Geoid; Free-Air, Bouguer and Isostatic Anomalies
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C Geophysics: geoid, Bruns formula, gravity reductions, free-air, Bouguer and isostatic anomalies, Airy, Pratt and flexure.
- 21 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Normal Gravity, Clairaut’s Theorem and the Shape of the Earth: the reference ellipsoid and the normal gravity formula that every anomaly is measured against.
- The Part B summary of anomalies and isostasy in Gravity, Geomagnetism, Heat Flow and Isostasy.
- The gravity of a slab and Laplace’s equation from Newtonian Potential, Laplace and Poisson Equations.
The Hook: Sailing Downhill Without Noticing
The Geoid
Definition
The geoid is the equipotential surface of Earth’s gravity field (gravitational plus centrifugal) that coincides with mean sea level over the open oceans, extended under the continents. Its potential \( W_0 \) is a single constant.
- The geoid is a level surface: gravity is perpendicular to it everywhere, so it is the surface that a spirit level and a plumb line actually reference.
- It is smooth but irregular, because it follows the real (lumpy) mass distribution.
- The departure of the geoid from the reference ellipsoid is the geoid undulation or geoid height \( N \). Globally it lies within roughly \( \pm 100 \) m.
Heights
$$\boxed{h = H + N}$$| Height | Measured from | Obtained by |
|---|---|---|
| Ellipsoidal \( h \) | reference ellipsoid | GPS / GNSS |
| Orthometric \( H \) | geoid (mean sea level) | spirit levelling with gravity corrections |
| Geoid undulation \( N \) | ellipsoid to geoid | gravity data, satellite models |
The disturbing potential and Bruns’ formula
Let \( W \) be the real geopotential and \( U \) the normal potential of the level ellipsoid, chosen so that \( U_0 = W_0 \). The disturbing (anomalous) potential is
$$T = W - U$$At a point on the geoid, \( W = W_0 \). Moving from the ellipsoid up to the geoid by \( N \) changes \( U \) by \( -\gamma N \) (normal gravity times height, in the positive-potential convention used in geodesy). Setting the total to \( W_0 \) gives Bruns’ formula:
$$\boxed{N = \frac{T}{\gamma}}$$A disturbing potential of 98.1 m\(^2\) s\(^{-2}\) corresponds to a 10 m geoid undulation.
Gravity anomaly and the geoid
Two different “anomalies” exist and are easily confused:
| Quantity | Definition |
|---|---|
| Gravity anomaly \( \Delta g \) | \( g_P \) on the geoid minus \( \gamma_Q \) on the ellipsoid (points along the same normal) |
| Gravity disturbance \( \delta g \) | \( g_P - \gamma_P \) at the same point |
They are linked to \( T \) by the fundamental equation of physical geodesy (spherical approximation):
$$\Delta g = -\frac{\partial T}{\partial r} - \frac{2}{r}T$$Solving it for \( T \) on a sphere, given \( \Delta g \) everywhere, gives Stokes’ integral:
$$N = \frac{R}{4\pi\gamma}\iint_\sigma \Delta g\,S(\psi)\,d\sigma$$where \( S(\psi) \) is Stokes’ function of the angular distance \( \psi \). Three consequences matter for the exam:
- Stokes’ integral needs gravity anomalies over the whole Earth: a geoid at one place depends on gravity far away.
- It assumes no masses outside the geoid, which is why topography must be removed or moved (the reductions below) before the integral is used.
- The geoid is a smoothed, integrated picture of mass: short-wavelength features are suppressed relative to gravity anomalies. Geoid emphasises long wavelengths and deep sources; gravity anomalies emphasise short wavelengths and shallow sources.
Deflection of the vertical
The slope of the geoid relative to the ellipsoid is the deflection of the vertical \( \varepsilon \): the angle between the plumb line and the ellipsoid normal. If \( N \) changes by \( \Delta N \) over a horizontal distance \( \Delta x \),
$$\varepsilon \approx -\frac{\Delta N}{\Delta x}\ \ \text{(radians)}$$A 3 m change over 50 km is \( 6\times 10^{-5} \) rad \( \approx 12.4'' \). The sign convention varies between texts; what matters is that the plumb line tilts towards excess mass.
What makes geoid highs and lows
| Feature | Geoid |
|---|---|
| Local mass excess (seamount, dense body) | high (the level surface bulges outward over extra mass) |
| Local mass deficit (sedimentary basin, trench) | low |
| Broad, locally compensated topography | small high, set by the dipole moment of the density column (below) |
| Deep, long-wavelength mantle structure | dominates the largest undulations |
The largest geoid undulations do not correlate with continents and oceans; this itself shows that topography is largely compensated. The long-wavelength geoid correlates instead with deep mantle structure: highs over regions of past subduction and over the large low-velocity provinces, and the strongest low, the Indian Ocean Geoid Low south of the Indian peninsula. Satellite missions measure it: altimetry over the oceans (the mean sea surface is the geoid plus a dynamic topography of about a metre), and gravity missions such as GRACE, GRACE-FO and GOCE.
Geoid anomaly of a compensated column
For local compensation and long wavelengths, the geoid anomaly is proportional to the first moment (the dipole moment) of the density anomaly with depth \( z \) (positive downward from sea level):
$$\boxed{\Delta N = -\frac{2\pi G}{g}\int_{-h}^{D}\Delta\rho(z)\,z\,dz}$$Mass balance makes the zeroth moment vanish (\( \int\Delta\rho\,dz = 0 \)), so a compensated column has no long-wavelength gravity anomaly, yet it still has a geoid anomaly because the excess mass (topography) is shallower than the deficit (root). For an Airy column of elevation \( h \), reference crustal thickness \( H_c \) and root \( r = \rho_c h/(\rho_m - \rho_c) \), evaluating the integral gives
$$\Delta N = \frac{\pi G\rho_c h}{g}\left(2H_c + \frac{\rho_m}{\rho_m - \rho_c}\,h\right)$$With \( \rho_c = 2{,}800 \), \( \rho_m = 3{,}300 \) kg m\(^{-3}\), \( H_c = 35 \) km, a 1 km plateau gives a geoid high of about 4.6 m; 2 km gives about 10 m. Compensated highlands sit on modest geoid highs even though their free-air anomaly is near zero.
Gravity Reductions
Observed gravity \( g_{obs} \) is measured on the topography. To compare it with normal gravity on the ellipsoid, a sequence of corrections is applied.
| Step | Correction | Size and sign (station above datum) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Instrument drift | from repeated base-station readings |
| 2 | Earth tide | up to about 0.3 mGal, computed from Sun and Moon positions |
| 3 | Latitude (normal gravity) | subtract \( \gamma(\phi) \), or use 0.814 \( \sin 2\phi \) mGal km\(^{-1}\) locally |
| 4 | Free-air | +0.3086 \( h \) mGal (\( h \) in metres) |
| 5 | Bouguer (slab) | −0.04193 \( \rho h \) mGal (\( \rho \) in g cm\(^{-3}\)); −0.1119 \( h \) for 2.67 |
| 6 | Terrain | always + (both hills above and valleys below the station reduce the measured value relative to a flat slab) |
| 7 | Eötvös (moving platform) | \( 7.503\,V\cos\phi\sin\alpha + 0.004154\,V^2 \) mGal, \( V \) in knots, \( \alpha \) heading from north |
Notes:
- The free-air correction accounts only for the station’s greater distance from Earth’s centre, treating the space between station and datum as empty (“free air”). 0.3086 mGal m\(^{-1}\) is the normal vertical gradient \( 2\gamma/R \).
- The Bouguer correction removes the attraction of an infinite horizontal slab of thickness \( h \) and density \( \rho \): \( 2\pi G\rho h \). \( 2\pi G = 0.04193 \) mGal m\(^{-1}\) per g cm\(^{-3}\).
- The Bullard scheme refines it: Bullard A is the flat slab, Bullard B converts the slab to a spherical cap of radius 166.7 km, Bullard C is the terrain correction.
- At sea, the Bouguer correction replaces water by rock: \( +2\pi G(\rho_c - \rho_w)d \) for water depth \( d \). For \( \rho_c = 2.67 \), \( \rho_w = 1.03 \) g cm\(^{-3}\) and 4 km of water, that is \( 0.04193\times 1.64\times 4000 \approx +275 \) mGal.
