Organogenesis in Animals: Lens, Limb, Regeneration, Neurons, Metamorphosis and Sex
Eye lens induction, limb axes (AER, ZPA, Wnt7a), regeneration, neural tube and axon guidance, amphibian and insect metamorphosis, and sex determination.
- 24 min
On this page · 15 sections
Prerequisites
- Basic Concepts of Development — induction, competence and morphogens are the working tools of organogenesis.
- Axis Formation in Animals — Hox genes and the organiser set up the body plan that organs are built into.
- Cell Division, Cell Cycle and Cell Death — apoptosis sculpts digits and removes the tadpole tail.
- Transcription and RNA Processing — alternative splicing is the core of Drosophila sex determination.
The Hook: A Wing With Six Digits
How CSIR NET asks it. Part B: match the signalling centre to the axis (AER, ZPA, dorsal ectoderm), predict the result of a graft, name hormones of metamorphosis, identify the sex of XXY or XO individuals in flies and mammals, recall axon guidance cue–receptor pairs. Part C: interpret AER removal at different stages, regeneration after retinoic acid, hormone-removal and hormone-addition experiments in insects, splicing outcomes in Drosophila sex mutants, and phenotypes of human disorders of sex development.
Eye Lens Induction
The vertebrate eye is the classic example of sequential and reciprocal induction.
graph TD
A["Head ectoderm made competent
(earlier signals: anterior neural plate,
endoderm, heart mesoderm)
expresses Pax6"] --> B["Optic vesicle from diencephalon
contacts head ectoderm
BMP4, FGF8"]
B --> C["Lens placode
(thickened ectoderm)"]
C --> D["Lens vesicle
(invaginates, pinches off)"]
D --> E["Lens fibres
crystallins; nuclei lost"]
B --> F["Optic cup
(induced by the lens placode)"]
F --> G["Neural retina (inner layer)
pigmented retina (outer layer)"]
D --> H["Lens induces overlying
ectoderm to form cornea"]- Competence. Only head ectoderm that has already been exposed to earlier signals and expresses the transcription factor Pax6 (with Sox2) can respond to the optic vesicle. Trunk ectoderm cannot form a lens when an optic vesicle is placed under it.
- Reciprocity. The optic vesicle induces the lens placode; the invaginating placode in turn shapes the vesicle into a two-layered optic cup. The lens then induces the overlying ectoderm to become cornea: a cascade.
- Lens fibres elongate, fill with crystallins (the major structural proteins of the lens), and lose their nuclei and organelles, which keeps the lens transparent.
- Species differences. Spemann found that in some amphibian species a lens still forms after removal of the optic rudiment, while in others it does not. The difference reflects how much of the induction has already taken place before the vesicle arrives.
Lens regeneration (Wolffian regeneration). In adult newts, after the lens is removed, the dorsal iris pigmented epithelium dedifferentiates and transdifferentiates into a new lens. It is a standard example of transdifferentiation.
Limb Development
The limb field and limb bud
- Limb buds arise from lateral plate mesoderm (which forms the skeleton and connective tissue) and somite-derived cells (which migrate in to form muscle) at positions set by Hox gene expression along the flank.
- Tbx5 is expressed in the forelimb field and Tbx4 (with Pitx1) in the hindlimb field; they initiate FGF10 in the mesenchyme. FGF10 induces the overlying ectoderm to form the apical ectodermal ridge (AER), which makes FGF8. FGF8 keeps FGF10 on: a positive loop that drives outgrowth.
- Each limb has three axes, each with its own signalling centre.
| Axis | Signalling centre | Signal | Key evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proximal–distal (shoulder to fingertip) | AER (ectoderm at the distal tip) | FGF8 (FGF4, 9, 17) | Removing the AER early gives only proximal elements (humerus); later removal truncates more distally. An FGF bead replaces the AER |
| Anterior–posterior (thumb to little finger) | Zone of polarising activity (ZPA), posterior mesenchyme | Sonic hedgehog (Shh) | ZPA graft or Shh bead anteriorly → mirror-image digit duplication; retinoic acid beads anteriorly induce Shh and mimic a ZPA |
| Dorsal–ventral (back of hand to palm) | Dorsal ectoderm | Wnt7a → induces Lmx1b in dorsal mesenchyme; Engrailed-1 in ventral ectoderm represses Wnt7a | Rotating the ectoderm over the mesenchyme reverses dorsal–ventral pattern; Wnt7a loss gives ventral (double-palm) structures |
Proximal–distal: three segments
| Segment | Bones (forelimb) | Marker |
|---|---|---|
| Stylopod | Humerus | Meis1/2 (maintained proximally by retinoic acid from the flank) |
| Zeugopod | Radius and ulna | Hoxa11, Hoxd11 |
| Autopod | Carpals and digits | Hoxa13, Hoxd13 (maintained distally by FGF) |
Two models compete: the progress zone model (cells under the AER acquire more distal values the longer they stay there) and the two-signal model (an opposing proximal retinoic-acid signal and distal FGF signal specify segments early, then segments expand). Exams accept the facts above under either model; know both names.
Integration of the three axes
Shh from the ZPA keeps the AER active through the BMP antagonist Gremlin: Shh → Gremlin → blocks BMP → AER maintained → FGF8 → maintains Shh. Wnt7a from dorsal ectoderm is also needed for full Shh expression. When the loop breaks, outgrowth stops. This is why removing the AER also reduces the ZPA, and why dorsal ectoderm removal reduces posterior digits.
Sculpting the digits
The tissue between the digits is removed by apoptosis, triggered by BMPs in the interdigital mesenchyme. In ducks, the BMP antagonist Gremlin is expressed in the interdigital webbing of the foot, cells survive and the foot stays webbed. Blocking BMP signalling in the chick leg (for example with a dominant-negative BMP receptor) also gives a webbed foot.
Regeneration
Regeneration is the re-forming of lost structures in adults. Four modes are recognised.
| Mode | Mechanism | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Stem-cell-mediated | Resident stem cells supply all new cells | Planarian neoblasts; mammalian blood, gut, skin |
| Epimorphosis | Adult tissues dedifferentiate to form a blastema, which then redifferentiates | Salamander limb, zebrafish fin |
| Morphallaxis | Existing tissue is repatterned with little new cell proliferation | Hydra |
| Compensatory | Differentiated cells divide but keep their identity; mass is restored, not shape | Mammalian liver (after partial hepatectomy) |
Salamander limb regeneration
- Wound epidermis. Epidermal cells cover the stump within hours, then thicken into the apical ectodermal cap (AEC), functionally like the AER.
- Dedifferentiation. Beneath the cap, bone, cartilage, muscle and connective tissue cells lose their specialised features; multinucleate muscle fibres fragment into mononucleate cells.
- Blastema. These cells accumulate as a cone of proliferating mesenchyme. Lineage tracing shows that cells keep a memory of their tissue of origin: muscle-derived cells make muscle, cartilage-derived make cartilage, and so on. The blastema is not one pluripotent population.
- Nerve dependence. If the limb is denervated before amputation, no blastema forms. Nerves (and Schwann cells) supply mitogenic factors, including the newt anterior gradient protein (nAG), which can rescue regeneration of denervated limbs.
- Positional memory and the rule of distal transformation. A limb cut at the wrist regrows a hand; cut at the shoulder it regrows a whole arm. The blastema makes only the parts distal to the cut. Retinoic acid (or vitamin A) treatment proximalises the blastema: a limb cut at the wrist can regenerate an entire limb from the shoulder onward, in a dose-dependent way.
Other models
- Hydra: the head organiser at the hypostome expresses Wnt3 and β-catenin; a gradient of head activation and inhibition decides where a new head forms after cutting. Graft a piece of hypostome to the body column and a second head forms.
- Planarians: dispersed neoblasts (including pluripotent clonogenic neoblasts) rebuild any missing part from tiny fragments. Wnt/β-catenin decides head vs tail: RNAi of β-catenin makes a head form at a posterior wound (two-headed animals), while too much Wnt signalling makes tails form at anterior wounds.
- Zebrafish: regenerates fins, heart (after removal of part of the ventricle, by proliferation of existing cardiomyocytes) and retina.
- Mammals: liver (compensatory), the tip of the terminal digit in mice and young children, and deer antlers. Most mammalian organs heal by fibrosis (scar) instead.
Neurons: From Neural Plate to Wiring
Neurulation
- Primary neurulation: the neural plate (induced ectoderm) thickens, folds at hinge points (median hinge point over the notochord, paired dorsolateral hinge points), the neural folds rise and fuse in the dorsal midline, and the tube separates from the epidermis. The cells at the border between the neural plate and epidermis become neural crest.
- Secondary neurulation: in the posterior (tail) region, mesenchymal cells condense into a solid cord that hollows out (cavitation).
- Failures of closure: anterior → anencephaly; posterior → spina bifida. Maternal folic acid supplementation reduces the risk.
Patterning the neural tube
| Axis | Signal | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Ventral | Shh from notochord, then floor plate | Graded Shh specifies ventral progenitor domains (V0–V3 interneurons, motor neurons) through classes of homeodomain factors (e.g. Nkx2.2, Olig2, Pax6) |
| Dorsal | BMPs (and Wnts) from epidermis, then roof plate | Dorsal interneurons, sensory relay neurons, neural crest |
| Anterior–posterior | Forebrain, midbrain, hindbrain vesicles; hindbrain rhombomeres with nested Hox expression; isthmic organiser (FGF8) at the midbrain–hindbrain boundary | Regional identity |
Making neurons
- Proneural genes (bHLH factors: achaete–scute in flies; neurogenin, Ascl1 in vertebrates) make a cell competent to become a neuron. Within a proneural cluster, Notch–Delta lateral inhibition selects one cell: the cell with most Delta becomes a neuroblast and stops its neighbours from doing so. Loss of Notch gives too many neurons (the neurogenic phenotype).
- In the vertebrate cortex, radial glia are the neural stem cells. Their nuclei move up and down with the cell cycle (interkinetic nuclear migration). Neurons migrate along radial glial fibres and the cortex forms inside-out: early-born neurons in deep layers, later-born neurons pass them to settle superficially. Reelin, secreted by Cajal–Retzius cells, is required; in the reeler mouse the layers are roughly inverted.
- Neural crest cells undergo EMT, migrate along defined routes and form peripheral neurons and glia, melanocytes, adrenal medulla and craniofacial skeleton.
Axon guidance
The growth cone at the tip of an axon senses guidance cues and steers by remodelling actin.
| Cue | Receptor | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Netrin (floor plate) | DCC (attraction); UNC5 (with DCC, repulsion) | Draws commissural axons to the ventral midline |
| Slit (midline) | Robo | Repulsion; once an axon has crossed, Robo rises and stops recrossing. In flies, Commissureless keeps Robo low before crossing |
| Semaphorins | Plexins, neuropilins | Mostly repulsive; growth cone collapse |
| Ephrins | Eph receptor tyrosine kinases | Repulsion by contact; topographic maps |
Retinotectal map. Sperry’s chemoaffinity hypothesis proposed that axons find targets through matching molecular labels. In the frog or chick, temporal retinal axons (high EphA) are repelled by the high ephrin-A in the posterior tectum and therefore stop in the anterior tectum; nasal axons (low EphA) project to the posterior tectum.
Neurotrophic factors and neuron number. Many more neurons are produced than survive. Neurons compete for limited target-derived neurotrophins; those that fail die by apoptosis. Nerve growth factor (NGF), discovered by Rita Levi-Montalcini and Stanley Cohen, supports sympathetic and some sensory neurons; removing a limb bud reduces the number of motor and sensory neurons that innervate it, and grafting an extra limb increases it.
Metamorphosis
Amphibians: thyroid hormone
- Thyroid hormones drive metamorphosis. The gland secretes mainly T₄ (thyroxine); in target tissues, type II deiodinase converts it to the more active T₃, and type III deiodinase inactivates it. Each tissue’s timing depends on its deiodinases and receptor levels.
- T₃ binds thyroid hormone receptors (TRs), which act as heterodimers with RXR on DNA. Without hormone, TR represses target genes; with hormone, it activates them.
- Hypothalamic corticotropin-releasing hormone stimulates the pituitary to release TSH, which drives the thyroid; corticosterone enhances the response.
| Change at metamorphosis | Detail |
|---|---|
| Regression | Tail and gills resorbed by apoptosis and matrix metalloproteinases |
| Remodelling | Gut shortens (herbivore to carnivore); liver switches from excreting ammonia to urea (urea-cycle enzymes induced); larval haemoglobin replaced by adult haemoglobin with different oxygen affinity; visual pigment changes from porphyropsin to rhodopsin in some species |
| New growth | Limbs, tongue, eyelids, middle ear; the eyes move forward, giving binocular vision |
Heterochrony and neoteny. The axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum) normally becomes sexually mature while keeping larval features such as gills (paedomorphosis by neoteny) because it makes too little thyroid hormone; giving it T₄ or T₃ induces metamorphosis. In some other permanently larval salamanders, such as Necturus, the tissues do not respond to the hormone, and treatment fails.
Insects: ecdysone and juvenile hormone
| Development | Stages | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Ametabolous | Egg → juvenile → adult (no metamorphosis) | Silverfish |
| Hemimetabolous | Egg → nymph (several instars, wing pads grow) → adult | Grasshopper, cockroach, bugs |
| Holometabolous | Egg → larva → pupa → adult | Flies, beetles, butterflies, bees |
Hormones.
- Prothoracicotropic hormone (PTTH) from the brain stimulates the prothoracic gland to secrete ecdysone, which is converted (in fat body and other tissues) to the active 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E). 20E triggers each moult.
- Juvenile hormone (JH) from the corpora allata decides what kind of moult happens.
| JH level at the moult | Moult |
|---|---|
| High | Larval → larval |
| Low | Larval → pupal |
| Absent | Pupal → adult |
- 20E receptor: EcR (ecdysone receptor) with Ultraspiracle (USP), the insect RXR. 20E induces a small set of early genes (Broad-Complex, E74, E75) seen as early puffs on polytene chromosomes, whose products turn on many late genes (late puffs) and switch the early genes off.
- Imaginal discs (sac-like epithelia set aside in the larva) evert and differentiate into adult legs, wings, eyes and antennae; most larval tissues die by programmed cell death.
- Eclosion hormone and ecdysis-triggering hormone drive shedding of the old cuticle; bursicon hardens and darkens (tans) the new cuticle.
Sex Determination
Mammals: chromosomal and hormonal
graph TD
A["Bipotential gonad
(genital ridge)"] -->|"Y chromosome: SRY"| B["SOX9 up
(FGF9 and PGD2 loops)"]
A -->|"No SRY: WNT4, RSPO1,
beta-catenin, FOXL2"| C["Ovary"]
B --> D["Testis: Sertoli cells"]
D --> E["AMH: Mullerian ducts regress"]
D --> F["Leydig cells: testosterone
Wolffian ducts kept"]
F --> G["DHT (5-alpha-reductase)
male external genitalia"]
C --> H["No AMH, no testosterone
Mullerian ducts form oviduct,
uterus; Wolffian ducts regress"]- Primary sex determination (gonad): the Y-linked gene SRY is the testis-determining factor. SRY up-regulates SOX9, which is maintained by positive loops (FGF9, prostaglandin D2) and drives Sertoli cell differentiation. Without SRY, the WNT4–RSPO1–β-catenin pathway and FOXL2 promote ovary development and repress SOX9. FOXL2 is needed even in the adult ovary: deleting it in adult mouse granulosa cells turns them toward Sertoli-like cells.
- Secondary sex determination (body): by gonadal hormones. Anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) from Sertoli cells destroys the Müllerian ducts; testosterone from Leydig cells maintains the Wolffian ducts (epididymis, vas deferens, seminal vesicles); dihydrotestosterone (DHT), made by 5α-reductase, masculinises the external genitalia and prostate. In females, the Müllerian ducts become oviducts, uterus and upper vagina.
| Condition | Karyotype | Phenotype | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Turner syndrome | 45,X | Female, gonadal dysgenesis | No Y; two X needed for ovary maintenance |
| Klinefelter syndrome | 47,XXY | Male, small testes, infertile | Y (SRY) makes testis regardless of X number |
| XX male | 46,XX with SRY translocated to an X | Male | SRY moved by abnormal X–Y exchange in paternal meiosis |
| Swyer syndrome (one cause) | 46,XY with mutant SRY | Female external phenotype, streak gonads | No testis |
| Androgen insensitivity | 46,XY, mutant androgen receptor | Female external genitalia; testes present (internal); no uterus (AMH acted) | Testosterone cannot act |
| 5α-reductase deficiency | 46,XY | Ambiguous or female-like genitalia at birth, virilisation at puberty | No DHT |
Drosophila: X counting and alternative splicing
- Sex depends on the number of X chromosomes (classically expressed as the X:A ratio). XX (and XXY) flies are female; XY and XO flies are male (XO males are sterile because the Y carries fertility genes, not sex determinants).
- X-linked signal elements (such as sisterless-a and sisterless-b) reach a high enough dose only in XX embryos to activate the establishment promoter of Sex-lethal (Sxl). Early Sxl protein then splices later Sxl transcripts (from the maintenance promoter) into the functional form, so Sxl maintains itself by autoregulatory splicing.
graph LR
A["Two X: Sxl ON
(female splicing)"] --> B["Sxl splices tra pre-mRNA
to functional form"]
B --> C["Tra + Tra2 splice dsx
to female form DsxF"]
C --> D["Female differentiation"]
A --> E["Sxl blocks msl-2
translation: no dosage
compensation complex"]
F["One X: Sxl OFF"] --> G["Default splicing: tra non-functional
dsx male form DsxM"]
G --> H["Male differentiation"]
F --> I["MSL complex forms,
X transcribed about twofold"]- doublesex (dsx) is the switch at the bottom: DsxF and DsxM share a DNA-binding domain but differ at the C-terminus and have opposite effects on sex-specific genes (yolk protein genes on in females).
- Dosage compensation in flies works the opposite way from mammals: the single male X is hypertranscribed about twofold by the MSL complex (with roX RNAs), while in females Sxl prevents MSL-2 synthesis.
- Drosophila somatic sex is largely cell-autonomous: gynandromorphs (XX/XO mosaics) show male and female patches side by side.
Other systems
| Organism | System | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Birds | ZZ male, ZW female | Female is the heterogametic sex. The leading model is dosage of the Z-linked DMRT1 gene |
| C. elegans | XX hermaphrodite, XO male | Read through X:A signal; a cascade of negative regulators ending in the transcription factor TRA-1 |
| Many turtles, all crocodilians, some lizards | Temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) | Incubation temperature during a sensitive window sets sex; in many turtles warmer gives females. Temperature acts partly through aromatase (testosterone → oestradiol) |
| Honeybees and other Hymenoptera | Haplodiploidy | Unfertilised (haploid) eggs → males; fertilised (diploid) → females; in honeybees females are heterozygous at the complementary sex determiner (csd) locus, and diploid homozygotes develop as (sterile) males |
| Bonellia viridis (echiuran worm) | Environmental (location) | A larva that settles on the female’s proboscis becomes a tiny male; one that settles on the sea floor becomes female |
| Some fish | Sequential hermaphroditism | Clownfish change from male to female (protandry); many wrasses from female to male (protogyny), triggered by social cues |
Memory Tricks
- Lens cascade: optic vesicle → lens → cornea; competence needs Pax6.
- Regeneration modes: Epimorphosis (blastema), Morphallaxis (repatterning, Hydra), Compensatory (liver), Stem cell (planaria).
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| AER (ectoderm; FGF8; outgrowth) | vs | ZPA (posterior mesenchyme; Shh; digit identity) |
| AER (developing limb bud) | vs | AEC (apical ectodermal cap of a regenerating limb) |
| Epimorphosis (dedifferentiation, blastema) | vs | Morphallaxis (repatterning existing tissue) |
| Dedifferentiation (cell reverts within lineage) | vs | Transdifferentiation (iris → lens; changes lineage) |
| Netrin–DCC (attraction to midline) | vs | Slit–Robo (repulsion from midline) |
| T₄ (mostly secreted, prohormone) | vs | T₃ (active form made in tissues by deiodinase II) |
| Ecdysone (triggers moults; prothoracic gland) | vs | Juvenile hormone (decides moult type; corpora allata) |
| Hemimetabolous (nymph, no pupa) | vs | Holometabolous (larva, pupa, adult) |
| Primary sex determination (gonad; SRY) | vs | Secondary (body; AMH, testosterone, DHT) |
| Mammal XXY = male | vs | Fly XXY = female (X dose decides) |
| Mammalian dosage compensation (inactivate one X in females) | vs | Fly dosage compensation (male X hypertranscribed) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which signalling molecule does the ZPA secrete?
- Which gland in insects makes juvenile hormone?
- Which gene product is the testis-determining factor in mammals?
Answers
- Sonic hedgehog (Shh).
- The corpora allata.
- SRY, on the Y chromosome.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A chick wing bud is treated by removing the dorsal ectoderm and replacing it with ventral ectoderm, keeping the mesenchyme intact. The most likely outcome is:
- (a) normal dorsal–ventral pattern
- (b) a limb with ventral (palm-like) features on both surfaces
- (c) loss of the AER only
- (d) mirror-image anterior–posterior duplication
Answer and explanation
(b). Dorsal identity of the mesenchyme depends on Wnt7a from dorsal ectoderm inducing Lmx1b. Ventral ectoderm expresses Engrailed-1 and no Wnt7a, so the mesenchyme becomes ventral on both sides. Since Wnt7a also supports Shh, posterior digits may be reduced, but the defining change is the double-ventral pattern.
Q2 (practice). In a fly with two X chromosomes, a loss-of-function mutation in transformer (tra) would produce:
- (a) a normal female
- (b) a pseudomale (male somatic phenotype)
- (c) lethality due to failed dosage compensation
- (d) a gynandromorph
Answer and explanation
(b). In XX flies Sxl is on and dosage compensation is correctly repressed, but without functional Tra, dsx is spliced to the male form by default, so somatic tissues develop as male. Sxl is upstream of tra, so the dosage compensation decision (via MSL-2) is unaffected.
Q3 (practice). A newt limb is amputated through the mid-forearm, and the animal is kept in water containing retinoic acid at a moderate dose during blastema formation. The regenerate is most likely to contain:
- (a) only a hand
- (b) radius, ulna (distal part) and hand, as normal
- (c) an extra set of proximal elements, such as a humerus, followed by radius, ulna and hand
- (d) no regenerate
Answer and explanation
(c). Retinoic acid proximalises blastema cells in a dose-dependent way, so they behave as if the cut had been made more proximally. The regenerate therefore repeats proximal elements before making the distal ones, a serial duplication.
Q4 (practice). Which pairing of axon guidance cue and response is correct?
- (a) Slit–Robo: attraction of axons to the midline
- (b) Netrin–DCC: attraction toward the floor plate
- (c) Ephrin-A–EphA: attraction of temporal retinal axons to posterior tectum
- (d) Semaphorin–Plexin: promotion of growth cone spreading
Answer and explanation
(b). Netrin from the floor plate attracts commissural axons through DCC. Slit–Robo is repulsive; ephrin-A repels temporal (high EphA) axons from the posterior tectum; semaphorins are mainly repulsive and cause growth cone collapse.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Chick wing buds were operated on at different stages and the skeleton scored at day 10:
| Operation | Skeletal elements formed |
|---|---|
| AER removed at stage 18 | Humerus only (partial) |
| AER removed at stage 24 | Humerus, radius, ulna |
| AER removed at stage 28 | Humerus, radius, ulna, carpals, part of digits |
| AER removed at stage 20, FGF8 bead placed at the tip | Nearly normal limb |
| ZPA tissue grafted to the anterior margin at stage 20 | Digits 4-3-2-2-3-4 |
Which conclusions are justified?
(A) The AER is required for proximal–distal outgrowth, and the level of truncation depends on the stage of removal. (B) FGF can substitute for the AER. (C) Elements are laid down in a proximal-to-distal sequence. (D) The ZPA specifies the dorsal–ventral axis.
- (a) A, B and C
- (b) A and D only
- (c) B, C and D
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B and C.
- (A) Removal truncates the limb, more distally the later it is done.
- (B) The FGF8 bead rescues outgrowth after AER removal.
- (C) Early removal leaves only proximal elements; later removal leaves progressively more distal ones, so the proximal parts are specified or laid down first.
- (D) The ZPA graft changes digit identity (anterior–posterior), not dorsal–ventral pattern.
Q2 (practice). Larvae of a holometabolous insect are subjected to the following:
(i) Corpora allata removed in the second (of five) larval instars. (ii) JH analogue applied at the start of the fifth (final) larval instar. (iii) A ligature is tied behind the head of a last-instar larva just after the critical period for PTTH release, separating the brain from the prothoracic glands (which lie in the thorax); the posterior part is examined. (iv) The same ligature is tied before the critical period; the posterior part is examined.
Predict the outcome for each.
Answer and worked solution
- (i) Without JH, the next ecdysone-triggered moult is pupal: a precocious, small pupa and then a miniature adult.
- (ii) High JH at the final moult makes it a larval–larval moult: a supernumerary (sixth) instar, giant larva.
- (iii) After the critical period, PTTH has already been released and has stimulated the prothoracic glands, which lie behind the ligature; they secrete ecdysone, so the posterior part pupates.
- (iv) Before the critical period, the brain is cut off from the glands, no PTTH reaches them, no ecdysone is made, so the posterior part does not moult (it stays larval).
The logic: ecdysone decides whether a moult happens; JH decides which kind.
Q3 (practice). A human with a 46,XY karyotype has female external genitalia, inguinal testes, no uterus or oviducts, and elevated testosterone. Another individual, also 46,XY, has female external genitalia, streak gonads, and a normal uterus and oviducts. Which statement correctly explains both?
- (a) Both have androgen receptor mutations.
- (b) The first has androgen insensitivity (AMH acted, androgen could not); the second lacks testis formation, for example through an SRY mutation, so neither AMH nor testosterone was made.
- (c) The first lacks SRY; the second lacks AMH receptors.
- (d) Both have 5α-reductase deficiency.
Answer and worked solution
(b).
- Individual 1: testes formed (so SRY worked) and made AMH, which removed the Müllerian ducts (no uterus). Testosterone is high but cannot act: androgen insensitivity. Wolffian ducts are not maintained and the external genitalia are female.
- Individual 2: no testis (streak gonads), so no AMH (Müllerian ducts persist: uterus and oviducts present) and no testosterone (female external genitalia). This is gonadal dysgenesis with an XY karyotype, as in Swyer syndrome from an SRY mutation. The comparison isolates the separate roles of AMH (internal ducts) and androgens (Wolffian ducts and external genitalia).
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Lens induction | Optic vesicle (BMP4, FGF8) → Pax6-competent head ectoderm → placode → vesicle → fibres (crystallins) → cornea |
| Pax6 | Small eye (mouse), aniridia (human), eyeless (fly; ectopic eyes) |
| Lens regeneration | Newt dorsal iris; transdifferentiation |
| Limb initiation | Tbx5 (fore), Tbx4 + Pitx1 (hind) → FGF10 → AER (FGF8) |
| P-D axis | AER/FGF8; stylopod (Meis), zeugopod (Hox11), autopod (Hoxa13) |
| A-P axis | ZPA/Shh; mirror digits 4-3-2-2-3-4; RA beads induce Shh |
| D-V axis | Wnt7a (dorsal ectoderm) → Lmx1b; En1 (ventral ectoderm) |
| Digit separation | BMP-induced apoptosis; duck web keeps Gremlin |
| Regeneration | Epimorphosis (salamander), morphallaxis (Hydra), compensatory (liver), stem cells (planaria) |
| Salamander | AEC, dedifferentiation, blastema with lineage memory, nerve-dependent (nAG), RA proximalises |
| Neural tube | Shh ventral (motor neurons), BMP dorsal; Notch lateral inhibition; reelin inside-out cortex |
| Guidance | Netrin–DCC attract, UNC5 repel; Slit–Robo repel; semaphorins; ephrins (retinotectal map) |
| Amphibian metamorphosis | T₄ → T₃ (deiodinase II); TR–RXR; tail apoptosis; ammonia → urea |
| Insect hormones | PTTH → ecdysone (20E, EcR/USP); JH (corpora allata) decides moult type |
| Mammal sex | SRY → SOX9 → Sertoli (AMH) and Leydig (testosterone, DHT); WNT4/RSPO1/FOXL2 ovary |
| Fly sex | X dose → Sxl (autoregulatory splicing) → Tra → DsxF/DsxM; MSL complex in males |
| Other | Birds ZW female; TSD in reptiles (aromatase); bees haplodiploid (csd); Bonellia location |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Plant Reproduction, Double Fertilisation and Seed Development — the plant side of gametogenesis and embryogenesis.
- Plant Morphogenesis, Cell Death and Ageing — meristems, flowers, programmed cell death and senescence.
- Cell Division, Cell Cycle and Cell Death — the apoptotic machinery behind digit sculpting and tail resorption.
- Developmental Biology chapter overview