMO instrumental definition, measured by transmissometers and forward-scatter meters |
| Runway visual range (RVR) | Range over which a pilot on the runway centre line can see the runway surface markings or the lights delineating the runway or its centre line | Reported for each runway (touchdown, mid-point, stop-end) when visibility is low |
| Prevailing visibility | Visibility value reached or exceeded over at least half the horizon circle or aerodrome surface | Main METAR value |
| Vertical visibility | How far one can see vertically into an obscuring layer (fog, heavy snow) when the sky is obscured | METAR VV group, in hundreds of feet |
| Slant visibility | Visibility along the descent path from the cockpit | Can differ greatly from horizontal visibility in shallow fog |
Shallow fog is the classic case where these disagree: the tower may see the sky overhead, yet a pilot on approach looking obliquely through the fog layer sees little of the runway until very low.
Koschmieder’s law
The contrast of a dark object against the horizon sky decays with distance \( x \) because the air between scatters light out of the line of sight (extinction) and scatters skylight into it (airlight). For a uniform atmosphere with extinction coefficient \( \sigma \),
$$C(x) = C_0\,e^{-\sigma x}$$The object disappears when \( |C| \) falls to the observer’s contrast threshold \( \varepsilon \). For a black object (\( C_0 = -1 \)):
$$\boxed{V = \frac{-\ln\varepsilon}{\sigma}}$$| Threshold \( \varepsilon \) | Visibility | Use |
|---|---|---|
| 0.02 (Koschmieder’s original) | \( V = 3.912/\sigma \) | Classical daytime visual range |
| 0.05 | \( V = 2.996/\sigma \) | Matches the MOR definition (5% transmission) |
The extinction coefficient sums scattering and absorption by gases, aerosols and hydrometeors. For a population of droplets much larger than the wavelength, each droplet removes about twice its geometric cross-section (extinction efficiency \( Q_\text{ext} \approx 2 \)), so
$$\sigma \approx N\,Q_\text{ext}\,\pi r^2 \approx 2N\pi r^2$$At night, observers judge visibility from lights, not dark objects. A light of intensity \( I \) gives illuminance at distance \( x \) by Allard’s law,
$$E = \frac{I\,e^{-\sigma x}}{x^2}$$and is seen while \( E \) exceeds the eye’s illuminance threshold (which depends on background brightness). RVR is computed this way from runway light intensity, a transmissometer’s \( \sigma \), and a background luminance sensor.
What restricts visibility
| Obscuration | METAR code | Defining features |
|---|---|---|
| Fog | FG | Suspended droplets (or ice crystals); visibility below 1,000 m; high relative humidity |
| Mist | BR | Droplets with visibility 1,000 m or more (reported up to 5,000 m) |
| Haze | HZ | Dry, very small particles; relative humidity lower; bluish or yellowish tint |
| Smoke | FU | Combustion particles (crop residue burning, forest fires, industry) |
| Dust / sand | DU, SA; DS, SS for duststorm, sandstorm | Lifted mineral dust; widespread or raised locally by strong winds |
| Precipitation | RA, SN, DZ (with + for heavy) | Heavy rain and snow cut visibility sharply; snow more than rain for the same rate |
| Low cloud | Ceiling groups | Cloud on the approach path is a “visibility” problem for landing |
Over India: winter fog over the Indo-Gangetic plains, smoke and haze in the post-monsoon burning season over the north-west, dust storms over the north-west in the pre-monsoon season, and heavy monsoon rain everywhere.
Fog types
Fog forms when air near the surface becomes saturated, by cooling to its dew point or by adding water vapour, and when there are nuclei for droplets to form on.
| Type | Mechanism | Typical setting | Dissipation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Radiation fog | Nocturnal radiative cooling of the ground and the air in contact with it | Clear sky, light wind, moist ground, long nights; valleys and plains in winter | Solar heating from the surface erodes it, often lifting it first into low stratus; or a wind increase mixes it out |
| Advection fog | Warm moist air moves over a colder surface and is cooled from below | Coasts over cold currents; warm air over snow or cold land; can persist day and night with moderate wind | Change of air mass or wind direction |
| Upslope fog | Adiabatic cooling of moist air forced up rising terrain | Windward slopes | Wind change |
| Steam (evaporation) fog | Cold air over much warmer water; evaporation saturates the cold air | Rivers, lakes and sea in cold outbreaks | Mixing or warming |
| Frontal (precipitation) fog | Warm rain falls through cold air and evaporates, saturating it | Ahead of warm fronts | Front passes |
| Ice fog | Ice crystals at very low temperatures | High latitudes, high altitude | Warming |
Radiation fog in detail
Radiation fog is the commonest aviation fog over north India in winter (December–January), and the favourite Part C fog question.
graph TD
A["Clear sky:
strong longwave loss
from the ground"] --> D["Surface cools;
nocturnal inversion forms"]
B["Light wind:
some mixing, not too much"] --> D
C["Moist surface air:
small dew-point depression,
wet soil after rain"] --> D
D --> E["Air cools to dew point;
droplets form on aerosols"]
E --> F["Fog top radiates;
cooling moves up;
fog deepens through the night"]
F --> G["After sunrise:
solar heating and mixing;
fog lifts to stratus, then clears"]Key points:
- Wind: with calm air, cooling is confined to a very thin layer and dew or a shallow ground fog forms. A light wind mixes the cooling through a deeper layer and favours fog. A stronger wind mixes in warmer, drier air from above, giving low stratus at most.
- Cloud cover: a cloud layer moving in overnight sends longwave radiation back down, stops the cooling, and can prevent or dissolve fog.
- Moisture source: wet soil after rain (for example after a western disturbance over north India), irrigation, and nearby water bodies lower the dew-point depression at sunset.
- Self-maintenance: once formed, the fog top becomes the main radiating surface; cooling at the top drives weak mixing inside the fog and it deepens.
- Aerosols: pollution provides many condensation nuclei, giving more numerous, smaller droplets and lower visibility for the same water (see the worked example).
- Dissipation: the sun heats the ground through thin fog; the fog lifts, thins from below, becomes stratus and breaks up. Thick fog with a strong inversion above can persist all day in midwinter.
A simple forecasting check: compare the expected night minimum temperature with the dew point. If the forecast minimum falls to or below the afternoon or evening dew point (sometimes called the crossover temperature approach) under clear skies and light winds, radiation fog is likely. Real forecasting adds the wind profile, soil moisture, cloud and model guidance.
Visibility and operations
Each type of approach has minima for decision height (or minimum descent altitude) and for RVR or visibility. Precision approaches with more capable aircraft equipment, crew training and airport lighting (Category II and III operations) allow landing in much lower RVR than basic instrument approaches; some aerodromes in north India are equipped for the most demanding categories because of winter fog. When RVR is below the minima for the approach, the crew holds, diverts or does not start the approach. Low visibility also slows ground movement and reduces runway capacity, so fog causes cascading delays across the network.
Part 2: Wind Shear
Definition
Wind shear is a change in wind speed and/or direction over a short distance, horizontally or vertically. For aviation, the critical case is low-level wind shear along the take-off and approach paths, within a few hundred metres of the ground (ICAO material on wind-shear warnings refers to the layer up to about 500 m, or 1,600 ft).
Note the distinction: a vertical wind shear of 10 m s\(^{-1}\) per km in the free atmosphere is normal; the hazard is a large change within the few tens of seconds an aircraft takes to fly through it, close to the ground.
Sources of low-level wind shear
| Source | Mechanism | Typical shear |
|---|---|---|
| Microbursts and downbursts | Convective downdraft hits the ground and spreads outward | Headwind to tailwind change across a few kilometres, plus downdraft |
| Gust fronts | Leading edge of a storm’s cold outflow, can extend many km ahead of the storm | Abrupt wind shift and surge, turbulence, possible shelf cloud |
| Fronts | Wind change across a frontal surface, especially fast-moving cold fronts | Vertical and horizontal shear through the frontal zone |
| Low-level jets above nocturnal inversions | Surface air decouples at night; wind above the inversion accelerates | Strong speed shear in the lowest few hundred metres at night and dawn |
| Sea-breeze fronts | Convergence where the onshore flow meets the land flow | Wind reversal, often in the afternoon at coastal aerodromes |
| Terrain and buildings | Flow separation and channelling around hills, valleys, hangars | Localised, depends on wind direction |
| Strong surface winds | Mechanical turbulence and gust structure | Gust-related airspeed changes |
Downbursts and microbursts
Fujita defined a downburst as a strong downdraft that induces an outburst of damaging winds at or near the ground, and split it by the horizontal extent of the outflow:
| Type | Outflow extent | Lifetime of strongest winds |
|---|---|---|
| Microburst | Less than 4 km | A few minutes |
| Macroburst | 4 km or more | Longer, up to tens of minutes |
What drives the downdraft. A downdraft accelerates when the air in it becomes negatively buoyant. Its buoyancy, including the weight of the water it carries, is approximately
$$b \approx g\left(\frac{T_v' }{\bar T_v} - r_h\right)$$where \( T_v' \) is the virtual temperature difference from the environment and \( r_h \) the mixing ratio of liquid and ice (the precipitation loading term). Three processes make the air negative:
- Evaporative cooling of rain falling through dry air (the strongest driver in dry microbursts).
