Induced Polarization
Induced polarization for CSIR NET geophysics: electrode and membrane polarization, chargeability, frequency effect, metal factor, Cole-Cole, pseudosections.
- 18 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Resistivity Profiling and Sounding: arrays, geometric factors and apparent resistivity. IP is measured with the same electrodes and arrays.
- Ferrous, Base and Noble Metal Deposits: the disseminated sulphide deposits that made IP the standard base-metal tool.
- Electrochemistry: the electrical double layer and electrode polarisation, which is the same physics at a mineral grain.
The Hook: The Voltage That Will Not Switch Off
How CSIR NET asks it. Part C Geophysics: the two polarisation mechanisms, definitions and units of chargeability, frequency effect and metal factor (with a calculation), the link between time and frequency domains, the pseudosection plotting point, EM coupling, and which targets IP finds that resistivity misses.
What Causes Induced Polarization
Induced polarization (IP) is the capacitor-like storage of charge in the ground when current flows, caused by blocked or slowed ion movement. Two mechanisms are recognised.
Electrode (grain) polarization
Where a pore channel is blocked by an electronically conducting grain (sulphide, graphite, some oxides), current must change from ionic to electronic at one face of the grain and back at the other. That transfer needs an electrochemical reaction, which is slower than the arrival of ions. Ions pile up on the grain faces, forming a double layer and an overvoltage. When the current stops, the ions diffuse back and the overvoltage decays.
- Strongest when metallic grains are disseminated (many grain surfaces exposed to pore water), not massive.
- The response depends on the total grain surface area more than on the volume of metal.
- Gives the largest IP effects and is the basis of IP for base-metal exploration.
Membrane (electrolytic) polarization
In rocks without metallic grains, clay minerals carry a negative surface charge that attracts a cloud of cations. Where pore throats are narrow and lined with clay, the cation cloud acts as an ion-selective membrane: cations pass, anions are held back. Current flow builds up ion concentration gradients across these zones, which relax when the current stops.
- Strongest in rocks with a modest, scattered clay content; very clay-rich rocks give less, because the pathways become uniformly charged.
- Gives a weaker effect than electrode polarization, but it is the “background” IP of almost every rock, and the response used in groundwater and environmental IP work.
| Electrode polarization | Membrane polarization | |
|---|---|---|
| Cause | ionic–electronic transfer at a metallic grain | ion-selective zones at clay-lined pore throats |
| Needs | electronically conducting minerals | clay minerals, narrow pores |
| Size of effect | large | small to moderate |
| Typical target | disseminated sulphides, graphite | clay content; distinguishing clay from saline water |
Measuring IP in the Time Domain
The transmitter sends a square wave with off-times (for example on +, off, on −, off), each part typically lasting one to a few seconds. During the on-time the receiver reads the primary voltage \( V_p \) (from which apparent resistivity is computed exactly as in a DC survey). After switch-off it samples the secondary (decay) voltage \( V_s(t) \).
graph LR
A["Current on: V rises toward Vp
(charging)"] --> B["Current off at t = 0:
instant drop"]
B --> C["Slow decay Vs(t)
(discharge of polarised ground)"]
C --> D["Chargeability:
Vs/Vp or area under decay / Vp"]Chargeability
The chargeability is defined in two ways.
Instantaneous ratio (at a chosen delay \( t \)):
$$M = \frac{V_s(t)}{V_p}\qquad\text{(dimensionless; quoted in mV/V or per cent)}$$Integral chargeability (area under the decay curve over a window \( t_1 \) to \( t_2 \)):
$$\boxed{M = \frac{1}{V_p}\int_{t_1}^{t_2} V_s(t)\,dt}\qquad\text{(unit: ms, or mV·s/V)}$$The integral form averages noise and is what most modern receivers report, often for several windows so the decay shape is recorded. Values from different instruments are comparable only if the windows and the waveform are the same; quote them with their timing.
Seigel’s definition and apparent chargeability
Seigel described IP as a change of effective resistivity: a polarisable medium of chargeability \( m \) behaves at DC (after full charging) as if its resistivity were \( \rho/(1 - m) \) instead of \( \rho \). Over non-uniform ground the measured apparent chargeability is a sensitivity-weighted sum of the true chargeabilities:
$$m_a \approx \sum_i \frac{\partial\ln\rho_a}{\partial\ln\rho_i}\,m_i, \qquad \sum_i \frac{\partial\ln\rho_a}{\partial\ln\rho_i} = 1 .$$The weights are the same sensitivities that control apparent resistivity. A polarisable body therefore shows up in \( m_a \) diluted by how much of the current actually passes through it. With weights 0.7 (barren cover, \( m = 5 \) mV/V) and 0.3 (mineralised zone, \( m = 40 \) mV/V), \( m_a = 3.5 + 12 = 15.5 \) mV/V.
