Skip to content

Formation Evaluation: Formation Factor, Porosity, Permeability, Saturation and Lithology

Archie's formation factor and saturation equations, Rwa and Pickett plots, moveable hydrocarbons, log permeability and lithology crossplots for CSIR NET.

  • 21 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 15 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Archie’s Cores
  3. The Workflow
  4. Formation Factor
  5. Water Saturation: Archie’s Equation
  6. Permeability from Logs
  7. Lithology from Logs
  8. From Logs to Pay
  9. Memory Tricks
  10. Don’t Confuse
  11. Common Mistakes
  12. Practice
  13. Quick Revision Table
  14. Key Takeaways
  15. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Archie’s Cores

How CSIR NET asks it. Part C Geophysics numericals: formation factor and \( R_o \); water saturation by Archie; \( R_w \) from a water zone and the \( R_{wa} \) method; Pickett-plot slope as \( m \); flushed-zone saturation and hydrocarbon movability; bulk volume water and irreducible saturation; log-derived permeability; lithology from M–N, matrix-density and Pe plots; and statement questions on the assumptions (clean formation, shaly sands, choice of \( a \), \( m \), \( n \)).


The Workflow

graph TD
    A["Quality check
caliper, depth match,
borehole corrections"] --> B["Shale volume
GR, SP, N-D separation"] B --> C["Lithology
Pe, N-D crossplot, M-N"] C --> D["Porosity
density, neutron, sonic
with correct matrix"] D --> E["Rw
SP, water-zone Rwa,
Pickett plot, samples"] E --> F["Water saturation
Archie (clean) or
shaly-sand model"] F --> G["Movability and
permeability
Sxo, BVW, k estimate"] G --> H["Net pay and
hydrocarbon volume
cutoffs, h phi (1 - Sw)"]

Formation Factor

For a clean (clay-free) rock fully saturated with water of resistivity \( R_w \), the rock resistivity \( R_o \) is proportional to \( R_w \). The constant of proportionality is the formation (resistivity) factor:

$$\boxed{F = \frac{R_o}{R_w}}$$

\( F \) depends only on the pore structure. More porosity means more conducting paths and a lower \( F \); more tortuous and more cemented pores mean a higher \( F \). Archie’s empirical relation:

$$\boxed{F = \frac{a}{\phi^{m}}}$$
ParameterNameTypical values
\( a \)tortuosity factor1 (Archie); 0.62 (Humble formula for sands, with \( m = 2.15 \)); 0.81 (with \( m = 2 \), a common approximation to Humble)
\( m \)cementation exponentabout 1.3 for unconsolidated sands; about 2 for consolidated sandstones and intergranular carbonates; higher (2.5 and above) where porosity is in isolated vugs or moulds; lower (towards 1) where fractures provide straight paths
\( n \)saturation exponent (next section)about 2 for water-wet rocks; higher in oil-wet rocks

Because \( F = 1/\phi^m \) with \( a = 1 \) gives \( F = 1 \) at \( \phi = 1 \) (pure water), \( a = 1 \) is the physically consistent choice; \( a \ne 1 \) values are fits over a limited porosity range.


Water Saturation: Archie’s Equation

When hydrocarbons occupy part of the pore space, the rock is more resistive than \( R_o \). The resistivity index \( I \) relates the two:

$$I = \frac{R_t}{R_o} = S_w^{-n}$$

Combining with \( F \):

$$\boxed{S_w = \left(\frac{a\,R_w}{\phi^{m}\,R_t}\right)^{1/n} = \left(\frac{F\,R_w}{R_t}\right)^{1/n} = \left(\frac{R_o}{R_t}\right)^{1/n}}$$

With \( n = 2 \), a rock reading four times \( R_o \) has \( S_w = 0.5 \); one reading 16 times \( R_o \) has \( S_w = 0.25 \). Hydrocarbon saturation is \( S_h = 1 - S_w \).

Assumptions: clean formation (no conductive clay), the matrix and hydrocarbon are insulators, \( R_t \) is the true uninvaded resistivity, \( R_w \) is at formation temperature, and \( a \), \( m \), \( n \) are appropriate for the rock.

The flushed zone

The same law applies to the flushed zone with filtrate:

$$S_{xo} = \left(\frac{a\,R_{mf}}{\phi^{m}\,R_{xo}}\right)^{1/n}$$

\( 1 - S_{xo} \) is the residual hydrocarbon saturation left after invasion. Comparing \( S_w \) and \( S_{xo} \) shows whether the hydrocarbons moved:

  • \( S_{xo} \approx S_w \): filtrate did not displace hydrocarbon; hydrocarbons are not moveable (or the zone is water).
  • \( S_{xo} \gg S_w \): filtrate pushed hydrocarbons out; they are moveable. The moveable hydrocarbon index \( S_w/S_{xo} \) is well below 1.
  • Moveable hydrocarbon volume: \( \phi(S_{xo} - S_w) \).

Ratio method. Dividing the two Archie equations eliminates \( \phi \), \( a \) and \( m \):

$$\frac{R_{xo}}{R_t} = \frac{R_{mf}}{R_w}\left(\frac{S_w}{S_{xo}}\right)^{n}$$

It needs no porosity, only \( R_{xo}/R_t \) and \( R_{mf}/R_w \) (which the SP gives directly). An extra empirical assumption about the link between \( S_{xo} \) and \( S_w \) in moderately invaded zones then gives \( S_w \) alone.

Finding Rw

  1. From a water zone: in a clean zone known to be 100% water, \( R_t = R_o \), so \( R_w = R_o/F = R_o\,\phi^m/a \).
  2. From the SP: \( \text{SSP} = -K\log(R_{mf}/R_w) \) (see the electrical logs page).
  3. From produced-water samples or catalogues, corrected to formation temperature.
  4. \( R_{wa} \) method: compute the apparent water resistivity
$$R_{wa} = \frac{R_t}{F} = \frac{R_t\,\phi^m}{a}$$

at every depth. In water zones \( R_{wa} = R_w \), so the lowest \( R_{wa} \) values in a clean sequence give \( R_w \). Elsewhere \( S_w = (R_w/R_{wa})^{1/n} \): with \( n = 2 \), \( R_{wa} \ge 4R_w \) means \( S_w \le 0.5 \), a quick hydrocarbon flag.

The Pickett plot

Take logarithms of Archie’s equation:

$$\log R_t = -m\,\log\phi + \log(a\,R_w) - n\,\log S_w$$

On log–log axes of \( R_t \) (x or y) against \( \phi \), points of constant \( S_w \) lie on straight lines of slope \( -m \) (in the \( \log R_t \) versus \( \log\phi \) sense). The water line (\( S_w = 1 \)) passes through the water-zone points; its slope gives \( m \), and its value at \( \phi = 1 \) gives \( aR_w \). Lines for \( S_w = 0.5, 0.25 \dots \) are parallel, shifted by \( n\log S_w \). Hydrocarbon points plot on the high-resistivity side. The plot solves for \( m \), \( R_w \) and \( S_w \) together without knowing any of them beforehand.

A Hingle plot does the same on linear axes by plotting \( \phi \) against \( R_t^{-1/m} \) (for a chosen \( m \)): water-zone points fall on a straight line through the matrix point.

Bulk volume water

$$\text{BVW} = \phi\,S_w$$

is the fraction of the bulk rock occupied by water. In a zone at irreducible water saturation (water held by capillarity, not producible), BVW is nearly constant from level to level: where porosity is higher, \( S_w \) is proportionally lower. Scattered BVW values suggest a transition zone that will produce some water. Finer-grained rocks hold more irreducible water, so the constant value depends on grain size and lithology.

Shaly sands

Clay minerals conduct through exchangeable cations on their surfaces. In a shaly sand this extra conduction lowers \( R_t \), so the clean Archie equation over-estimates \( S_w \): hydrocarbon zones can look wet (“low-resistivity pay”). Shaly-sand models add a clay-conductivity term: the Simandoux and Indonesia equations (using \( V_{sh} \) and \( R_{sh} \)), and the Waxman–Smits and dual-water models (using the cation exchange capacity of the clays). For the exam, know the direction of the error and the names.


Permeability from Logs

Permeability \( k \) is the ability of a rock to transmit fluid (Darcy’s law). Its unit is the darcy: about \( 0.987\times10^{-12} \) m²; reservoir values are usually given in millidarcies (md). Unlike porosity, permeability depends on pore-throat size, not just pore volume, and no conventional log measures it directly.

ApproachWhat it uses
Qualitative indicatorsmud cake on the caliper, microlog positive separation, SP deflection, separation of shallow and deep resistivity (invasion), Stoneley-wave attenuation
Empirical porosity–saturation transformspermeability rises with porosity and falls with irreducible water saturation (finer grains hold more water and have smaller throats). The Timur form, with \( \phi \) and \( S_{wi} \) in percent: \( k\ (\text{md}) = 0.136\,\phi^{4.4}/S_{wi}^{2} \)
NMR logsrelaxation-time distribution gives pore sizes, free-fluid and bound-fluid volumes; permeability from Coates or mean-\( T_2 \) (SDR) type transforms calibrated to cores
Formation testerspressure drawdown and build-up at a probe give fluid mobility \( k/\mu \)
Core calibrationlog porosity related to core permeability by a field-specific regression

Lithology from Logs

Single logs are ambiguous: a porosity reading depends on both lithology and porosity. Crossplots of two porosity logs separate the two, because each mineral has a different combination of responses.

Two-log crossplots

CrossplotWhat it shows
Neutron–densitythe most used: lines for sandstone, limestone and dolomite, graduated in porosity; a point between two lines gives a two-mineral mix and its porosity. Gas moves points to the upper left (towards low neutron), shale towards high neutron
Sonic–density and sonic–neutronsimilar, less sensitive to gas in some cases; sonic misses secondary porosity
Pe–densityPe identifies the mineral almost independently of porosity

Lithology-independent parameters

M–N plot. Combines all three porosity logs into two quantities that depend mainly on the matrix:

$$M = \frac{\Delta t_f - \Delta t}{\rho_b - \rho_f}\times0.01,\qquad N = \frac{\phi_{Nf} - \phi_N}{\rho_b - \rho_f}$$

(\( \Delta t \) in µs/ft, densities in g/cm³, \( \phi_{Nf} = 1 \) for fresh water). Using \( \Delta t_f = 189 \), \( \rho_f = 1.0 \): pure limestone gives \( M = 0.827 \), \( N = 0.585 \); sandstone gives \( M \approx 0.81 \); dolomite \( M \approx 0.78 \). Points fall inside the triangle of the three minerals; gas, shale and secondary porosity shift them in known directions.

Apparent matrix parameters (MID plots). Using porosity from the neutron–density crossplot, compute the matrix value that would explain each reading:

$$\rho_{maa} = \frac{\rho_b - \phi\,\rho_f}{1 - \phi},\qquad \Delta t_{maa} = \frac{\Delta t - \phi\,\Delta t_f}{1 - \phi},\qquad U_{maa} = \frac{\text{Pe}\,\rho_e - \phi\,U_f}{1 - \phi}$$

A clean quartz sandstone gives \( \rho_{maa} \approx 2.65 \) and \( U_{maa} \approx 4.8 \); calcite about 2.71 and 13.8; dolomite about 2.87 and 9.0. Anhydrite plots apart on \( \rho_{maa} \).


From Logs to Pay

  1. Cutoffs. Net reservoir is rock with \( V_{sh} \) below and \( \phi \) above chosen limits; net pay adds an \( S_w \) limit. Cutoffs are field-specific, set from core and test data.
  2. Hydrocarbon pore thickness: \( \text{HPT} = \sum h\,\phi\,(1 - S_w) \) over net pay. For 20 m of net pay at \( \phi = 0.20 \) and \( S_w = 0.25 \): \( 20 \times 0.20 \times 0.75 = 3.0 \) m of hydrocarbon column.
  3. Fluid type: gas from neutron–density crossover; oil versus water from resistivity; contacts from changes in \( R_t \) or \( R_{wa} \) in a continuous sand, confirmed by formation-tester pressure gradients.
  4. Volumes: \( A \times \text{HPT} \) divided by the formation volume factor gives in-place hydrocarbon, as in the STOIIP equation of the petroleum geology page.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

PairFirstSecond
\( R_o \) vs \( R_t \)resistivity if 100% water-saturatedmeasured true resistivity, with whatever fluids are present
\( F \) vs \( I \)\( R_o/R_w \): pore geometry\( R_t/R_o = S_w^{-n} \): saturation
\( m \) vs \( n \)cementation exponent: pore geometrysaturation exponent: wettability
\( S_w \) vs \( S_{xo} \)uninvaded zone, with \( R_t \), \( R_w \)flushed zone, with \( R_{xo} \), \( R_{mf} \)
\( S_{wi} \) vs \( S_w \)irreducible (immobile) saturationactual saturation; equal only at irreducible conditions
Porosity vs permeabilitystorage (pore volume)flow (pore throats)
\( R_{wa} \) vs \( R_w \)computed at every level as \( R_t/F \)true water resistivity; equals \( R_{wa} \) only in water zones
Neutron–density crossplot vs M–N plottwo logs; lithology and porosity togetherthree logs; lithology largely independent of porosity

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Define the formation factor in terms of resistivities.
  2. Write Archie’s water-saturation equation.
  3. What does a constant value of \( \phi S_w \) through a reservoir interval suggest?
Answers
  1. \( F = R_o/R_w \): resistivity of the fully water-saturated rock divided by the resistivity of the water; also \( F = a/\phi^m \).
  2. \( S_w^{\,n} = aR_w/(\phi^m R_t) \).
  3. The zone is at irreducible water saturation: it should produce hydrocarbon with little or no water.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. A clean sandstone has porosity 0.20, \( R_w = 0.05 \) Ω·m and \( R_t = 20 \) Ω·m. With \( a = 1 \), \( m = n = 2 \), the water saturation is:

(a) 0.0625 (b) 0.11 (c) 0.25 (d) 0.50

Answer: (c) 0.25

\( F = 1/0.20^2 = 25 \); \( R_o = 25 \times 0.05 = 1.25 \) Ω·m; \( S_w = \sqrt{1.25/20} = \sqrt{0.0625} = 0.25 \). (a) forgets the square root. (b) uses \( F = 1/\phi = 5 \), so \( S_w = \sqrt{0.25/20} = 0.11 \). (d) takes the root twice, \( 0.0625^{1/4} = 0.5 \).

Practice Q2. In a clean sand with porosity 0.25 (\( a = 1 \), \( m = 2 \)), \( R_t = 2.0 \) Ω·m. Water zones in the same sand give \( R_w = 0.05 \) Ω·m. The apparent water resistivity and the implied water saturation (\( n = 2 \)) are:

(a) 0.125 Ω·m; 0.63 (b) 0.125 Ω·m; 0.40 (c) 0.50 Ω·m; 0.32 (d) 0.125 Ω·m; 0.16

Answer: (a) 0.125 Ω·m; 0.63

\( F = 16 \), \( R_{wa} = R_t/F = 2.0/16 = 0.125 \) Ω·m. \( S_w = (R_w/R_{wa})^{1/2} = (0.4)^{1/2} = 0.632 \). (b) forgets the root. (c) uses \( F = 1/\phi = 4 \), so \( R_{wa} = 0.5 \) and \( S_w = \sqrt{0.1} = 0.32 \). (d) squares the ratio instead of taking its root.

Practice Q3. On a Pickett plot from a water-bearing sand, one point has \( \phi = 0.10 \), \( R_t = 10 \) Ω·m and another \( \phi = 0.25 \), \( R_t = 1.6 \) Ω·m. With \( a = 1 \), the cementation exponent and \( R_w \) are:

(a) \( m = 2.0 \), \( R_w = 0.10 \) Ω·m (b) \( m = 2.0 \), \( R_w = 1.0 \) Ω·m (c) \( m = 1.5 \), \( R_w = 0.32 \) Ω·m (d) \( m = 2.5 \), \( R_w = 0.03 \) Ω·m

Answer: (a)

Slope: \( m = \log(10/1.6)/\log(0.25/0.10) = 0.796/0.398 = 2.0 \). Then \( R_w = R_o\phi^m = 10 \times 0.01 = 0.10 \) Ω·m (check: \( 1.6 \times 0.0625 = 0.10 \)). (b) multiplies by \( \phi \) instead of \( \phi^m \) (\( 10 \times 0.10 = 1.0 \)). (c) and (d) misread the slope.

Practice Q4. Using the Timur relation \( k = 0.136\,\phi^{4.4}/S_{wi}^2 \) (md; \( \phi \) and \( S_{wi} \) in percent), a sand with 25% porosity and 20% irreducible water has a permeability of about:

(a) 5 md (b) 48 md (c) 480 md (d) 4,800 md

Answer: (c) about 480 md

\( 25^{4.4} = e^{4.4\ln25} = e^{14.163} \approx 1.416\times10^6 \). \( k = 0.136 \times 1.416\times10^6/400 \approx 481 \) md. The other options are powers-of-ten slips; estimate \( 25^{4.4} \) via logarithms (\( 4.4 \times 1.398 = 6.15 \)) to check the order of magnitude.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. Three clean sandstone zones in one well (same water) give:

ZoneGR (API)\( \rho_b \) (g/cm³)\( \phi_N \) (sandstone units)\( R_t \) (Ω·m)
A302.250.0960
B322.320.2120
C302.320.201.25

Take \( \rho_{ma} = 2.65 \), \( \rho_f = 1.0 \), \( a = 1 \), \( m = n = 2 \). Zone C is known to be water-bearing. Which interpretation is correct?

(a) A gas with \( S_w \approx 0.16 \); B oil with \( S_w \approx 0.24 \); C water, \( R_w = 0.05 \) Ω·m (b) A oil with \( S_w \approx 0.12 \); B gas with \( S_w \approx 0.24 \); C water, \( R_w = 0.05 \) Ω·m (c) A gas with \( S_w \approx 0.16 \); B water; C water, \( R_w = 0.25 \) Ω·m (d) A shale; B oil with \( S_w \approx 0.50 \); C water, \( R_w = 0.05 \) Ω·m

Answer: (a)

C (water zone): \( \phi_D = (2.65 - 2.32)/1.65 = 0.20 \), agreeing with \( \phi_N = 0.20 \); \( \phi = 0.20 \). \( R_w = R_t\phi^2 = 1.25 \times 0.04 = 0.05 \) Ω·m.

A: \( \phi_D = 0.40/1.65 = 0.242 \) against \( \phi_N = 0.09 \): a large crossover with low GR, so gas. \( \phi = \sqrt{(0.0081 + 0.0588)/2} = \sqrt{0.03344} = 0.183 \). \( S_w = \sqrt{0.05/(0.03344 \times 60)} = \sqrt{0.0249} = 0.158 \).

B: \( \phi_D = 0.20 \), \( \phi_N = 0.21 \): no crossover, liquid. \( \phi \approx 0.205 \). \( S_w = \sqrt{0.05/(0.0420 \times 20)} = \sqrt{0.0595} = 0.244 \): oil.

(b) takes A’s porosity as the density value alone (\( S_w = \sqrt{0.05/(0.242^2 \times 60)} \approx 0.12 \)), misses the gas signature, and calls the liquid zone B gas. (c) misreads C (\( R_w = 1.25 \times 0.20 \) uses \( m = 1 \)). (d) calls A shale despite its low GR.

Practice Q6. A vuggy limestone has porosity 0.15, \( R_w = 0.04 \) Ω·m and \( R_t = 30 \) Ω·m. An analyst uses \( m = 2 \); core measurements later show \( m = 2.5 \) (\( a = 1 \), \( n = 2 \)). Which statement is correct?

(a) \( S_w \) changes from about 0.24 to about 0.39; the original estimate was optimistic (b) \( S_w \) changes from about 0.39 to about 0.24; the original estimate was pessimistic (c) \( S_w \) is unchanged because \( m \) cancels in Archie’s equation (d) \( S_w \) changes from about 0.24 to about 0.32

Answer: (a)

\( m = 2 \): \( \phi^2 = 0.0225 \), \( S_w = \sqrt{0.04/(0.0225 \times 30)} = \sqrt{0.0593} = 0.243 \).

\( m = 2.5 \): \( \phi^{2.5} = 0.008714 \), \( S_w = \sqrt{0.04/(0.008714 \times 30)} = \sqrt{0.153} = 0.391 \).

A higher \( m \) means a higher \( F \), so more of the measured resistivity is explained by pore geometry and less by hydrocarbons: \( S_w \) rises. The \( m = 2 \) answer was optimistic. (c) confuses Archie with the ratio method, where \( m \) cancels. (d) changes the wrong exponent: keeping \( m = 2 \) and setting \( n = 2.5 \) gives \( 0.0593^{0.4} = 0.32 \).

Practice Q7. In a clean sand (\( \phi = 0.20 \), \( a = 1 \), \( m = n = 2 \)): \( R_t = 20 \) Ω·m, \( R_w = 0.05 \) Ω·m, \( R_{xo} = 15 \) Ω·m and \( R_{mf} = 0.50 \) Ω·m. Consider these statements:

  1. \( S_w = 0.25 \) and \( S_{xo} \approx 0.91 \).
  2. The moveable hydrocarbon index \( S_w/S_{xo} \approx 0.27 \), indicating moveable hydrocarbons.
  3. The ratio method gives \( S_w/S_{xo} \) without using porosity, and agrees with statement 2.
  4. Residual hydrocarbon saturation in the flushed zone is about 0.75.

Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) all four

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. True. \( S_w = \sqrt{25 \times 0.05/20} = 0.25 \); \( S_{xo} = \sqrt{25 \times 0.50/15} = \sqrt{0.833} = 0.913 \).
  2. True. \( 0.25/0.913 = 0.274 \): far below 1, so filtrate has displaced most of the hydrocarbon near the hole.
  3. True. \( (S_w/S_{xo})^2 = (R_{xo}/R_t)/(R_{mf}/R_w) = 0.75/10 = 0.075 \), so \( S_w/S_{xo} = 0.274 \).
  4. False. Residual hydrocarbon saturation is \( 1 - S_{xo} = 0.087 \), about 0.09. The value 0.75 is the original hydrocarbon saturation \( 1 - S_w \).

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact or formula
Formation factor\( F = R_o/R_w = a/\phi^m \)
Constants\( a = 1 \), \( m = n = 2 \); Humble \( 0.62/\phi^{2.15} \); \( m \approx 1.3 \) unconsolidated, higher for vugs, lower for fractures
Resistivity index\( I = R_t/R_o = S_w^{-n} \)
Archie\( S_w = (aR_w/\phi^m R_t)^{1/n} \)
Flushed zone\( S_{xo} = (aR_{mf}/\phi^m R_{xo})^{1/n} \); residual HC \( = 1 - S_{xo} \)
Movability\( S_w/S_{xo} \ll 1 \): moveable; moveable volume \( \phi(S_{xo} - S_w) \)
Ratio method\( R_{xo}/R_t = (R_{mf}/R_w)(S_w/S_{xo})^n \); no porosity needed
\( R_{wa} \)\( R_t/F \); minimum in clean sequence = \( R_w \); \( S_w = (R_w/R_{wa})^{1/n} \)
Pickettlog \( R_t \) vs log \( \phi \): slope \( -m \), water line through \( aR_w \) at \( \phi = 1 \)
BVW\( \phi S_w \); constant at irreducible saturation
Shaly sandclay conduction lowers \( R_t \); clean Archie over-estimates \( S_w \); Simandoux, Indonesia, Waxman–Smits, dual water
Permeabilitynot measured directly; Timur \( k = 0.136\phi^{4.4}/S_{wi}^2 \); NMR; testers; 1 D ≈ \( 0.987\times10^{-12} \) m²
M–N\( M = 0.01(\Delta t_f - \Delta t)/(\rho_b - \rho_f) \); \( N = (\phi_{Nf} - \phi_N)/(\rho_b - \rho_f) \); limestone 0.827, 0.585
Apparent matrix\( \rho_{maa} = (\rho_b - \phi\rho_f)/(1 - \phi) \); \( U_{maa} \): quartz 4.8, dolomite 9.0, calcite 13.8
Paycutoffs on \( V_{sh} \), \( \phi \), \( S_w \); HPT \( = \sum h\phi(1 - S_w) \)

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement