Gas Hydrates, Coal-Bed Methane, Nuclear and Non-Conventional Energy
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C: gas hydrate stability and BSRs, coal-bed methane, uranium and thorium deposits, shale gas, oil sands and geothermal energy.
- 25 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Coal rank, macerals and Indian coalfields, which control coal-bed methane: Coal: Origin, Rank, Petrography and Indian Resources.
- Kerogen, maturity, reservoirs and seals: Petroleum: Origin, Migration, Traps, Exploration and Indian Basins.
- Decay constants, half-lives and U–Th–Pb systematics: Geological Time Scale and Radiometric Dating.
- The Part B view of nuclear and renewable energy, including India’s three-stage programme and geothermal provinces: Energy Resources and Environmental Impact.
- The Singhbhum Shear Zone and the Cuddapah basin, home of India’s uranium: Cratons, Mobile Belts and Proterozoic Basins of India.
The Hook: Ice That Burns
Gas Hydrates
What a hydrate is
A gas hydrate (clathrate hydrate) is a crystalline solid in which hydrogen-bonded water molecules form cages that enclose small gas molecules. Without the guest molecules the cages are unstable; the gas holds the lattice up. In nature the guest is mostly methane, with some ethane, propane, \( \text{CO}_2 \) and \( \text{H}_2\text{S} \).
| Structure | Unit cell (water molecules) | Cages per unit cell | Typical guests | Natural setting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| sI (cubic) | 46 | 2 small \( (5^{12}) \) + 6 large \( (5^{12}6^{2}) \) | methane, ethane, \( \text{CO}_2 \), \( \text{H}_2\text{S} \) | most marine hydrates (microbial methane) |
| sII (cubic) | 136 | 16 small \( (5^{12}) \) + 8 large \( (5^{12}6^{4}) \) | propane, isobutane with methane | thermogenic gas; also forms in gas pipelines |
| sH (hexagonal) | 34 | 3 small + 2 medium + 1 large | large molecules (e.g. methylcyclohexane) with a small “help gas” | rare in nature |
The notation \( 5^{12}6^{2} \) means a cage with 12 pentagonal and 2 hexagonal faces. For sI with every cage filled by methane, the ideal formula is \( \text{CH}_4\cdot 5.75\,\text{H}_2\text{O} \) (46 water molecules / 8 cages).
Where hydrates are stable
Hydrate needs high pressure, low temperature, enough gas (above its solubility in pore water) and water. These conditions are met in:
- Marine sediments of continental margins, below water depths of a few hundred metres (the exact depth depends on bottom-water temperature).
- Permafrost regions, onshore and on Arctic shelves, beneath the frozen layer.
The gas hydrate stability zone (GHSZ) in marine sediment runs from the seafloor down to the depth at which the local geotherm crosses the hydrate phase boundary.
graph TD
A[Seafloor: cold bottom water,
pressure from water column] --> B[GHSZ: hydrate stable
if methane exceeds solubility]
B --> C[Base of GHSZ:
geotherm meets phase boundary]
C --> D[Free gas trapped below
the hydrate-bearing layer]
C -.seismic.-> E[BSR: reversed-polarity reflector
parallel to the seafloor]| Change | Effect on GHSZ thickness |
|---|---|
| Deeper water (higher pressure) | thicker |
| Warmer bottom water | thinner, top of stability deeper |
| Higher geothermal gradient | thinner |
| Salt in pore water | phase boundary shifts to lower temperature: thinner |
| Heavier gases (ethane, propane; sII) | phase boundary shifts to higher temperature: thicker |
Detecting hydrates
| Method | Hydrate signature |
|---|---|
| Bottom-simulating reflector (BSR) | a reflector that mimics the seafloor, cuts across bedding, and has reversed polarity relative to the seafloor, because high-velocity hydrate-bearing sediment overlies low-velocity gas-charged sediment. It marks the base of the GHSZ |
| Amplitude blanking | reduced reflection amplitudes within hydrate-cemented sediment |
| Well logs | high resistivity and high P-wave velocity in the hydrate zone (hydrate, like ice, is an electrical insulator) |
| Pore-water chemistry | chloride freshening in recovered cores: dissociating hydrate releases fresh water |
| Core temperature | cold spots on infrared scans, because dissociation is endothermic |
| Seafloor | gas plumes, pockmarks, cold seeps with chemosynthetic communities, authigenic carbonates |
Because the BSR sits where the temperature equals the hydrate dissociation temperature at that pressure, it doubles as a thermometer. If the seafloor temperature \( T_0 \), the BSR temperature \( T_{BSR} \) (from the phase diagram at the BSR pressure) and the sediment thermal conductivity \( k \) are known:
$$\boxed{q = k\,\frac{T_{BSR} - T_0}{z_{BSR}}}$$where \( z_{BSR} \) is the BSR depth below the seafloor. Mapping BSR depth across a margin gives a regional heat-flow map without drilling.
