Mineral Structures, Polymorphism and Solid Solution
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C geology: oxide, sulphide and silicate structures and properties, polymorphism, polytypism, solid solution and exsolution.
- 20 min
On this page · 17 sections
Prerequisites
- The six silicate families and Mohs hardness at Part B level: Minerals and Rocks.
- Close packing, holes and radius ratios: Close Packing and Ionic Structures.
- Space groups and site symmetry: Crystal Symmetry, Reciprocal Lattice and Diffraction.
- Site preference of transition metals: Crystal Field Theory, Mineral Spectroscopy and Lattice Defects.
The Hook: Moonstone’s Blue Glow
How Mineral Structures Are Built
Most rock-forming minerals are ionic to partly covalent structures of oxygen anions with small cations in the holes between them. Pauling’s rules summarise the logic:
- Coordination is set by the radius ratio \( r_c/r_a \): about 0.225–0.414 for 4-fold (tetrahedral), 0.414–0.732 for 6-fold (octahedral), 0.732–1 for 8-fold (cubic).
- Electrostatic valence: the bond strengths from neighbouring cations to an anion sum to the anion’s charge.
- Shared edges and faces between polyhedra destabilise a structure, especially for highly charged cations; this is why SiO\(_4\) tetrahedra share only corners.
- Cations of high charge and low coordination tend not to share polyhedral elements with each other.
| Cation | Typical coordination by O | Sites |
|---|---|---|
| Si\(^{4+}\) | 4 (6 in stishovite and bridgmanite at high pressure) | T |
| Al\(^{3+}\) | 4 or 6 (5 in andalusite) | T or M |
| Mg\(^{2+}\), Fe\(^{2+}\), Fe\(^{3+}\), Ti\(^{4+}\), Cr\(^{3+}\) | 6 | M |
| Ca\(^{2+}\), Na\(^+\) | 6–8 | M2 of pyroxenes, X of garnet, feldspar cavities |
| K\(^+\) | 8–12 | interlayer of micas, feldspar cavities |
Oxides
| Mineral | Structure type | Anion packing and cation sites | Key properties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Periclase MgO | rock salt (Fm\( \bar{3} \)m) | ccp O; Mg in all octahedral holes | cubic; with wüstite forms ferropericlase of the lower mantle |
| Corundum Al\(_2\)O\(_3\) | corundum (R\( \bar{3} \)c) | hcp O; Al in two-thirds of octahedral holes | H 9; no cleavage, basal parting; ruby, sapphire |
| Hematite Fe\(_2\)O\(_3\) | corundum type | as corundum | red-brown streak; weakly magnetic (canted antiferromagnet) |
| Ilmenite FeTiO\(_3\) | ordered corundum derivative | Fe and Ti in alternate layers | black, weakly magnetic; solid solution with hematite at high T |
| Rutile TiO\(_2\) | rutile (P4\(_2\)/mnm) | TiO\(_6\) octahedra in edge-sharing chains along c | Ti 6-fold, O 3-fold; high refractive index; polymorphs anatase, brookite |
| Spinel MgAl\(_2\)O\(_4\) | spinel (Fd\( \bar{3} \)m) | ccp O; A in \( \tfrac18 \) of tetrahedral and B in \( \tfrac12 \) of octahedral holes; 8 formula units per cell | H 7.5–8; octahedral habit |
| Magnetite Fe\(_3\)O\(_4\) | inverse spinel | Fe\(^{3+}\)[Fe\(^{2+}\)Fe\(^{3+}\)]O\(_4\) | strongly magnetic (ferrimagnetic, Curie temperature about 580 °C); black streak |
| Chromite FeCr\(_2\)O\(_4\) | normal spinel | Fe\(^{2+}\) tetrahedral, Cr octahedral | brown streak; ore of Cr; in ultramafic rocks |
| Perovskite CaTiO\(_3\) | perovskite ABO\(_3\) | corner-sharing BO\(_6\) octahedra, large A in cavities | the structure of bridgmanite, the most abundant mineral in Earth |
Spinel nomenclature. In a normal spinel A\(^{2+}\)[B\(^{3+}_2\)]O\(_4\), divalent ions occupy tetrahedral sites. In an inverse spinel B\(^{3+}\)[A\(^{2+}\)B\(^{3+}\)]O\(_4\), half the trivalent ions take the tetrahedral sites. Magnetite, ulvöspinel–magnetite solid solutions (titanomagnetite) and magnesioferrite are largely inverse; spinel, chromite, hercynite and gahnite are largely normal.
