Earth's Climatic History
Climate controls and proxies, Precambrian and Phanerozoic ice ages, greenhouse episodes, Cenozoic cooling, Milankovitch cycles and the Quaternary for CSIR NET.
- 19 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Stratigraphy, Origin of Life and the Fossil Record: the Great Oxidation Event and the history of life that climate both shaped and was shaped by.
- Geological Time and Radiometric Dating: the periods and boundary ages used on this page.
- Facies, Depositional Environments, Basins and Diagenesis: tillites, evaporites, coals and reefs are the climate-sensitive facies.
The Hook: Eight Hundred Thousand Years in a Column of Ice
What Controls Climate
| Control | Timescale | How it works |
|---|---|---|
| Solar luminosity | Billions of years | The Sun brightens slowly; it was roughly 25–30% fainter early in Earth history |
| Plate tectonics and palaeogeography | Tens to hundreds of Myr | Continents over the poles allow ice sheets; ocean gateways redirect heat; mountains raise weathering and alter circulation |
| Carbon cycle (CO₂) | Thousands to millions of years | Volcanic outgassing adds CO₂; silicate weathering and organic-carbon burial remove it |
| Orbital (Milankovitch) forcing | 10⁴–10⁵ years | Changes in eccentricity, obliquity and precession redistribute insolation by season and latitude |
| Ocean circulation | Decades to millennia | Thermohaline overturning moves heat between hemispheres |
| Volcanic aerosols, solar variability | Years to centuries | Sulphate aerosols cool for a few years after large eruptions |
Feedbacks
- Ice–albedo feedback (positive): more ice reflects more sunlight, causing further cooling. It can run away into a “snowball” state.
- Water-vapour feedback (positive): warmer air holds more water vapour, a greenhouse gas.
- Silicate-weathering feedback (negative): the long-term thermostat. Warmer, wetter climates weather silicate rocks faster, which consumes CO₂ (summarised by the Urey reaction):
Over millions of years this feedback keeps climate within habitable limits, but it is too slow to offset rapid CO₂ additions.
Two hypotheses about long-term CO₂
- BLAG (Berner, Lasaga and Garrels, 1983): long-term CO₂ is set mainly by outgassing rates, which follow seafloor-spreading rates.
- Uplift–weathering (Raymo and Ruddiman): uplift of the Himalaya and Tibetan Plateau since the Eocene raised chemical weathering rates and drew down CO₂, driving Cenozoic cooling. Rising seawater ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr through the Cenozoic is used as supporting evidence, though it can also reflect the weathering of radiogenic Himalayan rocks rather than total weathering flux.
Reading Past Climate: Proxies
| Proxy | Records | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Tillites, striated pavements, dropstones | Glaciation | Diamictite alone is not proof of ice |
| Evaporites | Arid climate, high evaporation | Mostly in subtropical belts |
| Coal | Humid climate, high plant productivity, waterlogging | Tropical or temperate wetlands |
| Laterite, bauxite, kaolinite-rich palaeosols | Warm, humid, intense leaching | |
| Calcrete (pedogenic carbonate) | Semi-arid, seasonal | δ¹³C of soil carbonate records C3 vs C4 vegetation |
| Reefs, ooids, thick carbonates | Warm, shallow tropical seas | |
| Aeolian sandstones, loess | Aridity, strong winds; loess also glacial grinding | |
| δ¹⁸O of foraminifera | Temperature + global ice volume | Benthic forams record deep-water temperature and ice volume; planktonic forams surface conditions |
| Mg/Ca in forams | Temperature | Separates temperature from the ice-volume part of δ¹⁸O |
| Alkenones (U^K’₃₇), TEX₈₆ | Sea-surface temperature | Organic biomarkers from haptophyte algae and archaea |
| δ¹³C of carbonates and organic matter | Carbon cycle perturbations, productivity, burial | Negative excursions mark release of isotopically light carbon |
| Boron isotopes (δ¹¹B), stomatal index, alkenone δ¹³C | Past CO₂ | |
| Ice cores | Temperature (δD, δ¹⁸O of ice), CO₂ and CH₄ (bubbles), dust, volcanic sulphate | Up to about 800 kyr (Antarctica) |
| Speleothems | Rainfall and monsoon strength (δ¹⁸O), precisely dated by U–Th | Key monsoon archives |
| Tree rings, corals, varves | Annual resolution | Last few thousand years (tree rings, corals) to longer for varves |
| Pollen, plant fossils (leaf margin analysis) | Vegetation, temperature, rainfall |
Two effects raise the δ¹⁸O of foraminiferal calcite:
- Colder water: calcite takes up relatively more ¹⁸O at lower temperature, roughly +0.2 to +0.25‰ per 1 °C of cooling.
