Strain Ellipsoid, Tectonic Fabrics and Strain Analysis
CSIR NET Geology Part C: strain measures, pure and simple shear, vorticity, Flinn and Lode parameters, S-L tectonites, Rf/phi, Fry and Wellman strain analysis.
- 21 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Squashed Trilobites and Stretched Pebbles
- Measures of Strain
- Homogeneous Strain and the Strain Ellipsoid
- Pure Shear, Simple Shear and Vorticity
- The Shape of the Strain Ellipsoid
- Tectonic Fabrics
- Strain Analysis: Measuring Finite Strain
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Basic strain terms (extension, shear strain, strain ellipse) from Stress, Strain, Folds, Joints and Faults.
- Matrix multiplication and eigenvectors, revised in Linear Algebra, Matrices and Eigenvalues. Homogeneous strain is a linear transformation.
- Stress and the Mohr circle from Stress, Mohr Circle, Failure Criteria and Fault Reactivation. Stress and strain axes coincide only in special cases.
The Hook: Squashed Trilobites and Stretched Pebbles
Measures of Strain
| Measure | Definition | Undeformed value |
|---|---|---|
| Extension (elongation) \( e \) | \( (l - l_0)/l_0 \) | 0 |
| Stretch \( S \) | \( l/l_0 = 1 + e \) | 1 |
| Quadratic elongation \( \lambda \) | \( S^2 = (1 + e)^2 \) | 1 |
| Reciprocal quadratic elongation \( \lambda' \) | \( 1/\lambda \) | 1 |
| Natural (logarithmic) strain \( \bar{\varepsilon} \) | \( \ln S \) | 0 |
| Angular shear \( \psi \) | change in angle between two initially perpendicular lines | 0 |
| Shear strain \( \gamma \) | \( \tan\psi \) | 0 |
| Volume change \( \Delta \) | \( (V - V_0)/V_0 = S_1S_2S_3 - 1 \) | 0 |
Natural strains add when strains are applied in the same direction one after another, which is why they are used in the Lode parameter and on the Hsu diagram.
Homogeneous Strain and the Strain Ellipsoid
Strain is homogeneous when it is the same everywhere in the body. Then:
- straight lines stay straight, and parallel lines stay parallel;
- a circle becomes an ellipse and a sphere becomes an ellipsoid;
- the transformation is linear: \( \mathbf{x}' = \mathbf{F}\mathbf{x} \), where \( \mathbf{F} \) is the deformation gradient (position-gradient) tensor.
The strain ellipsoid is the shape a unit sphere takes. Its semi-axes are the principal stretches \( S_1 \geq S_2 \geq S_3 \), written \( X \geq Y \geq Z \). The principal axes are the only lines that were perpendicular before and are still perpendicular after deformation.
In 2D, the lines of no finite elongation (\( S = 1 \)) divide the strain ellipse into a field of lines that have lengthened and a field of lines that have shortened. Lines may have shortened first and then lengthened during progressive strain, so the finite state does not tell the whole history.
Rotation of lines in coaxial strain
If the principal axes are fixed (pure shear with \( X \) horizontal), a line at angle \( \theta \) to \( X \) before strain lies at \( \theta' \) after:
$$\boxed{\tan\theta' = \frac{S_2}{S_1}\tan\theta = \frac{\tan\theta}{R_s}} \qquad R_s = \frac{S_1}{S_2}$$and its stretch is
$$\boxed{S^2 = S_1^2\cos^2\theta + S_2^2\sin^2\theta}$$Lines rotate towards \( X \), the direction of maximum stretching. This is how a randomly oriented set of elongate objects (pebbles, minerals) acquires a preferred orientation.
Pure Shear, Simple Shear and Vorticity
Coaxial and non-coaxial deformation
- Coaxial strain: the material lines along the principal strain axes are the same at every increment. The finite strain axes do not rotate relative to the material. Pure shear (plane strain, constant volume, shortening in one direction balanced by extension in another) is the standard example.
- Non-coaxial strain: different material lines lie on the principal axes at different stages. The finite strain ellipse rotates relative to the material. Simple shear (like sliding a deck of cards) is the standard example.
The instantaneous stretching axes (ISA) are the directions of maximum and minimum stretching rate at an instant. In simple shear they lie at 45° to the shear plane; the finite strain axes start at 45° and rotate towards the shear plane as strain increases.
Simple shear in numbers
In simple shear parallel to \( x \): \( x' = x + \gamma y \), \( y' = y \). Then:
$$\boxed{S_1 = \frac{\gamma}{2} + \sqrt{1 + \frac{\gamma^2}{4}}, \qquad S_2 = \frac{1}{S_1}}$$$$\boxed{\tan 2\theta' = \frac{2}{\gamma}}$$where \( \theta' \) is the angle between the long axis \( X \) and the shear plane. A material line at angle \( \alpha \) to the shear direction rotates according to
$$\boxed{\cot\alpha' = \cot\alpha + \gamma}$$| \( \gamma \) | \( S_1 \) | \( R_s = S_1^2 \) | \( \theta' \) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (onset) | 1 | 1 | 45° |
| 1 | 1.618 | 2.62 | 31.7° |
| 2 | 2.414 | 5.83 | 22.5° |
| 3 | 3.303 | 10.9 | 16.8° |
| large | about \( \gamma \) | about \( \gamma^2 \) | towards 0° |
This angle relation is the basis of measuring shear strain in shear zones from the foliation angle (see Deformation Mechanisms and Shear Zones).
Vorticity and general shear
Vorticity measures the rotation rate of material lines relative to the ISA. The kinematic vorticity number \( W_k \) compares vorticity with the stretching rate:
| \( W_k \) | Flow | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | pure shear | coaxial |
| between 0 and 1 | general shear (sub-simple shear) | a mix of pure and simple shear |
| 1 | simple shear | non-coaxial |
| greater than 1 | rotation dominated | not expected in ordinary steady flow |
In 2D steady flow, \( W_k = \cos\alpha \), where \( \alpha \) is the angle between the two flow apophyses (lines of no instantaneous rotation). In pure shear the apophyses are perpendicular (\( W_k = 0 \)); in simple shear they coincide with the shear plane (\( W_k = 1 \)). Natural shear zones often give \( W_k \) between about 0.5 and 0.9, so they combine thinning with shear.
Transpression and transtension are general shears in 3D: simple shear along a zone combined with shortening (or extension) across it. They are common along oblique plate boundaries.
Strain is not commutative
Superposed homogeneous strains combine by matrix multiplication: \( \mathbf{F}_{total} = \mathbf{F}_2\mathbf{F}_1 \). Matrix products do not commute, so a pure shear followed by a simple shear gives a different finite strain from the same two in reverse order. Only coaxial strains along the same axes commute.
The Shape of the Strain Ellipsoid
The Flinn diagram
D. Flinn (1962) plotted
$$\boxed{a = \frac{X}{Y}, \qquad b = \frac{Y}{Z}, \qquad k = \frac{a - 1}{b - 1}}$$with \( a \) on the vertical axis and \( b \) on the horizontal axis.
| \( k \) | Ellipsoid shape | Strain type | Tectonite |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | oblate (pancake), \( X = Y \) | uniaxial flattening | S-tectonite (foliation only) |
| 0 to 1 | oblate-ish | flattening | S > L |
| 1 | triaxial | plane strain (if no volume change) | L-S tectonite |
| 1 to \( \infty \) | prolate-ish | constriction | L > S |
| \( \infty \) | prolate (cigar), \( Y = Z \) | uniaxial constriction | L-tectonite (lineation only) |
J. G. Ramsay used logarithms instead: \( K = \ln a/\ln b \) on a plot of \( \ln a \) against \( \ln b \). This makes the plane-strain line straight even with large strains.
The Lode parameter and the Hsu diagram
With natural strains \( \bar{\varepsilon}_i = \ln S_i \):
$$\boxed{\nu = \frac{2\bar{\varepsilon}_2 - \bar{\varepsilon}_1 - \bar{\varepsilon}_3}{\bar{\varepsilon}_1 - \bar{\varepsilon}_3}}$$\( \nu = -1 \) for uniaxial constriction (prolate), 0 for plane strain, \( +1 \) for uniaxial flattening (oblate). Strain magnitude is measured by the natural octahedral shear strain
$$\bar{\varepsilon}_s = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\sqrt{(\bar{\varepsilon}_1 - \bar{\varepsilon}_2)^2 + (\bar{\varepsilon}_2 - \bar{\varepsilon}_3)^2 + (\bar{\varepsilon}_3 - \bar{\varepsilon}_1)^2}$$The Hsu diagram plots \( \bar{\varepsilon}_s \) (radius) against \( \nu \) (angle), separating shape from magnitude.
Tectonic Fabrics
A fabric is the geometric arrangement of the parts of a rock that repeats through a volume. Tectonic fabrics form during deformation:
- Planar fabric (foliation, S): aligned platy minerals, flattened grains, compositional layering, or closely spaced cleavage planes.
- Linear fabric (lineation, L): aligned elongate minerals, stretched pebbles, intersection lines, fold hinges.
- Shape-preferred orientation (SPO): alignment of grain shapes.
- Crystallographic (lattice) preferred orientation (CPO/LPO): alignment of crystal axes, produced mainly by dislocation creep. Quartz c-axis patterns are the classic example; their asymmetry gives the shear sense and their opening angle reflects temperature.
Fabrics and the strain ellipsoid
| Fabric | Strain-ellipsoid link (to a first approximation) |
|---|---|
| Foliation | parallel to the \( XY \) plane in coaxial strain; at a small angle to it at moderate strain in simple shear |
| Stretching lineation | parallel to \( X \) |
| Intersection lineation | parallel to the line of intersection of two planes, not to any strain axis |
| S-tectonite | \( k \approx 0 \) |
| L-tectonite | \( k \to \infty \) |
| L-S tectonite | \( k \approx 1 \) |
Foliation tracks the finite \( XY \) plane well in coaxial strain. In simple shear, a passive foliation follows the finite \( XY \) plane only approximately; at high shear strain it becomes almost parallel to the shear plane. That is why the angle between foliation and the shear-zone wall measures \( \gamma \).
Fabric symmetry and kinematic axes
Following Sander, fabrics are described with kinematic axes \( a \), \( b \), \( c \): \( a \) is the transport direction, \( b \) lies in the shear plane perpendicular to \( a \), and \( c \) is normal to the shear plane. A fabric with monoclinic symmetry (one mirror plane, the \( ac \) plane) records non-coaxial flow and gives a shear sense; an orthorhombic fabric (three mirror planes) records coaxial flow and does not. This is the symmetry principle behind every kinematic indicator. Fold hinges parallel to \( b \) are the old “b-lineations”; stretching lineations parallel to \( a \) are “a-lineations”. At high strain the two can become parallel (see sheath folds in Folds, Boudins, Foliations, Lineations and Superposed Folding).
Strain Analysis: Measuring Finite Strain
graph TD
A[What strain markers does the rock have?] --> B[Initially circular or spherical objects]
A --> C[Objects with known original angles]
A --> D[Objects with known original lengths]
A --> E[Evenly spaced grain centres]
A --> F[Initially elliptical objects, random orientation]
B --> B1[Measure ellipse axes directly: reduction spots, ooids]
C --> C1[Wellman construction; Breddin graph: brachiopods, trilobites]
D --> D1[Boudinaged belemnites, fibres: extension]
E --> E1[Fry method or centre-to-centre method]
F --> F1[Rf/phi method: pebbles, ooids]Initially circular markers
If the objects started as circles (reduction spots, many ooids), each ellipse is the strain ellipse: \( R_s = \) long axis / short axis. Measure in three perpendicular sections (ideally \( XY \), \( XZ \), \( YZ \)) to get the ellipsoid.
The Rf/\( \phi \) method
Pebbles and ooids are rarely perfect circles. If they started as ellipses of ratio \( R_i \) with random orientations, after strain \( R_s \) their final ratios \( R_f \) and long-axis orientations \( \phi \) scatter in a characteristic way. When \( R_s > R_i \):
$$\boxed{R_{f\max} = R_s R_i, \qquad R_{f\min} = \frac{R_s}{R_i}}$$so
$$\boxed{R_s = \sqrt{R_{f\max}R_{f\min}}, \qquad R_i = \sqrt{\frac{R_{f\max}}{R_{f\min}}}}$$and the long axes cluster around \( X \) within a limited fluctuation. When \( R_i > R_s \), the long axes of the most elongate objects keep the full 180° range of orientations, and \( R_{f\max} = R_iR_s \), \( R_{f\min} = R_i/R_s \).
Fry and centre-to-centre methods
If grain centres were initially distributed fairly evenly (sandstone grains, ooids in contact), strain changes the distances between neighbours. In the centre-to-centre method (Ramsay), distance between neighbouring centres is plotted against direction; the maximum and minimum give the strain ratio. The Fry method (N. Fry, 1979) plots every centre relative to every other on one overlay. Because neighbours cannot be closer than about one grain diameter, a central vacancy appears. Its shape is the strain ellipse.
Objects of known angle: Wellman and Breddin
Fossils such as brachiopods have a hinge line and a median (symmetry) line that were originally at 90°. After strain the angle changes by the angular shear \( \psi \).
- Wellman’s method (1962): on a drawing, draw each fossil’s hinge and median lines through the ends of a common reference line. The intersections lie on an ellipse that is the strain ellipse.
- Breddin graph: plot angular shear against orientation and fit standard curves for different \( R_s \). The lines with zero angular shear are the principal axes.
Objects of known length and incremental strain
- Boudinaged belemnites or tourmaline crystals: add up the fragments and the gaps. Extension = (present length − original length)/original length.
- Fibrous veins and pressure shadows: fibres grow as the vein opens or as the shadow forms. Their changing orientation records the incremental strain history, which finite-strain markers cannot.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | With this | Difference |
|---|---|---|
| Pure shear | Simple shear | coaxial, \( W_k = 0 \), no rotation of finite axes versus non-coaxial, \( W_k = 1 \), axes rotate |
| Coaxial strain | Plane strain | about rotation of axes versus \( Y = 1 \) (no change along \( Y \)) |
| Finite strain | Incremental strain | total state versus an instantaneous step; ISA are at 45° to the shear plane in simple shear |
| Stretch \( S \) | Quadratic elongation \( \lambda \) | \( l/l_0 \) versus \( (l/l_0)^2 \) |
| Flinn \( k \) | Ramsay \( K \) | ratio of \( (a-1)/(b-1) \) versus ratio of logs |
| Stretching lineation | Intersection lineation | parallel to \( X \) versus parallel to the line of two intersecting planes |
| SPO | CPO | grain shapes aligned versus crystal lattices aligned |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for these notes.
Level 1: Foundation
- Practice. A line 5 cm long becomes 7.5 cm. Give its stretch and quadratic elongation.
- Practice. What is the kinematic vorticity number of ideal simple shear?
- Practice. A rock has a strong lineation and almost no foliation. Where does it plot on the Flinn diagram?
Answers
- \( S = 7.5/5 = 1.5 \); \( \lambda = S^2 = 2.25 \) (extension \( e = 0.5 \)).
- \( W_k = 1 \) (pure shear is 0).
- Near the vertical axis, \( k \to \infty \): an L-tectonite formed by constriction.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q4. In homogeneous simple shear with \( \gamma = 2 \), the axial ratio of the strain ellipse and the angle between its long axis and the shear plane are:
(a) 4.0 and 26.6° (b) 5.83 and 22.5° (c) 2.41 and 22.5° (d) 5.83 and 45°
Answer: (b)
\( S_1 = 1 + \sqrt{2} = 2.414 \), \( S_2 = 0.414 \), \( R_s = S_1/S_2 = S_1^2 = 5.83 \). \( \tan 2\theta' = 2/2 = 1 \), so \( \theta' = 22.5° \). Option (c) gives \( S_1 \) instead of \( R_s \); (d) uses the ISA angle.
Practice Q5. A constant-volume strain ellipsoid has \( X : Y : Z = 3 : 1.2 : 0.278 \). The rock is best described as:
(a) L-tectonite, \( k \approx 2.2 \) (b) L-S tectonite, \( k = 1 \) (c) S > L tectonite, \( k \approx 0.45 \) (d) S-tectonite, \( k = 0 \)
Answer: (c)
\( a = 3/1.2 = 2.5 \), \( b = 1.2/0.278 = 4.32 \), \( k = 1.5/3.32 = 0.45 \). Between 0 and 1: flattening, foliation dominant with a weaker lineation. Option (a) inverts the ratio.
Practice Q6. In an Rf/\( \phi \) plot of deformed pebbles, \( R_{f\max} = 4.5 \) and \( R_{f\min} = 2.0 \), and the long axes show a limited fluctuation. The tectonic strain ratio \( R_s \) and initial ratio \( R_i \) are:
(a) 4.5 and 2.0 (b) 3.25 and 1.25 (c) 3.0 and 1.5 (d) 2.25 and 2.0
Answer: (c)
Limited fluctuation means \( R_s > R_i \). \( R_s = \sqrt{4.5\times 2} = 3.0 \); \( R_i = \sqrt{4.5/2} = 1.5 \). Option (b) uses arithmetic means.
Practice Q7. In pure shear with \( S_1 = 2 \) and \( S_2 = 0.5 \), a line initially at 30° to \( X \) ends at about:
(a) 8° to \( X \), stretch 1.75 (b) 15° to \( X \), stretch 1.50 (c) 30° to \( X \), stretch 1.75 (d) 8° to \( X \), stretch 0.88
Answer: (a)
\( \tan\theta' = 0.25\tan 30° = 0.144 \), \( \theta' \approx 8.2° \). \( S = \sqrt{4\times 0.75 + 0.25\times 0.25} = \sqrt{3.0625} = 1.75 \). The line rotates towards \( X \) and lengthens.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q8. Deformed reduction spots (originally spheres) are measured in three perpendicular sections of a slate. Assume no volume change.
| Section | Ellipse axial ratio |
|---|---|
| XZ | 6.0 |
| YZ | 2.0 |
| XY | 3.0 |
Which combination is correct?
(a) \( X : Y : Z \approx 2.62 : 0.87 : 0.44 \), \( k = 2 \), constrictional (L > S) (b) \( X : Y : Z \approx 2.62 : 0.87 : 0.44 \), \( k = 0.5 \), flattening (S > L) (c) \( X : Y : Z = 6 : 2 : 1 \), \( k = 2 \), plane strain (d) \( X : Y : Z \approx 1.82 : 1.21 : 0.45 \), \( k = 1 \), plane strain
Answer: (a)
The ratios are consistent: \( X/Z = (X/Y)(Y/Z) = 3\times 2 = 6 \).
Constant volume: \( XYZ = 1 \) with \( X = 6Z \), \( Y = 2Z \), so \( 12Z^3 = 1 \), \( Z = 0.437 \), \( Y = 0.874 \), \( X = 2.62 \).
\( k = (a - 1)/(b - 1) = (3 - 1)/(2 - 1) = 2 \): constriction. Lode \( \nu = \frac{2\ln 0.874 - \ln 2.62 - \ln 0.437}{\ln 2.62 - \ln 0.437} \approx -0.23 \), negative, confirming the prolate side. Option (c) gives correct ratios but not stretches (its volume is 12), and it misreads \( k = 2 \) as plane strain.
Practice Q9. A dyke was initially perpendicular to the walls of a 50 m wide shear zone. Inside the zone, deformed by homogeneous simple shear, the dyke now makes 30° with the shear-zone walls. The shear strain and the displacement across the zone are closest to:
(a) \( \gamma = 0.58 \), 29 m (b) \( \gamma = 1.0 \), 50 m (c) \( \gamma = 1.73 \), 87 m (d) \( \gamma = 2.0 \), 100 m
Answer: (c)
\( \cot\alpha' = \cot\alpha + \gamma \) with \( \alpha = 90° \) (\( \cot = 0 \)) and \( \alpha' = 30° \): \( \gamma = \cot 30° = 1.73 \).
Displacement = \( \gamma\times \) width \( = 1.73\times 50 \approx 87 \) m. Option (a) uses \( \tan 30° \). Note: a dyke perpendicular to the zone rotates by \( \tan^{-1}\gamma \) from the normal, here 60°.
Practice Q10. Which statements are correct?
- A fabric with orthorhombic symmetry cannot by itself give a sense of shear.
- A pure shear followed by a simple shear gives the same finite strain as the same simple shear followed by the same pure shear.
- Fibres in pressure shadows can record the incremental strain history.
- In steady simple shear, the instantaneous stretching axes lie at 45° to the shear plane throughout the deformation.
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 3 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 3 and 4 only
- 1 true: shear sense needs monoclinic (or lower) symmetry.
- 2 false: deformation matrices do not commute unless the strains are coaxial.
- 3 true: fibres grow incrementally and track changing extension directions.
- 4 true: the ISA are fixed at 45° in steady simple shear; it is the finite axes that rotate.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Measures | \( e = \Delta l/l_0 \); \( S = 1 + e \); \( \lambda = S^2 \); \( \gamma = \tan\psi \); \( \bar{\varepsilon} = \ln S \) |
| Homogeneous strain | lines stay straight and parallel; circle to ellipse; \( \mathbf{x}' = \mathbf{F}\mathbf{x} \) |
| Coaxial line rotation | \( \tan\theta' = (S_2/S_1)\tan\theta \); \( S^2 = S_1^2\cos^2\theta + S_2^2\sin^2\theta \) |
| Simple shear | \( S_1 = \gamma/2 + \sqrt{1 + \gamma^2/4} \); \( \tan 2\theta' = 2/\gamma \); \( \cot\alpha' = \cot\alpha + \gamma \) |
| Vorticity | \( W_k = 0 \) pure, 1 simple, between = general shear; \( W_k = \cos(\text{apophysis angle}) \) |
| Flinn | \( a = X/Y \), \( b = Y/Z \), \( k = (a-1)/(b-1) \); 0 S-tectonite, 1 L-S, \( \infty \) L-tectonite |
| Lode | \( \nu = (2\bar{\varepsilon}_2 - \bar{\varepsilon}_1 - \bar{\varepsilon}_3)/(\bar{\varepsilon}_1 - \bar{\varepsilon}_3) \); \( -1 \) prolate, 0 plane, \( +1 \) oblate |
| Rf/\( \phi \) | \( R_s = \sqrt{R_{f\max}R_{f\min}} \), \( R_i = \sqrt{R_{f\max}/R_{f\min}} \) (for \( R_s > R_i \)) |
| Fry | central vacancy = strain ellipse |
| Wellman / Breddin | originally perpendicular fossil lines; angular shear |
| Fabric symmetry | monoclinic → non-coaxial, gives shear sense; orthorhombic → coaxial |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Deformation Mechanisms and Shear Zones: how grains actually deform, and how shear zones record sense and amount of shear.
- Folds, Boudins, Foliations, Lineations and Superposed Folding: the structures these strains build.
- Back to the Structural Geology and Geotectonics overview.