- A gravimeter on a ship moving east measures less gravity (it is moving with Earth’s rotation and has greater centrifugal acceleration), so the Eötvös correction for eastward motion is positive.
The anomalies
$$\boxed{\Delta g_{FA} = g_{obs} - \gamma + 0.3086\,h}$$$$\boxed{\Delta g_{B} = \Delta g_{FA} - 0.04193\,\rho\,h\ (+\ \text{terrain correction})}$$$$\boxed{\Delta g_{I} = \Delta g_{B} - \Delta g_{\text{root}}}$$where \( \Delta g_{\text{root}} \) is the computed attraction of the compensating masses in a chosen isostatic model (negative under mountains, positive under oceans). The simple Bouguer anomaly omits the terrain correction; the complete Bouguer anomaly includes it.
Choosing the Bouguer density
- Nettleton’s profile method: compute Bouguer anomalies along a profile across a topographic feature for several trial densities; the right density is the one whose anomaly correlates least with topography.
- Parasnis’ regression: over a small area with a uniform regional field, \( \Delta g_{FA} \approx 0.04193\,\rho h + \text{constant} \), so the slope of free-air anomaly against elevation gives \( \rho \).
- The standard 2.67 g cm\(^{-3}\) is a conventional average for upper continental crust, not a measured value for any particular area.
Reading the Anomalies
The key result for compensated topography
Take broad topography of height \( h \) in local isostatic equilibrium (any model: Airy, Pratt or a mix). Mass balance says the excess mass per unit area above sea level equals the mass deficit below. For a broad feature both act like infinite slabs:
- free-air anomaly: slab of topography \( (+2\pi G\rho_c h) \) plus slab of deficit \( (-2\pi G\rho_c h) \) gives \( \Delta g_{FA} \approx 0 \);
- Bouguer anomaly: the topography slab has been removed, leaving only the deficit, so \( \Delta g_B \approx -2\pi G\rho_c h \approx -0.112\,h \) mGal (for 2.67).
So a fully compensated plateau 3 km high has a Bouguer anomaly near −335 mGal and a free-air anomaly near zero away from its edges. If the same plateau were uncompensated (held up entirely by plate strength), \( \Delta g_{FA} \approx +0.112\,h \approx +335 \) mGal and \( \Delta g_B \approx 0 \).
Typical settings
| Setting | Free-air | Bouguer | Isostatic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Broad compensated mountain belt or plateau | ≈ 0 in the interior; positive–negative pair at edges | strongly negative | ≈ 0 |
| Compensated ocean basin | ≈ 0 | strongly positive | ≈ 0 |
| Uncompensated load (young seamount on strong plate) | positive | ≈ 0 over the load | positive |
| Ocean trench | strongly negative | — | negative (held down dynamically) |
| Outer rise seaward of trench | small positive | — | positive |
| Area of post-glacial rebound (Fennoscandia, Hudson Bay) | negative | — | negative (root still too big; rising) |
| Dense intrusion, ophiolite slab | positive | positive | positive |
| Sedimentary basin, salt dome, granite pluton | negative | negative | negative |
The edge effect arises because near the margin of a plateau the shallow topographic excess and the deep root deficit are at different distances: on the high side the topography wins (positive free-air anomaly), on the low side the root wins (negative).
Isostasy
Isostasy: below a depth of compensation, the pressure due to overlying material is the same everywhere. The lithosphere floats on a weak asthenosphere.
Airy (constant density, variable thickness)
$$\boxed{r = \frac{\rho_c}{\rho_m - \rho_c}\,h} \qquad \boxed{r' = \frac{\rho_c - \rho_w}{\rho_m - \rho_c}\,d}$$\( r \) is the root below a mountain of height \( h \); \( r' \) is the anti-root (crustal thinning) below water depth \( d \). For \( \rho_c = 2.7 \), \( \rho_m = 3.3 \) g cm\(^{-3}\): \( r = 4.5h \).
Pratt (variable density, constant depth of compensation \( D \) below sea level)
$$\boxed{\rho_h(D + h) = \rho_0 D} \qquad \boxed{\rho_d(D - d) + \rho_w d = \rho_0 D}$$High regions are underlain by lower-density columns; oceans by denser columns.
Vening Meinesz: regional (flexural) compensation
The lithosphere is an elastic plate of flexural rigidity
$$D_f = \frac{E\,T_e^3}{12(1 - \nu^2)}$$where \( E \) is Young’s modulus, \( \nu \) Poisson’s ratio and \( T_e \) the effective elastic thickness. A load is supported over a width set by the flexural parameter
$$\alpha = \left[\frac{4D_f}{(\rho_m - \rho_{\text{infill}})\,g}\right]^{1/4}$$For a line load on a continuous plate, the deflection is \( w = w_0 e^{-x/\alpha}(\cos x/\alpha + \sin x/\alpha) \): the moat passes through zero at \( x = 3\pi\alpha/4 \) and the flexural bulge peaks at \( x = \pi\alpha \). For oceanic lithosphere with \( E = 70 \) GPa, \( \nu = 0.25 \), \( T_e = 25 \) km and water infill, \( \alpha \approx 64 \) km and the bulge is about 200 km from the load.
| Model | What varies | Compensation | Typical example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Airy | crustal thickness | local | thick crust under Himalaya–Tibet |
| Pratt | density | local | thermal elevation of mid-ocean ridges |
| Vening Meinesz | plate deflection | regional | Hawaiian moat and arch; foreland basins such as the Ganga basin in front of the Himalaya |
As \( T_e \to 0 \) flexural compensation becomes Airy; as \( T_e \to \infty \) the load is uncompensated.
The isostatic anomaly and its sign
Compute the gravity effect of the compensating root (or density deficit) predicted by a model, and subtract it from the Bouguer anomaly.
| Isostatic anomaly | Meaning | Expected motion if the plate is free to adjust |
|---|---|---|
| ≈ 0 | compensated as the model predicts | none |
| positive | undercompensated: root smaller than needed (mass excess) | subsidence |
| negative | overcompensated: root larger than needed (mass deficit), or a load recently removed | uplift |
A zero isostatic anomaly confirms only that the chosen model fits; Airy and Pratt can both give near-zero isostatic anomalies over the same broad feature because the long-wavelength gravity sees mainly the total mass, not how it is arranged.
Glacial isostatic adjustment
When an ice sheet melts, the depressed lithosphere rebounds, but slowly, because the mantle is viscous. While it is still too low, the region has a negative free-air anomaly. The slab formula estimates the remaining uplift:
$$w \approx \frac{\Delta g_{FA}}{2\pi G\rho_m}$$If the remaining uplift decays exponentially, \( dw/dt = -w/\tau \), so the observed uplift rate and \( w \) give a relaxation time \( \tau \), and from it a mantle viscosity of order \( 10^{21} \) Pa s.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Gravity anomaly: \( g \) on geoid minus \( \gamma \) on ellipsoid | Gravity disturbance: \( g - \gamma \) at the same point | |
| Geoid undulation \( N \) (metres) | Gravity anomaly \( \Delta g \) (mGal) | |
| Simple Bouguer anomaly (slab only) | Complete Bouguer anomaly (slab + terrain) | |
| Positive isostatic anomaly: undercompensated | Negative isostatic anomaly: overcompensated / still rebounding | |
| Local compensation (Airy, Pratt) | Regional compensation (flexure, \( T_e \)) | |
| Airy root \( r = \rho_c h/(\rho_m - \rho_c) \) | Total crustal thickening \( h + r \) | |
| Bouguer correction on land (subtract rock) | Bouguer correction at sea (add rock in place of water) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Use \( 2\pi G = 0.04193 \) mGal m\(^{-1}\) per g cm\(^{-3}\) and a free-air gradient of 0.3086 mGal m\(^{-1}\).
Level 1: Foundation
- State Bruns’ formula.
- Which anomaly is close to zero over a broad, fully compensated plateau?
- What does a positive isostatic anomaly indicate?
Answers
- \( N = T/\gamma \): geoid undulation equals disturbing potential divided by normal gravity.
- The free-air anomaly (away from the edges); the Bouguer anomaly is strongly negative.
- Undercompensation: less compensating mass deficit than the model needs, so there is excess mass and a tendency to subside.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Using the data of the worked example but with a Bouguer density of 2.20 g cm\(^{-3}\) (a sedimentary terrain), the simple Bouguer anomaly is closest to:
(a) +17.8 mGal (b) +34.6 mGal (c) +191.4 mGal (d) +78.4 mGal
Answer: (b) +34.6 mGal
\( \Delta g_{FA} = +112.99 \) mGal as before.
Bouguer correction \( = 0.04193\times 2.20\times 850 = 78.41 \) mGal.
\( \Delta g_B = 112.99 - 78.41 = +34.58 \) mGal.
A lower assumed density removes less mass, so the Bouguer anomaly is larger. (d) is the correction itself; (c) adds it instead of subtracting.
Practice Q2. A broad plateau 4 km high is in Airy equilibrium with \( \rho_c = 2.7 \) and \( \rho_m = 3.3 \) g cm\(^{-3}\). Its root extends below the normal crust by:
(a) 4.5 km (b) 14.9 km (c) 18.0 km (d) 22.0 km
Answer: (c) 18.0 km
\( r = \frac{2.7}{3.3 - 2.7}\times 4 = 4.5\times 4 = 18.0 \) km. (d) is the total extra crustal thickness \( h + r \).
Practice Q3. At a point the disturbing potential is \( T = 98.1 \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-2}\) and normal gravity is 9.81 m s\(^{-2}\). The geoid lies:
(a) 10 m above the ellipsoid (b) 10 m below the ellipsoid (c) 1 m above the ellipsoid (d) 962 m above the ellipsoid
Answer: (a) 10 m above the ellipsoid
\( N = T/\gamma = 98.1/9.81 = 10.0 \) m, positive (geoid above the ellipsoid) for positive \( T \) in the geodetic convention.
Practice Q4. A marine gravity station has 4,000 m of water beneath it. With crustal density 2.67 and seawater 1.03 g cm\(^{-3}\), the Bouguer correction is:
(a) −275 mGal (b) +275 mGal (c) +448 mGal (d) +173 mGal
Answer: (b) +275 mGal
\( 0.04193\times(2.67 - 1.03)\times 4000 = 0.04193\times 1.64\times 4000 = 275.1 \) mGal, added because rock replaces the lighter water. (c) uses 2.67 alone; (d) uses 1.03 alone.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. In a small area with a uniform regional field, free-air anomalies at four stations are:
| Station | Elevation \( h \) (m) | \( \Delta g_{FA} \) (mGal) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 100 | 15.48 |
| 2 | 250 | 31.21 |
| 3 | 400 | 46.93 |
| 4 | 550 | 62.65 |
Using Parasnis’ method, the near-surface density is closest to:
(a) 2.20 g cm\(^{-3}\) (b) 2.50 g cm\(^{-3}\) (c) 2.67 g cm\(^{-3}\) (d) 2.85 g cm\(^{-3}\)
Answer: (b) 2.50 g cm^-3
\( \Delta g_{FA} = 2\pi G\rho h + C \). The slope between stations 1 and 4 is \( (62.65 - 15.48)/(550 - 100) = 47.17/450 = 0.10482 \) mGal m\(^{-1}\) (a least-squares fit gives the same value, since the points are collinear).
\( \rho = 0.10482/0.04193 = 2.50 \) g cm\(^{-3}\). The intercept, about +5.0 mGal, is the regional Bouguer level.
Using 2.67 here would over-correct and leave a Bouguer anomaly that is negatively correlated with topography.
Practice Q6. A broad plateau 2,000 m high has an observed Bouguer anomaly of −180 mGal over its centre. An Airy model with \( \rho_c = 2.67 \) and \( \rho_m = 3.27 \) g cm\(^{-3}\) is used to compute the isostatic anomaly, treating the root as an infinite slab. Which statements are correct?
- The Airy root is 8.9 km thick.
- The computed attraction of the root is about −224 mGal.
- The isostatic anomaly is about +44 mGal.
- The plateau is overcompensated and would be expected to rise.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2 and 4 only (d) 3 and 4 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 true: \( r = \frac{2.67}{0.60}\times 2000 = 8{,}900 \) m.
- 2 true: \( \Delta g_{\text{root}} = -0.04193\times 0.60\times 8900 = -223.9 \) mGal. (This equals \( -0.04193\times 2.67\times 2000 \), as it must for full compensation.)
- 3 true: \( \Delta g_I = -180 - (-223.9) = +43.9 \) mGal.
- 4 false: a positive isostatic anomaly means the observed deficit is smaller than full compensation requires: the plateau is undercompensated (partly supported by plate strength or dynamic forces) and would tend to subside if left to adjust.
Practice Q7. A formerly glaciated region shows a broad free-air anomaly of −20 mGal and is rising at 9 mm per year. Take mantle density 3.3 g cm\(^{-3}\) and assume exponential relaxation. Which pair is closest to the remaining uplift and the relaxation time?
(a) 65 m, 7,200 yr (b) 145 m, 16,000 yr (c) 145 m, 1,600 yr (d) 477 m, 53,000 yr
Answer: (b) 145 m, 16,000 yr
Remaining uplift: \( w = \frac{20}{0.04193\times 3.3} = \frac{20}{0.1384} = 144.5 \) m.
Exponential relaxation: \( dw/dt = -w/\tau \Rightarrow \tau = w/\lvert\dot w\rvert = 144.5/0.009 \approx 16{,}000 \) yr.
(a) divides by the free-air gradient (\( 20/0.3086 \)), which treats the anomaly as a height error with no mass involved; (c) slips a factor of ten in the rate (90 mm per year); (d) leaves out the density (\( 20/0.04193 \)). A relaxation time of this order, with the region’s size, is how post-glacial rebound gives mantle viscosity near \( 10^{21} \) Pa s.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Geoid | equipotential surface at mean sea level; \( N \) within about \( \pm 100 \) m |
| Heights | \( h = H + N \) |
| Bruns | \( N = T/\gamma \) |
| Fundamental equation | \( \Delta g = -\partial T/\partial r - 2T/r \) |
| Stokes | \( N = \frac{R}{4\pi\gamma}\iint\Delta g\,S(\psi)\,d\sigma \): needs global data, no masses outside geoid |
| Deflection of vertical | geoid slope; 1 m per 17 km ≈ 12″ |
| Compensated column | geoid \( \Delta N = -(2\pi G/g)\int\Delta\rho\,z\,dz \): small high over plateaus |
| Free-air | \( +0.3086h \) mGal |
| Bouguer | \( -0.04193\rho h \) (0.1119 \( h \) for 2.67); at sea \( +0.04193(\rho_c - \rho_w)d \) |
| Terrain | always added on land |
| Eötvös | \( 7.503V\cos\phi\sin\alpha + 0.004154V^2 \) mGal (knots) |
| Compensated broad feature | \( \Delta g_{FA} \approx 0 \); \( \Delta g_B \approx -0.112h \) |
| Airy | \( r = \rho_c h/(\rho_m - \rho_c) \); \( r' = (\rho_c - \rho_w)d/(\rho_m - \rho_c) \) |
| Pratt | \( \rho_h(D + h) = \rho_0 D \) |
| Flexure | \( D_f = ET_e^3/12(1 - \nu^2) \); \( \alpha = [4D_f/\Delta\rho g]^{1/4} \); bulge at \( \pi\alpha \) |
| Isostatic anomaly | \( \Delta g_B - \Delta g_{\text{root}} \); + under-, − overcompensated |
| GIA | negative free-air; \( w \approx \Delta g/2\pi G\rho_m \); viscosity about \( 10^{21} \) Pa s |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- The Geomagnetic Field and Its Variations: the second potential field of the unit.
- Corrections and Regional–Residual Separation: the same reductions applied in exploration surveys, and how the regional field is removed.
- Stress, Mohr Circle, Failure and Reactivation: the strength of the lithosphere that decides between local and flexural compensation.
- Gravity and Magnetic Fields of the Earth: back to the chapter overview.