Skip to content

Primary and Secondary Production and Plankton

CSIR NET Ocean Sciences: GPP and NPP, 14C and light-dark bottle methods, P-I curves, Sverdrup critical depth, new production, phytoplankton and zooplankton.

  • 20 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 15 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: The Bloom That Waits for Spring
  3. Primary Production: Definitions
  4. Measuring Primary Production
  5. What Controls Primary Production
  6. Phytoplankton
  7. Zooplankton
  8. Secondary Production
  9. Memory Tricks
  10. Don’t Confuse
  11. Common Mistakes
  12. Practice
  13. Quick Revision Table
  14. Key Takeaways
  15. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: The Bloom That Waits for Spring


Primary Production: Definitions

Primary production is the synthesis of organic matter from inorganic carbon by autotrophs. In the ocean about 99% of it is done by phytoplankton; seaweeds, seagrasses, mangroves, symbiotic algae in corals and chemoautotrophs at vents make the rest.

TermDefinition
Gross primary production (GPP)total carbon fixed by photosynthesis
Net primary production (NPP)GPP minus autotrophic respiration (\( R_a \))
Net community production (NCP)GPP minus respiration of the whole community (autotrophs and heterotrophs)
Standing stock (biomass)amount present at a moment, usually as chlorophyll a (mg m\(^{-3}\))
Productivityrate (mg C m\(^{-3}\) h\(^{-1}\), g C m\(^{-2}\) yr\(^{-1}\))
Turnover timebiomass ÷ production rate; days for phytoplankton

The balanced equation for marine photosynthesis with the Redfield composition is

$$106\,\mathrm{CO_2} + 16\,\mathrm{HNO_3} + \mathrm{H_3PO_4} + 122\,\mathrm{H_2O} \rightarrow (\mathrm{CH_2O})_{106}(\mathrm{NH_3})_{16}\mathrm{H_3PO_4} + 138\,\mathrm{O_2}$$

The ratio of oxygen released to carbon fixed is the photosynthetic quotient (PQ). From this equation it is 138/106 ≈ 1.3 when nitrate is the nitrogen source; with ammonium it is closer to 1.1. Measured values commonly fall between 1.0 and 1.4.

Global ocean NPP is about 50 Pg C yr\(^{-1}\), roughly half of Earth’s total, from a phytoplankton biomass that is under 1% of land plant biomass. The ocean’s plants are tiny but turn over in days, not decades.

How productive are different regions?

RegionApproximate NPP (g C m\(^{-2}\) yr\(^{-1}\))Main control
Subtropical gyresabout 50 or lessnitrate supply (stratification)
Open ocean averageabout 100nutrients
Continental shelvesabout 100–300river input, tidal mixing
Coastal upwellingabout 300 or morewind-driven nutrient supply
Estuaries, reefs, seagrass, salt marshcan exceed 1,000nutrient trapping, benthic plants

These are order-of-magnitude ranges. The pattern matters more than the numbers: production per unit area is highest at the edges, but the open ocean contributes most of the total because it is so large.


Measuring Primary Production

Light and dark bottle (oxygen) method

Three bottles are filled from the same depth. One is fixed at once (initial), one is incubated in the light (LB) and one in the dark (DB).

$$\text{Respiration} = \text{IB} - \text{DB} \qquad \text{NPP} = \text{LB} - \text{IB} \qquad \text{GPP} = \text{LB} - \text{DB}$$

Oxygen is converted to carbon with \( \text{C} = \text{O}_2 \times \frac{12}{32} \times \frac{1}{\text{PQ}} \) (mass units). The method measures community respiration (the dark bottle contains bacteria and zooplankton too), assumes respiration is the same in light and dark, and needs precise Winkler titrations, so it is best in productive water.

\(^{14}\)C uptake (Steemann Nielsen, 1952)

A known activity of \( \mathrm{H^{14}CO_3^-} \) is added to a sample; after incubation the cells are filtered and their radioactivity counted.

$$P = \frac{(R_L - R_D)\times W \times 1.05}{R \times t}$$
SymbolMeaning
\( R_L, R_D \)radioactivity of particles from light and dark bottles
\( R \)radioactivity added
\( W \)total dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) in the sample
1.05isotope discrimination factor (\(^{14}\)C is taken up about 5% more slowly than \(^{12}\)C)
\( t \)incubation time

The method is very sensitive and works in oligotrophic water. Short incubations approach GPP; 24 h incubations approach NPP, because some fixed \(^{14}\)C is respired back. It misses dissolved organic carbon released by cells unless the filtrate is also counted.

Other methods

MethodMeasuresNote
Chlorophyll a (extraction, fluorometry)biomass, not ratecombine with light and P–I parameters to model production
Active fluorescence (FRRF, PAM)photosynthetic efficiency in real timeno incubation
\(^{18}\)O-labelled waterGPP (oxygen evolved from water)
O\(_2\)/Ar ratio in the mixed layerNCPargon corrects for physical gas exchange
Satellite ocean coloursurface chlorophyll from blue/green reflectanceglobal, daily; models convert to NPP; India flies ocean-colour sensors on its Oceansat series

What Controls Primary Production

Light: the P–I curve

Photosynthesis rises linearly with irradiance at low light, saturates, and may fall at very high light (photoinhibition). A widely used form is

$$P = P_{max}\,\tanh\!\left(\frac{\alpha I}{P_{max}}\right)$$
ParameterMeaning
\( \alpha \)initial slope (light-limited efficiency)
\( P_{max} \)light-saturated rate (set by enzyme capacity, temperature, nutrients)
\( I_k = P_{max}/\alpha \)saturation irradiance where the initial slope meets \( P_{max} \)
\( \beta \)slope of photoinhibition at high light

Chlorophyll-normalised \( P_{max} \) is called the assimilation number. Shade-adapted cells (deep, winter) have higher \( \alpha \) and lower \( I_k \); sun-adapted cells the reverse.

Compensation depth and Sverdrup’s critical depth

  • Compensation irradiance \( I_c \): light at which a cell’s gross photosynthesis equals its respiration. The compensation depth is where that light falls; it lies near the 1% light level.
  • Critical depth (Sverdrup, 1953): the depth of mixing for which photosynthesis integrated over the whole mixed layer equals respiration integrated over it. Cells mixed below the compensation depth are still fine as long as they spend enough time above it.
  • Bloom condition: a bloom starts when the mixed-layer depth becomes shallower than the critical depth.

If light decays as \( I_0 e^{-kz} \) and a cell is mixed uniformly through depth \( D \), the mean light it sees is

$$\bar I = \frac{I_0}{kD}\left(1 - e^{-kD}\right)$$

and the critical depth is the \( D \) at which \( \bar I = I_c \). For deep mixing, \( e^{-kD} \to 0 \) and \( D_{cr} \approx I_0/(k I_c) \).

Nutrients

  • Nitrogen usually limits production in the open ocean; phosphorus limits in some freshwater-influenced and N-fixer-dominated systems; silicate limits diatoms; iron limits HNLC regions.
  • Redfield ratio C : N : P = 106 : 16 : 1 (with Si : N about 1 : 1 for diatoms). If the nitrate-to-phosphate ratio of a water mass is well below 16, nitrogen will run out first.
  • Nutrient uptake follows Michaelis–Menten (Monod) kinetics: \( V = V_{max}[S]/(K_s + [S]) \). Small cells have low \( K_s \) relative to their needs and win in nutrient-poor water.
  • In stratified water the phytoplankton concentrate at the top of the nutricline, forming a deep chlorophyll maximum (DCM), often near the base of the euphotic zone.

New and regenerated production

ProductionNitrogen sourceOrigin of the nitrogen
New productionnitrate (NO\(_3^-\)), N\(_2\) fixation, atmospheric depositionfrom outside the euphotic zone
Regenerated productionammonium (NH\(_4^+\)), urearecycled within the euphotic zone by excretion and remineralisation

The f-ratio (Dugdale and Goering, 1967) is

$$f = \frac{\text{new production}}{\text{total production}} = \frac{\rho\mathrm{NO_3}}{\rho\mathrm{NO_3} + \rho\mathrm{NH_4}}$$

where \( \rho \) denotes uptake rates, measured with \(^{15}\)N tracers. Over a long enough period at steady state, new production equals export production (Eppley and Peterson, 1979): what leaves must be replaced by what arrives. Typical f-ratios are low (below about 0.1–0.2) in oligotrophic gyres and high (about 0.5 or more) in upwelling zones and spring blooms.

Seasonal cycles

graph LR
    A[Winter: deep mixing, nutrients high, light low] --> B[Spring: mixed layer shoals above critical depth]
    B --> C[Spring bloom: diatoms, nutrients drawn down]
    C --> D[Summer: stratified, nutrients exhausted, small cells, regenerated production]
    D --> E[Autumn: cooling and storms deepen mixing, small second bloom]
    E --> A
RegionPattern
Polarone short summer peak, limited by light and ice
Temperatelarge spring bloom, summer low, smaller autumn bloom
Tropical open oceanlow, nearly constant; permanently stratified
Arabian Seatwo blooms: summer (southwest monsoon upwelling) and winter (northeast monsoon convective mixing in the north)
Bay of Bengallower than the Arabian Sea; river freshwater stratifies the surface and suppresses mixing

Phytoplankton

GroupDistinguishing featuresEcological role
Diatoms (Bacillariophyceae)silica (opal) frustule of two valves; centric (radial) and pennate (bilateral); cells shrink with each division until restored by an auxosporedominate spring blooms and upwelling; fast growth; sink and export carbon and silica; some Pseudo-nitzschia make domoic acid
Dinoflagellatestwo flagella (one in a transverse girdle, one longitudinal); armoured forms have cellulose platesmany mixotrophic or heterotrophic; red tides and toxins; bioluminescence (Noctiluca); coral symbionts (Symbiodiniaceae); resting cysts
Coccolithophores (Haptophyta)covered in calcite plates (coccoliths); Emiliania huxleyi is the best knowncarbonate producers; large milky blooms; make DMSP; source of alkenones used as palaeothermometers
Prochlorococcussmallest known photosynthetic cell (about 0.6 µm); divinyl chlorophylls a and bdominates warm oligotrophic gyres; probably the most abundant photosynthetic organism
Synechococcuspicocyanobacterium with phycoerythrinwidespread, more coastal and higher-latitude than Prochlorococcus
Trichodesmiumfilamentous colonial cyanobacterium, fixes N\(_2\) without heterocysts; “sea sawdust”major source of new nitrogen in warm stratified seas, including the Arabian Sea
Phaeocystishaptophyte forming mucilaginous coloniesblooms in polar and coastal seas; DMSP producer
Silicoflagellatessilica skeletonminor; used as microfossils

Succession follows the physics. Margalef’s “mandala” puts diatoms (fast-growing, need turbulence to stay up and high nutrients) at the turbulent, nutrient-rich corner, and dinoflagellates (swimmers, tolerate low nutrients) at the stratified, nutrient-poor corner, with red-tide dinoflagellates as the anomaly of stratified but nutrient-enriched water.

Paradox of the plankton (Hutchinson, 1961): competitive exclusion predicts that a few species should win in a well-mixed water body with a handful of limiting resources, yet dozens coexist. Explanations: the environment changes before equilibrium is reached, selective grazing and viral lysis, spatial patchiness, and chaotic dynamics.


Zooplankton

GroupFeaturesRole
Copepodssmall crustaceans; six naupliar and six copepodite stages (the last is the adult)most numerous metazoans in the plankton; main link from phytoplankton to fish; Calanus in temperate and polar seas
Euphausiids (krill)shrimp-like, often bioluminescentAntarctic krill (Euphausia superba) is the hub of the Southern Ocean food web, eaten by whales, seals, penguins and fish
Chaetognaths (arrow worms)transparent carnivoresmajor predators of copepods; species used as indicators of water masses
Gelatinous zooplanktonmedusae, siphonophores, ctenophores (comb jellies), salps and doliolids (tunicates)salps filter very efficiently and produce fast-sinking faecal pellets; ctenophores can be damaging invaders
Pteropodsswimming snails, many with aragonite shellssensitive to ocean acidification
Protozooplanktonforaminifera (calcite tests), radiolarians (silica), ciliates including tintinnids, heterotrophic flagellatesgrazers of bacteria and small phytoplankton; part of the microbial loop
Meroplanktonlarvae of benthos and fishseasonal in coastal waters

Sampling: plankton nets of set mesh (about 200 µm for mesozooplankton), with flowmeters to measure the volume filtered; multiple opening–closing nets for depth strata; and the Continuous Plankton Recorder, towed behind merchant ships in the North Atlantic since 1931, which provides one of the longest biological time series in the ocean. Acoustics and optical imagers count organisms without catching them.


Secondary Production

Secondary production is the production of new heterotroph biomass, mainly zooplankton feeding on phytoplankton. Its energy budget is

$$\text{Ingestion (I)} = \text{Egestion (F)} + \text{Assimilation (A)}, \qquad A = \text{Respiration (R)} + \text{Excretion (U)} + \text{Production (P)}$$
EfficiencyFormulaTypical values for zooplankton
Assimilation efficiency\( A/I \)about 50–90%, lower on poor food
Gross growth efficiency \( K_1 \)\( P/I \)about 20–35%
Net growth efficiency \( K_2 \)\( P/A \)higher than \( K_1 \)
Ecological (trophic transfer) efficiencyproduction at level \( n+1 \) ÷ production at level \( n \)about 10% on average, often 10–20% in the sea

Ways to measure zooplankton production:

  • Cohort analysis: follow a single generation’s numbers and individual mass through time.
  • Growth increment (instantaneous growth rate): \( P = g B \), where \( g \) is the specific growth rate and \( B \) the biomass.
  • Egg production of adult female copepods as a proxy for adult growth.
  • Physiological (P/B ratio) models from temperature and body size.

Grazing is measured by gut-pigment methods, by incubating zooplankton with phytoplankton, or by the dilution technique for microzooplankton, which separates phytoplankton growth from grazing by diluting the grazers.


Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
GPP: total fixedvsNPP: GPP − autotrophic respiration
NPPvsNCP: GPP − community respiration
Biomass (standing stock): mg Chl m\(^{-3}\)vsProduction: rate, mg C m\(^{-3}\) h\(^{-1}\)
Compensation depth: \( P = R \) for one cell at that depthvsCritical depth: \( \int P = \int R \) over the mixed layer
New production: nitrate, N\(_2\) fixationvsRegenerated: ammonium, urea
Diatoms: silica, bloom formers, turbulencevsDinoflagellates: flagellated, stratified water, toxins
Coccolithophores: calcitevsPteropods: aragonite
Gross growth efficiency \( P/I \)vsNet growth efficiency \( P/A \)

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in the CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which isotope tracer is used to separate new from regenerated production?
  2. Name the cyanobacterium that is the smallest known photosynthetic organism.
  3. What is the condition for a spring bloom in Sverdrup’s model?
Answers
  1. \(^{15}\)N (as \(^{15}\)NO\(_3^-\) and \(^{15}\)NH\(_4^+\)).
  2. Prochlorococcus.
  3. Mixed-layer depth shallower than the critical depth.

Level 2: Part B Style

Q1 (practice). In a light and dark bottle experiment run for 6 h, oxygen concentrations were: initial 8.00 mg L\(^{-1}\), light bottle 9.20 mg L\(^{-1}\), dark bottle 7.40 mg L\(^{-1}\). Gross primary production (as O\(_2\)) for the 6 h is:

  • (a) 0.60 mg L\(^{-1}\)
  • (b) 1.20 mg L\(^{-1}\)
  • (c) 1.80 mg L\(^{-1}\)
  • (d) 2.40 mg L\(^{-1}\)
Answer and explanation

(c). GPP = LB − DB = 9.20 − 7.40 = 1.80 mg O\(_2\) L\(^{-1}\). NPP = LB − IB = 1.20; respiration = IB − DB = 0.60. With PQ = 1.2, GPP in carbon = \( 1.80 \times (12/32)/1.2 = 0.56 \) mg C L\(^{-1}\) per 6 h.

Q2 (practice). In a \(^{15}\)N experiment, nitrate uptake was 0.30 and ammonium uptake 0.90 µmol N L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\). The f-ratio and the new production in carbon units (Redfield C : N) are:

  • (a) 0.25 and 1.99 µmol C L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\)
  • (b) 0.33 and 1.99 µmol C L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\)
  • (c) 0.25 and 7.95 µmol C L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\)
  • (d) 0.75 and 5.96 µmol C L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\)
Answer and explanation

(a). \( f = 0.30/(0.30 + 0.90) = 0.25 \). New production in carbon = \( 0.30 \times 106/16 = 0.30 \times 6.625 = 1.99 \) µmol C L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\). (c) converts total N uptake (1.2) instead of nitrate only; (b) divides nitrate by ammonium instead of by total.

Q3 (practice). A phytoplankton culture has \( P_{max} = 5 \) mg C (mg Chl)\(^{-1}\) h\(^{-1}\) and \( \alpha = 0.05 \) mg C (mg Chl)\(^{-1}\) h\(^{-1}\) per µmol photons m\(^{-2}\) s\(^{-1}\). Using \( P = P_{max}\tanh(\alpha I/P_{max}) \), the saturation irradiance \( I_k \) and the rate at \( I = 50 \) are:

  • (a) 100 and 2.5
  • (b) 100 and 2.31
  • (c) 250 and 2.31
  • (d) 0.01 and 4.6
Answer and explanation

(b). \( I_k = P_{max}/\alpha = 5/0.05 = 100 \) µmol photons m\(^{-2}\) s\(^{-1}\). At \( I = 50 \): \( P = 5\tanh(0.5) = 5 \times 0.462 = 2.31 \). The linear estimate \( \alpha I = 2.5 \) overestimates because the curve already bends at half of \( I_k \).

Q4 (practice). Which statement about the Bay of Bengal compared with the Arabian Sea is correct?

  • (a) The Bay of Bengal is more productive because it receives more river nutrients.
  • (b) The Bay of Bengal is generally less productive because strong freshwater stratification limits vertical nutrient supply.
  • (c) Both have identical single summer blooms.
  • (d) The Arabian Sea is limited by light in both monsoons.
Answer and explanation

(b). River runoff caps the Bay of Bengal with low-salinity water; the strong halocline resists wind mixing. The Arabian Sea has two blooms, driven by summer upwelling and winter convective mixing; nutrients, not light, are the main control.

Level 3: Part C Style

Q1 (practice). A \(^{14}\)C incubation used 10 µCi of NaH\(^{14}\)CO\(_3\) (1 µCi = \( 2.22 \times 10^6 \) dpm) in a bottle with DIC = 24 mg C L\(^{-1}\). After 4 h, filtered particles from the light bottle gave 44,400 dpm and those from the dark bottle 2,220 dpm.

(i) Calculate the carbon fixation rate in mg C m\(^{-3}\) h\(^{-1}\). (ii) If chlorophyll a was 2.0 mg m\(^{-3}\), what is the assimilation number? (iii) State whether this 4 h value is closer to GPP or NPP.

Answer and worked solution
  1. Added activity \( R = 10 \times 2.22\times10^6 = 2.22\times10^7 \) dpm. Fraction taken up \( = (44{,}400 - 2{,}220)/2.22\times10^7 = 1.9\times10^{-3} \). \( P = 1.9\times10^{-3} \times 24 \times 1.05 / 4 = 0.01197 \) mg C L\(^{-1}\) h\(^{-1}\) = about 12.0 mg C m\(^{-3}\) h\(^{-1}\) (1 L\(^{-1}\) = 1,000 m\(^{-3}\)).
  2. Assimilation number \( = 11.97/2.0 \approx \) 6.0 mg C (mg Chl)\(^{-1}\) h\(^{-1}\), a high, light-saturated value.
  3. A short (4 h) incubation recycles little of the labelled carbon back to CO\(_2\), so it is closer to gross production; a 24 h incubation would be closer to net.

Q2 (practice). At a temperate station, daily-mean surface irradiance is 60 units, the attenuation coefficient is 0.10 m\(^{-1}\), and the compensation irradiance for the phytoplankton is 2 units. The mixed layer is 400 m deep in February and 80 m deep in April.

(i) Estimate the critical depth. (ii) What is the mean light experienced by a cell in each month? (iii) Predict whether a bloom occurs in each month.

Answer and worked solution
  1. For deep mixing \( D_{cr} \approx I_0/(kI_c) = 60/(0.10 \times 2) = \) 300 m. (Check: \( e^{-30} \) is negligible, so the approximation holds.)
  2. \( \bar I = \dfrac{I_0}{kD}(1 - e^{-kD}) \). February: \( 60/(0.10\times400) \times (1 - e^{-40}) = 1.5 \) units. April: \( 60/(0.10\times80) \times (1 - e^{-8}) = 7.5 \times 0.99966 = 7.50 \) units.
  3. February: mixed layer (400 m) deeper than \( D_{cr} \) (300 m); mean light 1.5 < \( I_c \) = 2: no bloom. April: 80 m < 300 m; mean light 7.5 > 2: bloom. The euphotic depth is only \( 4.6/0.1 = 46 \) m, showing that cells can grow even when mixed well below the euphotic zone.

Q3 (practice). A copepod population ingests 10 µg C d\(^{-1}\) per individual, egests 3 µg C, respires 4 µg C and excretes nothing measurable. Which statements are correct?

(A) Assimilation efficiency is 70%. (B) Gross growth efficiency is 30%. (C) Net growth efficiency is about 43%. (D) If this population’s production is passed to a planktivorous fish with a gross growth efficiency of 20%, then 0.6 µg C of fish is produced per 10 µg C eaten by copepods.

  • (a) A, B, C and D
  • (b) A and B only
  • (c) A, B and C only
  • (d) B and D only
Answer and worked solution

(a) A, B, C and D.

  • A = I − F = 10 − 3 = 7; \( A/I = 70\% \). (A) correct.
  • P = A − R = 7 − 4 = 3; \( K_1 = P/I = 30\% \). (B) correct.
  • \( K_2 = P/A = 3/7 = 42.9\% \). (C) correct.
  • Fish production = 3 × 0.20 = 0.6 µg C. (D) correct. Over two steps only 6% of what the copepods ate becomes fish, which is why short food chains support large fisheries.

Quick Revision Table

ItemFact
GPP, NPP, NCPgross; minus autotroph R; minus community R
Global ocean NPPabout 50 Pg C yr\(^{-1}\), about half of Earth’s
Light/dark bottleGPP = L − D; NPP = L − I; R = I − D
O\(_2\) to C\( \times 12/32 \div \) PQ; PQ about 1.0–1.4 (138/106 with nitrate)
\(^{14}\)C\( P = (R_L - R_D)W \times 1.05/(Rt) \); Steemann Nielsen 1952
P–I\( P = P_{max}\tanh(\alpha I/P_{max}) \); \( I_k = P_{max}/\alpha \)
Critical depthSverdrup 1953; bloom when MLD < \( D_{cr} \); \( D_{cr} \approx I_0/(kI_c) \)
RedfieldC : N : P = 106 : 16 : 1; O\(_2\) : P = 138
f-rationew/total = \( \rho\mathrm{NO_3}/(\rho\mathrm{NO_3} + \rho\mathrm{NH_4}) \); = export at steady state
Seasonalpolar one peak; temperate spring + autumn; tropics flat; Arabian Sea two
Diatoms / dinos / coccossilica / flagella, toxins / calcite, DMSP
Prochlorococcus / Trichodesmiumsmallest phototroph / N\(_2\) fixer
Copepods / krillmain grazers / Southern Ocean hub
Growth efficiencies\( K_1 = P/I \) about 20–35%; \( K_2 = P/A \)
Inverted pyramidbiomass can invert, energy never

Key Takeaways

What’s Next