Skip to content

CaCO3, Silica, Manganese Nodules and Phosphorites

CSIR NET Ocean Sciences: calcite and aragonite saturation, carbonate compensation, opal cycling, Fe-Mn nodule chemistry and growth, and marine phosphogenesis.

  • 18 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Four Ways the Ocean Writes in Stone
  3. Calcium Carbonate
  4. Biogenic Silica (Opal)
  5. Ferromanganese Nodules and Crusts
  6. Phosphorites
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Four Ways the Ocean Writes in Stone

How CSIR NET asks it. Part C: calculating Ω at depth and placing the saturation horizon; predicting how the CCD responds to CO\(_2\) changes; why opal survives although seawater is undersaturated; classifying nodules from Mn/Fe and trace-metal data; dating nodule growth; the conditions and mechanism of phosphogenesis.


Calcium Carbonate

The minerals and who makes them

PhaseCrystal systemMain producersSolubility
Low-Mg calciteTrigonalCoccolithophores, planktonic foraminiferaLeast soluble
AragoniteOrthorhombicPteropods, corals, many molluscs, ooids and inorganic needles on tropical banksAbout 1.5 times more soluble than calcite
High-Mg calcite (above about 4 mol% MgCO\(_3\))TrigonalCoralline red algae, echinoderms, benthic foraminiferaIncreases with Mg content; the most Mg-rich forms are more soluble than aragonite

Pelagic carbonate is mostly calcite from coccoliths and forams; aragonitic pteropod shells dissolve at shallower depth and are rarely preserved in deep-sea sediment.

Why the surface ocean does not precipitate carbonate spontaneously

Surface seawater is supersaturated about 5-fold for calcite and over 3-fold for aragonite, yet open-ocean inorganic precipitation is negligible. Nucleation and growth are kinetically inhibited:

  • Mg\(^{2+}\) adsorbs on calcite growth sites and is incorporated, raising its solubility; this is why abiotic precipitates in seawater are aragonite or high-Mg calcite.
  • Dissolved phosphate and organic compounds poison crystal surfaces.

The seawater Mg/Ca molar ratio today is about 5.1 (52.7/10.28). Above about 2, inorganic precipitates tend to be aragonite (“aragonite seas”, as today); at lower Mg/Ca, calcite (“calcite seas”). The ratio has varied through the Phanerozoic, recorded by the primary mineralogy of ooids and cements.

Saturation with depth

$$\Omega = \frac{[\text{Ca}^{2+}][\text{CO}_3^{2-}]}{K_{sp}^*(T, S, P)}$$

[Ca\(^{2+}\)] is nearly constant, so Ω depends on carbonate ion and on \( K_{sp}^* \). Ω falls with depth for three reasons:

  1. Pressure increases \( K_{sp}^* \) (the dissolved ions occupy less volume than the solid: negative partial molar volume change of dissolution).
  2. Lower temperature increases \( K_{sp}^* \) slightly (carbonates are more soluble in cold water) and raises CO\(_2\) solubility.
  3. Respired CO\(_2\) in deep water lowers [CO\(_3^{2-}\)]; the older the water, the lower it is. Deep Pacific water therefore has lower carbonate ion than deep Atlantic water.
HorizonDefinition
Saturation horizonΩ = 1 for the mineral in question
LysoclineDepth below which dissolution in the sediment becomes obvious (poor preservation of forams)
Carbonate compensation depth (CCD)Depth where the rain of CaCO\(_3\) is balanced by dissolution; little or no carbonate accumulates below
Aragonite compensation depth (ACD)The same for aragonite; much shallower than the CCD

Calcite saturation horizons lie at roughly 4–5 km in the North Atlantic but much shallower in the North Pacific; the aragonite saturation horizon in the North Pacific can be only a few hundred metres deep. The geological description of the CCD (its depth in each ocean, its history through the Cenozoic and plate stratigraphy) is on the oceanic sediments page.

