T-S Diagrams, Mixing and Water Masses
CSIR NET Ocean Sciences: potential temperature and density, T-S diagrams, two- and three-type mixing, cabbeling, double diffusion and the world's water masses.
- 21 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Ocean Floor, Sea Water and its Properties: salinity, temperature and density at Part B level.
- Ocean Currents, Waves, Tides and Productivity: the first look at water masses and thermohaline circulation.
- Linear algebra for three unknowns (the three-type mixing problem is a 3 × 3 linear system).
The Hook: Fingerprinting Water
The Variables: Getting Temperature and Density Right
Potential temperature
Water sinking from the surface is compressed and warms adiabatically. The potential temperature \( \theta \) is the temperature a parcel would have if moved adiabatically, without exchange of heat or salt, to a reference pressure (usually the sea surface). It removes the compression effect, so two samples of the same water at different depths have the same \( \theta \).
- In the upper few hundred metres \( T \) and \( \theta \) are almost equal.
- In the deep ocean \( \theta < T \) by a few tenths of a degree. In the deepest trenches the in-situ temperature can rise with depth while \( \theta \) keeps falling: the water column is still stable.
- Water-mass work uses \( \theta \), not \( T \). A “T–S diagram” in modern papers is almost always a \( \theta \)–S diagram.
Density anomalies
Seawater density \( \rho(S, T, p) \) is near 1020–1030 kg m\(^{-3}\), so oceanographers quote anomalies:
| Quantity | Definition | Use |
|---|---|---|
| \( \sigma_t \) | \( \rho(S, T, 0) - 1000 \) | old practice; mixes pressure effects back in at depth |
| \( \sigma_\theta \) (potential density anomaly) | \( \rho(S, \theta, 0) - 1000 \) | stability of the upper ocean |
| \( \sigma_2,\ \sigma_4 \) | potential density referenced to 2000 dbar or 4000 dbar, minus 1000 | stability and spreading at mid-depth and in the abyss |
| Neutral density \( \gamma^n \) | label surfaces along which a parcel moves without buoyancy restoring force | modern water-mass analysis |
Why several reference pressures? Cold water is more compressible than warm water (thermobaricity). A cold parcel that is lighter than a warm one at the surface can become heavier at 4000 dbar. Referenced to the surface, \( \sigma_\theta \) can show an apparent “inversion” in the deep Atlantic where Antarctic Bottom Water lies under North Atlantic Deep Water; referenced to 4000 dbar (\( \sigma_4 \)) the column is stable.
Linear equation of state
For estimates,
$$\rho \approx \rho_0\left[1 - \alpha(\theta - \theta_0) + \beta(S - S_0)\right]$$with thermal expansion coefficient \( \alpha \) of order \( 10^{-4} \) K\(^{-1}\) (typically about \( 2 \times 10^{-4} \) in warm surface water and much smaller near the freezing point) and haline contraction coefficient \( \beta \) of about \( 7.6 \times 10^{-4} \) per g kg\(^{-1}\). Because \( \alpha \) shrinks in cold water, salinity controls density in polar seas and temperature controls it in the tropics. This is why high-latitude deep-water formation is so sensitive to fresh-water input.
Static Stability
A water column is stable when density increases downward. The measure is the Brunt–Väisälä (buoyancy) frequency:
$$\boxed{N^2 = -\frac{g}{\rho_0}\frac{\partial \rho_\theta}{\partial z}}$$with \( z \) positive upward and \( \rho_\theta \) potential density. \( N^2 > 0 \) stable (a displaced parcel oscillates with period \( 2\pi/N \)), \( N^2 = 0 \) neutral (mixed layer), \( N^2 < 0 \) unstable (convection).
Shear can overcome stratification. The gradient Richardson number
$$Ri = \frac{N^2}{(\partial u/\partial z)^2}$$compares the two. A necessary condition for shear (Kelvin–Helmholtz) instability in a stratified flow is \( Ri < 1/4 \) somewhere. Low \( Ri \) at the base of the mixed layer, in the Equatorial Undercurrent and in estuaries is where turbulent mixing happens.