- Bigger ice sheets: ice is built from isotopically light precipitation (¹⁶O-rich), leaving the ocean enriched in ¹⁸O.
So higher δ¹⁸O = colder and/or more ice. Separating the two needs an independent temperature proxy (Mg/Ca) or a sea-level estimate.
A Tour Through Climate History
graph LR
A["Archean
warm despite
faint Sun"] --> B["Huronian glaciation
about 2.4-2.2 Ga
with the GOE"]
B --> C["Long mild interval
about 1.8-0.8 Ga"]
C --> D["Cryogenian
Snowball Earth
Sturtian, Marinoan"]
D --> E["Late Ordovician
Hirnantian ice"]
E --> F["Late Paleozoic
Ice Age
Gondwana"]
F --> G["Mesozoic and
early Cenozoic
greenhouse"]
G --> H["Cenozoic cooling
Antarctic ice 34 Ma
Northern ice 2.7 Ma"]
H --> I["Quaternary
glacial cycles
Holocene"]Precambrian
- Faint young Sun paradox. With a Sun about 25–30% fainter, a modern atmosphere would leave the early oceans frozen, yet sedimentary rocks show liquid water from the early Archean. The usual answer is a much stronger greenhouse: higher CO₂ and probably methane, possibly with lower albedo.
- Huronian glaciation (about 2.4–2.2 Ga). Glacial deposits in North America and elsewhere, overlapping in time with the Great Oxidation Event. One hypothesis: rising oxygen destroyed atmospheric methane, removing part of the greenhouse.
- A long, mild interval (roughly 1.8–0.8 Ga, sometimes nicknamed the “boring billion”) with little evidence of glaciation.
- Cryogenian “Snowball Earth” (the Sturtian glaciation from about 717 Ma to about 660 Ma, and the Marinoan, ending about 635 Ma). Evidence:
- glacial deposits that palaeomagnetism places at low (tropical) latitudes;
- cap carbonates: thin, unusual dolostones and limestones directly on top of the tillites, recording rapid deglaciation and ocean alkalinity;
- the brief return of banded iron formations, implying anoxic, iron-rich oceans under ice cover;
- large negative δ¹³C excursions. Escape is thought to have come from volcanic CO₂ accumulating while weathering was shut down, then a rapid greenhouse melt. Whether the oceans froze completely (“hard” snowball) or kept open water (“slushball”) is debated.
- Gaskiers glaciation (about 580 Ma), shorter and regional, in the Ediacaran.
Paleozoic
- Cambrian–Ordovician: generally warm, high sea level, broad epeiric seas.
- Late Ordovician (Hirnantian) glaciation (about 445 Ma): ice sheets on Gondwana over the South Pole (North Africa); sea-level fall and cooling contributed to the end-Ordovician mass extinction.
- Devonian: spread of land plants and the first forests; deeper roots and soils increased weathering and may have drawn down CO₂; repeated anoxic events in the Late Devonian.
- Late Paleozoic Ice Age (LPIA) (roughly mid-Carboniferous to mid-Permian, with peak glaciation around the Carboniferous–Permian transition): repeated glaciations across Gondwana (South America, Africa, Antarctica, Australia and India, where the Talchir Formation records glacial and glaciomarine deposits at the base of the Gondwana Supergroup). Drivers: Gondwana over the South Pole, and CO₂ drawdown by burial of plant carbon in vast coal swamps. Glacio-eustatic sea-level swings produced cyclothems in the Northern Hemisphere coal basins.