Dissolution kinetics

Below saturation, dissolution rate is often written as

$$R = k\,(1 - \Omega)^n$$

with the order \( n \) greater than 1 for calcite. Dissolution also occurs above the saturation horizon, inside sediments where respiration of organic matter releases CO\(_2\) into pore waters (“respiration-driven dissolution”), and in the guts of zooplankton. So the lysocline is not simply the saturation horizon.

Carbonate compensation: the ocean’s slow thermostat

Over thousands of years, rivers supply alkalinity and DIC (from weathering) that must be balanced by CaCO\(_3\) burial. The CCD adjusts to make that balance:

graph TD
    A["Extra CO2 enters the ocean
(fossil fuel, volcanism, PETM)"] --> B["Deep [CO3 2-] falls,
Ω falls"] B --> C["Saturation horizon and
CCD shoal"] C --> D["Less CaCO3 buried;
sea-floor carbonate dissolves"] D --> E["Alkalinity returns to seawater
(CaCO3 + CO2 + H2O → Ca2+ + 2HCO3-)"] E --> F["[CO3 2-] recovers;
CCD deepens back"] F --> G["Time scale: several thousand years
(carbonate compensation)"]

Consequences:

  • Anthropogenic CO\(_2\) will be neutralised partly by sea-floor carbonate dissolution over millennia; the CCD is expected to shoal meanwhile.
  • In the geological record, large carbon releases (the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum) produced abrupt carbonate-dissolution layers followed by “overshoot” of the CCD to greater depth.
  • A shift of carbonate production from the deep sea to shelves (or the reverse) moves the deep CCD in the opposite sense, because burial must stay balanced.

Biogenic Silica (Opal)

Producers and the undersaturation problem

Opal (amorphous hydrated silica, SiO\(_2\)·nH\(_2\)O) is made by diatoms (dominant), radiolarians, silicoflagellates and siliceous sponges. Its solubility is of order 1 mmol kg\(^{-1}\) or more at seawater temperatures, while seawater silicic acid ranges from near zero at the surface to below about 200 µmol kg\(^{-1}\) in the deepest Pacific. Seawater is undersaturated with respect to opal everywhere, at every depth.

So opal dissolves from the moment the organism dies. It is preserved only where:

  • production is high (much is made, so some survives);
  • particles sink fast (aggregates, faecal pellets);
  • burial is rapid, isolating opal in pore waters that quickly approach saturation;
  • Al from detrital clays is incorporated into the opal surface, lowering its solubility;
  • organic coatings protect frustules until bacteria strip them.

Only a small fraction of opal produced at the surface is buried; most dissolves in the upper water column and at the sediment–water interface. Unlike carbonate, opal dissolution is not tied to a sharp compensation depth: it is undersaturated at all depths, and dissolution is faster in warm surface water than in cold deep water.

Where siliceous ooze accumulates

RegionWhy
Southern Ocean opal belt (south of the Polar Front)Diatom-dominated production with high silicate supply; the largest opal sink. Burial rates are boosted by sediment focusing (lateral transport into basins), which must be corrected for
Equatorial PacificUpwelling; below the CCD, opal dominates as carbonate dissolves
Subarctic North PacificHigh silicate supply
Coastal upwelling margins (Gulf of California, Peru, Benguela)High productivity, rapid burial

The silica budget

  • Inputs: rivers (silicate weathering), hydrothermal fluids, dissolution of aeolian dust and of sediments, groundwater.
  • Output: burial of biogenic opal, plus uptake in authigenic clays (reverse weathering).
  • Residence time: order \( 10^{4} \) yr.

Diagenesis of opal

$$\text{opal-A (biogenic)} \;\rightarrow\; \text{opal-CT (porcellanite)} \;\rightarrow\; \text{microcrystalline quartz (chert)}$$

The transformation proceeds by dissolution and reprecipitation, accelerated by temperature and burial time; the opal-A to opal-CT transition is often visible as a seismic reflector. Radiolarian cherts in ophiolites are ancient deep-sea siliceous oozes. In the plate-stratigraphy sequence, chert layers mark the time a site spent under the equatorial productive belt.


