Nekton, Benthos and Fisheries
CSIR NET Ocean Sciences: nekton groups and migrations, benthic communities and larvae, fishery biology, Schaefer MSY, mortality, growth and Indian fisheries.
- 18 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Plankton, nekton and benthos as life habits, and benthic size classes: Marine Environments, Organisms and Their Adaptations.
- Primary and secondary production and growth efficiencies: Primary and Secondary Production and Plankton.
- Logistic growth, r and K, and population regulation: Environment, Adaptations and Population Ecology.
- Upwelling and ENSO, which drive fishery fluctuations: Ocean Circulation: Ekman, Upwelling, ENSO, IOD.
The Hook: The Sardine That Comes and Goes
Nekton
Nekton are animals that swim strongly enough to move independently of currents.
| Group | Members | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Bony fishes (teleosts) | sardines, anchovies, mackerels, tunas, cods, flatfishes, croakers | most species and most of the catch |
| Cartilaginous fishes | sharks, rays, skates | no swim bladder; buoyancy from a large oily liver; slow growth and few young, so vulnerable to fishing |
| Cephalopods | squids, cuttlefishes, octopuses | jet propulsion; fast growth, short life |
| Marine mammals | cetaceans (baleen whales that filter krill and small fish; toothed whales and dolphins that echolocate), pinnipeds (seals, sea lions), sirenians (dugong, manatees) | the dugong in India is found in the Gulf of Mannar, Palk Bay, Gulf of Kachchh and the Andaman and Nicobar Islands |
| Marine reptiles | sea turtles, sea snakes, saltwater crocodile | olive ridley turtles nest en masse (arribada) on the Odisha coast, notably at Gahirmatha and Rushikulya |
| Seabirds | penguins (swimming), petrels, gannets | top predators linked to the sea for food |
Swimming adaptations
- Fusiform (spindle) body minimises drag; tunas are the extreme.
- High-aspect-ratio, lunate tail (tunas, swordfish, lamnid sharks) gives efficient fast cruising; broad tails give acceleration.
- Buoyancy: teleosts use a gas-filled swim bladder; sharks use liver oil (low-density lipids such as squalene) and lift from pectoral fins.
- Red and white muscle: red (aerobic, myoglobin-rich) for cruising, white (anaerobic) for bursts.
- Schooling: reduces the chance of any individual being caught (confusion and dilution), and may save energy.
Where nekton live
| Habitat group | Examples | Fishing method |
|---|---|---|
| Epipelagic (small pelagics) | sardines, anchovies, herrings, mackerels | purse seines, ring seines, gillnets |
| Epipelagic (large pelagics) | tunas, billfishes, oceanic sharks | longlines, purse seines, pole-and-line (skipjack in Lakshadweep) |
| Mesopelagic | lanternfishes, bristlemouths | hardly fished; large but poorly known biomass |
| Demersal (near the bottom) | cod, croakers, threadfin breams, flatfishes, shrimps | bottom trawls, gillnets |
Migrations
| Type | Definition | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Anadromous | live in the sea, ascend rivers to spawn | salmon, hilsa (Tenualosa ilisha), shads |
| Catadromous | live in fresh water, descend to the sea to spawn | freshwater eels (Anguilla); Atlantic eels spawn in the Sargasso Sea |
| Amphidromous | move between fresh water and sea but not for breeding | some gobies |
| Oceanodromous | migrate within the sea | tunas, many sharks |
| Seasonal feeding–breeding | feed at high latitudes in summer, breed in warm water in winter | humpback and other baleen whales |
Benthos
Hard and soft bottoms
| Hard (rocky) bottom | Soft (sediment) bottom |
|---|---|
| mostly epifauna: barnacles, mussels, sponges, corals, seaweeds | mostly infauna: polychaetes, bivalves, crustaceans, echinoderms burrowing in sand and mud |
| competition for space is the main interaction | competition for food and the effect of animals on the sediment are central |
| strong zonation on shores | gradients follow grain size and organic content |
Feeding types
- Suspension (filter) feeders strain particles from the water: mussels, barnacles, sponges, sea pens, many polychaetes. They dominate sandy, current-swept bottoms with suspended food.
- Deposit feeders ingest sediment and digest its organic coating and bacteria: lugworms, holothurians, many polychaetes and bivalves. They dominate muddy, organic-rich bottoms.