Origin of the methane
Most marine hydrate methane is microbial, from methanogenesis in shallow sediment, with \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) typically below about −60‰ and almost no ethane or propane. Thermogenic methane migrating from deeper source rocks has heavier carbon isotopes and carries ethane and propane, which can stabilise sII hydrate. Hydrate occurs disseminated in mud, as nodules and veins filling fractures, and, most valuably for production, as pore fill in sands, where saturations can be high.
Resource, hazard and climate
- Production methods: depressurisation (lowering pressure below the stability limit, the most promising), thermal stimulation, inhibitor injection (methanol, glycols, brines) and \( \text{CO}_2 \)–\( \text{CH}_4 \) exchange, in which \( \text{CO}_2 \) replaces methane in the cages. Short offshore production tests have been made in the Nankai Trough (Japan) and the South China Sea; no field is yet in commercial production.
- Geohazards: dissociation weakens sediment and has been proposed as a factor in submarine slope failures; drilling through hydrate needs care.
- Climate: methane is a strong greenhouse gas. Large releases of hydrate methane have been proposed for past warming events such as the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum, a hypothesis that remains debated.
Gas hydrates in India
India’s National Gas Hydrate Programme (NGHP) has drilled and cored hydrates in the Indian offshore. Expedition NGHP-01 found hydrate in the Krishna–Godavari, Mahanadi and Andaman areas, mostly as fracture fill in clay-rich sediment in KG, and an unusually deep hydrate occurrence in the Andaman. Expedition NGHP-02 targeted sand reservoirs and found high-saturation, sand-hosted hydrate in the KG basin, the kind considered producible. BSRs have been mapped along both the eastern and western margins.
Coal-Bed Methane
How gas is stored in coal
Coal-bed methane (CBM) is natural gas held in coal seams. Unlike a conventional reservoir, coal is both source and reservoir, and most of its gas is adsorbed on the internal surfaces of the coal’s micropores, not held as free gas. Coal has an enormous internal surface area, so at shallow depth it can store several times more gas than the same volume of sandstone.
| Storage mode | Share |
|---|---|
| Adsorbed on micropore surfaces | the great majority |
| Free gas in cleats and fractures | small |
| Dissolved in water | small |
The gas is thermogenic (from coalification, mainly at bituminous ranks and above) or biogenic (from microbes, including secondary biogenic gas produced long after burial when groundwater carries microbes into low-rank coal).
The Langmuir isotherm
Adsorption capacity at constant temperature is described by the Langmuir isotherm:
$$\boxed{V = \frac{V_L\,P}{P_L + P}}$$| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| \( V \) | gas content the coal can hold at pressure \( P \) (m³ t\(^{-1}\)) |
| \( V_L \) | Langmuir volume: the maximum capacity at infinite pressure |
| \( P_L \) | Langmuir pressure: the pressure at which \( V = V_L/2 \) |
Capacity rises steeply at low pressure and flattens at high pressure. It increases with rank in general, and decreases with moisture, ash and temperature. A coal is saturated if its measured gas content equals the isotherm value at reservoir pressure, and undersaturated if it holds less.
Producing CBM: dewater, desorb, diffuse, flow
graph LR
A[Pump water from the seam
reservoir pressure falls] --> B[Pressure reaches the
critical desorption pressure]
B --> C[Methane desorbs from
micropore surfaces]
C --> D[Diffuses through the
coal matrix: Fick's law]
D --> E[Flows through cleats
to the well: Darcy's law]- Critical desorption pressure \( P_{cd} \): the pressure on the isotherm that matches the measured gas content. Gas will not flow until the reservoir pressure is lowered to \( P_{cd} \). Rearranging Langmuir: \( P_{cd} = \dfrac{V\,P_L}{V_L - V} \).