Ferromanganese Nodules and Crusts

What they are

Nodules are concentric layers of Mn oxides and Fe oxyhydroxides grown around a nucleus (rock fragment, tooth, fragment of an older nodule) on the sediment surface of abyssal plains at roughly 4–6 km depth. Crusts are pavements of similar material on bare rock surfaces of seamounts and ridges.

PhaseMineralCharacter
Mn oxidesVernadite (δ-MnO\(_2\))Poorly crystalline; typical of hydrogenetic growth
Todorokite, buserite, birnessiteBetter crystalline, tunnel or layered structures; typical of diagenetic growth; host Ni, Cu
Fe phasesFerrihydrite, Fe oxyhydroxideAssociated with vernadite

Three modes of growth

ModeMetal sourceGrowth rateMn/FeEnriched in
HydrogeneticSlow precipitation of colloidal oxides from oxic seawaterSlowest: of order a few mm per MyrClose to 1Co, Ce, Pt, Te, Pb, Ti
DiageneticPore water of the underlying sediment; Mn\(^{2+}\) released by suboxic diagenesis and re-oxidised at the noduleFaster (tens of mm per Myr or more)High (well above 1, very high under suboxic conditions)Ni, Cu, Zn, Li
HydrothermalVent fluids and plumes near spreading centresFastestExtreme (very high Mn or very high Fe)Poor in trace metals (not enough time to scavenge)

Most nodules are mixed: the upper surface, facing seawater, grows hydrogenetically; the lower surface, sitting in the sediment, grows diagenetically. Crusts, on rock with no sediment beneath, are purely hydrogenetic, which is why they are the cobalt-rich deposits.

The classic discrimination is a ternary diagram with corners Fe, Mn and (Ni + Cu + Co) × 10: hydrogenetic samples plot near the Fe–Mn midline with appreciable trace metals; diagenetic samples towards the Mn corner; hydrothermal samples near the Fe or Mn corners with almost no trace metals.

How metals are concentrated

Seawater concentrations of Co, Ni and Cu are nanomolar, yet nodules contain them at the percent level. The explanation is surface chemistry:

  • Mn oxide surfaces carry a negative charge at seawater pH, so they adsorb cations: Co\(^{2+}\), Ni\(^{2+}\), Cu\(^{2+}\), Zn\(^{2+}\), Tl\(^+\).
  • Fe oxyhydroxide surfaces are near-neutral to slightly positive, adsorbing anions and neutral complexes: phosphate, vanadate, arsenate, molybdate, and hydroxo-complexes of Ti, Th and others.
  • Oxidative scavenging: Co(II) is oxidised to Co(III) on the MnO\(_2\) surface and fixed in the structure; Ce(III) is oxidised to Ce(IV), giving hydrogenetic deposits a positive Ce anomaly and leaving seawater with its characteristic negative Ce anomaly. Tl and Pt are concentrated by similar surface oxidation.

The slower the growth, the longer each layer is exposed to seawater and the higher its trace-metal content; this is why slow hydrogenetic crusts are Co-richest and fast hydrothermal ones are poorest.

Where nodules grow best

  • Slow sedimentation: otherwise the nodules are buried.
  • Oxic bottom water: Mn must be oxidised.
  • Moderate surface productivity: enough organic matter reaches the sediment to drive suboxic Mn release (feeding diagenetic growth) but not so much that sediments become reducing throughout.
  • Availability of nuclei and some bottom-current activity.

The major fields are the Clarion–Clipperton Zone (northeast Pacific), the Peru Basin, the Penrhyn Basin (South Pacific), and the Central Indian Ocean Basin, where India became the first registered pioneer investor in 1987 and holds an exploration contract with the International Seabed Authority.

Dating nodule growth

Growth rates are measured by the decay of cosmogenic \(^{10}\)Be (half-life about 1.39 Myr) relative to stable \(^{9}\)Be, by excess \(^{230}\)Th in the outer millimetres, and by Os isotope stratigraphy matched to the known seawater Os curve. For \(^{10}\)Be, if the ratio falls from \( R_0 \) at the surface to \( R \) at depth \( x \) into the nodule:

$$\text{growth rate} = \frac{\lambda\,x}{\ln(R_0/R)}, \qquad \lambda = \frac{\ln 2}{t_{1/2}}$$

Phosphorites

Mineralogy

Marine phosphorites are sedimentary rocks rich in carbonate fluorapatite (CFA), also called francolite: apatite in which some PO\(_4^{3-}\) is replaced by CO\(_3^{2-}\) (charge balanced by extra F\(^-\), Na\(^+\) and vacancies). Pure fluorapatite, Ca\(_5\)(PO\(_4\))\(_3\)F, contains 42.2 wt% P\(_2\)O\(_5\); carbonate substitution lowers that for CFA. Phosphorite deposits are the world’s source of phosphate fertiliser.

Where they form today

Modern phosphogenesis is concentrated on continental margins under coastal upwelling and oxygen minimum zones, in organic-rich sediments: the Peru–Chile margin, the Namibian shelf (Benguela upwelling) and Baja California are the type examples. Older phosphorites also occur on seamount tops (phosphatised limestones) and on islands (guano-derived).

The mechanism: phosphogenesis in pore waters

graph TD
    A["High surface productivity
(upwelling)"] --> B["Organic-rich sediment
under low-O2 water"] B --> C["Organic P remineralised
in pore water"] B --> D["Fe-oxide-bound P released
where Fe(III) is reduced
(iron redox pump)"] B --> E["Bacterial polyphosphate
released under anoxia
(large sulfur bacteria)"] C --> F["Pore-water phosphate
supersaturated with CFA"] D --> F E --> F F --> G["CFA precipitates in the
top tens of cm
(F diffuses in from seawater)"] G --> H["Reworking and winnowing
by currents concentrate grains
into granular phosphorite"]

Key points:

  1. Phosphate in pore water must exceed CFA saturation. The supply comes from organic matter breakdown, from P released as Fe oxyhydroxides are reduced (the “iron redox pump”: P adsorbed on Fe oxides near the oxic surface is released when they are buried below the redox boundary), and from polyphosphate stored by large sulfur bacteria (on the Namibian shelf, Thiomargarita releases it under anoxia).
  2. Fluoride diffuses into the sediment from seawater and is incorporated into CFA; precipitation occurs close to the sediment surface where that diffusive supply is available.
  3. Slow net sedimentation with episodic reworking concentrates authigenic grains: pristine phosphatic muds are winnowed and the grains pile up as granular, economic phosphorites. Many large deposits formed during sea-level transgressions.
  4. Precipitation of CFA in sediments is a major “sink switch”: phosphorus that arrived as organic P or Fe-bound P is converted into an authigenic mineral that is not readily remobilised, making phosphorite formation one of the main long-term sinks of marine P.

In the geological record and in India

Phosphorite formation was episodic, with major episodes near the Proterozoic–Cambrian boundary, in the Permian (the Phosphoria Formation of the western USA) and in the Late Cretaceous to Eocene along the southern Tethys (North Africa; Morocco holds the world’s largest phosphate rock reserves). Indian examples:

  • Jhamarkotra (near Udaipur, Rajasthan): stromatolitic phosphorite in the Palaeoproterozoic Aravalli Supergroup.
  • Mussoorie (Lesser Himalaya, Uttarakhand): phosphorite of the Tal Formation near the Precambrian–Cambrian boundary.

Phosphorite episodes often coincide with widespread organic-rich black shales and with times of oceanic anoxia and high nutrient supply, which fits the upwelling–OMZ model above.


Memory Tricks

  • Solubility order of carbonates: “High-Mg calcite > aragonite > calcite”: “High Anxiety Calms down” (most to least soluble, with high-Mg meaning the Mg-richest forms).
  • Ω falls with depth for three Ps: Pressure, low temPerature, resPired CO\(_2\).
  • Nodule metals: “Co from the sea, Ni-Cu from below”: hydrogenetic top (Co), diagenetic bottom (Ni, Cu).
  • Mn oxide is negative, eats cations; Fe oxide is positive, eats anions.
  • Phosphorites: “Upwelling, OMZ, organic, fluoride, winnowing” (U-O-O-F-W).