- Permian: drying and warming as Pangaea assembled; huge evaporite basins; the end-Permian extinction coincides with Siberian Traps volcanism, extreme warming and ocean anoxia.
Mesozoic greenhouse
- Triassic: hot, arid interior of Pangaea; strong seasonal megamonsoon circulation around the Tethys.
- Jurassic–Cretaceous: generally warm, with no large permanent ice sheets for most of the interval; high sea levels flooded continents; high-latitude forests and reptiles indicate mild polar climates.
- Mid-Cretaceous hothouse, with Oceanic Anoxic Events (OAEs): episodes of widespread black-shale deposition and positive δ¹³C excursions (organic carbon burial), the best known at the Cenomanian–Turonian boundary (OAE 2, about 94 Ma). Large igneous provinces are the favoured trigger.
- Late Cretaceous cooling, then the end-Cretaceous perturbation (Chicxulub impact; Deccan Traps volcanism).
Cenozoic: from hothouse to icehouse
| Event | Age | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) | 56 Ma | Rapid release of isotopically light carbon: a negative δ¹³C excursion of several per mil; global warming of roughly 5–8 °C; ocean acidification (CCD shoaled, carbonate dissolution); benthic foraminiferal extinction; mammal dispersals. Recovery took on the order of 100–200 kyr. It defines the base of the Eocene (Dababiya GSSP) |
| Early Eocene Climatic Optimum | about 53–49 Ma | Warmest sustained interval of the Cenozoic |
| Long cooling | Middle–late Eocene | Falling CO₂; India–Asia collision under way |
| Eocene–Oligocene Transition | about 34 Ma | Rapid growth of a continent-scale Antarctic ice sheet; a stepwise benthic δ¹⁸O increase; deepening of the CCD. Opening of the Drake Passage and Tasmanian Gateway (isolating Antarctica within the circumpolar current) and declining CO₂ are the two main explanations, probably acting together |
| Mid-Miocene Climatic Optimum | about 17–15 Ma | Temporary warmth, overlapping Columbia River flood basalts |
| Middle Miocene cooling | about 14 Ma | Expansion of the East Antarctic ice sheet |
| Late Miocene | about 8–6 Ma | Expansion of C4 grasses (seen in δ¹³C of soil carbonates and tooth enamel in the Siwalik sediments of the Himalayan foreland); intensification of aridity in parts of Asia and Africa |
| Mid-Pliocene warm period | about 3 Ma | Temperatures a few degrees above pre-industrial, with CO₂ similar to today’s; higher sea level |
| Onset of major Northern Hemisphere glaciation | about 2.7 Ma | Ice sheets on North America and Eurasia; ice-rafted debris in the North Atlantic. The closure of the Central American Seaway is one suggested contributor |
| Mid-Pleistocene Transition | about 1.2–0.7 Ma | Glacial cycles change from about 41 kyr (low amplitude) to about 100 kyr (high amplitude, sawtooth) without a matching change in orbital forcing |
Quaternary glacial cycles
- The Quaternary begins at 2.58 Ma. Marine sediments record dozens of glacial–interglacial cycles, numbered as Marine Isotope Stages (MIS): odd numbers are warm (MIS 1 is the Holocene, MIS 5e the last interglacial), even numbers cold (MIS 2 includes the Last Glacial Maximum).
- Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), roughly 26–19 ka: global sea level about 120–130 m below present; CO₂ about 180–190 ppm; vast ice sheets over North America and northern Europe.
- Millennial-scale variability during glacials: Dansgaard–Oeschger events (abrupt Greenland warmings followed by slower cooling) and Heinrich events (armadas of icebergs depositing ice-rafted debris layers across the North Atlantic).
- Deglaciation with the warm Bølling–Allerød interval and the cold Younger Dryas (about 12.9–11.7 ka), whose end defines the base of the Holocene (11.7 ka).
- Holocene: an early-to-middle Holocene warm and wet phase in many regions (stronger Northern Hemisphere summer insolation, stronger monsoons), the 8.2 ka cooling event (meltwater pulse into the North Atlantic), the 4.2 ka event (aridity in many low-latitude regions; its record in a Meghalaya stalagmite defines the base of the Meghalayan Stage), the Medieval Climate Anomaly and the Little Ice Age.
Milankovitch Cycles
Milutin Milanković calculated how changes in Earth’s orbit alter the seasonal and latitudinal distribution of sunlight, and proposed that summer insolation at high northern latitudes (about 65°N) controls whether snow survives the summer and ice sheets grow. Hays, Imbrie and Shackleton (1976) found the predicted periods in deep-sea sediment cores.
| Parameter | What changes | Range | Main periods |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eccentricity | Shape of the orbit (near-circular to slightly elliptical) | About 0.005–0.06 (today about 0.017) | About 100 kyr and 405 kyr |
| Obliquity (axial tilt) | Seasonal contrast, especially at high latitudes | About 22.1°–24.5° (today about 23.4°) | About 41 kyr |
| Climatic precession | Timing of perihelion relative to the seasons | Modulated by eccentricity | About 19 and 23 kyr (average about 21 kyr) |
Key points:
- Eccentricity changes total annual insolation only slightly; it matters mostly by modulating the amplitude of precession.
- Obliquity dominates high-latitude insolation; precession dominates low-latitude insolation and monsoons (speleothem monsoon records show strong ~23 kyr cycles).
- The 100-kyr problem: late Pleistocene cycles follow eccentricity’s period although its direct forcing is weak, so internal feedbacks (ice-sheet dynamics, CO₂, ocean circulation) must amplify it.
- Orbital cycles in pre-Quaternary rocks (limestone–marl couplets, sapropels, bundles of 4–5 precession beds within 100-kyr eccentricity bundles) support cyclostratigraphy and astronomical tuning of the time scale.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | Difference |
|---|---|
| Glacial vs interglacial vs ice age | Cold phase vs warm phase within an ice age vs a long interval with polar ice (we live in one) |
| Icehouse vs greenhouse | Permanent polar ice vs no large ice sheets |
| δ¹⁸O vs δ¹³C excursions | Temperature/ice volume vs carbon cycle (release or burial of light carbon) |
| Negative vs positive δ¹³C excursion | Release of ¹²C-rich carbon (PETM) vs burial of organic carbon (OAEs) |
| Huronian vs Cryogenian glaciation | Paleoproterozoic, linked to the GOE vs Neoproterozoic Snowball Earth with cap carbonates |
| Hirnantian vs LPIA | Short Late Ordovician glaciation vs long Carboniferous–Permian Gondwana glaciation |
| Eccentricity vs precession | Orbital shape (100, 405 kyr) vs season of perihelion (19–23 kyr) |
| Obliquity vs axial precession | Tilt angle vs direction of the axis |
| Dansgaard–Oeschger vs Heinrich events | Abrupt warmings in Greenland vs iceberg discharge layers in the North Atlantic |
| PETM vs K–Pg | Carbon-release warming at 56 Ma vs impact and volcanism with extinction at 66 Ma |
| LGM vs Younger Dryas | Maximum ice extent about 21 ka vs brief cold reversal 12.9–11.7 ka during deglaciation |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which orbital parameter has a period of about 41 kyr?
- What sediment type directly overlies Cryogenian glacial deposits worldwide?
- At about what age did a continent-scale ice sheet first form on Antarctica?
Answers
- Obliquity (axial tilt).
- Cap carbonates.
- About 34 Ma, at the Eocene–Oligocene transition.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A benthic foraminiferal δ¹⁸O record shows an abrupt increase of about 1‰ at about 34 Ma. The best interpretation is:
- (a) warming of deep water by about 4 °C
- (b) growth of a large Antarctic ice sheet, with some deep-water cooling
- (c) the PETM
- (d) melting of the Greenland ice sheet
Answer and explanation
(b). An increase in δ¹⁸O means cooling and/or ice growth. At 34 Ma this is the Eocene–Oligocene transition, when Antarctic ice expanded. (a) has the wrong sign; the PETM (56 Ma) was a warming with a δ¹⁸O decrease; Greenland ice did not exist on a large scale then.
Q2 (practice). Which observation is the strongest evidence for a negative carbon-cycle feedback that stabilises climate over millions of years?
