Skip to content

Behavioural Ecology

Proximate and ultimate causes, learning, optimal foraging, communication, aggression and ESS, migration, kin selection, sexual selection, parental care.

  • 25 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 17 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Gull Chick and a Red Spot
  3. Proximate and Ultimate Causes
  4. Foraging Behaviour
  5. Communication
  6. Aggression and Conflict
  7. Migration and Navigation
  8. Social Behaviour
  9. Sexual Selection and Mating Systems
  10. Parental Care
  11. Memory Tricks
  12. Don’t Confuse
  13. Common Mistakes
  14. Practice
  15. Quick Revision Table
  16. Key Takeaways
  17. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: A Gull Chick and a Red Spot

How CSIR NET asks it. Part B: classify a statement as proximate or ultimate; fixed action pattern, imprinting and conditioning; waggle-dance meaning; Hamilton’s rule; haplodiploid relatedness; Batesian versus Müllerian mimicry; mating-system definitions. Part C: optimal-diet and marginal-value calculations, hawk–dove ESS frequencies, relatedness with multiple mating, interpreting playback, choice or removal experiments.


Proximate and Ultimate Causes

Ethology, the biological study of behaviour, was founded largely by Konrad Lorenz, Niko Tinbergen and Karl von Frisch, who shared the 1973 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. Behavioural ecology asks how behaviour contributes to survival and reproduction, using cost–benefit and evolutionary reasoning.

Tinbergen’s four questions (1963)

QuestionAsksLevel
Causation (mechanism)What stimuli, neurons, hormones and genes produce the behaviour?Proximate
Development (ontogeny)How does the behaviour change over the individual’s life; what role do learning and experience play?Proximate
Function (adaptive value)How does the behaviour increase survival and reproduction?Ultimate
Evolution (phylogeny)How did the behaviour arise and change over evolutionary history?Ultimate

Example: why do male songbirds sing in spring?

  • Proximate: lengthening days raise testosterone, which acts on song-control nuclei in the brain; young males learn the song from adult tutors during a sensitive period.
  • Ultimate: song defends a territory and attracts females, raising reproductive success; song evolved from ancestral calls.

A complete answer covers both levels. Part B often gives a statement and asks which level it addresses: anything about hormones, neurons, triggering stimuli or learning during development is proximate; anything about fitness, survival, mates or ancestry is ultimate.

Innate behaviour and learning

TermMeaningExample
Fixed action pattern (FAP)A stereotyped sequence that, once triggered, runs to completion even if the stimulus is removedGreylag goose egg-rolling: the goose completes the head movement even if the egg is taken away
Sign stimulus / releaserThe simple feature that triggers an FAP; a releaser when it comes from a member of the same speciesRed belly of male three-spined stickleback triggers attack by rival males; red spot on gull bill
Supernormal stimulusAn exaggerated stimulus that elicits a stronger response than the natural oneOystercatchers trying to incubate oversized model eggs
KinesisChange in speed or turning rate with stimulus intensity, without orientationWoodlice moving faster in dry air
TaxisOriented movement towards or away from a stimulusPhototaxis, chemotaxis
HabituationWaning response to a repeated harmless stimulusBirds ignoring a scarecrow
ImprintingLearning during a critical (sensitive) period, usually early in life, that is rapid and hard to reverseLorenz’s goslings following him; filial and sexual imprinting
Classical conditioningAssociation of a neutral stimulus with an unconditioned stimulusPavlov’s dogs salivating to a bell
Operant (instrumental) conditioningBehaviour shaped by its consequences: reward or punishmentSkinner box; trial-and-error learning
Latent learningLearning without immediate reward, shown laterRats exploring a maze learn its layout
Insight learningSolving a new problem without trial and errorKöhler’s chimpanzees stacking boxes to reach bananas
Social learningLearning by observing othersSong learning; cultural transmission of tool use

The old instinct-versus-learning split is now seen as a continuum: genes and experience interact in nearly every behaviour (bird song is the classic case).


Foraging Behaviour

Optimal foraging theory assumes natural selection favours foraging that maximises the net rate of energy gain (or another currency), subject to constraints.

The prey (diet) model

Each prey type i has energy Eᵢ, handling time hᵢ (pursuit, capture, eating) and encounter rate λᵢ. Profitability = Eᵢ/hᵢ. Rank prey by profitability. The long-term rate of intake when eating types 1…k (Holling’s disc equation generalised):

$$R_k = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{k}\lambda_i E_i}{1 + \sum_{i=1}^{k}\lambda_i h_i}$$

Rule: add the next-ranked prey type only if its profitability exceeds the rate obtained without it:

$$\frac{E_{k+1}}{h_{k+1}} > R_k$$

Predictions:

  • Zero–one rule: each prey type is either always taken or always ignored.
  • Whether a less profitable prey is included depends on the abundance of better prey, not on its own abundance (its λ does not appear in the condition).
  • As good prey become common, diets become more specialised; when they are scarce, diets broaden.

Tests: great tits choosing between large and small mealworm pieces on a conveyor belt (Krebs and colleagues) became more selective as large pieces became common, broadly as predicted, though not with a perfect zero–one switch. Shore crabs preferring intermediate-sized mussels, which give the highest energy per unit handling time, are another standard example.

The patch model: marginal value theorem

Food often occurs in patches that are depleted as the forager feeds, so the rate of gain inside a patch falls with time. Charnov’s marginal value theorem (1976): a forager should leave a patch when the instantaneous (marginal) rate of gain in the patch falls to the average rate of gain for the whole habitat, including travel time between patches.

With a cumulative gain curve g(t) and average travel time T, the optimal residence time t* satisfies:

$$g'(t^{*}) = \frac{g(t^{*})}{T + t^{*}}$$

Graphically, draw a tangent to the gain curve from a point T units to the left of the origin; the tangent point gives t*. Predictions:

  • Longer travel time → stay longer in each patch.
  • Richer habitat overall → leave patches sooner.
  • Starlings carrying more leatherjackets per trip when the nest is farther from the feeding site, and bees leaving flowers after partial depletion, fit these predictions qualitatively.

Beyond energy maximisation

  • Risk-sensitive foraging: when the expected intake on a safe option would not meet requirements (a small bird on a cold evening), animals may prefer a variable option; when it would, they are risk-averse.
  • Predation risk: animals trade feeding rate against safety, feeding less in exposed sites.
  • Central-place foraging: animals bringing food back to a nest or burrow.
  • Producer–scrounger games and information sharing in groups.

Communication

Communication is the transfer of information from a sender to a receiver through a signal, a trait or behaviour that evolved because it changes the receiver’s behaviour in a way that benefits the sender (and often the receiver). A cue carries information but did not evolve for that purpose (the sound of a moving prey).

ChannelAdvantagesLimitationsExamples
VisualFast, directional, information-richNeeds light and line of sightPeacock’s train, fiddler crab claw waving, firefly flashes
AcousticWorks in the dark and through vegetation; long range; easily located (or made hard to locate)Can attract predators and parasitesBird song, frog chorus, cricket calls, whale song
Chemical (pheromones)Long-lasting, long range, work in the darkSlow to change, hard to switch offBombykol, the silkworm moth sex attractant; ant trail and alarm pheromones; queen pheromones
TactileClose range, preciseRequires contactGrooming in primates; antennation in ants
ElectricalWorks in murky waterShort rangeWeakly electric fish
Vibrational (seismic)Through substratesShort rangeSpiders on webs; treehoppers

Pheromones are classed as releaser pheromones (immediate behavioural response: sex attractants, alarm) and primer pheromones (slower physiological change: queen substance suppressing worker ovary development).

