Skip to content

Logical Reasoning: Statements, Syllogisms and Arguments

CSIR NET Part A logical reasoning: conditionals, valid inference, negation, syllogisms with Venn diagrams, truth-tellers and liars, and arguments.

  • 22 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 15 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: The Lethal Knockout
  3. Propositions and Connectives
  4. Conditional Statements
  5. Negation
  6. Categorical Syllogisms
  7. Truth-Tellers and Liars
  8. Arguments, Assumptions and Conclusions
  9. Memory Tricks
  10. Don’t Confuse
  11. Common Mistakes
  12. Practice
  13. Quick Revision Table
  14. Key Takeaways
  15. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: The Lethal Knockout

Propositions and Connectives

A proposition is a statement that is either true or false. “The pH is 7.4” is a proposition; “Measure the pH” is not.

Five connectives build compound statements from simple ones \( P \) and \( Q \):

NameWrittenRead asTrue when
Negation\( \lnot P \)not PP is false
Conjunction\( P \land Q \)P and Qboth are true
Disjunction\( P \lor Q \)P or Qat least one is true
Conditional\( P \to Q \)if P then Qevery case except P true, Q false
Biconditional\( P \leftrightarrow Q \)P if and only if QP and Q have the same truth value

The full truth table, which you should be able to write in thirty seconds:

PQ\( P \land Q \)\( P \lor Q \)\( P \to Q \)\( P \leftrightarrow Q \)
TTTTTT
TFFTFF
FTFTTF
FFFFTT

“Or” in logic is inclusive unless the question says “either … or … but not both”. “The sample is contaminated or mislabelled” allows both.

Conditional Statements

From \( P \to Q \) you can form three others:

NameFormExample: “If the gel is stained, the bands are visible”Equivalent to the original?
Statement\( P \to Q \)If stained, then visible—
Converse\( Q \to P \)If visible, then stainedNo
Inverse\( \lnot P \to \lnot Q \)If not stained, then not visibleNo
Contrapositive\( \lnot Q \to \lnot P \)If not visible, then not stainedYes

The statement and its contrapositive always share a truth value. The converse and the inverse are contrapositives of each other, so they agree with each other, but neither follows from the original.

Translating English into “if … then”

Most errors in Part A happen at this step, not in the logic itself.

EnglishLogical formNote
If P, Q / Q if P\( P \to Q \)
P only if Q\( P \to Q \)“only if” introduces the consequent
P is sufficient for Q\( P \to Q \)
Q is necessary for P\( P \to Q \)
P unless Q\( \lnot Q \to P \), i.e. \( P \lor Q \)
No P without Q\( P \to Q \)
P if and only if Q\( P \leftrightarrow Q \)both directions
All P are Q\( P \to Q \) for each individual

Valid and invalid patterns of inference

PatternFormValid?
Modus ponens\( P \to Q \); \( P \); so \( Q \)Yes
Modus tollens\( P \to Q \); \( \lnot Q \); so \( \lnot P \)Yes
Affirming the consequent\( P \to Q \); \( Q \); so \( P \)No
Denying the antecedent\( P \to Q \); \( \lnot P \); so \( \lnot Q \)No
Hypothetical syllogism (chain)\( P \to Q \); \( Q \to R \); so \( P \to R \)Yes
Disjunctive syllogism\( P \lor Q \); \( \lnot P \); so \( Q \)Yes
Constructive dilemma\( P \to R \); \( Q \to R \); \( P \lor Q \); so \( R \)Yes

The two invalid patterns are the two “backwards” moves: going from the consequent to the antecedent, or from a false antecedent to a false consequent.

graph LR
    A["Given: if P then Q"] --> B{"What else do you know?"}
    B -->|"P is true"| C["Q is true (modus ponens)"]
    B -->|"Q is false"| D["P is false (modus tollens)"]
    B -->|"Q is true"| E["Nothing follows"]
    B -->|"P is false"| F["Nothing follows"]

Negation

To negate a statement is to write the statement that is true exactly when the original is false. The exam uses negation in “which statement contradicts…” and “which, if true, would show the claim false” questions.

StatementNegationNot the negation
All A are BSome A are not BNo A is B (too strong)
No A is BSome A are BAll A are B
Some A are BNo A is BSome A are not B
Some A are not BAll A are BNo A is B
P and Qnot P or not Qnot P and not Q
P or Qnot P and not Qnot P or not Q
If P then QP and not QIf not P then not Q

The two “and/or” rows are De Morgan’s laws:

$$\lnot(P \land Q) \equiv \lnot P \lor \lnot Q \qquad \lnot(P \lor Q) \equiv \lnot P \land \lnot Q$$

Categorical Syllogisms

A syllogism gives two premises about three categories and asks what conclusion follows. Each premise is one of four standard forms:

CodeFormVenn picture of A and B
A (universal affirmative)All A are Bcircle A entirely inside B
E (universal negative)No A is BA and B do not overlap
I (particular affirmative)Some A are Bthe overlap is non-empty
O (particular negative)Some A are not Bpart of A lies outside B

Convention used in aptitude papers: “some” means “at least one, possibly all”, and each category named is assumed to have at least one member. So “Some A are B” does not rule out “All A are B”.

Conversions that are always safe

  • “Some A are B” gives “Some B are A”.
  • “No A is B” gives “No B is A”.
  • “All A are B” gives “Some B are A” (because A has members, and they are all in B). It does not give “All B are A”.
  • “Some A are not B” gives nothing by conversion. “Some cells are not neurons” does not give “Some neurons are not cells”.

The two-premise table

Write the premises so the shared (middle) term B is linked to A in the first and to C in the second. Then:

Premise 1Premise 2Definite conclusion
All A are BAll B are CAll A are C (so also Some C are A)
All A are BNo B is CNo A is C
Some A are BAll B are CSome A are C
Some A are BNo B is CSome A are not C
No A is BAll B are CSome C are not A
No A is BSome B are CSome C are not A
All A are BSome B are Cnone
Some A are BSome B are Cnone
No A is BNo B is Cnone

Two quick rules cover the “none” rows: two particular premises give no definite conclusion, and two negative premises give no definite conclusion. A conclusion from one negative premise must itself be negative.

The diagram method

When the table is not at hand or the premises are worded oddly, draw the least committed diagram that satisfies the premises, and then try to break the conclusion.

graph TD
    A["Read both premises"] --> B["Draw circles so every premise is true,
committing to no extra overlap"] B --> C["Test each conclusion"] C --> D{"Is there ANY diagram that keeps
the premises true but makes
the conclusion false?"} D -->|"Yes"| E["Conclusion does NOT follow
(it may be 'possible')"] D -->|"No"| F["Conclusion follows"]

“Either I or II” (the complementary pair)

Sometimes neither conclusion follows on its own, but the two together cover every possibility. This happens when they have the same subject and predicate and are contradictory forms:

  • “Some A are B” with “No A is B” (I with E)
  • “All A are B” with “Some A are not B” (A with O)

Then exactly one of them must be true, and the answer is “either I or II follows”.

Possibility questions

Some aptitude papers ask “which conclusion is possible?” A conclusion is possible if some diagram satisfying the premises makes it true. With “All A are B; No B is C”:

  • “All A are C” is impossible (A is inside B, which avoids C).
  • “Some B are A” is definite.
  • “All B are A” is possible (A could fill B completely).

Truth-Tellers and Liars

In these puzzles each person either always tells the truth or always lies. The method is the same as for arrangement puzzles: assume a case, follow it, and keep only the cases with no contradiction.

Two facts shorten the work:

  1. Nobody can say “I am a liar”. A truth-teller would be lying, and a liar would be telling the truth.
  2. If X says “Y is a liar”, then X and Y are of opposite types. If X says “Y is truthful”, they are of the same type.

Exactly-one-is-lying puzzles

A second family: several suspects make statements, and you are told how many statements are true. Count true statements for each candidate answer.

The shortcut is worth remembering: look for two statements that contradict each other. One of them is false, which pins down the rest.

Arguments, Assumptions and Conclusions

Some Part A items are verbal: a short argument followed by “which is an assumption”, “which follows”, or “which most weakens it”. Scientists have an advantage here, because the reasoning is the reasoning of a methods section.

Item typeWhat you look forTest
Conclusionwhat the passage forcesCould the passage be true and this false? If yes, it does not follow
Assumptionan unstated premise the argument needsNegate it. If the argument collapses, it was assumed
Strengthennew fact closing a gapDoes it rule out an alternative explanation?
Weakennew fact opening a gapDoes it offer another cause, or break the link?
Course of actiona practical, proportionate stepDoes it address the stated problem, and is it feasible?

Flaws that recur

FlawPatternExample
Correlation taken as causeA and B occur together, so A causes BLabs with more freezers publish more, so freezers raise output
Common cause ignoredA and B both follow from CBoth reflect lab funding
Reverse causationA causes B? Perhaps B causes AProductive labs buy more freezers
Unrepresentative samplea few cases stand for allthree colonies on one plate
Affirming the consequentthe hook’s errorlethal, therefore essential
Hasty generalisation“some” read as “all”one batch failed, so the supplier is unreliable

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Contrapositive \( \lnot Q \to \lnot P \): equivalentConverse \( Q \to P \) and inverse \( \lnot P \to \lnot Q \): not equivalent
Necessary condition (must be present)Sufficient condition (enough on its own)
Negation of “All A are B”: Some A are not BContrary: No A is B (both can be false together)
“Some A are B” (at least one, possibly all)everyday “some” (implies not all)
Conclusion follows (true in every diagram)Conclusion possible (true in at least one diagram)
Inclusive “or” (one or both)“Either … or … but not both” (exactly one)

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Write the contrapositive of: “If a solution is acidic, its pH is below 7.”
  2. Write the negation of: “All enzymes are proteins.”
  3. Rewrite “P only if Q” as an if-then statement.
Answers
  1. “If the pH is not below 7, the solution is not acidic.” Swap the two halves and negate both.
  2. “Some enzymes are not proteins.” The negation of “all” is “some … not”. (As it happens, catalytic RNAs make the negation the true statement, but the logic does not depend on that.)
  3. If P then Q. “Only if” introduces the consequent.

Level 2: Part A Style

Practice Q1. Which statement is logically equivalent to “If the gel is stained, the bands are visible”?

(a) If the bands are visible, the gel is stained. (b) If the gel is not stained, the bands are not visible. (c) If the bands are not visible, the gel is not stained. (d) The gel is stained and the bands are not visible.

Answer: (c)

(c) is the contrapositive, which is always equivalent. (a) is the converse and (b) is the inverse; neither follows. (d) is the negation of the original: it describes the one case the original rules out.

Practice Q2. Statements: All pipettes are tools. Some tools are made of glass. Conclusions: I. Some pipettes are made of glass. II. Some glass items are tools.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both follow (d) Neither follows

Answer: (b) Only II follows

The glass region may lie entirely in the part of “tools” outside “pipettes”, so I is only possible. “Some tools are glass” converts to “Some glass items are tools”, so II follows. The pattern “All A are B; Some B are C” gives no definite A–C conclusion.

Practice Q3. A, B and C each either always tell the truth or always lie. A says, “B is a liar.” B says, “C is a liar.” C says, “A and B are both liars.” Who tells the truth?

(a) A only (b) B only (c) A and C (d) B and C

Answer: (b) B only

A–B are opposite types and B–C are opposite types, so A and C are the same type. If A and C were truthful, C’s statement would make A a liar, a contradiction. So A and C lie and B tells the truth. Checks: A’s “B is a liar” is false; B’s “C is a liar” is true; C’s “A and B are both liars” is false because B is truthful. All consistent.

Practice Q4. “Every time the incubator alarm rang last month, the cultures in it were later found contaminated. So the alarm is causing the contamination.” The argument is weakest because:

(a) it does not say how loud the alarm was (b) a door left open could both trigger the alarm and let in contaminants (c) the cultures were of different species (d) the alarm rang on weekdays only

Answer: (b)

(b) names a common cause that explains both events, so the link between them need not be causal. (a), (c) and (d) are details that do not touch the causal claim.

Level 3: Multi-Step (Part C depth)

Practice Q5. Statements: Some reagents are toxic. No toxic item is kept on open shelves. Conclusions: I. Some reagents are not kept on open shelves. II. Some reagents are kept on open shelves. III. No reagent is kept on open shelves.

Which is correct?

(a) Only I follows (b) Only I and II follow (c) Either II or III follows, and I follows (d) Only III follows

Answer: (c)
  • The toxic reagents are not on open shelves, so I follows (Some A are B + No B is C gives Some A are not C).
  • II and III: the non-toxic reagents (if any) may or may not be on open shelves, so neither follows alone. But “Some reagents are kept on open shelves” and “No reagent is kept on open shelves” are an I–E pair with the same subject and predicate, so exactly one is true: either II or III.

So I follows, and either II or III follows. Option (a) misses the complementary pair.

Practice Q6. Given: (i) If it rains, the field trip is cancelled. (ii) If the field trip is cancelled, the lab session runs. (iii) The lab session did not run.

Consider the statements:

  1. It did not rain.
  2. The field trip was not cancelled.
  3. The field trip was cancelled.
  4. If it rains, the lab session runs.

Which must be true?

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 4 only
  • Chain (i) and (ii): rain → cancelled → lab runs, so 4 holds (hypothetical syllogism).
  • From (ii) and (iii) by modus tollens: the trip was not cancelled, so 2. From (i) and that, by modus tollens again: it did not rain, so 1.
  • 3 contradicts 2, so it is false.

A common slip is to reason “the lab session did not run, so nothing is known” (denying the consequent is valid; it is denying the antecedent that fails).

Practice Q7. Exactly one of four students broke a cuvette, and exactly one of their four statements is true. A: “B did it.” B: “D did it.” C: “I did not do it.” D: “B is lying.” Who broke the cuvette?

(a) A (b) B (c) C (d) D

Answer: (c) C

B and D contradict each other, so exactly one of them is true. That is the single true statement, so A and C are both lying.

  • C lying means C did it.
  • Check A: “B did it” is false. Correct for a liar.
  • B: “D did it” is false, so D’s “B is lying” is true. Exactly one true statement (D’s).

Compare the worked example above with the same statements and exactly one false: the answer there is B. Read which count is given.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaRule
\( P \to Q \) falseonly when P is true and Q is false
Equivalent to \( P \to Q \)contrapositive \( \lnot Q \to \lnot P \); also \( \lnot P \lor Q \)
Not equivalentconverse \( Q \to P \), inverse \( \lnot P \to \lnot Q \)
P only if Q\( P \to Q \): Q is necessary for P
P unless Q\( \lnot Q \to P \), i.e. P or Q
Validmodus ponens, modus tollens, chain, disjunctive syllogism
Invalidaffirming the consequent, denying the antecedent
Negation of “All A are B”Some A are not B
Negation of “If P then Q”P and not Q
De Morgannot(P and Q) = not P or not Q; not(P or Q) = not P and not Q
Syllogism: no conclusiontwo particular premises, or two negative premises
Either–orsame terms, I–E or A–O pair
Liars“X says Y lies” → opposite types; nobody says “I am a liar”
Count puzzlesfind two contradicting statements first

Key Takeaways

What’s Next