Electrical, SP and Temperature Logs
Resistivity tools (normal, lateral, laterolog, induction, micro), invasion profiles, the SP and Rw, Arps correction and temperature logs for CSIR NET.
- 22 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Logging Operations: Open-Hole, Cased-Hole, Production Logging and LWD — the invasion zones and the symbols \( R_m, R_{mf}, R_{xo}, R_t, R_w \) used throughout this page.
- Electrochemical Cells and the Nernst Equation — the SP is a concentration cell; its slope per decade of activity ratio comes from the Nernst equation.
- Gravity, Magnetism, Heat Flow and Isostasy — geothermal gradient and heat flow, the background for temperature logs.
- Hydrogeology: Darcy’s Law, Aquifers, Groundwater Exploration and Pollution — surface resistivity surveys use the same electrode physics as the borehole tools.
The Hook: Electrodes Down a Hole
How CSIR NET asks it. Part C Geophysics: choosing laterolog or induction for a given mud; reading invasion from shallow, medium and deep curves; the SP equation \( \text{SSP} = -K\log(R_{mf}/R_w) \) with temperature-dependent \( K \); SP polarity with fresh and salty mud; shale reduction of the SP; Arps temperature correction; formation temperature from a gradient; Horner extrapolation of bottom-hole temperatures; and conductivity contrasts on temperature logs.
Why Rocks Conduct
Dry rock-forming minerals (quartz, calcite, feldspar) are effectively insulators. Current in a sedimentary rock flows through the ions in the pore water, so the resistivity of a rock depends on:
- the resistivity of the water \( R_w \) (lower for higher salinity and higher temperature);
- the amount of water: porosity \( \phi \) and water saturation \( S_w \);
- the geometry of the pore network (tortuosity, cementation);
- clay minerals, which add surface conduction through exchangeable cations (the shaly-sand problem).
Oil and gas are insulators. So in a rock of given porosity, replacing water by hydrocarbon raises the resistivity. That is the basis of every saturation calculation (Archie’s law, on the formation evaluation page).
Temperature correction (Arps)
Electrolyte resistivity falls as temperature rises. The standard correction for NaCl solutions (Arps) is:
$$\boxed{R_2 = R_1\,\frac{T_1 + 21.5}{T_2 + 21.5}\ \ (T \text{ in } ^\circ\text{C})}\qquad\left(R_2 = R_1\,\frac{T_1 + 6.77}{T_2 + 6.77}\ \ (T \text{ in } ^\circ\text{F})\right)$$Mud and filtrate resistivities are measured at the surface and must be converted to formation temperature before use. Formation temperature is found from a linear geothermal gradient:
$$T_f = T_s + g\,D$$with surface (mean annual) temperature \( T_s \), gradient \( g \) and depth \( D \).
Resistivity Tools
Unfocused electrode devices (conventional electrical survey)
The first logs used current electrode A on the sonde, a return electrode B far away, and measuring electrodes M and N. In a homogeneous medium, the potential at distance \( r \) from a point current source \( I \) is \( V = IR/(4\pi r) \), so the apparent resistivity is
$$R_a = 4\pi\,\overline{AM}\,\frac{\Delta V}{I}\quad\text{(normal device)}.$$| Device | Arrangement | Response |
|---|---|---|
| Normal | A and M on the sonde, spacing \( \overline{AM} \); B and N remote. Short normal \( \overline{AM} \) = 16 in (about 0.4 m), long normal 64 in (about 1.6 m) | symmetrical curves about a bed; larger spacing reads deeper |
| Lateral | M and N close together at a larger distance from A | deeper reading; strongly asymmetrical curves, hard to read in thin beds |
These tools need a conductive mud, and in salty mud or in thin resistive beds the current takes the easy path through the mud column, so the readings are far from \( R_t \). They were replaced by focused devices, but they explain the vocabulary and appear in older logs.
Focused electrode devices: the laterolog
A laterolog adds guard (bucking) electrodes above and below the current electrode, held at the same potential, so the measuring current cannot run up and down the mud column. It is forced to flow radially into the formation as a thin sheet. Consequences:
- works well in salty (conductive) mud and in high-resistivity formations (carbonates, tight sands);
- good vertical resolution in thin beds;
- the current passes in series through mud, mud cake, flushed zone and uninvaded zone, so the reading is roughly a resistance-weighted sum and is dominated by the most resistive zone:
where \( J \) is the pseudo-geometric factor of the invaded zone (0 for no invasion, approaching 1 for deep invasion).
The dual laterolog records a deep (LLd) and a shallow (LLs) curve with different focusing. A pad-mounted micro-spherically focused log (MSFL) or microlaterolog gives \( R_{xo} \).
Induction logging
An induction tool carries transmitter and receiver coils. An alternating current in the transmitter (tens of kilohertz) induces eddy currents flowing in horizontal loops (ground loops) around the hole. These currents set up their own magnetic field, which induces a voltage in the receiver coil proportional to the conductivity of the formation. No electrodes touch the mud, so:
- it works in oil-based mud, fresh mud and air-filled holes;
- it is best in low-to-moderate resistivity formations (the signal is proportional to conductivity, so very resistive rocks give a tiny, noisy signal);
- the ground loops are in parallel, so the response is a conductance-weighted sum, dominated by the most conductive zone:
with geometric factor \( G \) of the invaded zone. Conductivity is often logged in mS/m: \( \sigma = 1000/R \) for \( R \) in Ω·m.
| Choose | When |
|---|---|
| Induction | fresh water-based or oil-based mud, air-filled hole; \( R_{mf} \) much greater than \( R_w \); low to moderate \( R_t \) |
| Laterolog | salty mud (\( R_{mf} \approx R_w \) or lower); high \( R_t \); thin beds |
Service-company charts draw the boundary between the two regions in terms of \( R_{mf}/R_w \) and \( R_t \); the exam asks for the direction of the choice, not the chart.
Micro-resistivity devices
Pad devices pressed against the wall read a few centimetres in: \( R_{xo} \) and mud cake.
- Microlog: two readings from one pad, a micro-inverse (about 1 in × 1 in spacing, reads mostly mud cake) and a micronormal (about 2 in, reads a little deeper). Opposite a permeable bed with mud cake, the micronormal reads higher than the micro-inverse: positive separation, a direct indicator of mud cake and therefore permeability. Opposite shale or tight rock the two read alike.
- Microlaterolog, proximity log, MSFL: focused pad devices for \( R_{xo} \) through mud cake of different thicknesses.
Interpreting resistivity curves: invasion profiles
| Case | Shallow (\( R_{xo} \)) vs deep (\( R_t \)) |
|---|---|
| Fresh mud (\( R_{mf} \gg R_w \)), water zone | \( R_{xo} > R_t \): shallow reads higher than deep (resistive invasion) |
| Fresh mud, hydrocarbon zone | both high; deep often similar to or above shallow |
| Salty mud (\( R_{mf} \approx R_w \)), water zone | \( R_{xo} \approx R_t \), both low: curves overlay |
| Salty mud, hydrocarbon zone | \( R_t > R_{xo} \): deep reads higher than shallow |
| Impermeable bed or shale | no invasion, curves overlay; no mud cake |
An annulus (a ring of low resistivity between flushed and uninvaded zone) can form in hydrocarbon zones, where the more mobile formation water pushed ahead of the filtrate accumulates. Deep induction readings are sensitive to it because it is conductive.
With three curves (shallow, medium, deep) the analyst solves a step-profile model for \( R_{xo} \), \( R_t \) and \( d_i \) on a tornado chart (also called a butterfly chart).
The Spontaneous Potential (SP)
The SP log records the difference between the potential of an electrode moving in the hole and a fixed electrode at the surface, with no current applied. It is a relative curve: what matters is the deflection from the shale baseline, the nearly straight line the curve follows opposite thick shales.
Where the SP comes from
The main source is electrochemical, arising because the mud filtrate and the formation water have different salinities:
graph TD
A["Salinity contrast
formation water vs mud filtrate"] --> B["Membrane potential
across shale: clay passes
cations (Na+), blocks anions"]
A --> C["Liquid-junction potential
at flushed/uninvaded boundary:
Cl- diffuses faster than Na+"]
B --> D["Electrochemical EMF
SSP = -K log(Rmf/Rw)"]
C --> D
E["Electrokinetic (streaming)
potential: filtrate forced
through mud cake"] --> F["Usually small;
larger with high overbalance,
low permeability"]- Membrane (shale) potential. Shale, with its negatively charged clay surfaces, acts as a cation-selective membrane. Na⁺ can pass from the saltier to the fresher solution through the shale; Cl⁻ cannot. This is the larger part of the EMF.
- Liquid-junction (diffusion) potential. At the contact between filtrate and formation water inside the permeable bed, both ions diffuse, but Cl⁻ is more mobile than Na⁺, so a smaller potential develops.
- Electrokinetic (streaming) potential. Filtrate flowing through the mud cake under the pressure overbalance generates a potential, usually small and ignored in the simple SP equation.
The SP equation
For a thick, clean, water-bearing bed, the total electrochemical EMF, the static SP (SSP), is:
$$\boxed{\text{SSP} = -K\,\log_{10}\frac{a_w}{a_{mf}} \approx -K\,\log_{10}\frac{R_{mf}}{R_w}}$$with the coefficient increasing with temperature:
$$K = 61 + 0.133\,T(^\circ\text{F}) \approx 65 + 0.24\,T(^\circ\text{C}),\qquad K \approx 71 \text{ mV at } 25\,^\circ\text{C}.$$Strictly, the equation uses ionic activities, written as equivalent resistivities \( R_{mfe} \) and \( R_{we} \); charts convert these to actual resistivities. For moderate salinities the simple form with \( R_{mf} \) and \( R_w \) is the exam form.
| Mud vs formation water | SP deflection opposite permeable bed |
|---|---|
| \( R_{mf} > R_w \) (fresh mud, saline formation water: the usual case) | negative (to the left of the shale baseline) |
| \( R_{mf} < R_w \) (salty mud, or fresh-water aquifer) | positive (reversed SP) |
| \( R_{mf} = R_w \) | none: the SP is flat, and the bed cannot be found from SP |
Why the measured SP is often less than the SSP
The SP log records only the ohmic potential drop in the mud of the SP current loop (mud → formation → shale → mud). The full SSP appears only when almost all the resistance of the loop is in the mud, which needs a thick, clean, permeable bed. The deflection is reduced by:
| Factor | Effect |
|---|---|
| Thin beds | the deflection never reaches the full SSP |
| Shaliness | clay in the sand reduces the membrane contrast: the pseudo-static SP (PSP) is smaller than the SSP |
| High \( R_t/R_m \), hydrocarbons | more of the loop resistance is in the formation: smaller deflection |
| Large hole, salty mud | smaller ohmic drop in the mud |
The SP reduction factor \( \alpha = \text{PSP}/\text{SSP} \) gives a rough shale estimate:
$$V_{sh} \approx 1 - \frac{\text{PSP}}{\text{SSP}}.$$Bed boundaries are at the inflection points of the SP curve, where the slope is greatest.
Uses of the SP
- Identifying permeable beds (any measurable SP deflection means ions can move, hence permeability; its size is not a measure of permeability).
- Locating bed boundaries and correlating between wells.
- Determining \( R_w \) from the SSP.
- Estimating shale volume.
- Reading depositional trends: in sand–shale sequences the SP shape, like the GR shape, shows fining-up (bell) and coarsening-up (funnel) units.
Temperature Logs
Geothermal gradient and heat flow
Temperature increases with depth. In steady conduction, the vertical heat flow \( q \) is constant through a layered sequence and obeys Fourier’s law:
$$q = k\,\frac{dT}{dz}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad \frac{dT}{dz} = \frac{q}{k}.$$So the gradient is inversely proportional to thermal conductivity \( k \). Shales (low \( k \)) show steep gradients; sandstones, and especially rock salt and quartz-rich rocks (high \( k \)), show gentle ones. A temperature log in a well at thermal equilibrium therefore changes slope at lithological boundaries and can be used for correlation and conductivity estimation. Undercompacted, overpressured shales hold extra water, have lower conductivity and show anomalously high gradients. Heat flow and its global pattern are covered in Gravity, Magnetism, Heat Flow and Isostasy.
Bottom-hole temperature and the Horner correction
Each logging run records a bottom-hole temperature (BHT) with maximum-reading thermometers. Circulating mud cools the bottom of the hole, so BHTs taken soon after circulation stops are too low. With several BHTs from successive runs, the Horner plot extrapolates to the static formation temperature: plot each BHT against \( \log_{10}[(t_c + \Delta t)/\Delta t] \), where \( t_c \) is circulation time and \( \Delta t \) the time since circulation stopped. The points fall on a straight line, and its intercept at \( (t_c + \Delta t)/\Delta t = 1 \) (log = 0, infinite shut-in time) is the static temperature.
$$T(\Delta t) = T_{static} - m\,\log_{10}\frac{t_c + \Delta t}{\Delta t}$$What temperature logs are run for
| Application | Signature |
|---|---|
| Cement top | warm anomaly from the heat of hydration of setting cement, logged within a day or so of cementing; the anomaly ends at the cement top |
| Gas entry | cooling where gas expands into the wellbore |
| Liquid entry | departure from the geothermal line; liquid from deeper, warmer zones carried upward |
| Lost-circulation zones | cool anomaly where large volumes of cold mud entered the rock |
| Injection profile | zones taking cold injected water stay cool longest after shut-in (slow warm-back) |
| Flow behind casing and leaks | non-geothermal shape between zones in a shut-in well |
| Thermal conductivity and overpressure | slope changes with lithology; high gradient in undercompacted shale |
| Corrections for other logs | formation temperature for Arps and SP \( K \) |
A differential temperature log displays the change in temperature over a short fixed depth interval, which sharpens small anomalies.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| SSP vs PSP | full electrochemical EMF of a thick clean bed | reduced SP of a shaly bed |
| Membrane vs liquid-junction potential | across shale; cation-selective; larger | at filtrate/formation-water contact; Cl⁻ faster than Na⁺; smaller |
| Laterolog vs induction | electrodes; series; salty mud; high \( R_t \) | coils; parallel; fresh or oil mud; low to moderate \( R_t \) |
| Normal vs lateral device | M close to A; symmetrical response | M and N close together far from A; asymmetrical, deeper |
| Micro-inverse vs micronormal | shallower, reads mud cake | slightly deeper; reads higher opposite permeable beds |
| BHT vs static formation temperature | measured, cooled by circulation | true, from Horner extrapolation |
| SP deflection size vs permeability | size depends on salinity contrast | any deflection shows permeability; size does not measure it |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which resistivity tool, laterolog or induction, would you choose in a well drilled with oil-based mud?
- Write the SP equation for a clean, water-bearing sand.
- Why does the geothermal gradient steepen in a shale compared with an adjacent sandstone?
Answers
- Induction. It needs no conductive path in the mud; laterolog and SP do.
- \( \text{SSP} = -K\log_{10}(R_{mf}/R_w) \), with \( K \approx 65 + 0.24\,T(^\circ\text{C}) \).
- Heat flow is constant through the column and \( dT/dz = q/k \); shale has lower thermal conductivity, so its gradient is higher.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A thick clean sand at 75 °C shows an SSP of −83 mV. \( R_{mf} \) at formation temperature is 0.60 Ω·m. Using \( K = 65 + 0.24\,T(^\circ\text{C}) \), \( R_w \) is:
(a) 0.041 Ω·m (b) 0.060 Ω·m (c) 0.60 Ω·m (d) 6.0 Ω·m
Answer: (b) 0.060 Ω·m
\( K = 65 + 18 = 83 \) mV, so \( \log_{10}(R_{mf}/R_w) = 1 \) and \( R_w = 0.60/10 = 0.060 \) Ω·m. (a) uses \( K = 71 \). (c) ignores the SP. (d) inverts the ratio, which would correspond to a positive SP.
Practice Q2. Mud-filtrate resistivity is 0.90 Ω·m at 25 °C. Its value at 100 °C (Arps) is closest to:
(a) 0.23 Ω·m (b) 0.34 Ω·m (c) 0.90 Ω·m (d) 2.35 Ω·m
Answer: (b) 0.34 Ω·m
\( 0.90 \times (25 + 21.5)/(100 + 21.5) = 0.90 \times 0.3827 = 0.344 \) Ω·m. (a) uses the plain temperature ratio \( 25/100 \). (d) inverts the Arps ratio (resistivity would rise with temperature, which is wrong). (c) applies no correction.
Practice Q3. A well is drilled with salty mud whose filtrate resistivity is lower than that of the formation water in a sandstone aquifer. Opposite the sandstone the SP will:
(a) deflect negative from the shale baseline (b) deflect positive from the shale baseline (c) show no deflection at all (d) show the same deflection as in fresh mud, since SP depends only on permeability
Answer: (b)
With \( R_{mf} < R_w \), \( \log(R_{mf}/R_w) < 0 \) and SSP \( = -K\log(R_{mf}/R_w) > 0 \): a reversed (positive) SP. (a) is the usual fresh-mud case. (c) needs \( R_{mf} = R_w \). (d) is wrong because the SP is driven by the salinity contrast.
Practice Q4. On a microlog, positive separation (micronormal reading higher than micro-inverse) opposite a sandstone most directly indicates:
(a) hydrocarbons (b) mud cake, hence a permeable bed (c) an overpressured zone (d) a washed-out hole
Answer: (b)
The micro-inverse reads mainly the low-resistivity mud cake; the micronormal reads a little deeper into the more resistive flushed zone. Mud cake forms only where filtrate can enter the rock, so separation means permeability. In a washout (d) the pad loses contact and both curves read mud resistivity, with no separation.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Two bottom-hole temperatures were recorded on successive logging runs. Mud had been circulated for 4 h before circulation stopped. The BHT is 96.0 °C at 4 h after circulation stopped and 101.4 °C at 16 h. Using a Horner plot, the static formation temperature is closest to:
(a) 101.4 °C (b) 104 °C (c) 107 °C (d) 112 °C
Answer: (b) 104 °C
Horner time ratios: \( (4 + 4)/4 = 2 \) and \( (4 + 16)/16 = 1.25 \); \( \log_{10} \) values 0.3010 and 0.0969.
Slope: \( m = (101.4 - 96.0)/(0.3010 - 0.0969) = 5.4/0.2041 = 26.5 \) °C per log cycle.
Extrapolate to ratio 1 (log 0): \( T_{static} = 96.0 + 26.5 \times 0.3010 = 104.0 \) °C.
(a) takes the last BHT as static, but every BHT is still cooled by circulation. (c) and (d) overshoot: the two points fix a single straight line, and its value at log ratio 0 is 104 °C (the result is the same with natural logarithms, since only the ratio of the log differences matters).
Practice Q6. In a water-bearing sand drilled with fresh mud, the deep induction reads 2.5 Ω·m, the flushed-zone resistivity is 10 Ω·m and the invaded zone contributes a geometric factor \( G = 0.2 \) to the deep reading. Formation porosity is 0.25 and \( F = 1/\phi^2 \). Which pair (true resistivity, apparent water resistivity \( R_{wa} = R_t/F \)) is correct?
(a) 2.1 Ω·m, 0.13 Ω·m (b) 2.5 Ω·m, 0.16 Ω·m (c) 2.1 Ω·m, 0.53 Ω·m (d) 0.63 Ω·m, 0.039 Ω·m
Answer: (a)
Induction responds to conductivity in parallel: \( 1/R_t = (1/2.5 - 0.2/10)/0.8 = 0.38/0.8 = 0.475 \), \( R_t = 2.105 \) Ω·m.
\( F = 1/0.25^2 = 16 \). \( R_{wa} = 2.105/16 = 0.132 \) Ω·m.
(b) uses the uncorrected deep reading (\( 2.5/16 = 0.156 \)). (c) takes \( F = 1/\phi \) (\( 2.105 \times 0.25 = 0.53 \)). (d) applies the series (laterolog) mixing rule to an induction tool: \( R_t = (2.5 - 0.2 \times 10)/0.8 = 0.625 \) Ω·m and \( R_{wa} = 0.039 \) Ω·m. Note that the uncorrected reading inflates \( R_{wa} \) by almost 20%: in a water zone this could be misread as a hint of hydrocarbon.
Practice Q7. Consider these statements:
- The membrane potential across shale is larger than the liquid-junction potential in a typical SP.
- A laterolog reading is dominated by the most conductive zone in its path.
- A temperature log run a few hours after cementing shows a warm anomaly that ends at the top of the cement.
- In a clean sand with \( R_{mf} = R_w \), the SP cannot be used to identify the bed.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 3 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) all four
Answer: (b) 1, 3 and 4 only
- True. Shale acts as a nearly perfect cation-selective membrane; the liquid-junction term is the smaller part.
- False. The laterolog current flows through the zones in series, so the most resistive zone dominates. Induction (parallel) is dominated by the most conductive zone.
- True. Cement hydration is exothermic; the anomaly marks where cement is present.
- True. With no salinity contrast there is no electrochemical EMF, so the SP is flat.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Conduction | through pore-water ions; hydrocarbons and matrix insulate; clays add surface conduction |
| Arps | \( R_2 = R_1(T_1 + 21.5)/(T_2 + 21.5) \) (°C); \( +6.77 \) in °F |
| Formation temperature | \( T_f = T_s + gD \) |
| Normal device | \( R_a = 4\pi\overline{AM}\,\Delta V/I \); 16 in and 64 in spacings |
| Laterolog | focused; series; salty mud, high \( R_t \), thin beds; LLd, LLs, MSFL |
| Induction | coils, eddy currents; parallel; fresh or oil mud, low–moderate \( R_t \); \( \sigma = 1000/R \) mS/m |
| Invasion, fresh mud, water zone | \( R_{xo} > R_t \) |
| Invasion, salty mud, hydrocarbon zone | \( R_t > R_{xo} \) |
| Microlog | positive separation = mud cake = permeable |
| SSP | \( -K\log_{10}(R_{mf}/R_w) \); \( K \approx 65 + 0.24T(^\circ\text{C}) \), 71 at 25 °C |
| SP polarity | negative if \( R_{mf} > R_w \); positive if \( R_{mf} < R_w \); flat if equal |
| Shale from SP | \( V_{sh} \approx 1 - \text{PSP}/\text{SSP} \) |
| Bed boundary | SP inflection point |
| Gradient | \( dT/dz = q/k \): steep in shale, gentle in salt and sandstone |
| Horner | BHT vs \( \log[(t_c + \Delta t)/\Delta t] \); intercept at ratio 1 = static temperature |
| Temperature anomalies | gas entry cold; cement warm; lost circulation cold |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Porosity Logs: Sonic, Density, Neutron and Gamma Ray: the second half of the measurements, porosity and shale volume.
- Formation Evaluation: Formation Factor, Porosity, Permeability, Saturation and Lithology: where \( R_t \) and \( R_w \) from this page go into Archie’s equation.
- Mineral Exploration: Methods, Sampling and Evaluation: the surface electrical methods from which logging grew.
- Well Logging: back to the chapter overview.