Measuring IP in the Frequency Domain
Because the ground “charges up” over time, its apparent resistivity measured with a slowly alternating current is higher than with a rapidly alternating one: at high frequency the polarisation does not have time to build up. Resistivity falls with increasing frequency.
Frequency effect (resistivities at a low frequency \( \rho_{dc} \) and a higher one \( \rho_{ac} \), commonly about a decade apart):
$$\boxed{FE = \frac{\rho_{dc} - \rho_{ac}}{\rho_{ac}}}, \qquad PFE = 100 \times FE\ \ (\text{per cent frequency effect}).$$Metal factor (normalises the frequency effect by resistivity):
$$\boxed{MF = A\,\frac{\rho_{dc} - \rho_{ac}}{\rho_{dc}\,\rho_{ac}} = \frac{A\cdot FE}{\rho_{dc}}}, \qquad A = 2\pi\times10^5 .$$The idea behind MF: a sulphide body tends to have both high IP and lower resistivity, so dividing by \( \rho \) enhances it. But dividing by resistivity also enhances anything conductive, so MF must be read with both FE and \( \rho_a \).
Phase (complex resistivity) and spectral IP
Measured as a complex quantity, resistivity has a small negative phase: the voltage lags the current. Phase IP reports this phase angle (usually in milliradians) at one or more frequencies. Spectral IP (SIP) measures amplitude and phase over several decades of frequency, which carries information about grain size and texture, and can help discriminate sulphide types and remove coupling.
The standard empirical description is the Cole–Cole model (as adapted to IP data by Pelton and co-workers):
$$\boxed{\rho(\omega) = \rho_0\left[1 - m\left(1 - \frac{1}{1 + (i\omega\tau)^c}\right)\right]}$$| Parameter | Meaning |
|---|---|
| \( \rho_0 \) | DC resistivity |
| \( m \) | chargeability (0 to 1) |
| \( \tau \) | time constant: controls where in frequency the dispersion happens; tends to increase with polarisable grain size |
| \( c \) | frequency exponent (0 to 1): controls how spread out the dispersion is |
Limits. At \( \omega \to 0 \), \( \rho \to \rho_0 \). At \( \omega \to \infty \), \( \rho \to \rho_0(1 - m) \). So the total fall in resistivity is a fraction \( m \): this is Seigel’s chargeability again, and it links the two domains:
$$FE_{\text{full}} = \frac{\rho_0 - \rho_\infty}{\rho_\infty} = \frac{m}{1 - m}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad m = \frac{FE}{1 + FE}.$$For small \( m \), \( FE \approx m \). (A real survey measures between two finite frequencies, so its FE is smaller than this full-range value.)
| Frequency (Hz) | 0.01 | 1 | 10 | 15.9 | 100 | 1,000 | 10,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| \( \lvert\rho\rvert/\rho_0 \) | 0.996 | 0.966 | 0.914 | 0.901 | 0.852 | 0.818 | 0.806 |
| Phase (mrad) | −3.4 | −25.9 | −44.6 | −46.0 | −38.4 | −18.3 | −6.6 |
(Cole–Cole model with \( m = 0.2 \), \( \tau = 0.01 \) s, \( c = 0.5 \).) Amplitude falls from \( \rho_0 \) toward \( 0.8\rho_0 \); the phase peaks at a few tens of Hz, in the neighbourhood of \( f = 1/(2\pi\tau) \approx 15.9 \) Hz (for these parameters the exact maximum, about −46 mrad, falls near 20 Hz).
Field Surveys and Pseudosections
Arrays
| Array | Use in IP |
|---|---|
| Dipole-dipole | standard for 2-D profiling and pseudosections; symmetric, good lateral resolution; lower signal |
| Pole-dipole | stronger signal and deeper reach for a given cable; asymmetric response |
| Gradient | large fixed current electrodes, potential dipole moved over a central area; fast reconnaissance mapping of a wide block |
| Schlumberger / Wenner | IP soundings (for example, clay layers in groundwater work) |
Plotting a pseudosection
For dipole-dipole, each reading is plotted below the midpoint between the two dipoles, at the intersection of two lines drawn at 45° from the dipole centres. Dipole centres \( (n + 1)a \) apart give a pseudo-depth of
$$z_{\text{plot}} = \frac{(n + 1)a}{2}.$$So \( a = 25 \) m, \( n = 4 \) plots at 62.5 m. Contoured readings of \( \rho_a \), chargeability or PFE then form a pseudosection. Over a compact polarisable body, a dipole-dipole pseudosection shows a characteristic inverted-V (“pant’s leg”) pattern: the anomaly appears along both 45° lines from the body, because a reading is high whenever either the current or the potential dipole is over the body. Pseudosections must be inverted to obtain a true chargeability section.
Electromagnetic coupling and other noise
Other noise: electrode polarisation at the potential electrodes (use non-polarisable electrodes), telluric currents, and capacitive coupling between cables and ground.
Interpretation and targets
| Target | Resistivity | IP | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Disseminated sulphides (porphyry copper) | modest low | high | classic IP target |
| Massive sulphides | very low | moderate to high | also a strong EM target |
| Graphite, graphitic schist | very low | high | the main false target; geology needed |
| Pyrite halo | variable | high | barren but polarisable: high IP does not mean ore |
| Clay | low | moderate | membrane polarisation |
| Saline water | very low | low | distinguishes it from clay |
| Fresh, clean sand or massive rock | moderate to high | low | background |
Applications beyond minerals: mapping clay layers and distinguishing clay from saline water in aquifers, detecting some hydrocarbon-contaminated and landfill sites, and characterising disseminated mineralisation for engineering.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| Electrode vs membrane polarization | metallic grain, large effect | clay-lined pores, smaller effect |
| Chargeability vs frequency effect | time domain: \( V_s/V_p \) or integral (ms) | frequency domain: \( (\rho_{dc} - \rho_{ac})/\rho_{ac} \) |
| Frequency effect vs metal factor | dimensionless, independent of \( \rho \) scale | \( FE/\rho_{dc} \) scaled by \( 2\pi\times10^5 \): favours conductive polarisable ground |
| IP vs self-potential | induced by an applied current | natural potential, no transmitter |
| IP signal vs EM coupling | ground polarisation, low-frequency or late-time effect | inductive wire–ground coupling, grows with frequency, separation, conductivity |
| \( \tau \) vs \( c \) in Cole–Cole | position of the dispersion in frequency | width (spread) of the dispersion |
| Pseudosection vs inverted section | readings plotted at nominal depth, pant’s-leg artefacts | model of true chargeability |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name the polarisation mechanism caused by clay minerals.
- What is the unit of integral chargeability?
- Is resistivity higher at the lower or the higher frequency in an IP survey?
Answers
- Membrane (electrolytic) polarization.
- Milliseconds (mV·s per V).
- At the lower frequency: the ground has more time to polarise, so it presents a higher effective resistance.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A time-domain survey records \( V_p = 250 \) mV and, at a chosen delay after switch-off, \( V_s = 5 \) mV. The chargeability at that delay is:
(a) 2 mV/V (b) 5 mV/V (c) 20 mV/V (d) 50 mV/V
Answer: (c) 20 mV/V
\( M = V_s/V_p = 5/250 = 0.02 = 20 \) mV/V (2%). (a) is the percentage written as mV/V. (b) quotes \( V_s \) itself. (d) inverts and rescales.
Practice Q2. Resistivities of 120 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) at 0.1 Hz and 112 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) at 1 Hz are measured. The per cent frequency effect and metal factor are closest to:
(a) PFE 6.7, MF 349 (b) PFE 7.1, MF 374 (c) PFE 7.1, MF 401 (d) PFE 0.071, MF 3.7
Answer: (b)
\( FE = (120 - 112)/112 = 0.0714 \), PFE \( = 7.14 \). \( MF = 2\pi\times10^5\times0.0714/120 \approx 374 \). (a) divides by \( \rho_{dc} \) in FE (\( 8/120 \)). (c) divides by 112 in the metal factor. (d) gives FE as a fraction and drops the \( 10^5 \) scale.
Practice Q3. In the Cole–Cole model, a rock has DC resistivity 200 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) and chargeability \( m = 0.1 \). Its resistivity at very high frequency is:
(a) 180 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) (b) 200 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) (c) 220 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) (d) 222 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \)
Answer: (a) 180 Ω m
\( \rho_\infty = \rho_0(1 - m) = 200 \times 0.9 = 180\ \Omega\,\text{m} \). Resistivity falls with frequency. (c) and (d) have it rising (multiplying by 1.1 or dividing by 0.9).