- Cleats are the natural fractures of coal, perpendicular to bedding: face cleats are continuous; butt cleats are shorter and end against the face cleats. Cleat permeability controls productivity and falls with depth because of rising stress, so the best CBM is a balance between gas content (rising with depth) and permeability (falling with depth).
- Production profile: water production is high at first and declines; gas production rises over months to years as desorption spreads (“negative decline”), then declines. Produced water disposal is a major environmental issue.
Related gases and uses
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| CBM | gas produced from unmined coal seams through wells |
| Coal mine methane (CMM) | methane drained from working or abandoned mines; a safety and greenhouse issue (firedamp) |
| Ventilation air methane | very dilute methane in mine exhaust air |
| Enhanced CBM (ECBM) | injecting \( \text{CO}_2 \) (adsorbed more strongly than methane) or \( \text{N}_2 \) to displace methane; with \( \text{CO}_2 \) it doubles as geological storage |
India. CBM blocks have been awarded in the Gondwana coalfields of the Damodar valley (Raniganj, Jharia, East and West Bokaro, North Karanpura) and the Son valley (Sohagpur), among others; commercial production began in the Raniganj coalfield. Indian Gondwana coals are high in ash, which reduces gas content per tonne of rock, and permeability is a key constraint.
Nuclear Energy Resources
Uranium and thorium geochemistry
| Property | Uranium | Thorium |
|---|---|---|
| Isotopes | \( ^{238}\text{U} \) (99.27%, \( t_{1/2} \) 4.47 Gyr), \( ^{235}\text{U} \) (0.72%, 0.704 Gyr), \( ^{234}\text{U} \) (trace) | \( ^{232}\text{Th} \) (about 100%, 14.0 Gyr) |
| Oxidation states | U⁴⁺ (insoluble) and U⁶⁺ (soluble as uranyl, \( \text{UO}_2^{2+} \), especially as carbonate complexes) | Th⁴⁺ only |
| Mobility | high in oxidising water; precipitates on reduction | very low; stays in resistant minerals |
| Main minerals | uraninite \( \text{UO}_2 \) (pitchblende is its fine-grained colloform variety), coffinite \( \text{USiO}_4 \), brannerite, secondary uranyl minerals (autunite, torbernite, carnotite) | monazite (Ce, La, Th)\( \text{PO}_4 \), thorianite, thorite, uranothorite |
| Concentrating process | redox fronts: dissolved in oxidised water, precipitated by organic matter, sulfides or \( \text{Fe}^{2+} \) | placers: heavy, resistant monazite in beach and river sands |
This single contrast (U mobile when oxidised, Th never mobile) explains almost every uranium and thorium deposit type, and it is also why the Th/U ratio of rocks rises during oxidative weathering.
Uranium deposit types
| Type | Setting | Ore control | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unconformity-related | Proterozoic basin sandstones over metamorphic basement | oxidised basinal brine meets reduced (graphitic) basement at the unconformity; exceptionally high grades | Athabasca basin (Canada), Alligator Rivers (Australia); Lambapur–Peddagattu (Telangana) |
| Sandstone-hosted | fluvial and marginal-marine sandstones with organic matter or pyrite | oxidised groundwater carries uranium down-dip until it meets reduced ground: roll-front, tabular and basal-channel bodies; often mined by in situ recovery | Wyoming and Texas (USA), Kazakhstan, Niger; Domiasiat area (Meghalaya), in Cretaceous sandstone |
| Quartz-pebble conglomerate | Archean–Paleoproterozoic fluvial conglomerates | detrital uraninite, preserved only under a low-oxygen atmosphere | Witwatersrand (South Africa), Elliot Lake (Canada) |
| IOCG (breccia complex) | Proterozoic hematite breccias | U with Cu, Au, REE in oxidised Fe-oxide breccia | Olympic Dam (Australia), the largest known uranium resource |