- (a) Ice-albedo feedback during glaciations
- (b) Faster silicate weathering under warm, wet climates, consuming CO₂
- (c) Increase of water vapour with temperature
- (d) Release of methane from permafrost on warming
Answer and explanation
(b). The silicate-weathering thermostat is a negative feedback: warming raises weathering, which removes CO₂ and cools. (a), (c) and (d) are positive feedbacks.
Q3 (practice). The Late Paleozoic Ice Age is recorded in India mainly by:
- (a) the Siwalik Group
- (b) the Talchir Formation at the base of the Gondwana Supergroup
- (c) the Deccan intertrappean beds
- (d) the Karewa Group
Answer and explanation
(b). The Talchir Formation contains tillites, varve-like rhythmites and dropstone-bearing shales of glacial and glaciomarine origin. The Siwaliks and Karewas are Neogene–Quaternary; the intertrappeans are latest Cretaceous–Paleocene.
Q4 (practice). Which pairing of event and dominant δ¹³C signal is correct?
- (a) PETM: positive excursion from organic carbon burial
- (b) Cenomanian–Turonian OAE 2: positive excursion from organic carbon burial
- (c) Cryogenian cap carbonates: positive excursion only
- (d) Last Glacial Maximum: positive excursion of about 10‰
Answer and explanation
(b). Burial of large amounts of ¹²C-rich organic matter during OAE 2 left the ocean–atmosphere carbon heavier, giving a positive excursion. The PETM shows a negative excursion; cap carbonates commonly show negative values; glacial–interglacial δ¹³C changes are a fraction of a per mil, not 10‰.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). A palaeotemperature equation for calcite is \( T = 16.9 - 4.38(\delta_c - \delta_w) + 0.10(\delta_c - \delta_w)^2 \), with \( T \) in °C, \( \delta_c \) the calcite δ¹⁸O and \( \delta_w \) the seawater δ¹⁸O (both in ‰ on their standard scales).
(i) A glacial-age planktonic foraminifer from mid-latitude surface water has \( \delta_c = +2.0 \)‰. Calculate \( T \) assuming \( \delta_w = 0 \)‰ (no ice-volume correction). (ii) Recalculate with \( \delta_w = +1.0 \)‰. (iii) Show that \( \delta_w \approx +1.1 \)‰ is reasonable for the LGM if sea level was 120 m lower, the mean ocean depth is 3,800 m and the extra ice had a δ¹⁸O of −35‰.
Answer and worked solution
- \( \Delta = 2.0 \): \( T = 16.9 - 8.76 + 0.40 = 8.5 \) °C.
- \( \Delta = 1.0 \): \( T = 16.9 - 4.38 + 0.10 = 12.6 \) °C. Ignoring ice volume underestimates temperature by about 4 °C.
- Mass balance: the fraction of ocean water locked in ice is about \( 120/3800 = 0.032 \). Removing water with δ¹⁸O = −35‰ shifts the remaining ocean by about \( 0.032 \times 35 = +1.1 \)‰. So \( \delta_w \approx +1.1 \)‰ at the LGM, close to the value assumed in (ii).
The lesson: of a glacial–interglacial benthic δ¹⁸O change of about 1.8‰, roughly 1.0–1.1‰ is ice volume, and the remainder is deep-water cooling.
Q2 (practice). At the PETM, assume the ocean–atmosphere carbon reservoir held 40,000 Gt C with δ¹³C = 0‰, and that a carbon release lowered the reservoir to −3‰ (ignore all other fluxes).
(i) How much carbon is needed if the source was biogenic methane (δ¹³C = −60‰)? (ii) If the source was organic carbon (δ¹³C = −25‰)? (iii) What other observation would help distinguish the two?
Answer and worked solution
Mass balance: \( M_r\delta_r + M_s\delta_s = (M_r + M_s)\delta_{final} \), which rearranges to \( M_s(\delta_s - \delta_{final}) = M_r(\delta_{final} - \delta_r) \). Here \( M_r = 40{,}000 \) Gt C, \( \delta_r = 0 \) and \( \delta_{final} = -3 \)‰.