Don’t Confuse

ThisIs not this
Saturation horizon (Ω = 1)CCD (supply = dissolution; usually deeper than the lysocline)
Calcite (coccoliths, forams; less soluble)Aragonite (pteropods, corals; more soluble, shallower ACD)
Opal: undersaturated everywhere; no sharp compensation depthCalcite: supersaturated above, undersaturated below a horizon
Hydrogenetic (slow, Mn/Fe ≈ 1, Co-rich, vernadite)Diagenetic (faster, high Mn/Fe, Ni–Cu-rich, todorokite)
Crusts (seamount rock surfaces, hydrogenetic)Nodules (sediment surface, mixed growth)
Phosphorite (authigenic CFA in upwelling sediments)Guano phosphate (island deposits from bird excreta)

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Name the main mineral of marine phosphorites.
  2. Which Mn oxide mineral is typical of hydrogenetic growth?
  3. Is seawater supersaturated or undersaturated with respect to biogenic opal at 4 km depth?
Answers
  1. Carbonate fluorapatite (francolite).
  2. Vernadite (δ-MnO\(_2\)).
  3. Undersaturated (as at every depth).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. The modern seawater Mg/Ca molar ratio and the carbonate mineral favoured in inorganic precipitation are:

(a) about 1.0; calcite (b) about 5.1; aragonite (c) about 5.1; low-Mg calcite (d) about 0.2; aragonite

Answer: (b)

\( 52.7/10.28 = 5.1 \). At Mg/Ca above about 2, Mg poisoning of calcite growth favours aragonite and high-Mg calcite.

Practice Q2. A nodule layer has Mn/Fe = 25, high Ni and Cu and todorokite as the main Mn phase. It most likely formed by:

(a) hydrogenetic precipitation (b) diagenetic growth from pore water (c) hydrothermal precipitation (d) detrital accumulation

Answer: (b)

High Mn/Fe with Ni–Cu enrichment and todorokite is the diagenetic signature. Hydrogenetic layers have Mn/Fe near 1 and are Co-rich; hydrothermal ones are poor in Ni and Cu.

Practice Q3. Which of the following does not lower the calcite saturation state with increasing depth?

(a) Higher pressure (b) Lower temperature (c) Accumulation of respired CO\(_2\) (d) Higher [Ca\(^{2+}\)] in deep water

Answer: (d)

Deep water has very slightly more Ca (from CaCO\(_3\) dissolution), which would raise Ω, not lower it; the change is negligible anyway. (a)–(c) all lower Ω.

Practice Q4. Phosphorites form today mainly:

(a) on abyssal plains under oligotrophic gyres (b) on upwelling margins beneath oxygen minimum zones (c) at mid-ocean-ridge vents (d) in evaporitic lagoons

Answer: (b)

High productivity, organic-rich sediment, low-oxygen bottom water and slow net sedimentation with reworking (Peru–Chile, Namibia, Baja California).

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. At a station, Ca\(^{2+}\) = 10.28 mmol kg\(^{-1}\) throughout. At 4,000 m, [CO\(_3^{2-}\)] = 80 µmol kg\(^{-1}\) and the in-situ \( K_{sp}^* \) for calcite is \( 8.0\times10^{-7} \) mol\(^2\) kg\(^{-2}\). Which statements are correct?

  1. Ω(calcite) at 4,000 m is about 1.03.
  2. Using the surface \( K_{sp}^* \) of \( 4.27\times10^{-7} \) would wrongly give Ω ≈ 1.9.
  3. The calcite saturation horizon lies just below 4,000 m at this station.
  4. Aragonite is also supersaturated at 4,000 m.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  • 1: \( 10.28\times10^{-3}\times80\times10^{-6}/8.0\times10^{-7} = 1.03 \). True.
  • 2: \( 8.22\times10^{-7}/4.27\times10^{-7} = 1.93 \): ignoring pressure overstates Ω. True.
  • 3: Ω is just above 1 at 4,000 m and continues to fall with depth, so Ω = 1 is reached a little deeper. True.
  • 4: false. Aragonite is more soluble; with Ω(calcite) ≈ 1, aragonite is undersaturated.