Practice Q4. A dipole-dipole IP survey uses 25 m dipoles. The reading for \( n = 4 \) is plotted on the pseudosection at a pseudo-depth of:
(a) 25 m (b) 50 m (c) 62.5 m (d) 125 m
Answer: (c) 62.5 m
Dipole centres are \( (n + 1)a = 125 \) m apart; the 45° lines meet at half that depth, 62.5 m. (b) uses \( na/2 \). (d) uses the full centre separation.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Three anomalies are found in a frequency-domain IP survey (resistivities at the low and the high frequency):
| Anomaly | \( \rho_{dc} \) (\( \Omega\,\text{m} \)) | \( \rho_{ac} \) (\( \Omega\,\text{m} \)) |
|---|---|---|
| P | 80 | 76 |
| Q | 8 | 7.6 |
| R | 400 | 388 |
Which statements are correct?
- P and Q have the same per cent frequency effect, about 5.3%.
- Q has a metal factor about ten times that of P.
- R has the lowest metal factor of the three.
- The metal factor alone proves Q is the best sulphide target.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) all four
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
FE: P \( = 4/76 = 0.0526 \); Q \( = 0.4/7.6 = 0.0526 \); R \( = 12/388 = 0.0309 \).
MF \( = 2\pi\times10^5\,FE/\rho_{dc} \): P \( \approx 413 \); Q \( \approx 4{,}134 \); R \( \approx 49 \).
- True. 5.26% each.
- True. Same FE, one-tenth the resistivity.
- True.
- False. Q’s high MF comes entirely from its low resistivity. Its polarisability is the same as P’s. An 8 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) zone with modest FE could be graphite, clay or saline water with some polarisable material; MF alone cannot rank them.
Practice Q6. A time-domain decay is modelled as \( V_s(t) = 10e^{-t/0.5} \) mV after switch-off (t in s), with \( V_p = 500 \) mV. A second receiver integrates from 0.45 s to 1.45 s instead of 0.1 s to 1.1 s. Which is correct?
(a) Both receivers report about 7.1 ms. (b) The first reports about 7.1 ms; the second reports less, about 3.5 ms. (c) The second reports more, because its window ends later. (d) Both report 10 ms, since \( \tau V_0/V_p = 10 \) ms.
Answer: (b)
First window: \( 10\times0.5(e^{-0.2} - e^{-2.2}) = 3.54 \) mV·s; \( M = 3.54/500 \) s \( = 7.1 \) ms.
Second window: \( 5(e^{-0.9} - e^{-2.9}) = 5(0.4066 - 0.0550) = 1.76 \) mV·s; \( M \approx 3.5 \) ms.
The same ground gives half the chargeability with a later window, because the decay is fastest early. (d) is the integral from 0 to infinity, which no receiver measures. The lesson: quote windows with integral chargeability.
Practice Q7. Which statements about IP are correct?
- Disseminated sulphides can give a strong IP anomaly with only a small resistivity anomaly.
- Saline groundwater gives low resistivity and strong IP.
- EM coupling increases with frequency, dipole separation and ground conductivity.
- For small chargeability, the full-range frequency effect is approximately equal to the Cole–Cole chargeability.
(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2 and 3 only
Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
- True. Unconnected grains polarise strongly but carry little current.
- False. Saline water lowers resistivity but polarises weakly; low IP is how it is told apart from clay.
- True.
- True. \( FE = m/(1 - m) \approx m \) for small \( m \).
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Electrode polarization | ionic–electronic transfer at metallic grains; large; disseminated sulphides |
| Membrane polarization | ion-selective clay-lined pores; smaller; moderate clay content |
| Chargeability | \( M = V_s/V_p \) (mV/V) or \( (1/V_p)\int_{t_1}^{t_2}V_s\,dt \) (ms) |
| Seigel | polarisable medium acts as \( \rho/(1 - m) \); \( m_a = \sum(\partial\ln\rho_a/\partial\ln\rho_i)m_i \) |
| Frequency effect | \( FE = (\rho_{dc} - \rho_{ac})/\rho_{ac} \); PFE \( = 100\,FE \) |
| Metal factor | \( MF = 2\pi\times10^5\,FE/\rho_{dc} \) |
| Cole–Cole | \( \rho_0[1 - m(1 - 1/(1 + (i\omega\tau)^c))] \); limits \( \rho_0 \), \( \rho_0(1 - m) \) |
| Domain link | \( m = FE/(1 + FE) \approx FE \) |
| Phase peak | near \( f \approx 1/(2\pi\tau) \) |
| Pseudo-depth (dipole-dipole) | \( (n + 1)a/2 \); pant’s-leg pattern over compact bodies |
| EM coupling | rises with frequency, separation, dipole length, conductivity |
| False targets | graphite, barren pyrite, clay |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- EM Methods: Loop Methods, VLF, AFMAG and TEM: conductors detected by induction, without any electrode in the ground.
- Ore-Forming Processes and Metallogeny: the deposit styles that produce disseminated sulphides.
- Electrical and Electromagnetic Methods: back to the chapter overview.