Environmental Change and Extra-terrestrial Geomorphology
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C Physical Geography: Quaternary and human-driven landscape change, cosmogenic rates, GLOFs, craters and planetary landforms.
- 20 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Thresholds, complex response, sensitivity and relaxation time: Concepts, Historical and Process Geomorphology.
- Glacial cycles and their proxies: Glacial Cycles, Paleoclimate Proxies and Ice Cores.
- Radiocarbon, luminescence and cosmogenic dating: Quaternary Dating Methods.
- Coastal retreat (Bruun rule), glacier mass balance and dune mechanics: Fluvial, Glacial, Aeolian, Coastal and Karst Processes.
- The planets, their gravity and atmospheres, and meteorite impacts: Solar System Origin and Kepler’s Laws.
The Hook: A Moraine in Ladakh and a Delta on Mars
Environmental Change
Time scales of change
| Scale | Driver | Landscape signal |
|---|---|---|
| 10\(^6\)–10\(^7\) yr | tectonics, ocean gateways, CO\(_2\) | uplift and incision, long-term climate trends, erosion surfaces |
| 10\(^4\)–10\(^5\) yr | orbital (Milankovitch) cycles of about 100, 41 and 23 kyr | glacial–interglacial cycles: moraines, terraces, loess, dune phases, sea-level stands |
| 10\(^2\)–10\(^3\) yr | millennial events, solar and volcanic forcing, monsoon variability | Holocene river avulsions, lake-level changes, dune reactivation |
| 10\(^0\)–10\(^2\) yr | human activity, recent warming | channel change, sediment-supply changes, glacier retreat, coastal erosion |
Quaternary landscapes
The last glacial maximum (LGM, roughly 26–19 ka) was the most recent extreme state:
- Ice and periglacial belts expanded; mid-latitude lowlands acquired periglacial slope deposits and patterned ground that are now relict.
- Sea level stood about 120 m below today’s. Continental shelves were exposed, rivers incised their lower courses to reach the lowered base level, and canyon heads extended across the shelf. The post-glacial transgression drowned these valleys (rias, estuaries) and pushed coastlines landward; drowned river valleys and relict shelf sands record it.
- Deserts expanded and became windier in many low-latitude regions: dunes advanced into areas that are now vegetated, and dust and loess accumulated downwind (the Chinese Loess Plateau is the classic archive).
- Pluvial lakes filled in some now-arid basins where evaporation was lower or storm tracks shifted (Lake Bonneville in the western USA).
- Monsoon rainfall over South Asia was weaker at the LGM and strengthened in the early Holocene, when many lakes in the Thar margins were high; later Holocene drying is recorded by falling lake levels and renewed dune activity. A drying around 4.2 ka is widely discussed in connection with the late Harappan decline, but the link is debated.
River response to climate and base level. In the Himalayan foreland and the Ganga plains, phases of aggradation and incision have been tied to changes in monsoon strength and sediment supply rather than to sea level, which matters only near the coast. The older, higher alluvium of the Ganga plains (bhangar) stands above the younger floodplain alluvium (khadar).
Reading the archive: evidence and dating
| Archive | Change it records | Typical dating |
|---|---|---|
| Moraines, trimlines | glacier extent | cosmogenic exposure ages, radiocarbon on organic material, OSL on outwash |
| River terraces, fans | aggradation and incision phases | OSL, radiocarbon, cosmogenic depth profiles |
| Dunes, loess–palaeosol sequences | aridity and wind; soil formation in wetter phases | OSL |
| Lake shorelines and sediments | hydrological balance | radiocarbon, U-series on carbonates |
| Speleothems | rainfall (oxygen isotopes) | U-series |
| Marine terraces, coral reefs | sea level, uplift | U-series on corals |
Rates from cosmogenic nuclides
Cosmic rays produce nuclides such as \(^{10}\)Be in quartz within the top metre or two of rock. Production falls off with depth with an attenuation length \( \Lambda \approx 160 \) g cm\(^{-2}\) (about 60 cm of rock). Two end-member uses (Lal, 1991):
- Exposure age of a surface with no erosion (and age short relative to the nuclide’s half-life): \( t = N/P \), where \( N \) is the concentration (atoms g\(^{-1}\)) and \( P \) the local production rate (atoms g\(^{-1}\) yr\(^{-1}\)).