The T–S Diagram
Plot \( \theta \) (vertical axis) against \( S \) (horizontal) for every depth of a cast, and draw the isopycnals (lines of constant \( \sigma_\theta \)) as a background.
graph LR
A[CTD cast: theta, S at each depth] --> B[Plot theta against S]
B --> C[Overlay isopycnals]
C --> D[Points: water types]
C --> E[Curves and segments: water masses and mixing]
C --> F[Extrema: cores of intermediate waters]
D --> G[Mixing fractions by lever rule]
E --> GReading the diagram
| Feature on the diagram | Meaning |
|---|---|
| A single point | a water type: one \( \theta \), one \( S \), formed at a source |
| A curve segment | a water mass: a body of water with a characteristic range of \( \theta \) and \( S \), the product of mixing source water types |
| Straight segment between two points | mixing of two water types |
| Salinity minimum (bend to the left) | core of a low-salinity intermediate water, e.g. Antarctic Intermediate Water |
| Salinity maximum (bend to the right) | core of a high-salinity water, e.g. Mediterranean or Red Sea Water |
| Depth not on the axes | the diagram removes depth; label depths beside the points |
| Curve crossing isopycnals steeply upward | strongly stable thermocline |
Two strengths make the diagram powerful. First, \( \theta \) and \( S \) are conservative below the surface: they change only by mixing, so a water mass carries its source signature. Second, mixing of conservative properties is linear, so mixing shows up as straight lines.
Mixing
Two-type mixing: the lever rule
If water types 1 and 2 mix in fractions \( m_1 \) and \( m_2 = 1 - m_1 \), the mixture has
$$\theta = m_1\theta_1 + m_2\theta_2, \qquad S = m_1 S_1 + m_2 S_2$$and lies on the straight line joining the two points. The fraction of type 1 is the distance from the mixture to point 2 divided by the whole length:
$$\boxed{m_1 = \frac{S - S_2}{S_1 - S_2} = \frac{\theta - \theta_2}{\theta_1 - \theta_2}}$$If the two estimates differ, the point is not on the line and a third water type is involved.
Three-type mixing: the mixing triangle
With three source types the mixture lies inside the triangle they form. Three unknowns, three equations:
$$m_1 + m_2 + m_3 = 1,\quad \sum m_i\theta_i = \theta,\quad \sum m_i S_i = S$$On a vertical profile through a layered system (warm salty upper, an intermediate core, cold deep) the curve cuts the corner of the triangle near the intermediate type: the extremum is eroded by mixing above and below. The farther from its source, the more the core salinity is diluted toward the line joining the other two types. Wüst’s core method traced intermediate waters (e.g. the Mediterranean salinity maximum) by following the extremum along its spreading level.
Cabbeling: mixing makes water denser
Isopycnals on a \( \theta \)–S diagram are curved, concave toward the high-S, low-\( \theta \) corner, because \( \alpha \) increases with temperature. Take two parcels on the same isopycnal but with different \( \theta \) and S. The straight mixing line between them lies on the denser side of the curved isopycnal, so the mixture is denser than either parent. This is cabbeling. It can make the mixed water sink, and it operates at fronts where waters of equal density but different \( \theta \)–S meet (e.g. polar fronts of the Southern Ocean).
Turbulent and molecular mixing
| Process | Scale | Typical diffusivity |
|---|---|---|
| Molecular diffusion of heat | mm | \( \sim 1.4 \times 10^{-7} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\) |
| Molecular diffusion of salt | mm | \( \sim 10^{-9} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\), about 100 times smaller than heat |
| Diapycnal (vertical) turbulent mixing in the thermocline | m | order \( 10^{-5} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\) |
| Diapycnal mixing needed in the abyss | m | order \( 10^{-4} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\) |
| Isopycnal (lateral) mixing by eddies | km | order \( 10^{2} \)–\( 10^{3} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\) |
Mixing is much easier along isopycnals than across them, because crossing an isopycnal requires work against gravity. Water masses therefore spread along density surfaces, which is why Mediterranean Water spreads near 1000 m and not at the surface or bottom.
Double diffusion
Heat diffuses about 100 times faster than salt. When one of them is unstably stratified, even in a statically stable column, the difference drives convection.
| Regime | Arrangement | What happens | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| Salt fingering | warm, salty over cold, fresh (both T and S decrease downward) | a sinking salty parcel loses heat sideways faster than salt, becomes denser, keeps sinking: narrow fingers | below the Mediterranean outflow, subtropical thermoclines (central waters), under the Red Sea outflow |
| Diffusive convection (layering) | cold, fresh over warm, salty (both increase downward) | heat leaks upward faster than salt: convecting layers separated by sharp interfaces | polar oceans, Arctic thermocline, under ice |
The density ratio \( R_\rho = \alpha\Delta\theta / (\beta\Delta S) \) measures how close the column is to the fingering regime; fingering is vigorous when \( R_\rho \) is a little above 1. Both regimes can produce thermohaline staircases: well-mixed layers separated by thin high-gradient interfaces on a CTD profile.