- Trophic-group amensalism (Rhoads and Young, 1970): deposit feeders rework and loosen mud, which resuspends easily and clogs the feeding structures of suspension feeders and buries their larvae, so the two groups tend to exclude each other.
- Carnivores, scavengers and grazers complete the community.
Bioturbation and benthic–pelagic coupling
- Bioturbation: burrowing and feeding mix sediment; bioirrigation pumps oxygenated water into burrows. Both move the oxygen and redox boundaries deeper and speed up remineralisation and nutrient return to the water. The sediment side is covered in Oceanic Sediments and Diagenesis.
- Benthic–pelagic coupling: on shallow shelves a large share of production sinks to the bottom and feeds the benthos, which return nutrients to the water. In the deep sea only a few per cent of surface production reaches the floor, so benthic biomass falls roughly exponentially with depth, and the community is dominated by small animals.
Larval strategies
| Type | Features | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Planktotrophic | many small eggs; larvae feed in the plankton for weeks | wide dispersal, high mortality |
| Lecithotrophic | fewer, yolky eggs; larvae do not feed | short larval life, moderate dispersal |
| Direct development | brooded or encapsulated young | no dispersal phase; low mortality |
Thorson’s rule: the proportion of species with planktotrophic larvae falls towards the poles and into the deep sea, where cold and short or unpredictable food supply favour lecithotrophy and brooding. Larvae settle in response to cues: chemical signals from adults (gregarious settlement in barnacles), biofilms and surface texture.
Organic enrichment: the Pearson–Rosenberg model
Along a gradient of increasing organic input (from a sewage outfall or a fish farm), benthic communities change in a predictable way (Pearson and Rosenberg, 1978):
graph LR
A[Normal: many species, large long-lived deep burrowers] --> B[Transitional: species number falls]
B --> C[Peak of opportunists: few species, huge numbers of small polychaetes such as Capitella]
C --> D[Grossly polluted: azoic sediment, anoxic and sulfidic]Species richness falls steadily, while total abundance peaks at the opportunist stage (the “peak of opportunists”) before collapsing. Biomass peaks at a milder level of enrichment, in the transition zone before the opportunist peak, where larger species still benefit from the extra food. The model is used to monitor pollution with benthic samples.
Sampling the benthos
Grabs (Van Veen, Smith–McIntyre) and box corers for quantitative infauna, multicorers for undisturbed surface sediment and meiofauna, dredges and trawls for epifauna (qualitative), and ROVs and cameras for the deep sea. Macrofauna are sieved on 0.5 mm mesh (sometimes 0.3 mm). Diversity is commonly summarised with the Shannon index
$$H' = -\sum_i p_i \ln p_i$$where \( p_i \) is the proportion of individuals in species \( i \).
Fisheries
Stocks, growth and mortality
A stock is a group of a species that is self-sustaining and can be managed as a unit. Its biomass rises with recruitment and growth and falls with natural mortality and fishing mortality.
Growth: von Bertalanffy equation
$$L_t = L_\infty\left(1 - e^{-K(t - t_0)}\right)$$\( L_\infty \) is the asymptotic length, \( K \) the growth coefficient (yr\(^{-1}\)), \( t_0 \) the theoretical age at zero length. Age is read from otoliths, scales or length-frequency analysis (in tropical fish, which lack clear annual rings, length-frequency methods are common).
Mortality
$$N_t = N_0\, e^{-Zt}, \qquad Z = F + M$$\( Z \) is total instantaneous mortality, \( F \) fishing mortality, \( M \) natural mortality. The exploitation rate \( E = F/Z \). The catch from a cohort over time \( t \) is given by the Baranov catch equation:
$$C = \frac{F}{Z}\, N_0\left(1 - e^{-Zt}\right)$$Surplus production: the Schaefer model
Treat the stock as a single biomass \( B \) growing logistically and harvested at catch rate \( C \):
$$\frac{dB}{dt} = rB\left(1 - \frac{B}{K}\right) - C, \qquad C = qEB$$where \( r \) is the intrinsic growth rate, \( K \) the carrying capacity, \( q \) the catchability coefficient and \( E \) the fishing effort. Surplus production is greatest at half the carrying capacity:
$$B_{MSY} = \frac{K}{2}, \qquad \text{MSY} = \frac{rK}{4}, \qquad E_{MSY} = \frac{r}{2q}$$At equilibrium, catch per unit effort (CPUE) falls linearly with effort:
$$\text{CPUE} = \frac{C}{E} = qK - \frac{q^2 K}{r}E = a - bE$$so from a regression of CPUE on effort, \( E_{MSY} = a/(2b) \) and \( \text{MSY} = a^2/(4b) \). The yield–effort curve is a parabola, \( Y = aE - bE^2 \).
Other models
| Model | Idea |
|---|---|
| Beverton–Holt yield per recruit | combines growth and mortality to find the age (mesh size) and \( F \) that maximise yield from each recruit |
| Stock–recruitment (Ricker; Beverton–Holt) | recruitment as a function of spawning stock; Ricker’s curve is dome-shaped (overcompensation), Beverton–Holt’s levels off |
| Virtual population analysis (VPA) | reconstructs past numbers at age from catch-at-age data, working backwards |
| Ecosystem models | include predators, prey and environment (ecosystem-based fishery management) |
Kinds of overfishing
| Type | Meaning | Sign |
|---|---|---|
| Growth overfishing | fish caught before they reach the size that maximises yield per recruit | catch dominated by small, young fish |
| Recruitment overfishing | spawning stock reduced so far that recruitment falls | recruitment failure, stock collapse |
| Ecosystem overfishing | removal changes the food web (predators down, prey or jellyfish up) | falling mean trophic level of the catch |
Classic collapses: the Peruvian anchoveta in the early 1970s (overfishing combined with a strong El Niño) and the Newfoundland northern cod, under a moratorium since 1992. Both are discussed further on the impacts page.
Why fish come from upwelling and shelves
Fish production depends on primary production and on how many trophic steps separate fish from phytoplankton:
$$P_{fish} = P_{primary} \times \text{TE}^{\,n}$$where TE is the transfer efficiency and \( n \) the number of transfers. In upwelling systems, large diatoms are eaten directly by anchovies and sardines, so \( n \) is small and TE is higher; in the open ocean, tiny cells pass through several steps of the microbial food web before reaching a fish. That is why a small fraction of the ocean’s area (upwelling zones and shelves) yields most of the world’s fish catch. The calculation is worked in the energy flow page.
Indian marine fisheries
| Resource | Where | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Oil sardine (Sardinella longiceps) | south-west coast (Kerala, Karnataka) | plankton feeder; landings fluctuate with upwelling and SST |
| Indian mackerel (Rastrelliger kanagurta) | west coast mainly | small pelagic |
| Bombay duck (Harpadon nehereus) | north-west coast (Gujarat, Maharashtra) | caught in stationary bag nets |
| Penaeid shrimps | both coasts | high value; bottom trawls; mangrove and estuarine nursery |
| Hilsa (Tenualosa ilisha) | Bay of Bengal and its rivers | anadromous |
| Tunas | Lakshadweep (skipjack by pole and line), Andaman and Nicobar, oceanic waters | oceanic resource, under-exploited in the EEZ |
| Ribbonfishes, croakers, threadfin breams, cephalopods | both coasts | trawl and gillnet catches |
- India’s Exclusive Economic Zone is about 2.02 million km\(^2\).
- Most landings come from the shelf, and the west coast lands more than the east, reflecting the higher productivity of the Arabian Sea.
- Potential Fishing Zone (PFZ) advisories issued by INCOIS (Hyderabad) use satellite sea-surface temperature and chlorophyll to point fishers to fronts and productive patches.
- Research and assessment are led by the ICAR-Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute (CMFRI, Kochi) and the Fishery Survey of India.
- A seasonal fishing ban for mechanised boats during the monsoon (west coast) and the pre-monsoon (east coast) protects spawning stocks.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Anadromous: sea → river to spawn | vs | Catadromous: river → sea to spawn |
| Epifauna: on the bottom | vs | Infauna: in the sediment |
| Suspension feeder: strains water | vs | Deposit feeder: eats sediment |
| Planktotrophic larva: feeds, disperses far | vs | Lecithotrophic larva: yolk-fed, short larval life |
| Growth overfishing: fish too young | vs | Recruitment overfishing: too few spawners |
| MSY: peak of the yield–effort parabola | vs | MEY: lower effort, maximum profit |
| Z (total mortality) | vs | F (fishing) and M (natural); \( Z = F + M \) |
| Pelagic fish: water column (sardine, tuna) | vs | Demersal fish: near the bottom (croaker, flatfish) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- At what fraction of the carrying capacity is surplus production maximal in the Schaefer model?
- What do we call fish that migrate from fresh water to the sea to spawn?
- Which polychaete genus is the classic opportunist in organically enriched sediments?
Answers
- One half (\( K/2 \)).
- Catadromous.
- Capitella.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A stock has \( r = 0.6 \) yr\(^{-1}\) and \( K = 2.0 \times 10^6 \) t. Its maximum sustainable yield is:
- (a) \( 1.2 \times 10^6 \) t yr\(^{-1}\)
- (b) \( 6.0 \times 10^5 \) t yr\(^{-1}\)
- (c) \( 3.0 \times 10^5 \) t yr\(^{-1}\)
- (d) \( 1.0 \times 10^6 \) t yr\(^{-1}\)
Answer and explanation
(c). MSY = \( rK/4 = 0.6 \times 2.0\times10^6/4 = 3.0\times10^5 \) t yr\(^{-1}\), taken when the biomass is held at \( K/2 = 1.0\times10^6 \) t. (d) is \( B_{MSY} \), not the yield.
Q2 (practice). A fish follows the von Bertalanffy equation with \( L_\infty = 30 \) cm, \( K = 0.8 \) yr\(^{-1}\) and \( t_0 = 0 \). Its length at age 2 years is closest to:
- (a) 12.0 cm
- (b) 19.0 cm
- (c) 24.0 cm
- (d) 28.5 cm
Answer and explanation
(c). \( L_2 = 30(1 - e^{-1.6}) = 30(1 - 0.202) = 23.9 \) cm. Fast-growing small pelagics reach most of their asymptotic length within two or three years.
Q3 (practice). In a stock, total mortality \( Z = 1.2 \) yr\(^{-1}\) and natural mortality \( M = 0.4 \) yr\(^{-1}\). Which is correct?
- (a) \( F = 1.6 \) yr\(^{-1}\); exploitation rate 0.33
- (b) \( F = 0.8 \) yr\(^{-1}\); exploitation rate 0.67
- (c) \( F = 0.8 \) yr\(^{-1}\); exploitation rate 2.0
- (d) \( F = 0.4 \) yr\(^{-1}\); exploitation rate 0.5
Answer and explanation
(b). \( F = Z - M = 0.8 \); \( E = F/Z = 0.8/1.2 = 0.67 \). Two-thirds of the deaths are caused by fishing; a common rule of thumb treats \( E \) above about 0.5 as a sign of heavy exploitation.
Q4 (practice). A muddy, organic-rich bay bottom is dominated by burrowing deposit feeders, and suspension-feeding bivalves are nearly absent though larvae arrive in large numbers. The best explanation is:
- (a) Thorson’s rule
- (b) trophic-group amensalism
- (c) competitive exclusion for space on hard substrate
- (d) Liebig’s law applied to oxygen
Answer and explanation
(b). Deposit feeders destabilise the mud; resuspended sediment clogs suspension feeders and buries settling larvae. (a) is about larval types with latitude and depth; (c) is a rocky-shore mechanism.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Equilibrium catch and effort data for a demersal fishery give a regression CPUE = 200 − 0.01E, where CPUE is in kg per boat-day and E in boat-days per year.
(i) Find \( E_{MSY} \) and MSY. (ii) Current effort is 14,000 boat-days. What is the equilibrium yield, and is the fishery under- or over-exploited? (iii) If each boat-day costs ₹ 8,000 and fish sells at ₹ 100 per kg, at what effort would open access stabilise?
Answer and worked solution
- \( E_{MSY} = a/(2b) = 200/0.02 = \) 10,000 boat-days. \( \text{MSY} = a^2/(4b) = 40{,}000/0.04 = 1{,}000{,}000 \) kg = 1,000 t.
- \( Y = E(a - bE) = 14{,}000(200 - 140) = 840{,}000 \) kg = 840 t. Effort is above \( E_{MSY} \), so the fishery is over-exploited: cutting effort to 10,000 would raise the catch to 1,000 t.
- Open access: revenue = cost. \( 100 \times E(200 - 0.01E) = 8{,}000E \Rightarrow 200 - 0.01E = 80 \Rightarrow E = \) 12,000 boat-days, beyond \( E_{MSY} \), with yield \( 12{,}000 \times 80 = 960 \) t and zero profit. Profit is maximised at MEY, where marginal revenue equals marginal cost: \( 100(200 - 0.02E) = 8{,}000 \Rightarrow E = 6{,}000 \) boat-days, below \( E_{MSY} \).
