Weather Forecasting: Elements, Methods and Hazards
CSIR NET Part C meteorology: forecast ranges, NWP, forecasting temperature, rain, fog and thunderstorms, IMD hazard criteria and forecast verification.
- 19 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Richardson’s Forecast Factory
- Forecast Ranges and Methods
- Forecasting Weather Elements
- Forecasting Thunderstorms: Stability Indices
- Temperature Hazards: IMD Heat and Cold Wave Criteria
- Cyclone and Impact-Based Warnings
- Forecast Verification
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Observations and Synoptic Charts — the data, charts and tephigrams every forecast starts from.
- Vertical Stability and Tropical Convection — CAPE, CIN and the parcel method behind thunderstorm indices.
- Humidity, Precipitation and Water Balance — dew point, saturation and precipitation processes behind fog and rain forecasts.
The Hook: Richardson’s Forecast Factory
How CSIR NET asks it. Part C questions on this line include computing stability indices (K index, Total Totals, lifted index) from a sounding and judging thunderstorm potential; deciding whether a heat wave, cold wave or heavy-rain category applies from given data; identifying the fog type from conditions; computing verification scores (POD, FAR, CSI, bias, Brier score); and placing methods (nowcasting, NWP, ensembles) on the right range.
Forecast Ranges and Methods
| Range | Lead time | Main tools |
|---|---|---|
| Nowcasting | 0 to a few hours | radar and satellite extrapolation, lightning detection, AWS, conceptual models of storms |
| Very short range | up to about 12 h | nowcasting tools plus high-resolution NWP |
| Short range | about 1–3 days | synoptic analysis, deterministic NWP |
| Medium range | about 3–10 days | global NWP, ensembles |
| Extended range | about 10–30 days | ensembles and coupled models; skill from slowly varying modes (MJO, MISO) |
| Long range / seasonal | a month to a season | coupled ocean–atmosphere models; statistical models using predictors such as ENSO and the IOD |
Classical methods still used for checking and for short lead times:
| Method | Idea | Works when |
|---|---|---|
| Persistence | tomorrow = today | slowly changing regimes; very short range |
| Climatology | forecast the long-term average | long range; baseline for skill |
| Trend (extrapolation) | systems keep moving at their present speed and direction | nowcasting fronts, squall lines, cyclones |
| Analogue | find a past situation like today and use what followed | rarely exact; atmosphere seldom repeats |
| Synoptic / conceptual | apply models of fronts, cyclones, monsoon systems | short range |
| Numerical weather prediction | integrate the governing equations from an analysed initial state | all ranges beyond nowcasting |
Numerical weather prediction (NWP)
graph LR
A["Observations
surface, upper air,
satellite, radar, aircraft"] --> B["Quality control"]
B --> C["Data assimilation
3D-Var, 4D-Var,
ensemble Kalman filter"]
C --> D["Analysis
initial state"]
D --> E["Model integration
primitive equations +
parameterised physics"]
E --> F["Post-processing
MOS, bias correction,
downscaling"]
F --> G["Forecast products
and warnings"]
E --> H["Ensemble members
perturbed initial states
and physics"]
H --> GKey ideas:
- Primitive equations: momentum (usually hydrostatic for global models, non-hydrostatic at high resolution), continuity, thermodynamic energy, moisture, equation of state.
- Parameterisation: processes smaller than the grid (convection, boundary-layer turbulence, radiation, cloud microphysics, surface exchange) are represented statistically. Convection parameterisation is a large source of error in the tropics.
- Numerical stability: explicit time stepping must satisfy the CFL condition \( c\,\Delta t/\Delta x \le 1 \), where \( c \) is the fastest signal speed resolved; finer grids need shorter time steps.
- Data assimilation blends a short-range model forecast (the background) with observations, weighted by their error statistics, to produce the analysis.
- Predictability: small errors in the initial state grow (Lorenz’s sensitive dependence on initial conditions), so deterministic skill for synoptic weather is lost after roughly two weeks. Ensemble prediction runs many forecasts from perturbed initial states; the spread estimates uncertainty and gives probabilities.
- Model output statistics (MOS): regression relations between model output and observed station weather that correct systematic biases.
Forecasting Weather Elements
Temperature
| Factor | Effect on maximum or minimum temperature |
|---|---|
| Advection \( -\mathbf{V}\cdot\nabla T \) | warm advection raises, cold advection lowers; dominant with frontal and western disturbance passages |
| Cloud cover | by day cuts maximum; by night raises minimum (less longwave loss) |
| Wind | at night mixes warmer air down and keeps minimum up; calm nights allow strong inversions |
| Humidity | moist air keeps nights warmer (water-vapour greenhouse); dry desert air has a large diurnal range |
| Soil moisture and snow | wet soil and snow cover lower the maximum |
| Thickness and model fields | layer-mean temperature from forecast thickness; model 2 m temperature with MOS |
A rough rule for clear, calm nights in a stable air mass: the minimum temperature is not much below the evening dew point, because condensation (dew, fog) releases latent heat once saturation is reached.
Precipitation
- Quantitative precipitation forecasts (QPF) come from NWP and are calibrated with radar and gauge data.
- Probability of precipitation (PoP) expresses uncertainty from ensembles or statistics.
- Ingredients for heavy rain: deep moisture (high precipitable water), lift (convergence, orography, fronts, low-pressure systems), instability and a long duration (slow movement or repeated cells).
IMD rainfall intensity terms (24-hour accumulation at a station):
| Category | Rainfall (mm) |
|---|---|
| Very light | trace to 2.4 |
| Light | 2.5–15.5 |
| Moderate | 15.6–64.4 |
| Heavy | 64.5–115.5 |
| Very heavy | 115.6–204.4 |
| Extremely heavy | 204.5 or more |
Wind
Gradient and geostrophic wind from the pressure analysis, adjusted for friction and stability (strong daytime mixing brings momentum down; nocturnal inversions decouple the surface). Local effects: land and sea breezes, mountain and valley winds, channelling, gusts in convective downdrafts.
Visibility and fog
Fog is a suspension of water droplets that reduces horizontal visibility below 1 km; mist is the same with visibility of 1 km or more.
| Fog type | Formation | Favourable conditions | Indian example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Radiation fog | surface cools by longwave emission at night | clear sky, light wind (about 1–3 m s⁻¹), moist surface air, long nights; often after rain | Indo-Gangetic plains in winter, especially after a western disturbance has moistened the ground and cleared out |
| Advection fog | warm moist air flows over a colder surface | moderate wind; sharp surface temperature contrast | coastal areas over cold water; less common in India |
| Steam (evaporation) fog | cold air over much warmer water | large air–water temperature difference | rivers and lakes on cold mornings |
| Upslope fog | moist air cooled adiabatically as it rises | gentle upslope flow | hill slopes |
| Frontal fog | rain falling into cold air saturates it | ahead of warm fronts | mid-latitudes |
Radiation fog dissipates after sunrise as the surface warms and mixing increases; a stronger wind or a cloud deck at night prevents it. Fog forecasting uses the evening dew point, the expected minimum temperature, wind and cloud forecasts, and satellite night-time fog products (difference of IR channels).
IMD grades fog by visibility from shallow and moderate fog through dense and very dense fog; dense fog reduces visibility to a few hundred metres or less and disrupts aviation and rail traffic.
Forecasting Thunderstorms: Stability Indices
Thunderstorms need moisture, instability and a lifting mechanism. Indices computed from a sounding (see Observations and Synoptic Charts) summarise the first two.
| Index | Formula | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| K index | \( K = (T_{850} - T_{500}) + T_{d,850} - (T_{700} - T_{d,700}) \) | higher = more likely air-mass thunderstorms; values of about 35 and above indicate high potential (operational tables vary) |
| Total Totals | \( TT = T_{850} + T_{d,850} - 2T_{500} \) | about 50 or more suggests severe thunderstorms are possible |
| Lifted index | \( LI = T_{500,\mathrm{env}} - T_{500,\mathrm{parcel}} \) (parcel lifted from the surface or mixed layer) | negative = unstable; more negative = more vigorous |
| Showalter index | as LI but parcel lifted from 850 hPa | negative = unstable |
| CAPE | \( \int_{LFC}^{EL} g\,(T_{v,p} - T_{v,e})/T_{v,e}\,dz \) | energy available to updrafts; maximum updraft \( \approx \sqrt{2\,\mathrm{CAPE}} \) |
| CIN | negative area below the LFC | the “lid”; large CIN suppresses storms until it is broken |
The K index includes a dryness penalty (the 700 hPa dew-point depression), so it is suited to air-mass (non-severe) storms in moist tropical air; Total Totals and LI weight lapse rate and instability. Vertical wind shear (from the hodograph) decides storm organisation: weak shear gives short-lived single cells; moderate shear multicells and squall lines; strong, veering shear supercells.
Convective hazards over India
| Hazard | Season and region | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Nor’westers (kalbaisakhi) | April–May; West Bengal, Odisha, Jharkhand, Assam, Bangladesh | squall lines approaching from the north-west; hail, gusts, lightning; dry-line setting with cT air over moist mT air |
| Dust storms (andhi) | April–June; Rajasthan, Punjab, Haryana, Delhi, west UP | convective downdrafts and gust fronts lift dust; can be violent |
| Pre-monsoon thunderstorms in the south | April–May; Kerala, Karnataka | ‘mango showers’, ‘blossom showers’ |
| Hail | late winter and pre-monsoon; north and central India | needs strong updrafts and a low freezing level |
| Lightning | pre-monsoon and monsoon; east and central India especially | a major cause of weather-related deaths in India |
| Cloudburst | monsoon; Himalaya and hills | extreme short-duration rain over a small area, enhanced by orographic lifting; often tied to a monsoon system or a WD–monsoon interaction |
| Squalls | with thunderstorms and fronts | a sudden, sharp increase of wind speed lasting minutes, then dying away |
Temperature Hazards: IMD Heat and Cold Wave Criteria
Heat wave
A heat wave is considered when the maximum temperature of a station reaches at least 40 °C in the plains, 37 °C at coastal stations or 30 °C in hilly regions, and then:
| Basis | Heat wave | Severe heat wave |
|---|---|---|
| Departure from normal maximum | 4.5 °C to 6.4 °C above normal | more than 6.4 °C above normal |
| Actual maximum (plains) | 45 °C or more | 47 °C or more |
Heat waves in India are typical of April–June over the north-west, central and east India and the east coast, under subsidence, clear skies and hot, dry cT air (the loo). A delayed monsoon onset prolongs them. Humidity makes coastal heat more dangerous at lower temperatures.
Cold wave
For plains stations with a minimum temperature of 10 °C or less:
| Basis | Cold wave | Severe cold wave |
|---|---|---|
| Departure from normal minimum | 4.5 °C to 6.4 °C below normal | more than 6.4 °C below normal |
| Actual minimum (plains) | 4 °C or less | 2 °C or less |
Cold waves follow western disturbances: clearing skies and cold north-westerlies after passage, with snow-covered hills upstream. Cold day conditions occur when fog or low cloud persists all day and keeps the maximum far below normal.
Cyclone and Impact-Based Warnings
Tropical cyclone warnings. IMD issues cyclone bulletins in stages as a system approaches the coast, typically: a pre-cyclone watch, a cyclone alert, a cyclone warning, and a post-landfall outlook, each given progressively closer to landfall, with track and intensity forecasts shown as a cone of uncertainty. Storm-surge forecasts are issued with them (see Tropical Weather Systems).
Colour-coded impact-based warnings. IMD’s district-level warnings use a four-colour scale:
| Colour | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Green | no warning; no action |
| Yellow | watch: be aware, stay updated |
| Orange | alert: be prepared |
| Red | warning: take action |
Forecast Verification
For a yes/no event (for example, “heavy rain at a district”), forecasts and observations fill a 2 × 2 contingency table:
| Observed yes | Observed no | |
|---|---|---|
| Forecast yes | \( a \) hits | \( b \) false alarms |
| Forecast no | \( c \) misses | \( d \) correct negatives |
| Score | Formula | Perfect | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Probability of detection (POD) / hit rate | \( a/(a+c) \) | 1 | ignores false alarms |
| False alarm ratio (FAR) | \( b/(a+b) \) | 0 | fraction of “yes” forecasts that were wrong |
| Probability of false detection (POFD) | \( b/(b+d) \) | 0 | used in ROC curves |
| Critical success index (CSI) / threat score | \( a/(a+b+c) \) | 1 | ignores correct negatives; good for rare events |
| Frequency bias | \( (a+b)/(a+c) \) | 1 | > 1 over-forecasting; < 1 under-forecasting |
| Proportion correct | \( (a+d)/n \) | 1 | inflated by many correct “no"s for rare events |
| Heidke skill score (HSS) | \( \dfrac{2(ad-bc)}{(a+c)(c+d)+(a+b)(b+d)} \) | 1 | skill relative to random chance; 0 = no skill |
For probability forecasts, the Brier score is
$$BS = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}(p_i - o_i)^2$$with \( p_i \) the forecast probability and \( o_i \) = 1 or 0. It ranges from 0 (perfect) to 1. A skill score compares any score with a reference (climatology or persistence):
$$SS = 1 - \frac{\text{score}_{\text{forecast}}}{\text{score}_{\text{reference}}}$$for error-type scores such as MSE or the Brier score. SS = 1 is perfect, 0 is no better than the reference, negative is worse.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Nowcasting: 0 to a few hours, extrapolation | vs | Short range: 1–3 days, NWP |
| Deterministic forecast: one run | vs | Ensemble: many runs, probabilities |
| POD: hits / observed events | vs | FAR: false alarms / forecast events |
| FAR (ratio, over yes forecasts) | vs | POFD (over observed non-events) |
| CSI: ignores correct negatives | vs | Proportion correct: includes them, flatters rare-event forecasts |
| Radiation fog: light wind, clear night, land | vs | Advection fog: warm moist air over a cold surface, needs wind |
| K index: high = unstable | vs | Lifted index: negative = unstable |
| Heat wave criteria: departure or absolute maximum | vs | Cold wave criteria: departure or absolute minimum |
| Fog: visibility below 1 km | vs | Mist: visibility 1 km or more |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- In what IMD category is a 24-hour station rainfall of 120 mm?
- Write the formula for the critical success index.
- Which fog type is typical of the Indo-Gangetic plains on clear winter nights?
Answers
- Very heavy (115.6–204.4 mm).
- CSI = hits/(hits + false alarms + misses) = \( a/(a+b+c) \).
- Radiation fog.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A sounding gives \( T_{850} = 24 \) °C, \( T_{d,850} = 18 \) °C, \( T_{700} = 10 \) °C, \( T_{d,700} = 4 \) °C and \( T_{500} = -8 \) °C. The K index and Total Totals are:
- (a) 44 and 58
- (b) 32 and 42
- (c) 44 and 42
- (d) 50 and 58
Answer and explanation
(a). \( K = (24 - (-8)) + 18 - (10 - 4) = 32 + 18 - 6 = 44 \). \( TT = 24 + 18 - 2(-8) = 58 \). Both indicate high thunderstorm potential, with TT in the severe range.
Q2 (practice). A plains station with a normal maximum of 39.5 °C records 45.0 °C. Under IMD criteria this is:
- (a) no heat wave, because the departure is below 6.5 °C
- (b) a heat wave
- (c) a severe heat wave
- (d) a heat wave only if it persists for a week
Answer and explanation
(b). The station is above 40 °C. The departure is 5.5 °C (heat wave band, 4.5–6.4 °C), and the actual maximum of 45 °C also meets the absolute heat-wave criterion. It is not severe: departure is below 6.5 °C and the maximum is below 47 °C.
Q3 (practice). A southerly wind of 10 m s⁻¹ blows across isotherms in which temperature decreases northward by 5 K per 500 km. Ignoring other effects, the local temperature change due to advection is about:
- (a) −0.36 K h⁻¹
- (b) +0.36 K h⁻¹
- (c) +3.6 K h⁻¹
- (d) +8.6 K h⁻¹
Answer and explanation
(b). \( -\mathbf{V}\cdot\nabla T = -v\,\partial T/\partial y = -(10)(-5/5\times10^5) = +1\times10^{-4} \) K s⁻¹ = +0.36 K h⁻¹ (about 8.6 K per day): warm advection. Option (d) is the daily value given with the wrong unit.
Q4 (practice). An explicit model with 10 km grid spacing must resolve signals travelling at up to 300 m s⁻¹. The largest stable time step under the CFL condition is about:
- (a) 3 s
- (b) 33 s
- (c) 330 s
- (d) 3000 s
Answer and explanation
(b). \( \Delta t \le \Delta x/c = 10^4/300 = 33 \) s. Halving the grid spacing halves the allowed time step, so cost rises steeply with resolution.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Over one monsoon season, district heavy-rain warnings gave the following results:
| Heavy rain observed | Not observed | |
|---|---|---|
| Warning issued | 30 | 10 |
| No warning | 20 | 140 |
Compute POD, FAR, CSI, frequency bias, proportion correct and the Heidke skill score. Comment on the forecasts.
Answer and worked solution
\( a = 30, b = 10, c = 20, d = 140, n = 200 \).
- POD = 30/50 = 0.60
- FAR = 10/40 = 0.25
- CSI = 30/60 = 0.50
- Bias = 40/50 = 0.80 (under-forecasting: warnings issued less often than events occurred)
- Proportion correct = 170/200 = 0.85
- HSS = \( \dfrac{2(30\times140 - 10\times20)}{(50)(160) + (40)(150)} = \dfrac{8000}{14000} = \) 0.57
Comment: warnings caught 60% of events with a modest false-alarm ratio, but the bias below 1 shows the forecasters were cautious; issuing a few more warnings would raise POD at the cost of FAR. The 85% proportion correct looks better than the CSI of 0.5 because of the 140 easy correct negatives.