Magnetism of Fe oxides underlies palaeomagnetism: in magnetite the tetrahedral and octahedral sublattices have antiparallel moments that do not cancel (ferrimagnetism). In hematite two equal sublattices are slightly canted, giving a weak net moment.
Sulphides
Sulphides are more covalent and metallic than oxides: many are opaque, with metallic lustre, high density and low hardness. They are the main ores of Cu, Pb, Zn, Ni, Mo and Hg.
| Mineral | Structure | Key properties |
|---|---|---|
| Galena PbS | rock salt | lead-grey; perfect cubic cleavage in three directions; H 2.5; very dense (about 7.5 g cm\(^{-3}\)) |
| Sphalerite ZnS | zinc blende: ccp S, Zn in half the tetrahedral holes (F\( \bar{4} \)3m) | resinous lustre; six directions of dodecahedral \( \{110\} \) cleavage; colour darkens with Fe |
| Wurtzite ZnS | hcp S, Zn tetrahedral (P6\(_3\)mc) | the hexagonal stacking variant of sphalerite |
| Pyrite FeS\(_2\) | rock-salt-like arrangement of Fe and S\(_2\) dumbbells (Pa\( \bar{3} \)) | brass-yellow; H 6–6.5 (hard for a sulphide); striated cubes and pyritohedra; no good cleavage |
| Marcasite FeS\(_2\) | orthorhombic | the polymorph of pyrite; paler, cockscomb habit; forms at low temperature |
| Chalcopyrite CuFeS\(_2\) | sphalerite derivative with ordered Cu and Fe; tetragonal | brass-yellow, greenish-black streak; H 3.5–4; the main Cu ore |
| Pyrrhotite Fe\(_{1-x}\)S | NiAs type: hcp S, Fe octahedral, with Fe vacancies | bronze; magnetic in Fe-poor monoclinic varieties because of vacancy ordering |
| Pentlandite (Fe,Ni)\(_9\)S\(_8\) | cubic | main Ni ore; exsolves from pyrrhotite in magmatic sulphide deposits |
| Molybdenite MoS\(_2\) | layers of Mo in trigonal-prismatic coordination | H 1–1.5; greasy feel; polytypes 2H and 3R |
| Cinnabar HgS | trigonal chains | scarlet; main Hg ore |
Silicates
Silicate structures are classified by how many oxygens of each SiO\(_4\) tetrahedron are shared with neighbouring tetrahedra.
| Class | Linkage | Shared O per tetrahedron | Si:O | Unit | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nesosilicate (orthosilicate) | isolated tetrahedra | 0 | 1:4 | SiO\(_4\) | olivine, garnet, zircon, Al\(_2\)SiO\(_5\) polymorphs |
| Sorosilicate | pairs | 1 | 2:7 | Si\(_2\)O\(_7\) | lawsonite; epidote (has both SiO\(_4\) and Si\(_2\)O\(_7\)) |
| Cyclosilicate | rings of 3, 4 or 6 | 2 | 1:3 | Si\(_6\)O\(_{18}\) | beryl, tourmaline, cordierite |
| Inosilicate, single chain | chains | 2 | 1:3 | SiO\(_3\) | pyroxenes; wollastonite (a pyroxenoid with a three-tetrahedron repeat) |
| Inosilicate, double chain | bands | 2 and 3 (average 2.5) | 4:11 | Si\(_4\)O\(_{11}\) | amphiboles |
| Phyllosilicate | sheets | 3 | 2:5 | Si\(_2\)O\(_5\) | micas, chlorite, clays, serpentine, talc |
| Tectosilicate | frameworks | 4 | 1:2 | SiO\(_2\) | quartz, feldspars, feldspathoids, zeolites |
As polymerisation increases, the remaining charge on the silicate unit falls, fewer other cations are needed, and minerals generally crystallise later from magmas (Bowen’s series), become less dense and weather more slowly.
Nesosilicates
- Olivine (Mg,Fe)\(_2\)SiO\(_4\): approximately hcp oxygen; Mg and Fe in two octahedral sites (M1, M2); complete solid solution forsterite–fayalite. Density rises from about 3.2 (Fo) to about 4.4 g cm\(^{-3}\) (Fa). Poor cleavage, conchoidal fracture, olive green. Forsterite melts at about 1,890 °C, fayalite at about 1,205 °C.