- Melting of hail and graupel just below the freezing level (cools the air by absorbing latent heat of fusion).
- Precipitation loading (the drag of falling hydrometeors).
Ignoring mixing and drag, a parcel colder than its environment by \( \Delta T \) over a depth \( H \) gains a downward speed
$$w \approx \sqrt{2gH\frac{\Delta T}{T}}$$This is an upper estimate; entrainment and pressure perturbations reduce it.
| Type | Setting | Sounding | Radar and visual clues |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wet microburst | Humid environments; heavy rain shaft | Moist, with a dry layer at middle levels; loading and evaporation of entrained dry air | Heavy rain reaches the ground; high reflectivity |
| Dry microburst | High cloud base above a deep, dry, well-mixed subcloud layer | Inverted-V: temperature and dew-point lines diverge downward from cloud base | Virga or weak echo; dust ring at the surface |
Dry microbursts are common over arid and semi-arid regions in the hot season, including north-west India before the monsoon; wet microbursts dominate humid tropical convection.
Structure at the surface. The downdraft spreads radially as a shallow outflow, often with a ring vortex curling up at its leading edge. Peak outflow winds lie very close to the ground, typically within the lowest hundred metres or so. An aircraft crossing the centre therefore meets equal and opposite horizontal winds on each side.
The microburst encounter
graph LR
A["1. Enter outflow:
headwind increases;
airspeed and lift rise;
aircraft balloons above path"] --> B["2. Core:
headwind falls,
downdraft pushes
aircraft down"]
B --> C["3. Exit:
tailwind;
airspeed and lift fall;
aircraft sinks below path"]
C --> D["Crew reduced thrust
in stage 1, so recovery
is late: crash risk"]The physics is simple. At the instant the wind changes, the aircraft’s ground speed is unchanged (inertia) but its airspeed changes by the wind change. On approach:
- Performance-increasing shear (increasing headwind or decreasing tailwind): airspeed rises; the aircraft climbs above the glide path. A natural response is to reduce thrust.
- Performance-decreasing shear (decreasing headwind, increasing tailwind, downdraft): airspeed falls; lift (∝ \( V^2 \)) falls; the aircraft sinks.
The trap is the sequence: the crew corrects for the first, then meets the second with low thrust, close to the ground, with a downdraft added. Total airspeed change across a microburst can be several tens of knots.
The F-factor
Wind-shear alerting systems on aircraft express the hazard as the F-factor, the loss of the aircraft’s ability to maintain energy:
$$\boxed{F = \frac{1}{g}\frac{dW_x}{dt} - \frac{w}{V}}$$where \( W_x \) is the horizontal wind component along the flight path (positive as a tailwind, so a change from headwind to tailwind makes \( dW_x/dt > 0 \)), \( w \) the vertical wind (positive upward, so a downdraft makes \( -w/V > 0 \)), and \( V \) the airspeed. \( F \) is positive for performance-decreasing shear. Its meaning: \( F \) equals the climb gradient lost to the shear. When \( F \) exceeds the aircraft’s available climb gradient, the aircraft loses energy (height or speed) however it is flown. Operational alert thresholds are of order 0.1.