- Steady-state erosion rate of a surface eroding at \( \varepsilon \) (cm yr\(^{-1}\)), long enough for production and removal to balance:
Applied to river sand, the same equation gives a catchment-averaged erosion rate. The rate is averaged over the time taken to erode one attenuation length, \( \Lambda/\rho\varepsilon \).
Humans as a geomorphic agent
The Anthropocene is widely used informally for the period of dominant human influence; it is not a formal unit of the geological time scale (a 2024 proposal to define it as an epoch was rejected). Geomorphically, human effects include:
| Activity | Geomorphic effect |
|---|---|
| Deforestation, agriculture | higher runoff and sediment yield; gullying; colluvium and floodplain aggradation (legacy sediment) |
| Dams and reservoirs | sediment trapped upstream; downstream channel incision and armouring (Lane’s balance); delta starvation, subsidence and shoreline retreat (the Nile delta after the Aswan High Dam is the standard case) |
| Sand and gravel mining in channels | bed lowering, bank collapse, undermined bridges, lowered water tables |
| Urbanisation | impervious surfaces: flashier hydrographs and channel enlargement downstream |
| Groundwater and hydrocarbon extraction | land subsidence; worsens relative sea-level rise on deltas |
| Coastal engineering | groynes and breakwaters trap longshore drift and starve downdrift beaches; seawalls reflect waves and steepen beaches |
| Mining and construction | direct earth-moving; at the global scale human earth-moving is estimated to rival or exceed natural sediment transport by rivers |
Geomorphic responses to present warming
- Glacier retreat and thinning across most mountain ranges, including the Himalaya, with expansion of moraine-dammed proglacial lakes.
- Glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs): failure of a moraine or ice dam releases a lake catastrophically. The 2013 Kedarnath disaster combined extreme monsoon rain with the breach of Chorabari Lake; the October 2023 South Lhonak Lake outburst in Sikkim sent a flood down the Teesta that destroyed the Chungthang dam.
- Rock–ice avalanches and paraglacial slope failure as ice that buttressed slopes melts and permafrost warms. The February 2021 Chamoli disaster in Uttarakhand began as a rock and ice avalanche that turned into a debris flow, not as a lake outburst.
- Permafrost thaw: thermokarst, ground subsidence, retrogressive thaw slumps.
- Sea-level rise: global mean sea level rose about 0.2 m between 1901 and 2018 (IPCC AR6), with the rate accelerating. Coasts retreat (Bruun rule), deltas drown where sediment supply is cut, saltwater intrudes.
- Intense rainfall: more landslides and debris flows, higher flood peaks.
How strongly a landscape responds depends on its sensitivity, the thresholds it is close to and its relaxation time, the concepts of process geomorphology. Hazard aspects are treated on Natural Hazards.
Extra-terrestrial (Planetary) Geomorphology
Why it matters and how it is done
Planetary geomorphology applies the methods of terrestrial geomorphology to other solid bodies. With few samples and no direct observation of most processes, it relies on:
- Orbital imaging and altimetry (laser altimeters such as MOLA on Mars and LOLA on the Moon; stereo imagery) to build DEMs; the DEM methods on Submarine Relief and DEM-Based Analysis transfer directly.
- Terrestrial analogues: the Channeled Scablands of Washington, cut by Pleistocene megafloods, for Martian outflow channels; Antarctic Dry Valleys and Ladakh for cold, dry Mars-like conditions; Lonar crater in Maharashtra, a young impact crater about 1.8 km across in Deccan basalt, for craters in basaltic crust on the Moon and Mars.
- Scaling of processes for different gravity, atmospheric density and temperature.
- Crater counting for relative and model ages.
Impact craters
Cratering is the dominant process on airless bodies and an important one on all solid surfaces.
| Morphology | Features |
|---|---|
| Simple crater | bowl-shaped; depth about one-fifth of diameter; raised rim; ejecta blanket; breccia lens on the floor |
| Complex crater | central peak (or peak ring) from rebound of the floor, terraced walls from rim collapse, flat floor; shallower relative to diameter |
| Multi-ring basin | several concentric rings, hundreds of kilometres across (Orientale on the Moon) |
The simple-to-complex transition diameter varies roughly inversely with surface gravity: about 2–4 km on Earth (lower in sedimentary targets), about 15–20 km on the Moon, and in between (several kilometres) on Mars. Other impact features: rays of bright ejecta (a sign of youth, since they fade with space weathering), secondary craters from blocks of ejecta, and on Mars rampart (layered-ejecta) craters whose fluidised ejecta suggest ground ice or water in the target.
Crater counting and relative age
A surface accumulates craters with time, so crater density (number per unit area above a size) measures relative age: more craters, older surface. The crater size–frequency distribution is often roughly a power law, \( N(\geq D) \propto D^{-b} \), with \( b \) commonly near 2. Calibrated against radiometric ages of Apollo and Luna samples, lunar crater densities give model ages, which are transferred to Mars and Mercury with assumptions about relative impact rates. Complications: secondary craters, saturation (old surfaces where new craters destroy old ones at the same rate), and resurfacing by lava or sediment.
Relative stratigraphy also uses superposition and cross-cutting as on Earth. Lunar periods: pre-Nectarian, Nectarian, Imbrian, Eratosthenian, Copernican. Martian periods: Noachian (heavily cratered, valley networks, wetter), Hesperian (volcanism, outflow channels), Amazonian (cold, dry, wind and ice dominated).
Landforms body by body
| Body | Main agents | Signature landforms |
|---|---|---|
| Moon | impacts; ancient basaltic volcanism; mass wasting; space weathering | heavily cratered anorthositic highlands; dark, smoother basaltic maria filling large basins; sinuous rilles (lava channels and collapsed lava tubes); a fragmental regolith |
| Mercury | impacts; volcanism; global contraction | craters and smooth plains; lobate scarps (thrust faults from planetary cooling and shrinking) |
| Venus | volcanism and tectonics under a thick, hot atmosphere; little erosion | relatively few craters (a young surface overall); tesserae (intensely deformed highlands), coronae (circular volcano-tectonic features), vast lava plains |
| Mars | wind, past water, ground ice and glaciers, volcanism, impacts | Tharsis volcanoes and Olympus Mons (a shield volcano over 20 km high); Valles Marineris (a canyon system about 4,000 km long); outflow channels (catastrophic floods); valley networks (Noachian); fan-deltas (Jezero); gullies; polar layered deposits and caps of water ice with seasonal CO\(_2\) frost; dunes, yardangs, dust devil tracks; lobate debris aprons (ice-rich) |
| Titan | methane–ethane hydrological cycle; wind | hydrocarbon lakes and seas, river channels, extensive linear dunes |
| Io | tidal heating | the most volcanically active body known; lava lakes, plumes; no impact craters preserved |
| Europa | ice-shell tectonics | double ridges, chaos terrain; few craters (young surface) |
How gravity and atmosphere change processes
- Lower gravity lets volcanoes grow taller and impact craters stay simple to larger sizes; it lengthens ballistic ranges of ejecta.
- Thin atmosphere (Mars, surface density of order 0.02 kg m\(^{-3}\), about 1/60 of Earth’s) raises the wind speed needed to move sand. From Bagnold’s threshold \( u_{*t} \propto \sqrt{(\rho_s/\rho_a)\,g\,D} \), the Mars-to-Earth ratio for the same grain is \( \sqrt{(\rho_E/\rho_M)(g_M/g_E)} \approx \sqrt{60 \times 0.378} \approx 4.8 \). Martian sand moves only in strong gusts, yet dunes and ripples on Mars are observed to migrate.
- Low pressure and temperature make liquid water unstable at most of the Martian surface today; water ice sublimates rather than melts, and CO\(_2\) frost drives seasonal processes.
- No atmosphere (Moon, Mercury): no wind or water; erosion is by impacts (from large to micrometeorite scale), space weathering and downslope movement.
India’s planetary missions in brief
ISRO’s Chandrayaan-1 (launched 2008) carried NASA’s Moon Mineralogy Mapper, which detected hydroxyl and water signatures on the lunar surface. The Mars Orbiter Mission (launched 2013, in Mars orbit from 2014) imaged the planet from an elliptical orbit. Chandrayaan-3 landed near the lunar south pole in August 2023, giving in situ measurements of the near-surface regolith.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Relict landform: made under past conditions, no longer active | Active landform: shaped by present processes | |
| Exposure age (no erosion) \( t = N/P \) | Steady-state erosion rate \( \varepsilon = P\Lambda/(\rho N) \) | |
| GLOF: lake water released by dam failure (Kedarnath 2013 in part; South Lhonak 2023) | Rock–ice avalanche turning into a debris flow (Chamoli 2021) | |
| Bhangar: older, higher alluvium | Khadar: younger floodplain alluvium | |
| Simple crater: bowl | Complex crater: central peak, terraces, flat floor | |
| Outflow channels (Mars): catastrophic floods, mostly Hesperian | Valley networks (Mars): branching, mostly Noachian, sustained flow | |
| Lunar highlands: anorthosite, many craters, old | Lunar maria: basalt, fewer craters, younger | |
| Lobate scarps (Mercury): thrusts from contraction | Sinuous rilles (Moon): lava channels and tubes |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- About how far below present was sea level at the last glacial maximum?
- What is the term for a landform produced under past conditions that no longer operate?
- Which feature of a complex crater is absent in a simple crater?
Answers
- About 120 m.
- A relict landform.
- A central peak (and terraced walls, a flat floor).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A continental shelf has a uniform gradient of 1:1,000. A sea-level fall of 120 m would move the shoreline seaward by about:
(a) 1.2 km (b) 12 km (c) 120 km (d) 1,200 km
Answer: (c) 120 km
Horizontal distance = vertical / gradient = \( 120 \times 1000 = 120{,}000 \) m = 120 km. This is why glacial lowstands exposed wide shelves and joined islands to continents.
Practice Q2. A boulder surface with no erosion has \( N = 1.2\times10^5 \) atoms g\(^{-1}\) of \(^{10}\)Be and a production rate of 6 atoms g\(^{-1}\) yr\(^{-1}\). Its exposure age is:
(a) 2 kyr (b) 7.2 kyr (c) 20 kyr (d) 720 kyr
Answer: (c) 20 kyr
\( t = N/P = 1.2\times10^5/6 = 2\times10^4 \) yr. (d) multiplies instead of dividing; (a) slips a power of ten. At 20 kyr, \(^{10}\)Be decay (half-life of order a million years) is negligible.
Practice Q3. Surface A has 200 craters ≥ 1 km on 50,000 km\(^2\); surface B has 30 craters ≥ 1 km on 10,000 km\(^2\). Which is correct?
(a) A is younger because it has more craters in total (b) A is older; its crater density is higher (c) Both have the same age (d) B is older; its area is smaller
Answer: (b)
Densities: A = 200/50,000 = 4.0 per 1,000 km\(^2\) (4,000 per 10\(^6\) km\(^2\)); B = 30/10,000 = 3.0 per 1,000 km\(^2\). Compare densities, not totals: A has the higher density and is older.
Practice Q4. Which Martian landforms are mainly attributed to brief, catastrophic floods?
(a) valley networks (b) outflow channels (c) polar layered deposits (d) lobate scarps
Answer: (b) outflow channels
Outflow channels are huge channels starting full-size at chaotic terrain, comparable with the Channeled Scablands megaflood landscape. Valley networks are branching and point to longer-lived runoff; polar layered deposits are ice and dust; lobate scarps are thrust faults (typical of Mercury).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. River sand from a Himalayan catchment has \( N = 2\times10^4 \) atoms g\(^{-1}\) of \(^{10}\)Be. Take a catchment-mean \( P = 20 \) atoms g\(^{-1}\) yr\(^{-1}\), \( \Lambda = 160 \) g cm\(^{-2}\), \( \rho = 2.65 \) g cm\(^{-3}\). Which statements are correct?
- The catchment-averaged erosion rate is about 0.6 mm yr\(^{-1}\).
- The rate is averaged over roughly 1,000 years.
- A higher \(^{10}\)Be concentration would imply faster erosion.
- Landslides delivering deep, low-\(^{10}\)Be material would bias the estimate toward faster erosion.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- 1 true: \( \varepsilon = 20 \times 160/(2.65 \times 2\times10^4) = 3200/53{,}000 = 0.0604 \) cm yr\(^{-1}\) = 0.60 mm yr\(^{-1}\) (600 m Myr\(^{-1}\)), plausible for the Himalaya.
- 2 true: \( \Lambda/(\rho\varepsilon) = 160/(2.65 \times 0.0604) = 1{,}000 \) yr (also \( N/P \)).
- 3 false: \( \varepsilon \propto 1/N \): higher concentration means slower erosion (longer residence near the surface).
- 4 true: deep landslide debris carries little \(^{10}\)Be and dilutes the sample, lowering \( N \) and raising the calculated rate.
Practice Q6. Take Earth: \( g = 9.81 \) m s\(^{-2}\), surface air density 1.2 kg m\(^{-3}\); Mars: \( g = 3.71 \) m s\(^{-2}\), surface air density 0.020 kg m\(^{-3}\). Using \( u_{*t} \propto \sqrt{(\rho_s/\rho_a)gD} \) for the same grains, which statements are correct?
- The threshold friction velocity on Mars is about 4.8 times Earth’s.
- The lower gravity on Mars, taken alone, would lower the threshold.
- If Earth’s threshold for this sand is 0.23 m s\(^{-1}\), Mars’s is about 1.1 m s\(^{-1}\).
- The thin atmosphere alone raises the threshold by a factor of 60.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 true: \( \sqrt{(1.2/0.020)(3.71/9.81)} = \sqrt{60 \times 0.378} = \sqrt{22.7} = 4.76 \).
- 2 true: \( u_{*t} \propto \sqrt g \), and \( g \) is lower on Mars.
- 3 true: \( 0.23 \times 4.76 = 1.09 \) m s\(^{-1}\).
- 4 false: density enters under the square root: the atmosphere alone raises it by \( \sqrt{60} = 7.7 \).
Practice Q7. A glacier snout in a Himalayan valley retreated 600 m between 1990 and 2020, and a proglacial lake formed behind the 1990 terminal moraine. Which statements are correct?
- The mean retreat rate is 20 m yr\(^{-1}\).
- Retreat means that the ice has stopped flowing.
- The moraine-dammed lake is a potential GLOF source, especially if the moraine has an ice core.
- If the climate stabilised, the glacier would adjust to a new length only after a delay set by its response time.
(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
- 1 true: 600 m/30 yr = 20 m yr\(^{-1}\).
- 2 false: ice keeps flowing forward; retreat means snout ablation exceeds supply.
- 3 true: moraine dams are weak, and melting buried ice lowers them further.
- 4 true: glaciers, like other systems, have reaction and relaxation times; their length lags climate.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Orbital cycles | about 100, 41 and 23 kyr |
| LGM | roughly 26–19 ka; sea level about −120 m; deserts and loess expanded; monsoon weaker |
| Post-glacial | transgression drowned valleys; early Holocene monsoon stronger, later drying |
| Relict / inherited / active | past and inactive / past but still influencing / forming now |
| Ganga plains | bhangar (older, higher) vs khadar (younger floodplain) |
| Dating | radiocarbon, OSL, cosmogenic, U-series |
| Cosmogenic | \( t = N/P \); \( \varepsilon = P\Lambda/\rho N \); \( \Lambda \approx 160 \) g cm\(^{-2}\); averaging time \( \Lambda/\rho\varepsilon \) |
| Anthropocene | informal (2024 proposal for an epoch rejected); dams, mining, urbanisation, deforestation, coastal works |
| Warming responses | glacier retreat, GLOFs (Kedarnath 2013 in part, South Lhonak 2023), rock–ice avalanches (Chamoli 2021), permafrost thaw, sea-level rise (about 0.2 m, 1901–2018) |
| Planetary methods | orbital DEMs (MOLA, LOLA), analogues (Scablands, Ladakh, Lonar), crater counting |
| Craters | simple (bowl, d/D about 1/5) vs complex (central peak, terraces); transition ∝ 1/g: Earth 2–4 km, Moon 15–20 km |
| Crater ages | density ∝ age; \( N(\geq D) \propto D^{-b} \), b about 2; secondaries, saturation |
| Lunar periods | pre-Nectarian, Nectarian, Imbrian, Eratosthenian, Copernican |
| Mars periods | Noachian, Hesperian, Amazonian |
| Mars | Olympus Mons, Tharsis, Valles Marineris, outflow channels, valley networks, Jezero delta, polar deposits, dunes |
| Other bodies | Mercury lobate scarps; Venus tesserae, coronae; Titan lakes and dunes; Io volcanism; Europa chaos |
| Mars wind threshold | about 4.8 times Earth’s |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Geomorphology: Quick Revision: the whole unit on one page.
- Return to the chapter overview for the syllabus map.
- For the timing of Quaternary events, continue with Quaternary Stratigraphy.