The honeybee dance

Karl von Frisch decoded the dances of returning forager honeybees (Apis mellifera) on the vertical comb in the dark hive:

DanceWhenInformation
Round danceFood close to the hive“Food nearby”; no precise direction; recruits use odour and search
Waggle danceFood farther awayDirection and distance

In the waggle dance, the bee runs straight while waggling her abdomen, then loops back alternately left and right:

  • Angle of the waggle run from vertical (upwards on the comb) = angle of the food source from the sun’s azimuth. Waggling straight up means “fly towards the sun”; straight down, “away from the sun”; 60° to the right of vertical, “60° to the right of the sun”.
  • Duration of the waggle run increases with distance to the food.
  • Odour and taste of nectar carried by the dancer add information.
  • Bees compensate for the sun’s movement over time.

Honesty of signals

Why should receivers believe signals when senders gain by exaggerating? Signals tend to be honest when they are costly in a way cheaters cannot afford (Zahavi’s handicap principle, 1975, later modelled formally by Grafen), when they are physically tied to quality (index signals: the depth of a male common toad’s croak, which is limited by body size), or when sender and receiver share interests (relatives). Deceptive signals do occur: Photuris fireflies mimic the flash pattern of Photinus females to lure and eat males; Batesian mimics and orchids that resemble female wasps exploit receivers.


Aggression and Conflict

Aggression covers threat displays, fighting and submission. Most contests between members of the same species are ritualised: displays, assessment and graded escalation, with few serious injuries. The red deer roaring contest, followed by parallel walk and only then by fighting, lets weaker stags withdraw early.

Game theory: the hawk–dove game

Maynard Smith and Price (1973) introduced the evolutionarily stable strategy (ESS): a strategy that, once adopted by most of a population, cannot be invaded by any rare alternative.

Two strategies compete for a resource of value V; fighting injury costs C:

  • Hawk: escalates until injured or the opponent retreats.
  • Dove: displays; retreats if the opponent escalates; shares if the opponent also displays.
Payoff to focal strategy (row)Against a hawkAgainst a dove
Hawk(V − C)/2V
Dove0V/2
  • Dove is never an ESS: a rare hawk among doves gets V, more than V/2.
  • If V > C, Hawk is a pure ESS.
  • If V < C, the ESS is a mixed strategy (or a population mix) with hawk frequency
$$p^{*} = \frac{V}{C}$$

At p*, hawks and doves have equal payoffs. Adding a conditional strategy such as Bourgeois (“play hawk if owner, dove if intruder”) can give an ESS that settles contests by an arbitrary asymmetry such as ownership: territory holders usually win, as in Davies’ speckled wood butterflies.

Dominance and territoriality

  • Dominance hierarchies reduce repeated fighting; rank affects access to food and mates. A linear hierarchy (pecking order) was first described in domestic hens.
  • A territory is a defended area. It pays when the benefits (exclusive food, mates, nest sites) exceed the defence costs: economic defendability (J. L. Brown, 1964). Territories are expected at intermediate resource density; too sparse and the area is too large to defend, too dense and intruder pressure is too high. Sunbirds and nectar-feeding birds defending flowers are standard examples.

Migration and Navigation

Migration is a regular, often seasonal, round-trip movement between breeding and non-breeding areas. It is triggered proximately by photoperiod and hormones, with pre-migratory hyperphagia and fat deposition; caged migratory birds show restless, oriented activity in the migration season (Zugunruhe).

Ultimate benefits: exploiting seasonal food peaks, escaping harsh seasons, safer breeding sites. Costs: energy, predation on the route, navigation errors.

Navigation mechanismEvidence
Sun compass (time-compensated)Kramer’s caged starlings oriented by the sun, and shifting the apparent sun with mirrors shifted their orientation; clock-shift experiments (phase-shifting the light–dark cycle) shifted orientation predictably, showing the compass is corrected by the internal clock
Star compassEmlen’s indigo buntings in a planetarium learned the centre of celestial rotation (near the Pole Star) as young birds
Magnetic compassBirds orient in the Earth’s field in cages and respond to its inclination; sea turtles also use magnetic cues
OlfactionSalmon return to their natal stream by its odour (imprinted as juveniles)
Landmarks and polarised lightPigeons near home; insects use polarised skylight

Terms: orientation (holding a compass direction) versus navigation (knowing position relative to the goal, needing a “map” plus a compass). Experienced migrants displaced off course often correct; first-year birds often keep flying the inherited direction, ending up displaced. Examples of long-distance migrants: Arctic tern (pole to pole), monarch butterfly (multigenerational journey across North America), salmon, eels, and the many waterbirds that winter in Indian wetlands.


Social Behaviour

Costs and benefits of group living

BenefitsCosts
Dilution effect and selfish herd (Hamilton, 1971): individuals reduce risk by putting others between themselves and the predatorCompetition for food and mates
Many eyes: earlier detection, so each animal can spend less time vigilantEasier disease and parasite transmission
Group defence (mobbing) and confusion of predatorsGreater conspicuousness to predators
Cooperative hunting, information about foodCuckoldry and exploitation by group members

Altruism and kin selection

An altruistic act raises the recipient’s fitness at a cost to the actor. Hamilton’s rule (1964): an allele for altruism spreads when

$$rB > C$$

where r is the coefficient of relatedness between actor and recipient, B the benefit to the recipient and C the cost to the actor (both in offspring equivalents). Inclusive fitness = direct fitness (own offspring) + indirect fitness (extra offspring of relatives due to the actor’s help, weighted by r).

Relatedness in diploid, outbred, singly mated families:

Relationshipr
Parent–offspring0.5
Full siblings0.5
Half siblings0.25
Grandparent–grandchild, uncle–nephew0.25
First cousins0.125

Haplodiploidy and eusociality

In Hymenoptera (ants, bees, wasps), females are diploid (from fertilised eggs) and males haploid (unfertilised eggs). If the queen mates once:

Relationship (from a female worker’s view)r
Full sister0.75
Brother0.25
Own daughter or son0.5
Mother (queen)0.5

Full sisters share all their father’s genes (he is haploid) and half their mother’s: r = ½ × 1 + ½ × ½ = 0.75. A worker is thus more related to her sisters than to her own offspring: the haplodiploidy hypothesis for the origin of worker sterility. With the queen mating k times (equal paternity), average relatedness among sisters is

$$\bar r = \frac{1}{4} + \frac{1}{2k}$$

which falls to 0.5 at k = 2 and towards 0.25 as k increases. Because many eusocial insects have multiply mated queens, and because eusociality also occurs in diploid termites and naked mole-rats, haplodiploidy is now considered a contributing factor at most; monogamy of ancestral queens and ecological factors (defensible nests, high cost of independent breeding) are emphasised.

Eusociality is defined by three traits: cooperative brood care, overlapping generations in the colony, and reproductive division of labour (sterile or non-breeding castes). Examples: social Hymenoptera, termites, naked mole-rats (a eusocial mammal), some snapping shrimps.

Reciprocal altruism and helpers

  • Reciprocal altruism (Trivers, 1971): help to unrelated individuals can evolve if it is likely to be returned and cheaters can be recognised and punished, as in repeated interactions. Vampire bats sharing blood meals with roost-mates (including non-kin who previously shared) are the standard example. The iterated prisoner’s dilemma and tit-for-tat formalise it.
  • Helpers at the nest: in many cooperatively breeding birds, young adults help their parents raise siblings, gaining indirect fitness and sometimes inheriting the territory or gaining breeding experience.
  • Mutualism and by-product benefits: cooperation that benefits the actor directly needs no kinship.

Sexual Selection and Mating Systems

Why the sexes differ

Anisogamy: females produce fewer, larger gametes; males many small ones. Bateman’s principle: male reproductive success usually varies more than female success and rises more steeply with number of mates, so males usually compete for mates and females choose. Parental investment theory (Trivers, 1972): the sex that invests more in offspring becomes a limiting resource for the other. When males invest more (pipefish and seahorses, where males brood; jacanas and phalaropes, where males incubate), the roles reverse: females compete and are often larger or more colourful.

Sexual selection (Darwin)

TypeMechanismExample
Intrasexual selectionCompetition within one sex (usually males) for access to matesAntlers, horns, large body size; elephant seal fights; sperm competition
Intersexual selectionChoice by one sex (usually females) of mates in the otherPeacock train; widowbird tails; bowerbird bowers

Why females prefer elaborate traits:

  • Direct benefits: food, territory, parental care, freedom from parasites transmitted at mating.
  • Good genes / indicator traits: the ornament honestly signals heritable quality (Hamilton–Zuk parasite hypothesis; Zahavi’s handicap).
  • Fisherian runaway: a genetic correlation between preference and trait drives both to exaggeration, because sons inherit the attractive trait (“sexy sons”).
  • Sensory bias: the preference existed before the trait, for other reasons (food colour, for example), and males evolved to exploit it.

Experimental classic: Andersson (1982) lengthened or shortened the tails of male long-tailed widowbirds; males with artificially lengthened tails attracted more females.

Sperm competition: when females mate with several males, selection favours larger testes, more sperm, mate guarding, copulatory plugs and sperm removal (damselfly penises can scoop out a rival’s sperm). Cryptic female choice acts after mating.

Mating systems

SystemDefinitionWhere common
MonogamyOne male, one female per breeding attempt or seasonMost bird species are socially monogamous; DNA paternity tests reveal frequent extra-pair offspring, so genetic monogamy is rarer
PolygynyOne male, several femalesCommon in mammals
— resource-defence polygynyMales defend resources females needRed-winged blackbird territories
— female-defence (harem) polygynyMales defend groups of femalesElephant seals, red deer
— lek polygynyMales display on a communal arena that contains no resources; females choose and leaveSage grouse, peafowl, some antelopes
PolyandryOne female, several malesJacanas, phalaropes (role-reversed)
Polygynandry / promiscuityBoth sexes have several matesMany fish, some primates

The polygyny threshold model (Orians, 1969): a female should settle as a second mate on a high-quality territory if her expected success there exceeds that as the sole mate on a poor territory. The female that chooses to be a second mate then does better than her monogamous alternative, even though she shares the male’s help (the first female on that territory may lose out).


Parental Care

Parental care increases offspring survival at a cost to the parent’s future reproduction. Who cares varies by group:

GroupTypical careExplanation offered
MammalsFemale (gestation, lactation); male care uncommonInternal fertilisation and lactation commit females
BirdsBiparental care in most speciesBoth sexes can incubate and feed; uniparental care often cannot raise the brood
FishesWhere care exists, male-only care is commonExternal fertilisation and territorial males guarding a nest where eggs are laid; paternity more certain; caring costs males little extra if they already guard a territory
InvertebratesUsually none; some maternal care (earwigs, spiders, social insects)

Parent–offspring conflict

Trivers (1974): a parent is equally related (r = 0.5) to each of its offspring, but each offspring is related to itself by 1 and to a full sibling by 0.5. So offspring are selected to demand more investment than the parent is selected to give. Predicted outcomes: weaning conflict, begging, and sibling rivalry, including siblicide in some eagles and boobies. Genomic imprinting of growth-related genes is interpreted by some as a molecular expression of the same conflict.

Brood parasitism: cuckoos lay eggs in other birds’ nests; the common cuckoo chick ejects host eggs (koel chicks do not) and the chick’s gape and begging stimulate the host to feed it (a supernormal stimulus). Hosts evolve egg rejection and cuckoos evolve egg mimicry: a coevolutionary arms race. The Asian koel and several Indian cuckoos parasitise crows, babblers and other hosts.


Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Proximate: how (mechanism, development)vsUltimate: why (function, evolution)
Kinesis: undirected rate changevsTaxis: directed movement
Imprinting: critical period, largely irreversiblevsConditioning: association, any time, extinguishable
Classical conditioning: stimulus–stimulusvsOperant conditioning: behaviour–consequence
Signal: evolved to informvsCue: incidental information
Releaser pheromone: immediate behaviourvsPrimer pheromone: slow physiological change
Kin selection: rB > C, relativesvsReciprocal altruism: unrelated, repeated, return expected
Intrasexual selection: rivalryvsIntersexual selection: mate choice
Lek: display arena, no resourcesvsResource-defence polygyny: territory with resources
Polygyny: one male, many femalesvsPolyandry: one female, many males
Orientation: compass directionvsNavigation: map plus compass

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which two of Tinbergen’s four questions are ultimate?
  2. What does the duration of the waggle run indicate?
  3. What is the coefficient of relatedness between full sisters in a honeybee colony headed by a singly mated queen?
Answers
  1. Function (adaptive value) and evolution (phylogeny).
  2. Distance to the food source.
  3. 0.75.

Level 2: Part B Style

Q1 (practice). A bird can help its full sibling raise young. Helping costs the bird 1 offspring of its own. By Hamilton’s rule, helping is favoured only if the sibling gains more than:

  • (a) 0.5 extra offspring
  • (b) 1 extra offspring
  • (c) 2 extra offspring
  • (d) 4 extra offspring
Answer and explanation

(c). rB > C with r = 0.5 and C = 1 → B > 1/0.5 = 2 extra offspring for the sibling.

Q2 (practice). A forager honeybee performs waggle runs pointing 40° to the right of vertical on the comb. The food source lies:

  • (a) 40° to the right of the sun’s azimuth
  • (b) 40° to the left of the sun’s azimuth
  • (c) 40° to the right of the hive entrance
  • (d) 140° from the sun’s azimuth
Answer and explanation

(a). Vertical up on the comb stands for the direction of the sun; the waggle-run angle to the right of vertical is the angle of the food to the right of the sun’s azimuth.

Q3 (practice). Which statement addresses an ultimate cause of migration in a warbler?

  • (a) Shortening day length triggers hormonal changes and fat deposition.
  • (b) Young birds orient using a magnetic compass from their first autumn.
  • (c) Birds that migrate raise more offspring than those that stay because they exploit the summer insect peak in the north and avoid winter food shortage.
  • (d) Caged birds show nocturnal restlessness (Zugunruhe) in the migration season.
Answer and explanation

(c). It explains the behaviour by its effect on reproductive success: function. (a), (b) and (d) describe mechanisms and development: proximate causes.

Q4 (practice). In a hawk–dove game, the resource is worth V = 4 and injury costs C = 10. At the ESS, the proportion of hawks is:

  • (a) 0.2
  • (b) 0.4
  • (c) 0.6
  • (d) 1.0
Answer and explanation

(b). Since V < C, the ESS is mixed with p* = V/C = 4/10 = 0.4. Check: hawk payoff = 0.4 × (4 − 10)/2 + 0.6 × 4 = −1.2 + 2.4 = 1.2; dove payoff = 0.4 × 0 + 0.6 × 2 = 1.2. Equal, as required.

Level 3: Part C Style

Q1 (practice). A bird feeds on two prey types. Large prey: energy 10 J, handling time 2 s, encounter rate 0.5 s⁻¹ of search. Small prey: energy 4 J, handling time 2 s.

(i) Rank the prey by profitability. (ii) What is the intake rate if the bird eats only large prey? (iii) Should it eat small prey when it meets them? (iv) Would your answer change if small prey became ten times more common? (v) Below what encounter rate of large prey would the small prey be included?

Answer and worked solution
  1. Profitability: large 10/2 = 5 J s⁻¹; small 4/2 = 2 J s⁻¹. Large ranks first.
  2. R₁ = λE/(1 + λh) = (0.5 × 10)/(1 + 0.5 × 2) = 5/2 = 2.5 J s⁻¹.
  3. Small-prey profitability (2) < R₁ (2.5): ignore small prey. Eating one would spend 2 s earning 2 J s⁻¹ when searching for large prey yields 2.5 J s⁻¹.
  4. No. The small prey’s own encounter rate does not enter the inclusion condition.
  5. Include small prey when 10λ/(1 + 2λ) < 2 → 10λ < 2 + 4λ → λ < 1/3 ≈ 0.33 s⁻¹.

Q2 (practice). In a habitat, the cumulative energy gained in a patch rises as g(t) = a√t (a constant), and the mean travel time between patches is T. Which statements are correct according to the marginal value theorem?

(A) The optimal patch residence time equals the travel time T. (B) If travel time doubles, optimal residence time doubles. (C) The forager should leave the patch when g(t)/t, the average rate within the patch, is maximal. (D) At the optimum, the overall long-term intake rate is a/(2√T).

  • (a) A and B only
  • (b) A, B and D
  • (c) C and D only
  • (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution

(b) A, B and D.

  • MVT condition: g’(t) = g(t)/(T + t) → a/(2√t) = a√t/(T + t) → T + t = 2t → t = T*. (A) correct; it follows that doubling T doubles t*, so (B) is correct.
  • (C) wrong: within-patch average rate a/√t is highest at the start; the criterion is the marginal rate equal to the habitat average including travel.
  • (D) Long-term rate = g(t*)/(T + t*) = a√T/(2T) = a/(2√T), which also equals g’(t*). Correct.

Q3 (practice). In a species of eusocial wasp, the queen mates with k males, each fathering an equal share of her daughters. Which statements are correct?

(A) With k = 1, a worker is more closely related to her full sisters (0.75) than she would be to her own daughters (0.5). (B) With k = 2, a worker’s average relatedness to her sisters equals her relatedness to her own daughters. (C) With k = 4, average sister relatedness is 0.375. (D) A worker’s relatedness to her brothers depends on k.

  • (a) A, B and C
  • (b) A and D only
  • (c) B, C and D
  • (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution

(a) A, B and C.

  • Average sister relatedness = 1/4 + 1/(2k).
  • (A) k = 1: 0.25 + 0.5 = 0.75 > 0.5. Correct.
  • (B) k = 2: 0.25 + 0.25 = 0.50, equal to relatedness to own daughter. Correct.
  • (C) k = 4: 0.25 + 0.125 = 0.375. Correct.
  • (D) Wrong: brothers come from the queen’s unfertilised eggs and carry no paternal genes, so a worker’s relatedness to a brother is 0.25 whatever k is.

The pattern underlies the observation that eusociality arose in lineages with monogamous ancestral queens; multiple mating evolved later in some groups.


Quick Revision Table

ItemFact
Founders of ethologyLorenz, Tinbergen, von Frisch (Nobel 1973)
Tinbergen’s four questionsMechanism, development (proximate); function, evolution (ultimate)
FAP / sign stimulusEgg-rolling in geese; stickleback red belly; gull bill spot
Learning typesHabituation, imprinting (critical period), classical, operant, latent, insight, social
Prey modelRank by E/h; include if E/h > rate without it; zero–one rule
Marginal value theoremLeave when marginal rate = habitat average; longer travel → stay longer
SignalsVisual, acoustic, chemical (releaser, primer), tactile, electrical
Waggle danceAngle from vertical = angle from sun; duration = distance; round dance for near food
Handicap principleCostly signals are honest (Zahavi 1975)
Hawk–dovePayoffs (V − C)/2, V, 0, V/2; ESS hawk fraction V/C when V < C
ESSMaynard Smith and Price, 1973
TerritoryEconomic defendability (Brown, 1964)
NavigationSun compass (Kramer), star compass (Emlen), magnetic, olfactory (salmon)
Hamilton’s rulerB > C (1964); full sib 0.5, half sib 0.25, cousin 0.125
HaplodiploidySisters 0.75; brother 0.25; with k mates sisters 1/4 + 1/(2k)
EusocialityCooperative brood care, overlapping generations, reproductive division of labour
Reciprocal altruismTrivers 1971; vampire bats
Sexual selectionIntrasexual (competition) vs intersexual (choice); Fisher runaway, good genes, sensory bias
Mating systemsMonogamy, polygyny (resource, harem, lek), polyandry (jacanas, phalaropes)
Polygyny thresholdOrians 1969
Parental careMammals female; birds biparental; fish often male
Parent–offspring conflictTrivers 1974; weaning conflict, sibling rivalry

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement