Deformation Mechanisms and Shear Zones
CSIR NET Geology Part C: cataclasis, pressure solution, dislocation and diffusion creep, recrystallisation, flow laws, fault rocks, mylonites, shear senses.
- 17 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Failure criteria and friction from Stress, Mohr Circle, Failure Criteria and Fault Reactivation: they govern the brittle field above.
- Simple shear, \( \tan 2\theta' = 2/\gamma \) and fabric symmetry from Strain Ellipsoid, Tectonic Fabrics and Strain Analysis.
- Rock-forming minerals and metamorphic textures, from Minerals and Rocks.
The Hook: One Fault, Two Rocks
Deformation Mechanisms
The big picture
| Group | Mechanisms | Conditions favouring it | Pressure-sensitive? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brittle (frictional) | microcracking, cataclasis, frictional sliding | low temperature, high strain rate, low confining pressure | yes; dilatant |
| Diffusive mass transfer | pressure solution (dissolution–precipitation creep); solid-state diffusion creep | fluid present (pressure solution), fine grain size, low stress | no |
| Crystal plasticity | dislocation glide, mechanical twinning, dislocation creep (glide plus climb) | higher temperature, moderate to high stress | no |
| Grain-boundary sliding | sliding accommodated by diffusion or dislocations; superplastic flow | very fine grain size, high temperature | no |
The useful scaling is the homologous temperature \( T/T_m \) (absolute temperature over the melting temperature). Diffusion and climb become important at about \( T/T_m > 0.3 \)–0.5, which is why quartz and calcite flow at mid-crustal temperatures while feldspar and olivine stay strong.
Cataclasis
Cataclasis is deformation by fracturing of grains, rotation and frictional sliding of the fragments. It reduces grain size, is strongly dependent on confining pressure, increases volume (dilatancy) and produces cataclasites and gouge. Cataclastic flow can look ductile at the outcrop scale while being brittle at the grain scale: “ductile” describes distributed deformation, not the mechanism.
Pressure solution
Under differential stress and in the presence of an intergranular fluid, material dissolves where grains are pressed together (high normal stress) and precipitates where stress is lower, in pressure shadows, veins or overgrowths.
- Evidence: stylolites, truncated grains and fossils, insoluble residue seams (spaced cleavage), fibrous overgrowths and pressure shadows.
- It is important at low temperature (diagenesis to low-grade metamorphism) and often involves volume loss, which matters when reading the Flinn diagram.
- It is a form of diffusion creep (dissolution–precipitation creep), with a linear (Newtonian) stress dependence.
Crystal plasticity
Dislocations are line defects. They let a crystal shear one atomic row at a time, at much lower stress than shearing a whole plane at once.
- Dislocation glide happens on specific slip systems (a slip plane and direction) when the resolved shear stress exceeds the critical resolved shear stress. Glide alone causes strain hardening, because dislocations tangle.
- Climb (by diffusion of vacancies) and cross-slip let dislocations bypass obstacles. Glide plus climb is dislocation creep, and it allows steady-state flow.
- Mechanical twinning shears part of the crystal into a mirror orientation. It is the dominant low-temperature mechanism in calcite (e-twins), and also occurs in plagioclase. Thin, straight calcite twins indicate lower temperature than thick, curved or patchy twins.
Recovery lowers the dislocation density by rearranging dislocations into walls, forming subgrains (slightly misoriented domains). Undulose extinction, deformation bands and subgrains are its optical signs.
Dynamic recrystallisation
During deformation, strained grains are replaced by new, less-strained ones. Three regimes are recognised in quartz, broadly in order of increasing temperature (or decreasing strain rate):
| Regime | Mechanism | Microstructure | Approximate temperature in quartz |
|---|---|---|---|
| BLG (bulging) | grain-boundary bulges into a neighbour with higher dislocation density | small new grains along old boundaries, “core and mantle” | about 280–400 °C |
| SGR (subgrain rotation) | subgrains progressively rotate until they become new grains | new grains about the size of subgrains; ribbons | about 400–500 °C |
| GBM (grain-boundary migration) | grain boundaries sweep through the crystal | large, lobate, amoeboid grains; pinning and dissection | above about 500 °C |
These ranges are approximate and depend on strain rate and water content. At still higher temperatures quartz may show chessboard extinction, reflecting slip on both basal and prism planes.
Static recrystallisation (annealing) after deformation gives a foam texture: straight grain boundaries meeting at about 120° triple junctions and low internal strain.
Diffusion creep and grain-boundary sliding
In diffusion creep, atoms (or vacancies) diffuse from grain boundaries under compression to those under tension, changing grain shape without dislocations.
- Nabarro–Herring creep: diffusion through the crystal lattice; strain rate \( \propto d^{-2} \).
- Coble creep: diffusion along grain boundaries; strain rate \( \propto d^{-3} \); dominates at lower temperature and finer grain size.
Diffusion creep produces no crystallographic preferred orientation and often equant grains. Grain-boundary sliding in very fine-grained aggregates can give superplastic flow, with very large strains and weak or destroyed CPO. Ultramylonites sometimes show it.
Flow laws
Steady-state creep is described by
$$\boxed{\dot{\varepsilon} = A\,\sigma^n d^{-m}\exp\left(-\frac{Q}{RT}\right)}$$| Mechanism | Stress exponent \( n \) | Grain-size exponent \( m \) | Rheology |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dislocation creep | about 3–5 | 0 | power-law (non-Newtonian) |
| Nabarro–Herring creep | 1 | 2 | Newtonian (linear viscous) |
| Coble creep | 1 | 3 | Newtonian |
| Pressure solution | about 1 | about 1–3 | Newtonian |
Three quick consequences:
- With \( n = 3 \), doubling the stress raises strain rate by \( 2^3 = 8 \) times.
- Under Coble creep, halving the grain size raises strain rate by 8 times; under Nabarro–Herring, by 4 times.
- Grain-size reduction by recrystallisation can switch a rock from dislocation to diffusion creep, which weakens it. This strain softening is a main reason deformation localises into shear zones.
Deformation mechanism maps (as compiled by Frost and Ashby) plot normalised stress against homologous temperature (or stress against grain size) and show the field in which each mechanism gives the fastest strain rate.
Palaeopiezometry and strength profiles
The size of dynamically recrystallised grains decreases as differential stress increases (roughly as a power of stress), so calibrated palaeopiezometers give flow stress from grain size. Twin density in calcite has been used in the same way at low temperature.
Combine Byerlee friction (strength rising linearly with depth) with a flow law (strength falling with temperature) and you get a strength envelope for the lithosphere. The crossover is the brittle–ductile (frictional–viscous) transition, often placed near 10–15 km for quartz-rich crust at typical geotherms, where quartz reaches about 300 °C. Its depth changes with geotherm, strain rate and mineralogy. In many continental areas this matches the base of the seismogenic layer.
Shear Zones
A shear zone is a tabular zone in which strain is much higher than in the wall rocks, with the walls displaced parallel to the zone. A fault is the limiting case of zero thickness.
Types with depth
| Type | Mechanism | Products | Typical setting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brittle | frictional sliding, cataclasis | breccia, gouge, cataclasite, pseudotachylyte | upper crust |
| Brittle–ductile (semi-brittle) | mixed: fracturing plus pressure solution or local plasticity | en echelon veins, sigmoidal tension gashes | transition |
| Ductile | crystal plasticity, diffusion | mylonite series; continuous foliation and lineation | middle and lower crust |
R. H. Sibson’s (1977) two-layer model has an upper elastico-frictional regime of cataclasites and seismic slip, and a lower quasi-plastic regime of mylonites and aseismic creep.
Fault rocks (Sibson 1977, simplified)
| Random fabric | Foliated | |
|---|---|---|
| Incohesive | fault breccia (visible fragments over about 30% of the rock); fault gouge (fragments under about 30%) | foliated gouge |
| Cohesive, glassy | pseudotachylyte | — |
| Cohesive, by matrix % | protocataclasite (10–50%), cataclasite (50–90%), ultracataclasite (90–100%) | protomylonite (10–50%), mylonite (50–90%), ultramylonite (90–100%) |
Pseudotachylyte is a glass or devitrified glass formed by frictional melting during seismic slip. It forms dark veins and injection veins, and it is accepted as direct evidence of a palaeo-earthquake. Phyllonite is a mica-rich mylonite that looks like phyllite.
Strain in a shear zone
J. G. Ramsay and R. H. Graham (1970) modelled ductile shear zones as heterogeneous simple shear: shear strain varies across the zone, but each thin slice is homogeneous.
Shear strain from the foliation angle. A passive foliation forming in the zone lies close to the finite \( XY \) plane, at angle \( \theta' \) to the zone boundary:
$$\boxed{\gamma = \frac{2}{\tan 2\theta'}}$$The foliation curves into the zone (sigmoidal), becoming more nearly parallel to the boundary where strain is highest.
Displacement across the zone. Add up \( \gamma \) across the profile:
$$\boxed{D = \int_0^W \gamma(y)\,dy \approx \sum \gamma_i\,\Delta y_i}$$Pure simple shear keeps the zone thickness constant. Many natural zones also thin (general shear, \( W_k < 1 \)) or change volume, so these formulas give estimates.
Kinematic indicators
Shear sense is read in the XZ section: perpendicular to the foliation and parallel to the stretching lineation. In any other section the asymmetry can be missing or misleading.
| Indicator | Description | How it gives the sense |
|---|---|---|
| S-C fabric | S (schistosity) surfaces, sigmoidal, at an angle to C (shear) surfaces parallel to the zone | S is rotated towards C in the sense of shear; the acute angle between S and C points the movement |
| C′ (shear bands, extensional crenulation cleavage) | short shear surfaces oblique to the main foliation, at roughly 15–35° | synthetic to the overall shear; they offset the foliation in the same sense |
| σ-type porphyroclast | wedge-shaped tails of recrystallised material that do not cross the reference line | tails step up in the direction of shear (stair-stepping) |
| δ-type porphyroclast | thin tails wrapped around the clast and crossing the reference line | wrapping shows rotation in the sense of shear |
| Mica fish | lozenge-shaped mica grains inclined to the foliation | inclined like the S in S-C fabric; trails step in the shear direction |
| Oblique grain-shape foliation | recrystallised quartz grains elongated at an angle to the main foliation | inclined in the sense of the S surfaces |
| Asymmetric folds | small folds with asymmetry, in the XZ section | vergence follows the shear (not reliable alone) |
| Asymmetric (domino or shearband) boudins | boudins rotated or separated by shears | see Folds, Boudins, Foliations, Lineations and Superposed Folding |
| Quartz c-axis CPO | asymmetric girdle or maximum relative to foliation | the obliquity of the girdle gives the sense |
| Rotated porphyroblasts | garnet with spiral (snowball) inclusion trails | inclusion trail rotation (interpretation debated) |
| En echelon tension gashes | sigmoidal veins in brittle–ductile zones | veins open normal to extension, at 45° to the zone, and rotate with shear |
Use several independent indicators. Any single one can mislead; for example, back-rotated clasts and folds formed by local flow can give the opposite asymmetry.
Shear zones in India (examples)
Major exposed shear zones studied in India include the Singhbhum Shear Zone (host to copper and uranium mineralisation in eastern India), the Palghat–Cauvery Shear Zone system in the Southern Granulite Terrane, and the Main Central Thrust zone of the Himalaya, with its inverted metamorphism (see Himalayan Orogeny and Supercontinents).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | With this | Difference |
|---|---|---|
| Ductile | Plastic | ductile is distributed deformation at the outcrop scale (can be cataclastic); plastic is a mechanism (dislocations) |
| Cataclasite | Mylonite | brittle, random fabric versus crystal-plastic, foliated |
| Recovery | Recrystallisation | rearranges dislocations into subgrains versus forms new grains with new boundaries |
| Dynamic recrystallisation | Static recrystallisation | during deformation (sutured, small grains) versus after (foam texture, 120° junctions) |
| Nabarro–Herring | Coble | lattice diffusion, \( d^{-2} \) versus grain-boundary diffusion, \( d^{-3} \) |
| S surface | C surface | foliation of the finite strain versus discrete shear surfaces parallel to the zone |
| C surface | C′ surface | parallel to zone versus oblique shear bands |
| Pseudotachylyte | Ultramylonite | frictional melt (seismic) versus extremely fine ductile fault rock (aseismic) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for these notes.
Level 1: Foundation
- Practice. Name the dynamic recrystallisation mechanism that produces large lobate quartz grains.
- Practice. What fault rock is direct evidence of seismic slip?
- Practice. A cohesive, foliated fault rock has 70% fine matrix. Name it.
Answers
- Grain-boundary migration (GBM), at high temperature.
- Pseudotachylyte (frictional melt).
- Mylonite (50–90% matrix).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q4. A rock deforming by dislocation creep with stress exponent \( n = 3 \) has its differential stress doubled. Its strain rate:
(a) doubles (b) increases 4 times (c) increases 8 times (d) is unchanged, because creep does not depend on stress
Answer: (c)
\( \dot{\varepsilon} \propto \sigma^n = 2^3 = 8 \). Option (a) is Newtonian (diffusion) behaviour.
Practice Q5. In a granitic mylonite, fine recrystallised quartz ribbons wrap around angular, fractured feldspar porphyroclasts. The most likely deformation conditions are:
(a) near-surface, below 150 °C (b) greenschist facies, about 300–450 °C (c) granulite facies, above 750 °C (d) during magmatic flow
Answer: (b)
Quartz flows by dislocation creep while feldspar is still brittle: the classic greenschist-facies combination. Higher temperature would recrystallise feldspar too; near-surface conditions would make quartz brittle as well.
Practice Q6. In a ductile shear zone, the foliation at the centre makes 20° with the zone boundary. The shear strain is about:
(a) 0.36 (b) 1.2 (c) 2.4 (d) 5.5
Answer: (c)
\( \gamma = 2/\tan(2\times 20°) = 2/0.839 = 2.38 \). Option (d) forgets to double the angle.
Practice Q7. A σ-type feldspar porphyroclast in the XZ section of a horizontal shear zone has its right tail above the reference line and its left tail below. The shear sense (top relative to bottom) is:
(a) top to the right (dextral in this view) (b) top to the left (sinistral in this view) (c) cannot be determined from σ-clasts (d) coaxial, no shear sense
Answer: (a)
σ-tails step up in the direction of movement of the upper block: the right tail is raised, so the top moved to the right. In this view that is a dextral sense.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q8. A traverse across a ductile shear zone gives the following (foliation-angle method, homogeneous segments):
| Segment | Width (m) | Shear strain \( \gamma \) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 (margin) | 10 | 0.2 |
| 2 | 5 | 1.0 |
| 3 (centre) | 4 | 4.0 |
| 4 | 5 | 1.0 |
| 5 (margin) | 10 | 0.2 |
Which statements are correct?
- The total displacement across the zone is 30 m.
- More than half of the displacement is taken up in the central 4 m.
- In segment 3 the foliation makes about 13° with the boundary.
- If the zone had also thinned during shearing, these simple-shear values would give an exact displacement.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 true: \( D = 10(0.2) + 5(1) + 4(4) + 5(1) + 10(0.2) = 2 + 5 + 16 + 5 + 2 = 30 \) m.
- 2 true: 16 of 30 m (53%) is in the central segment.
- 3 true: \( \tan 2\theta' = 2/4 = 0.5 \), \( 2\theta' = 26.6° \), \( \theta' \approx 13.3° \).
- 4 false: thinning means general shear; the simple-shear formulas then give only estimates.
Practice Q9. Two samples from one shear zone:
| Sample | Quartz microstructure | Feldspar | c-axis CPO |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | small new grains along sutured boundaries of old grains; core-and-mantle | brittle, fractured | weak |
| B | large lobate grains, irregular boundaries, “left-over” grains | recrystallised, with new small grains | strong, asymmetric |
Which interpretation is most consistent?
(a) A deformed at higher temperature than B (b) A records BLG at about 300–400 °C; B records GBM at above about 500 °C, so B formed deeper or earlier in a cooling history (c) Both record diffusion creep, because both have recrystallised grains (d) B records cataclasis because its grain boundaries are irregular
Answer: (b)
Bulging with core-and-mantle structure and brittle feldspar point to low-temperature dislocation creep (BLG). Lobate grains and feldspar recrystallisation point to GBM at high temperature. A strong CPO in B means dislocation creep, not diffusion creep, so (c) is wrong. Irregular, lobate boundaries are migration features, not fractures, so (d) is wrong. A common setting is a shear zone active during exhumation: B at depth, A later and shallower.
Practice Q10. A fine-grained quartz aggregate (grain size 20 μm) deforms by Coble creep. Recrystallisation reduces the grain size to 10 μm, all else equal. Its strain rate at the same stress:
(a) halves (b) doubles (c) increases 4 times (d) increases 8 times
Answer: (d)
Coble creep: \( \dot{\varepsilon} \propto d^{-3} \), so halving \( d \) gives \( 2^3 = 8 \) times faster. (Nabarro–Herring would give 4 times.) This weakening by grain-size reduction helps localise strain into shear zones.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Mechanism groups | cataclasis; pressure solution and diffusion creep; dislocation glide, twinning, creep; grain-boundary sliding |
| Calcite | twinning at low temperature; thin twins colder than thick |
| Quartz recrystallisation | BLG about 280–400 °C; SGR about 400–500 °C; GBM above about 500 °C |
| Greenschist mylonite | quartz plastic, feldspar brittle |
| Static recrystallisation | foam texture, 120° triple junctions |
| Flow law | \( \dot{\varepsilon} = A\sigma^n d^{-m}e^{-Q/RT} \); dislocation \( n \approx 3 \)–5, \( m = 0 \); N–H \( n = 1, m = 2 \); Coble \( n = 1, m = 3 \) |
| Softening | grain-size reduction → diffusion creep → localisation |
| Brittle–ductile transition | about 10–15 km, about 300 °C for quartz-rich crust |
| Fault rocks | breccia/gouge (incohesive); cataclasite and mylonite series: 10–50, 50–90, 90–100% matrix; pseudotachylyte = frictional melt |
| Shear strain | \( \gamma = 2/\tan 2\theta' \) |
| Displacement | \( D = \int\gamma\,dy \) |
| Kinematic indicators | S-C, C′, σ and δ clasts, mica fish, oblique foliation, CPO, tension gashes; read in XZ |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Folds, Boudins, Foliations, Lineations and Superposed Folding: the larger structures built by the same mechanisms.
- Extensional, Compressional and Strike-Slip Terrains; Mantle Plumes: where shear zones sit in rifts, thrust belts and transforms.
- Back to the Structural Geology and Geotectonics overview.