Q2 (practice). Macrofauna were sampled at two stations, near and far from a fish-farm cage (practice data):
| Species | Far station | Near station |
|---|---|---|
| Polychaete A (Capitella-like) | 25 | 850 |
| Bivalve B | 25 | 50 |
| Amphipod C | 25 | 50 |
| Echinoderm D | 25 | 50 |
Which statements are correct?
(A) Shannon \( H' \) (natural log) is about 1.39 at the far station and about 0.59 at the near station. (B) Total abundance is higher at the near station, consistent with the “peak of opportunists”. (C) Species richness differs between the stations. (D) The near station shows strong dominance by one species, typical of organic enrichment.
- (a) A, B and D
- (b) A, B, C and D
- (c) B and C only
- (d) A and C only
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B and D.
- Far: four equal species, \( H' = \ln 4 = 1.386 \).
- Near: N = 1,000; proportions 0.85, 0.05, 0.05, 0.05. \( H' = -(0.85\ln0.85 + 3 \times 0.05\ln0.05) = 0.138 + 0.449 = 0.588 \). (A) correct.
- (B) correct: 1,000 vs 100 individuals.
- (C) wrong: both have four species; the difference is in evenness, which is what \( H' \) picks up.
- (D) correct: one species makes 85% of individuals.
Q3 (practice). A cohort of \( 1.0 \times 10^6 \) fish experiences \( F = 0.8 \) yr\(^{-1}\) and \( M = 0.4 \) yr\(^{-1}\) for one year. Which statements are correct?
(A) About 30% of the cohort survives the year. (B) About 466,000 fish are caught during the year. (C) About 233,000 fish die of natural causes during the year. (D) If \( F \) were halved, more than twice as many fish would survive the year.
- (a) A, B and C only
- (b) A and B only
- (c) B, C and D
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B and C only.
- \( Z = 1.2 \); survivors \( = 10^6 e^{-1.2} = 301{,}194 \): about 30%. (A) correct.
- Deaths \( = 10^6 - 301{,}194 = 698{,}806 \). Catch \( = (F/Z) \times \) deaths \( = (0.8/1.2)\times 698{,}806 = 465{,}871 \approx 466{,}000 \). (B) correct.
- Natural deaths \( = (0.4/1.2) \times 698{,}806 = 232{,}935 \approx 233{,}000 \). (C) correct.
- With \( F = 0.4 \), \( Z = 0.8 \), survivors \( = 10^6 e^{-0.8} = 449{,}329 \), which is 1.49 times as many, not more than twice. (D) wrong.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Nekton | fishes, cephalopods, mammals, reptiles, seabirds; swim against currents |
| Shark buoyancy | oily liver, no swim bladder |
| Migrations | anadromous (salmon, hilsa) up; catadromous (eels) down; oceanodromous (tunas) |
| Olive ridley | mass nesting (arribada) in Odisha |
| Benthos feeding | suspension on sand, deposit in mud; trophic-group amensalism |
| Larvae | planktotrophic, lecithotrophic, direct; Thorson’s rule towards poles and deep sea |
| Deep-sea benthos | biomass falls about exponentially with depth |
| Pearson–Rosenberg | richness falls; opportunists (Capitella) peak; then azoic |
| Shannon | \( H' = -\sum p_i \ln p_i \) |
| von Bertalanffy | \( L_t = L_\infty(1 - e^{-K(t - t_0)}) \) |
| Mortality | \( N_t = N_0 e^{-Zt} \); \( Z = F + M \); \( E = F/Z \) |
| Baranov | \( C = (F/Z)N_0(1 - e^{-Zt}) \) |
| Schaefer | \( B_{MSY} = K/2 \); MSY = \( rK/4 \); \( E_{MSY} = r/2q \) |
| CPUE line | \( a - bE \); \( E_{MSY} = a/2b \); MSY = \( a^2/4b \) |
| MEY vs open access | MEY below \( E_{MSY} \); open access above |
| Overfishing | growth, recruitment, ecosystem |
| India | EEZ about 2.02 million km\(^2\); oil sardine (SW coast), Bombay duck (NW), PFZ advisories by INCOIS |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Estuaries, Coral Reefs, Mangroves, Deep-Sea and Vent Communities: the special habitats that serve as nurseries and hotspots.
- Human, Climate and Pollution Impacts on Marine Life: overfishing, collapses and management.
- Biodiversity, Conservation and Policy: diversity indices and conservation tools in the general setting.
- Biological Oceanography: chapter overview.