Evolution of the Lithosphere, Hydrosphere, Atmosphere, Biosphere and Cryosphere
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C geology: how Earth's crust, oceans, air, life and ice evolved through the Precambrian, from Hadean zircons to snowball Earth.
- 20 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: A Grain of Sand Older Than Any Rock
- The Precambrian Time Frame
- Lithosphere: From Magma Ocean to Stable Cratons
- Hydrosphere: Oceans and Their Chemistry
- Atmosphere: From Anoxic to Oxygenated
- Biosphere: Metabolisms Before Animals
- Cryosphere: Precambrian Glaciations
- Putting the Spheres Together
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- The geological time scale and U–Pb dating: Geological Time Scale and Radiometric Dating. This page uses the Pb–Pb age equation and decay constants from there.
- Primary differentiation of Earth into core, mantle and crust: Meteorites, Earth’s Composition and Differentiation.
- The Part B outline of oxygenation and early life: Stratigraphy, Origin of Life and the Fossil Record.
- Plate tectonics as it works today: Paleomagnetism, Sea-Floor Spreading and Plate Tectonics.
The Hook: A Grain of Sand Older Than Any Rock
The Precambrian Time Frame
The Precambrian is an informal name for everything before the Cambrian: about 88% of Earth history. Its subdivisions are mostly chronometric: boundaries fixed at round ages (GSSAs), not at points in rock, because fossils are too sparse. The exception is the base of the Ediacaran, which has a GSSP.
| Eon | Era | Approx. span (Ma) | Periods (Proterozoic) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hadean | (no formal eras) | about 4,567–4,031 | none |
| Archean | Eoarchean | 4,031–3,600 | none |
| Paleoarchean | 3,600–3,200 | none | |
| Mesoarchean | 3,200–2,800 | none | |
| Neoarchean | 2,800–2,500 | none | |
| Proterozoic | Paleoproterozoic | 2,500–1,600 | Siderian, Rhyacian, Orosirian, Statherian |
| Mesoproterozoic | 1,600–1,000 | Calymmian, Ectasian, Stenian | |
| Neoproterozoic | 1,000–538.8 | Tonian, Cryogenian (about 720–635), Ediacaran (635–538.8) |
The Ediacaran base is defined by a GSSP at Enorama Creek in the Flinders Ranges, South Australia, at the base of the cap carbonate that overlies Marinoan glacial deposits. The Ediacaran (ratified 2004) was the first new period added to the time scale in more than a century.
Lithosphere: From Magma Ocean to Stable Cratons
The Hadean
Accretion and the Moon-forming impact left the outer Earth largely molten (a magma ocean). As it cooled, a thin crust formed, probably basaltic and repeatedly recycled. Almost no Hadean rock survives. What we have:
| Record | Age | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Detrital zircons, Jack Hills (Western Australia) | up to about 4.4 Ga | felsic-to-intermediate magmas existed; heavy \( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) implies water–rock interaction at low temperature |
| Acasta Gneiss (Slave craton, Canada) | about 4.0 Ga | oldest well-dated intact rock (tonalitic gneiss) |
| Nuvvuagittuq belt (Quebec) | 3.8 Ga or about 4.3 Ga | age contested: the older figure is a Sm–Nd (\( ^{142}\text{Nd} \)) interpretation, the younger a zircon age |
| Isua supracrustal belt (Greenland) | about 3.7–3.8 Ga | oldest well-preserved volcanic and sedimentary rocks, including pillow basalts and BIF |
Short-lived isotope systems (\( ^{146}\text{Sm}\to{}^{142}\text{Nd} \), \( ^{182}\text{Hf}\to{}^{182}\text{W} \)) record silicate differentiation and core formation within the first few tens of millions of years, because those parents were extinct soon after.
The Archean: a hotter Earth
Earth’s interior was hotter for two reasons: more primordial heat (accretion and core formation) and more radiogenic heat. Every heat-producing isotope was more abundant in the past:
$$\frac{N(t\ \text{ago})}{N(\text{today})} = e^{\lambda t}$$For \( ^{40}\text{K} \) (\( \lambda = 5.543\times10^{-10}\ \text{yr}^{-1} \)), the factor is about 4.0 at 2.5 Ga and about 9 at 4.0 Ga. Total radiogenic heat production in the late Archean was roughly two to three times today’s, depending on the model.