Detection and avoidance
| System | Principle | Strengths and limits |
|---|---|---|
| LLWAS (Low-Level Wind Shear Alert System) | Network of anemometers around the runways; compares winds to detect divergence and convergence | Direct surface wind; cannot see shear aloft or beyond the network |
| Terminal Doppler weather radar | Radial velocity reveals divergent couplets (approaching on the near side, receding on the far side) near the surface, plus gust fronts and storm cells | Sees the whole terminal area; relies on precipitation or insect/dust echo; less effective in dry microbursts with weak echo |
| Doppler lidar | Measures radial wind from aerosol backscatter | Works in clear air (dry shear, terrain-induced shear); limited by heavy rain and fog |
| Wind profilers and sodar | Vertical wind profile | Detect low-level jets and frontal shear over a site |
| Airborne predictive systems | Forward-looking Doppler weather radar on the aircraft | Warns before entry; needs hydrometeors |
| Airborne reactive systems | Compute F-factor from the aircraft’s own sensors | Warn on entry; recovery guidance (maximum thrust, pitch to the limit) |
| Pilot reports and observation | Virga, dust rings, rain shafts, gust fronts | Human judgement; dry microbursts can be nearly invisible |
The most effective measure is avoidance: do not take off or land into or near an active thunderstorm cell or a reported microburst. The detection side is developed further in Nowcasting.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| MOR: instrumental, 5% transmission | vs | Meteorological visibility: human, dark object against sky (2% classical threshold) |
| RVR: what a pilot on the runway sees (markings and lights) | vs | Prevailing visibility: half the horizon or more |
| Fog: visibility below 1 km | vs | Mist: visibility 1 km or more, still moist |
| Mist: wet droplets, high RH | vs | Haze: dry particles, lower RH |
| Radiation fog: forms in light wind, clears in daytime | vs | Advection fog: needs wind, persists day and night |
| Microburst (< 4 km) | vs | Macroburst (≥ 4 km) |
| Wet microburst: heavy rain, high reflectivity | vs | Dry microburst: inverted-V sounding, virga, weak echo |
| Gust front: leading edge of the outflow, can be far from the storm | vs | Downburst: the downdraft and its immediate outflow |
| Performance-increasing shear (more headwind) | vs | Performance-decreasing shear (less headwind, tailwind, downdraft) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- State Koschmieder’s law for a 2% contrast threshold.
- What outflow size separates a microburst from a macroburst?
- What visibility separates fog from mist?
Answers
- \( V = 3.912/\sigma \).
- 4 km (Fujita).
- 1,000 m: fog below, mist at or above.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A transmissometer measures an extinction coefficient of 19.6 km\(^{-1}\). The MOR (5% threshold) is about:
- (a) 50 m
- (b) 150 m
- (c) 200 m
- (d) 1.5 km
Answer and explanation
(b). MOR = 2.996/σ = 2.996/19.6 km ≈ 0.153 km ≈ 150 m. With the 2% threshold it would be 3.912/19.6 ≈ 200 m, option (c), so read which definition the question uses.
Q2 (practice). Which set of conditions most favours dense radiation fog at an inland aerodrome?
- (a) Overcast sky, strong wind, dry air
- (b) Clear sky, light wind, moist ground after rain, long winter night
- (c) Clear sky, strong wind, dry air
- (d) Overcast sky, calm, warm moist air over warm ground
Answer and explanation
(b). Clear skies maximise longwave cooling; light wind spreads the cooling through a layer; moist ground reduces the dew-point depression; long nights allow more cooling.
Q3 (practice). A sounding shows a cloud base near 3 km with an almost dry-adiabatic, very dry layer below, with the temperature and dew-point profiles diverging downward. The convective downdraft hazard most likely is:
- (a) a wet microburst with very heavy rain
- (b) a dry microburst with virga and weak radar echo
- (c) freezing rain
- (d) advection fog
Answer and explanation
(b). The inverted-V sounding is the dry-microburst signature: rain evaporating into the deep dry layer cools it strongly, driving a fast downdraft that may produce only virga and a dust ring.
Q4 (practice). An aircraft on approach at 140 kt meets a microburst in which a 15 kt headwind changes to a 15 kt tailwind. If pitch and thrust are unchanged, the lift just after the change is roughly what fraction of the lift before?
- (a) 0.95
- (b) 0.79
- (c) 0.62
- (d) 0.45
Answer and explanation
(c). The airspeed falls by the wind change, 30 kt, to 110 kt. Lift ∝ \( V^2 \): \( (110/140)^2 \approx 0.62 \), a loss of about 38%.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Rain evaporating below a cloud base cools a downdraft by 3 K relative to its environment (mean temperature 300 K) over a depth of 1.5 km.
(i) Estimate the maximum downdraft speed at the ground, ignoring drag, mixing and loading. (ii) If precipitation loading adds a mixing ratio of 4 g kg\(^{-1}\) of rain, how much does the effective negative buoyancy change? (iii) Give two reasons the real downdraft is slower than (i).
Answer and worked solution
- \( w = \sqrt{2gH\,\Delta T/T} = \sqrt{2\times9.81\times1500\times3/300} = \sqrt{294.3} \approx \) 17 m s\(^{-1}\).
- Thermal term: \( g\Delta T/T = 9.81\times0.01 = 0.098\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}} \). Loading term: \( g r_h = 9.81\times0.004 = 0.039\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}} \). Total negative buoyancy ≈ 0.137 m s\(^{-2}\), about 40% more than thermal alone (the speed estimate rises by \( \sqrt{1.4} \approx 1.18 \), to about 20 m s\(^{-1}\)).