- Methane: \( M_s(-60 + 3) = 40000(-3) \) → \( M_s = 120000/57 = \) about 2,100 Gt C.
- Organic carbon: \( M_s(-25 + 3) = 40000(-3) \) → \( M_s = 120000/22 = \) about 5,500 Gt C.
- The amount of warming and of ocean acidification (CCD shoaling, carbonate dissolution) scales with the total carbon added. If dissolution in deep-sea cores implies more carbon than 2,100 Gt, a methane-only source cannot explain it; a larger, isotopically heavier source (volcanic–thermogenic or organic carbon) fits better.
Q3 (practice). A Cretaceous pelagic section shows limestone–marl couplets each about 20 cm thick, grouped in bundles of five couplets, and super-bundles in which bundle thickness rises and falls with a period of four bundles. Which statements are correct?
A. If each couplet represents one precession cycle (take 21 kyr), the compacted accumulation rate is about 0.95 cm/kyr.
B. Bundles of five couplets probably record the ~100 kyr eccentricity cycle.
C. Super-bundles of four bundles fit the ~405 kyr eccentricity cycle.
D. The couplets must record obliquity because Cretaceous climate had no ice sheets.
(a) A, B and C only
(b) A and D only
(c) B and D only
(d) A, B, C and D
Answer and explanation
(a) A, B and C.
- A: 20 cm / 21 kyr = 0.95 cm/kyr. Correct.
- B: 5 × 21 kyr = 105 kyr, about the short eccentricity period. Correct.
- C: 4 × ~100 kyr ≈ 400 kyr, matching the 405 kyr long eccentricity cycle. Correct.
- D: wrong. Precession affects low-latitude insolation, monsoons and runoff whether or not ice exists; the 5 : 1 bundling is the signature of precession modulated by eccentricity, not obliquity.
Quick Revision Table
| Topic | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Faint young Sun | Sun about 25–30% fainter early; strong greenhouse (CO₂, CH₄) kept water liquid |
| Silicate thermostat | CaSiO₃ + CO₂ → CaCO₃ + SiO₂; negative feedback over Myr |
| Huronian | About 2.4–2.2 Ga; linked to the GOE |
| Cryogenian Snowball | Sturtian (about 717–660 Ma), Marinoan (ends about 635 Ma); low-latitude tillites, cap carbonates, BIF return |
| Gaskiers | About 580 Ma |
| Hirnantian | About 445 Ma, Gondwana ice; end-Ordovician extinction |
| LPIA | Carboniferous–Permian; Gondwana tillites incl. Talchir; cyclothems |
| Mesozoic | Greenhouse; Pangaea megamonsoon; Cretaceous OAEs (OAE 2 about 94 Ma) |
| PETM | 56 Ma; negative δ¹³C excursion; +5–8 °C; acidification |
| EECO | About 53–49 Ma |
| Antarctic ice | About 34 Ma (Eocene–Oligocene transition) |
| MMCO | About 17–15 Ma |
| C4 expansion | Late Miocene, seen in Siwalik soil carbonates |
| Northern ice | About 2.7 Ma |
| MPT | About 1.2–0.7 Ma, 41 → 100 kyr cycles |
| LGM | About 26–19 ka; sea level −120 to −130 m; CO₂ about 180–190 ppm |
| Younger Dryas | 12.9–11.7 ka; end = base of Holocene |
| Holocene events | 8.2 ka, 4.2 ka (Meghalayan base), MCA, LIA |
| Milankovitch | Eccentricity 100 and 405 kyr; obliquity 41 kyr (22.1–24.5°); precession 19–23 kyr |
| δ¹⁸O | Higher = colder and/or more ice; about 0.2–0.25‰ per °C |
| MIS | Odd = warm (MIS 1, 5e); even = cold (MIS 2) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Phanerozoic Stratigraphy of India: Talchir tillites, Gondwana coals, Deccan Traps and Siwalik soils as Indian climate archives.
- Stratigraphic Code, Correlation and Sequence Stratigraphy: glacio-eustasy and cyclostratigraphy in correlation.
- Surface Energy Balance: the radiation physics behind greenhouse forcing.
- Sedimentology and Stratigraphy: the chapter map.