Q2 (practice). A forecaster issued probability-of-rain forecasts on five days: 0.9, 0.7, 0.2, 0.1 and 0.6. Rain occurred on the first two days only.
(i) Compute the Brier score. (ii) Compute the Brier skill score against a climatological forecast of 0.4 on every day. (iii) Interpret.
Answer and worked solution
- \( BS = \frac{1}{5}[(0.9-1)^2 + (0.7-1)^2 + (0.2)^2 + (0.1)^2 + (0.6)^2] = \frac{1}{5}[0.01 + 0.09 + 0.04 + 0.01 + 0.36] = 0.51/5 = \) 0.102.
- Climatology: \( \frac{1}{5}[2(0.4-1)^2 + 3(0.4)^2] = \frac{1}{5}[0.72 + 0.48] = 0.24 \). \( BSS = 1 - 0.102/0.24 = \) 0.575.
- The forecasts have clear skill over climatology. Most of the error comes from day 5 (0.6 with no rain); without it, the score would be much better.
Q3 (practice). On a December evening over the Indo-Gangetic plains, a western disturbance has just passed. Observations at 12 UTC: sky clearing, surface wind 2 m s⁻¹ and expected to fall to 1–2 m s⁻¹ overnight, temperature 16 °C, dew point 11 °C, soil moist after rain the previous day. Normal minimum at the station is 8 °C.
Which of the following statements are correct?
(A) Radiation fog is likely by early morning. (B) The minimum temperature is unlikely to fall far below about 10–11 °C, because the air will saturate near the dew point and latent heat release and fog will slow further cooling. (C) If the minimum were instead 3.5 °C, a cold wave would apply on the absolute criterion. (D) A strong north-westerly wind of 8 m s⁻¹ overnight would make fog more likely.
- (a) A, B and C only
- (b) A and D only
- (c) B, C and D only
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B and C.
- (A) Clear sky, light wind, moist ground and a dew-point depression of 5 °C that the night will remove: classic radiation-fog setting after a WD. Correct.
- (B) Correct as a forecasting rule: once the air reaches its dew point, condensation (dew and fog) releases latent heat and the fog layer itself reduces longwave loss.
- (C) A plains minimum of 4 °C or less is a cold wave on the absolute criterion (2 °C or less would be severe). Correct.
- (D) Incorrect: strong wind mixes the boundary layer and prevents radiation fog.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Ranges | nowcast (0 to a few h), very short (to 12 h), short (1–3 d), medium (3–10 d), extended (10–30 d), long/seasonal |
| Classical methods | persistence, climatology, trend, analogue, synoptic |
| NWP chain | obs → QC → assimilation (3D/4D-Var, EnKF) → model → MOS → products; ensembles for uncertainty |
| CFL | \( c\Delta t/\Delta x \le 1 \) |
| Predictability | about two weeks for synoptic weather |
| IMD rain (24 h) | light 2.5–15.5; moderate 15.6–64.4; heavy 64.5–115.5; very heavy 115.6–204.4; extremely heavy ≥ 204.5 mm |
| Heat wave | ≥ 40 °C plains (37 coast, 30 hills); +4.5 to +6.4 °C = HW, > 6.4 = severe; or ≥ 45 / ≥ 47 °C |
| Cold wave | min ≤ 10 °C plains; −4.5 to −6.4 °C = CW, beyond −6.4 = severe; or ≤ 4 / ≤ 2 °C |
| Fog | < 1 km; radiation (clear, light wind, moist); advection (warm over cold, windy) |
| Indices | K = (T850 − T500) + Td850 − (T700 − Td700); TT = T850 + Td850 − 2T500; LI < 0 unstable; \( w_{max} \approx \sqrt{2\,\mathrm{CAPE}} \) |
| Hazards | nor’westers, andhi, hail, lightning, cloudbursts, heat and cold waves, fog, cyclones |
| Warnings | cyclone: watch → alert → warning → post-landfall outlook; colours green/yellow/orange/red |
| Verification | POD a/(a+c); FAR b/(a+b); CSI a/(a+b+c); bias (a+b)/(a+c); HSS; Brier score; SS = 1 − S/S_ref |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Synoptic Meteorology: Quick Revision — the whole unit on one page.
- Southwest and Northeast Monsoon — the seasonal and extended-range forecasting problem for India.
- Climate Change — how heat waves and heavy rain are changing.
- Synoptic Meteorology chapter overview