| Vein and shear-zone | granites, metamorphic shear zones | fracture-controlled hydrothermal veins | Singhbhum Shear Zone (Jaduguda, Bhatin, Narwapahar, Turamdih, Bagjata); Gogi (Karnataka) |
| Intrusive | alaskites, pegmatites, peralkaline complexes | magmatic uraninite | Rössing (Namibia) |
| Metasomatite | sodium-metasomatised (albitised) rocks | U introduced with Na metasomatism | Ukraine; albitite-associated occurrences in Rajasthan |
| Carbonate-hosted | dolostones and limestones | strata-bound, low grade, large tonnage | Tummalapalle (Andhra Pradesh), in the phosphatic dolostone of the Vempalle Formation, Cuddapah basin |
| Surficial (calcrete) | arid-zone valley fill | U precipitates with V as carnotite on evaporation | Yeelirrie (Australia) |
| Phosphorite, black shale | marine phosphorites and organic shales | U substitutes for Ca in apatite, adsorbed on organic matter | very low grade; potential by-product |
Indian uranium and thorium
| Province | Deposits | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Singhbhum Shear Zone (Jharkhand) | Jaduguda, Bhatin, Narwapahar, Turamdih, Bagjata, Banduhurang, Mohuldih | shear-zone-hosted, with copper, apatite and magnetite; the oldest uranium mining district in India |
| Cuddapah basin (Andhra Pradesh, Telangana) | Tummalapalle (south-western margin); Lambapur–Peddagattu, Chitrial (northern, Srisailam sub-basin) | carbonate-hosted strata-bound; unconformity-related |
| Meghalaya | Domiasiat and nearby deposits | sandstone-hosted, Cretaceous |
| Bhima basin (Karnataka) | Gogi | fracture-controlled, near basement granite |
| Rajasthan | Rohil and others | albitite-associated |
Exploration is carried out by the Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration and Research (AMD) and mining by Uranium Corporation of India Limited (UCIL).
Thorium: India has large thorium resources, mostly in monazite from the beach and inland placers of Kerala (Chavara), Tamil Nadu (Manavalakurichi), Odisha (Chhatrapur) and Andhra Pradesh, along with ilmenite, rutile, zircon, sillimanite and garnet (the placer process is in Ore-Forming Processes and Metallogeny). India’s limited uranium and large thorium explain the design of its three-stage nuclear programme, described in Energy Resources and Environmental Impact.
Exploration for radioactive minerals
| Method | Principle |
|---|---|
| Gamma-ray spectrometry (ground, airborne, borehole) | separates the three natural emitters by energy: K from \( ^{40}\text{K} \) at 1.46 MeV; U from its daughter \( ^{214}\text{Bi} \) at 1.76 MeV; Th from its daughter \( ^{208}\text{Tl} \) at 2.61 MeV |
| Scintillometer and Geiger counter | total radioactivity; quick reconnaissance |
| Radon emanometry | radon gas (from \( ^{226}\text{Ra} \)) in soil gas and water over buried deposits |
| Hydrogeochemistry | dissolved uranium in groundwater and stream water; uranium is mobile in oxidised water |
| Geology | redox boundaries, unconformities, shear zones, albitisation, hematite alteration |
Energy from fission
Each fission of \( ^{235}\text{U} \) releases about 200 MeV. For 1 kg of \( ^{235}\text{U} \):
$$N = \frac{1000}{235.0}\times 6.022\times 10^{23} = 2.56\times 10^{24}\ \text{nuclei}$$$$E = 2.56\times 10^{24}\times 200\times 1.602\times 10^{-13}\ \text{J} = 8.2\times 10^{13}\ \text{J}$$This equals the heat from about 3,300 tonnes of coal at 25 MJ kg\(^{-1}\). \( ^{235}\text{U} \) is the only naturally occurring fissile nuclide; \( ^{238}\text{U} \) and \( ^{232}\text{Th} \) are fertile, converting by neutron capture to fissile \( ^{239}\text{Pu} \) and \( ^{233}\text{U} \).
Non-Conventional Hydrocarbons
Conventional oil and gas are buoyant accumulations in discrete traps that flow to a well without special stimulation. Unconventional (continuous) resources are spread across large areas, often without a trap, and need special technology: horizontal drilling, hydraulic fracturing, heating or mining.