- Entrainment of environmental air dilutes the cold anomaly; pressure perturbations decelerate the flow as it nears the ground and turns horizontal; the cooling is not uniform over the whole depth. The estimate is an upper bound.
Q2 (practice). A jet at 75 m s\(^{-1}\) traverses a microburst. Along its path the horizontal wind changes from a 15 m s\(^{-1}\) headwind to a 25 m s\(^{-1}\) tailwind over 4 km, and the core downdraft is 6 m s\(^{-1}\).
(i) Compute the F-factor. (ii) Compare with an alert threshold of about 0.1. (iii) By how much does the airspeed change across the event, and why does the crew’s reaction at entry matter?
Answer and worked solution
- Crossing time = 4000/75 = 53.3 s. \( dW_x/dt = 40/53.3 = 0.75\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}} \); divided by g: 0.076. Downdraft term: 6/75 = 0.080. \( F \approx \) 0.156.
- Above 0.1: a hazardous, performance-decreasing shear; an alert would be issued.
- Airspeed falls by 40 m s\(^{-1}\) (about 78 kt) between entry and exit at constant ground speed. At entry the headwind raises airspeed by 15 m s\(^{-1}\) and the aircraft balloons; reducing thrust then leaves it with low energy just as the downdraft and tailwind arrive. The recovery technique is maximum thrust and pitch to the limit, accepting the airspeed.
Q3 (practice). At a north Indian aerodrome on a December evening: clear sky, surface wind 2 m s\(^{-1}\), temperature 16 °C, dew point 10 °C at 1800 local time, forecast minimum 8 °C, light rain the previous day, no cloud expected. Which statements are correct?
(A) The forecast minimum is below the evening dew point, so saturation near the surface is likely overnight. (B) The light wind favours a deeper fog than dead calm would. (C) A stratocumulus sheet arriving at 0200 would favour the fog deepening. (D) Polluted air with abundant aerosol would tend to give lower visibility for the same liquid water content.
- (a) A, B and D only
- (b) A and C only
- (c) B, C and D only
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B and D only.
- (A) Cooling to 8 °C passes the 10 °C dew point (the dew point itself falls a little as dew forms, but the crossover check indicates fog risk). Correct.
- (B) Light wind spreads cooling through a deeper layer. Correct.
- (C) Cloud returns longwave radiation, stopping surface cooling; it tends to prevent or lift fog, not deepen it. Incorrect.
- (D) More CCN means more, smaller droplets; \( \sigma \propto \mathrm{LWC}/r \), so visibility falls. Correct.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Koschmieder | \( V = -\ln\varepsilon/\sigma \): 3.912/σ (2%), 2.996/σ (5%, MOR) |
| Droplet extinction | \( \sigma \approx 2N\pi r^2 \propto \mathrm{LWC}/r \) |
| Allard’s law (lights, night) | \( E = I e^{-\sigma x}/x^2 \) |
| MOR | Path for 5% transmission of a 2700 K lamp beam |
| RVR | What a pilot on the centre line sees of markings and lights |
| Fog / mist | Below 1,000 m / 1,000 m and above |
| Haze vs mist | Dry particles vs wet droplets |
| Radiation fog | Clear, light wind, moist, long night; clears by solar heating, lifts to stratus |
| Advection fog | Warm moist air over cold surface; persists with wind |
| Fog forecasting | Night minimum vs dew point (crossover check) |
| Low-level wind shear | Along take-off and approach paths, lowest few hundred m |
| Shear sources | Microbursts, gust fronts, fronts, nocturnal low-level jets, sea breeze, terrain |
| Microburst / macroburst | < 4 km / ≥ 4 km (Fujita) |
| Downdraft drivers | Evaporation, melting, precipitation loading |
| Downdraft speed | \( w \approx \sqrt{2gH\Delta T/T} \) (upper bound) |
| Dry microburst | Inverted-V sounding, virga, weak echo |
| Encounter | Headwind (balloon), downdraft, tailwind (sink) |
| F-factor | \( F = \dot W_x/g - w/V \); alert thresholds of order 0.1 |
| Detection | LLWAS, terminal Doppler radar, lidar, profilers, airborne predictive and reactive systems |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Nowcasting — how radar, satellite and lightning data turn these signatures into warnings for the next hour or two.
- Icing and Turbulence — revisit the other half of the hazard line.
- Atmospheric Optics — scattering theory behind extinction and visibility.
- Quick Revision — the whole unit on one page.