- Garnet X\(_3\)Y\(_2\)Si\(_3\)O\(_{12}\): X in 8-fold (dodecahedral) sites (Mg, Fe\(^{2+}\), Mn, Ca), Y octahedral (Al, Fe\(^{3+}\), Cr), Si tetrahedral. Pyralspite series (pyrope Mg, almandine Fe, spessartine Mn, all with Al) and ugrandite series (uvarovite Cr, grossular Al, andradite Fe\(^{3+}\), all with Ca). Isotropic, no cleavage, H 6.5–7.5.
- Al\(_2\)SiO\(_5\): kyanite (triclinic; all Al 6-fold; densest), andalusite (orthorhombic; Al 6 and 5-fold), sillimanite (orthorhombic; Al 6 and 4-fold). Kyanite’s hardness differs strongly with direction (about 4.5–5 along the length of blades, 6.5–7 across them).
- Zircon ZrSiO\(_4\): tetragonal; hosts U and Th, the main mineral of U–Pb geochronology; very resistant.
Inosilicates
Pyroxenes XYZ\(_2\)O\(_6\) (M2 M1 T\(_2\)O\(_6\)): single chains linked by M1 (smaller cations) and M2 (larger Ca, Na, or Fe and Mg in Ca-poor pyroxenes). Two cleavages at about 87° and 93°.
| Group | Members | Symmetry |
|---|---|---|
| Orthopyroxene | enstatite–ferrosilite | orthorhombic (Pbca) |
| Ca-poor clinopyroxene | pigeonite | monoclinic (P2\(_1\)/c) |
| Ca clinopyroxene | diopside–hedenbergite, augite | monoclinic (C2/c) |
| Na pyroxene | jadeite NaAlSi\(_2\)O\(_6\), aegirine NaFe\(^{3+}\)Si\(_2\)O\(_6\), omphacite (Ca–Na) | monoclinic |
Amphiboles A\(_{0-1}\)B\(_2\)C\(_5\)T\(_8\)O\(_{22}\)(OH)\(_2\): double chains; hydrous; two cleavages at about 56° and 124°. Tremolite–actinolite (greenschist facies), hornblende (amphibolite facies, calc-alkaline igneous rocks), glaucophane (blueschist facies), riebeckite (alkaline rocks).
Phyllosilicates
Built from a tetrahedral sheet (T) and an octahedral sheet (O). The octahedral sheet is dioctahedral if two of three sites are filled by trivalent cations (gibbsite-like, Al) or trioctahedral if all three are filled by divalent cations (brucite-like, Mg, Fe).
| Layer type | Structure | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| 1:1 (TO) | one T + one O | kaolinite (di), serpentine (tri) |
| 2:1 (TOT) | O between two T | talc (tri), pyrophyllite (di) |
| 2:1 + interlayer cation | TOT + K | muscovite (di), biotite and phlogopite (tri) |
| 2:1 + hydrated interlayer | TOT + exchangeable cations and water | smectite (montmorillonite; swelling), vermiculite |
| 2:1:1 | TOT + brucite-like sheet | chlorite |
One perfect basal cleavage \( \{001\} \) follows from the weak bonding between layers.
Tectosilicates
- Silica polymorphs: quartz, tridymite, cristobalite, coesite, stishovite (details under polymorphism below).
- Feldspars: Al replaces Si in the framework, and the charge is balanced by large cations in cavities. Alkali feldspars (K,Na)AlSi\(_3\)O\(_8\) and plagioclase NaAlSi\(_3\)O\(_8\)–CaAl\(_2\)Si\(_2\)O\(_8\). Two cleavages at or near 90°. Al–O–Al linkages are avoided (Loewenstein’s rule), which forces strict Al–Si alternation in anorthite.
- Feldspathoids (nepheline, leucite, sodalite): richer in Al and alkalis, poorer in Si; they replace feldspar in silica-undersaturated rocks and never coexist stably with quartz.
- Zeolites: open frameworks with channels holding water and exchangeable cations.