Consequences that show in the rock record:
| Feature | Archean expression | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Komatiites | ultramafic lavas with more than 18 wt% MgO, spinifex texture; abundant in Archean, rare later | high degrees of melting of a mantle a few hundred °C hotter than today |
| TTG crust | tonalite–trondhjemite–granodiorite gneisses dominate Archean continental crust | melting of hydrated basalt with garnet in the residue |
| Granite–greenstone terrains | dome-and-keel structure; weaker, hotter crust | see Granite–Greenstone and Granulite Belts |
| Thick, depleted mantle keels | cratonic lithosphere about 150–250 km thick, harzburgitic, buoyant | melt extraction left Mg-rich, Fe-poor residue that resisted later recycling |
| Late Archean K-granites | potassic granites intrude TTG near 2.7–2.5 Ga | crustal remelting; marks cratonisation (stabilisation) |
When did modern plate tectonics start?
This is an open question and Part C examiners know it, so questions ask which evidence points which way.
| Evidence | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Paired metamorphic belts (high-P/low-T beside low-P/high-T) appear in the Neoarchean | subduction-like settings by about 2.7–2.5 Ga |
| Eclogitic mineral inclusions in diamonds appear after about 3 Ga | recycling of oceanic crust into the mantle by then |
| Change in TTG and continental crust composition around 3.2–3.0 Ga | a shift in the way crust was made |
| Blueschists and ultrahigh-pressure rocks are almost all Neoproterozoic or younger | “cold” deep subduction like today’s only late; Archean subduction, if present, was hotter and shallower |
| Ophiolites: few convincing Archean examples | oceanic lithosphere was thicker-crusted, or poorly preserved |
Alternatives proposed for the early Earth include a stagnant lid with episodic overturn, heat-pipe volcanism, and vertical tectonics (sagduction of dense greenstones into soft crust). Many workers place the start of some form of plate tectonics between about 3.2 and 2.5 Ga, but estimates range from the Hadean to the Neoproterozoic.
Crustal growth
Two end-member families of models:
- Progressive growth: continental crust volume grew through time, slowly at first, with most added in pulses (for example near 2.7, 1.9 and 1.1 Ga, the peaks in zircon age distributions).
- Early growth with recycling (steady state): most crust formed early; since then new crust has roughly balanced crust returned to the mantle.
Zircon age peaks may record preservation (crust stabilised in collisional orogens during supercontinent assembly) rather than production. Combined U–Pb, Hf and O isotope data on zircons are used to separate juvenile crust from reworked crust. The Nd model-age tool for this is worked through on Cratons, Mobile Belts and Proterozoic Basins of India.
Secular changes and the supercontinent cycle
| Feature | Time distribution |
|---|---|
| Komatiites | mostly Archean; a few Paleoproterozoic; the Cretaceous Gorgona Island komatiite (Colombia) is the famous young exception |
| Banded iron formations | mostly about 3.8–1.8 Ga, peak 2.5–2.4 Ga; brief return in the Cryogenian |
| Massif-type anorthosites | mainly Proterozoic, especially about 1.8–1.0 Ga |
| Red beds, evaporites with sulphate | common after the Great Oxidation Event |
| Blueschists, UHP rocks | mostly Neoproterozoic and Phanerozoic |
| Phosphorites | major pulses in the Paleoproterozoic and around the Precambrian–Cambrian boundary |
Supercontinents (ages approximate and debated):
| Supercontinent | Assembly | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Kenorland / Superia (“supercratons”) | late Archean, about 2.7–2.5 Ga | it is debated whether this was one landmass or several |
| Columbia (Nuna) | about 2.0–1.8 Ga | assembled by worldwide 2.1–1.8 Ga orogens |
| Rodinia | about 1.1–0.9 Ga | Grenvillian-age orogens; broke up from about 0.75 Ga |
| Gondwana | about 0.65–0.5 Ga (Pan-African and Brasiliano orogens) | India, Africa, South America, Antarctica, Australia; later part of Pangea |
India’s eastern margin, the Eastern Ghats, is one of the belts used to place India against East Antarctica in Rodinia reconstructions.
Hydrosphere: Oceans and Their Chemistry
Where the water came from
Water reached Earth during accretion, in hydrated silicates and possibly in late-arriving volatile-rich bodies, and was outgassed from the interior. The deuterium/hydrogen ratio of ocean water is close to that of carbonaceous chondrites, which is why they are favoured over most measured comets as the main source.
Evidence for early liquid oceans:
- Zircon oxygen isotopes: mantle-derived zircon has \( \delta^{18}\text{O} \approx 5.3 \pm 0.6 \)‰. Several Jack Hills zircons are heavier, which needs a source rock altered by water at low temperature.
- Pillow basalts and water-lain sediments at Isua by about 3.8 Ga.
- Archean marine sediments: cherts, BIFs, carbonates and stromatolites.
Ocean chemistry through time
| Interval | Deep ocean | Key evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Archean | ferruginous (anoxic, Fe\(^{2+}\)-rich), low sulphate | BIFs; small sulphur-isotope fractionation (little sulphate to reduce) |
| Paleoproterozoic after the GOE | sulphate rises; BIF deposition ends near 1.8 Ga | evaporitic sulphates; end of major BIFs |
| Mid-Proterozoic (about 1.8–0.8 Ga) | anoxic at depth, with euxinic (H\(_2\)S-rich) belts along productive margins (the “Canfield ocean”) | iron speciation in black shales; Mo isotopes |
| Neoproterozoic | ferruginous again during the Cryogenian; deep-ocean oxygenation late in the Ediacaran–Cambrian | Cryogenian BIFs; rising redox-sensitive trace-metal enrichments |
Seawater \( ^{87}\text{Sr}/^{86}\text{Sr} \) stayed close to mantle values in the early Archean, because hydrothermal exchange at ridges dominated. It rose after about 2.5 Ga as weathering of large, emergent, Rb-rich continents supplied radiogenic Sr. This is one line of evidence for substantial continental emergence by the late Archean.
Atmosphere: From Anoxic to Oxygenated
Primary and secondary atmospheres
Earth’s present atmosphere is secondary. Heavy noble gases (Ne, Kr, Xe) are depleted on Earth relative to the Sun by many orders of magnitude, so any primary atmosphere captured from the nebula was lost. The secondary atmosphere came from outgassing (H\(_2\)O, CO\(_2\), N\(_2\), SO\(_2\), with some H\(_2\) and CO) and from impacts. The Archean atmosphere was mainly N\(_2\) and CO\(_2\), with CH\(_4\) and H\(_2\), and almost no free O\(_2\).
The faint young Sun paradox
Stellar models show the Sun brightening as hydrogen is converted to helium in its core. A widely used approximation (Gough, 1981) is
$$\frac{L(t)}{L_0} = \left[1 + \frac{2}{5}\left(1 - \frac{t}{t_0}\right)\right]^{-1}$$where \( t \) is time since the Sun formed and \( t_0 \approx 4.57 \) Gyr is its present age. At \( t = 0 \), \( L = L_0/1.4 \approx 0.71L_0 \): about 30% fainter. With today’s albedo and no extra greenhouse, Earth’s effective temperature scales as \( L^{1/4} \) and would have been well below freezing for the first half of its history. Yet there is evidence of liquid water from about 4.4 Ga, and no glaciation before about 2.9 Ga.
Proposed solutions: much higher CO\(_2\) (limited by palaeosol and other constraints), CH\(_4\) from methanogens (a powerful greenhouse gas while O\(_2\) was absent), lower albedo (less continental area, fewer cloud condensation nuclei), and more N\(_2\) pressure broadening. No single factor is agreed on.
The rise of oxygen
graph TD
A["Archean
O2 below about 10^-5 of present level
MIF-S preserved"] --> B["Whiffs of O2
about 2.7-2.5 Ga
local oxygen oases"]
B --> C["Great Oxidation Event
about 2.4-2.3 Ga
MIF-S disappears"]
C --> D["Lomagundi-Jatuli excursion
about 2.2-2.06 Ga
delta-13C carb up to +10 permil or more"]
D --> E["'Boring billion'
about 1.8-0.8 Ga
low O2, euxinic margins"]
E --> F["Neoproterozoic Oxygenation Event
about 0.8-0.54 Ga
deep ocean oxygenates; animals"]Evidence for the Great Oxidation Event (GOE):
| Proxy | Before the GOE | After the GOE |
|---|---|---|
| Mass-independent sulphur isotope fractionation (\( \Delta^{33}\text{S} \neq 0 \)) | present; requires UV photolysis of SO\(_2\) with almost no O\(_2\) or ozone (below about \( 10^{-5} \) of present atmospheric level) | absent |
| Detrital pyrite, uraninite, siderite in river sediments | present (Witwatersrand, Huronian) | absent: these grains oxidise during weathering |
| Palaeosols | Fe lost from the soil profile (Fe\(^{2+}\) mobile) | Fe retained as Fe\(^{3+}\) oxides |
| Red beds | rare | common |
| Sulphate evaporites | rare | appear |
The source of O\(_2\) was oxygenic photosynthesis by cyanobacteria. Whether cyanobacteria evolved shortly before the GOE or hundreds of millions of years earlier (with O\(_2\) consumed by reduced sinks such as Fe\(^{2+}\), volcanic H\(_2\) and CH\(_4\)) is debated. Either way, the GOE marks the time when O\(_2\) sources outran sinks.
Carbon isotopes as an oxygen ledger
Organic matter is depleted in \( ^{13}\text{C} \) by about 25‰ relative to carbonate formed at the same time. At steady state, carbon entering the surface system (volcanic and weathering input, \( \delta_{\text{in}} \approx -5 \)‰) leaves as carbonate and organic carbon:
$$\delta_{\text{in}} = (1 - f_{\text{org}})\,\delta_{\text{carb}} + f_{\text{org}}\,(\delta_{\text{carb}} - \Delta) \quad\Rightarrow\quad \boxed{f_{\text{org}} = \frac{\delta_{\text{carb}} - \delta_{\text{in}}}{\Delta}}$$With \( \Delta = 25 \)‰: \( \delta_{\text{carb}} = 0 \)‰ gives \( f_{\text{org}} = 0.2 \) (close to the long-term average). The Lomagundi–Jatuli excursion, with \( \delta_{\text{carb}} \) of +10‰ or more about 2.2–2.06 Ga, would need \( f_{\text{org}} \approx 0.6 \) at steady state. Burying that much organic carbon releases a matching amount of O\(_2\), so the excursion is read as a period of large O\(_2\) production soon after the GOE. Its steady-state interpretation is still argued over.
Biosphere: Metabolisms Before Animals
The fossils themselves are on Precambrian Life and the Precambrian–Cambrian Boundary in India. Here the point is how life and the other spheres changed each other.
| Approx. age | Biological innovation | Effect on the Earth system |
|---|---|---|
| by about 3.5 Ga | anoxygenic photosynthesis, methanogenesis, microbial sulphate reduction | stromatolites; CH\(_4\) greenhouse; light carbon in sediments |
| before 2.4 Ga (start debated) | oxygenic photosynthesis (cyanobacteria) | the GOE; ozone shield; oxidative weathering |
| Paleoproterozoic | eukaryotes (by about 1.8–1.6 Ga in the fossil record) | new metabolism with mitochondria; later algae |
| about 1.05 Ga and later | multicellular red algae; then green algae | larger primary producers |
| Ediacaran | large multicellular organisms; first animals with skeletons near the end | stronger biological pump; bioturbation begins |
| Cambrian | widespread burrowing and skeletons | mixing of seafloor sediment; carbonate and silica cycles change |
Life also changed the solid Earth: oxidative weathering created many new oxide, hydroxide and sulphate minerals after the GOE, and organic carbon burial altered ocean and atmospheric chemistry.
Cryosphere: Precambrian Glaciations
Glacial deposits are recognised by diamictites (poorly sorted, matrix-supported, with faceted and striated clasts), dropstones in laminated sediment, and striated pavements. A diamictite alone is not proof, since debris flows also make them; dropstones and striated clasts are more diagnostic.
| Glaciation | Approx. age | Where | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pongola | about 2.9 Ga | South Africa | oldest known glacial deposits |
| Huronian (Paleoproterozoic) | about 2.45–2.2 Ga | Ontario (Ramsay Lake, Bruce, Gowganda formations); also South Africa (Makganyene) | overlaps the GOE; loss of CH\(_4\) greenhouse as O\(_2\) rose is a favoured trigger; Makganyene may be low-latitude |
| (gap) | about 2.2–0.72 Ga | none confirmed | the long ice-free “boring billion” |
| Sturtian (Cryogenian) | about 717–660 Ma | worldwide | long; low-latitude ice; Cryogenian BIFs |
| Marinoan (Cryogenian) | ended about 635 Ma | worldwide | capped by distinctive cap dolostones; its end defines the Ediacaran base |
| Gaskiers (Ediacaran) | about 580 Ma | Newfoundland and elsewhere | short and regional, not global |
The snowball Earth hypothesis
The idea (named by J. L. Kirschvink in 1992 and developed with cap-carbonate evidence by P. F. Hoffman and colleagues in 1998) is that the Cryogenian glaciations covered the oceans with ice to the equator.
| Observation | Snowball explanation |
|---|---|
| Glacial deposits formed at low palaeolatitude (palaeomagnetism) | ice reached the tropics at sea level |
| Ice-albedo runaway | once ice passes about 30° latitude, albedo feedback drives it to the equator |
| Return of BIFs (e.g. Rapitan, Canada) | ice-covered ocean became anoxic and Fe\(^{2+}\) accumulated |
| Cap carbonates directly on glacial deposits, with negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) | volcanic CO\(_2\) built up over millions of years with no weathering sink; deglaciation was rapid and the resulting intense weathering dumped alkalinity into the sea, precipitating carbonate |
| Negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) excursions before and after | collapse of biological productivity |
Escape needs CO\(_2\) to reach very high levels (often quoted as a few hundred times present). The slushball alternative keeps open tropical water, which helps explain how photosynthetic eukaryotes survived.
Putting the Spheres Together
graph LR
H["Hadean
magma ocean, zircons,
first oceans"] --> A["Archean
TTG and greenstones,
anoxic air, stromatolites,
Pongola ice"]
A --> P1["Paleoproterozoic
GOE, Huronian ice,
Lomagundi, Columbia"]
P1 --> P2["Mesoproterozoic
boring billion,
anorthosites, Rodinia"]
P2 --> P3["Neoproterozoic
snowball Earth, NOE,
Ediacaran biota, Gondwana"]
P3 --> C["Cambrian
skeletal animals"]The spheres are coupled. Two chains Part C likes:
- Oxygen and ice: cyanobacteria produce O\(_2\) → CH\(_4\) is oxidised → the greenhouse weakens → Huronian glaciation.
- Continents and climate: breakup of Rodinia produced many low-latitude continental margins and large basaltic provinces → enhanced silicate weathering drew down CO\(_2\) → Cryogenian glaciation.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Acasta Gneiss, about 4.0 Ga: oldest intact rock | Jack Hills zircons, up to about 4.4 Ga: oldest minerals (detrital) | |
| GOE, about 2.4–2.3 Ga: first persistent O\(_2\) in the atmosphere | NOE, about 0.8–0.54 Ga: oxygenation of the deep ocean | |
| Lomagundi: positive \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) (more organic burial) | Cap carbonates and Shuram: negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) | |
| Huronian glaciation, Paleoproterozoic | Sturtian and Marinoan, Cryogenian (Neoproterozoic) | |
| Algoma-type BIF: small, volcanic-associated, in greenstone belts | Superior-type BIF: large, shelf-deposited, mostly Neoarchean to Paleoproterozoic (peak about 2.5–2.4 Ga) | |
| Primary atmosphere (nebular, lost) | Secondary atmosphere (outgassed, retained) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name the oldest well-dated intact rock on Earth and its approximate age.
- What is the IUGS minimum MgO content for a komatiite?
- Which Precambrian period has its base defined by a GSSP?
Answers
- The Acasta Gneiss (Slave craton, Canada), about 4.0 Ga.
- 18 wt% MgO.
- The Ediacaran (GSSP at Enorama Creek, Flinders Ranges, South Australia; base 635 Ma).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Relative to today, the abundance of \( ^{40}\text{K} \) in the Earth 2.5 Ga ago was about (\( \lambda_{40} = 5.543\times10^{-10}\ \text{yr}^{-1} \)):
(a) 1.4 times (b) 2.0 times (c) 4.0 times (d) 9.2 times
Answer: (c)
9.2 is the factor for 4.0 Ga. Higher K, U and Th abundances made the Archean mantle hotter.
Practice Q2. Which observation is evidence that atmospheric O\(_2\) was very low at the time of deposition?
(a) Red beds with hematite cement (b) Sulphate evaporites (c) Rounded detrital uraninite in a fluvial conglomerate (d) An oxidised palaeosol retaining Fe\(^{3+}\)
Answer: (c)
Uraninite (UO\(_2\)) oxidises to soluble U\(^{6+}\) in an oxygenated environment, so detrital grains survive transport only under a nearly anoxic atmosphere. The other three indicate oxidising conditions.
Practice Q3. The cap carbonates that directly overlie Cryogenian glacial deposits are best explained by:
(a) slow carbonate precipitation during the coldest phase of the glaciation (b) rapid deglaciation under very high CO\(_2\), followed by intense weathering and a flood of alkalinity to the ocean (c) biological reefs that grew on the ice shelf (d) hydrothermal alteration of the underlying diamictite
Answer: (b)
In the snowball model, CO\(_2\) built up for millions of years with no silicate-weathering sink. When the ice melted, weathering under a strong greenhouse delivered alkalinity that precipitated carbonate over the glacial deposits, with negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \).
Practice Q4. Mass-independent fractionation of sulphur isotopes in Archean sediments is produced by:
(a) bacterial sulphate reduction in anoxic sediments (b) UV photolysis of volcanic SO\(_2\) in an atmosphere lacking ozone (c) hydrothermal leaching of sulphides at mid-ocean ridges (d) evaporation of sea water in restricted basins
Answer: (b)
MIF-S needs photochemical reactions driven by short-wavelength UV, and preservation of the signal needs very low O\(_2\) (below about \( 10^{-5} \) of the present level). Biological and evaporative processes fractionate mass-dependently.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A detrital zircon gives a concordant radiogenic \( ^{207}\text{Pb}^*/^{206}\text{Pb}^* \) ratio of 0.550. Using \( \lambda_{238} = 1.55125\times10^{-10}\ \text{yr}^{-1} \), \( \lambda_{235} = 9.8485\times10^{-10}\ \text{yr}^{-1} \) and present \( ^{238}\text{U}/^{235}\text{U} = 137.88 \), its age is closest to:
(a) 2.7 Ga (b) 3.5 Ga (c) 4.0 Ga (d) 4.4 Ga
Answer: (d) about 4.4 Ga
Test the options:
| \( t \) (Ga) | \( e^{\lambda_{235}t}-1 \) | \( e^{\lambda_{238}t}-1 \) | ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.7 | 13.28 | 0.520 | 0.185 |
| 3.5 | 30.41 | 0.721 | 0.306 |
| 4.0 | 50.39 | 0.860 | 0.425 |
| 4.4 | 75.20 | 0.979 | 0.557 |
0.550 falls just below the 4.4 Ga value; solving exactly gives about 4.38 Ga. This is the age range of the oldest Jack Hills zircons. The Pb–Pb age needs no U/Pb measurement, only the radiogenic Pb isotope ratio, so it is robust against recent Pb loss.
Practice Q6. Using \( L(t)/L_0 = [1 + 0.4(1 - t/t_0)]^{-1} \) with \( t_0 = 4.57 \) Gyr, and a present effective temperature of 255 K, estimate Earth’s effective temperature 3.8 Ga ago, assuming unchanged albedo.
(a) 255 K (b) 247 K (c) 237 K (d) 191 K
Answer: (c) about 237 K
Time since the Sun formed: \( t = 4.57 - 3.8 = 0.77 \) Gyr, so \( t/t_0 = 0.168 \).
$$\frac{L}{L_0} = \frac{1}{1 + 0.4(0.832)} = \frac{1}{1.333} = 0.750$$Effective temperature scales as \( L^{1/4} \): \( T_e = 255 \times 0.750^{1/4} = 255 \times 0.931 \approx 237 \) K.
(d) comes from scaling \( T_e \) linearly with \( L \). A 237 K effective temperature means a much stronger greenhouse than today’s (about 33 K) was needed to keep the oceans liquid: the faint young Sun paradox.
Practice Q7. A carbonate succession shows \( \delta^{13}\text{C}_{\text{carb}} \) rising from 0‰ to +10‰. Take \( \delta_{\text{in}} = -5 \)‰ and a constant organic–carbonate offset \( \Delta = 25 \)‰, and assume steady state. Which statements are correct?
- The fraction of carbon buried as organic matter rises from 0.2 to 0.6.
- The excursion implies an increased net release of O\(_2\) to the surface environment.
- A value of \( \delta_{\text{carb}} = -5 \)‰ would imply that no organic carbon was being buried.
- An excursion to \( \delta_{\text{carb}} = -12 \)‰ can be explained at steady state by a negative \( f_{\text{org}} \).
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
\( f_{\text{org}} = (\delta_{\text{carb}} - \delta_{\text{in}})/\Delta \).
- 1 true: \( (0 + 5)/25 = 0.2 \); \( (10 + 5)/25 = 0.6 \).
- 2 true: each mole of organic carbon buried leaves a mole of O\(_2\) unconsumed. This is how the Lomagundi–Jatuli excursion is linked to oxygenation.
- 3 true: \( (-5 + 5)/25 = 0 \).
- 4 false: \( (-12 + 5)/25 = -0.28 \), which is physically impossible. Values below \( \delta_{\text{in}} \) (such as the Ediacaran Shuram excursion) require non-steady-state behaviour (for example oxidation of a large organic reservoir) or diagenetic alteration.
Quick Revision Table
| Topic | Key facts |
|---|---|
| Oldest materials | Jack Hills zircons about 4.4 Ga; Acasta Gneiss about 4.0 Ga; Isua about 3.7–3.8 Ga |
| Archean eras | Eo 4.031, Paleo 3.6, Meso 3.2, Neo 2.8, end 2.5 Ga |
| Hotter Archean | \( ^{40}\text{K} \) about 4× at 2.5 Ga; komatiites (MgO > 18 wt%); TTG crust |
| Plate tectonics onset | debated; many estimates 3.2–2.5 Ga; blueschists mostly Neoproterozoic onwards |
| Supercontinents | Kenorland about 2.7–2.5; Columbia about 2.0–1.8; Rodinia about 1.1–0.9; Gondwana about 0.65–0.5 Ga |
| Early oceans | zircon \( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) above mantle (5.3‰) by about 4.4–4.3 Ga |
| Ocean redox | ferruginous Archean → euxinic margins mid-Proterozoic → oxygenated deep ocean late Neoproterozoic |
| Faint young Sun | about 70% of present luminosity at 4.57 Ga; \( T_e \propto L^{1/4} \) |
| GOE | about 2.4–2.3 Ga; MIF-S vanishes; detrital pyrite and uraninite end; red beds |
| Carbon ledger | \( f_{\text{org}} = (\delta_{\text{carb}} - \delta_{\text{in}})/\Delta \); Lomagundi +10‰ |
| Glaciations | Pongola 2.9; Huronian 2.45–2.2; Sturtian 717–660; Marinoan to 635; Gaskiers 580 Ma |
| Snowball evidence | low-latitude tillites, BIF return, cap carbonates, negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Granite–Greenstone and Granulite Belts: the rock associations that record Archean and Proterozoic crust-building.
- Cratons, Mobile Belts and Proterozoic Basins of India: where these events are recorded in the Indian shield.
- Precambrian Geology: Quick Revision.