| Resource | What it is | Key properties | Recovery |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shale gas | gas retained in an organic-rich shale that is its own source and reservoir | TOC commonly above about 2%; mature (gas window); brittle (quartz- or carbonate-rich, low clay); nanodarcy permeability | horizontal wells with multistage hydraulic fracturing |
| Shale oil / tight oil | light oil in shales or tight siltstones and carbonates in the oil window | as above, oil-window maturity | as above |
| Tight gas | gas in low-permeability sandstones (below about 0.1 mD) | conventional source, poor reservoir | fracturing |
| Oil shale | immature, kerogen-rich (type I or II) shale | has not generated oil yet | mining and retorting (heating to around 500 °C) or in situ heating |
| Oil sands (tar sands) | sand saturated with bitumen, heavily biodegraded oil | API gravity below 10°, very viscous | surface mining; steam-assisted gravity drainage (SAGD) |
| Heavy and extra-heavy oil | dense, viscous, often biodegraded oil | API below about 22° (extra-heavy below 10°) | steam flooding, in situ combustion |
| CBM, gas hydrates | above |
API gravity classifies crude oils by density:
$$\boxed{^\circ\text{API} = \frac{141.5}{\text{SG}_{60^\circ\text{F}}} - 131.5}$$Water (SG = 1) is 10°. Light oil is above about 31°, medium 22–31°, heavy 10–22°, extra-heavy and bitumen below 10° (denser than water). Biodegradation by bacteria in shallow, cool reservoirs removes n-alkanes first, lowers API gravity and raises viscosity and sulfur; it is the main way giant heavy-oil and oil-sand deposits (Athabasca in Canada, the Orinoco belt in Venezuela) form.
India. Shales in the Cambay, Krishna–Godavari, Cauvery and Gondwana (Damodar) basins have been studied as shale-gas prospects, and heavy oil occurs in the Bikaner–Nagaur basin of Rajasthan and in parts of Cambay. Underground coal gasification, which burns coal in place to make syngas (CO + H\(_2\)), has also been studied for deep or thin Indian seams and lignite.
Geothermal Energy
Earth’s internal heat comes from radioactive decay (U, Th, K) and primordial heat. It is extracted where heat is concentrated at shallow depth: plate boundaries, hotspots, young intrusions and rifts.
| System | Description | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Vapour-dominated hydrothermal | steam fills fractures; the easiest to use | Larderello (Italy), The Geysers (USA) |
| Liquid-dominated hydrothermal | hot water, flashes to steam as pressure drops | most high-temperature fields (Iceland, New Zealand) |
| Low-enthalpy | warm water below about 150 °C | binary-cycle power, direct heating |
| Hot dry rock / enhanced geothermal (EGS) | hot impermeable rock fractured artificially, water circulated | experimental; induced seismicity is a concern |
| Geopressured | hot, overpressured brines with dissolved methane | Gulf Coast (USA) |
| Ground-source heat pumps | shallow, near-constant ground temperature for heating and cooling | widespread |
A geothermal field needs a heat source, a reservoir (permeable, fractured rock), a cap rock and recharge water. Surface signs include hot springs, fumaroles, geysers and alteration (sinter, travertine). Silica (and Na–K) geothermometers estimate reservoir temperatures from the chemistry of spring water.
Power plants convert heat to work with a maximum (Carnot) efficiency \( \eta = 1 - T_c/T_h \). A 200 °C reservoir rejecting heat at 30 °C has \( \eta_{max} = 1 - 303/473 = 0.36 \); real plants reach a fraction of this, which is why low-temperature fields are better used for direct heat.
India has mainly low- to moderate-enthalpy geothermal provinces: the Himalaya (Puga valley in Ladakh; Manikaran), the Son–Narmada–Tapi lineament (Tattapani), the west coast, Cambay and the Godavari valley. Details are in Energy Resources and Environmental Impact.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | Not this |
|---|---|
| BSR: base of hydrate stability, reversed polarity | Flat spot: horizontal fluid contact in a conventional reservoir |
| CBM: gas from unmined seams by wells | CMM: gas drained from coal mines |
| Adsorbed gas: on coal surfaces (CBM) | Free gas: in pores (conventional, tight gas) |
| Face cleat: continuous | Butt cleat: ends against face cleats |
| Fissile \( ^{235}\text{U} \) | Fertile \( ^{238}\text{U} \), \( ^{232}\text{Th} \) |
| Uraninite: \( \text{UO}_2 \), U⁴⁺, primary | Carnotite, autunite: secondary uranyl (U⁶⁺) minerals |
| Unconformity-related: high grade, Proterozoic | Sandstone roll-front: low grade, younger, ISR |
| Oil shale: immature kerogen, retort it | Shale oil: mature oil in shale, fracture it |
| Oil sands: bitumen, API below 10° | Tight oil: light oil in low-permeability rock |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many water molecules are there in the unit cell of structure I gas hydrate?
- Which oxidation state of uranium is mobile in groundwater?
- Which mineral is India’s main source of thorium?
Answers
- 46 (with 8 cages: 2 small, 6 large).