Polymorphism
Polymorphs have the same composition but different structures. Buerger’s classification by mechanism:
| Type | What changes | Kinetics | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reconstructive | primary bonds broken and remade; new topology | sluggish, needs large energy; high-temperature or high-pressure forms often survive metastably | graphite–diamond; quartz–coesite–stishovite; calcite–aragonite; kyanite–andalusite–sillimanite; pyrite–marcasite; quartz–tridymite–cristobalite |
| Displacive | bonds bent, not broken; small atomic shifts | instantaneous and reversible; cannot be quenched | α–β quartz at 573 °C (1 atm); high–low cristobalite and tridymite; leucite cubic–tetragonal |
| Order–disorder | distribution of atoms over sites (Al/Si, cations) | gradual, temperature-dependent | sanidine \( \to \) orthoclase \( \to \) microcline (Al–Si ordering); Fe–Mg order in pyroxenes |
SiO\(_2\) phase relations
At 1 atm, on heating: α-quartz \( \xrightarrow{573^\circ\text{C}} \) β-quartz \( \xrightarrow{\sim 870^\circ\text{C}} \) tridymite \( \xrightarrow{\sim 1470^\circ\text{C}} \) cristobalite \( \xrightarrow{\sim 1713^\circ\text{C}} \) melt. The α–β transition is displacive; the others are reconstructive. At high pressure, quartz gives way to coesite (above roughly 2.5–3 GPa at crustal temperatures; still Si 4-fold) and stishovite (above roughly 8–10 GPa; Si 6-fold, rutile structure). Coesite and stishovite in nature mark ultrahigh-pressure metamorphism or meteorite impact. Because coesite inverts readily to quartz, it survives mainly as inclusions shielded inside rigid garnet or zircon.
Clapeyron slopes and pressure
$$\boxed{\frac{dP}{dT} = \frac{\Delta S}{\Delta V}}$$High-pressure polymorphs are denser (\( \Delta V < 0 \) going from low- to high-pressure form) and usually have higher coordination. Aragonite (Ca 9-fold, about 2.93 g cm\(^{-3}\)) is denser than calcite (Ca 6-fold, about 2.71); kyanite (all Al 6-fold) is denser than sillimanite and andalusite. That density rule is how you rank polymorphs by stability field even without a phase diagram.
The Al\(_2\)SiO\(_5\) diagram has a triple point near 500 °C and 3.8 kbar in Holdaway’s (1971) calibration (other calibrations place it higher). Kyanite is the high-pressure phase, andalusite the low-pressure phase and sillimanite the high-temperature phase. This diagram anchors metamorphic facies series (see Metamorphic Textures, Facies, Reactions and P–T–t Paths).
Polytypism
Polytypism is a special kind of polymorphism in layer structures: the polytypes are built from identical layers stacked in different sequences. Two polytypes therefore have essentially the same cell dimensions parallel to the layers and differ only in the repeat distance perpendicular to them (a multiple of the layer thickness).
| Mineral | Common polytypes |
|---|---|
| ZnS | sphalerite (3C, cubic ABC stacking), wurtzite (2H, hexagonal AB stacking), and many long-period polytypes |
| SiC (moissanite) | hundreds of polytypes; 6H and 4H are common |
| Micas | 1M, 2M\(_1\), 2M\(_2\), 3T; muscovite is typically 2M\(_1\), biotite 1M |
| Molybdenite | 2H, 3R |
| Chlorite, kaolin minerals | stacking variants (kaolinite, dickite, nacrite differ in stacking) |
Ramsdell notation: the number of layers in the repeat, then a letter for the resulting lattice symmetry (C cubic, H hexagonal, R rhombohedral, M monoclinic, T trigonal, Or orthorhombic). Polytypes form because the energy differences between stacking choices are tiny. Some polytypes correlate with growth conditions (the 1M to 2M\(_1\) transformation in illite and muscovite with increasing temperature is used in low-grade metamorphism). Distinguishing them needs diffraction along the stacking direction or TEM.
Solid Solution
A solid solution is a single crystalline phase whose composition varies because ions of similar size and charge share the same sites.
Types
| Type | Mechanism | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Simple substitutional | one ion replaces another of the same charge | Mg\(^{2+}\) \( \leftrightarrow \) Fe\(^{2+}\) in olivine (forsterite–fayalite) |
| Coupled substitutional | two substitutions balance charge | Na\(^+\)Si\(^{4+}\) \( \leftrightarrow \) Ca\(^{2+}\)Al\(^{3+}\) in plagioclase; Mg\(^{2+}\)Si\(^{4+}\) \( \leftrightarrow \) Al\(^{3+}\)Al\(^{3+}\) (Tschermak) in pyroxene and amphibole |
| Interstitial | ions fill normally empty sites or channels | Na, K, H\(_2\)O in beryl channels; “stuffed” derivatives of β-quartz |
| Omission | cations missing to balance charge | pyrrhotite Fe\(_{1-x}\)S (2Fe\(^{3+}\) + vacancy for 3Fe\(^{2+}\)) |
Controls on extent (Goldschmidt). Extensive substitution needs radius difference less than about 15% and charge difference of at most one, with a coupled substitution where the charge differs. Higher temperature widens substitution (thermal vibration accommodates misfit); differences in electronegativity and bond type limit it.
Thermodynamics of mixing
For an ideal binary solution of \( A \) and \( B \) (one mixing site per formula unit),
$$\Delta G_{\text{mix}}^{\text{ideal}} = RT\left[x\ln x + (1-x)\ln(1-x)\right]$$which is always negative. A regular solution adds an excess term from the mismatch of the ions:
$$\Delta G_{\text{mix}} = RT\left[x\ln x + (1-x)\ln(1-x)\right] + W\,x(1-x)$$With a positive interaction parameter \( W \), the curve develops two minima below a critical temperature
$$\boxed{T_c = \frac{W}{2R}}$$and the solid solution splits into two phases: a miscibility gap bounded by the solvus. Above \( T_c \) a complete solid solution is stable; below it, compositions inside the solvus are unstable or metastable.
graph TD
A[Homogeneous solid solution at high T] --> B{Cooling below the solvus}
B --> C[Inside spinodal: no nucleation barrier]
B --> D[Between solvus and spinodal: needs nucleation]
C --> E[Spinodal decomposition: fine, periodic, coherent modulations]
D --> F[Nucleation and growth: discrete lamellae or blebs]
E --> G[Coarsening with slow cooling]
F --> GExsolution
Exsolution is the unmixing of an initially homogeneous solid solution into two phases on cooling below the solvus. The minor phase usually forms lamellae oriented along planes of best lattice fit with the host, which minimises strain energy.
| Host–lamella system | Texture name | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| K-feldspar host, Na-feldspar lamellae | perthite | microperthite (microscope), cryptoperthite (submicroscopic; moonstone) |
| Plagioclase host, K-feldspar lamellae | antiperthite | |
| Roughly equal Na and K phases | mesoperthite | typical of high-temperature, dry rocks such as granulites and some charnockites |
| Augite host, orthopyroxene or pigeonite lamellae (and vice versa) | pyroxene exsolution | inverted pigeonite: orthopyroxene with coarse augite lamellae, typical of slowly cooled gabbros |
| Ti-magnetite host, ilmenite lamellae | trellis or sandwich texture | strictly “oxy-exsolution”: oxidation of ulvöspinel component makes ilmenite |
| Ilmenite–hematite | hemo-ilmenite and ilmeno-hematite | |
| Pyrrhotite host, pentlandite flames | flame texture | magmatic Ni sulphides |
| Plagioclase | peristerite (about An\(_{2-16}\)), Bøggild (intermediate An; causes labradorescence), Huttenlocher (calcic) intergrowths | sub-microscopic; the plagioclase series is not ideal at low temperature |
Uses of exsolution:
- Thermometry. Coexisting phases on opposite limbs of a solvus record temperature: two-feldspar and two-pyroxene thermometry. Re-integrating lamellae with the host (measuring both and recombining in proportion) recovers the original high-temperature composition.
- Cooling rate. Lamella width and spacing grow with slower cooling and longer time at high temperature: coarse lamellae in plutonic rocks, none or cryptic ones in volcanic rocks quenched from above the solvus.
- Pressure and history. In some ultrahigh-pressure rocks, oriented lamellae in garnet or pyroxene record exsolution of a component that was soluble only at higher pressure.
Formula recalculation
Microprobe analyses are given as oxide weight percent. To get a formula: divide each oxide by its molecular weight, multiply by the number of oxygens it carries, scale so the oxygen total equals the formula oxygens (4 for olivine, 6 for pyroxene, 8 for feldspar, 12 for garnet), and then compute cations.
Worked example. An olivine analyses SiO\(_2\) 40.50, FeO 10.00, MgO 49.00 wt% (total 99.50).
| Oxide | wt% | ÷ M | mol oxide | O | cations (on 4 O) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SiO\(_2\) | 40.50 | 60.08 | 0.6741 | 1.3481 | Si 0.997 |
| FeO | 10.00 | 71.84 | 0.1392 | 0.1392 | Fe 0.206 |
| MgO | 49.00 | 40.30 | 1.2158 | 1.2158 | Mg 1.799 |
| Total | 2.7031 | 3.003 |
Scaling factor \( = 4/2.7031 = 1.480 \). Formula (Mg\(_{1.80}\)Fe\(_{0.21}\))Si\(_{1.00}\)O\(_4\); Fo \( = 1.799/(1.799 + 0.206) = \) 89.7 (Fo\(_{90}\)), a typical mantle olivine. A cation sum close to 3 confirms a good analysis.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Polymorph: different structure, same composition | Polytype: same layers, different stacking; one cell dimension changes | |
| Displacive: fast, unquenchable (α–β quartz) | Reconstructive: sluggish, often metastable (coesite, aragonite) | |
| Normal spinel: A\(^{2+}\) tetrahedral (chromite) | Inverse spinel: half B\(^{3+}\) tetrahedral (magnetite) | |
| Dioctahedral: 2 of 3 octahedral sites, Al (muscovite) | Trioctahedral: all 3, Mg/Fe (biotite) | |
| Perthite: Na-lamellae in K-feldspar host | Antiperthite: K-lamellae in plagioclase host | |
| Solvus: limits of a miscibility gap in the solid state | Solidus: start of melting | |
| Spinodal decomposition: no nucleation barrier, wavy modulations | Nucleation and growth: discrete lamellae | |
| Pyrite: cubic FeS\(_2\), hard | Marcasite: orthorhombic FeS\(_2\), low-temperature polymorph |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the Si:O ratio of a double-chain silicate?
- Name the polymorph of SiO\(_2\) in which Si is octahedrally coordinated.
- In which kind of spinel do half of the trivalent cations occupy tetrahedral sites?
Answers
- 4:11 (Si\(_4\)O\(_{11}\)).
- Stishovite.
- Inverse spinel (magnetite).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which pair consists of polytypes rather than ordinary polymorphs?
(a) Calcite and aragonite (b) Sphalerite and wurtzite (c) Quartz and coesite (d) Pyrite and marcasite
Answer: (b)
Sphalerite (ABC stacking) and wurtzite (AB stacking) are built from identical close-packed ZnS layers in different stacking sequences. The others differ in coordination or in the whole framework (reconstructive polymorphs).
Practice Q2. The transition sanidine \( \to \) orthoclase \( \to \) microcline is best described as:
(a) displacive (b) reconstructive (c) order–disorder (d) polytypic
Answer: (c)
All three are KAlSi\(_3\)O\(_8\) frameworks; what changes is how Al and Si are distributed over the tetrahedral sites. Full ordering lowers the symmetry to triclinic (microcline).
Practice Q3. For a symmetric regular solution with interaction parameter \( W = 20 \) kJ mol\(^{-1}\), the critical temperature of the solvus is closest to:
(a) 600 K (b) 930 K (c) 1,200 K (d) 2,400 K
Answer: (c) about 1,200 K
\( T_c = W/(2R) = 20{,}000/(2\times 8.314) = 1{,}203 \) K (about 930 °C). Option (b) is that value in °C, presented as kelvin; (d) forgets the factor 2.
Practice Q4. Which statement about garnet is correct?
(a) Si is octahedral and Al tetrahedral (b) Grossular and andradite belong to the pyralspite series (c) Divalent cations occupy 8-fold (dodecahedral) sites (d) Garnet is strongly birefringent because it is cubic
Answer: (c)
Mg, Fe\(^{2+}\), Mn and Ca sit in distorted cubic (dodecahedral) X sites; Al, Fe\(^{3+}\), Cr in octahedral Y sites; Si tetrahedral. Grossular and andradite are ugrandite. Cubic minerals are isotropic (some grossular–andradite shows weak anomalous birefringence, but not because it is cubic).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A mineral with formula unit mass 140.69 g mol\(^{-1}\) is orthorhombic with \( a = 4.756 \), \( b = 10.207 \), \( c = 5.980 \) Å and four formula units per cell. A second sample of the same structure measures 3.70 g cm\(^{-3}\). Which statements are correct?
- The calculated density of the first sample is about 3.22 g cm\(^{-3}\).
- The first sample is pure forsterite.
- The second sample must contain more Fe than the first.
- The second sample could be a higher-pressure polymorph with the same composition as the first.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 true: \( V = 4.756\times 10.207\times 5.980 = 290.3 \) Å\(^3\); \( \rho = 4\times 140.69/(6.022\times 10^{23}\times 290.3\times 10^{-24}) = 3.22 \) g cm\(^{-3}\).