Water Masses of the World Ocean
Water masses are formed at the surface where air–sea exchange sets \( \theta \) and S, then subducted or convected to their level of neutral buoyancy.
graph TD
S[Surface forcing: cooling, evaporation, sea-ice formation] --> SM[Surface and mode waters]
S --> CW[Central waters: thermocline]
S --> IW[Intermediate waters: about 500-1500 m]
S --> DW[Deep waters: about 1500-4000 m]
S --> BW[Bottom waters: below about 4000 m]
IW --> AAIW[AAIW: salinity minimum]
IW --> MW[Mediterranean and Red Sea Water: salinity maximum]
DW --> NADW[NADW]
BW --> AABW[AABW: coldest, densest]Main water masses (approximate properties)
| Water mass | Formed | Approx. \( \theta \) | Approx. S | Signature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Antarctic Bottom Water (AABW) | Weddell and Ross Seas, shelves around Antarctica: brine rejection under sea ice, cooling | about −0.8 to 2 °C (below 0 °C near its sources) | about 34.6–34.7 | coldest, densest; fills the abyss of all basins |
| North Atlantic Deep Water (NADW) | Nordic Seas overflows plus Labrador Sea convection | about 2–4 °C | about 34.9–35.0 | relatively salty, oxygen-rich, low in nutrients; spreads south between AAIW and AABW |
| Antarctic Intermediate Water (AAIW) | near the Subantarctic Front | about 3–7 °C | about 34.2–34.4 | salinity minimum at about 700–1000 m in the southern oceans and tropical Atlantic |
| Mediterranean Water (MW) | Mediterranean outflow through Gibraltar | about 11–13 °C | very salty at source, about 36 near 1000 m off Iberia | salinity maximum near 1000 m in the North Atlantic, “Meddies” |
| Labrador Sea Water | winter convection in the Labrador Sea | about 3 °C | about 34.8–34.9 | upper NADW component; low potential vorticity |
| Subtropical Mode Water (e.g. North Atlantic “18° Water”) | winter mixed layers south of the Gulf Stream | about 18 °C | about 36.5 | thick layer of nearly uniform properties |
| Central waters (thermocline) | subduction in the subtropical gyres | about 8–20 °C | rising with \( \theta \) | nearly straight \( \theta \)–S line |
| Circumpolar Deep Water | mixture in the Southern Ocean | about 1–2 °C | about 34.7 | oldest-looking deep water; feeds Pacific and Indian deep waters |
| North Pacific Intermediate Water | northwest Pacific (Okhotsk Sea influence) | — | about 34.0–34.3 | salinity minimum in the North Pacific |
The numbers are representative ranges for recognising the water masses, not definitions; textbooks differ in the second decimal.
The Indian Ocean and the Arabian Sea
The northern Indian Ocean is landlocked at about 25°N, so it forms no deep water of its own. Its upper ocean is a contrast:
| Region | Water mass | Origin and signature |
|---|---|---|
| Northern Arabian Sea | Arabian Sea High Salinity Water (ASHSW) | formed in winter by evaporation and convective cooling under dry northeasterly winds; salinity above about 36 in the upper 100 m; subducts and spreads south |
| Arabian Sea, about 200–350 m | Persian Gulf Water (PGW) | very salty outflow through the Strait of Hormuz; subsurface salinity maximum |
| Arabian Sea, about 500–800 m | Red Sea Water (RSW) | salty (about 40 at the source) outflow through Bab-el-Mandeb; intermediate salinity maximum, traceable into the western Indian Ocean |
| Bay of Bengal surface | low-salinity surface water | Ganga–Brahmaputra and other river discharge plus monsoon rain; surface salinity well below that of the Arabian Sea; strong haline stratification |
| Eastern Indian Ocean thermocline | Indonesian Throughflow water | Pacific water entering through the Indonesian seas; relatively fresh |
| Below about 1500 m | Circumpolar Deep Water / modified NADW, and AABW at the bottom | from the Southern Ocean |
Barrier layer. In the Bay of Bengal, fresh water at the surface makes the halocline shallower than the thermocline. The layer between them, isothermal but stratified in salinity, is a barrier layer: wind mixing cannot reach the cold water below, so the sea surface stays warm (above about 28 °C), which feeds monsoon convection and cyclones. The Arabian Sea, salty and evaporative, mixes more deeply and cools more strongly under the monsoon winds.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Water type: single \( \theta \)–S point | Water mass: range of \( \theta \)–S, a curve | |
| \( \sigma_t \): in-situ T, zero pressure | \( \sigma_\theta \): potential temperature, zero pressure | |
| In-situ temperature can increase in deep trenches | Potential temperature keeps decreasing; column is stable | |
| Salt fingers: warm salty over cold fresh | Diffusive convection: cold fresh over warm salty | |
| Cabbeling: mixing increases density (curved isopycnals) | Thermobaricity: compressibility depends on temperature | |
| AAIW: salinity minimum | MW, RSW, PGW: salinity maxima | |
| Conservative tracers (\( \theta \), S): identify | Non-conservative (O\(_2\), nutrients, \( ^{14}\)C): date |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which water mass is identified by a salinity minimum at about 800 m in the South Atlantic?
- What is \( \sigma_\theta \) for a sample of potential density 1027.4 kg m\(^{-3}\)?
- In which regime of double diffusion does warm, salty water lie over cold, fresh water?
Answers
- Antarctic Intermediate Water (AAIW).
- 27.4 kg m\(^{-3}\) (subtract 1000).
- Salt fingering. Both T and S decrease downward; the salt stratification is the unstable component.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A sample has \( S = 34.80 \). It is a two-type mixture of a water with \( S = 34.66 \) and one with \( S = 34.95 \). The fraction of the fresher water is closest to:
(a) 0.29 (b) 0.48 (c) 0.52 (d) 0.71
Answer: (c) 0.52
\( m_{\text{fresh}} = \frac{34.95 - 34.80}{34.95 - 34.66} = \frac{0.15}{0.29} = 0.517 \).
The sample is slightly closer to the fresh end (0.14 from it, 0.15 from the salty end), so it has slightly more than half fresh water. Option (b) is the salty fraction rounded the wrong way.
Practice Q2. Two water parcels of equal potential density but different \( \theta \) and S mix in equal parts. The mixture is:
(a) lighter than both parents (b) exactly the same density (c) denser than both parents (d) denser or lighter depending on the hemisphere
Answer: (c)
Cabbeling. Isopycnals on a \( \theta \)–S diagram are curved; the straight mixing line between two points on the same isopycnal lies on the denser side. The cause is the temperature dependence of the thermal expansion coefficient.
Practice Q3. In the northern Arabian Sea, a subsurface salinity maximum near 250 m and a second one near 700 m are best attributed to, respectively:
(a) Red Sea Water and Persian Gulf Water (b) Persian Gulf Water and Red Sea Water (c) ASHSW and AAIW (d) Indonesian Throughflow and Red Sea Water
Answer: (b)
Persian Gulf Water spreads at roughly 200–350 m, Red Sea Water at roughly 500–800 m. AAIW is a salinity minimum; Indonesian Throughflow water is fresh.
Practice Q4. For a thermocline with \( N = 0.01 \) s\(^{-1}\), the minimum vertical shear for which Kelvin–Helmholtz instability becomes possible (by the \( Ri < 1/4 \) criterion) is:
(a) \( 0.005 \) s\(^{-1}\) (b) \( 0.01 \) s\(^{-1}\) (c) \( 0.02 \) s\(^{-1}\) (d) \( 0.04 \) s\(^{-1}\)
Answer: (c) 0.02 s⁻¹
\( Ri = N^2/(\partial u/\partial z)^2 < 1/4 \Rightarrow \partial u/\partial z > 2N = 0.02 \) s\(^{-1}\). That is a 2 m s\(^{-1}\) velocity difference over 100 m.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Three source water types are (idealised values for this problem):
| Type | \( \theta \) (°C) | S |
|---|---|---|
| A (warm, salty) | 12.0 | 35.6 |
| B (intermediate, fresh) | 4.0 | 34.3 |
| C (deep) | 2.0 | 34.9 |
A sample has \( \theta = 4.6 \) °C and \( S = 34.86 \). Assuming three-type mixing, the fractions of A, B and C are:
(a) 0.20, 0.30, 0.50 (b) 0.25, 0.25, 0.50 (c) 0.15, 0.35, 0.50 (d) 0.30, 0.20, 0.50
Answer: (a) A 0.20, B 0.30, C 0.50
Equations: \( a + b + c = 1 \); \( 12a + 4b + 2c = 4.6 \); \( 35.6a + 34.3b + 34.9c = 34.86 \).
Substitute \( c = 1 - a - b \):
- \( \theta \): \( 10a + 2b + 2 = 4.6 \Rightarrow 10a + 2b = 2.6 \)
- S: \( 0.7a - 0.6b + 34.9 = 34.86 \Rightarrow 0.7a - 0.6b = -0.04 \)
From the first, \( b = 1.3 - 5a \). Then \( 0.7a - 0.78 + 3a = -0.04 \Rightarrow 3.7a = 0.74 \Rightarrow a = 0.20 \), \( b = 0.30 \), \( c = 0.50 \).
Check: \( \theta = 2.4 + 1.2 + 1.0 = 4.6 \) °C; \( S = 7.12 + 10.29 + 17.45 = 34.86 \).
The distractors are built to satisfy only one equation each: option (c) gives \( S = 34.795 \), close to the right salinity, but \( \theta = 4.2 \) °C; option (b) gives \( \theta = 5.0 \) °C and \( S = 34.925 \). Always check an option against both \( \theta \) and S.
Practice Q6. In the deep North Pacific the potential temperature profile below 1000 m follows \( \theta(z) - \theta_b = \Delta\theta\, e^{(z + H)/h} \) closely, with \( h = 1.0 \) km. If the upwelling velocity is \( w = 1.2 \) cm per day, consider:
- The implied vertical diffusivity \( K_z = w h \) is about \( 1.4 \times 10^{-4} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\).
- This is roughly ten times the diffusivity measured by tracer release in the open-ocean thermocline.
- If \( K_z \) were \( 10^{-5} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\) with the same \( w \), the scale height would be about 70 m.
- The balance assumes \( \theta \) is non-conservative.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3
- \( w = 0.012/86400 = 1.39 \times 10^{-7} \) m s\(^{-1}\); \( K_z = w h = 1.39 \times 10^{-7} \times 1000 = 1.39 \times 10^{-4} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\). Correct.
- Thermocline diffusivities are of order \( 10^{-5} \). Correct.
- \( h = K_z/w = 10^{-5}/1.39 \times 10^{-7} = 72 \) m. Correct.
- Wrong: the advection–diffusion balance treats \( \theta \) as conservative (no sources or sinks in the interior).
Practice Q7. A CTD profile in the Bay of Bengal in October shows: surface salinity 31.0 rising to 34.5 at 40 m; temperature 29.0 °C uniform down to 80 m, then falling. Which statements are correct?
- The mixed layer (defined by density) is about 40 m deep or less.
- A barrier layer about 40 m thick exists between the halocline and the top of the thermocline.
- Wind mixing during a cyclone will cool the surface less than it would without the barrier layer.
- The profile is typical of the northern Arabian Sea in winter.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3
Density is controlled by salinity in the upper 40 m (temperature uniform), so the density-defined mixed layer ends at the halocline, at or above 40 m (1). Between about 40 m and 80 m the water is isothermal but salt-stratified: the barrier layer (2). Mixing that entrains water from 40–80 m brings up water of the same 29 °C, so surface cooling is suppressed (3). Statement 4 is wrong: the winter northern Arabian Sea is salty and deeply convecting.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Potential temperature | adiabatic to surface; use for all deep water analysis |
| \( \sigma_\theta,\ \sigma_2,\ \sigma_4 \) | potential density anomalies at 0, 2000, 4000 dbar |
| Buoyancy frequency | \( N^2 = -(g/\rho_0)\,\partial\rho_\theta/\partial z \) |
| Shear instability | \( Ri = N^2/(u_z)^2 < 1/4 \) |
| Two-type mixing | straight line; \( m_1 = (S - S_2)/(S_1 - S_2) \) |
| Three-type mixing | triangle; solve 3 linear equations |
| Cabbeling | curved isopycnals: mixture denser than parents |
| Salt fingers | warm salty over cold fresh |
| Diffusive convection | cold fresh over warm salty; staircases |
| Abyssal recipe | \( K_z/w \approx 1 \) km; \( K_z \sim 10^{-4} \) m\(^2\) s\(^{-1}\) |
| Atlantic layering | AABW bottom, NADW deep, AAIW intermediate (S min), MW (S max) |
| Arabian Sea | ASHSW surface, PGW ~250 m, RSW ~700 m |
| Bay of Bengal | fresh surface, barrier layer, warm SST |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Geostrophy, Dynamic Topography and Eddies: turn the density field into currents.
- Thermohaline circulation and the AMOC at Part C geology level: Ocean Circulation, Ekman Spiral, ENSO and IOD.
- Back to the Physical Oceanography overview.