- U⁶⁺, as the uranyl ion \( \text{UO}_2^{2+} \), mostly complexed with carbonate.
- Monazite, from beach placers.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A seismic section across a continental slope shows a strong reflector about 200 m below the seafloor that parallels the seafloor, cuts across dipping strata and has polarity opposite to the seafloor reflection. It most likely marks:
(a) an oil–water contact (b) the base of the gas hydrate stability zone (c) a diagenetic opal-A to opal-CT transition (d) the top of the oceanic crust
Answer: (b)
These are the defining features of a BSR: parallel to the seafloor (it follows isotherms, which follow the seafloor), cross-cutting bedding, and reversed polarity because high-velocity hydrate-bearing sediment overlies low-velocity gas-bearing sediment. A diagenetic silica front also mimics the seafloor but gives normal polarity, because velocity increases downward across it.
Practice Q2. A coal has Langmuir parameters \( V_L = 25 \) m³ t\(^{-1}\) and \( P_L = 2.5 \) MPa. Its gas content at a reservoir pressure of 5.0 MPa, if saturated, is:
(a) 8.3 m³ t\(^{-1}\) (b) 12.5 m³ t\(^{-1}\) (c) 16.7 m³ t\(^{-1}\) (d) 25 m³ t\(^{-1}\)
Answer: (c)
\( V = 25\times 5.0/(2.5 + 5.0) = 125/7.5 = 16.7 \) m³ t\(^{-1}\). Option (b) is the value at \( P = P_L \); option (d) is \( V_L \), reached only at infinite pressure.
Practice Q3. A crude oil has a specific gravity of 0.85 at 60 °F. Its API gravity and class are:
(a) 35°, light (b) 22°, heavy (c) 10°, extra-heavy (d) 45°, condensate-like
Answer: (a)
\( 141.5/0.85 - 131.5 = 166.5 - 131.5 = 35.0° \). Above about 31° is light oil.
Practice Q4. Which pairing of Indian uranium deposit and type is incorrect?
(a) Tummalapalle – carbonate-hosted, Cuddapah basin (b) Domiasiat – sandstone-hosted, Meghalaya (c) Jaduguda – Singhbhum Shear Zone (d) Lambapur – quartz-pebble conglomerate, Witwatersrand type
Answer: (d)
Lambapur–Peddagattu, in the northern Cuddapah basin, is unconformity-related, at the contact of basin sandstone with basement granite. The other pairings are correct.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. At a site, the BSR lies 200 m below a seafloor at 4 °C. At the BSR pressure, the methane hydrate phase boundary gives a temperature of 18 °C. The sediment thermal conductivity is 1.0 W m\(^{-1}\) K\(^{-1}\). At a second site with the same water depth, the BSR is at 280 m below the seafloor. Which statement is correct?
(a) Heat flow at site 1 is 70 mW m\(^{-2}\); site 2 has lower heat flow. (b) Heat flow at site 1 is 70 mW m\(^{-2}\); site 2 has higher heat flow. (c) Heat flow at site 1 is 14 mW m\(^{-2}\); site 2 has lower heat flow. (d) Heat flow at site 1 is 90 mW m\(^{-2}\); BSR depth is unrelated to heat flow.
Answer: (a)
Gradient \( = (18 - 4)/200 = 0.070 \) K m\(^{-1}\); \( q = 1.0\times 0.070 = 0.070 \) W m\(^{-2}\) = 70 mW m\(^{-2}\).
At site 2 the same temperature rise (same water depth, so roughly the same BSR temperature and seafloor temperature) is spread over 280 m: gradient \( = 14/280 = 0.050 \) K m\(^{-1}\), \( q = 50 \) mW m\(^{-2}\). A deeper BSR means lower heat flow. Option (c) divides the 14 K rise by 1,000 m instead of 200 m.
Practice Q6. A coal with \( V_L = 25 \) m³ t\(^{-1}\) and \( P_L = 2.5 \) MPa is at a reservoir pressure of 5.0 MPa, but desorption canister tests give a gas content of only 10 m³ t\(^{-1}\). Which statements are correct?
- The coal is undersaturated, at 60% of its capacity.
- The critical desorption pressure is about 1.7 MPa.
- Gas will begin to desorb as soon as pumping begins.