- 2 true: 140.69 g mol\(^{-1}\) is Mg\(_2\)SiO\(_4\), with the forsterite cell.
- 3 true: the question states that the second sample has the same structure; within the olivine solid solution, density rises linearly with Fe (towards about 4.4 for fayalite), so 3.70 requires a substantial fayalite component.
- 4 false: a high-pressure polymorph (wadsleyite, ringwoodite) would not have “the same structure”.
Practice Q6. A two-feldspar granulite contains alkali feldspar with abundant, regularly spaced, crystallographically oriented albite lamellae occupying about 40% of each grain. Which interpretations are correct?
- The feldspar crystallised as a homogeneous high-temperature solid solution.
- The texture is mesoperthite-to-perthite exsolution on slow cooling.
- Re-integrating host and lamellae gives a composition that can be used in two-feldspar thermometry for peak temperature.
- The lamellae are evidence of late albite veining that added Na to the rock.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 4 only (c) 1 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
Regularly spaced, oriented lamellae within single grains are exsolution, which conserves bulk composition (statement 4 describes replacement, which follows cracks and is irregular). A large lamella fraction implies an original intermediate (Na–K) feldspar stable only at high temperature, as expected in granulites, and recombining the two gives the pre-exsolution composition for thermometry.
Practice Q7. For a regular solution with \( W = 20 \) kJ mol\(^{-1}\) at 1,000 K, the solvus limbs are at the compositions where \( W(1-2x) = RT\ln[(1-x)/x] \). The Na-rich limb lies at approximately:
(a) \( x = 0.02 \) (b) \( x = 0.17 \) (c) \( x = 0.33 \) (d) \( x = 0.50 \)
Answer: (b) about 0.17
For a symmetric regular solution, the minima of \( \Delta G_\text{mix} \) satisfy \( \partial\Delta G/\partial x = 0 \): \( RT\ln[x/(1-x)] + W(1-2x) = 0 \). Try \( x = 0.17 \): LHS \( = 20{,}000\times 0.66 = 13{,}200 \); RHS \( = 8.314\times 1000\times\ln(0.83/0.17) = 8.314\times 1000\times 1.586 = 13{,}180 \). They match (numerical solution \( x = 0.169 \)). The other limb is at \( 1 - 0.169 = 0.831 \). At 1,000 K we are below \( T_c = 1{,}203 \) K, so a gap exists; option (d) would be the answer only at \( T = T_c \).
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Coordination by radius ratio | 0.225–0.414 tetrahedral; 0.414–0.732 octahedral; 0.732–1 cubic |
| Corundum, hematite | hcp O, \( \tfrac23 \) octahedral holes |
| Spinel | ccp O, \( \tfrac18 \) tet + \( \tfrac12 \) oct; 8 AB\(_2\)O\(_4\) per cell; magnetite inverse, chromite normal |
| Galena, pyrite | rock-salt type (pyrite with S\(_2\) dumbbells) |
| Sphalerite / wurtzite | ccp / hcp ZnS polytypes |
| Silicate Si:O | 1:4, 2:7, 1:3, 1:3, 4:11, 2:5, 1:2 |
| Cleavage angles | pyroxene 87/93°; amphibole 56/124° |
| Al\(_2\)SiO\(_5\) | Ky (all Al 6), And (6+5), Sil (6+4); triple point about 500 °C, 3.8 kbar (Holdaway) |
| SiO\(_2\) at 1 atm | α–β 573; tridymite about 870; cristobalite about 1470; melt about 1713 °C |
| Polymorph types | reconstructive, displacive, order–disorder |
| Polytypes | ZnS, SiC, micas (1M, 2M\(_1\), 3T), MoS\(_2\) |
| Solid solution | simple, coupled, interstitial, omission |
| Regular solution | \( T_c = W/2R \) |
| Exsolution | perthite, antiperthite, mesoperthite, pyroxene lamellae, trellis ilmenite, pentlandite flames |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Magma Genesis, Phase Equilibria and Magma Mixing: solid solutions and eutectics in melting and crystallisation.
- Metamorphic Textures, Facies, Reactions and P–T–t Paths: polymorphs as pressure and temperature indicators.
- Phase Equilibria and the Phase Rule in Chemical Sciences.
- Mineralogy and Petrology: Quick Revision.