Practice Q6. In a diatom-dominated region, opal production at the surface is 100 units; 50% dissolves in the water column, and 90% of what reaches the sea floor redissolves before burial. Which statements are correct?

  1. Burial is 5 units, a preservation efficiency of 5%.
  2. If sediment focusing doubles the opal reaching the local sea floor, local burial per unit area doubles without any change in surface production.
  3. Faster sinking in aggregates would raise preservation.
  4. The low preservation shows that this deep water is supersaturated with opal.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  • 1: \( 100\times0.5\times0.1 = 5 \). True.
  • 2: with the same fractional preservation at the sea floor, doubling supply doubles burial; this is why focusing must be corrected before inferring productivity. True.
  • 3: less time in undersaturated water column. True.
  • 4: false. Low preservation reflects undersaturation.

Practice Q7. A ferromanganese deposit from a seamount flank at 1,800 m shows: Mn/Fe = 1.1; Co = 0.7 wt%; Ni + Cu = 0.6 wt%; positive Ce anomaly; \(^{10}\)Be/\(^{9}\)Be falling to half its surface value at 3 mm depth (\( t_{1/2} = 1.39 \) Myr). Which statements are correct?

  1. It is a hydrogenetic crust.
  2. Its growth rate is about 2.2 mm Myr\(^{-1}\).
  3. The positive Ce anomaly reflects oxidative scavenging of Ce(III) to Ce(IV).
  4. The Co enrichment is explained by fast growth.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  • 1: seamount rock surface, Mn/Fe near 1, high Co, positive Ce anomaly. True.
  • 2: one half-life over 3 mm: \( 3/1.39 = 2.2 \) mm Myr\(^{-1}\). True.
  • 3: True.
  • 4: false. Co enrichment comes from slow growth and oxidative uptake of Co(III) on MnO\(_2\).

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact or formula
Carbonate mineralslow-Mg calcite (coccoliths, forams) < aragonite (pteropods, corals) < high-Mg calcite (most Mg-rich) in solubility
Mg/Ca seawaterabout 5.1 → aragonite sea
InhibitionMg\(^{2+}\), phosphate, organics block inorganic precipitation
Ω with depthfalls: pressure, cold, respired CO\(_2\); Pacific shallower horizons than Atlantic
Horizonssaturation horizon → lysocline → CCD; ACD shallower
Dissolution\( R = k(1-\Omega)^n \); also respiration-driven in sediments
Carbonate compensationCO\(_2\) pulse → CCD shoals → dissolution restores alkalinity over millennia
Opalundersaturated everywhere; preserved by high production, fast sinking, rapid burial, Al
Opal regionsSouthern Ocean (focusing), equatorial and North Pacific, upwelling margins
Opal diagenesisopal-A → opal-CT → chert
Nodules4–6 km, slow sedimentation, oxic bottom water; CCZ, Peru Basin, CIOB
Growth modeshydrogenetic (Co, Mn/Fe ≈ 1, slow), diagenetic (Ni, Cu, high Mn/Fe), hydrothermal (fast, metal-poor)
Surface chemistryMnO\(_2\) negative (cations), FeOOH positive (anions); Co(III), Ce(IV) oxidative scavenging
Dating\(^{10}\)Be (1.39 Myr), excess \(^{230}\)Th, Os isotopes
TernaryFe – Mn – (Ni + Cu + Co)×10
PhosphoriteCFA (francolite); fluorapatite 42.2% P\(_2\)O\(_5\)
Phosphogenesisupwelling + OMZ + organic-rich mud; Fe redox pump; bacterial polyphosphate; F from seawater; winnowing
IndiaCIOB nodules (pioneer investor 1987); Jhamarkotra and Mussoorie phosphorites

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement