Identifying Synoptic Systems, Cyclones and Fog
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C satellite meteorology: cloud signatures of fronts, jets, monsoon systems, thunderstorms, the Dvorak technique and fog detection.
- 19 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Naming a Storm Without a Single Ship Report
- The Interpreter’s Toolkit
- Extratropical Systems
- Tropical and Monsoon Systems
- Tropical Cyclones and the Dvorak Technique
- Fog
- A Decision Path for a Bright Pixel
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- What VIS, IR, WV and 3.9 μm channels measure, and the bispectral and channel-difference tests, from Visible and Infrared Radiometers.
- Air masses, fronts, jets, monsoon and cyclones as weather systems, from Air Masses, Monsoon, Jet Streams, Tropical Cyclones and ENSO and Monsoon, Cyclones and ENSO.
- Condensation, fog types and cloud classification, from Humidity, Precipitation and Water Balance.
- Conditional instability and deep convection, from Vertical Stability and Tropical Convection.
The Hook: Naming a Storm Without a Single Ship Report
The Interpreter’s Toolkit
Every identification combines five clues:
| Clue | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Brightness in VIS | optical thickness: thick cloud bright, thin cloud faint |
| Brightness temperature in IR | cloud-top temperature, hence height |
| Texture | lumpy and shadow-casting = convective; smooth = stratiform; fibrous = cirrus |
| Shape and organisation | bands, commas, spirals, lines, cells, streets |
| Motion in a loop | clouds move and evolve; snow and terrain do not |
Add the WV image for upper-level flow and the channel differences for fog, dust and fire.
Cloud types in imagery
| Cloud | VIS | IR | Texture and shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cumulonimbus | very bright | very cold (often colder than 210–220 K) | round or carrot-shaped anvil with a sharp upwind edge; overshooting tops cast shadows at low Sun |
| Cumulus, congestus | bright, small elements | warm to moderately cold | lumpy, cellular, streets along the wind |
| Stratocumulus | moderately bright | warm | cells (open or closed), rolls |
| Stratus and fog | bright, uniform | warm, close to surface temperature | smooth, sharp edges that follow terrain |
| Nimbostratus, altostratus | bright | moderate to cold | extensive, uniform sheet, often with a frontal band |
| Cirrus | faint to grey | cold | fibrous, streaky, often along the jet; ground features visible through it |
Convective cell patterns
When cold air flows over a warmer sea it is heated from below and convects in cells:
- Open cells: cloud-free centres ringed by cloud. Typical of strongly heated cold air behind cold fronts over warm water.
- Closed cells: cloudy centres with clear rims. Typical of stratocumulus under a strong subsidence inversion, as off the west coasts of continents beneath the subtropical highs.
- Cloud streets: parallel rows of cumulus aligned roughly with the low-level wind, in moderate shear.
Extratropical Systems
The comma cloud and the frontal cyclone
A developing mid-latitude cyclone has a characteristic sequence in satellite imagery:
graph LR
A["Baroclinic leaf
(S-shaped cloud bulge
on a frontal band)"] --> B["Comma cloud
(cloud head + tail)"]
B --> C["Dry slot intrudes
(dark in WV)"]
C --> D["Occlusion spiral
(cloud wraps round
a cold low)"]| Feature | What it marks |
|---|---|
| Cloud head | ascent ahead of and poleward of the low centre; heavy precipitation |
| Comma tail | the cold-front cloud band, often narrow and long |
| Broad cloud shield | warm-front ascent over a large area |
| Dry slot | dry, sinking air from the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere wrapping into the system behind the cold front; dark in WV |
| Occlusion spiral | a mature or decaying cyclone; the centre lies inside the spiral |
| Open cells behind the cold front | cold air over a warm sea |
Jet streams
- In VIS and IR, a cirrus band lies on the equatorward (anticyclonic-shear) side of the jet axis; its poleward edge is sharp and straight and the jet axis runs close to that edge.
- In WV, the jet appears as a sharp boundary between moist (bright) air on the equatorward side and dry (dark) descending air on the poleward side.
- Transverse bands (ripples of cirrus at right angles to the flow) indicate strong vertical shear and turbulence.
Western disturbances
Western disturbances are eastward-moving extratropical troughs or lows embedded in the subtropical westerlies that reach northwest India mainly in winter. In imagery they appear as a cloud band or comma cloud advancing from Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan toward Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh and the plains, often with jet-stream cirrus on their equatorward flank. They bring winter rain and snow to northern India. After a disturbance passes, clear skies, light winds and moist ground favour radiation fog over the plains: one link between this section and the fog section below.
Tropical and Monsoon Systems
| System | Satellite signature |
|---|---|
| ITCZ | an east–west belt of convective clusters near the equator, shifting with the seasons; best seen in time-averaged cold-cloud or outgoing longwave radiation (OLR) maps |
| Monsoon trough | a WNW–ESE band of cloud from the head Bay of Bengal across the Gangetic plain to northwest India in the active monsoon |
| Monsoon onset over Kerala | organised deep convection over the southeast Arabian Sea and Kerala; IMD’s onset criteria include low INSAT-derived OLR over the southeast Arabian Sea, together with rainfall and wind criteria |
| Offshore trough or vortex | a band or vortex of cloud parallel to the west coast, giving heavy coastal rain |
| Monsoon depression | a large, roughly circular cloud mass forming over the head Bay of Bengal and moving west-northwest along the monsoon trough; the deep convection and heaviest rain lie mostly in the southwest sector, displaced from the low-level centre by the easterly shear of the monsoon |
| Break monsoon | cloud band shifts to the Himalayan foothills and northeast India; central India becomes largely clear |
| Easterly waves | inverted-V cloud patterns in the trade easterlies, convection mainly behind (east of) the trough axis |
| MJO | a planetary-scale envelope of enhanced convection (negative OLR anomaly) moving eastward across the Indian Ocean and Pacific over about 30–60 days |
Thunderstorms and mesoscale convective systems
| Feature | Image signature | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Overshooting top | small, very cold dome above the anvil; shadows in VIS at low Sun | strong updraft penetrating the tropopause; hail and severe weather likely |
| Enhanced-V (cold U or V) | a V-shaped cold pattern opening downwind, often with a warm spot inside it | severe storm with a strong updraft deflecting the upper flow |
| Rapid cloud-top cooling | \( T_B \) falling by several K in 15–30 min | intensifying convection; a nowcasting cue |
| Arc clouds (outflow boundaries) | a curved line of low cloud moving away from a storm | gust front; new storms may form where arcs meet |
| Squall line | a narrow line of Cb with a common anvil | organised convection; nor’westers (kalbaisakhi) in eastern India in the pre-monsoon season are frequently organised in lines |
| Mesoscale convective complex | a large, nearly circular cold cloud shield lasting many hours | the largest organised convective systems |
Maddox’s satellite definition of a mesoscale convective complex uses IR thresholds: a cloud shield colder than −32 °C covering at least 100,000 km\(^2\) with an inner region colder than −52 °C of at least 50,000 km\(^2\), persisting at least 6 hours and roughly circular (minor-to-major axis ratio at least 0.7).
Tropical Cyclones and the Dvorak Technique
What a cyclone looks like
| Stage | Satellite features |
|---|---|
| Disturbance or depression | a cluster of convection with some curvature; low-level circulation may be visible in VIS cumulus lines |
| Cyclonic storm | curved convective bands wrapping round the centre |
| Severe cyclonic storm | a central dense overcast (CDO): a solid, cold cirrus canopy over the centre |
| Very severe and stronger | an eye: a clear or warm spot at the centre, ringed by a cold eyewall; outflow cirrus spreading anticyclonically aloft |
| Sheared storm | the low-level centre exposed at the edge of the convection, which is pushed downshear |
The eye is warm because air sinks and warms adiabatically in it; a warmer eye surrounded by a colder ring of cloud tops means a stronger storm.
The Dvorak technique
The technique, developed by Vernon Dvorak at NOAA from the 1970s, assigns a T-number (tropical number) from 1 to 8 in half-steps to the cloud pattern, then converts the resulting current intensity (CI) number to a maximum sustained wind.
graph TD
A["Locate the cloud-system centre"] --> B["Identify the pattern:
curved band, shear, CDO,
embedded centre, eye"]
B --> C["Data T-number (DT)
from pattern measurements"]
A --> D["Model expected T (MET)
from the 24-h trend"]
C --> E["Final T-number
(constrained by rules)"]
D --> E
E --> F["Current intensity (CI)
and maximum wind"]| Pattern | What is measured | Direction of the effect |
|---|---|---|
| Curved band | how far the band of dense cold cloud wraps round the centre (fraction of a 10° log spiral) | more wrap, higher T |
| Shear | distance of the exposed low-level centre from the edge of the dense overcast | closer to the convection, higher T; sheared storms are generally weaker |
| CDO and embedded centre | size of the cold overcast, and how deep inside it the centre lies | larger and colder, higher T |
| Eye | temperature of the eye and of the coldest ring of cloud surrounding it, from an enhanced IR image | warmer eye and colder ring, higher T |
Typical development is about one T-number per day; the rules limit how fast the T-number may change and, during weakening, let the CI number lag behind the T-number because winds decay more slowly than the cloud pattern. The Advanced Dvorak Technique is an objective, computer-based version used alongside the manual method, and microwave imagery (85–91 GHz) is used to locate eyewalls hidden under cirrus.
From CI number to wind
Dvorak’s original conversion (one-minute mean wind):
| CI | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 3.5 | 4.0 | 4.5 | 5.0 | 5.5 | 6.0 | 6.5 | 7.0 | 7.5 | 8.0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wind (kt) | 25 | 25 | 30 | 35 | 45 | 55 | 65 | 77 | 90 | 102 | 115 | 127 | 140 | 155 | 170 |
IMD classifies systems in the north Indian Ocean by maximum sustained surface wind (3-minute average):
| IMD category | Wind (kt) |
|---|---|
| Depression | 17–27 |
| Deep depression | 28–33 |
| Cyclonic storm | 34–47 |
| Severe cyclonic storm | 48–63 |
| Very severe cyclonic storm | 64–89 |
| Extremely severe cyclonic storm | 90–119 |
| Super cyclonic storm | 120 and above |
IMD uses its own adapted T-number-to-wind relation for the north Indian Ocean; the practice questions on this page simply use the table above.
Fog
Why fog is a satellite problem
Fog is a cloud whose base touches the ground. Its top is low and almost as warm as the surface, so in a single IR image it nearly disappears, especially at night when the ground has cooled to about the fog-top temperature. The satellite sees only the top: it cannot tell fog from low stratus whose base is above the ground. Surface visibility reports, ceilometers and models settle that.
Over the Indo-Gangetic plain, dense radiation fog is common in December and January: long nights, light winds, high near-surface humidity (irrigated fields, winter rain from western disturbances) and a shallow inversion. It often forms after midnight, is densest around sunrise and clears from its edges in the late morning or persists all day under a strong inversion.
Daytime detection
- VIS: a bright, smooth, uniform, textureless sheet with sharp edges that follow terrain, such as the Himalayan foothills, river valleys and coastlines; no shadows; little motion in a loop except slow erosion from the edges.
- 3.9 μm by day: small water droplets reflect sunlight strongly at 3.9 μm, so fog and low water cloud look anomalously warm compared with 10.8 μm.
- IR: nearly the same temperature as clear land: little help.
Night-time detection: the 10.8 − 3.9 μm test
At night only emission counts. Water-droplet clouds have a lower emissivity at 3.9 μm than at 10.8 μm (droplets of fog size are nearly black at 10.8 μm but not at 3.9 μm). So over fog and low stratus
$$\boxed{\Delta T = T_B(10.8) - T_B(3.9) > 0\ \text{(a few kelvin)}}$$while over clear land and sea \( \Delta T \) is near zero. A map of \( \Delta T \) shows the fog as a bright sheet. INSAT-3D and INSAT-3DR fog products over north India use this difference.
Related surface phenomena
| Phenomenon | Signature |
|---|---|
| Dust storm | VIS: diffuse, brownish, no sharp texture; IR: cooler than the ground by day; \( T_B(10.8) - T_B(12.0) \) negative; common over Rajasthan and the northwest in the pre-monsoon season |
| Smoke, haze | VIS: grey veil, especially at low Sun; little IR signal; seen over the Indo-Gangetic plain in post-monsoon crop-residue burning |
| Snow | bright in VIS, dark at 1.6 μm; fixed to terrain, does not move in a loop |
| Volcanic ash | negative split-window difference like dust |
A Decision Path for a Bright Pixel
graph TD
A["Bright in VIS (day)"] --> B{"Cold in IR?"}
B -->|"Very cold, lumpy"| C["Deep convection (Cb)"]
B -->|"Moderate, smooth"| D["Mid-level or frontal cloud"]
B -->|"Warm"| E{"Moves in loop?"}
E -->|"No, dark at 1.6 um"| F["Snow or ice"]
E -->|"Slowly; smooth; terrain edges"| G["Fog or low stratus"]
E -->|"Diffuse, split-window negative"| H["Dust"]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | Distinction |
|---|---|
| Fog vs low stratus | base on the ground vs base above it; satellites see only the top and cannot tell them apart alone |
| Open vs closed cells | cloud rims round clear centres (strong heating from below) vs cloudy centres with clear rims (under a subsidence inversion) |
| Dust vs cirrus in split window | \( T_{11} - T_{12} \) negative vs positive |
| Snow vs cloud | fixed, dark at 1.6 μm vs moving, water cloud bright at 1.6 μm |
| T-number vs CI number | pattern-based analysis number vs the final intensity number, which may lag during weakening |
| Monsoon depression vs tropical cyclone | weaker, broad, convection displaced southwest, forms in the monsoon trough vs compact, convection symmetric round an eye when mature |
| Overshooting top vs anvil | small cold dome above the tropopause vs flat cirrus spreading at about the tropopause |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- In a satellite image, what is a “dry slot”?
- What is the CI number of a cyclone whose Dvorak conversion gives 90 kt?
- Why is a fog layer hard to see in a single 10.8 μm image at night?
Answers
- A tongue of dry, descending air (dark in WV, often cloud-free) wrapping into a mid-latitude cyclone behind its cold front.
- CI 5.0.
- Its top is nearly as warm as the surrounding ground, so its brightness temperature hardly differs from the clear land.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. In a winter IR image over the Arabian Sea north of 20° N, cold air flowing off the land shows a pattern of cloud rings with clear centres. These are:
(a) closed cells under a subsidence inversion (b) open cells in air heated from below (c) transverse bands of a jet (d) a central dense overcast
Answer: (b)
Cloud-free centres ringed by cloud are open cells, produced when cold air is strongly heated by a warmer sea. Closed cells have cloudy centres.
Practice Q2. A Bay of Bengal cyclone is analysed at CI 4.5. Using the Dvorak table on this page and IMD’s wind categories, it would be classed as:
(a) severe cyclonic storm (b) very severe cyclonic storm (c) extremely severe cyclonic storm (d) super cyclonic storm
Answer: (b)
CI 4.5 corresponds to 77 kt, which falls in 64–89 kt, very severe cyclonic storm.
Practice Q3. In a 6.7 μm image, a long dark tongue curls into the southwest flank of a mature mid-latitude cyclone. The tongue is best interpreted as:
(a) a moist conveyor belt (b) a dry intrusion of descending upper-level air (c) a fog bank (d) a sea-surface warm anomaly
Answer: (b)
Dark in WV means dry aloft. The dry intrusion descends from the upper troposphere behind the cold front, forming the dry slot. The WV channel does not see fog or the sea.
Practice Q4. Which feature in an IR image is the strongest indicator of a severe thunderstorm with a strong updraft?
(a) a broad, warm anvil (b) an enhanced-V with an overshooting top (c) closed stratocumulus cells (d) a smooth uniform cloud sheet with sharp edges
Answer: (b)
Overshooting tops and the enhanced-V signature mark updrafts strong enough to penetrate the tropopause and deflect the upper flow. (d) describes fog or stratus.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Night-time brightness temperatures (K) over north India in January:
| Pixel | \( T_B(10.8) \) | \( T_B(3.9) \) | \( T_B(10.8) - T_B(12.0) \) |
|---|---|---|---|
| W | 281.0 | 276.5 | 0.4 |
| X | 283.5 | 283.2 | 0.6 |
| Y | 228.0 | 229.5 | 3.8 |
| Z | 279.8 | 275.9 | 0.3 |
Which statements are correct?
(A) W and Z are probably fog or low stratus. (B) X is probably clear land. (C) Y is probably semi-transparent cirrus, and any fog beneath it cannot be detected by this test. (D) The test proves that the base of the layer at W is at ground level.
(a) A and B (b) A, B and C (c) A, C and D (d) all four
Answer: (b) A, B and C
\( \Delta T = T_{10.8} - T_{3.9} \): W +4.5 K, X +0.3 K, Y −1.5 K, Z +3.9 K. W and Z show the positive difference of low water cloud; X is near zero, as for clear land. Y is cold with a large positive split-window difference, the signature of thin ice cloud, which masks anything below. (D) is wrong: the satellite sees only the top; fog versus low stratus needs surface visibility.
Practice Q6. A cyclone in the Bay of Bengal is analysed at CI 3.0 at 00 UTC on day 1. It develops at the typical rate of about one T-number per day. Which statements are correct?
(A) At 00 UTC on day 1 its Dvorak wind is 45 kt (cyclonic storm by IMD’s categories). (B) By 00 UTC on day 3 it would be expected near CI 5.0, about 90 kt, extremely severe. (C) Its eye, if one appears, should become warmer as it intensifies. (D) During later weakening, the CI number may stay higher than the T-number for a time.
(a) A and B (b) A, B and C (c) A, C and D (d) A, B, C and D
Answer: (d) all four
CI 3.0 is 45 kt (34–47 kt, cyclonic storm). Two days at one T-number per day gives CI 5.0, 90 kt (90–119 kt, extremely severe). A warmer eye inside a colder ring raises the eye-pattern T-number. The Dvorak rules let CI lag T during weakening because winds respond more slowly than the cloud pattern.
Practice Q7. Over central and eastern India in mid-July, a sequence of daily images shows: (i) a large cloud mass forming over the head Bay of Bengal, moving west-northwest, with most deep convection southwest of the low-level centre; (ii) a week later, central India largely clear and a cloud band along the Himalayan foothills. The best interpretation is:
(a) (i) a western disturbance; (ii) monsoon onset (b) (i) a monsoon depression; (ii) a break in the monsoon (c) (i) a severe cyclonic storm with an eye; (ii) an active monsoon (d) (i) an easterly wave; (ii) the ITCZ withdrawing south of the equator
Answer: (b)
A west-northwestward-moving system from the head Bay, with convection displaced southwest by the monsoon’s easterly shear, is a monsoon depression. A shift of the cloud band to the foothills with clear skies over central India is the classic break. Western disturbances are winter systems from the west; an eye was not described; the ITCZ does not withdraw south of the equator in July.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Clues | brightness (VIS), temperature (IR), texture, shape, motion; WV for upper flow |
| Cells | open: clear centres, heated cold air; closed: cloudy centres, under inversion |
| Mid-latitude cyclone | baroclinic leaf → comma → dry slot → occlusion spiral |
| Jet | cirrus on equatorward side; sharp poleward edge = axis; WV moist–dry boundary |
| Western disturbance | winter cloud band or comma from the west; rain and snow in north India; fog after it |
| Monsoon depression | head Bay, moves WNW; convection and rain in SW sector |
| Break | cloud band at Himalayan foothills; central India clear |
| Severe storm | overshooting tops, enhanced-V, rapid top cooling |
| MCC (Maddox) | ≤ −32 °C over ≥ 100,000 km\(^2\); ≤ −52 °C over ≥ 50,000 km\(^2\); ≥ 6 h; axis ratio ≥ 0.7 |
| Cyclone patterns | curved band → CDO → eye; shear pattern weaker |
| Dvorak | T 1–8; typical +1 per day; CI 3.0 = 45, 4.0 = 65, 5.0 = 90, 6.0 = 115, 7.0 = 140, 8.0 = 170 kt |
| IMD categories (kt) | D 17–27, DD 28–33, CS 34–47, SCS 48–63, VSCS 64–89, ESCS 90–119, SuCS ≥ 120 |
| Fog by day | bright, smooth, terrain-bound edges; warm at 3.9 μm |
| Fog at night | \( T_{10.8} - T_{3.9} > 0 \) by a few K; fails under cirrus and near dawn and dusk |
| Dust | split window negative; Rajasthan pre-monsoon |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Retrieval of SST, Cloud-Top Temperature, Winds, Rainfall and Soundings: from recognising systems to measuring them.
- Revise the dynamics of the systems themselves in Air Masses, Monsoon, Jet Streams, Tropical Cyclones and ENSO.
- Back to the chapter overview.