- Reservoir pressure must be drawn down by about two-thirds before gas flows.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
Capacity at 5.0 MPa: \( 25\times 5/7.5 = 16.7 \) m³ t\(^{-1}\); saturation \( = 10/16.7 = 0.60 \). Statement 1 true.
\( P_{cd} = V P_L/(V_L - V) = 10\times 2.5/15 = 1.67 \) MPa. Statement 2 true.
Since \( P_{cd} \) is well below 5.0 MPa, the early production is water only: statement 3 false. The drawdown needed is \( 5.0 - 1.67 = 3.33 \) MPa, two-thirds of the initial pressure: statement 4 true.
Practice Q7. Present-day \( ^{235}\text{U}/^{238}\text{U} = 1/137.88 \). Half-lives: \( ^{235}\text{U} \) 0.7038 Gyr, \( ^{238}\text{U} \) 4.468 Gyr. The \( ^{235}\text{U} \) abundance (atom %) in natural uranium 2.0 billion years ago was closest to:
(a) 0.72% (b) 1.4% (c) 3.7% (d) 17%
Answer: (c) 3.7%
\( \lambda_{235} = 0.693/0.7038 = 0.9849 \) Gyr\(^{-1}\); \( \lambda_{238} = 0.693/4.468 = 0.1551 \) Gyr\(^{-1}\).
Going back in time, each isotope is multiplied by \( e^{\lambda t} \), so the ratio grows by \( e^{(\lambda_{235} - \lambda_{238})t} = e^{0.8297\times 2.0} = e^{1.659} = 5.26 \).
Ratio then \( = 5.26/137.88 = 0.0381 \); abundance \( = 0.0381/1.0381 = \) 3.7%. This is comparable to the enrichment of light-water reactor fuel, which is why ordinary groundwater could moderate a natural chain reaction at Oklo. Option (a) assumes the abundance has not changed; option (d) is far too high for only about three half-lives of \( ^{235}\text{U} \).
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Hydrate structures | sI 46 H₂O, 2 + 6 cages, methane; sII 136 H₂O, 16 + 8 cages, propane; sH 34 H₂O |
| Ideal sI formula | \( \text{CH}_4\cdot 5.75\,\text{H}_2\text{O} \); about 160–170 m³ \( \text{CH}_4 \) (STP) per m³ hydrate |
| GHSZ | seafloor to where geotherm crosses phase boundary; thinner with high gradient, warm water, salt |
| BSR | base of GHSZ; parallels seafloor; reversed polarity; free gas below; gives heat flow \( q = k\Delta T/z \) |
| Hydrate evidence | high resistivity and velocity, chloride freshening, IR cold spots |
| Indian hydrates | NGHP: KG (fracture-fill and sand-hosted), Mahanadi, Andaman |
| CBM storage | mostly adsorbed; coal is source and reservoir |
| Langmuir | \( V = V_L P/(P_L + P) \); \( P_{cd} = V P_L/(V_L - V) \) |
| CBM production | dewater → desorb → diffuse (Fick) → Darcy flow in cleats; face and butt cleats |
| Uranium | U⁶⁺ mobile (uranyl carbonate), U⁴⁺ precipitates; uraninite, pitchblende, coffinite |
| Thorium | Th⁴⁺ immobile; monazite placers |
| Deposit types | unconformity, sandstone (roll front), QPC, IOCG, vein, intrusive, metasomatite, carbonate, calcrete |
| Indian U | Singhbhum Shear Zone (Jaduguda); Tummalapalle; Lambapur–Peddagattu; Domiasiat; Gogi |
| Gamma peaks | K 1.46, U (Bi-214) 1.76, Th (Tl-208) 2.61 MeV |
| Fission | about 200 MeV per fission; 1 kg \( ^{235}\text{U} \) about \( 8.2\times 10^{13} \) J |
| API | \( 141.5/\text{SG} - 131.5 \); light above 31°, heavy 10–22°, bitumen below 10° |
| Unconventional | shale gas and tight oil (fracking), oil shale (retort), oil sands (SAGD, mining) |
| Geothermal | vapour- and liquid-dominated, EGS, geopressured; Carnot \( 1 - T_c/T_h \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Economic Geology: Quick Revision: every number and trap from the unit on one page.
- Ore-Forming Processes and Metallogeny: the redox and placer processes behind uranium and thorium, set among all ore-forming processes.
- Oceanic Sediments, Diagenesis and Resources: hydrates and other resources of the seafloor in their marine context.